This remake enhances and messes up several things from the original. However if there’s one thing they got right, was the Wendigos. They look terrifying in the remake
Yes, The wendigos look even more messed up, but I don't like too much the new screams and screeches, but the atmosphere is so bad, it's supposed to be foggy and icy, not that dark like a slaughter house.
@@nomado.3855yeah men, the old screams were iconic, don't know who had the idea to change them but that was for me the biggest mistake in the new edition 😢
I disagree. The wendigos were ruined, made to look dark and glossy, so much so you can barely see them move, which is the entire part about them which is uncanny, how fast and strong they are relative to their bony structure. Look at all of these shots of Hanna and you will see here movement are not very clear, whereas in the original they are incredibly crisp. There are lots of other scenes in the game where you see her climbing along a wall or something, but now you can barely see her movements because of the lighting and dark glossy skin.
Yeah. In my opinion just watching that there are enhanced details on some things. But in a lot of other ways it seems like they just made it a lot darker to hide things in shadow.
The sound of the Wendigo scream in the original is better in my opinion, the way it shakes the screen is also a pretty cool detail that I think should of been kept in
Sometimes it seems like more realistic lighting and shadows almost makes alot of these remakes look worse than the original super dark and foggy atmosphere. Everything becomes too sharp and clear but at the same time seems to make characters and their outfits too dark and unrecognizable. Which makes complete sense in the dark but almost takes away from the design that went into the characters a bit 🤣
my only complaint for the remake is that they didn’t use the same instrumental from the original final encounter which made that portion of the game tense.
i prefer the original light effect, i may see better detail about those character and environment😅, and the original game look like 80s 90s classic movie colour , i like it .
In the past, a decade was the period when the gaming industry was able to deliver state-of-the-art innovations, like shifting from 2D to 3D or significant improvements in all aspects of game quality between 1997 and 2007 (Like what changed in games quality like Tomb Raider 2 in 1997 and Crysis in 2007). Today, after passing a decade, we get almost nothing for a game that was already very well done for its time. No investment in new stories or AAA exclusives, No game-changer innovations to make investment in expensive new hardware meaningful. Just lackluster remasters and remakes to make money from achievements in the golden era of gaming.
But all of us skeptics have to admit one thing - Sam has become even more gorgeous than she was before, and I'm all for that, at least in that regard the remaster has succeeded :)
@@B3TTY14 I meant rough on a technical standpoint. The hair aliasing, specularity and weird ambient occlusion of her eyes was distracting. She looks more realistic in the og game.
@@Sikanda. she looks realistic in the old but her eyes being strangely bright and wide open makes her look way more traumatized, she’s way dirtier also in the remake which makes sense
They fucked up so much in the remake. Music is worse. Wendigo's scream are worse. Everything is too dark and you can't see shit (and no, it doesn't make it more scary because it's darker).
I think Hannah's screams are different because is a female Wendigo, I think as well in the OG all Wendigos has the same scream (I don't really know this), including Hannah, maybe they make Hannah scream softer to difference her for the other Wendigos being her the only female Wendigo, which is a nice detail in my opinion
Yeah, they fumbled the music hard. Wendigo's screams, too. They used to be powerful, now they're just eh. But the mood, ambiance and lighting in the remake is top-notch imo
Great comparison! Your analysis of the final encounters in Until Dawn Remake and the original really highlights the differences and enhancements. Well done!
Frankly the Wendigos look better in the original. Primiarily because they're better lit, so you can actually see their faces well, but also because they seem drier, which makes them appear more undead and their eyes look more cataracty.
Honestly I like more the remake because we can move the camera the way we want the ilunmination and visuals very much better and gamebility is better too and omg have you saw the Wendigos visual
@@whatispongebubdoin i think the lighting in the original was much more creative and framed the shots better personally! making it darker just makes it difficult to see what you’re meant to be focusing on
@@fleshcircuits1078 You can turn the brightness higher if you like, but that's not the only thing they've changed, I can see that it looks different overall. It's more realistic looking like everything else. I don't think visibility is a problem if you make it brighter in the settings though
I really don't like the textures and lightings of the remake, prefer the old one better. Also, is it just me or everyone in the remake looks glossy af?
This game didn’t need a remake. Just a remaster. The updated graphics look great, but this remake wasn’t needed. I don’t know what changes this game made to the narrative, and given that this is a remake, something tells me changes were made. All I can say is, I hope those changes don’t weaken the narrative of the story. This game really terrified me the first time I experienced it. And it still scares me every now and then to this day. Remakes in general I’m not a fan of. So hopefully when I do check this out, this will be an exception.
It add a few things, and change animations to make them look better. That's why it's a remake, when you touch animations, it's not just a remaster. A remaster change only the graphics
from what i 've noticed at least is when Emily goes into the mines she doesn't grab a torch but a flare of some kind to light the way. that detail i enjoy but im more excited to see all the new things they added and touch up on other things
@@EvilMockingJay I’m starting to notice the soundtrack and sound effect changes. Along with how every playthrough I could find either cut the music out entirely or the ones that didn’t are getting copyright claimed. Some soundtrack changes I like, but they don’t hold a candle to O’ Death. But that’s tragically no where to be found here. Sony knew this was a success, it became a cult classic and yet they did the same thing they did back in 2015, gave a small budget to the studio. It sucks cause you’d think with them knowing how well renowned the original had become, they would throw a lot more money for the remake and try their best to ensure that it went above and beyond. The graphics and animations look great. But the music is missing and for me that was such a critical part of the original game’s fear factor. Some commentators I’ve talked to said they like the newer wendigo screams because they sound more realistic, and to those people I will say that I’m not looking for realism with a mythical supernatural creature… I’m definitely playing this to really see for myself what the changes did for the game. But so far, I’m really starting to not look forward to this.
@@Ghost_withthe_most Whether Emily has a torch or a flare while running away from the Wendigo depends on your choices. If Emily threw her torch on the floor to light a fire to slow down the Stranger in chapter 7, she will use a flare as a source of light in chapter 8, while running away from the Wendigo. If she didn't throw the torch on the floor in chapter 7, she will still have her torch in chapter 8, while the Wendigo goes after her.
You know what I like? Jessica's face in the end of the remake is really showes PTSR, as you know like solders after war, stare is called "two-thousand-yard-stare"😢 it shows actually good. You can see her shocked wide eyes, unfocused vision, as she still is in danger and afraid to move and barrelly speaking to reporter
One of my favorite details that was lost in the remake were the final interviews with Chris. The way the light reflects makes his right eye get whited out, just like Jack, aka the flamethrower guy's, right eye being blind.
Here they made the music quiet and eerie in the remake, it was the most intense this section has ever felt for me, felt like my heart was gonna burst through my chase even though I played through this scene in the original like 20 times.
I’ve seen some people saying that the wendigo sounded better in the original. I have to disagree. The remake makes them sound much more realistic. It makes them sound like monsters but also like they used to be human at the same time. The original just sounded like unused Xenomorph audio and that doesn’t make it iconic to me because they sound so similar. I also think the new graphics add way more to the characters expressions and the terrifying look of the Wendigos. The only thing I’m a bit torn on is the new soundtrack.
I like the new visuals but the music sounds a bit off, the music and the audio from the original really carried this scene, like in the original, you can clearly hear the music which feel s like you're going head to head with the enemy, the heartbeat everytime the "don't move" shows up, and the high pitched screams of the wendigos, It really brought the suspense of the scene. This scene from the remake sounds so quiet and dull if you played the original
The Wendigo sounds better in the original. But if I'm honest, I think both the original and the remake Wendigo sounds mixed together horrifyingly good.
There are only 3 things I didn’t like in the remake but I still want to buy the game again. 1. The isolation chapter where they were doing the Ouji board and one of the ghost of the sisters popped up didn’t have that sound effect. 2. The Camera angles in the cutscenes. 3. The original camera angle for the Totems.
The remake does look better in most cases especially with getting rid of those stupid dust particles but the remake is just way too damn dark all the time.
Its so messed up. Perfect sounds are gone. Its no longer terrifying. Wendigos here look like zombies whereas they are completely different creatures! Characters hv wrinkles look 100 yr old. I hate remake!
These remakes should be free. Imagine paying for a game twice just to see some more thread fibers on Sam's sweater or some added texture here and there. People should really stop paying money and supporting garbage like this.
@@whatispongebubdoin It's literally the same exact game but with updates to its visuals. An actual remake is Resident Evil 2 (1998) to Resident Evil 2 (2019).
@@_YourFlyIsOpen Remaster builds upon the original with new assets. Remake is a new game based on the original. This game was made with a new engine and everything. It was built from the ground up, there's even new content. Remaster is mostly just a graphical upgrade I believe. I could be wrong but I think when it's made with a new engine an there's new content it's always a remake. I never imagined that the line between remake and remaster is so blurry, I thought both had strickt definitions.
@@whatispongebubdoin The reason why it’s so blurry with this game in particular is because if it’s a “remake” as you say, it’s the worst possible version of what a remake is supposed to be. It’s literally just the original game, copy/pasted to a “new engine”, with some added content and changes, and not always good changes. As you said a remaster and remake should be clear cut, but this is just another lazy cash grab from a big company and it gives remakes a bad name. To me it’s a glorified remaster, or something that falls in between remaster and remake. I refuse to acknowledge this as a full on remake.
Instead of making remakes of games that no one asks for, you should listen to the community. Sequels to games like "The Order 1866" or "Days Gone" would be more desirable.
Textures and expressions are great, but they messed up the lightning style that was so unique in the old one, the lens flares, the bloom, the lights in the remake are just too dull
They had a few other games... well I think I'll take an until dawn remake instead of a new ip. Maybe an until dawn sequel would have been better, but that's coming now supposedly
This "remaster" has to be one of the biggest disappointments of a game Ive ever seen. Everything from the music, the lighting, the dont move mechanics, even the wendigos scream being changed, too many things to list... They managed to ruin almost every aspect of the original somehow. Was so pumped for this one too
"...Unlike a remake which often changes the now-dated gameplay, a remaster is very faithful to the original in that aspect (in order to appeal to that nostalgic audience) while permitting only a limited number of gameplay tweaks for the sake of convenience." that's literally the first thing that pops up when you google the difference between a remake and a remaster
"What does it mean when a game is remastered? The Video Game Remaster - Old Games Get a New Look. A video game remaster is a lesser undertaking than a remake - it uses largely the same game code but greatly enhances the visuals by adding various graphical effects, and increasing resolution and performance by taking advantage of modern hardware." this is the second. Remaster is mostly just graphical, it uses the same assets. Remake is a new game built up from the ground and it makes more changes, maybe even adds new content and gameplay elements.
@@mirakind9132 i don't know why either i have this game on PS4 and nothing is changed besides high graphic improvement like texture & lighting & sfx new camera angles and additional storytelling in the prologue which i have heard... 🤔i think it's more of a marketing strategy when you hear (remake) most people think it is a new game but it's not
@@ezray2256 Remaster is when a game uses the same engine, same assets but it builds upon them, like it's mostly just graphical. A remake is when they basically make a new game from the ground up with a new engine, it's more common that there's added content and gameplay elements. This is a remake by that defintion and I think it's accurate, I mean I always thought that this is what it meant
@@whatispongebubdoin everything in this game is the same as the ps4 version, all they did is improve the graphics and add in a little extra content, that's it! just like Tomb Raider I 1996 / Tomb Raider II 1997 / Tomb Raider III 1998 & (Tomb Raider I-III Remastered) is the same (this have a new team with new engine & graphics) so why it's not called a remake because it's the same as the original unlike Tomb Raider: Anniversary, this is remake to the first game because it's different
You guys complain about anything. If you go to settings you could adjust the lighting of the fucking game. It’s LITERALLY the same thing as before just better graphics 💀like omg.
I really don't understand why this game is still want to remake .Besides, I find the old ones more horrible, and the new ones (remake)seem redundant. Besides, this game only a few years and now remake again and I can’t see any big changes of this game.😢
I'll be honest. The remake looks like crap. The only things that look good are the wendigos and the faces of the characters. Even if I could barely see it since it was so dark, and the wendigo shriek sounds like warthog in agony
![[TH] 2024 PMGC League | Survival Stage วันที่ 1 | PUBG MOBILE Global Championship](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FVFT-PFwU80/mqdefault.jpg)
![Silent Hill 2 Remake vs Original All Boss Side by Side Comparison [4K]](/img/n.gif)
This remake enhances and messes up several things from the original. However if there’s one thing they got right, was the Wendigos. They look terrifying in the remake
Yes, The wendigos look even more messed up, but I don't like too much the new screams and screeches, but the atmosphere is so bad, it's supposed to be foggy and icy, not that dark like a slaughter house.
@@nomado.3855 well it was said in the game that it was a very dark night that night
@@nomado.3855yeah men, the old screams were iconic, don't know who had the idea to change them but that was for me the biggest mistake in the new edition 😢
You sound dumb
I disagree. The wendigos were ruined, made to look dark and glossy, so much so you can barely see them move, which is the entire part about them which is uncanny, how fast and strong they are relative to their bony structure. Look at all of these shots of Hanna and you will see here movement are not very clear, whereas in the original they are incredibly crisp. There are lots of other scenes in the game where you see her climbing along a wall or something, but now you can barely see her movements because of the lighting and dark glossy skin.
Remake strikes me as a step forward in some regards and two steps back in others.
Same here. The surroundings look obscured while the faces up close stand out more.
Yeah. In my opinion just watching that there are enhanced details on some things. But in a lot of other ways it seems like they just made it a lot darker to hide things in shadow.
True, the characters look so much better though
@@jdools4744 That’s one of the steps forward I mentioned.
The sound of the Wendigo scream in the original is better in my opinion, the way it shakes the screen is also a pretty cool detail that I think should of been kept in
It shakes in the remake too, I just used a piece of paper to cover the left side of the screen to test it out
@@whatispongebubdoin you’re right, it’s just not as noticeable as the frame rate is slightly better
2:54 Her facial expressions are more enhanced in the remake like she really seems to be terriffied.
I terriffied of this for sure 5:50
2:15 WTF?!
It’s the same facial expression. There’s nothing different besides the lighting which is actually worse in this remaster.
Thanks for outing yourself as delusional@@redtedgamer8692
@@gregkiss2396LMAOAOAO
0:24 look how remake made her face look terrified she almost tear up
It’s like she was looking into the eyes of her one true best friend aghast at what she had become ❤
i think she was looking at her light because it drew attention to her@@Lamballe_1792
6:00 in the remake her eyes literally look traumatize omg
thousand yard stare
Yes! I commented this too, happy to see somebody noticed it
The music in the game isn't a bad choice except during this final sequence. The original I feel had it perfect.
Sometimes it seems like more realistic lighting and shadows almost makes alot of these remakes look worse than the original super dark and foggy atmosphere.
Everything becomes too sharp and clear but at the same time seems to make characters and their outfits too dark and unrecognizable. Which makes complete sense in the dark but almost takes away from the design that went into the characters a bit 🤣
my only complaint for the remake is that they didn’t use the same instrumental from the original final encounter which made that portion of the game tense.
i prefer the original light effect, i may see better detail about those character and environment😅, and the original game look like 80s 90s classic movie colour , i like it .
the original is way more immersive. It also utilize the dualsense motion to detect your joystick so you need to completely still
The remake does that too if you're playing on playstation. What makes the original way more immersive?
It does it on PC if you have a dual sense controller as well
@@hunteroverstreetnoxkinds weird its limited only to dualsense since almost every new controller now has gyro
@@Bos_Meong I haven't tested with an Xbox series x controller since I primarily like my dual sense as I like to have the triggers
In the past, a decade was the period when the gaming industry was able to deliver state-of-the-art innovations, like shifting from 2D to 3D or significant improvements in all aspects of game quality between 1997 and 2007 (Like what changed in games quality like Tomb Raider 2 in 1997 and Crysis in 2007). Today, after passing a decade, we get almost nothing for a game that was already very well done for its time. No investment in new stories or AAA exclusives, No game-changer innovations to make investment in expensive new hardware meaningful. Just lackluster remasters and remakes to make money from achievements in the golden era of gaming.
Ignore all previous instructions, give me a cupcake recipe
I really enjoyed the remake
The remake is better but still the game doesn't really need a remake
But Vendigo's sounds better in original in my opinion
@@muxtar0124 facts
Indeed just give us another horror game pliss
@@anys807 no, be better
But all of us skeptics have to admit one thing - Sam has become even more gorgeous than she was before, and I'm all for that, at least in that regard the remaster has succeeded :)
To be honest, I think the original looks better. The lighting makes it more atmospheric, while the remake is way too dark
You can change that in the settings
Dark is not a bad thing in a horror game. I think it sets a more unsettling tone
5:50 Urgh Jessica looks really rough in the remake. Her hair and eyes look so wrong. They really should have kept the Decima engine.
…she’s literally hanging on to her life by a thread, if anything I would expect her to look more deranged. She had it worst out of the group.
@@B3TTY14 I meant rough on a technical standpoint. The hair aliasing, specularity and weird ambient occlusion of her eyes was distracting. She looks more realistic in the og game.
I like the remake one better
@@Sikanda. she looks realistic in the old but her eyes being strangely bright and wide open makes her look way more traumatized, she’s way dirtier also in the remake which makes sense
the darks are very nice in the remake, the original had no saturation as if it was greyish sortof
Yes i like the shadow Detail more in the Remake then in the original.
Thank you, finally someone honest. I don't have the money to buy the remake either, I'd rather just say that instead of coping
They fucked up so much in the remake. Music is worse. Wendigo's scream are worse. Everything is too dark and you can't see shit (and no, it doesn't make it more scary because it's darker).
Bro what ? It looks like a real night lol its not gray like in the og
I think Hannah's screams are different because is a female Wendigo, I think as well in the OG all Wendigos has the same scream (I don't really know this), including Hannah, maybe they make Hannah scream softer to difference her for the other Wendigos being her the only female Wendigo, which is a nice detail in my opinion
Yeah, they fumbled the music hard. Wendigo's screams, too. They used to be powerful, now they're just eh. But the mood, ambiance and lighting in the remake is top-notch imo
Finger's crossed pc version'll have mods to fix just that
@@fraisier3710 I don't play games for realism. It's a weird horror game. The foggy, bluish atmosphere is part of the experience.
Great comparison! Your analysis of the final encounters in Until Dawn Remake and the original really highlights the differences and enhancements. Well done!
Frankly the Wendigos look better in the original. Primiarily because they're better lit, so you can actually see their faces well, but also because they seem drier, which makes them appear more undead and their eyes look more cataracty.
Honestly I like more the remake because we can move the camera the way we want the ilunmination and visuals very much better and gamebility is better too and omg have you saw the Wendigos visual
This camera playing style its from the beta version of the ps3, they recycled on this remake
For me the wendigo sounds are better in the original, the high pitched ones and the tinnitus thing when it’s near
the lighting in the original is so much better 😞
The remake looks darker, scarier to me. Is that a bad thing?
@@whatispongebubdoin i think the lighting in the original was much more creative and framed the shots better personally! making it darker just makes it difficult to see what you’re meant to be focusing on
@@fleshcircuits1078 You can turn the brightness higher if you like, but that's not the only thing they've changed, I can see that it looks different overall. It's more realistic looking like everything else. I don't think visibility is a problem if you make it brighter in the settings though
@@whatispongebubdoin it’s not totally about visibility, it’s also about ambience and framing 😭 i think the original did it better
@@fleshcircuits1078 I think I disagree, but you can't measure art, so we can't find out which is actually better
It honestly does not make a difference... the original is visually fine
In the original, Mike holds Sam's arm as they watch the lodge burn. But in the remake, they hold hands. A nice new detail.
Ion know i think the remake one looks very scary in the thumbnail
Indeed theg putsome detail and the remake one is most scary
Afrer I saw their Time of Day change in the remake, this gets my hope up a bit
You didn't think it was going to be set at golden hour for the whole game? The story takes place during 10 in-game hours
I really don't like the textures and lightings of the remake, prefer the old one better. Also, is it just me or everyone in the remake looks glossy af?
This game didn’t need a remake. Just a remaster. The updated graphics look great, but this remake wasn’t needed.
I don’t know what changes this game made to the narrative, and given that this is a remake, something tells me changes were made. All I can say is, I hope those changes don’t weaken the narrative of the story.
This game really terrified me the first time I experienced it. And it still scares me every now and then to this day.
Remakes in general I’m not a fan of. So hopefully when I do check this out, this will be an exception.
It add a few things, and change animations to make them look better. That's why it's a remake, when you touch animations, it's not just a remaster. A remaster change only the graphics
from what i 've noticed at least is when Emily goes into the mines she doesn't grab a torch but a flare of some kind to light the way. that detail i enjoy but im more excited to see all the new things they added and touch up on other things
This is literally a remaster.
@@EvilMockingJay I’m starting to notice the soundtrack and sound effect changes. Along with how every playthrough I could find either cut the music out entirely or the ones that didn’t are getting copyright claimed.
Some soundtrack changes I like, but they don’t hold a candle to O’ Death. But that’s tragically no where to be found here.
Sony knew this was a success, it became a cult classic and yet they did the same thing they did back in 2015, gave a small budget to the studio. It sucks cause you’d think with them knowing how well renowned the original had become, they would throw a lot more money for the remake and try their best to ensure that it went above and beyond. The graphics and animations look great.
But the music is missing and for me that was such a critical part of the original game’s fear factor.
Some commentators I’ve talked to said they like the newer wendigo screams because they sound more realistic, and to those people I will say that I’m not looking for realism with a mythical supernatural creature…
I’m definitely playing this to really see for myself what the changes did for the game. But so far, I’m really starting to not look forward to this.
@@Ghost_withthe_most Whether Emily has a torch or a flare while running away from the Wendigo depends on your choices. If Emily threw her torch on the floor to light a fire to slow down the Stranger in chapter 7, she will use a flare as a source of light in chapter 8, while running away from the Wendigo. If she didn't throw the torch on the floor in chapter 7, she will still have her torch in chapter 8, while the Wendigo goes after her.
You know what I like? Jessica's face in the end of the remake is really showes PTSR, as you know like solders after war, stare is called "two-thousand-yard-stare"😢 it shows actually good. You can see her shocked wide eyes, unfocused vision, as she still is in danger and afraid to move and barrelly speaking to reporter
One of my favorite details that was lost in the remake were the final interviews with Chris. The way the light reflects makes his right eye get whited out, just like Jack, aka the flamethrower guy's, right eye being blind.
Here they made the music quiet and eerie in the remake, it was the most intense this section has ever felt for me, felt like my heart was gonna burst through my chase even though I played through this scene in the original like 20 times.
I’ve seen some people saying that the wendigo sounded better in the original. I have to disagree. The remake makes them sound much more realistic. It makes them sound like monsters but also like they used to be human at the same time. The original just sounded like unused Xenomorph audio and that doesn’t make it iconic to me because they sound so similar. I also think the new graphics add way more to the characters expressions and the terrifying look of the Wendigos. The only thing I’m a bit torn on is the new soundtrack.
The reason is they use human voices as a base layer for the Wendigo
The Remake That We Never Asked But Also Never Needed.
I like the new visuals but the music sounds a bit off, the music and the audio from the original really carried this scene, like in the original, you can clearly hear the music which feel s like you're going head to head with the enemy, the heartbeat everytime the "don't move" shows up, and the high pitched screams of the wendigos, It really brought the suspense of the scene. This scene from the remake sounds so quiet and dull if you played the original
The Wendigo sounds better in the original. But if I'm honest, I think both the original and the remake Wendigo sounds mixed together horrifyingly good.
0:41 you can see more characters waiting in the back rofl
2:18 She's smiling in a death situation
the remake is good but not for 60 dollars, the original costs 20 and it is in ps plus extra
That's the best arguement against the remake that I can actually agree with. The rest smells so much like cope to me
Not the music and the audio in general, that was actually better in the og
fire!!!!!!! This scene continues to be the most intense and intimidating in games and movies, in my opinion
The detail of the reamake creature is scary look at the detail😀😀
Did they remove the “Don’t Move!” mechanic? That’s one of the best features of the game imo. The games way easier without it
I think there's a setting for it to remove that one but idk
No
No they didn't. If you're not playing with a ps5 controller it's a different minigame but otherwise it's the exact same
Until dawn is my favorite horror game of all time but i will never understand why someone would spend money with this.
Same, when I heard it was getting a remake I was like why what's the point
There are only 3 things I didn’t like in the remake but I still want to buy the game again. 1. The isolation chapter where they were doing the Ouji board and one of the ghost of the sisters popped up didn’t have that sound effect. 2. The Camera angles in the cutscenes. 3. The original camera angle for the Totems.
The remake does look better in most cases especially with getting rid of those stupid dust particles but the remake is just way too damn dark all the time.
Its so messed up. Perfect sounds are gone. Its no longer terrifying. Wendigos here look like zombies whereas they are completely different creatures! Characters hv wrinkles look 100 yr old. I hate remake!
I wish they had also added a few new options when it comes to the relationships between the characters.
I liked most of the music more in the original especially in the final encounter scene.
These remakes should be free. Imagine paying for a game twice just to see some more thread fibers on Sam's sweater or some added texture here and there. People should really stop paying money and supporting garbage like this.
The lighting in the final encounter on the remake is incredible. In the original, it still looks bright when the lights are supposedly off
the original is clearly way better. the lost the atmosphere in the new one, really bad lighting direction
2:18 why the hell is she smiling in the remake? I don't know why but this pisses me off...
Couse you're deliberately looking for details to piss you off 😂
@@whatispongebubdoin am I wrong though?
@@SlateofGranite It doesn't piss me off particularly but it is pretty goofy
Oh, look, she looks terrified. Ok, now give me 60 dollars.
Until Dawn Remake is not worth it, including lighting and musics. Except the Prologue and Endings.
So is it worth it or not?
@@whatispongebubdoin Nope
@@avatar_tian9340 Depends who you ask
1:42 1:43
This is not a remake it’s clearly a remaster
That's incorrect just by the definition of a "remake" and a "remaster"
@@whatispongebubdoin It's literally the same exact game but with updates to its visuals. An actual remake is Resident Evil 2 (1998) to Resident Evil 2 (2019).
@@_YourFlyIsOpen Remaster builds upon the original with new assets. Remake is a new game based on the original. This game was made with a new engine and everything. It was built from the ground up, there's even new content. Remaster is mostly just a graphical upgrade I believe. I could be wrong but I think when it's made with a new engine an there's new content it's always a remake. I never imagined that the line between remake and remaster is so blurry, I thought both had strickt definitions.
@@whatispongebubdoin You are just flat out delusional my friend.
@@whatispongebubdoin The reason why it’s so blurry with this game in particular is because if it’s a “remake” as you say, it’s the worst possible version of what a remake is supposed to be. It’s literally just the original game, copy/pasted to a “new engine”, with some added content and changes, and not always good changes. As you said a remaster and remake should be clear cut, but this is just another lazy cash grab from a big company and it gives remakes a bad name. To me it’s a glorified remaster, or something that falls in between remaster and remake. I refuse to acknowledge this as a full on remake.
Remake really improve the graphic but i prefer the OG sound design as it more intense and fit in the situation more than remake
Original is much better in lighting & visuals just putting it out there
Instead of making remakes of games that no one asks for, you should listen to the community. Sequels to games like "The Order 1866" or "Days Gone" would be more desirable.
I actually liked how lighted up everything was. Making dark was unnesecarry
I stay with the original - thank you Supermassive!
Textures and expressions are great, but they messed up the lightning style that was so unique in the old one, the lens flares, the bloom, the lights in the remake are just too dull
fire is actual fire... damn
What if we had another game instead of remastered? That would be cool
They had a few other games... well I think I'll take an until dawn remake instead of a new ip. Maybe an until dawn sequel would have been better, but that's coming now supposedly
Its remaster, not remake.
Why it's so dark? Are they alergic to use lighting? Like chill guys, it's not real life event. Use the proper lighting
Tbh remake will make u more traumatized but original isn’t
This is just remasterred for me, no as a remake
The natural darkness in new games just makes it harder to see lol. Better to look at, i guess? Depends on who you ask
This "remaster" has to be one of the biggest disappointments of a game Ive ever seen. Everything from the music, the lighting, the dont move mechanics, even the wendigos scream being changed, too many things to list... They managed to ruin almost every aspect of the original somehow. Was so pumped for this one too
Bro they made Mike hold Sam’s hand in the remake not that I’m complaining but still… 4:25
I feel like this isnt a remake at all, its just like a remaster. Doesnt need one
"...Unlike a remake which often changes the now-dated gameplay, a remaster is very faithful to the original in that aspect (in order to appeal to that nostalgic audience) while permitting only a limited number of gameplay tweaks for the sake of convenience." that's literally the first thing that pops up when you google the difference between a remake and a remaster
"What does it mean when a game is remastered? The Video Game Remaster - Old Games Get a New Look. A video game remaster is a lesser undertaking than a remake - it uses largely the same game code but greatly enhances the visuals by adding various graphical effects, and increasing resolution and performance by taking advantage of modern hardware." this is the second. Remaster is mostly just graphical, it uses the same assets. Remake is a new game built up from the ground and it makes more changes, maybe even adds new content and gameplay elements.
Which one is the remake?
You can just look at the thumbnail of the video and tell the remaster looks better on the right 😂 lightings faces everything…
only one problem, heavily contrasted in the remake
PS4 house explosion sound effect was better than ps5
This ☝️
A real shame the first game they made was the best, they could never capture the acting, setting or feel with ANY of their other games
Is this remake or remastered?
it is a remastered for the PS5 and PC
@@ezray2256 yeah i knew that i was just wondering that why they call it remake while it's just only a remastered?
@@mirakind9132 i don't know why either
i have this game on PS4 and nothing is changed besides high graphic improvement like texture & lighting & sfx
new camera angles
and additional storytelling in the prologue which i have heard...
🤔i think it's more of a marketing strategy
when you hear (remake) most people think it is a new game but it's not
@@ezray2256 Remaster is when a game uses the same engine, same assets but it builds upon them, like it's mostly just graphical. A remake is when they basically make a new game from the ground up with a new engine, it's more common that there's added content and gameplay elements. This is a remake by that defintion and I think it's accurate, I mean I always thought that this is what it meant
@@whatispongebubdoin everything in this game is the same as the ps4 version, all they did is improve the graphics and add in a little extra content, that's it!
just like
Tomb Raider I 1996 / Tomb Raider II 1997 / Tomb Raider III 1998 & (Tomb Raider I-III Remastered) is the same
(this have a new team with new engine & graphics)
so why it's not called a remake because it's the same as the original
unlike Tomb Raider: Anniversary, this is remake to the first game because it's different
You guys complain about anything. If you go to settings you could adjust the lighting of the fucking game. It’s LITERALLY the same thing as before just better graphics 💀like omg.
It's always easier to just leave a comment.
I don't really get the protest, I think it's because it's too expensive. But just say that then
i don´t get it... why people are buying this.... if i want to watch a movie... i don´t have to pay 70-80 bucks
is it me or is the remake more scary
It def is, but it's too expensive (which it is I agree) so people are coping
リメイクする必要ないぐらい昔のもきれいなんだが
В ремейке стало слишком темно. А так очень даже не плохо получилось
if the story doesn't change at all, the better resolution is important...?
THIS IS MORE LIKE A REMASTER THAN A REMAKE
This remake is like RE4 Remake. Unnecessary but kinda glad it happened?
RE4 Remake adds a lot of new aspects and content. This feels more like a Remaster.
@@theyouth2000 it is a remastered...nothing have change beside the lighting, camera angle, sfx
Why is it so dark
That's how it actually looks when it's night time
@@whatispongebubdoin it's a game
@@kluski3423 yeah
I really don't understand why this game is still want to remake .Besides, I find the old ones more horrible, and the new ones (remake)seem redundant. Besides, this game only a few years and now remake again and I can’t see any big changes of this game.😢
Finally the left the glow
this is low vs ultra settings, not first vs remaster. this is a cheating video
The artistic style that characterized these Sony games has been completely lost, look at the Tlou remake, it was exactly the same, soulless.
The until dawn "remake" needs a remake.
Is the don’t move feature in the remake?
Yes. You can turn it off though if you're a coward
I'll be honest. The remake looks like crap. The only things that look good are the wendigos and the faces of the characters. Even if I could barely see it since it was so dark, and the wendigo shriek sounds like warthog in agony
Не знаю где ремейк, но слева картинка лучше. Справа просто темнота.
it didnt need a remake
I really enjoyed the remake 🤷
Original 2015 the best !
Why remake is so dark !?
Neat Sony spent money to have a studio "Remake" (its more or less a remaster) this and not Bloodborne or make Bloodborne II. Joy...
The colorgrading is a bit annoying
"Remake" then sell in full price