For those of you that do not know, the gentlemen Oskar was speaking with at the other factory was Julius Madritsch. He also has a fascinating story of saving Jews by hiring them and making them essential workers even under threat from the SS to have him hire Poles instead of Jews.
They should do more movies about people who helped others during a time of great turmoil. Plenty of people in WWII alone who risked everything to help the Jews including a maid who hid Jews in a cellar and while the owners were away they helped clean the house or something along those lines.
60 Jews under his protection wound up on the list, whereas others got deported and either died in Auschwitz or may have survived. I don't know how many did, but either way, the fact that more couldn't be saved ultimately destroyed their friendship.
@@bartolomeestebanmurillo4459 I’d pay for a movie with multiple narratives that explore the people all around the world who, like Schindler, defied their governments to save lives
He wasn't a Nazi. Not really. He was a businessman and joined Nazi party because it was easier to make money this way but he didn't believe their ideology.
@@pasjonatpl that still makes him a member of the Nazi party. The reason why he was able to do what he did was because he was a black market dealer and a spy on the Czechs. He made lots of powerful friends because of his early services to the regime. His story is not just a great humanitarian service but a redemption story as well.
@@pasjonatpl He was a committed Nazi who had done extensive work for the Reich intelligence agencies. He had supported the Nazi rise to power, he engaged in espionage for the Reich before the annexation of the Sudetenland, and provided intelligence and surveillance against Poland before the Second World War opened up. He was a committed German nationalist who supported the expansion of the Reich and the policies of the Third Reich, except, it seems, for the Holocaust. He was a legitimate Nazi who thought genocide was too far. There were even leaders of the Third Reich who felt this way, but none did as much to stop it.
@@pasjonatpl While it's technically correct to call him a Nazi on a technical point (he was a registered member), it's completely incorrect from a moral point to say he was a Nazi.
The one thing I loved about Oskar Schindler's portrayal in this movie is how selfish he was in the beginning. He didn't care for them, only about money, but as his Jewish friends around him starting getting deported, he used his wealth to save the Jews that he'd hired. It really brought out his humanity.
What I enjoyed is how his greed manifested. He obsessed over what he bought, who he knew, who knew him. Then his greed elevated to a game of how many he could save from an unholy death. People might say he as a person changed but I think all that changed was the context. The charismatic and foundational elements of Oskar always were there with his greed.
@@totoroid Greed is the opposite of charity, what he did was not greed but guilt. Greed would drive him to save friends or just family, not random strangers
@@Yusuf-fs4fnit depends on what you define by greed. It is greedy to obsessively not letting possessions go or being taken away by any other party no matter what. Like dragons sitting on its cache of gold he has no need of (and bring disaster more than fortune to said dragon). These people technically he has no need of. They cost more to keep, but since he decided that those people are *his* people, he keep them around with all that he has.
i love this scene so much. he is trying to talk to other business men, talk them into a more dangerous scenario to save many more lives. i love how much risk he is taking compared to others, who are keeping it safe. which is understandable, but the contrast that was shown is heart warming nevertheless
The other businessman is Julius Madritsch, who was also in the 1st lunch scene involving Schindler and Goeth. Madritsch also saved hundreds of Jews from the death camps as well.
That's because play time was over, loving money, and girls, was his thing before he saw the little red girl as her own daughter. It was like smashing a beautiful flower.
So true. It took me several showings before I caught all the things I would’ve missed by only watching it once. This movie is such a blessing. It’s a masterpiece.
@@nobertas.tnobertas.t8193 the part with the ring! At the end “he who saves one life saves the world entire” Stern told him that there are 1100 people who are alive today because of him And that there will be generations because of him... At that moment he couldn’t imagine it... but then when you saw how many people came to this tomb.... you realize stern was right
Itzhaak Stern passed away before Schindler. It's said that Oscar Schindler was inconsolable at Stern's funeral. They weren't just business partners, they were brothers
Now do I understand the true meaning of that line “you’re not buying them, you’re buying them.” Stern previously told Schindler if he wants to continue running his business he will have to hire Polish workers but they cost a little more. Stern believes that Schindler has convinced Amon Geoth to let him hire these Jews to profit more from slave labour. Stern is happy to transcribe the list because he knows that the sub camp built for Schindler for his workers was a haven for the prisoners compared to the main concentration camp. But Stern understands he is not buying them for labour he is buying them to save them from the gas chambers.
I think initially Stern thought Schindler has convinced Amon to give him the workers for free, so Schindler can continue make profit. A logical businessman and accountant's logic. But then, he suddenly realise, Amon wouldn't just simply give up these people. Hence he was shocked to know Schindler is doing something that a person like him wouldn't do, so he had to reconfirm it twice.
It’s amazing rewatching the scenes that he always refers how it’s effecting him. The train depot scene - “Then where would I be” line and this line “It’s costing me a fortune”. Interesting how he reflects how it effects him and portrayed! Watching documentaries and others they all say he was no saint but that’s why they lived.
I having a feeling that when Schindler saw and interacted with Jews such as Stern and the others, it was the first time he realized that he had a chance to get something more precious than money. The love and respect of others. He may have made mistakes before and after the war, but when the time came, at the most crucial moment, Oskar Schindler chose to save his soul, than lose it to 'fool's' gold.
Well, Stern did help him a lot, but, to quote the man himself, "[he] knew the people who worked for [him], when you know people, you have to behave toward them like human beings"
Amon Goth- Monster from KL Płaszów. Hanging by polish justice in gallow in former camp, where he was diabolical comendant. Can says : ,,Jedem das seine" - ,, everyone what they deserve"
There were many industrialists who did what Oskar Schindler did. Some payed the supreme price with their lives. Schindler was the one who was made known but all were angels here on earth.
they're shown in the video. Oskar mentioned Julius(the guy he's trying to convince) fed his Jewish workers out of his own money so he thought he will be sympathetic with the idea of moving them to a safe region.
Man when I bought this movie on TH-cam it made me kinda sad that the comments were off, I just know that shit was because of crazy anti semites going nuts in the comment section.
@@rocket_owo8341 Anti Zionism is not Anti Semitism, there are tons of Orthodox Jews, Secular Jews, and young Jews who are critical of the actions of Israel.
It's been some while since I've seen the movie: why did Schindler say "If you were still working for me ....." - who was Stern working for here if not Schindler ?
He wasn't officially working for him anymore. Goeth made him watch over Schindler/his money, there's one scene where Goeth says something like "Remember who you work for now" (him). Maybe it was also a way to respect him, making them equal that they're working with each other and not for each other.
You cut out the last couple seconds that showed the reaction to the list from the point of the people it was intended to benefit. You could've just showed THAT instead of everything else and it would've made sense. What you clipped here was just lazy.
Helen most likely as they dont know yet if amon is going to let her go. So they keep it empty giving her preference but if she doesnt make it they will fill some other name. This heart wrenching cruetly all should never have taken place :/ Never stay quite in face of injustice even in face of death. All those brutally murdered are all in heaven and far more lucky as God is rewarding them way more than we can ever dream of. Peace and be good to others
![Shareปลาวาฬ ส่งท้าย SS1 พาเปียโน ขึ้น Ferrari ก่อนไปขาย แลก Nissan l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KAknGkTNIvg/mqdefault.jpg)
For those of you that do not know, the gentlemen Oskar was speaking with at the other factory was Julius Madritsch. He also has a fascinating story of saving Jews by hiring them and making them essential workers even under threat from the SS to have him hire Poles instead of Jews.
They should do more movies about people who helped others during a time of great turmoil. Plenty of people in WWII alone who risked everything to help the Jews including a maid who hid Jews in a cellar and while the owners were away they helped clean the house or something along those lines.
60 Jews under his protection wound up on the list, whereas others got deported and either died in Auschwitz or may have survived. I don't know how many did, but either way, the fact that more couldn't be saved ultimately destroyed their friendship.
@@bartolomeestebanmurillo4459 I’d pay for a movie with multiple narratives that explore the people all around the world who, like Schindler, defied their governments to save lives
I just realized he is the guy in the beginning of the film as well when he was trying to impress the Nazi members.
Really speaks to how much Schindler's secretly cared about his workers that he can list off 1100 names from memory.
He is the only Nazi to be buried in Israel. He was dubbed a righteous man.
He wasn't a Nazi. Not really. He was a businessman and joined Nazi party because it was easier to make money this way but he didn't believe their ideology.
@@pasjonatpl that still makes him a member of the Nazi party. The reason why he was able to do what he did was because he was a black market dealer and a spy on the Czechs. He made lots of powerful friends because of his early services to the regime. His story is not just a great humanitarian service but a redemption story as well.
There are thousands of Nazis buried in "Israel" but they're called Zionists these days.
@@pasjonatpl He was a committed Nazi who had done extensive work for the Reich intelligence agencies. He had supported the Nazi rise to power, he engaged in espionage for the Reich before the annexation of the Sudetenland, and provided intelligence and surveillance against Poland before the Second World War opened up. He was a committed German nationalist who supported the expansion of the Reich and the policies of the Third Reich, except, it seems, for the Holocaust.
He was a legitimate Nazi who thought genocide was too far. There were even leaders of the Third Reich who felt this way, but none did as much to stop it.
@@pasjonatpl While it's technically correct to call him a Nazi on a technical point (he was a registered member), it's completely incorrect from a moral point to say he was a Nazi.
“Whoever saves one life saves the world entire.” Beautiful words to live by.
Didn’t give a shit about his wealth.. he just wanted to save as many as he could but it hurt him knowing he couldn’t save all of them.
The one thing I loved about Oskar Schindler's portrayal in this movie is how selfish he was in the beginning. He didn't care for them, only about money, but as his Jewish friends around him starting getting deported, he used his wealth to save the Jews that he'd hired. It really brought out his humanity.
What I enjoyed is how his greed manifested. He obsessed over what he bought, who he knew, who knew him. Then his greed elevated to a game of how many he could save from an unholy death. People might say he as a person changed but I think all that changed was the context. The charismatic and foundational elements of Oskar always were there with his greed.
@@totoroid Greed is the opposite of charity, what he did was not greed but guilt. Greed would drive him to save friends or just family, not random strangers
@@Yusuf-fs4fnit depends on what you define by greed. It is greedy to obsessively not letting possessions go or being taken away by any other party no matter what. Like dragons sitting on its cache of gold he has no need of (and bring disaster more than fortune to said dragon). These people technically he has no need of. They cost more to keep, but since he decided that those people are *his* people, he keep them around with all that he has.
i love this scene so much. he is trying to talk to other business men, talk them into a more dangerous scenario to save many more lives. i love how much risk he is taking compared to others, who are keeping it safe. which is understandable, but the contrast that was shown is heart warming nevertheless
The other businessman is Julius Madritsch, who was also in the 1st lunch scene involving Schindler and Goeth. Madritsch also saved hundreds of Jews from the death camps as well.
That's because play time was over, loving money, and girls, was his thing before he saw the little red girl as her own daughter. It was like smashing a beautiful flower.
It’s crazy how much symbolism you miss by watching this movie once
Please elaborate. Would like to know.
So true. It took me several showings before I caught all the things I would’ve missed by only watching it once. This movie is such a blessing. It’s a masterpiece.
@@nobertas.tnobertas.t8193 the part with the ring! At the end “he who saves one life saves the world entire”
Stern told him that there are 1100 people who are alive today because of him
And that there will be generations because of him...
At that moment he couldn’t imagine it... but then when you saw how many people came to this tomb.... you realize stern was right
@@nobertas.tnobertas.t8193 “I could have gotten one more person”
Thanks. :)
Itzhaak Stern passed away before Schindler. It's said that Oscar Schindler was inconsolable at Stern's funeral. They weren't just business partners, they were brothers
Now do I understand the true meaning of that line “you’re not buying them, you’re buying them.” Stern previously told Schindler if he wants to continue running his business he will have to hire Polish workers but they cost a little more. Stern believes that Schindler has convinced Amon Geoth to let him hire these Jews to profit more from slave labour. Stern is happy to transcribe the list because he knows that the sub camp built for Schindler for his workers was a haven for the prisoners compared to the main concentration camp. But Stern understands he is not buying them for labour he is buying them to save them from the gas chambers.
I think initially Stern thought Schindler has convinced Amon to give him the workers for free, so Schindler can continue make profit. A logical businessman and accountant's logic. But then, he suddenly realise, Amon wouldn't just simply give up these people. Hence he was shocked to know Schindler is doing something that a person like him wouldn't do, so he had to reconfirm it twice.
Yes. He paid for all of them. He saved so many lives. It wasn't even about the money. He genuinely wanted to do it.
It’s amazing rewatching the scenes that he always refers how it’s effecting him. The train depot scene - “Then where would I be” line and this line “It’s costing me a fortune”. Interesting how he reflects how it effects him and portrayed! Watching documentaries and others they all say he was no saint but that’s why they lived.
I would be upset thinking great so much success in my business I did everything right only to give it all away
When steirn figures out that he's doing all this to save as many people as he can... 😭 Humanity at it's best
Absolutely beautiful man
A man touched by God's hand in the center of hell.
Amen.
Every time I watch this movie, I cry... An old man of 60
A 60 year old man with a heart
Thank you very much!
I always found this scene touching.
Don't come in here with that 666 bullshit. I know what you are doing and who sent you. We are with God. Don't try to twist the path and truth.
"I felt that the Jews were being destroyed. I had to help them; there was no choice." (Oskar Schindler)
Stern's realization at 3:25- 3:33 is one of the most overwhelming but subtle moments in any movie I can recall.
Can we talk about how beautiful sounding all these names are
🤢🤮🤣 eww
@crc3387 your hate is eww.
They are BEAUTIFUL INDEED.
Schindler always being focused on one more life - like saving the whole world.
I having a feeling that when Schindler saw and interacted with Jews such as Stern and the others, it was the first time he realized that he had a chance to get something more precious than money. The love and respect of others. He may have made mistakes before and after the war, but when the time came, at the most crucial moment, Oskar Schindler chose to save his soul, than lose it to 'fool's' gold.
A beautiful masterpiece from Steven Spielberg
This scene shows us that not Oskar helping people but other factories too.
How the hell did he remember all their names?
People had much better memories back then from what I have read.
Many come from the same families too
@@alecaquino4306 yeah but that was 70 years ago and now i can hardly remember my birthday
Human memory is incredible when trained, and being a business man, he has been remembering names for most of his life.
Well, Stern did help him a lot, but, to quote the man himself, "[he] knew the people who worked for [him], when you know people, you have to behave toward them like human beings"
Julius Madritsch in this scene is also something else.
This is a perfect movie. Ben k is such a fantastic actor.
01:23 Amon Goth with bloody money
Amon Goth- Monster from KL Płaszów. Hanging by polish justice in gallow in former camp, where he was diabolical comendant. Can says : ,,Jedem das seine" -
,, everyone what they deserve"
Leave one space at the bottom :(
There were many industrialists who did what Oskar Schindler did. Some payed the supreme price with their lives. Schindler was the one who was made known but all were angels here on earth.
they're shown in the video. Oskar mentioned Julius(the guy he's trying to convince) fed his Jewish workers out of his own money so he thought he will be sympathetic with the idea of moving them to a safe region.
wow, had no clue whatsoever that was Ben Kinglsey, wtf
Really dude? Yeah just cut the most important part of this scene
Allied collaborators and prisoners first, first change the headstones on the graveyards, to avoid reprisals. 2 of yours one of ours.
3:37
Did he chose those people randomly or he knew them personally?
They were his factory workers.
Man when I bought this movie on TH-cam it made me kinda sad that the comments were off, I just know that shit was because of crazy anti semites going nuts in the comment section.
Yeah and even some comments regarding Israel today as well
@@rocket_owo8341 Anti Zionism is not Anti Semitism, there are tons of Orthodox Jews, Secular Jews, and young Jews who are critical of the actions of Israel.
It's been some while since I've seen the movie: why did Schindler say "If you were still working for me ....." - who was Stern working for here if not Schindler ?
He wasn't officially working for him anymore. Goeth made him watch over Schindler/his money, there's one scene where Goeth says something like "Remember who you work for now" (him). Maybe it was also a way to respect him, making them equal that they're working with each other and not for each other.
Bloody money for beast from Plaszow
I HATE the old typewriter cus I type fast but lots of mistakes I can't erase. Also the pressure writing a book of life
3:26
You cut out the last couple seconds that showed the reaction to the list from the point of the people it was intended to benefit. You could've just showed THAT instead of everything else and it would've made sense. What you clipped here was just lazy.
Oh hush. Go post that part on your channel and I will come there to watch it with you :)
@@alecaquino4306 Ghehe okay :)
"Essential worker"
Where have i heard that before??
Uh, all over the USA, since 2019?? 😭😭😰😭😭
@@Mopehome yeah. We have learned they were all gassed since.
Immigration officer bargaining with the Judge...
What's the one space at the bottom for?
Helen most likely as they dont know yet if amon is going to let her go. So they keep it empty giving her preference but if she doesnt make it they will fill some other name. This heart wrenching cruetly all should never have taken place :/
Never stay quite in face of injustice even in face of death.
All those brutally murdered are all in heaven and far more lucky as God is rewarding them way more than we can ever dream of.
Peace and be good to others
@Charles Der Esser In respect of the murdered Jews, please leave out the reference to Jesus.
0:52 1:02
Subtitles? Come on....
0:52
0:06
1:08
3:15
0:33
1:17
"The list is life " - this clip does not show that line; but to me it is one of the most moving lines in the movie. I always cry at this whole scene.