Schindler's List | "I Didn't Do Enough"
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ธ.ค. 2019
- Schindler's List. Stream now on Peacock. www.peacocktv.com?cid=20200101evergreenownyt002&
As Oskar Schindler (Liam Neeson) prepares to leave his factory and surrender to the Americans at the end of World War II, he bids farewell to the workers whose lives he saved. The workers give Schindler a signed statement affirming all he did to help Jewish lives during the Holocaust. This causes Schindler to break down, and he says that he should have saved more lives.
Buy/Rent Schindler's List:
Amazon: www.amazon.com/Schindlers-Lis...
iTunes: itunes.apple.com/us/movie/sch...
TH-cam Movies: • Schindler's List
Google Play: play.google.com/store/movies/...
Fandango Now: www.fandangonow.com/details/m...
VUDU: www.vudu.com/content/movies/d...
Universal Pictures Home Entertainment: www.uphe.com/movies/schindler...
Synopsis:
One of the most historically significant films of all time, Steven Spielberg’s Schindler’s List is a powerful story whose lessons of courage and faith continue to inspire generations. Winner of seven Academy Awards® including Best Picture and Best Director, this incredible true story follows the enigmatic Oskar Schindler (Liam Neeson), who saved the lives of more than 1,100 Jews during the Holocaust. It is the triumph of one man who made a difference and the drama of those who survived one of the darkest chapters in human history because of what he did.
© 1993 Universal Studios. All Rights Reserved.
Cast: Liam Neeson, Sir Ben Kingsley, Ralph Fiennes, Caroline Goodall, Jonathan Sagalle, Embeth Davidtz
Produced By: Steven Spielberg, Gerald R. Molen, Branko Lustig
Directed By: Steven Spielberg - บันเทิง
![[LIVE] BABYMONSTER(베이비몬스터) - SHEESH | 두시탈출 컬투쇼](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6q-_9s6a_1g/mqdefault.jpg)
![[UNCUT]”บิ๊กโจ๊ก” แฉพลีชีพ เดินหน้า ล้างบาง สตช. ฟ้องหมด มันสนพวกใคร I คนดังนั่งเคลียร์](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FIWKnr2ArPs/mqdefault.jpg)
"There will be generations because of what you did"
That fucking line my god
And there were. Almost 10,000 people are directly related to the people he saved.
@@gc99289😢cry more 😢 loser
@@user-zp6ff2gr4nso incredible! He was such a great person and legacy still lives on today ❤
Yeah me too man, tear jerker.
Around 10000 people are the descendants of schindlers jew. This makes the sentence if you save one life it's like saving the entire world especially meaningful
Why Liam Nesson didn't win an Oscar for this is beyond. This scene alone should have won him an Oscar
He did get nominated for Best Actor, and just to be nominated for a Academy Award is THE highlight of most acting careers. As for the winner for Best Actor, Neeson had the misfortune to run into Tom Hanks in Philadelphia, which was a great performance as well, along with dealing with issues Hollywood was far more in tune with than this.
Schindler’s List did win a boatload of other Oscar awards, though.
He didn't get an Oscar, because he WAS an Oskar
his performance was beyond what mankind can honor with an Oscar. It was more than just screenplay. This was magic, and the kind of we'll never see again. It is a priviledge to watch this movie, to lay eyes upon such greatness.
Simple, Oscar doesn't deserve him
@stevendebettencourt7651 sorry but people will forget Tom Hanks performance in that movie. Once you see this movie you never forget.
This scene makes me ball like a baby, everytime. Schindler saved my grandfather, great uncles and cousins. They are portrayed in the movie. My cousin Olek was the boy who jumped into the toilet to hide from the nazis. Thank you Oscar Schindler, I'm here because of you. You've given me and thousands of other souls the great opportunity to experience life.
❤❤
Goddamn
I cried while reading this
I am so glad you knew your redeemers name this side of heaven.
I hope to see you in heaven.
It is truly an honor to encounter you in the TH-cam comment section.
That is a sentence I never, ever thought I'd type, yet here we are.
That letter as good as saved Schindler’s life. Some French forces came upon him and things would have gone badly until an interpreter read the letter. It made him burst into tears and he made sure everyone knew what Schindler had done.
He had protected their lives and now they did their best to shelter his. Now I can't stop crying.
The comments section in this video is an absolute gold mine. It makes me shed tears of joy knowing how well Oskar Schindler has been loved and respected till date. He has left behind a very large legacy. God bless his soul, and may God bless you all for sharing your gems of knowledge too.
@@abhishekjee919Me too man, me too. ❤
In his last years, Oskar Schindler was basically penniless, however for the remainder of his life he received donations from the survivors he saved. It was enough to keep him going till the day he died.
One pay check a year each if I remember correctly.
@@James-C24 abandoned his wife and moved to south america??? Failed businesses left a right after the war??? Its... Not thier fault?
The only member of the Nazi party to be buried on Mt Zion
@@josephgarrett5693 indeed although for schindler i think his membership was more for his own benefit not an ideological one that many had.
SO SAD
The way he frantically searches for the ring after dropping it is such an amazing non verbal way of showing how much it means to receive it.
his character was a suave sophisticated and clever businessman, and that combination requires a great deal of counterpressure to allow him to break character, meaning that his sympathies and empathies and humanitarianism had to battle through a huge ego to emerge in that pure vulnerable state of utter frankness that is capable of so much power!
Apparently schindler sold it years later
Its also making the movie more realistic and human its like a little accident that no one would think of to put it on purpose in a movie. But stuff like that happens a few times in the movie and i like that and it remembers me that its not fiction and really something that happend.
And this wasn't intentional.It happened while the were filming and they decided to keep it in the film
He was piss drunk during almost all the films in his career lol so dropping it could have been accidental but added good value to the scene
He saved 1200 people by selling absolutely everything he owned and was left in the streets and he said he didn't do enough. My heart is literally exploding from my chest, today's people all they know is themselves and nothing else and Schindler believed he didn't do enough
I had a similar thought, I'm often so incredibly saddened by how most people around me don't care about any suffering that is not their own. People even get upset at me for caring about important human rights issues (particularly the Uyghur genocide in china for example which is an issue I care a LOT about, because it's genocide...) and some even say, "who cares? why should I care about some random Uyghurs? how about my own life?" It breaks me sometimes because people are so selfish. Why shouldn't we care and try to do EVERYTHING we can do to save lives?
It's not today's people. People always put themselves first, throughout history. But there are always those golden few who can fight back the primitive urge screaming to look out for their own, and sacrifice for another.
Humans are not inherently cruel and selfish. We just have a lot of baggage.
@@cinnamonliebeMaybe you should 🙂 I bet you can find a way to do a lot of good. ask Jesus and trust him.
He has treasure in Heaven. ❤
@@MaiRaven3 amen ❤
"Whoever saves one life, saves the world entire." What an inspiring thought! After saving nearly eleven hundred lives, Schindler thought it wasn't enough...His compassion, kindness and courage will be remembered forever.
It's fiction you dumbass
“I could have gotten 1 more person, and I didn’t”
Perfect line, perfectly acted, perfect everything.
Perfect for hundreds tears
Such immense kindness, compassion and bravery in the same human being is an amazing thing ❤️❤❤
When I die, I hope I will be remembered as a good man.
Such is the hope of any man, to save all that he can.
Such is the fate of any man, to save only that he can.
Such is the destiny of any man, to save not who he wants, but who he can.
gets me every time
Even if he sold the car, pawned off the pin, and sold everything else he owned, including the clothes off his back, he would still think it wasn’t enough
That's a good man's heart that you just described
Selfless men will always believe they're not selfless enough.
That's the point.
this comment is kind of stupid he didnt say he wanted save them all, he sais he coulve got more, because he REALLY couldve got more, you are an idiot
@@baronss7499 first of all, please try to maintain some sense of respect and second, you misunderstood the comment. OP was simply saying that Schindler still would have thought that he didn't do enough even if he had done everything he could.
In my eyes, I see no mention of Oskar Schindler wanted to "save them all" like you said
Not only Oskar's regretting message broke my heart but Stern's reaction broke my heart even more.. He shook his head as he wanted to convince him and settle him down with his saying Oskar was already a hero to them.
But he could have done more
@@shmosel_Congratulations: You missed the point of the scene.
The curse of being a good person, no matter how much good you do you always feel it's not enough, because it didn't take ALL of you, there's still some of you left so you could have given more.
You can’t save everybody. But better to save the few you can than to do nothing. It’s both a blessing and a curse. God help those who through determined selflessness sacrificed their own happiness and mental wellbeing to ensure the future wellbeing of oppressed human beings and their future generations. Men like that make me question my own humanity at times. May he rest in peace.
Well said.
This man saved over a thousand people, and yet he believed he didn't do enough.
So shines a good deed in a weary world.
Willy Wonka/1971
@@malibustacy3606 the original quote is actually from a Shakespeare play. But I'm glad you caught the reference.
@@benanderson3029 Which play? I caught "In springtime the only pretty ring time..."
It's not how many he saved, it's how many he couldnt save, it's like survivors guilt, I tried to save someone and failed, I'm not faster than a car going 75mph, but I was so close that my mind can not accept that. I failed her and that's the only way my brain can process it.
@@Kajojek, way to downplay someone's selflessness.....
His reaction after dropping the ring as he scurries to pick it up like he's dropped the most precious thing is absolutely beautiful. So much said with absolutely no words.
That was not supposed to happen. He actually drop the ring but it was keep in the film.
@@josebarrozo7620, that's incredible. Just goes to show how good an actor Liam Neeson is by improvising so well.
@@prithviprakash1110 And I thought it was an accident.
@@josebarrozo7620 I thought so! I thought, "Did Liam intentionally do that and stay embodying Oskar?" I wasn't sure because this is too good a movie to not have that planned...BUT THEN AGAIN Spielberg is too good a director to not just let the camera roll and Liam is too good in this role to not stay being Schindler
Yeah, I've always thought that part wasn't in the script. It's just that Liam immersed himself so much in the role, that he reacted like real Oscar Schindler would. Whether it is true or not it doesn't matter, the scene is a pure gold as is the whole movie
When someone says, "I didn't do enough," It's always a sign that they did more than enough.
More than the majority.
More than what they believe.
Reason why Spielberg will remain as a legendary film maker even after several centuries. The sheer story telling involved in a ring falling from his hands in this iconic scene is insane
"One more person..." I can not imagine being in his position, knowing that no matter how many I saved, I could not save them all
this comment is kind of stupid he didnt say he wanted save them all, he sais he coulve got more, because he REALLY couldve got more, you are an idiot
@Quaker 2019 wtf that has to do with it, u idiot
@@baronss7499 ... morality is centre stage for schindlers list, it portrays how his morals compelled him to try and save as many as he could overriding his greed and 'devotion' to nazism as the little girl in red was a wake up call to what was happening. ideally schindler would of liked to save all of them but of course who wouldn't? his greedy and lavish past haunts him as he believes if he was more selfless he could of saved more jews despite the clearly amazing thing he has already done.
Hell
Very emotional movie.
“We’ve written a a letter, trying to explain things, in case you were captured...every worker has signed it.”
Would have carried no weight until it's verified as the allied interrogators had to assume the letter was written and signed at gunpoint.
@@aeroAdvocate but they would also ponder that if that was true, then all of then would have been killed after
@@UchihaFabio Well Schindler survived the war and post-war period, making it through the interrogations. I'm not familiar with his entire biography and if the letter part helped him in any capacity.
@@aeroAdvocate i dont remember, who caught him? The soviets or americans?
@@UchihaFabio i assume the letter was written in hebrew and english/german giving it instantly recognizable weight. of course it's no proof but it should instantly raise eyebrows.
This scene proves Liam Neeson was robbed of the best actor award in 1993.
nope - tom hanks in philadelphia was every bit as powerful; although i love both films - it's toss up, but definitely not a "robbing."
Facts!!!!
Tom Hanks was phenomenal in Philadelphia. It was a very tough lineup that year, but the Academy did right.
The woman on the far left of the screen crying as they rush to comfort Schindler at 4:16 reduces me to tears each and every time I watch this.
"Whoever saves one life, saves the world entire."
What a beautiful thing to say.
Allah said that in the Holy Qur’an
I think that's why he thinks he didn't do enough. Because he see's that one life matters that much, even looking at a golden pin remembers him of saving one more. Beautifull...
@@homex9636 it is common passage said by God in both jewdisum and Islam.
@@homex9636 well as alot of things from the quran that sentence is copied from the judisum too
@@harellevi3810 lol show us where in the torah it mentions it
“One more person”
You can feel the emotion from it in your heart. I personally think Liam should have been the one to get the Oscar.
But O he did, his name says it all, Oskar
Absolutely.
Similar to Andrew Garfield in Hacksaw Ridge
oscars sucks pure ass
@@tommypillay743 Aha so true xD
This is a movie that should be shown in every Highschool. This film was produced in a way that had the audience feeling the true impact of what the Holocaust victims had to endure. No Hollywood cheese, no over the top moments that has you feeling like you’re watching a Hollywood movie. It is intense, emotional, and at times downright brutal.
Im very thankful that my English teacher let us watch this masterpiece. I appreciated it then, and I appreciate it even more now, 12 years later. This scene never fails to give me full body chills. Neeson, Kingsley and Fiennes were all incredible.
A true cinematic masterpiece.
Oskar Schindler was a great man, and his story should be shared for generations to come.
They showed this to us in school too, in the 90s. I honestly thought it was a normal part of the curriculum.
I remember my history teacher showed us this movie in class back in high school. We had to let our parents know if we can have their permission to watch this movie in class because of how graphic the movie is, Which I told my mom I wanted to see it. I was one of the few students who was crying through the movie because I couldn't believe people would do such horrors to others just because of what they are.
You won’t be the same, if you have ever heard the firsthand stories, and truly unimaginable suffering that happened in that time.
It will happen again to the people that stay with God in the end
And history repeats itself year after year
@@TheBarefootedGardenerI feel compassion for the victims but at the same time I don't understand- Why does this one war deserve so much focus? Why was this the pinnacle of evil?
We've done this for as long as humanity has existed. There's so many that have died just because of their origin, who their parents were- On massive scales. It's just unfathomable that people don't understand this to me. Genocide isn't unique. This is part of humanity's dark side, not just a one-off. It'll keep happening, generation after generation, there will always be another monster.
@@wesleytheanonymous3751so? do you enjoy devaluing a genocide because others happen? what a stupid take.
"one more person... is dead... for this?" its truly a heartbreaking moment to realize how little human life can be valued at times, I rewatch this movie every year and it still breaks my heart
The way he looks at every earthly possession he owns and wishes he could have sold it even just to save one more person. Old or young. Smart or dumb. Healthy or unhealthy. As long as it was one more human life.
Pretty sure he said “a person stern” instead of “is dead” but still such a sad line
" We might call you back... "
Yeah. The way he says it is both devastating and just.. flabbergasted. A simple piece of jewellery, a mere ornament on his finger, would have saved two human beings. A father, a mother, a daughter, a son - that these mere things could equal their value to anyone else is shocking.
thats so funny because in the Jewish holy scripture, the talmud, gentiles are referred to as cattle and not as human as pure jews. so what was oskar to them? alpha of the pack of cows?
"I didn't do enough"? Let that sink in. He used to be a greedy scam artist who wanted nothing more than to be wealthy. And when he made the fortune he always wanted, he gave it all up. Every penny, to save the very same people he took advantage of. He gave up everything he worked so hard to get. And for that 1100 people got to live. And he still thinks he didn't do enough. No one could've done more than he did.
This scene is my one of my favorite movie scenes of all time. The raw emotion in that scene is so close to what I expect, and it probably didn't do that moment justice. What really was said at that moment (or thought) was far greater.
Before he settled into saving as many workers as he could, Schindler was known for leading a pretty lavish lifestyle. Here at the end he is wracked with guilt, because he knows if he had acted sooner, not spent so much money on drink and women, he could have saved more. Nobody could have done more than he did, but he thinks he could have.
@@CrashB111 that's want makes this scene so powerful- because he did so much, but he knew could have to so much more. That movie was so good
This is the heaviest movie scene ever for ALOT of reasons.Although he saved the people he did, only he knows those moments where he compromised. Those moments where he thought "maybe I should at least keep the car", those moments where he hesitated, and all the while remembering those times when he splurged for personal instant gratification. This scene captures how all of that crosses his mind, the moment where he is confronted with his moral decisions all of which are amplified when he is given the golden ring from the people who have lost everything. A ring made from people that agreed to literally have gold fillings extracted from their bodies.
When Schindler pulls off is own gold pin and realizes this could have been 2 more people, that guilt must have been overwhelming. It takes a certain level of empathy to decide to save 1100 people, and with that increased level of empathy comes increased levels of guilt. Anytime you decide to be charitable, it isn't the times that you decided to do good that stick with you, it is those times that you didn't.
This is inescapable. This is a very hard emotion to deal with. I break down everytime I watch this scene because you see how Schindler overcome with the gravity of the situation, breaks down and literally tries to hide. He cannot though, surrounded by the 1100 people he saved, there is nowhere to go. Yes he is a hero, but in being a hero, he more than anyone else, knows he is broken, and this is on full display
Whatever emotion that I am trying to explain it isn't often portrayed. There are probably people who go through life without ever experiencing some level of this emotion. Yet in this scene, the portrayal of this emotion is as real as it gets.
This part of the movie ties into the ending so well... when stern said “it’s from the Talmud “he who saves one life saves the world entire” at that moment like a real hero Schindler still thought he could saved more and laments the lives he didn’t say... but then you look at the ending and everything comes full circle... he literally saved these lives and the lives of future generations
Steven Spielberg was just magnificent in ‘93. This and Jurassic Park in the same year. Two completely different films, but both absolutely magnificent in their own way.
Truly incredible.
The actor did such a great job. the switch from laughing when he said "I threw away so much money" to crying was just seamless. Really got me. And the other actors did extremely well too.
A foolish man is one who is satisfied with his good deeds, but a righteous man is one who has done many good deeds but still believes he didn’t do enough. May God bless Mr. Schindler and those like him.
@geralt7050 Nothing wrong with being content by doing a good deed, but if you are happy about all your good deeds and think you have done enough and are, in fact, good enough, than you are not a righteous man. It's a very Christian way of thinking.
Rare.
Emulation of jesus is the ideal, but simultaneously an impossible ideal for Christians. A man is not foolish for being satisfied with his good deeds. As long as he stays humble and it doesnt make him arrogant or holier-than-thou
Now that you mention that, I immediately thought of Mother Teresa! A true Saint to the world!
A righteous man is also one who has done many good deeds and has already forgotten about them and never consider he has done any good deeds.
I love the way Stern immediately starts shaking his head “no” at Oscar once he says he could’ve got more. Stern instantly knows where he’s going with that and tries to put a stop to it immediately. It shows how close they became as friends and how well Stern came to know Oscar.
Someone said the same to me. It helps.
Ben Kingsley made this scene for me.
@@felixzayas8190 He was perfect as Stern.
Stern remained friends with Schindler for the rest of his life, corresponding with him until his death in 1969. It was reported that Schindler "cried inconsolably" at his funeral
A lovely historical fact as to how close the two became is that when Stern died, Schindler was apparently inconsolable for some time after.
Though perhaps the nicest detail of the film is the very end with the survivors and their families having come with the actors to place stones of remembrance on his grave.
People like Oscar Schindler are what makes me not lose hope in the Human Species. A true rare gem of a person that should be cherished as an example of who we should *all* be. Nothing in this World, *nothing* ,is more important than treating other Human Beings in the way that you would like to be treated. Not your big job promotion, not acclaim, not economics or social considerations should matter when compared to this.
I don't think there's an eye left dry after watching this scene.
I can't believe Liam Neeson didn't win the Oscar that year!, Tom Hanks' performance in Philadelphia is very good but Neeson's performance is an acting gem.What an actor!
Fiennes performance was just as good, albeit horrifying.
@@jareddoesstuff1928 your entire comment makes zero sense. 😂😂 I agree, Liam should have won, but no, not just anyone could’ve done that performance as well as Tom Hanks.
Agreed!
Agree. I think the world knows who really won the Oscar!!
Liam was really good but man, Tom Hanks in Philadelphia is at another level, still remember the opera scene where he explains the song to Denzel. Do you think, anybody else pulling that off??
I cried when they gathered to hug him. He thought he had not done enough, but these people’s hugs showed that what he did was already meaningful enough for them.
that pin was a nazi pin but made of gold, two people. he did all he could. i feel for him.deep one.
Well duh they got saved from being cooked.
I cried through the entire scene, what are you talking about lol
I am always crying when I am watching this scene. It is heartbreaking.
4:05 the crying, the embarrassment Liam portrays, just amazing acting
There are three movies that have made me cry, but not as much as seeing this scene.
Good lord, the music, and the sheer pain in his voice. Good god, seeing this for the first time, I bawled like a damn baby, seeing a grown man cry, realizing his mistakes, and knowing a life he could have saved, had been taken from him.
Liam Neeson, I applaud you for your performance in this movie.
What are the other two?
@@maverickmurphy Hachikō and "Boy in Striped Pajamas"
@@SUB-IN-SUPER heard of the boy in striped pyjamas before, didn't watch it yet. Will find out more about Hachiko.
Also, I would like to recommend grave of the fireflies if you want another movie that might make you cry.
@@SUB-IN-SUPER What's Hachiko about?
@@SUB-IN-SUPER Please reply!
At that moment he realized that he didn't need to keep pretending that he didn't care about those people. And his heart broked.
"Whoever saves one life, saves the world entire" that line always got me.
@Samuel I thought it was from Mishnah Sanhedrin 4:9; Yerushalmi Talmud, Tractate Sanhedrin 37a.
@Samuel it’s definitely there. Give it a look: “Whoever destroys a soul, it is considered as if he destroyed an entire world. And whoever saves a life, it is considered as if he saved an entire world.”
Wow.... something about how u pointed that out just hit me.. im not gonna lie. Theres never been a minute in my life that i am myself. 33 years and still just another pretender. And although right now in this very moment i can feel some kind of emotion or somthing, 5 minutes from now ill go back to wearing that mask again. And i wouldnt even care anymore
@Brian Presley had a feeling, was just waiting for him to slip up
@Samuel I know it was in the Torah
Imagine not getting an Oscar for playing Oskar.
So sad
You're right.
TBH, after seeing your comment, I wasn't in the mood to make a joke.
I can see that you are very serious.
There's a time for jokes, and there's a time to be serious.
I took the time to be serious.
Better that way.
Damn :(
Sad that he is better known for having a special set of skills and finding people. His performance in this was brilliant. No more powerful moment in all of cinema than at the end.
Do you really got a plan Dutch?
This film hits you even harder when you see it again years later after becoming an adult. It still hits you 30 years later!
Hey, when did you first watch this?!
@@HitlerLovesAnime when it came out, back in ‘ 93
@@marioaguileraiii8181 Did anyone in your theatre cry back then?
@@marioaguileraiii8181 How old were you then?
@@HitlerLovesAnime 18
Few movies left me as speechless as this one did. The acting, the story, the music; all based on the horrific events that occured in Nazi Germany during World War II. It's heartbreakingly beautiful...
The moment he realizes what "one person" means it's perfect, it's what this movie was trying to show us, no matter the race, ideology or the religion, only one person means too much
>pfp related
I'd say Nazis and fascists don't deserve being considered people.
One person is a human being, your mother, father, brother or sister. It’s the reality. One more person saved. So tragic.
says the guys with a pfp who killed 80% of humanity 😭🤣 but i get what you mean and i agree with you 🥲
@@josh6567 hahahaha yeah! About that I really love Eren but I've never supported his decision, though I can understand why he did all that
“There will be generations because of what you did”
Later in the ending we see what Stern meant
@Libs are Nazis my god that's amazing
@Libs are Nazis love your very accurate name!
@Libs are Nazis i watched and bawled
Also look up Konstanty Rokicki. He was polish consul in Bern who fabricated thousands passports to save Jews from holocaust. He was a member of Ładoś group, who together forged around 5000 latin countries' passports to save Jews. He died poor, forgotten and without tombstone.
@@Cephalos666 not forgotten, my friend. YOU know who he is, don't you? And now I do :)
The most important movie ever made, its' not easy to watch, it even painful ..but we must, we should never forget..
My god this is devastating. I can't watch this movie without any tears but this scene destroys me every single time. I'm bawling right now typing this. Gut wrenching
Every time he said 1 more person I kept thinking of the little girl in red in the village. That scene and this scene is so powerful.
Me too! I think she's meant to be the demon beneath his roads, what he could have done more if only he had begun his crusade earlier, had stopped his greed earlier. Powerful film
@@viddykhaos2896 What I find ironic is that if he had been a good guy from the start, he would never have been able to save so many people, and likely would never have been in power in the first place.
@@user-ez9ng2rw9c That is a good point! Without his crookedness, he would have never amounted the power and influence needed.
Dear Wendy Rotonto The little girl in red is getting out of sight - like Schindler never ever was someone who wanted to save people from Concentration Camps. He loved money, the fruitful network and the world he lived in. He was betraying his wife with younger women. Surely, he was not a Saint, but I'm pretty sure he was a chiseler. Like the littel girl gets out of sight - - innocence gets lost, too. Can his conscience bear it?
Take care and stay healthy
@@user-ez9ng2rw9c @Vidyut Krishnasrinivas The girl in reds significance can not be overstated. According to Spielberg, seeing the raid and that little girl was what fully turned Schindler from an opportunist into the live saving hero he became.
Oskar Schindler
"A Nazi Buried in Jerusalem."
The Profound Respect This Man still gets in Israel is Heartwarming.
Marmik Saini it is the irony of man, that the oppressed become the oppressers. I wonder what he would think of modern Israel today and if he would question if what he did was right. Not saying that saving the jews wasn’t right or that they are all to blame for Israel. Not at all but among the crowd he saved, many joined Israel and I wonder sometimes if he would blame himself for their actions. If he would think that it was by his hands that the many that now oppress the Palestinians were saved. I wonder what he would think...
He is buried in Jerusalem but was no Nazi
@@tomgauntlestrange he was a member of the nazi party
@@dominikudovicic3573 maybe, but he sure as hell didn't die a nazi
On Mount Zion too of all places.
I cry every time I watch this scene. The value of one human life to a generation hits home. He went bankrupt and risked his life trying to save every single person and wished he could have done more. They should show this movie in schools today. Many lessons can be learned from this great movie. 😢😢😭
Instead they try to whitewash it and say it never happened.
Idiot kids wouldn't understand
One dialogue of this movie always remains in my mind- “power is when you can kill a person but you forgive “
Whoever saves one life saves the world entire
The phrase is in the Torah, the Bible and the Quran, and yet, here we are.
@@guru0011 the fact that these 3 religions are sadly pointlessly fighting each other saddens me
Can somebody explain those words for me, please? It's hard for me to understand :(
@@fried_cabbage5653 a life is as valuable as all the lives
Buddhism states the same....
"Whoever saves one life, saves the world entire."
Oskar Schindler, you saved the world 1,100 times.
You know it's also mentioned in the hadith
@@outhmanejebli198 Bruh, don't. Focus on the film please.
@@outhmanejebli198 how is that relevant to the movie, this scene, to the discussion under this video or to this specific comment you've put it under? Don't take sides, try to spread love.
@k jeez I didn't do something Wath is it with you Americans when I mention the quran is like you are vampires and I throw at you holywater and between I just said that the parole from this movie is also mentioned in the quran so I am the guy with the friendly vibes
@@Wickerless the parole in the movie is also mentioned in the hadith so that's why it's relevant
When he looks at his gold pin and realizes it was worth the life of a person--a human being--and he breaks down a sobs, I lose it every time. A truly gut-wrenching movie.
This is one of the most intense and emotional movies ever made. I think everyone on earth needs to watch it at least once.
If Caught:
Schindler would have been strung up with piano wire.
That was the risk this man took.
God bless his soul and all the people he saved.
That is a man of real courage!
Yes ❤️
💜
And you mean that literally. I know what the Nazis did to traitors. He was taking the greatest risk to save these people. A truly admirable man.
@@martenhoyle And that's if the ones who caught him were being nice (especially nice would be shooting him outright), if they really wanted to, they would have tortured him for months to make him an example for anyone else thinking to do the same as he did, and perhaps making him watch the deaths of all those he saved one by one.
I doubt it would've been so easy. Poland was the one country Nazis treated ANY help of Jewish people with death... he helped many. Death would've been an easy way out in Nazis eyes.
How can anyone not cry with this masterful scene? Liam Neeson was excellent and masterful. He should do more drama than action.
Just watch the scene 347 times then the pride and admiration you feel for the man overtakes the sad....
Then cry on the next viewing anyway cause dammit this is a masterpiece
i never thought he belongs in action movies. he's not cut for it but he is cut for playing stuff like this masterfully
@@hazardeur
I disagree slightly, I think the first Taken was refreshing and quite enough of a display of his capability in that realm. Unfortunately, he’s worked out that that’s where the money is for him at the moment.
@@Telechontar09 that's weird, i remember Taken 1 to be full of broken up shots and not much fluidity in the fighting moves which ususally is used if the actor is not able to put down a convincing fight scene and/or the driector has not much expertience in th is genre. But I might just not recall those scenes....Can you link me a fight scene that has a constant shot of Neeson doing some convincing stuff?
Tears flowed by right when he said” I didn’t do enough”😭😭😭😭
Combat veteran here I have seen how inhumane people can be .and yet I still tear up to see him breakdown thinking that he didn't do all he could have to save more!
I have watched this scene over a dozen times now… and each time I cannot help myself from bursting into tears.
The most powerful scene in the cinematic medium. I can’t stop crying when I watch this scene.
Spielberg did his best work with this film.
Me too buddy.
@@HUEnshiro_do_Norte Same here
Seems you haven't seen the Godfather yet.
@Miss White ,
Idiot.
@@Arkantosi fuck that boring overrated shit Schindlers list is far better
Crying hysterically for 15 minutes.
The pain. The guilt. The sorrow. The love for this man to gather and rally around him.
So unbelievably powerful.
It hurts. It literally hurts. I cried even after the Hebrew quote.
As a human being, you cannot be left unmoved. Simply amazing scene and climax to the movie
When you understand how deep is this if you are human with hearth you will start crying even when you just remember this....
I cried for 15 minutes after this scene as well... it hurt my heart and soul, I felt the aching so hard. I am so grateful this movie was made to remember the incredible actions of Oskar Schindler and keep his story alive, reminding everybody how important it is to be kind, to fight for what's right, and that every life saved matters. Every single life matters.
Y en la noche de Estrellas sin ser nos esconderemos
This scene always makes me cry, it shows how little some value human life over material goods versus those who give up everything and feel they still haven't done enough. Schindler was on both sides of this, so it's even more heartbreaking to see how he realizes he could've always done more a lot sooner. I'm glad people like him still exist in the world, and that those he saved are still here. Even the actor who played him, just seeing hom give a flower on Schindler's grave...that part broke me for a long time.
Thanks to this man my grandmother lived
Liam Neeson never gets enough praise for his acting. The emotion here is unreal. I watched this film my senior year of high school in my English Class, and I have never been so drawn and moved by a film I am required to watch in school. This is why history is important. Fuck those people trying to erase it and make their own timeline and events. You can't change the past. Its called accepting it, but never forget it.
Agreed.
Agreed
the problem is accepting the fact that it was dark,I wish all those souls,all those beatiful souls gone by the words of one maniac.I cannot believe it until now,so many lives were lost and I mean the people who survived like how are they able to move forward?Just one death from my family already got me in unbearable tears and schindler?He saved a lot of them,he couldn’t do anything abt it either,If I was in his shoes I would already get shot by the nazis.
PIEKNE CO NAPISAŁEŚ 🙌🙌🙌🙌❤❤ PAMIĘĆ, PRAWDA I PRZEKAZYWANIE KOLEJNYM POKOLENIOM
Republicans
The entire cast of this film was seriously amazing. Didn't feel like a movie
A moment of lifetime bhai❤️
It was too upsetting for me but Liam neeson's performance was absolutely incredible.
Indeed amazing acting. It is frustrating that Liam didn't won an Oscar for his performance as Oskar Schindler that year.
He definitely did an incredible acting.
@@fredrydmusic1 no disrespect but this performance was above any of the standards. Oscars aren't made for this much amount of a performance.
Even the roles of Itzhak Stern and Amen Goeth were seriously nailed by them.
The reason why it didn't feel like a movie is because everything is true. I hear some people say it was nowhere near this bad but it was in fact worse. Some of the horrific acts committed can't be recreated.
No matter how many times I watch this, it brings me to tears. The signed the letter, the engraved ring, the confession.
Having just watched this for the umpteenth time, it is this scene that breaks me into tears. His guilt. His pain. It is beautiful acting. I would say this is Spielberg's finest work.
"I could have got one more person and I didn't" how broken he felt that. We need more like him. He did bad in the beginning but he found his humanity.
Just like Desmond from Hacksaw Ridge. "Just one more"
one of those he saved said in an interview that if oskar was not the type of person he was(including his bad characteristics, especially), he couldn't have done what he did.
The movie downplays it. From the very start itself, Oskar tried to save as many people as possible.
@@davidschwartz6380 indeed if Oskar didn't belong in Nazi party and if he didn't have the right connections and wouldn't have been trusted by other Nazis, he would never have been able to save these people
@Steve Watson You are absolutely right. Thank you for making this comment, I mean that sincerely.
How Liam Neeson didn’t win an Oscar for his fantastic acting in this superb movie is beyond me.
Oscars are bs.
Oscars don't deserve him
Because HE IS Oskar
Oh my ...I thought he won Oscar for this....this is a shame.
Well he was up against Tom Hanks that year for Philadelphia which was a huge success in it own rights I believe
This movie is so incredible, it can't even be called a masterpiece...it is completely undefined.
There aren't any words more painful than these:"I didn't do enough. I could have done more..."
I visited his grave in Israel. This was truly a great man.
❤️
An only Nazi to be buried in Jerusalem. He didn't die a Nazi. He lives as a Nazi. And thank god he is. (or he won't be able to bribe so much guard to save these people)
I will one day too.
@@siminoof how many lives have you saved buddy?
@@ethan132 silly
The ending to this movie made me cry so much. I’m not Jewish either, and anti-Semitism makes no sense to me.
@@Howlingburd19 Antisemitism has been around for at least 5,000 years. I wouldn’t expect it to go away in a comparative instant.
Couldn't stop crying while watching this scene. One of the most powerful scenes in cinematic history.
Oh tell me about I cried like a baby with no shame and I've never cried in a movie this was a masterpiece
It was a good scene - but one of the most powerful in cinematic history??? That seems a little overblown.
Me too but what i noticed is that a lot of friends that watched the movie cried the most wenn de family's had to get apart from each other but almost no one cried wenn all the people died and were burned. I think thats very intresting and i had the same thing and i think its because its so surreal that so many people die on one spot that our generation cant even imagen that put getting away from your family is more relatable. So i think it was important to have both things in the movie and not just the KZ.
I just wept watching it. Had to turn away from my daughter. Just told her about the movie
Man I cry every time I watch it
"Laughs"..I threw away so much money...."weeps"... You have no idea..." This entire scene is so powerful.
Liam Neeson acting as Oskar Schindler is masterpiece. I can't believe he doesn't win an oscar for that amazing role
@@muhammadnabilhakimi9237 He should've
At first I thought he was just laughing at the fact he threw away all his money that he originally wanted, but actually what he was regretting is all the money he threw away that could have gone to save another person.
@@freddieevans1668 The oscars are a joke honestly. Never giving awards to those who most deserve them
@@muhammadnabilhakimi9237 Tom Hanks got it instead.
Its crazy how he feels almost like he killed somebody by not saving 1 more person..
This is probably the most touching scene in the history of the film industry. I already watched it four times and made me cry in every single one of them. Liam Neeson deserves an Oscar for this memorable scene.
I was a jaded angry teen when i saw this movie. And this scene broke me. I cried like a baby. It gave me hope in humanity. What a masterpiece of a film.
“ a l risa dije Enloqueces y al Hedonismo, de que sirve esto?”
Delfooos
Cuidado
Con el pentágono
Es un loco peor que Nos.
Nada es necesario para ser paz
Y en mi desAnimo siempre
Recordaré al Reino.
Por las playas libres
🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶☮️🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶
The absolute range of Spielberg to make a historical drama like Schindler's List and then follow it up with a sci-fi blockbuster like Jurassic Park IN THE SAME YEAR! At his peak, Spielberg was the greatest director in history, no one comes close to his range.
You're so right...I was 14 in 1993...I remember seeing Jurassic Park and Schindler's List multiple times, and it cemented my lifelong long of cinema. I know some people condescend to Spielberg and consider him just a "dumb blockbuster" director, but no one has fueled my love of movies like this man has over the course of my life.
@@keefriff99 the people who call him that are morons. You don't become one of the most, if not THE most influential director in cinematic history by just directing "dumb blockbusters"
I was thinking the same thing about the music.
Absolutely 100% true. There has never been a better direction in history.
Kubrick's range was insane too, though he was no where near as productive as Spielberg. He released a couple of movie every decade or so, while Steven made two movies in one year, both being Brak box office records I might add.
This is the only scene from any movie I have seen that has ever brought tears to my eye. Nothing else have ever come close, but right at 4:00 is what somehow breaks me every time.
Watch brotherhood of war on kissasian you'll cry
The man who saved 1100 generations
Everything this man did is so powerful. The look in his eyes after he says “ one more person “ is the same look he had when he saw the little girl in the red coat dead. That’s what really made this man break down in pieces after he realized that the little girl in the red coat was a person he knew he had to save… after seeing her walking through a massacre.
Especially because in exchange for that he had the Golden Party Badge instead - of the Nazi Party with the swastika on it.
Crazy this is he was originally an awful person but slowly over time realized the error of his ways. He once recounted wining and dining a Nazi that he considered an abomination but he did it anyways to trick them into letting him hide more Jews. Had he been a good person from the start he never would have managed to save so many.
I believe the girl in the red coat is the person he thought of. I couldn't really hear but I think he says, "...a person who is dead." That's what makes me think he is actually thinking of the girl in the red coat.
@@chrisbcream64 Nah he said “a person Stern”
He truly knows the value of human life, because he doesn’t see the quantity but rather the value that even one person has. That’s why he keeps saying he could have save more. What a wonderful man.
Even if he did save one more person, he'd still want to save another person.
😘🙏🏻🙏🙏🏾
I watched most of the movie externally unscathed and serious. But this scene broke me to tears so incredibly fast I could not help myself. What a movie
I've never cried to a movie before, but God... Wathcing this scene for the first time brought me to tears, Schindler.... God bless you, you saved so many people.
Without having to watch the entire movie, this scene alone always gets to me 💔
GR ultra legendary movie
With this i force u to eatch it if you can its art
Mee too.
Yeah.
Truly
This scene is so powerful because it translates the urge every human has to help others, to be a good person.
Well said Shravan.
Maybe not every but most normal people yeah
@@mide8845 I mean not the Nazis, clearly
I think the best part of the movie is Oskar himself and that commanding officer who likes to kill people. It shows how war truly changes people. If the war didn't happen Oskar would have been a greedy industrial pig who only cared about money, and the officer would have been a kind and lay low man who would have settled down and made an honest living, war truly changed them.
I used to believe that. Sadly, I no longer do. We have tent cities & growing crime in the US which amount to a mental health crisis of epic proportions…fully ignored.
if i were to choose one movie to be seen by the entire world, this would be the one. apart from the fact that it's cinematically speaking an amazing movie, for the director, the cast, the cameramen's work etc. but it also holds such a powerful message and it tells a story that humanity cannot forget. we mustn't forget these innocent souls. we cannot. i personally watched this movie only twice, because it really shows human cruelty at its worst, and even though this isn't even close to what actually happened (because of course they could have never portrayed perfectly the horror of ghettos and concentration and termination camps) it haunts me. it really does. i've always wondered why would someone want to humiliate, discriminate, hurt, torture, kill an entire group of people. why?. i really can't find an explanation to this kind of human evil. it's horrendous to think that children (even newborns), mothers, elderly, disabled, homosexual, political opposers and jews had to suffer this. the least thing we can do is to respect these people. respect the survivors who keep on telling us stories in order to never forget what happened, even if by documenting history they suffer reliving those years. respect the victims and their families. respect the millions of people who were involved in the lowest point of human history.
I am a 28 year old man, and I cannot watch this scene without bursting into tears. There are plenty of fictional movie scenes that move me, but it hits so much more, knowing this actually happened. May you live forever in paradise, Oskar Schindler.
Fictional?
Bro I’m 27 and if I hear the music anywhere I start crying automatically😂😭
@@Brohskey19 here, same
@@Brohskey damn you bro, I'm also 27 I just cried as well
@@shlapdat2126 He means that because this movie is real, that means this could've happened. That's what heartbreaking
Can we just appreciate neeson as an absolute powerhouse of an actor like oh my god how did he not get an oscar
But we do
@@OmarLivesUnderSpace keep doing it
Daniel Day Lewis did not get for In the name of Father which i felt was more deserving than Tom Hanks. And i felt more than Tom Hanks, Denzel Washington should have got nominated for best actor.
this pin, one more person. oh that breaks my heart. one more person who didn't die in the gas chamber, its deep man.
It's not the trinket won, it's how people are moved that's remembered. That is the power of sublime story telling.
All human beings were treated like vermin during this War.
Undoubtedly one of the finest movies ever made .
And superbly acted by the cast led admirably by Neeson, Kingsley & Fiennes.
This scene makes tears flow not just for the acting & emotions but for the thought that we humans are capable of doing so much good but throughout history end up doing so much bad 😢
Truly one of the bravest men ever....R.I.P. Oskar Schindler!
If Oskar Schindler was able to save at least one more person, he’ll still feel guilty for not saving more other Jews
Goes to show that one life means everything and can make such a difference.
Who else wanted to be part of that group hug? I did!
Music - Genius
Acting - Masterclass
Directing - Unmatched
Story - True
And thus you get a timeless milestone and warning for generations to come.
Hotel-Trivago
@@l.vucko996 I was crying and you made me laugh lol
Unless you live in the US today. Sadly.
@@sheridixon190 What do you mean?
@@l.vucko996 Stop it
Teen-agers & maybe some adults should be made to watch this film. Horrendously beautiful, amazing acting & camera work to show what horrors mankind can do to themselves.
Until today I cannot watch this without shedding a tear. He saved over a thousand people and instead of bragging about it he thought he didn't do enough. Yes, he didn't do enough. Enough would have meant to save all the six million murdered. No man could have done that by himself!
Europa: The Last Battle. watch it.
The reason this scene breaks my heart is because Oskar seemed to have viewed them as a cohort throughout the movie (for pragmatic and mental health reasons I presume), but now after hearing the inscription he fully realises the immeasurable value of just one single life. Just as one life saved is an entire world saved, one life lost is an entire world lost. Everyone is a person with just as much thoughts and emotions as himself, and everyone is someone's child or parent someone never gets to see again. Those left behind will always be plauged by the thought of their child or parent dying helplessly in horror and agony; and their world will forever be destroyed. What if you would have been a jew under WW2 and he had just saved one single more person and it was your daughter or mother?
And what hurts him even more than keeping the car, was keeping that Golden Party Badge, of the Nazi Party, with the swastika on it. The car was at least useful. And during the regime, I suppose that badge carried a lot of weight - while there were millions of Nazi Party members, only a few tens of thousands had the golden badge which carried huge prestige, opened doors, made people deferential. But still ...
One of the best comments in here. The one moment I like the most is when he says: "One more person... Person, Stern, for this." He was referring to his golden pin, a sign of membership in NSDAP. To think that one golden pin (in weight less than 20 g) is worth a human life is truly heartbreaking.
Sometimes you just feel the need to cry, but it won’t come out, so you find something to make you cry.
This has done that for me for my whole life.
No matter how many times I see it, I can’t stop the tears
Same
Same, I don't get how, even when I totally don't have any need to cry I'm here sobbing with him.
Very sad. People reduce to numbers and value. And he wishes he calculated them better
I am a callous thirty-something man. It's difficult for me to cry, even when I'm over-burdened with emotions. When I need to cry--when I need to feel pain and love for my fellow human beings--this is the scene that I watch.
ABSOLUTELY RIGHT!!!!!!
The emotion shown in this scene is why I love Liam Neeson as an actor. You could feel the pain in his voice...
As I saw somewhere else, the tragedy is that it wouldn't have mattered how many he saved, Oskar Schindler would always believe he could have done more. He could have saved a thousand more, ten thousand, a million, and he would *still* believe he didn't do enough, because he couldn't save *everyone*.
“The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.” ― Edmund Burke
knowing this was real it makes even more heartbreaking
ya sure about that bud?
@@drovid008 Oh fuxk off you Holocaust denier
@@bosertheropode5443 i think he means this specific scene
@@diegorubio2625 I dont Think so, there are tens of thousands of neo nazis out there, if it wasnt meant that way I apologize
@Jeff Rutt Yeah, you could say that. However, many of them died because of the japanese, Sovjets, italians, british, americans...
never watched this movie before, but his acting alone made me cry
If you’re on the older side, you should really watch this movie. But you might want to bring some tissues