Mumbai Local with Devdutt Pattanaik: A World Without Heroes, Villains and Victims - Session 1
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 พ.ค. 2018
- A World Without Heroes, Villains and Victims | Devdutt Pattanaik | Mumbai Local | Session 1
This talk by Devdutt Pattanaik is a part of our Mumbai Local series.
The Mumbai Local addas with artists and scientists are held regularly at our partner venues across Mumbai.
The sessions are free and open to all. To know more, please visit www.junoontheatre.org
We look forward to seeing you at Mumbai Local. If you can’t make it for understandable reasons like you’re not in Mumbai - enjoy the videos!
Warm regards,
The Junoon Team
I can spend hours listening to Devdutt! Pure Gold wisdom and knowledge.
I am spreading hours and hours listening him only
Me too
The simplicity and logic with which he explains is just awesome ❤❤
Krishna Patil
Devadutt's speeches are beautiful you never feel tired of hearing
True
I think in years to come, Devdutt Pattanaik will have a staunch fan following due to his clarity in thought and powerful story telling :)
Beautiful way of explaination character of person situation and
Fictional story telling!
@@sourabhs7443 Can you even do that ??
@@choudhurysaheb8326 Cooks up a story which is factually incorrect and sells them as truth. ....... And yes I can't do that!!!
Dr. Pattanak's wisdom is so unique. Real knowledge is hidden behind what we have learned till now in Surinam and Holland and I think also in India.
He is such a fantastic storyteller that how my 2-3 hrs goes that I don't know
Amazing talk.. I really admire Devdutt Sir!
Amazing session
Sir pranam ur smile says lots of things and u dont need to tell anything
Such an amazing speech
Thanks a lot sir
Just mesmerizing. Thank you
Very good
amazing!!!!
Just amazing sir..
I appreciate what you did....great....
Awesome 🤘
Love from burma.Rangoon.
what r u doing there
very good
Love every new prospective on a subject
Attractive Wisdom ...
Excellent
Somebody needs to tell Devdutt Pattanaik that he doesn't need to pop a cork every time he says a word with the letter 'T' in it.
Duvidha! 🙏
Excellent 🔥
i liked for mann ki baat!
:3
I used to like listening to his talks. In fact, this is the second time I'm listening to it...and it has dawned upon me...he just obfuscates a simple story by bringing In some back story. Yes Kansa had a terrible childhood, yet him being a "baby killer" is not justifiable and hence he is a "vilian". And why is this so called uniqueness of India model he speaks of...doesn't Joker have a sad origin story? Almost every superhero villian has a dark origin story. Devdutt has read the the text and knows some stories that others don't, but that doesn't mean his interpretations carry special weight . Pretentious at best.
Arre par that is the point, why do you want a supervillain and superhero and from whose perspective? Even the western has story telling format with no villains or hero's, take sienfield for example
19:15 इसे कहते हैं अभ्यास 🙏
I don't see any purpose in this discussion. At the end of the session , what is the learning ?
Correction @30:24 *Kans (not Karna)
सर क्या आप कलयुग ओर अंत पर लिख रहे हो....यदी हा तो कब तक अस बारे मे युटुब पर सुन्ने मीलेगा.
I read Amar Chitrakatha from DC books and I always feel the story is manipulated badly and distortion is so obvious. But mostly feel helpless not knowing where to get the real stories for my child who is extremely curious about Mahabharata stories. Hope your audience/writers will make a change in this direction
Didn’t expect you to say वसुदेव कुटुम्बकम…. It is वसुधैव … of the whole earth
Now time it's main problem with us we want only say not listen. That's why we so far from success or dharam. We should do work on that loos point. Hare Krishna 😊✌️🚩
What is your dharma, dear?
When Devdutt (Pattanaik) puts up a situation in which a person standing in front of a grazing dear and a lion standing behind the dear. The person is suppose to act in good will. Then isn't the person suppose to let everything happen by itself if he is walking on the path of dharma?
Aditya Gupta it depends whether there are enough deer, grass or tigers in society to sustain it.
Mohit Shetty say if there are only few lions & dears in society but enough of grass and dear begs for help then how's person suppose to respond?
@@adityagupta_1995 offer yourself reference raja shivi
@@adityagupta_1995 that's a flawed hypothesis, Nature has it's restraint to manage the order.
If there are more lions than deer, a large fraction of predators will die of intraspecific struggle, if there is more grass then deer or some other animal will grow to maintain the order.
It is hard to fathom some rather irate opinions about Devdutt’s interpretations of Hindu scriptures. What is the issue, people? I have seen books on the holy Bhagwat Gita by Mahatma Gandhi, Vinobha Bhave, KM Munshi, Radhakrishnan, Rajgopalachari, Chinmaynanda, Prabhupada, Dayananda, and a dozen others. So why begrudge Devdutt HIS commentaries and interpretations?
Jamna badal gaya hai logon ke Apne dimag ek version leke chalte hai gita ka aur kisi ka version saha nahi jata
Good always triumphs over evil 😂
Many will disagree but,
.
Sometimes even Devdutt put things in very wrong context in order to explain some things else.
This is what exactly he is talking.. The meaning will change with the context .
22:40
See problem is this when people's ask him questions they have to understand he is just doing baykhan off story he is not a saint whom tell you how to get moksha if there is no.moksha then what bhudha doing mahaberas doing are they are brainless
Who is Devdutt Pattanaik @
I like your interpretations on epics,but plz don't throw your own ideas on mukti, jivan and atma at us
If you really want to know what this guy is about watch this: th-cam.com/video/vtkMFLuOa3M/w-d-xo.html
He is very creative and articulate but he himself commits many of the mistakes he complains about others for example many of the story writers do not stick to the facts as in Mahabharata or Ramayana but use their own prejudiced opinions. But he claims Kunti was raped from which Karan was born. In no version of Mahabharata was shown to be Kunti raped. Karan could have been a result of youthful love but wants to use rape as the certainity. He states it as a fact not what could have been. I can name many other such instances where he states his figments of imagination as facts. Again, no doubt he is talented, creative and succesful but he is too self obsessive and wants to others to see things his way.
Not karna dude kamsa hear properly.
Kamsa? How is kamsa born to kunti? Taking cocaine?
@@MaheshKumar-yj8nc you will do the world a greater good if you start watching properly from 30.18....yes he accidentally told karna instead of kamsa but he later corrected it.... cocaine is very costly dude i cannot afford it.
bugger is self admittedly sponsored by the swedish church. 1. Foreign funded. 2. Anti brahmin. 3. Anti hetrosexual - proponent of lgbtq. 4. Sex and Violence painting of hinduism 5. Feminism supporter. 6. anipulating and Misrepresenting facts. 7. Anti-India dog.
He is the Indian but u have become drenched in colonial education.... So you can't see the truth that lies in his views.... I have also read many Indian Purana's.. His words makes sense but he is a little wrong in some places but mostly he caught the idea right.... You doubter.....
This is a message to Devdutt, please dont distort truth feom vedas and puranas. If u r thus true Hindu please correct major anomalies as discovered by Rajiv Malhotra. Looks like u r no better than Shashi Tharoor!
Please stop and correct urself, first master Sanskrit and then disect Hindu vedas. Also it is wrong to tag Myth to all Hindu scriptures and traditions. Its very important at this time we are dire in need of intellectual True Hindu who can fight verbally with Christians and Islamists including Intellectual Communist party affiliated hindus who are slapping Hindus right and left and tagging us as Terror Hindus!
Please for heavens sake and the respects we have towards you kindly change ur assumed attitudes towards Hinduism!
Thanks.
Sashi Tharoor himself consults devdutt for advice on Hindu scriptures, that is why they have similar views. About the rest I don't know so I won't say anything
You forgot an essence of story telling. Somewhere the story needs an end. If not, this state of mindset (continous enquiry)lead to commit suicide Mr.Devdutt ji... One day I'll read this in News Paper.
I disagree, curiosity doesn't kill.
Otherwise all the researchers and philosophers have died early than they did.
When you find story that has been left in the realm of ' what would de and what should be? '
You get lots of possibilities to explore.
Dude you do realise you are using TH-cam and commenting. Do we know about your life story, how does it being, how did you reach this youtube video, how does it end? Is everyone whose going to read your comment will commit suicide?
All that glitters is not gold. Devdutt may be a best selling author but is he really presenting Hinduism/Vedic culture correctly? No. Kindly refer to critique offered by Rajiv Malhotra on youtube for only 5 mins to understand what Devdutt's books are worth!
Don't you feel that you have been writing the same comment over quite a number of videos? I agree everyone has the freedom of speech and expression-so does Devdutt ji has, so does Rajiv ji has, so do you have and so do I have...but if you hate him so much from the bottom of your heart, then why are you just going on watching all of his videos and commenting the same thing over each of them...even if it's out of context...I think you have a lot of free time...anyways you are not judging him on whatever he is speaking...you are judging him on Rajiv Malhotra's commentary on his book "My Gita" which he is not even talking about in these videos...So please clarify your actions...obviously if you feel free to...noone can oblige you...it's a free nation after all...
I don't care what rajiv malhotra says...This person Patnaik is actually making our new gen to respect our Mythology and Hindu values that's all matters.
Yaa rajiv sir who proposed reincarnation money transfer fund(lol)...
I respect him,. Rajiv sir's work is good but he got stuck with to only one approach ...whereas devdutts approach is good for today's generation who wants to narrate things in todays context....
Rajiv g heard/learned scriptures in older time with limited/no technology...whereas devdutt learned/heard scriptures as well as internet(which is the most powerful library if used properly).
We got to be careful....we as a person see what we wanna se...can't digest the fact that there are other realities, other approach and another way of telling same story.
Devdutt is completely ignorant of sanskrit language and is a just fictional writer.
But he caught the idea correct.... The meaning is bigger than the words... His books sell because his words make sense.... If rajiv is correcting him then he must give another alternative for explaining Indian world views as well as he is an NRI... But his mind is in colonial era and a left out ego.. I can hear it in his videos... And books.....
Bhai Hanuman chalisa aur ramcharitra manas dono sanskrit main nahi thi aur Valmiki ramayan aur ramcharitra manas dono main bahut difference hai par kaha jata hai Tulsidas hi Valmiki punar janam hai, tho kya fark padta hai language se?
@@niteshprabhu6791 I am talking about Devdutt as he makes up things as per his convenience.
He is a story teller without any noble purpose
Also sees Indian civilization from a western abrahamic religion lense by just calling Indian ithihasa as mythology 😂😂
One more mini version of Ram Guha 😀
Beware that this guy is a deciple of Wendy Donegar and Sheldon Pollock's school of western indologists. Great talker or a story teller does not mean Devdutt tells the truth.
Bas wohi issue hai kya, translation proper nahi hai?