@@gems9525 Lmao! I actually think that somewhere between 2nd and 3rd gen some rules (and more) changed in music shows and now everyone just seeks perfection ... But yeah...most of the 3rd gen can't relate...I still love them tho...
I dont know if at his last minute before flew away from this world, did all these memories flash back on his mind? Did he cry like on his first stage? If so, do those tears for happiness? or sadness? Nobody but him got the answer...
@@SimpleInThinking exactly nobody know the answer so stop this kind of thing okay? i'm so sick and tired when people only remember him as a depressed person,he was happy he's living his life to the fullest so stop it if you don't know what exactly happened just fucking stop it!
@@achocolatelily0804 as a blinger for 4 years i don't think that applies here, though. i'd rather we talk about him a little more mindfully, and not out of nowhere in public spaces meant to celebrate a performance. i think most of us are still really sensitive, after all, and it's not like this comment was doing much besides morbid speculation - it's one thing to try to understand jonghyun the person, and another to ask pointless rhetorical questions about someone's passing.
2:40 watch Taemin give his microphone to Key so subtly 2:50 Key passes it back. Taemin puts his left hand behind his back while his right is attracting attention on his chest, and Key looks at the camera so you can barely see the hand off.
I'm extremely proud of how far they've come. SHINee will always have such an important place in my heart. Wherever they decide to go now or whoever they continue with their lives or careers, I will support these members for as long as I can. And to my prince, my dashing beauty by the moon Jonghyun, I will always feel proud of you. You made me feel so many types of love and happiness, all of which I hope you can feel in your next life. I love you, 5HINee
Can we appreciate the amount of singing they did? Like even the background vocals they sang!? I mean singers back then actually put up such good shows with so much singing coordination. I may not stan them but they are just so good, they have been so good over the years
i never got a chance to stan shinee (i just saw a few things about members individually), i came here after txt's cover of this song and honestly, tears flew, that was really emotional. this is such great debut stage, i'm regreting i wasn't there for shinee.
Every time i come back to this stage i realize that no matter how many excuses we make, the newer generations of kpop don't even come close to these og groups specially in live performances. Now don't come at me sayin "stop comparing, they're young, hard choreos, they're better performers etc" cause shinee are also teenagers here but still slayed. You see all those footworks they were doing, still slayed. I'm not complaining but we should stop claiming our 4th gen groups superiority for doing the bare minimum that they're supposed to do as idols.
They were babies here, omg how I miss Jonghyun. I've never felt more affected by a "celebrity" loss, but he really is the only one that shook me to my core. Such a bright spirit. So talented, too.
Happy 15th anniversary to Replay! Idk why but watching this made me emotional 🥺 Perhaps it’s knowing how young, scared, and nervous they were? They had no idea what the future held for them, but still gave it their all. They probably never thought they would dominate the world and still be active (and relevant) for their 15th year anniversary. They did so so so well. A group like SHINee is rare and I’m so proud of them. Knowing and loving SHINee during my lifetime is such a big honor 🩵
SHINee's vocals are no joke even 10 years ago.. (especially JongHyun and Onew's) It's their debut stage and they were singing live, PERFECT LIVE , while lot of Kpop groups nowadays just lip sync on their first stage.
I really missss those old days that you can actually hear the idols singing live + catching their breath and ain't afraid of voice damages. That's what you called real talent.
I really can't believe this was 5 years ago!They looked so fresh and cute andinnocent and all of them were under 20!!!!Time really flies!^^ Makes me feel nostagic!
All of them so cute..and see Jonghyun putting is all effort in this debut..since young he was amazing and will always be. I will never forget of his existence and wonderful work. ❤️💙
i hold my cry when i watch this video.. they grew up so much.. but a believe they are still same.. still shining until now.. :') the time passes quickly..
I remember SM debuted them without much notice or at least that’s how it felt like to me. When I saw their video on TH-cam back then “I was like what?? Who are they?” Regardless, their debut was a success and is really one of the best debuts ever in kpop
i swear this will never die. this has the exact same feeling as the first time i watched it. i love them all so much. i wish i was born like maybe 1997...but isntead i was born in 2008 so i missed out on them, and their adventures, and their wins, and their growth. :(
The one that really amazed me is they sing it for live in their first debut and it's really sound like a pro singer. The one and only one the best boy group who really talented in all aspects. Shinee bogoshipda 😭
I’m here cos Taemin is enlisting today....... the feels.....🥺🥺🥺🥺 Always a bittersweet moment seeing old videos of you guys...happy and thankful for the memories even though the pain doesn’t really go away...still we must smile and be happy for everything JH has given us. ❤️🙏🏼
Me coming back to see our Jonghyun again🥰....guess we are missing him so much❤.....Thankyou Jonghyun for all those amazing songs❤.....I guess i will keep on coming here to see them again in their early debut period❤❤❤
![[ENG/JPN] SHINee dancing to their song from debut to now in 2024 #SHINEE](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cmI8g9-u3E0/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ENG/JPN] SHINee dancing to their song from debut to now in 2024 #SHINEE](/img/tr.png)
![[ASTRO - Replay (SHINee)] Special Stage | M COUNTDOWN 161110 EP.500](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/k0saglyPww8/mqdefault.jpg)
Taemin looks like a damn 10-year old among his adult brothers and yet still rocking the stage with his dancing
Well he was only 14 at tat time🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Yesssss ahahah, our sweet baby!!!
tbh even half the other members were still kids too
All of them r in their teens here... Cute babynee❤️
Nice
This never gets old. Listen to those live vocals.
facts
3rd gen can't relate😳😳😳
@@gems9525
Lmao!
I actually think that somewhere between 2nd and 3rd gen some rules (and more) changed in music shows and now everyone just seeks perfection ...
But yeah...most of the 3rd gen can't relate...I still love them tho...
Exactly. Forever 5HINee 💎💎💎💎😇
@@gems9525 comments like this are unnecessary💀 compliment your faves without having to tear down a whole generation of idols. Bitch
2020 is cancelled. We’re bringing back 2008.
Meena Hanufi jesus, baby, I was 8
@Meena Hanufi I wasn’t born
I was 3 tho
@@frostedjosieos3193 y'all are using social media way too fast.
i was like 5 years old in 2008 omg
Onew seemed to have never aged after 9 years. 😂😂😂
i see no lies, tbh. he still looks the same. :')
Pandaholic7913 agree
Make that 12 years
he drank from the fountain of youth😄
Fae don't age at the same rate as humans
i am the only one who can see how "excited" Jonghyun was?? and the tears in his face at the end?
I dont know if at his last minute before flew away from this world, did all these memories flash back on his mind? Did he cry like on his first stage? If so, do those tears for happiness? or sadness? Nobody but him got the answer...
@@SimpleInThinking can you not. Just enjoy his dancing damn. Stop speculating his last moments, it's mad disrespectful. Enjoy his LIFE
@@SimpleInThinking exactly nobody know the answer so stop this kind of thing okay? i'm so sick and tired when people only remember him as a depressed person,he was happy he's living his life to the fullest so stop it if you don't know what exactly happened just fucking stop it!
Haus of Tiffany it is disrespectful.
@@achocolatelily0804 as a blinger for 4 years i don't think that applies here, though. i'd rather we talk about him a little more mindfully, and not out of nowhere in public spaces meant to celebrate a performance. i think most of us are still really sensitive, after all, and it's not like this comment was doing much besides morbid speculation - it's one thing to try to understand jonghyun the person, and another to ask pointless rhetorical questions about someone's passing.
This song is the definition of nostalgia
old
Same
So true
RIGHT
@@stephanievidal955 old but GOLD. ✨
Oh my god they're all so tiny. It blows my mind that these cute boys grew into the dashing men we know and love today.
Look at little mushroom Taemin
Replay is still the best debut song, going into their 12years and it still has that feels ❤️
CDnee since debut, live since their debut stage
CDnee ?
@@_TokoShin yeah we call them CDNee because of their amazing live vocals
@@rubyjane8606 Ahh, that actually makes sense, thanks !
Still the best debut song ever.
2020 everyone?
this song is superior
Me, always wiht 5HINee.
2021
Abril 2021
november 2022
It’s already 2024 and this is still a masterpiece
dayum Jonghyun doing all of that dancing and STILL IN TUNE!!!!
2:40 watch Taemin give his microphone to Key so subtly 2:50 Key passes it back. Taemin puts his left hand behind his back while his right is attracting attention on his chest, and Key looks at the camera so you can barely see the hand off.
That was so smooth
thanx for pointing that out, I would never notice 😄
yeah I replayed it several times because how smooth it was
holy based. it took me 45 mins of internet research to believe this is taemin since the only taemin i know is from move. holy crap
@@skzanarchistreplayed 😂
I'm extremely proud of how far they've come. SHINee will always have such an important place in my heart. Wherever they decide to go now or whoever they continue with their lives or careers, I will support these members for as long as I can. And to my prince, my dashing beauty by the moon Jonghyun, I will always feel proud of you. You made me feel so many types of love and happiness, all of which I hope you can feel in your next life.
I love you, 5HINee
For me it’s the same!!
Can we appreciate the amount of singing they did? Like even the background vocals they sang!? I mean singers back then actually put up such good shows with so much singing coordination. I may not stan them but they are just so good, they have been so good over the years
I miss this kind of stages. Vocals on point and backup vocals not overpowering the actual voices of the singers.
Rest in peace Jonghyun❤
I hope more idols in the future can sing live like this.. SHINee sets such a high standard for me it’s hard to get into other groups 🥹
How can their debut stage already have great vocals like this
Trainees during 2 or 3 years before this video....
@@LS-uo5roobviously every kpop idol trained before debut, but they were crazy good for a newly debut group
@@LS-uo5rowell nowadays there are idols who were trained for 3-5 years yet they can’t sing and dance at the same time
i never got a chance to stan shinee (i just saw a few things about members individually), i came here after txt's cover of this song and honestly, tears flew, that was really emotional. this is such great debut stage, i'm regreting i wasn't there for shinee.
But you cant to be now, you heart is Shawol.
Never is late i became a Shawol this month! 🥺💙
Every time i come back to this stage i realize that no matter how many excuses we make, the newer generations of kpop don't even come close to these og groups specially in live performances. Now don't come at me sayin "stop comparing, they're young, hard choreos, they're better performers etc" cause shinee are also teenagers here but still slayed. You see all those footworks they were doing, still slayed. I'm not complaining but we should stop claiming our 4th gen groups superiority for doing the bare minimum that they're supposed to do as idols.
This song is the reason why I started to love SHINee.....still my most favorite debut song
Now they are a senior with 7 years of experience & they still look young & fresh more than many rookiers groups these days.
They’re 13 this year 😭
14 this year. OT5 forever.
15 this year and still look young and fresh
They were babies here, omg how I miss Jonghyun. I've never felt more affected by a "celebrity" loss, but he really is the only one that shook me to my core. Such a bright spirit. So talented, too.
im amazed how they are literally making every single those little background sound by their own on LIVE. like u guys dont breathe???
ikr! they really are great live performers ❤️
Happy 15th anniversary to Replay! Idk why but watching this made me emotional 🥺 Perhaps it’s knowing how young, scared, and nervous they were? They had no idea what the future held for them, but still gave it their all. They probably never thought they would dominate the world and still be active (and relevant) for their 15th year anniversary. They did so so so well. A group like SHINee is rare and I’m so proud of them. Knowing and loving SHINee during my lifetime is such a big honor 🩵
dang jonghyun is a powerhouse of a vocalist in this song. so much dancing around but still in tune
SHINee's vocals are no joke even 10 years ago.. (especially JongHyun and Onew's)
It's their debut stage and they were singing live, PERFECT LIVE , while lot of Kpop groups nowadays just lip sync on their first stage.
look at that flawless live vocals, 1st debut stage with such young age, but they delivered.
I really missss those old days that you can actually hear the idols singing live + catching their breath and ain't afraid of voice damages.
That's what you called real talent.
they were singing live at their first ever stage. iconic debut. shinee are legends
いつ見返してもやっぱり5HINeeかっこいい。。
#YoureallydidwellJongHyun
#YoureallyworkedhardJongHyun
#RestInPeace
#MyAngel
#LoveU&RememberU4ever
I really can't believe this was 5 years ago!They looked so fresh and cute andinnocent and all of them were under 20!!!!Time really flies!^^
Makes me feel nostagic!
and now it’s been 12 years... wow
@@enyivictoriaa 13*
14 now, girl. 🥺
my god they're singing LIVE, like, literally
I'm shook
this choreo is deeply iconic and it deserves to be so
Who knew this cute maknae would release a song like move, criminal 🤧🤧
And danger. ❤️
I miss shinee 😭 they were my very 1st time Kpop Boygroup i staned since 2008, they will be my forever 1st Kpop Boygroup i loved so muchhhhhh
Same my first K-pop boy group
It's been almost 12 years from their debut. I'm such a proud mom 😭♡
same:((((♡
I was in highschool when I witnessed their debut stage… dang, suddenly nostalgia hits!!! I miss you Jonghyun, you were my bias!!!
I watch on 25 May 2018, it's been10-years..SHINee is real LEGEND!!!❤
Wow, how far they've come! I wonder if they even dreamed that they'd still be going strong nearly 16 years later?
The debut of the most talented kpop group. Happy SHINee Day
I still remember this. Can't believe it's been 15 yrs. Never gets old😍
14 years later our baby Taeminnie becomes King Taem ❤️ You've been grown up very well baby!
I miss the OT5 so much... All love to SHINee and miss you always Jonghyun
so many years have passed and I'm still stuck here…
Taemin killed his part. i can not stop watching it, and to this day 2023 he still killin it
BEST KPOP BOY GROUP INDEED
Almost 8 years since then... So many memories~!
I can't believe that its been 11 years since their debut
They will always shine in our hearts
10 Years old today.
Thank-you for everything, SHINee. I love you.
THIS SONG NEVER GETS OLD.
Look at onew’s big smile, they looked so happy to be there🥺
It's 2022 and still in love with them❤❤
Live vocals and smooth dancing
Everyone chanting "shinee" at the beginning gives me energy 🥺🫶
All of them so cute..and see Jonghyun putting is all effort in this debut..since young he was amazing and will always be. I will never forget of his existence and wonderful work. ❤️💙
i hold my cry when i watch this video.. they grew up so much.. but a believe they are still same.. still shining until now.. :') the time passes quickly..
I remember SM debuted them without much notice or at least that’s how it felt like to me. When I saw their video on TH-cam back then “I was like what?? Who are they?”
Regardless, their debut was a success and is really one of the best debuts ever in kpop
i swear this will never die. this has the exact same feeling as the first time i watched it. i love them all so much. i wish i was born like maybe 1997...but isntead i was born in 2008 so i missed out on them, and their adventures, and their wins, and their growth. :(
The one that really amazed me is they sing it for live in their first debut and it's really sound like a pro singer. The one and only one the best boy group who really talented in all aspects. Shinee bogoshipda 😭
10 yrs later still love this song. You were a bright light.
14 years with SHINee 💎❤
its 2021 and I've decided to binge watch Early era of shinee. Now here I am all teary eyed and saying "my boys 😭😭😭😭"
It’s 2021 yet this is still my favorite debut song ever. They’re so young. This song still bring tears to my eyes. I’m so proud of my boys.
Best debut song ever!!!! The smiles on their faces is so adorable. Apparently, SM didn't have a clothing budget back then?
Legends and they didn’t even know it
Shinee is legendary
I suddenly miss the 2008 shinee, happy 2023
Just watching this and thinking back to the old days and all of a sudden tears just started rolling down my face.
I’m here cos Taemin is enlisting today....... the feels.....🥺🥺🥺🥺
Always a bittersweet moment seeing old videos of you guys...happy and thankful for the memories even though the pain doesn’t really go away...still we must smile and be happy for everything JH has given us. ❤️🙏🏼
💙💙💙💙💙
OMG IT'S A DEBUT STAGE AND THEY WERE DOING IT LIVE. LEGENDSSSS
Tear up… so proud … I feel like I keep watching all of my boys are growing up. My 5hinee. 💎 almost 15 years.
The most beautiful debut stage ever
I wish we could turn back time
It's 2021, and I've seen a lot of new groups still cover shinee replay. It's a timeless song for real.
Now I know what SHINee did when I just turned 3 months old on that day
😭
@@itsppi I just turned 3 months old when SHINee debuted
ohh you're a baby shawol!
i was only 5 years old when they debuted. kinda wish i could experience this in real time
@@cuteshark2964 yeah.... I liked SHINee when I was ten because I heard everybody and I became addicted
This was one of the best debuts
When I am sad, I just come here. They always make my day better💗
The seed that grew to become one of the most talented, wonderful and "avant-garde"-art-experiment in K-pop wave. I will love you always 5HINee
Key was the pretty boy since debut omg they are so good , I want to replay 2008
Love you Jonghyun💛
Key slayed that outfit hard. I love this stage!
Me coming back to see our Jonghyun again🥰....guess we are missing him so much❤.....Thankyou Jonghyun for all those amazing songs❤.....I guess i will keep on coming here to see them again in their early debut period❤❤❤
SHINee will be back on May!! Can't waittt
Baby Onew ❤❤❤
His vocals have always been unique. 🥰
SHINee 5 forever 💙
Many years and I still love this song so much 🥺💜
This one is one of the best songs in k pop history..
I really love it
this is the best debut so far
Such a timeless song ❤
RIP jonghyun I love you so much 💔💔💙💙💙
im obsessed with this era of shinee
I can't believe that this was their first day on the job
今聴いても良い曲すぎる
Watching this right now cause why not? They are the reason why i'm into kpop 😭❤
Everything this song transmits is incredible
Taemin born to be the greatest dancer 💖
No, taemin s born to be a star. 😁
14 YEARS WITH SHINEE, HAPPY ANNIVERSARY!!!
💎💎💎💎💎
2022 and i’m still inlove with these boys
Laughing the whole performance how young they were 🥹 I listened to them since 2010 but just decided to be a real fan maybe idk lol
its never too late
they look like they are actually having fun, this is my favorite debut performance of all time