Pranckall lmao i was so falling hard for moonbin but rocky was always there too..and wham with this cover omgggggggggggg totally fangirling oveer rocky!!!!!!! 😍😍😍😭😍😍😍
This is probably the first cover of Replay that actually did the original justice, I love how they put their own color into the song while keeping the original spirit.
Txt did good but it just felt more aggressive with their dancing. Not that it's a bad because they are amazing dancers especially with intricate dances. This song just feels softer with Astro and reminds me more of Shinee.
At this rate I think they’re not underrated anymore.. more like under appreciated 🥺 but I know our boys and one day they’ll be the star of everyone’s heart❤️
I think this is the best cover of Replay ever done. Astro fits SHINee's early boyish image so well and they sort or remind me of young SHINee (my bias group is shinee so to me this is a huge ass compliment)
Three years ago, I left a comment here how as a Shawol I said this is my favorite cover. Astro did a great job. Seeing it again, and Moonbin singing Jonghyun's part breaks my heart. Rest in paradise, Moonbin.❤
Astro is the only group that gave me SHINee vibes and this cover is indeed the best. Depression and anxieties are beasts that took these bright talents. Your job shouldn't put you under this much pressure. Wish everyone good health and self-care.
mj was 22 jinjin was 20 eunwoo was 19 moonbin was 18 rocky was 17 sanha was 16 the power they have already hold since they were so young but people still sleep on their talents. i’m glad they’re getting more recognition these days.
It's so weird because I was the same age as Taemin when Shinee debuted so I couldn't really understand the whole "noona love" concept but with Astro I'm fawning over them and I completely understand.
Lukabunny0 They can't refrain from giving fans a heart attack that's what because bloody hell these boys I swear I'm one foot in the grave because of these beautiful boys.
I cried😢 Replay is an anthem and so many people listen to it, what's so sad is that the new kpop 'fans' just troll older groups even though the older groups are so iconic
Yeah I was happy and smiling but then I noticed that then I was crying this is the second time this happens I didn't know I was lost watching the video :)💙
@@cherryflower6081 then watch his other song covers, he was recently on the masked singer and he did so well. He isn’t a vocal in Astro, but he’s considered an all around-er. He covered Versace on the floor (Bruno Mars) and Hold My Hand (IU). And there wasn’t much autotune here anyway. If you’re hating in someone at least try to back it up with validity.
this is the first natural sounding cover I've heard. they sang so well. most other cover I've heard sound very awkward or the voices don't match the song at all but they pulled it off so well
It's prerecorded, it's also got slight pitch correcter evident which can be an effect of the mic itself. They are still heavily talented! I believe there are some live moments in the recording whereas Rocky's belts are definately not live.
One thing about ASTRO is that when they have to cover a senior groups’s song, they really do it properly and make sure the song is executed to the maximum 👏🏼👏🏼🎉
*GUYS! I'VE BEEN A SHAWOL SINCE 2012... AND I GOT TO TELL YOU, THIS COVER IS THE 'BEST OF THE BEST'. FIRST, THE THEME FITS THEM WELL. SECOND, THEIR SHARPNESS AND CHILLNESS WHILE DANCING. SHINee IS THE REASON WHY I'M IN THE K-POP WORLD AND KIM JONGHYUN IS MY BIAS SINCE 2012, HE WAS MY EVERYTHING( i miss him so much and his birthday was yesterday). AND BECAUSE OF THIS PERFORMANCE, ROCKY ALMOST HAS THE SAME VOCAL AS MY JJONG, I SWEAR TO YOU GUYS. IN ORIG SONG, JJONG HAS STRONG INTONATION BUT THEIR VOICE IS VEEEEEEEEERY SIMILAR. I LOVE JJONG AND MINHYUK SO MUCH. ANOTHER THING IS SANHA'S PERFORMANCE, I REAALLY NOTICED THAT THE WAY HE SINGS IS VERY SUITABLE AND ALMOST A GOOD MATCH TO THE ORIG SONG. DON'T GET MAD AT ME. I'M TELLING YOU, IM A CERTIFIED SHAWOL.* .... *STAN SHINee* *STAN ASTRO*
@@채원-i3x I already did my dear, this is just my opinion since most astro's voice are suitable for this song and yeah the fact im a shawol. I love my babies(TXT) too!!! Theyre just soo cute. Dont worry im a fan of both.
When I first went to cf with Shinee I only found some early stages, 1 looked like the back of a room and the 2 groups sounded quite different to each other. Taemin still had longish hair tho. I assumed Astro had been asked to perform this special stage bcs they sounded or looked similar, But they did have a similar vibe. I looked at the time bcs someone had commented that Astro was cute and Shinee was not.(I knew Taemin must have been young and HE would be cute at lleast, front and centre). At that time I'd watch the sports clips and not many music ones so knew who MinHo was. I still have only warched a couple of Shinee M/vs, I watch their concerts -feel the love. I cried a little too over JongHyun but at the time I was mad. Thank you for your meaningful remarks.
As an oldie second gen fan, this is the performance that brought me back into kpop after nearly a decade of being out. I was thinking "there's no way they can do shinee justice" and well I was dead wrong. This group is something special.
I'm so happy seeing people think he's a vocalist, when he's actually one of the groups rappers I also love that people are interested in "the pretty one in the green sweatshirt" MJ shall be slept on no longer
Idc if people hate on me for saying this but this is the best rookie group of the year if you listen to their mr removed they are hella stable even with their hard choreography, perfect synchronization, and amazing visuals. Like seriously this group doesn't lack anything yet they aren't really popular
YES. I'm shawol too and I was pleased to see so many other shawols giving these boys props. They absolutely nailed this cover. Their voices fit the song really well, they added a little bit of their own flavor, the dancing was on point, and they have that same fresh, boyish cute energy debut SHINee did.
astro is the best. what rocky did is very hard for a rapper.his high notes were excellent. sanha is looking very cute in pink and his expressions were full of cuteness. astro has very talented members. actually everyone are cute and talented.
On point. I'm completely surprised (in a good way) hearing rocky sing like this. Who knew he can hit high notes like this. Astro really have a lot of talent hidden. 😍
From what I remember rocky is a good singer, it was just astro was filled with so many singers they trained him as a rapper and he just agreed to it since they were all friends when they became trainees. He sometimes shows his singing abilities but for the most part he stays as a rapper.
@@yessiawk4102 sad truth,,,i have watched it somewhere when he says he wants to be a singer,and im surprised coz he always do the rap and dancing but what he really dreamed of before was to sing,,,so i really wonder why fanmu didnt gave him a chance to sing to,(i mean w/ a longer part,)i am really hoping he can have a solo song that he will do the rap and the singing,,,
I really think fantagio is the luckiest entertainment like they got this talented group under them. Beside they all such a group full of visuals, all of them have their own charms and talents. Beside rocky can sing high notes, jinjin also can sing really beautiful and well here even tho he didn't get many parts. And all vocal line proved they can sing to anything beautifully. Don't forget how sweet and lovable this guys in the group. Fantagio, you're the luckiest. Please treat them well. We're not gonna stop support them!
I'm a 9 year shawol so when I saw the title of this video, I was like "I know I didn't just see some rookies cover my babies. Man I'm ready to judge" BUTTTT HEY!! It may seem rude for me to say so but I didn't expect them to do so well! Thumbs up! And most importantly, I think they really add their own color to the song!
I am an AROHA and a SHAWOL and let me tell you this is so good it literally makes me feel like i am listening to the original version sung by SHINee . Astro did an amazing job on this
I feel this deeply cuz when shinee released this song, I didn't feel much since they're all older than me. But with astro there are two members younger than me so I lowkey like when they sing the chorus 👀👀
When I first saw this I was praying in my head "Please don't butcher my song".. and it was so good! I don't know much about ASTRO, so I'm glad I saw this!
I'm a Shawol of 5 years so Astro just went under harsh judging... and they came out well! You did a great job Astro and SHINee would be proud that you guys did well. The guy (sorry, don't know names) doing Jonghyun's stronger lines thankfully didn't try and do the exact same and used his own voice in a great way. I approve!
***** The SHINee fandom is one of the very few fandoms that don't criticize covers 😁 as a fandom, we are very kind. And yeah, a lot of rappers seem to hide their amazing voices!
Back here after watching pd101 s2's replay covers and finding it even more impressive how astro pulled off this song. Not that pd101's were bad but Astro's is just on another level
I guess that time many viewers would be thinking that Rocky is one of the main vocals but he is main rapper of the group....as I am new AROHA this side of Rocky is really good to see
i am a shawol and every shinee cover out there did not appeal me as much as astro’s. they did it so well, they didn't leave out lines or choreography and i heard astro's rapper rocky(?) did jonghyun's high note like wow...astro is full of talent and i am definitely gonna look into them more!
Do you know the difference of this cover of ASTRO to other groups cover? It sounded natural just like how SHINee does it. Others think Replay is a song where you do aegyo or they think it's cute (I'm not hating on others but I just want to tell that Replay is kinda like innocent? Not being cute. SHINee made it looked cute because of their visuals that time, I MEAN TAEMIN'S HAIRCUT THAT TIME JUST MADE HIM CUTER, not because of their performance.) Plus their voices fitted the song well. That's all. I REPEAT I DONT HATE OTHERS WHO DID A COVER OF REPLAY OKAY I JUST WANTED TO TELL WHAT I THINK IS DIFFERENT AND WHATS MY OPINION. lovelots peeps uwu
Because they covered this song, was the first day I started stanning this group. This was my absolute favorite Shinee song. And then their vocals is what got me in.
BEST TRIPLE THREAT THAT I EVER SEEN!!!! MAIN DANCER....SKILLED RAPPER.....CAN HIT THE HIGH NOTE TOO?? wow... FANTAGIO GOT ALL BEST TRIPLE THREAT.... MALE: ROCKY..FEMALE:YOOJUNG and ACTUALLY MOONBIN IS GOOD TRIPLE THREAT too
OMG I'M A SHAWOL SINCE SHINEE'S DEBUT AND I'M AROHA ALSO OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG ~~~~~~ WHY THIS SONG OMG MY HEART UGHUGHUHG. I WAS SO SURPRISED. THANK YOU ASTRO & FANTAGIO I LOVE YOU EVEN MORE
As a Shawol I want to thank to Astro >< This is so fresh OMG ❤ When I saw Astro perform with Replay I just realized that SHINee has growing old lol Sorry love xD xD
MJ is way to underrated. HE HITS THOSE GODDAMN HIGH NOTES SO GOOD HE'S GOT ONE OF THE BEST VOICES IN THE KPOP INDUSTRY in my opinion NOTICE HIM AND WORSHIP HIM TILL THE END OF TIME
SHINee and Astro are my two favourite groups. I would have never given kpop another shot if not for Astro and mainly Moonbin. MJ totally reminds me.of Jonghyun too, voice and size. Both groups with beautiful songs
I don't think you guys know how happy this makes me astro are my precious angels and shinee is my ult group and I've always wanted to see a group I really like perform a shinee song and the fact that the group was Astro and the fact that it was shinee's song reply makes me so happy. It went together so well. I feel a lot of earlier shinee songs fit Astro well.
Well. Frick. Now I'm confused. You got Rocky, who can rap, sing, AND dance like he's trying to break the stage, JinJin who is basically the same, but THE DEEP VOICE THO, Moonbin who has a good voice and is a good dancer, MJ with those *Slaying Vocals*, Eunwoo who is absolutely adorable, and I ADORE his cute nasally voice, then Sanha the giant puppy. I- I can't- They make me want to simultaneously jump off a bridge and sing my little heart out. ALL 6 OF THEM-
TBH Rocky's talent isn't fair. He is the main dancer, has the voice to be a main vocalist, and is one of Astro's rappers. WTF?!?!?!?!?! LOVE HIMMMMM!! His talent is uncannyyyy
As a rapper, Rocky did absolutely amazing with the high note! And his dancing slays as usual. As expected as the lead dancer. They all slayyed! One of the best covers of my favorite song.
Watching this again after I saw TXT perform REPLAY on KBS Gayo Deachukhe 2019.I wanted to compare the two but they have different concept. This one was cute concept while TXT's is like a boyband concept. Both does good.
Astro did an amazing job covering this iconic song. There's just something about Jinjin. So talented. Under estimated. Jinjin deserve a lot more recognition.
and this is how you properly cover shinee's replay everyone learn from astro ✌️ some groups tend to over execute the steps and the vocals when they cover this song it ruins the whole thing ☹️ when it just actually have to be this clean and simple ✔️
![TXT - INTRO + 누난 너무 예뻐 (원곡 : SHINee) [2019 KBS Song Festival / 2019.12.27]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6gsEaTnsrGc/mqdefault.jpg)
![TXT - INTRO + 누난 너무 예뻐 (원곡 : SHINee) [2019 KBS Song Festival / 2019.12.27]](/img/tr.png)
![[ASTRO - Crazy Sexy Cool] Comeback Stage | M COUNTDOWN 171102 EP.547](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/g0486DHOOXA/mqdefault.jpg)
![(광고)저세상 텐션으로 역대급 분량 뽑고 간 아스트로(ASTRO) [엄마가 잠든후에] #차은우 #미모도역대급 (ENG sub)](/img/n.gif)
I know I'm late but WHAT???? A rapper can singing like a lead vocalist??????
Our Rocky is SO TALENTED 💜
Actually they all can sing it's just jinjin prefers rapping and rocky just goes with what hes given lol
Rocky was trained as a vocal before being a rapper
BAHAHHAHA meet rocky
rocky
Moonbin covering Jonghyun’s part is so emotional. hope they both rest peacefully 💔💔
I was just gonna say this. So heartbreaking. I hope the both of them rest peacefully among the stars....❤
The same part, the same destiny😭😭😭
They were my biases, what has happened to them destroys me, I just hope that wherever they are they no longer feel pain.💔🌙
:((
i came here to say this also
Isn't rocky a rapper? Wooow that was a amazing vocal he did there👍👍👍👍
can u show me who that is??
FA21 the one in black shirt and jeans
The guy in 1:53. Watch my bias slay!
OMG YA WOW Rocky's vocal is reallyyy great 👍👍👍😱
and he is one of the main dancer too wowww damn talented 👏👏👏
Knowing that moonbin covering Jonghyun's part here making me more emotional. The feeling while watching this will never be the same again...
I DIDNT KNOW ROCKY COULD SING LIKE THAT IM SHOOK
IK!
I already wached this like a 400X and I still not beliving
jongbrothers hhgg i was shocked at rapperline like 😍
jongbrothers hhgg your Jungshook
sorry not sorry XD
Same here yo I was like "Whoaaaaaaaa" ^^
Yeah..
The guy in pink shirt, his voice is so sweet and he looks so cute 😍
That's our maknae named Sanha! :] He's a 00' liner
MrChhay SONExotic yess.. he is maknae in ASTRO :D
when u thought u decided on moonbin as bias but rocky pulls this vocal shit
Pranckall
I feel you :')
my life was almost together
minhyuk just had to didn't he? HE JUST HAD TO BE A BIAS WRECKER AND SING THEM HIGH NOTES FLAWLESSLY AND SKKFJEKDKF
Pranckall lmao i was so falling hard for moonbin but rocky was always there too..and wham with this cover omgggggggggggg totally fangirling oveer rocky!!!!!!! 😍😍😍😭😍😍😍
Moonbin still the 1st bias and Rocky is a very close 2nd bias/bias wrecker
Nneka O lol yup...he is too adorable...but honestly they both are like my bias...if im not looking at moonbin im looking at rocky lol
THE FACT THAT MOONBIN DID THE SAME PART AS JONGHYUN MAKES ME CRY THEY SUFFERED THE SAME WAY AND DID THE SAME END REST IN PEACE 😭🤍🕊
ASTRO COVERING MY FAVS MY DAY HAS BEEN MADE I LOVE
AND ROCKY WTFFFFFFF AJJSMCNBZKCJANZKJWWNFOHEYQHNXBHDWJWKWMXB❤
Ky (KYoMicA27) SAME
Ky (KYoMicA27) I found you!
Rocky and those high notes tho
Who's Your Bias
Mine is Cha Eun Woo
Asian PusheenCat Mj's my bias
Asian PusheenCat MJ is my bias 💕💕💕💕
eunwoo, sanha, rocky and jinjin (( iTS TOO HARD TO ONLY CHOOSE ONE OKAY ))
Mine is MJ 😍😍
This is probably the first cover of Replay that actually did the original justice, I love how they put their own color into the song while keeping the original spirit.
Check out the Produce 101 season 2 one.I think they did great.
A year later and i still agree with this statement ☆ this is the only cover that did the song justice
@@zunerazoonie4594 what about TXT cover have you seen it?
Txt did good but it just felt more aggressive with their dancing. Not that it's a bad because they are amazing dancers especially with intricate dances. This song just feels softer with Astro and reminds me more of Shinee.
@@siska_yuri i have and honestly Astro's cover is wayyy better. I have nothing against txt but this just wasnt their kinda song i guess
the fact that he covered jonghyun’s part made me burst in tears. you made our hearts heavy but i hope yours is at rest now.
sobbing
😢
Shawols and Arohas?
2019?
HIII
💚💚💚
Meeee
Meee!!
hi😍
This group is so underrated. They should be worldwide famous
They are was so talented ❤
They are already worlwide famous
🥰🥰🥰🥰
At this rate I think they’re not underrated anymore.. more like under appreciated 🥺 but I know our boys and one day they’ll be the star of everyone’s heart❤️
JACOB ALARCA yes this is the comment Astro is extremely good , they’re just under appreciated
I think this is the best cover of Replay ever done. Astro fits SHINee's early boyish image so well and they sort or remind me of young SHINee (my bias group is shinee so to me this is a huge ass compliment)
I feel exactly the same, imma shinee group ult biased and this is so good(?
Agree
I just saw this now, and seeing someone singing Jonghyun's part makes me both happy and sad.
They're too adorable! And I agree I didn't know ASTRO can pull this off! SHINee's songs are hard to cover.
Doesn't MJ sorta look like and give off a similar charm as Jonghyun? My heart ♡♡ ~ saying as a fellow Shawol
Three years ago, I left a comment here how as a Shawol I said this is my favorite cover. Astro did a great job. Seeing it again, and Moonbin singing Jonghyun's part breaks my heart. Rest in paradise, Moonbin.❤
I did the same as you. The feeling is so weird.
Astro is the only group that gave me SHINee vibes and this cover is indeed the best. Depression and anxieties are beasts that took these bright talents. Your job shouldn't put you under this much pressure. Wish everyone good health and self-care.
2 minutes 57 seconds and the fact they're singing my fav group that got me into kpops debut song is enough to convert me. I need names and ages!
Saitama Trash
Green - MJ (1994) Main vocalist, eldest
White - Jinjin (1996) leader, main rapper, dancer
Blue - Eunwoo (1997) visual, vocalist
Yellow - Moonbin (1998) vocalist, dancer, rapper
Black - Rocky (1999) main dancer, rapper
Pink - Sanha (2000) vocalist, youngest
please check out their new MV confession !!
Ani Lin I shall and oh fuck, the time was gonna come. when idols are younger than me. two are younger. I finally get to call myself a noona!!
Saitama Trash then their cover of replay is fitting 😂😂
*bless vocalist rocky*
sun shone rocky is not vocalists but he is rapper
sun shone legend says he is main vocalist
Yes hes a rapper but he can sing 😉😉and also a good dancer
Ryein leigh Mariano more than good dancer tbh😂
He's gotten every talent there is!! ❤
When the lead rapper/main dancer can sing like a main vocal.....well damn.😨😱
I agree. Im here scrolling checking who appreciates rocky's vocals as i do in this cover. 😍
Kim Jisoo My Wifeu ma bias. He has beautiful visuals too.
hold on... that guy in the black shirt is the rapper ?????? bruh, i just came here as a shawol, and i'm impressed HSGHLKFHLFJLG
@@4ngelgotchi yahh
Thank you for appreciating Rocky 😭😭😭
4 years passed but this is still the best cover of the song replay. No one can change my mind ❤️
Agreed
✨😭😭✊
I agreeeee
TXT’s is definitely up there as well though
@@huengyu4899 watch txt..but..just for me..it not enought strong like astro..txt even change the dance..im sorry. it just my opinion.
as a shawol, i think they did great in covering their sunbaenim's
yeeeeeees omg they did great
if you dont think Rocky is the most talented boy on earth,, we cant talk
Mood
Lol
I’m here to talk then ksjsj
Agree
Let's talk about the living talent that he is!
actually rocky looks like a main vocal in this performance😂
eunha heart yuju yeah
If you're not an AROHA you'd think he is😂
@@DanisbelMuro i think so, cause i'm not an aroha😅. He did the most difficult part of jonghyun. And he nailed it. Seems like now i'll look after him
@@litarisnawt You really should! 😂 He is actually a rapper believe it or not but he can belt high notes like a main vocalist
@@DanisbelMuro and I'm still wondering why he didn't get the line more
mj was 22
jinjin was 20
eunwoo was 19
moonbin was 18
rocky was 17
sanha was 16
the power they have already hold since they were so young but people still sleep on their talents. i’m glad they’re getting more recognition these days.
Yeah... I really feel sorry for My boys.. 🥺
One day they'll get the recognition they deserve 🔥💜But I can say AROHA is increasing day by day🥳
Yess me too so proud of them🥰
So Sadd about that :(
and now binnie on the sky
@little waterfall - So cute, they were paying tribute to SHINee.
And now, sadly MoonBin is gone, too.
Don't know these boys, but they did really good. Thank you for singing so well this iconic song for us Shawols.
please watch more about ASTRO please...
they cover many song in their predebut also their special stage..
linda165 Yes, I'm a Shawol since debut so it's very important for me. Sanha is really making me fall for him, haha
It's so weird because I was the same age as Taemin when Shinee debuted so I couldn't really understand the whole "noona love" concept but with Astro I'm fawning over them and I completely understand.
and now u're the same age as MJ who is the oldest member of astro 😂😂
linda165 I
ROCKYS HIGH NOTES AND RUNS I ALMOST THREW MYSELF OFF MY BED THIS IS BEYOND EVERHTHING AROHA HAD EVER ASKED FOR GOD BLESS
i know! I was so surprised, Rocky was amazing!
IM SO HAPPY wtf
Im shock too!!
***** YAAAAS WE NEED MORE OF HIM SINGING
I almost cried! he did such a good job!
I like how the cameraman is focusing on the other members rather than eunwoo all the time. I love u cameraman💓😂
cuz the visuals on this album is just too damn good for all of them! and this is coming from me, an EUNWOO BIASED FAN lol
noor.zaf i agree..even though i originally became a fan of astro bc of eunwoos handsomeness lol i got tired of them only focusing on him lol
I don't think I'll ever get over rocky's vocals. ever.
Samee
HOLY F U C K I N G SHIT ROCKY'S VOICE HE'S LIKE A QUINTUPLE THREAT I'VE NEVER BEEN MORE SHOOK IN ALL MY YEARS OF LIVING
JINJIN TOO HOLY SHIT WHAT CAN THIS GROUP N O T DO
Lukabunny0 They can't refrain from giving fans a heart attack that's what because bloody hell these boys I swear I'm one foot in the grave because of these beautiful boys.
I actually dead rn so...
5 out the 6 members are from HANLIM Multi Art School, so they're all quite talented. :)
Who is not from Hanlim
jonghyun and shinee have inspired so many. these boys included. it breaks my heart
# MEMESTRO I feel you😭
I started crying while watching this.
I started crying thinking about jonghyun suicide note
I cried😢 Replay is an anthem and so many people listen to it, what's so sad is that the new kpop 'fans' just troll older groups even though the older groups are so iconic
Yeah I was happy and smiling but then I noticed that then I was crying this is the second time this happens I didn't know I was lost watching the video :)💙
So this video proves that ALL members of Astro can sing. ♡
are they singing their song, I keep hearing Shinee song playing in the background?
????????? 'ASTRO - Replay (SHINee)' ???????
They sing it .not Shinee
Astro sing it. I really know astro's voice!!💖
k-pop cool
rocky stole the show man, how isn’t he a main vocal what the heck?!?!?!
@@cherryflower6081 then watch his other song covers, he was recently on the masked singer and he did so well. He isn’t a vocal in Astro, but he’s considered an all around-er. He covered Versace on the floor (Bruno Mars) and Hold My Hand (IU). And there wasn’t much autotune here anyway. If you’re hating in someone at least try to back it up with validity.
Yesterday Rocky upload cover of brunomars "Grenade" it soo good
@@mahirohaartsandcrafts8092 i know it was amazing!!
@@cozaeatsbread810 woo happy 😊
this is the first natural sounding cover I've heard. they sang so well. most other cover I've heard sound very awkward or the voices don't match the song at all but they pulled it off so well
Most of the 'live' covers are so auto tuned as well xD
Hi! Im new here. Are they singing live?
It's prerecorded, it's also got slight pitch correcter evident which can be an effect of the mic itself. They are still heavily talented! I believe there are some live moments in the recording whereas Rocky's belts are definately not live.
Did you also listen to the PD101 trainees that sang Replay (Yuehua trainees)? They are also very talented :3
@@gabiiii1107 pd 101 almost killed the song never again
Fantagio knew what they are doing. Total package.
OngNiel 101 Nice profile picture XDD
Emma Shum you have been blessed ;)
OngNiel 101 FANTAGIO HAS SO MANY GOOD BABIES THAT CAN RAP, SING, DANCE AND EVEN ACT LIKE YOOJUNG, DOYEON, ASTRO AND OF COURSE DANIEL'S WIFE.
OngNiel 101 wannable
I know this is late, but of course, Ong is from Fantagio too!
I don't know ASTRO well but this makes me so happy
and what makes me happier is the fact there's one rocking taemin's replay bowlcut
whuttaBLUR That's maknae Sanha
and key is watching them
euxine venice mae i wonder how he felt about the performance
i wish there is fancam on key watching them
whuttaBLUR true af
One thing about ASTRO is that when they have to cover a senior groups’s song, they really do it properly and make sure the song is executed to the maximum 👏🏼👏🏼🎉
So true💜
Agree
💯💜
Yes
I feell the same
*GUYS! I'VE BEEN A SHAWOL SINCE 2012... AND I GOT TO TELL YOU, THIS COVER IS THE 'BEST OF THE BEST'. FIRST, THE THEME FITS THEM WELL. SECOND, THEIR SHARPNESS AND CHILLNESS WHILE DANCING. SHINee IS THE REASON WHY I'M IN THE K-POP WORLD AND KIM JONGHYUN IS MY BIAS SINCE 2012, HE WAS MY EVERYTHING( i miss him so much and his birthday was yesterday). AND BECAUSE OF THIS PERFORMANCE, ROCKY ALMOST HAS THE SAME VOCAL AS MY JJONG, I SWEAR TO YOU GUYS. IN ORIG SONG, JJONG HAS STRONG INTONATION BUT THEIR VOICE IS VEEEEEEEEERY SIMILAR. I LOVE JJONG AND MINHYUK SO MUCH. ANOTHER THING IS SANHA'S PERFORMANCE, I REAALLY NOTICED THAT THE WAY HE SINGS IS VERY SUITABLE AND ALMOST A GOOD MATCH TO THE ORIG SONG. DON'T GET MAD AT ME. I'M TELLING YOU, IM A CERTIFIED SHAWOL.*
....
*STAN SHINee*
*STAN ASTRO*
watch txt's perf in kbs and both covers are good
@@채원-i3x I already did my dear, this is just my opinion since most astro's voice are suitable for this song and yeah the fact im a shawol. I love my babies(TXT) too!!! Theyre just soo cute. Dont worry im a fan of both.
When I first went to cf with Shinee I only found some early stages, 1 looked like the back of a room and the 2 groups sounded quite different to each other. Taemin still had longish hair tho. I assumed Astro had been asked to perform this special stage bcs they sounded or looked similar, But they did have a similar vibe.
I looked at the time bcs someone had commented that Astro was cute and Shinee was not.(I knew Taemin must have been young and HE would be cute at lleast, front and centre). At that time I'd watch the sports clips and not many music ones so knew who MinHo was. I still have only warched a couple of Shinee M/vs, I watch their concerts -feel the love.
I cried a little too over JongHyun but at the time I was mad.
Thank you for your meaningful remarks.
Yas! there are a lot of ShawolRohas. They have similar vibe. ^^
@@Eileron A proud ShawolFiloRoha here, replaying in August 2020
Astro is soo crazy. 4 album in a year. They're working soo hard. And it remind me so much BTS debut day
3 albums to be exact
even so are flop 😂😂😂
Erlan A flop? No they are quite popular in South Korea and international, even in my country Indonesia they are really famous
+Erlan A so what? You think SF9 and Berry Good is a huge success? LOOOL. Tell me about your faves then
flop what???
both their first album and their 2nd album made into Billboard World Albums Chart? and let's wait for this third album
try hard..hahahaha
I'm fell for Rocky so hard (I broke my face fml)
1. He can rap
2. HE CAN SING SO WELL
3. He can dance
4. THOSE VISUALS
He also choreographs!
ASTRO FANTASTIC MY GAWD I LOVE HIM
Also
6. He can do taekwondo
7. He can cook
8. He can act ,eventually
9. plus He's a weird cutie with rock abs, and it never ends...💕
i can jump in I'm in love
hey, Jin jin can too! just saying
As an oldie second gen fan, this is the performance that brought me back into kpop after nearly a decade of being out. I was thinking "there's no way they can do shinee justice" and well I was dead wrong. This group is something special.
Indeed astro is special. I also never think of becoming kpop fan but here I am its been 4 years of being aroha and I didn't regret it.
aaaaaa😿
Fantagio's artists are actually actors/actresses that can sing, dance, and rap also model.
Question: What is Fantagio Entertainment?
Normal ppl: A South Korean talent agency/company.
Me: *Perfect* people~
Exactly
that's why Rocky is my bias
Multi-fandom Shit i was not expecting his singing to be that good 0-0 😍😍😍😍😍
Astridou J He did hints of his high note before but this good wasn't expected from him. triple threat
SAME!! My neighbors probably think I'm crazy because I'm always screaming "DAMMIT ROCKY!" :D
SAME
he is doing jonghyun's part (i think) and he actually kind of sound like him, and god knows how great jonghyun is *-*
Wow their vocalist are good.
8luvbug Look up some of San ha and MJ's duet 👌🏼
This never gets old. BEST Shinee cover 100%!
Rocky sang Jonghyun’s part.... Jonghyun must be proud ❤️ You’ll always be in our hearts Jonghyun Oppa ❤️
he looks like jonghyun spmetimes with that face
miss roset ikr
miss roset he does! That's actually originally why I biased rocky, then i discovered he was also an amazing dancer, rapper and singer
After seeing all the coments, i'm glad that the most of you mentioning Rocky, he's very talented right?! he can do everything ❤❤❤❤
I'm so happy seeing people think he's a vocalist, when he's actually one of the groups rappers
I also love that people are interested in "the pretty one in the green sweatshirt"
MJ shall be slept on no longer
Idc if people hate on me for saying this but this is the best rookie group of the year if you listen to their mr removed they are hella stable even with their hard choreography, perfect synchronization, and amazing visuals. Like seriously this group doesn't lack anything yet they aren't really popular
Lakshmi fantiago isn't small lol it has some of the best actors in korea
just curious for all the kpop Bands in general, whether they sing live on stage or just lip sync ... ? it seems hard with the choreography
Lakshmi Santiago is still popular on produce ioi they said that was big company when someone and looking auditioned also hello Venus is pretty popular
We are one I'm so pissed off that they didn't win the best rookie award but I'm also sad and... I'm so emotional
We are one But they dont sing that good, i didn't like this performance ? The original is 10000 times better
Moonbin singing Jonghyuns parts hits different now 🙏🏻
i´m here to remember everyone they were rookies in this performance and rocky isnt the main vocal, he is a rapper. Stan Astro, Stan Talent
True
Agree!
Which one is rocky sorry
@@sagala7816 navy blue jacket on 0:41
May i ask? Who is the green guy?? ^^
As a shawol , this is one of the best covers I've ever seen of other kpop groups covering SHINee. 👍👍👍
As a shawol and an aroha, I appreciate this comment ^^
Agree with u100%
Agree!
YES. I'm shawol too and I was pleased to see so many other shawols giving these boys props. They absolutely nailed this cover. Their voices fit the song really well, they added a little bit of their own flavor, the dancing was on point, and they have that same fresh, boyish cute energy debut SHINee did.
At the first time i saw this clip, i thought the boy in black is VOCAL and then i read the comments, omg haha i think i'm into this group 💕💕💕
Tram Tran welcome to the AROHA family
Tram Tran WELCOME FAM
Tram Tran welcome to the AROHA family ❤️✨
Anyone here in 2021?
Also I can't ever get over Rocky and his heavenly vocals. You could never tell from this performance that he's a rapper.
Indeed
astro is the best. what rocky did is very hard for a rapper.his high notes were excellent. sanha is looking very cute in pink and his expressions were full of cuteness. astro has very talented members. actually everyone are cute and talented.
Thanks for liking my comment.but it is the truth.
On point. I'm completely surprised (in a good way) hearing rocky sing like this. Who knew he can hit high notes like this. Astro really have a lot of talent hidden. 😍
I think u forgot the word “gods” somewhere in there
From what I remember rocky is a good singer, it was just astro was filled with so many singers they trained him as a rapper and he just agreed to it since they were all friends when they became trainees. He sometimes shows his singing abilities but for the most part he stays as a rapper.
@@yessiawk4102 sad truth,,,i have watched it somewhere when he says he wants to be a singer,and im surprised coz he always do the rap and dancing but what he really dreamed of before was to sing,,,so i really wonder why fanmu didnt gave him a chance to sing to,(i mean w/ a longer part,)i am really hoping he can have a solo song that he will do the rap and the singing,,,
I really think fantagio is the luckiest entertainment like they got this talented group under them. Beside they all such a group full of visuals, all of them have their own charms and talents. Beside rocky can sing high notes, jinjin also can sing really beautiful and well here even tho he didn't get many parts. And all vocal line proved they can sing to anything beautifully. Don't forget how sweet and lovable this guys in the group. Fantagio, you're the luckiest. Please treat them well. We're not gonna stop support them!
very true. they have their individual charms and u end up loving them all so picking a bias is hard
We can mention Ong seung-woo and weki meki too :)
@@diaryofbi 5uprise too
Fantagio is the home of visuality and talents💕
Sadly, fantagio didnt know how to promote all of these talents well ㅠㅠ
I feel like shawols are one of the best fandoms out there! I really admire them, and I love to see them get along so well with Arohas!
Patricia Peña Hdez. Thank you (: This group & fandom seem promising too
I love your comment, I'm proud to be a Shawol 😭😭💛💙💜💚
Monce Contreras I'm proud too!! This performance made me cry happy tears! SHINee and ASTRO FIGHTING!!!!!!!
Christian DeLaRosa Dibidibillora :'c
Patricia Peña Hdez. when you're both a shawol and an aroha and your life is complete
In my opinion, there is nothing any boyband who covers Replay that becomes perfect as Astro. Honestly, I watch it every day.
I'm a 9 year shawol so when I saw the title of this video, I was like "I know I didn't just see some rookies cover my babies. Man I'm ready to judge" BUTTTT HEY!! It may seem rude for me to say so but I didn't expect them to do so well! Thumbs up! And most importantly, I think they really add their own color to the song!
Siqi Shi even they lack of enthusiasm this is better than the other group cover
Siqi Shi x2
EXACT
SAME
Check ASTRO's cover of DREAM GIRL, they did it so well:
th-cam.com/video/51rIaLmq9yk/w-d-xo.html
people be talking about rockys vocals but I NEED SOMEONE TO APPRECIATE JINJINS VOCALS AT 1:23 i a m s h o o k
I STILL COME BACK TO THIS EVERY DAY
I'll appreciate Jinjin's rapping skills much. It's a secret that they can sing 😂 they're the secret vocalist of ASTRO
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa help me
@@harounhassan9110 ikr ive been stanning astro since their debut and sEEING THEIR PROGRESS GETS ME SO HAPPY
@@ryn7942 we are progressing a lot
After watching produce 101 and learning how hard certain notes of this song were , I was shocked Rocky slayed it .
a rapper slayed it IM SHOOKT
yeah.. It was hard to pull off the notes here.. the pd101 trainees really trained hard for the eprformance
THATS ASTRO FOR YOU
I am an AROHA and a SHAWOL and let me tell you this is so good it literally makes me feel like i am listening to the original version sung by SHINee . Astro did an amazing job on this
ahh that's great to hear!
I've watched it over 10 times and every time I watch it I act like I'm surprised by rocky's singing and high notes
I feel this deeply cuz when shinee released this song, I didn't feel much since they're all older than me. But with astro there are two members younger than me so I lowkey like when they sing the chorus 👀👀
same!!!!!!
omg same
for me sanha is the one younger than me
sorry let me correct myself 3 of them are younger than me i am 97 liner
oh wait nevermind there are 3 members younger than me, not 2 😂😂 i'm a 97 liner also but i forgot to count minhyuk
Rocky sang Jonghyun part. Why does it hurt so much... Jonghyun would be so proud😭😭😭
Hurts my heart to realize that Moonbin was the one who sang Jonghyun’s part here…
he adored shinee :((
When I first saw this I was praying in my head "Please don't butcher my song".. and it was so good! I don't know much about ASTRO, so I'm glad I saw this!
hope you will watch more about them~
STAN ASTRO I will try!
Please vote for them in the mama rookie awards! 😘
Check ASTRO's cover of DREAM GIRL, they did it so well:
th-cam.com/video/51rIaLmq9yk/w-d-xo.html
I'm a Shawol of 5 years so Astro just went under harsh judging... and they came out well! You did a great job Astro and SHINee would be proud that you guys did well. The guy (sorry, don't know names) doing Jonghyun's stronger lines thankfully didn't try and do the exact same and used his own voice in a great way. I approve!
Thank you for your kind words! ^_^ The one who sang Jonghyun's lines is Rocky, who is actually the rapper in their group!
***** The SHINee fandom is one of the very few fandoms that don't criticize covers 😁 as a fandom, we are very kind. And yeah, a lot of rappers seem to hide their amazing voices!
SHINeePINee33 yeah i noticed that as well! :')
***** omg yes imagine if Arohas became the next Shinee fandom? They will be our juniors!
SHINeePINee33 true omg! :')
Back here after watching pd101 s2's replay covers and finding it even more impressive how astro pulled off this song. Not that pd101's were bad but Astro's is just on another level
You just witnessed the difference between trainees and debuted artists.
I guess that time many viewers would be thinking that Rocky is one of the main vocals but he is main rapper of the group....as I am new AROHA this side of Rocky is really good to see
i am a shawol and every shinee cover out there did not appeal me as much as astro’s. they did it so well, they didn't leave out lines or choreography and i heard astro's rapper rocky(?) did jonghyun's high note like wow...astro is full of talent and i am definitely gonna look into them more!
yeah please do! but don't blame us if you fall into the pit as deep as we did.
Do you know the difference of this cover of ASTRO to other groups cover? It sounded natural just like how SHINee does it. Others think Replay is a song where you do aegyo or they think it's cute (I'm not hating on others but I just want to tell that Replay is kinda like innocent? Not being cute. SHINee made it looked cute because of their visuals that time, I MEAN TAEMIN'S HAIRCUT THAT TIME JUST MADE HIM CUTER, not because of their performance.) Plus their voices fitted the song well. That's all. I REPEAT I DONT HATE OTHERS WHO DID A COVER OF REPLAY OKAY I JUST WANTED TO TELL WHAT I THINK IS DIFFERENT AND WHATS MY OPINION. lovelots peeps uwu
baekdistant Agreed
I agree astrology is based on cute mainly
i've lost count of how many times i've watched this in the past 3 days help
RamenLab same
RamenLab SAME my data is gone
SAME TBH
Cause this song is called replay XD
gyujin's non-existent lines I see what u did there 😉😉
This is the best cover of replay .
No one can change my mind.
I don't even stan astro but this...
Thank you this means a lot 💜
even 3 years later, no one is able to make a cover so perfect and reliable like this one
Even almost 4 years later no one has ever can do it.
You can listen Tomorrow X Together's cover. It is also Awesome 😁😁😁
Watch txt's
Yea i checked that txt group. This is still better for me.
@@justhuman3424 everyone has different taste i like txt's more, but no matter how good you do the cover, it can't never bit the original..
SHINee legends imagine debuting with a song this iconic. there’s a shawol in every group, in every company and that’s just the way god works!!!
LOUDER!
YES
👏👏👏👏👏
SHINee world domination😍
SHINee will always be iconic✨✨
SHINee is a legendary group^^
Ok but Rocky and JinJin slaying those vocals?! ❤️
Because they covered this song, was the first day I started stanning this group. This was my absolute favorite Shinee song. And then their vocals is what got me in.
Welcome Roha💜
Yess, welcomeee
WHEN ROCKY CAN DANCE, RAP, AND SING! STAN TALENT STAN ROCKY.
came here after watch pd101 😂 now i know that the difference between the trainee and the one who already debuted
same here
Bangtan trasheu I didn't know the adlibs were that hard because here we have the rapper doing it easily😂
Minh Huong Ngo i was about to comment something like yours xD. a trainee was having hard time meanwhile rocky, a rapper, did it easily and slayed. 😂
Gunhee wouldn't have a hard time if he was trained a little longer.
well honestly speaking, astro trained around 5th grade xD but yeah, you can see the difference
I was Like what the Hell Rocky?!?! them vocals tho😍
Yeeeaaah
Puno Autopop Hot as fuck myghad😂😂😂😭❤💓💓💓💓
He did soooooo well!!! fantagio please give the rap line more vocal parts and maybe the vocal line rap parts!! I wanna see Sanha rap!!
dem high notes doe :'DDD
BEST TRIPLE THREAT THAT I EVER SEEN!!!!
MAIN DANCER....SKILLED RAPPER.....CAN HIT THE HIGH NOTE TOO??
wow...
FANTAGIO GOT ALL BEST TRIPLE THREAT.... MALE: ROCKY..FEMALE:YOOJUNG
and ACTUALLY MOONBIN IS GOOD TRIPLE THREAT too
One of the best covers of Shinee I've seen and Rocky singing Jjong Oppa's part, I'm crying.
OMG I'M A SHAWOL SINCE SHINEE'S DEBUT AND I'M AROHA ALSO OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG ~~~~~~ WHY THIS SONG OMG MY HEART UGHUGHUHG. I WAS SO SURPRISED. THANK YOU ASTRO & FANTAGIO I LOVE YOU EVEN MORE
Meet too!!!
SAME OMG MY SHAROHA HEART :'0
paec me too 😍😍😍
paec YEAHHHHH ME TOOO!! IM A SHAWOL AND AN AROHA! AND THIS IS FANTASTIC!❤😆😆
As a Shawol I want to thank to Astro >< This is so fresh OMG ❤ When I saw Astro perform with Replay I just realized that SHINee has growing old lol Sorry love xD xD
Trie Ningtyas Hapsari please watch the new MV of astro.
are you an indonesian? xD
SHINee will never grow old!!!
Trie Ningtyas Hapsari they aint old tho all of them are still in their 20s
you stole my words . . aaah i'm in tears (except SHInee is forever young)
MJ is way to underrated. HE HITS THOSE GODDAMN HIGH NOTES SO GOOD HE'S GOT ONE OF THE BEST VOICES IN THE KPOP INDUSTRY in my opinion NOTICE HIM AND WORSHIP HIM TILL THE END OF TIME
SHINee and Astro are my two favourite groups. I would have never given kpop another shot if not for Astro and mainly Moonbin. MJ totally reminds me.of Jonghyun too, voice and size. Both groups with beautiful songs
I don't think you guys know how happy this makes me astro are my precious angels and shinee is my ult group and I've always wanted to see a group I really like perform a shinee song and the fact that the group was Astro and the fact that it was shinee's song reply makes me so happy. It went together so well. I feel a lot of earlier shinee songs fit Astro well.
I totally know what you mean! If Infinite or MonstaX did a SHINee song I'd reeeeeally enjoy it! Or if anyone I know does a SHINee song, haha!
Squishy kaisoo I ALMOST CRIED. This is so cute and sweet and amazing and Shinee and Astro and GAAAAAAHHHH 😭😭😭
astro fits the shinee concept. but this was amazing
Squishy kaisoo can't relate to this even more
I also want them to cover BTS SONGS😂😂
Well. Frick. Now I'm confused.
You got Rocky, who can rap, sing, AND dance like he's trying to break the stage, JinJin who is basically the same, but THE DEEP VOICE THO, Moonbin who has a good voice and is a good dancer, MJ with those *Slaying Vocals*, Eunwoo who is absolutely adorable, and I ADORE his cute nasally voice, then Sanha the giant puppy. I-
I can't-
They make me want to simultaneously jump off a bridge and sing my little heart out. ALL 6 OF THEM-
Maddy Freeman I FEEL IT
Same...... same😓❤️😍
Check ASTRO's cover of DREAM GIRL, they did it so well:
th-cam.com/video/51rIaLmq9yk/w-d-xo.html
as a shinee fan since their debut I can say this is one of the best covers I have heard👌👌 Astro got me shook
Ur jungshook
The best Shinee's cover
TBH Rocky's talent isn't fair. He is the main dancer, has the voice to be a main vocalist, and is one of Astro's rappers. WTF?!?!?!?!?! LOVE HIMMMMM!! His talent is uncannyyyy
They gave him more vocal lines in the recent album :)
Wasn't he supposed to be a vocalist?
@@seol7035 nopee he was all along a rapper
Rocky just shook us all with those vocals. Hide your kids, hide your wives, cuz Rocky's out to steal them hearts.
I want a studio version of this asap. I want to hear those high notes on repeat
I think I will repeat this over every astro's videos but eunwoo is so beautiful im shook everytime I see him on my screen
btsvelvet i even think i saw a video on Twitter of Monsta x being shook by eunwoos visuals
EVEN GIRL IDOLS ARE SHOOK
OMGod where?! I got to see this. lollll
btsvelvet whereee
when a rapper sings like a main vocal that's our rocky sweegg!!
As a rapper, Rocky did absolutely amazing with the high note! And his dancing slays as usual. As expected as the lead dancer. They all slayyed! One of the best covers of my favorite song.
Rocky should sing more...
Watching this again after I saw TXT perform REPLAY on KBS Gayo Deachukhe 2019.I wanted to compare the two but they have different concept. This one was cute concept while TXT's is like a boyband concept. Both does good.
no need to compare, both of the groups did awesome job and covered their own ways..
Junelyn Manigos I just watched the txt one too lol
@@_cherrychi_
Same
They do have a different vibe don't they? Like TXT's is more chill, this one is more poppy!
eczion scarletgem Yesh and more bubbly. Like a cheerful vibe. And TxT but their own touch into it. I think they both did amazing
Astro did an amazing job covering this iconic song.
There's just something about Jinjin. So talented. Under estimated. Jinjin deserve a lot more recognition.
Still the best cover of Replay
honestly they could say theyre an all vocal group and id believe it tbh
and this is how you properly cover shinee's replay everyone learn from astro ✌️ some groups tend to over execute the steps and the vocals when they cover this song it ruins the whole thing ☹️ when it just actually have to be this clean and simple ✔️
Siroun Evangelista AGREED! :) This is the best cover by far!! #Aroha #Shawol
So....people are still sleeping on Astro after this iconic ass performance?!?!?!
yes. sadly.
Ikr
How sad!
Seems like it
honestly the disrespect is quite saddening :/
I am extremely sorry i had been so dumb , sleeping on them
It's 2021, and I still think this cover is the best cover of Replay by SHINee
yess
2022 and i still think this is the best cover of replay 🥺💕