Atleast jonghyun is in a better place now. We dont deserve him. Never did and will never do. Let's hope that hes happy wherever he is. We love you jonghyun
9:31 when she innocently asked one person is missing, you can see in Minho’s eyes that’s so sad, yet he protected her from the world’s complication at that moment
The way he chose to answer the question was so heartwarming- instead of saying he passed away or why he died, he knew exactly how to word it when talking about it to a child and instead went with “he’s not well.” Even for someone like me who doesn’t really follow their music much at all, that definitely got me…
When I hear the questions about Jonghyun I was worried about our SHINee members, like... "What would happen if they ask about him? or How will they react or think about that questions? I really almost cry when I hear our Minho answers... +PS. I'm not good writting in English so I hope You understand what I'm saying...
The moment when minho told her that "he's not well" and "He's not a bad uncle, he's good uncle" just left me in tears and heartbroken😭💔 And the moment when she asked "One person is missing though" at that time Minho's eyes were just heartbreaking😭😔
"he's not doing well. he's not a bad uncle." the way i started crying.. that was such a good way of addressing it. they all did so well, i can imagine how hard looking back at their stuff can be.
A better translation than the one in the video would be "he was unwell health-wise", that whole exchange made me absolutely bawl, I think minho put what happened in the best way he could. Looking back at everything is always bittersweet but SHINee was 5 and always will be 5.
My heart almost melted with the way Onew, Minho, Key and Taemin talk to the children. When the girl noticed that they were 4... the way Minho answered was so sweet, as if JJ is still alive. Actually JJ is still living in our hearts and his voice will be forever with us.
초5때부터 샤이니 노래들었고 그리고 6학년때 링딩동 컴백하는날 다음날 반친구들끼리 샤이니 진짜 중독성 강한노래 들고나왔다 해서 이야기 하고 그랬는데 벌써 시간이 이렇게 흘렀구나 ㅠㅠ 그리고 민호님이 한명없다고 이야기했을때 아이에게 그냥 몸이아파서 나갔다고 돌려 말했는것을 들었을때 굉장히 맘이 아팠음 종현님 진짜 노래도 잘하고 작사 작곡도 잘했는데 군생활할때 갑자기 사지방에서 종현 사망이라는 뉴스 봤을때 깜짝 놀란기억이 아직도 가시지 않는다 ㅠㅠ 종현님 항상 기억하고 있을게요
you can see the sadness in Minho's eyes when he talks about Jonghyun... He's trying to hide it soo well😭 I swear I ain't crying but it's just soo sweet. 'he is not a bad uncle, he is a great uncle"
Minho is so strong, and responded in a perfectly appropriate way. I'm glad he didn't say Jonghyun was gone, just not well to not worry the girl. As soon as she said one is missing my eyes started watering..
lol very true. The inspiration for the comment was onew realizing they debuted before the kid was born and looking at the camera and going “that was a quick reality check” and he looked just so defeated and I couldn’t stop laughing 😂😂😂
As someone who is the same age as him and has been listening to SHINee for 12 years I felt this way too lmao. Every time a kid said the songs were old-fashioned or retro I felt my joints ache and my skin wrinkle 😂
That exchange between Minho and the little girl about jjong not being a bad uncle makes me tear up every time i see it :( They've done so well throughout the years though 🥲💖
허어.. 한때 엄청난 인기를 누렸던 아이돌이였는데.. 이제 요즘 애들은 모르는 아이돌이 되었다는 게 충격적이다.. 내가 나이가 많이 들었다는 것도 체감되고.. 지금 보니 다들 앳되고 힘든 시기였을텐데 엄청난 멘탈과 노력으로 극복해낸 게 멋있네.. 샤이니 오빠들, 한때 제 초등학생 시절 삶의 낙이였어요. 좋은 노래들 불러주셔서 감사합니다. 앞으로도 행복한 일만 있으시길
I see many comments about Minho, but did anyone else notice that Key looked really sad when saying it was their first time as a four and looked kinda sad when watching the footage? My heart goes out to them all.
Actually, the 4 of them looked sad. They all look like choked up and their smiles stiffened. The subtle eye twitch and the hard swallow they tried to hide. I rewatched this video as I got lost in the SHINee TH-cam hole again so this time I see more details about how they talked and their gestures. As a Shawol, this will always be something heartbreaking, even now, sobbing like a child is a norm because the pain remains.
The way that Minho said "he's not a bad uncle" make me think that childrens in Korea thinks that every people who left the group is because they're problematic and this considered bad :(
I hope the girl doesn't go back to check because she'll probably very shocked. Or even ask her parent's if he is feeling better now. Children ask a lot of questions 😢😢😢
@@kokieduoh I understand but she should know. It’s not like kids don’t know what death is. I understand why Minho wouldn’t bring it up on tv because it could have been upsetting And caused a bad reaction. But still. She’s not 3.
"one person's missing though" "yes, one person's missing" "who? why?" "left the group?" "it's uncle jonghyun, he's not well" "ah, then he's not a bad uncle" "yes, he's not a bad uncle. he's a great uncle." my tears won't stop
I’m glad to hear one of the kids say “ So he isn’t a bad uncle”. Because now, there are so many scandals involving idols, actors and people from the entertainment industry almost everyday that has a bad effect of kids point of view on the adults.
yes, and the kids' point of view here in sk, those who are leaving the group was involved in scandals or whatever so they see them as bad person, you see? the girl asked if he left the group and she was relieved that that's not the case, ofc, they don't have much knowledge regarding the issues surrounding the celebrities and it's not like it's time for parents to explain to them everything, those are only what kids heard
I felt like it would have been okay to touch on why he wasn't there with he because she's old enough to understand, BUT that's not why they were there. I will agree that it was a decent explanation, given the time allotted. I still cried.
@@tdelioncourt1268 well i missed the point of that joke, didn't I?! I just figured I had one more competitor for Taemin's affections... sdfsdfsd 😂 Thank you for straightening me out! 💕
9:27 이때 부터 종현이 얘기 하는데 민호 표정 때문에 더 맘이 아프다 진짜 아이는 순진하게 아무것도 모르니까 민호한테 물어 본거 지만 대답해 주는 민호는 진짜 저렇게 덤덤하게 말 하기 까지 얼마나 많은 시간을 슬프게 보냈을까 연습생 때부터 데뷔하고 첫1위 첫 대상 첫콘서트 첫 음악방송 무대 를 하면서 많을 시간 을 종현이와 함께 보내고 했을텐데 종현이 언급 할때 마다 민호가 덤덤하게 말하는 이유는 이제는 민호 본인 스스로가 종현이 빈 자리를 받아 드릴 준비를 하고 있어서 그런게 아닌가 싶어요
9:28 - one is missing... - oh, yes... - why? Where? Did he left? - uh, yeah... Jonghyun uncle... Hes not well... - oooh! So he is good uncle. - yes, ofc. He is a good uncle. I. CRIED.
I am in SHAMBLES. He answered in such a good way for a child to understand. And those of us who are old enough to grasp it, felt how that hurt. To be honest, I love Shinee very much. They’re one of my first favorite groups but it hurts too much to listen a lot. I listen in a very bittersweet way.
she looks like a too innocent girl that aint allowed to use the internet by her mom (just blabbering sorry) at that time, when i was.. as old as her i guess idk ive already so so not innocent :(
@R. Tolmach what i tried to mention is im not sure she would check the fact what happened to jonghyun, on the internet and its normal THESE DAYS, if parents r so strict like that. i didnt say this kind of parenting is wrong.
It’s funny coz he’s 31 and that kid must be like 12? So it’s a bit of a stretch to be her Dad but technically yes he could. The kid settled with “uncle”. Then you have Taemin who decided he was the 9 year olds “Oppa”. 😂
I saw how he still smiled when she asked who he was, and although I think it was a bittersweet smile, the fact that he seemed to be looking back at the memories like he was happy to have them made me feel better. I hope that makes sense
The way Minho spoke of Uncle Jonghyun and the way he said he IS one of our members...My heart broke and filled at the same time. JH will never be forgotten by any of us, least of all his brothers.
Honestly, the way Minho handled the girls question was very mature. He didn’t want to make her sad and he also probably knows that with adults, the response would be something like “sorry for your loss” but with kids there would probably be a follow up question like “how?”
right, I thought the same. it was a very clever answer and he managed the situation very well. it must have been hard for him too, to answer that question all of a sudden.
제 세대보단 조금 앞이지만 오빠가 있어서 샤이니 무대도 그렇고 많이 봤었는데 그 당시에는 이런 일이 있구나 했는데 크면서 보니 얼마나 큰 일이고 모두가 슬펐을지 상상이 안되네...항상 팬사랑 최고에 언제나 진심으로 열심히하던 샤이니이기에 아직도 활동하는 것 같고 너무 좋은 노래를 많이 들려줘서 고맙고 항상 응원하고 사랑해 샤이니😊🫶🏻🩵
진짜 요즘엔 팀에서 없어지면 다 사건 사고들로 나가는 거라 애들이 나가면 나쁜 사람이라고 생각되는 거에서 한 번 충격받고 ㅈㅎ 생각만 해도 아직도 존나 눈물 나옴 다시는 이런 일 없으면 해 얘들아 항상 좋은 것만 보고 우리의 존재가 힘든게 아니라 늘 힘이 되는 존재였으면 해
The kid with key was so cute. The girl with minho was not impressed in the beginning but as the discography revealed more she was clapping and she liked it. The girl with onew was mature and onew was the nervous one i feel and the kid with taemin yeah he was cute too. "My uncle is 30 and he's still single" wdym baby I'm your aunt 😂😂
“One person is missing though?” “Yea one person is missing” “Who?”why? Left the group?” “Uhh.. it’s uncle Jonghyun, he’s not well..” “Ah. Then he’s not a bad uncle.” “Yes, he’s not a bad uncle, he’s a good uncle.” “Good uncle” Minho’s face when he said that.😕 We all miss him🕊❤️
its been a year since this was released and I am still touched by how minho explained when the girl said one person is missing and asked why.. that clip, this whole video never failed to make me cry... i swear
Its nice to see that we are not just "erasing" Jonghyun from our memories. Its nice to see they didn't cut the scenes were they talked about him. You can tell that every member still feels the loss but they are still moving forward. I cried so much but im also happy i saw this video.
@@jinlissul Well it makes sense to only show one clip showing a member explaining why someone was missing, it would be too much to show every member explaining.
@@MarkehJLL the children's parents mentioned that it was a shame because they explained it well to the kids, especially the mother of the kid kibum was with said it was touching i felt like it would have been nice to show all of the members' explanations, especially since people use jjong as some kind of taboo topic that always needs to have some kind of trigger warning.
오랫만에 알고리즘에 타서 다시 보게 됐네요. 사실 그 동안 알고리즘 뜰 때마다 거의 한번씩 보거든요 작년 컴백 후 입덕된 아기 샤월이라 그때 이 영상 처음 봤을 때 팬이 아니였는데 이번 다시 보더니 느낌 새로워지네요. 원래 팬 아니었지만 종현이 떠난다는 소식 듣었을 때 몇일 울었는데 팬 아니였던 때이든 팬이 되는 지금이든 변한없이 언제나 종현이 그립고 보고 싶더라고요. 아무래도 이 양상은 내가 샤월 된 계기라고 할 수 있을려나...? 다들 애들이랑 대화할 때 나오는 훈훈한 분위기, 종현이를 그리운 모습들 보면서 어떻게 응원해 주지 않을 수가 있을까요...? 아무튼 태민이 군대 다니는 동안 다른 멤버들 솔로 활동을 응원하면서 완전체 컴백할 때까지 기다리겠습니다. 샤이니 사랑해🌹🥰💎
샤월이였을 때 최애였던 종현이가 잠시 쉬게 된 후로부터 샤이니를 의도적으로 피하게 된 일인으로서(보면 눈물이 안 끊겨서;;) 가끔씩 우연히 관련영상을 돌려보게 될 때면 피하고 싶다가도 보게 되고 막상 보고나면 또 펑펑 울고...이 영상은 여러번 들러보게 되는데 볼 때마다 민호가 돌려말할 때 눈물이 터지면서도 한켠으로는 따스한 감정이 들고...하지만 데리러 가는 여전히 온전히 듣지 못하는 한 곡이고...아 진짜 모순되는 심리네...
i love coming back to this video, especially today. it’s so healing whenever i have a rough time. their honesty and openness and kindness always warms my heart
아무데나 미로같이 고등학생
샤이니 X ODG
샤이니의 ODG 아웃핏은
www.odg.kr
에서 구매하실 수 있습니다.
SHINee's oufit on www.odgkids.com
--------------------------------------------
↓↓↓↓Follow Us↓↓↓↓
ODG instagram :
instagram.com/odg.studio
ODG Facebook :
facebook.com/odgkids
ODG 제작일기 :
blog.naver.com/odgkid
Daeebaaak..😆🥰
Kids review
Please invite IKON, and Nuest in future . Please .
Kids with SHINee uncles!
So sweet to watch!
💞 Lovely kids with Kind uncles
Sub Indo tolong
I cried when minho told the girl "He's not a bad uncle,he's a good uncle" 🥲
SAME I MISS HIM SO MUCH
Atleast jonghyun is in a better place now. We dont deserve him. Never did and will never do. Let's hope that hes happy wherever he is. We love you jonghyun
@@Donttsteponme I just love your profile name 😅😅😅
Same i miss him so much 🙂
🥺same🥺
I cried when the girl said, “One person is missing though.” and the look on Minho's eyes is just so heartbreaking.
😥😥
Time stamp?
@@jiminsinvisiblejams5993 9:27
Yo
Yeah its really sad
9:31 when she innocently asked one person is missing, you can see in Minho’s eyes that’s so sad, yet he protected her from the world’s complication at that moment
"He's a good uncle." I broke down hearing that after watching this again.
If we want to find the answer just Google Jonghyun, everything is In it
@@NEALMateo Me too.
wait, what happened?
@@amaira-jain he passed away during dec of 2019
The tender way that Minho talked about Uncle Jonghyun made me tear up. I know it will never be easy for them.
100%!!!!!! I am not sentimental, but I started to tear up too.
The way he chose to answer the question was so heartwarming- instead of saying he passed away or why he died, he knew exactly how to word it when talking about it to a child and instead went with “he’s not well.”
Even for someone like me who doesn’t really follow their music much at all, that definitely got me…
Rightt had me crying a whole new river
"He's not a bad uncle, he's a good uncle"
Yeah, he was the best person anyone could ever know
When I hear the questions about Jonghyun I was worried about our SHINee members, like... "What would happen if they ask about him? or How will they react or think about that questions?
I really almost cry when I hear our Minho answers...
+PS. I'm not good writting in English so I hope You understand what I'm saying...
@@maricelaflores8429 that's exactly what I thought when they started watching the videos.
I'm a bit touched when hearing minho's answer
Good Daddy too❤️
He's a good uncle... He was so good that God wanted to take care of him because we didn't deserve him... He was made into a real angel... 🤧🤧🤧🤧🤧
the fact he didnt wanna tell her hes no longer here with us is sweet and sad at the same time.
Ikr 🥺 So touching
The fact that he left the conversation so early too is so sad 🥺
i thought the same thing :(
FR😕
He’s a great uncle :(
아... 한명 없어졌다고 했을때 망설이다가 어린 아이가 듣기에 너무 무거운 이야기가 되지 않게끔 아파서 못나왔다고 돌려말하는 민호의 배려...ㅠㅠ 그리고 나오는 데리러 가 라는 노래가 너무 슬프게 들려 ㅋㅋㅋ ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
???: 혜야, 너는 말했었지. 그저 좋은 친구의 가슴으로 날 사랑하는 것이기에 영원한 거라고.
그런 말 다신 하지 마. 네겐 너무 가벼운, 그러나 내겐 너무 무거운 이 마음이 너를 너무나 힘들게 했구나...
아 눈물난다
ㅜㅜ
우리 마음속에 있으니...잠깐 아파하고 있는중....
저 말 듣자마자 존나 처울었어요 ㅠㅜㅜ
The moment when minho told her that "he's not well" and "He's not a bad uncle, he's good uncle" just left me in tears and heartbroken😭💔
And the moment when she asked "One person is missing though" at that time Minho's eyes were just heartbreaking😭😔
"He's not a bad uncle"
"He's a good uncle"
I'm crying
Nah he is not Uncle 😗
@@prashannasingh6535 wdym?
@@prashannasingh6535 for the kid he is
@@Nosiwo2919 What do you mean. She didn't knew anything about what happened. How th do you expect her to behave.
@@Nosiwo2919 it's not her fault? She didn't knew about it..
Don't come at her..plzz
“He’s not a bad uncle. He’s a good uncle.”
I’M NOT CRYING. I’M.NOT.CRYING.
I AM
YOU ARE CRYING WITH ME. JUST BE HONEST
YES YOU ARE LIKE ME AND EVERYONE ELSE HERE 😭
SOBS
SAME HERE BUT THE TRUE IS I'M CRYING REALLY BAD 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
나도 엄마아빠가 이문세나 조용필이 그렇게 인기가 많았었다는거 별 실감못했는데
나와 같은 세대의 샤이니가 인기가 얼마나 있었는지 실감못하는 아이들을 보니 좀 뭉클하네
이제 저 아이들이 저걸 느낄 쯤에는 더 어린아이들이 저런반응이겠꾸ㄴ구나
몇년 뒤에 우리가 방탄이나 뉴진스 얘기하는거나 같을까...
몇년 뒤는 아니고…. 샤이니는 이제 20년을 향해가네요
아 종현오빠 얘기 나오니까 민호 말하는거봐...애기라서...아 눈물난다.....
The kid realizing he’s sitting with THE Key is a whole mood😂
He was like: wait, so this is THAT Key?!!!! So cute😂😂😂😂
He’s always my favorite he’s so cute! I wanna pinch his cheeks! 🤗
So true!!
He was so cute!
What's his name? 😂 I need his name please
I cried when the girl said, “One person is missing though.” and the look on Minho's eyes is just so heart breaking.
minho released a new single now song titled 'Heartbreak' pls do check it and listen to his wonderful voice ^^
Im on the verge of crying lol
why'd you copy a comment
the fact that he whispered “hyung”
me either 😢
9:27 아 민호 너무 좋게 말해주는 거 너무 좋다 애기 충격 안 받게 ㅠㅠ
민호 아이한테 아프다구 설명해주는거
너무 표정이 씁쓸해보인다...진짜 내가 샤이니도 아닌데 너무 민호의 감정이 너무 잘 이해됨..
why is nobody talking about how minho and the kid act like literal siblings they're bickering and wholesome to each other so effortlessly
When
@@studykoreanwithme9535 the whole video
Yeah they got along really well
Agreed. I really like their interactions the most.
NOBODY??? MAYBE YOU JUST TOO LATEE BRUHHH EVERYBODY LIKE VERY2 NOTICED IT (AT THE PAST)
“옛날스럽지 않아?” 하면 “에이 레트로죠~”로 대답하고
“할머니같진 않고?”하면 “이건 빈티지죠!” 해준 민서 너무너무너무 좋다
아 ~~저 착한친구가 민서였군요!!!뭔가 같은 이름이라 좋군욯ㅎ
@런앤드히트 2:46 8:43
키 옆에 꼬맹이 너무 귀엽다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
리액션이 아저씨 같애 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 우와 키 청년이 이렇게 인기가 많았구마잉!!! 으메 지리구연!
"He's a good uncle" shatters my heart every single time
"he's not doing well. he's not a bad uncle." the way i started crying.. that was such a good way of addressing it. they all did so well, i can imagine how hard looking back at their stuff can be.
A better translation than the one in the video would be "he was unwell health-wise", that whole exchange made me absolutely bawl, I think minho put what happened in the best way he could. Looking back at everything is always bittersweet but SHINee was 5 and always will be 5.
Literally have tears flowing atm cuz of that line:(
@@saerbom5528 yeah or just translate it as "he was sick" :(
@@saerbom5528 oh don't worry! that's how i understood it as well,, less of a he's not well more like a he's sick right now,, it still made me cry haha
"he's not a bad uncle, he's a good uncle"
this hit me like a train
Somehow I wish JH was able to hear that... I remembered his last letter when all he wished for was someone to say he was good....
I love how Minho says that, with love
It's uncle jonghyun 🥺
@@kimhoang4484 nowday I still cry remembering him, he was epic
i can't-
he was really amazing, i miss him-
다른 돌 영상보고 넘어왔는데 상대적으로 샤이니 멤버들 너무 매너있음
아이들에게 본인 소개하는거나 이런 모습들이 진짜 매너남 너낌
My heart almost melted with the way Onew, Minho, Key and Taemin talk to the children. When the girl noticed that they were 4... the way Minho answered was so sweet, as if JJ is still alive. Actually JJ is still living in our hearts and his voice will be forever with us.
"he's not a bad uncle, he's a good uncle" I'm sorry I'll be crying at the corner
Tears dropingg....
arent we.all crying 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
I'm a mess.
🤍
Let me join you
so SHINee categorized their songs as
“before you were born”
“the year you were born”
“after you were born”
IM HOLLERING
This had me dying srsly. And the way they refer to themselves as "ahjussi/samchon"😂
@@boredcat4345 I feel old too 😆
@@boredcat4345 then there’s taemin... lol 12:47
Hi iam the year you were born one the 09 one 😀✌ must be guessing your older than me 😂🙇♀️
초5때부터 샤이니 노래들었고 그리고 6학년때 링딩동 컴백하는날 다음날 반친구들끼리 샤이니 진짜 중독성 강한노래 들고나왔다 해서 이야기 하고 그랬는데 벌써 시간이 이렇게 흘렀구나 ㅠㅠ 그리고 민호님이 한명없다고 이야기했을때 아이에게 그냥 몸이아파서 나갔다고 돌려 말했는것을 들었을때 굉장히 맘이 아팠음 종현님 진짜 노래도 잘하고 작사 작곡도 잘했는데 군생활할때 갑자기 사지방에서 종현 사망이라는 뉴스 봤을때 깜짝 놀란기억이 아직도 가시지 않는다 ㅠㅠ
종현님 항상 기억하고 있을게요
아이들에게 직접적으로 자살했다고 말할 수도 없으니.... 그 맘은 참...ㅠㅠ
기억해줘서 고마워요
온유랑 대화하는 애기 되게 말도 이쁘고 생각이 깊어 보인다
"It's uncle Jonghyun. He's not well. He's not a bad uncle. He's a good uncle."
Minho, you are so strong 😭
And how sad he looked💔😭
@@multistanfamilyforeverkpop2254 I'm broke 😭😭🤚🏻
you can see the sadness in Minho's eyes when he talks about Jonghyun...
He's trying to hide it soo well😭
I swear I ain't crying but it's just soo sweet.
'he is not a bad uncle, he is a great uncle"
🥲🥲
おっっっyｙ六ｙ
I didn't see sadness in his eyes I saw that he was thinking of an appropriate way to respond.
Minho is so strong, and responded in a perfectly appropriate way. I'm glad he didn't say Jonghyun was gone, just not well to not worry the girl. As soon as she said one is missing my eyes started watering..
Yes
민서 성격 진짜 좋다,,, 저런 친구 있으면 행복할 듯
Ngl she's actually really kind and comforting. She's good with words lol.
한명이 없어졌다고 할때 너무 울컥.. 어린아이가 충격받지 않게 몸이 아팠다고 말하는 민호.. 너무 울컥했음..
“He’s not a bad uncle, he’s a good uncle” of course he is❤️
Hes the best uncle in the world:))
@@ssgsnsgs3181 you’re right
This part is really the best 💘
❤❤❤❤❤
This video should be titled “Onew realizing how old he is for 13 minutes and 14 seconds”
Lol
THIS IS SO FREAKING FUNNY
not just onew, tbh.
lol very true.
The inspiration for the comment was onew realizing they debuted before the kid was born and looking at the camera and going “that was a quick reality check” and he looked just so defeated and I couldn’t stop laughing 😂😂😂
As someone who is the same age as him and has been listening to SHINee for 12 years I felt this way too lmao. Every time a kid said the songs were old-fashioned or retro I felt my joints ache and my skin wrinkle 😂
종현이는 아주 좋은 삼촌이야...❤️
That exchange between Minho and the little girl about jjong not being a bad uncle makes me tear up every time i see it :( They've done so well throughout the years though 🥲💖
The saddest part...
Minho : Uncle Jonghyun is not well... He's not a bad uncle.. just not well....
Ngl I cried.
Read the room pal
Edit: this comment was for a self advertiser btw
@Now up to 56% off Get These Cool Trendy Tees Now! wtf
I was so worried when she asked that
@@chrizeeey Ikr like I would have had no reply if I was in his place
Who is jonghyun and why he isn’t with them I am new so can you tell me
"he's not a bad uncle he's a good uncle"
i am not crying I aM nOt CrYiNg
STOP CUTTING THE ONION MOM 😩😭😭😭😭😭
😭😭
SAME
I am crying
I just got you to 1k likes
민서가 생각도 깊고 아는것도 많고 착하네..
4:58 첫 1위하고 오열하는 사람을 보고도 누구에요? 하는 말에 멤버에요, 라고 대답할 때부터
9:29 한명 없다는 말에 아파서 그런거라고 좋은 삼촌이라는 말이
지금 없는 사람을 아이에게 어떻게 설명하는가 접근하는 태도가 일관되게 다정하고 선량해보임
중간에 한명 어디갔어요? 하는데...진짜 타팬이지만..마음이 울컥하고..찡하다..증말..ㅠ 보고싶어ㅠ 종현아.. 다들 아직 널 기억해ㅠ
애기 말에 민호 표정 내표정. ㅠㅠ
애기가 질문할때 갑자기 쿵 내려앉은 느낌이...
저도 타팬이지만.. 당시 샤이니노래 춤 다 따라했던 1인으로 리뷰영상 시작부터 종현 나올때마다 울컥하다가 민호가 얘기할때 결국 눈물이 나와버렸네요.. 저도 이렇게 보고싶고 그리운데....
아 진짜 ㄹㅇㅠ 타팬이여도 그시대 노래 다 좋아했던 인간으로써....ㅠㅠ 나우럭
@@user-cg4sh2in4q 그냥 궁금해서 물어본거 아닌가 계속 5명으로 나오다가 한명이 없으니까 아무생각없이 물어본거지 개꼬였네;;
@@user-cg4sh2in4q 애기는 암것도 모르고 한말일 텐데 과민반응 좀...
Minho: "It's uncle jonghyun, he's not well, he's not a bad uncle, he's a good uncle"
I felt that... 😭 They will always be 5♥️❤️
Sad😥
same. so glad he came up
Frrrr I started cryinggg 🥺🥺🥺
Such..why did it bring tears to my eyes..😢
That was such a great, gentle way to explain it to her.
허어.. 한때 엄청난 인기를 누렸던 아이돌이였는데.. 이제 요즘 애들은 모르는 아이돌이 되었다는 게 충격적이다.. 내가 나이가 많이 들었다는 것도 체감되고.. 지금 보니 다들 앳되고 힘든 시기였을텐데 엄청난 멘탈과 노력으로 극복해낸 게 멋있네.. 샤이니 오빠들, 한때 제 초등학생 시절 삶의 낙이였어요. 좋은 노래들 불러주셔서 감사합니다. 앞으로도 행복한 일만 있으시길
I see many comments about Minho, but did anyone else notice that Key looked really sad when saying it was their first time as a four and looked kinda sad when watching the footage? My heart goes out to them all.
Actually, the 4 of them looked sad. They all look like choked up and their smiles stiffened. The subtle eye twitch and the hard swallow they tried to hide. I rewatched this video as I got lost in the SHINee TH-cam hole again so this time I see more details about how they talked and their gestures. As a Shawol, this will always be something heartbreaking, even now, sobbing like a child is a norm because the pain remains.
The way that Minho said "he's not a bad uncle" make me think that childrens in Korea thinks that every people who left the group is because they're problematic and this considered bad :(
its because usually if someone leaves a group it usually they did something
This reality check you gave makes me so sad about how the Korean industry is shaped. Very unfair
At the same time, it's just a kids understanding.
Ah, idk if y’all know but jonghyun passed away in 2017.
@@yakiroon8349 we all know that
Not me actually starting to cry after Minho said that Jonghyun was not feeling well
I hope the girl doesn't go back to check because she'll probably very shocked. Or even ask her parent's if he is feeling better now. Children ask a lot of questions 😢😢😢
@@kokieduoh I understand but she should know. It’s not like kids don’t know what death is. I understand why Minho wouldn’t bring it up on tv because it could have been upsetting And caused a bad reaction. But still. She’s not 3.
@@riahlexington Its also not his place to explain death to her, that's her parents' job. Whether she understood now or not, he handled it perfectly.
I think we all did :(
민서 13살밖에 안됐는데 말을 저렇게 유창하고 센스있게 잘해...? 언어 선택이나 능청스러움이 거의 어른이얔ㅋㅋㅋ
2년이라는 시간이 지났음에도 볼때마다 울게되는 영상인듯..
"one person's missing though"
"yes, one person's missing"
"who? why?"
"left the group?"
"it's uncle jonghyun, he's not well"
"ah, then he's not a bad uncle"
"yes, he's not a bad uncle. he's a great uncle."
my tears won't stop
I can't stop crying 😔
I cried 🥺
Still crying. 😭
I cried too
Im tear up when minho mentioned uncle Jonghyun 😢😢😢
Same. It's just so heartbreaking
The pain in their eyes watching their first win was so hard to see they are such strong people who deserve so much happiness
Onew and Minho just give me the most wholesome dad vibes. Totally different styles but they’d be such good fathers 🥹
I agree! 🥰
Can we talk about how mature is the girl paired with Onew. She is very well educated
I've been watching her for awhile now and she is probably more matured than I am.
She always appreciate shinee, she's really have a good attitude
she's one of the oldest of the odg kids so that's to be expected!
She sounds so mature when she speaks
I'm 17 and jealous of how well she talks. Gotta train for it
I’m glad to hear one of the kids say “ So he isn’t a bad uncle”. Because now, there are so many scandals involving idols, actors and people from the entertainment industry almost everyday that has a bad effect of kids point of view on the adults.
Yes agreed. Minho Oppa did a good explanation to that girl. Which is why she understood that Jonghyun Oppa is not a "bad uncle"...
🥺
I agree!
yes, and the kids' point of view here in sk, those who are leaving the group was involved in scandals or whatever so they see them as bad person, you see? the girl asked if he left the group and she was relieved that that's not the case, ofc, they don't have much knowledge regarding the issues surrounding the celebrities and it's not like it's time for parents to explain to them everything, those are only what kids heard
I felt like it would have been okay to touch on why he wasn't there with he because she's old enough to understand, BUT that's not why they were there. I will agree that it was a decent explanation, given the time allotted. I still cried.
민서가 온유를 치유해주는 느낌이다.
주기적으로 보게 된다 이 영상은
샤이니의 보기 드문(?!) 편안하고 잔잔한 바이브와 뽀짝 생기 넘치는 애기들이 같이 만드는 힐링분위기....,,, 사랑함... 흑 흑...
태민아 보고싶어어어어어억
“That’s Uncle Jonghyun, he’s not well.”
K gonna go cry now..
I literally just discovered SHINee less than 30 min ago and I'm in full tears
Yeah, I just had a feeling somehow someone would mention him... but I still cried
@@levelup9273 Same-
Damn he looked so sad, I miss him too Minho :( Also love how he said that he is still one of the members.
i still cant accept the fact he is no more,he is still in our heart
Taemin: *showing how much albums he would have bc of his solo career*
The kid with Taemin: my uncle is in his thirties and he's single
That little guy make my daaaay!😂
Well kiddo just tell your uncle to GET IN LINE! 😂😂😂
@@byeongcheol5610 the uncle is taemin, he's 30 in korean age
Taemin is 30 and solo, that's a joke
@@tdelioncourt1268 He's 29 yet lol and it was just play on words with homonym of solo (single) in korean (the girl didn't meant to tho)
@@tdelioncourt1268 well i missed the point of that joke, didn't I?! I just figured I had one more competitor for Taemin's affections... sdfsdfsd 😂 Thank you for straightening me out! 💕
종현이 언급 할 때 민호 표정ㅠㅠ.... 슬퍼 저 애기는 아무것도 모르고 물어봤을 거 아니야ㅠㅜ
WE'LL NEVER FORGET YOUR JONGHYUN!!!!!
9:27 이때 부터 종현이 얘기 하는데 민호 표정 때문에 더 맘이 아프다 진짜 아이는 순진하게 아무것도 모르니까 민호한테 물어 본거 지만 대답해 주는 민호는 진짜 저렇게 덤덤하게 말 하기 까지 얼마나 많은 시간을 슬프게 보냈을까 연습생 때부터 데뷔하고 첫1위 첫 대상 첫콘서트 첫 음악방송 무대 를 하면서 많을 시간 을 종현이와 함께 보내고 했을텐데 종현이 언급 할때 마다 민호가 덤덤하게 말하는 이유는 이제는 민호 본인 스스로가 종현이 빈 자리를 받아 드릴 준비를 하고 있어서 그런게 아닌가 싶어요
뭔가 기분이가.. ㅜㅡ
여기서 민호답변 못들을거같아서 끔. 아이의 질문에 흠칫 놀라게 된다. 도망칠련다.
사랑해 샤이니.. 초심 잃지 않고 오래오래 활동해줘서 너무 고마워 ㅜㅠ 평생 덕질할게
4:30 애들 눈에도 보이는 똘망똘망 함
9:28
- one is missing...
- oh, yes...
- why? Where? Did he left?
- uh, yeah... Jonghyun uncle... Hes not well...
- oooh! So he is good uncle.
- yes, ofc. He is a good uncle.
I. CRIED.
Me too 😭😭 it’s 1am and I’m ugly sobbing in my room
3:25 and I’m crying next to my sleeping partner over it lol
I am in SHAMBLES. He answered in such a good way for a child to understand. And those of us who are old enough to grasp it, felt how that hurt. To be honest, I love Shinee very much. They’re one of my first favorite groups but it hurts too much to listen a lot. I listen in a very bittersweet way.
i felt so sad :(
Crying...
"my uncle is in his thirties and is still solo" child i-
i cracked so mush over it
timestamp?
@@charlottevr775 12:11
single* :)
Omg, I was about to comment this
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
9:28
너무 순수하게 물어봤는데 내 마음이 쿵하고 떨어지는 기분이지😢
샤이니는 진짜 미워할수없는 그룹이지 종현아...
Imagine the girl searching for SHINee afterwards and finds out about Jonghyun, she'll realize how wonderful Minho just did and told her
It needs to be talked about.
pls i cant rn i am sobbing :(((
she looks like a too innocent girl that aint allowed to use the internet by her mom
(just blabbering sorry)
at that time, when i was.. as old as her i guess
idk ive already so so not innocent :(
@R. Tolmach what i tried to mention is
im not sure she would check the fact what happened to jonghyun, on the internet
and its normal THESE DAYS, if parents r so strict like that. i didnt say this kind of parenting is wrong.
Yes...
key: who do you like the most in shinee?
kid: uncle key
key: i know right!
who is haeun😅😅
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ민호님 계속 호탕하게 웃는 거 너무 좋다ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
5:19 9:30 민호가 종현 삼촌 할 때마다… 눈물이… 그리고 다들 여러 감정이 교차하는 듯한 표정이네…
"Im old enough to be her father, right?"
HE JUST DRAGGED A WHOLE GENERATION DOWN WITH HIM HAHAHAHA
IM CRYING
I just laughed, he needs to stop making us realize our age.
Time stamp?
Hahahaha riiiight 😂😂😂😂😂
It’s funny coz he’s 31 and that kid must be like 12? So it’s a bit of a stretch to be her Dad but technically yes he could. The kid settled with “uncle”. Then you have Taemin who decided he was the 9 year olds “Oppa”. 😂
I was not crying, I am OK. The way Minho spoke about Jonghyun ripped my heart to pieces, but this video is just amazing. Thank you for doing this
I can’t stop crying and the whole video just made my day
I thought I was the only one .... ㅠㅠ my sister is trying to calm me down right now...
Sameeee ')))
Minho face was soo sad And swett
I saw how he still smiled when she asked who he was, and although I think it was a bittersweet smile, the fact that he seemed to be looking back at the memories like he was happy to have them made me feel better. I hope that makes sense
이 영상 가끔씩 보러와요 마음이 따뜻해져요 초등학교 입학할때 샤이니가 데뷔해서 초등학교 고학년부터 좋아했는데 어느덧 22살이네요 언제나 응원해요 행복하고 건강하자 샤이니 🤍🤍🤍
The way Minho spoke of Uncle Jonghyun and the way he said he IS one of our members...My heart broke and filled at the same time. JH will never be forgotten by any of us, least of all his brothers.
순수하게 종현 왜 없냐고 물어보는 거 맴찢...
근데 사실대로 말하면 충격 받을까봐 몸이 아파서 그렇대..
눈물나. 샤이니팬 아니지만.. 그냥 ..민호 잠깐 멈칫할때.. 눈물남 ㅠ. 다들 정말 대단하고 멋지다.
Honestly, the way Minho handled the girls question was very mature. He didn’t want to make her sad and he also probably knows that with adults, the response would be something like “sorry for your loss” but with kids there would probably be a follow up question like “how?”
Yes you are right, he handled it beautifully.
This!!
Exactly right
I was like I hope she doesn’t say anything about jonghyun but he really did a great job 😭🤍
right, I thought the same. it was a very clever answer and he managed the situation very well. it must have been hard for him too, to answer that question all of a sudden.
제 세대보단 조금 앞이지만 오빠가 있어서 샤이니 무대도 그렇고 많이 봤었는데 그 당시에는 이런 일이 있구나 했는데 크면서 보니 얼마나 큰 일이고 모두가 슬펐을지 상상이 안되네...항상 팬사랑 최고에 언제나 진심으로 열심히하던 샤이니이기에 아직도 활동하는 것 같고 너무 좋은 노래를 많이 들려줘서 고맙고 항상 응원하고 사랑해 샤이니😊🫶🏻🩵
9:35 민호 표정보고 울컥함 😢
"he's not well" "so he's not a bad uncle", my heart broke.
yeah Minho gave me the vibes that "He's still here, he will never be forgotten." Ahhhhhhhh ಥ╭╮ಥ
He gave a great answer so the kid wouldn't be upset or not understand. You can tell it hit him hard. Good job Minho!
Mine too😭
I cry this part😢😢😭
🥺🥺🥺🥺😭all I can do is - crying 😭🥺
진짜 요즘엔 팀에서 없어지면 다 사건 사고들로 나가는 거라 애들이 나가면 나쁜 사람이라고 생각되는 거에서 한 번 충격받고 ㅈㅎ 생각만 해도 아직도 존나 눈물 나옴
다시는 이런 일 없으면 해 얘들아 항상 좋은 것만 보고 우리의 존재가 힘든게 아니라 늘 힘이 되는 존재였으면 해
민호가 당황했어요
멤버들마다 분위기가 비슷한 아이들과 매칭돼서 더 귀엽고 보기 좋네요 ㅎㅎ
진짜 인정이요ㅎㅎ
The kid with key was so cute. The girl with minho was not impressed in the beginning but as the discography revealed more she was clapping and she liked it. The girl with onew was mature and onew was the nervous one i feel and the kid with taemin yeah he was cute too. "My uncle is 30 and he's still single" wdym baby I'm your aunt 😂😂
“One person is missing though?”
“Yea one person is missing”
“Who?”why? Left the group?”
“Uhh.. it’s uncle Jonghyun, he’s not well..”
“Ah. Then he’s not a bad uncle.”
“Yes, he’s not a bad uncle, he’s a good uncle.”
“Good uncle”
Minho’s face when he said that.😕
We all miss him🕊❤️
😭😭😭😭
@@Nosiwo2919 yes shes 12, what about it? did you expect her to act like an adult or something?
@@Nosiwo2919 well she didn’t know about the situation... but at least her and minho had fun together :)
timestamp?
@@Nosiwo2919 The girl didn’t know the situation that’s why she asked why one member is missing.
종현이 같이 나왔었다면 아이들이랑 눈맞춰주며 이뻐해주고 잘 들어주고 그랬을텐데 하며 그려지는데,,
아직도 종현이 이름만 들려도 진짜 눈물이 난다,,
맞아요 .. 얼마나 예뻐하고 .. 눈 마주하면서 예쁜 말 해주면서 눈에서 꿀 떨어질 종현이오빠 얼굴 안봐도 보여요
its been a year since this was released and I am still touched by how minho explained when the girl said one person is missing and asked why.. that clip, this whole video never failed to make me cry... i swear
하랑이 넘 귀엽다 ㅋㅋㅋ 순수하게 드러나는 표정이 다 말해주고 잇어 ㅋㅋㅋ 오늘 제일 기분 좋아보이넹 ㅋㅋㅋ
종현이 삼촌은 너무 좋은 사람이었어 이젠 보지 못해도 지금도 많은 사람들의 가슴속에 있는 너무 소중한 사람이었어
The girl throwing around words like 'retro' and 'vintage' not to hurt their feelings is giving me life kajfjsls
if u watched ODG videos, u will noticed Minseo always smart, deep thinker, and wise with her words.
@@Password9141 so true! She's always so incredible, especially for her age :)
It is not vintage- ✋😭 it’s just cringey
I watched few of the episodes, i always found her inspiring like he doesn’t wanna hurt anyone’s feeling rather than that she wanna encourage them.
@@no5778 but it was avante garde at the time.
샤이니는 앞으로도 오래오래 나와줬음 좋겟다
진짜 말하는 모습이 너무 배려심이 깊은 모습!!!!
천사네요
Its nice to see that we are not just "erasing" Jonghyun from our memories. Its nice to see they didn't cut the scenes were they talked about him. You can tell that every member still feels the loss but they are still moving forward. I cried so much but im also happy i saw this video.
Agreed, I was worried about that, glad they didn’t just pretend he wasn’t there.
Exactly what i thought, it made me so happy to mention him but couldn't hold my tears
actually they edited out the parts where the other members talked about him
@@jinlissul Well it makes sense to only show one clip showing a member explaining why someone was missing, it would be too much to show every member explaining.
@@MarkehJLL the children's parents mentioned that it was a shame because they explained it well to the kids, especially the mother of the kid kibum was with said it was touching i felt like it would have been nice to show all of the members' explanations, especially since people use jjong as some kind of taboo topic that always needs to have some kind of trigger warning.
not the kid calling taemin single the same way taemin calls his manager single during their lives
exactly LMFAO
Totally payback, for all the times Taemin called his manager hyung motae solo LOL
Tables have turned ㅋㅋㅋ I loved this comment so much 😆
That is karma for you 😂😂😂
payback in it's purest form 😂😂💙
민호의 배려가 따뜻하다... ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
오랫만에 알고리즘에 타서 다시 보게 됐네요. 사실 그 동안 알고리즘 뜰 때마다 거의 한번씩 보거든요
작년 컴백 후 입덕된 아기 샤월이라 그때 이 영상 처음 봤을 때 팬이 아니였는데 이번 다시 보더니 느낌 새로워지네요. 원래 팬 아니었지만 종현이 떠난다는 소식 듣었을 때 몇일 울었는데 팬 아니였던 때이든 팬이 되는 지금이든 변한없이 언제나 종현이 그립고 보고 싶더라고요. 아무래도 이 양상은 내가 샤월 된 계기라고 할 수 있을려나...? 다들 애들이랑 대화할 때 나오는 훈훈한 분위기, 종현이를 그리운 모습들 보면서 어떻게 응원해 주지 않을 수가 있을까요...?
아무튼 태민이 군대 다니는 동안 다른 멤버들 솔로 활동을 응원하면서 완전체 컴백할 때까지 기다리겠습니다. 샤이니 사랑해🌹🥰💎
“He’s not a bad uncle, he’s a good uncle” i'm crying
Me too
Me too
me too
me too
Me too
“That’s one of our members. Uncle Jonghyun”
🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲
I miss him ot5 ✊🏼🙏
@@tiushkabidla2385 yes 🙌🏼 He was my bias then, and he’s still my bias now and forever ✨
@@onedivinenote 🥺
We all love Jonghyun :)
샤월이였을 때 최애였던 종현이가 잠시 쉬게 된 후로부터 샤이니를 의도적으로 피하게 된 일인으로서(보면 눈물이 안 끊겨서;;) 가끔씩 우연히 관련영상을 돌려보게 될 때면 피하고 싶다가도 보게 되고 막상 보고나면 또 펑펑 울고...이 영상은 여러번 들러보게 되는데 볼 때마다 민호가 돌려말할 때 눈물이 터지면서도 한켠으로는 따스한 감정이 들고...하지만 데리러 가는 여전히 온전히 듣지 못하는 한 곡이고...아 진짜 모순되는 심리네...
i love coming back to this video, especially today. it’s so healing whenever i have a rough time. their honesty and openness and kindness always warms my heart
I cried the whole day, it was like I needed to watch something to pour all my tears.
Jonghyun why why why my heart my Jonghyun bias heart I cannot....
Taemin refusing to believe he is getting old! The little girl calls him ‘uncle’ but he refers to himself as ‘oppa’ 😂
I also recognized that... So funny
He's always going to be Shinee's baby. Maknae on top lol
Lol that's what we call baby culture 🤗
Which minute?
😭she even roasted him for being single I'm dead