Can you guys stop attacking her for one slip and some sharp notes-cmon now. She’s obviously somewhat is a international comp. she still made it to the next round. She did amazing and you guys need to stop bashing her for something you can’t even do. She did great
i know right? like she practiced and do you expect people to play perfectly, no mistakes or something whatsoever in a perfromance, she was probably nervous
This is probably the once in a few times someone doesn't perform as well as they always do, if you hear and watch sumina's other recordings of Caprice No.5 they are really well played. Show her more support guys, musicians need the confidence to stand on stage and perform their best and i personally think she has the talent and the time to improve much more.
People always only focus on the failure, like the memory slip. But never remember she is playing the original down down down up bowings for the paganini...so precise and clear
Tbh it gets increasingly easier to play with a better violin and now (not taking away from her trying to play it with the original bowing at a competition, takes guts)
@@Ickguenthrasil not necessarily. once you hit a certain 'price' for a violin, it becomes very apparent and obvious if you even 'slightly' hit a note a little high or low.
@@CknSalad but I'm not referring to intonation? And no matter the price point you will always be able to hear intonation. I'm referring to the projection of a violin while doing ricochet. Try playing the original bowing in Paganini 5 with a 5000 euro violin and a 5000 euro bow, and then with a strad and a peccatte. The better the violin the less effort you have to put in to produce the same sound as before
As an examiner, we do not focus on the mistakes on the candidate, but the techniques, musicality and their connection with the music to know their knowledge to the piece. Everyone mistakes, so why should we judge them by those?
is like telling a student in a Maths exam, that the final results for that sum doesn't matter, is the steps and the process that counts (when the steps probably took up an entire page). Pity that the question was worth 4 marks, the mistake was 1 mark deducted, with the wrong result costing another 1 mark, final score 50%. Damn! She was so judged on that one mistake. It just makes a judge's life so much easier. But I'm sure in the end, that one expensive mistake will probably get her much further in life. Imagine a solo violinist at a concert, making a mistake like that, might cost a career.
0:21 - W.A. Mozart from Violin Concerto No. 3 in G major K. 216, 1st movement 7:22 - F. Kreisler Syncopation 9:49 - J.S. Bach Solo Sonata in G minor BWV 1001 Siciliana and Presto 15:02 - N. Paganini Caprice No. 5 for Solo Violin, Op. 1 Beautiful performance Miss. Studer. Your Presto was especially very well played. Thank you for your art. And a thank you to Miss. Eimer as well. Elegantly played.
Performing in competition is completely different than other situations. Nerves can influence playing and even the best prepared player can make an error due to nerves. Also, since most people in competitions are young they sometimes have not yet acquired the necessary confidence and experience at performing. Give Sumina a break. She played very well.
Funny how people are acting like violin critics when none of them can produce a fraction of the sound she can nor can they play an instrument nearly as well as she can. The people critiquing her for a small memory slip have clearly never performed in front of an audience as a soloist. All musicians have memory slips, including the best of the best. I just find it ironic how it’s always the old, white men who don’t play instruments that have the most to say.
she may have had some slip ups but nevertheless she was wonderful! But it feels like there's still something missing... Hmm? And to the others saying she shouldn't have tried, I think it was better she did, than not. Watch her video playing Pag. 5!
Very fine playing, I must say. Slightly distracted by what appears to be several piles of old boxes on the stage, apparently once containing bottles of Menuhin claret?
Wonderful player . She has a joyful presence hiding her incredible intonation and tastefulness . Very different from Adamyan but totally engaging but a different kid of Mozart graceful but she can change mood quickly not a classical era period trait ! Her Schumann, Dvorak Bruch ,Mendells concerti and romantic repertoire is ideal .
She played 20min straight! Holy shit that’s tough already let alone she was playing one the most difficult pieces ever. I thought she did great though. And her bow technique is usually very solid. I’m actually very curious what she got from the competition? I felt like she’s really good to be in the final
I didn't know how hard it is to play a violin unless I took the initiative to start learning myself (2 months and yet I can't bow straight, bow is shaky, got no idea how to make sound out of the violin with tip and fro-(?) Bottom of the bow, just doing the scales has my shoulder, hands hurt like hell) I've got little to no knowledge about music but I could listen to music pieces for hours, I'm surprised at how some people actually find beautiful music boring I've seen a lot of comment saying people need to stop attacking her but didn't find any comment that was actually attacking her And ofc I couldn't notice mistakes because I was working with the music on and now re watching and noticed her expression which told me she messed up a lil She looks like she's giving her all to express through violin and her movement is so graceful... I'm also new to her channel but she inspired me a lot... She's a sweet person❤️ Looking her play motivates me... I might not stand in front of an audience and perform this gracefully but I do want to master every techniques I can and play to my hearts content... Might as well go to a teacher if I still can't play right after few more months I've written a lot of irrelevant stuffs but I want to say... I'm not an expert so I cannot notice any mistake at all... Fabulous playing T^T)❤️
The caprice no 5 wasnt the best, but i mean its also so exhausting to play so long and play this then. And it affords so much concentration. But we all know that she can play this caprice so perfectly, its really sad that this made her maybe upset for the rest of the caprice after her little fail. Poor sumina, but she is still great!❤️
Wow, great performance and amazing personality!!!! So much fun to watch and listen...she plays with heart and so much passion!!!! ❤️😀 Presto and Caprice No.5 blew me away, even though there was a little glitch at 17:42. Hope it will not cost her points!!!!
Aspiring Violinist Newbie No problem, she made it to the semifinals. I think we will see her also in the final round. Definitely one of my favorites together with Tianyou Ma.
Adoro ouvi-la tocar violino.!!! Arte maravilhosa.!!! Há muito tempo subscrevi seu canal no Gmail, mas nunca veio maus nenhum vídeo sei.!!! Por favor não me deixe de ouvi-la....! A alma precisa de beleza e arte para viver......
These acoustics are so the judges can hear all of the intonation and techinal work. Especially in the first rounds of the competition the judges want to make note of the player's technical ability. In the last stages of the competition you'll notice great acoustics :)
But erm I am sry to say.. but I don't think u r at ur best that time.. I like ur other video better the caprice no .5.... I think u r nervous.... but I still think u r great!!♡
Nadia Kołacińska except...sumina didn't win did she? An someone who played with no mistakes as drastic as hers did. Stop acting like competition is about making mistakes. That's not how any of this works lol. "I know you had less points an made more mistakes than this person who clearly played it flawlessly so instead of giving it to them let's give it to you. Did you watch ray chen competition? He didn't win because he made mistakes... Do you think that logic works at auditions too? Come on...she should've picked another piece.
Nadia Kołacińska first off you saying it was boring is entirely personal opinion..not fact at all. Second...she didn't miss a few notes lol. The entire piece was bad. She was sharp each time she went for the high note. 3 memory slips one after another. The tempo suffered. It sounded like she was practicing the piece...not performing it. I really find it hard to believe you go to auditions and competitions an think they go for the person who messes up lol. An no...mature playing wasn't why. I mean some of the juniors destroyed all the senior runners by miles. What's also funny is pag 5 wasn't her only mistake but it was pretty bad as a whole. That's not debatable.
Nadia Kołacińska i knew what you meant. It's still a opinion. An while i don't do competitions i have many friends who do an they wouldn't go spouting off the things you're here. Let's just disregard the point system entirely by your logic because MISTAKES(not singular but multiple because the whole piece was bad) don't matter an that'll actually help you win.... Point is the judges were extremely gracious to let her pass this round.
You think it’s that easy? Ray Chen isn’t the one playing and this is the most competitive violin competition in the world. You can’t just magically please everyone just because your boyfriend has a few things to say.
At 11 you are not mature enough to understand Mozart. She can play all the notes in tune probably. However, she has to grow a bit more to play like Sumina. This girl plays with passion and truly emotion, we can see that she knows what she is playing and most of all WHO she is playing...
@@afonsomarques7475 oh stop. That Mozart movement is as boring as music gets and it’s drivel like that that gives classical music a bad reputation.There’s no understanding a deeper level to it. It just plain boring - and he just wrote it mindlessly.
![ประสบการณ์ จ้าง Developer ที่ผมจะไม่มีวันลืม [ภาค1]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bzivN4KDg-k/mqdefault.jpg)
Can you guys stop attacking her for one slip and some sharp notes-cmon now. She’s obviously somewhat is a international comp. she still made it to the next round. She did amazing and you guys need to stop bashing her for something you can’t even do. She did great
Gabe A. Well said
Me too. Talent, class and Swiss. You can't beat it! Is she the next ASM?
i know right? like she practiced and do you expect people to play perfectly, no mistakes or something whatsoever in a perfromance, she was probably nervous
Ikr also she is the one who went for competition, only she can judge herself of HER performance totally not random ppl on the internet
This is probably the once in a few times someone doesn't perform as well as they always do, if you hear and watch sumina's other recordings of Caprice No.5 they are really well played. Show her more support guys, musicians need the confidence to stand on stage and perform their best and i personally think she has the talent and the time to improve much more.
Is there a mistake at around 16:00 ?
Định Vĩnh
Her expression said it all
Định Vĩnh She had a memory slip
That's why they judge playing live... Recordings can be manipulated and edited after multiple takes.
That's because on no. 5 she recorded it MUCH slower and then sped it up...
People always only focus on the failure, like the memory slip. But never remember she is playing the original down down down up bowings for the paganini...so precise and clear
T Mic i
Tbh it gets increasingly easier to play with a better violin and now (not taking away from her trying to play it with the original bowing at a competition, takes guts)
@@Ickguenthrasil not necessarily. once you hit a certain 'price' for a violin, it becomes very apparent and obvious if you even 'slightly' hit a note a little high or low.
@@CknSalad but I'm not referring to intonation? And no matter the price point you will always be able to hear intonation. I'm referring to the projection of a violin while doing ricochet. Try playing the original bowing in Paganini 5 with a 5000 euro violin and a 5000 euro bow, and then with a strad and a peccatte. The better the violin the less effort you have to put in to produce the same sound as before
@@Ickguenthrasil i am an adult beginner with 1,5 years of progress.
My 4/4 violin🎻 (for beginners) is 150€ 🙈🙉🙊🔫🔫🔫
Great performance. Violin is so hard to master. She did wonderful job. Heifetz didn't like competition in music. It cannot measure like a sports.
As an examiner, we do not focus on the mistakes on the candidate, but the techniques, musicality and their connection with the music to know their knowledge to the piece. Everyone mistakes, so why should we judge them by those?
is like telling a student in a Maths exam, that the final results for that sum doesn't matter, is the steps and the process that counts (when the steps probably took up an entire page). Pity that the question was worth 4 marks, the mistake was 1 mark deducted, with the wrong result costing another 1 mark, final score 50%. Damn! She was so judged on that one mistake. It just makes a judge's life so much easier. But I'm sure in the end, that one expensive mistake will probably get her much further in life. Imagine a solo violinist at a concert, making a mistake like that, might cost a career.
0:21 - W.A. Mozart from Violin Concerto No. 3 in G major K. 216, 1st movement
7:22 - F. Kreisler Syncopation
9:49 - J.S. Bach Solo Sonata in G minor BWV 1001 Siciliana and Presto
15:02 - N. Paganini Caprice No. 5 for Solo Violin, Op. 1
Beautiful performance Miss. Studer. Your Presto was especially very well played. Thank you for your art.
And a thank you to Miss. Eimer as well. Elegantly played.
Max Lever I believe she also posted all of the pieces in this round to her channel except for the Paganini. :)
i love how ray nearly had the same lineup of pieces. He must have guided her. fantastic performance
Performing in competition is completely different than other situations. Nerves can influence playing and even the best prepared player can make an error due to nerves. Also, since most people in competitions are young they sometimes have not yet acquired the necessary confidence and experience at performing. Give Sumina a break. She played very well.
Wish I had something in my life for which I can dress this grand
Sumina Studer fanclab here *LIKE PEOPLE*
lets goooo
Felix Mendelssohn Fanclub of TwoSetViolin = Fanclub of Samina
Erik Nystrom Also Ray
Felix Mendelssohn Yes, absolutely!
shes gonna get first this tiem
You cannot rise to the top without taking risks. I enjoyed it, Bravo!
Funny how people are acting like violin critics when none of them can produce a fraction of the sound she can nor can they play an instrument nearly as well as she can. The people critiquing her for a small memory slip have clearly never performed in front of an audience as a soloist. All musicians have memory slips, including the best of the best. I just find it ironic how it’s always the old, white men who don’t play instruments that have the most to say.
I think she handled it really good. It didn't sound bad at all. I could never do that
she may have had some slip ups but nevertheless she was wonderful! But it feels like there's still something missing... Hmm?
And to the others saying she shouldn't have tried, I think it was better she did, than not. Watch her video playing Pag. 5!
Tough crowd in the comments
Incredible Sumina!!! So glad I found you on instagram because you play so beautifully. Thanks for being such an inspiration!!!
Um this video isn’t on her channel
Very fine playing, I must say.
Slightly distracted by what appears to be several piles of old boxes on the stage, apparently once containing bottles of Menuhin claret?
Isn’t the acoustic of the Hall a bit dry?
May Shuen Poon I kinda hear that too compared to the stage in London
May Shuen Poon . from what I’ve seen the stage gets fancier as the competition progresses
Byron Huang this is awful for a such prestigious competition then.
Maybe at this stage in the competition they're very picky with sound and want hear everthing without the distraction of echo-y acoustics.
Lachlan Edwards I see, Despite the dry acoustic, some players still sound amazingly beautiful and super projecting !
Wonderful player . She has a joyful presence hiding her incredible intonation and tastefulness . Very different from Adamyan but totally engaging but a different kid of Mozart graceful but she can change mood quickly not a classical era period trait ! Her Schumann, Dvorak Bruch ,Mendells concerti and romantic repertoire is ideal .
She played 20min straight! Holy shit that’s tough already let alone she was playing one the most difficult pieces ever. I thought she did great though. And her bow technique is usually very solid. I’m actually very curious what she got from the competition? I felt like she’s really good to be in the final
the irony of the people criticizing her slip-up in the caprice is that now she has a flawless version with 9 million views
I’m playing this piece for an audition and the style is just so hard 😩 and the audition is on July 1
It is a competition, the pressure aiming for perfection must be alot. Bravo, well done !
Amazing! She sounds beautiful! So much skill and grace!
:-) Best of luck to you Sumina. It's a true pleasure to listen you in action!
We musicians are normal human beings, which means we're all allowed to make mistakes! We love you Sumina! #ViolinGang
she's almost crying out at the end...
probably yes....😟😟
i’d cry too
Shows you don’t have to play the hardest piece to be excellent
I didn't know how hard it is to play a violin unless I took the initiative to start learning myself (2 months and yet I can't bow straight, bow is shaky, got no idea how to make sound out of the violin with tip and fro-(?) Bottom of the bow, just doing the scales has my shoulder, hands hurt like hell) I've got little to no knowledge about music but I could listen to music pieces for hours, I'm surprised at how some people actually find beautiful music boring
I've seen a lot of comment saying people need to stop attacking her but didn't find any comment that was actually attacking her
And ofc I couldn't notice mistakes because I was working with the music on and now re watching and noticed her expression which told me she messed up a lil
She looks like she's giving her all to express through violin and her movement is so graceful... I'm also new to her channel but she inspired me a lot... She's a sweet person❤️ Looking her play motivates me... I might not stand in front of an audience and perform this gracefully but I do want to master every techniques I can and play to my hearts content... Might as well go to a teacher if I still can't play right after few more months
I've written a lot of irrelevant stuffs but I want to say... I'm not an expert so I cannot notice any mistake at all... Fabulous playing T^T)❤️
The caprice no 5 wasnt the best, but i mean its also so exhausting to play so long and play this then. And it affords so much concentration. But we all know that she can play this caprice so perfectly, its really sad that this made her maybe upset for the rest of the caprice after her little fail. Poor sumina, but she is still great!❤️
At one time I was a competitive violinist til It broke me mentally after my grandmother died I never competed again.
Wow, great performance and amazing personality!!!! So much fun to watch and listen...she plays with heart and so much passion!!!! ❤️😀 Presto and Caprice No.5 blew me away, even though there was a little glitch at 17:42. Hope it will not cost her points!!!!
Yeah, I hope her original bowings will make up for it!
Aspiring Violinist Newbie No problem, she made it to the semifinals. I think we will see her also in the final round. Definitely one of my favorites together with Tianyou Ma.
She made it, YEY! ❤️😀👍
She is an excellent communicator for sure!
Sumina you have a lot of people supporting you, go for it! But most of all enjoy it
Dang y’all need to chill I’d like to see you play what she did
Amazing!!! I've hardly heard any other violinist play paganini so well
No sé dónde está el error de Sumina, no soy violinista será por eso ,para mí lo hace tan bien que me parece ingrato cuestionarla.
The Kreisler was beautifully played - great sense of fun and got the rhythmic feel just perfect.
The ling ling is strong in this one....
Love the accompanist😍😍 and Sumina‘s Paganini is to die for!
The Kreisler piece was really refreshing to hear. I don’t think I‘ve heard it before! Obviously Kreisler got some inspiration f rom Scott Joplin.
Paganini no.5!!!!!
Paganini violin concerto
Andrew Liu 5 and 9 are really hard!
@@totalwar1793 what about 24?
🎵🎻💙🎶🎹🥀🎵🎻💙🎶🎹🥀🎵
12:50 - Mvt 4 of Bach Sonata.
Adoro ouvi-la tocar violino.!!! Arte maravilhosa.!!!
Há muito tempo subscrevi seu canal no Gmail, mas nunca veio maus nenhum vídeo sei.!!!
Por favor não me deixe de ouvi-la....! A alma precisa de beleza e arte para viver......
Utterly amazing. Great work. And talent
this is playing in piano not in the orcester
Genial SUMINA te saludo desde La Patagonia Argentina America del Sur abrazo fraternal bellisima tu actuacion
Wow, look at that violin, amazingly carved F holes...
I love how you play!
The acoustics of the venue just made me cringe...
Btw, a big fat ❤️ for Sumina!!!
These acoustics are so the judges can hear all of the intonation and techinal work. Especially in the first rounds of the competition the judges want to make note of the player's technical ability. In the last stages of the competition you'll notice great acoustics :)
She's playing with the original bowing... Do better than her, otherwise you can't say a word.
Ez
you look so beautiful.
beautiful sound!
amazing!♡
Fantastic performance!
Wish you the best! You Did amazing!! Bravo!!!
Brilliant - of course! (That pianist is no slouch, either)
Wow...a recording that is not sped up to make her look better than she is....
Beautiful!
Is it my impression, or did she really miss near the end?
Sara Albuquerque Silva she made 2 memory slips it seems
hats off to you! Bravo Bravo
#SuminaArmy suppord 😘
beautiful！！！
YASSS SHE'S PLAYING PAG 5
Harrison Loeffler she messed up nooooooo
Anyone know who wrote that Mozart cadenza?
In case you didn't know, you are actually supposed to write your own cadenza....
@@niccolopaganini6602 Wow! Good for her. Was very well done
Niccolò Paganini Stop composing pieces that 99% of people can’t play
Why is this so comedie
Wonderful performance !!Fantastic playing !!
Omg u went to that comp♡♡♡ u r doing great!! Nailed that paganini >♡
But erm I am sry to say.. but I don't think u r at ur best that time.. I like ur other video better the caprice no .5.... I think u r nervous.... but I still think u r great!!♡
Fantastic violinist!
well played👍🏼
Very good!
quite remarkable
amazing!
Cool
ray chen must be proud
👏 👏 👏 BRAVO
Nicola Eimer is great!
Go SUMINAAAAAAA!!!!
all of his presentation sounds crunshy, scratchy. maybe so much weight on bow or rosin? Can someone tell me what is causing this sound?
amazing!
u look different
15:58 bye bye 1st prize
Kevin Javdani yea even after an before that. That whole piece was a no go.
Nadia Kołacińska this isn't a anime...you make MULTIPLE MISTAKES an you lose. No different than any COMPETITION.
Nadia Kołacińska except...sumina didn't win did she? An someone who played with no mistakes as drastic as hers did. Stop acting like competition is about making mistakes. That's not how any of this works lol.
"I know you had less points an made more mistakes than this person who clearly played it flawlessly so instead of giving it to them let's give it to you. Did you watch ray chen competition? He didn't win because he made mistakes...
Do you think that logic works at auditions too? Come on...she should've picked another piece.
Nadia Kołacińska first off you saying it was boring is entirely personal opinion..not fact at all. Second...she didn't miss a few notes lol. The entire piece was bad. She was sharp each time she went for the high note. 3 memory slips one after another. The tempo suffered. It sounded like she was practicing the piece...not performing it. I really find it hard to believe you go to auditions and competitions an think they go for the person who messes up lol. An no...mature playing wasn't why. I mean some of the juniors destroyed all the senior runners by miles. What's also funny is pag 5 wasn't her only mistake but it was pretty bad as a whole. That's not debatable.
Nadia Kołacińska i knew what you meant. It's still a opinion. An while i don't do competitions i have many friends who do an they wouldn't go spouting off the things you're here. Let's just disregard the point system entirely by your logic because MISTAKES(not singular but multiple because the whole piece was bad) don't matter an that'll actually help you win....
Point is the judges were extremely gracious to let her pass this round.
tone is so dope
i checked the list to see whether shes in top 4...nope?...checked the vid...somewhat disappointed.
Dechosen Pen she didn’t make it to the finals
Paganini 5 is lol oh...🤔
Nice :)
Sumina studer fanclab here LIKE PEOPLE
Wowwww
Support!!
The acoustics of that place are simply horrible.
Sumina, without a doubt, is the best violinist now in the world. She will pass the level of Heifetz in a couple of years.
Crack sumina!
Paganini ...
Sorry but it doesn't look like she's quite ready for prime time. But at least she'll continue to get regular gigs from Ray.......😏
She must have an advantage dating ray Chen lol. Previous winner and jury member so he knows all the tricks and things the jury likes 🙃
She is dating Ray Chen wtf ? I didn't know
I thought they were just friend or smth
And even if they were, I don't think Ray would say anything
Even if he does and did share he can’t play for her so I don’t really see too much of an advantage
You think it’s that easy? Ray Chen isn’t the one playing and this is the most competitive violin competition in the world. You can’t just magically please everyone just because your boyfriend has a few things to say.
Not bad 🤔
15:58 OOOPS
16:14 oops
Probably shouldn't have tried the Paganini.
I have a friend and she’s 11 and she can play this
At 11 you are not mature enough to understand Mozart. She can play all the notes in tune probably. However, she has to grow a bit more to play like Sumina. This girl plays with passion and truly emotion, we can see that she knows what she is playing and most of all WHO she is playing...
@@afonsomarques7475 oh stop. That Mozart movement is as boring as music gets and it’s drivel like that that gives classical music a bad reputation.There’s no understanding a deeper level to it. It just plain boring - and he just wrote it mindlessly.
@@joefagan9335 you’re clearly not a classical musician 😂
This song is so boring
Terrible
You are such a low life. I’d like to see you play even a fraction of what she played. Typical insolent man.