Anu Malik's version of these songs sounds like second hand copy of the original. Copying Rahman's stuff is also not easy. Music production and quality on another level.
ARR doesn't not like talking about past... He always stays humble and down to earth nature. He till today doesn't want to talk about his success at all, but always strive to encourage young musician to aim for the skies the limits. Who is the best, he doesn't want to know... But putting Indian music to the top of the world is what's matters most for him.
I don't think AR RAHMAN is not down to earth.he always think he is God.he never respect Illayaraj sir and never tells the masters he worked at telugu music directors He has superior attitude problem
ARR is an original musician and whatever credits he gets are not important to him. People have passed the verdict and he also has Oscars to his credit after innumerable awards at home. Standing head and shoulders above most others, he is humble and trains youngsters giving breaks to unknown people with skill. His works transcends music and reaches the soul.
ARR isn't an original composer. No one is original composer if you think that way. Rahman lifted countless songs from wastern music and also Indian folk music.
Yes, Arr also walks with his feet on the Earth! Others walk with their feet in the sky! ARRogance is his 2013 BBC interview in which he was boasting FALSELY that before he came, it was all just Dholak, Violin and Flute, just to overproject himself over his greater / humbler seniors! Arr has been ACCUSED of PLAGIARISM / Outsourcing THRICE by his peers (Ismail Darbar, Ouseppachan, and Hindustani musician's family), and he got almost sued by Ouseppachan in 2018! RAM GOPAL VARMA said Slumdog songs were OUTSOURCED! He also said Arr had a rift with Subhash Ghai over the same issue!
@@priyanshusinha6541 You fools have brilliant music directors in Hindi like shankar jaikishen, sd burman da, KJ, Ravi, LP etc... yesteryears and Nadeem Shravan, Jatin Lalith, Anu Malik Modern yet you dont value them. But you consider Consider AR music which i consider like artificial Fast Food full of synthesizers etc..... will cause Only constipation😁🤣😂 Just because he have got some Oscar Award people think he is great Music Director. I m not saying allhis compostions are bad. If you dont understand still Just compare Illayaraja music with AR Rehman.
@@sanatanihindu7477guys don’t go by TH-cam video. I pretty sure AR Rehman might be busy with next project and couldn’t do Hindi remark BGm and recording. Producer might have managed to pay enough money to Anu to do recording work with existing songs. AR Rahman is an artist, producer owns all rights of the song legally. It’s up to them if they want to reuse. Hope that gives clarity. If a music director want to copy they won’t do in exact same movie remake at exact same spot. It’s just song remake job for Anu just like the director.
@@sanatanihindu7477 I appreciate your love and Respect for Anu Malik, I guess he is the same Music Director who was charged for Se xual harassment against most of the Female Staff Like Alisha Chinnoy. Also Sound Engineer Hardwares Used by Anu Malik are the ones which ARR started Using in 2004. If you are a 50+yr old Fat Jack and listen to songs in a cassette player with no clue of Mixing then I completely agree with Your Choice. Spend some time listening to Tracks which he mastered in 1990s , Its music is as clean as his Character
Whatever dispute between copying issues is human nature. But what’s the end result. Look at Anu Malik n AR.Rehman Level. It’s simple as that , “The best man wins!
@@rijeshmathewsboth the songs displayed in video composed by A R Rahman is a total bullshit. I Don't know why you people lick his feet so much. A R Rahman is the most overrated composer ever, he is nowhere near Anu Malik.
@@parmadola4993if those songs were bad, why Anu malik copied it? You mean he has no sense? 😂 Let's admit, the song Anu malik actually composed in this film is a very mediocre one. It just sounds like his other songs.
@@upendraprasad5171both the songs displayed in video composed by A R Rahman is a total bullshit. I Don't know why you people lick his feet so much. A R Rahman is the most overrated composer ever, he is nowhere near Anu Malik.
@@soumalyachatterjee6974Yess he is no music composer close him i don't think you know about best work's of Ar Bombay, Roja, Alaipayuthey, Jeans, Kadhal, Thiruda Thiruda, vendukondain vendukondain, Minsara kanavu, Dil se, Mudhu, kadhalan, Duet, Gentleman, Jeans, Vinnaithandi varuvaaya, Sillunu oru kadhal, Guru, Ok kamnani And Many More Albums
@@introvert1232both the songs displayed in video composed by A R Rahman is a total bullshit. I Don't know why you people lick his feet so much. A R Rahman is the most overrated composer ever, he is nowhere near Anu Malik.
Couldn’t have been said any better, Infact the song actually started playing in my ears the moment you mentioned it, truly the most befitting example, your comment should get 10 million likes !
Apart from composition, the sound engineering was way above contemporaries in his songs..He invested in best equipments even before his first film. That quality could not be copied.
Yes exactly and if you have an ear for music you will notice it vividly all the music at those times sounded muddy compared to the clarity of sound engineering that a r rahmans music had.
@@BC999 😂 dekh Bhai music is subjective but when you mentioned the word tunes I understood it's quite difficult for you to appreciate melodies , harmonies and rhythms which doesn't come under your capabilities to understand it .... He's the only composer after Ilayaraja and rd Burman to give us such quality melodies and quality recordings...when you go the extra mile it's not only cleverness but also sincerity and he's not taking you and me i.e. the listeners for granted ...Anu Malik and Nadeem shravan and jatin lalit can only dream of making such songs with grand arrangements, harmonies and such crystal clear rhythms ....it's okay if you don't like his music but to call it mediocre not happening ...this guy can compose gazals , hindustani , carnatic , western classical, pop , edm etc. with equal eaze ...the other composers who are good but can only dream of what arr has achieved....you and I can be fools but berkley and other top universities who have given him doctorate are not ... anyways man I hope you're open to new music which don't fit your regular pattern ....watch gulzars video on ar rahman
@@kalunaga1582 Just because Arr is better than the 90s' crop of Bollywood music directors, it does NOT mean he is in the "top" tier. That doctorate means nothing, just like the Acadummy awards. The same Gulzar said it was DIFFICULT to write for Ilayaraja's tunes! So, Ae Zindagi was COMPOSED FOR Gulzar's lyrics! Moreover, Arr's style of working is a mix of things; sounds, production, sampling, outsourcing, and plagiarizing - all powered by corporate PR team! STOP dropping words like harmonies, rhythms etc. Coming to RDB, he had assistants to arrange. That leaves Ilayaraja whose compositions are 100% his own, with WRITING SCORES for each instrument for 1000+ movies and counting!
AR REHMAN IS NOT A GENIUS ........... ANU MALIK IS REAL GENIUS......... HE HAS MANY MANY FLAVORS OF WORKING........ ALL ROUDER......... AR REHMAN IS CHEAP AND LIMITED
both the songs displayed in video composed by A R Rahman is a total bullshit. I Don't know why you people lick his feet so much. A R Rahman is the most overrated composer ever, he is nowhere near Anu Malik.
AR REHMAN IS NOT A GENIUS ........... ANU MALIK IS REAL GENIUS......... HE HAS MANY MANY FLAVORS OF WORKING........ ALL ROUDER......... AR REHMAN IS CHEAP AND LIMITED
@@POMI_Singing_Guru Anu Malik is not genius. He is cheap copycat and limited. He is a fraud who steals other's hardwork. AR Rehman is real genius. He has many flavours of working. He makes songs in different genres and styles.
AR REHMAN IS NOT A GENIUS ........... ANU MALIK IS REAL GENIUS......... HE HAS MANY MANY FLAVORS OF WORKING........ ALL ROUDER......... AR REHMAN IS CHEAP AND LIMITED
If one is a listener of many languages, and have heard Tamil music, you can most of the times identify if the song is originally in Tamil or not. Many Hindi songs were originally made in Tamil and when remade in Hindi, you can still feel the Tamil flavour in it.
If this is completely true, then it's a shame on Anu Malik. But from comments I see that in the movie they had thanked ARR for using his tunes for 3 songs.. I think that's totally acceptable
Its a remake film. The producer wanted to use copies of the original 3 songs. The producer has the right to do that as he had bought the right to remake the movie. So even those 3 songs were remade.
Mr . A. R. Rahman Sir Worlds One Of The Best Music Director .. Rahman Sir's Music Is Truly Original Music .. Rahman Sir Know All World About Their Great Music ..
They even didn't mentioned the name of music maestro the melody king in Hindi version of saathiya tune kya kiya. It's original song is from Telugu composed by Ilayaraja garu but when you watch the Hindi version it shows Anand-milind as music composer and many films too even in kaadhal psycho (saiyaan psycho) they changed the music director name of Hindi version
AR REHMAN IS NOT A GENIUS ........... ANU MALIK IS REAL GENIUS......... HE HAS MANY MANY FLAVORS OF WORKING........ ALL ROUDER......... AR REHMAN IS CHEAP AND LIMITED
I dont agree with this. Anu malik never took credit. Because in the titles of the hindi version they mentioned special thanks to a r rehman, for using his composition for 3 songs.
It’s a 100 % remake - so they retained the tunes of the original Tamil movie - one because they liked , second they also felt that these songs were a hit & will help in making the Hindi remake also a success - they would have definitely taken the necessary permissions from the source - there was no controversy till now - 😊
@@delugeakrp when a artist sold his songs to movie producer or label the rights goes to label and its labels decision whether to use it anywhere or sold that composition/song to anyone
@@princesolanki5914 does that mean anyone with money can buy another person's songs and pass it of as their own... Without any mention... Asking because I don't know how this works
Anu malik's sound production & musical harmony sounds absolutely horrendous. Nowadays even cover bands singing in pubs & bistros do a much better job in those departments.
Even in Virasat, paayale Jhunmun jhunmun is the same tune as in Tamil original. But it is still beautiful. And the other songs in the movie are also awesome. Anyways Anu Malik's work in Border, Baazigar, Munna Bhai, Viraasat etc is really special.
The technicalities of the original was far better right from the tempo and the mixing of the songs...you could hear each and every instrument used in the original songs...!!
AR cannot be compared with any composer alive or dead …. All his compositions touch the soul and make us feel emotions that are hidden within … nobody can surpass him in any form .. I still get goosebumps listening to his songs be it any language
Nice Joke. 😂😂 both the songs displayed in video composed by A R Rahman is a total bullshit. I Don't know why you people lick his feet so much. A R Rahman is the most overrated composer ever, he is nowhere near Anu Malik.
@@saravanabalajik not really. Ilaiyaraaja is the greatest Indian music director of all times. Only composer near his level are Hemanta Mukhopadhyay, G. Devarajan, Shankar-Jaikishan, M. S. Viswanathan, K. V. Mahadevan and K. Chakravarthy.
@@circuits00both the songs displayed in video composed by A R Rahman is a total bullshit. I Don't know why you people lick his feet so much. A R Rahman is the most overrated composer ever, he is nowhere near Anu Malik.
Not only this . Anu Malik is just following what is seniors did in Bollywood. For eg .the song from Kalakar Neele neele ambar pe Chand jab ..... Original version was by Ilayaraja in Tamil in the Payanangal mudivathilai .
Totally agree with you on not giving credit to ar rehman, should have been given ..but Anu Malik had his own style of music, although some of his music is copied but I still have his tracks on my playlist like judwaa, baazigar,border, main hoon na, refugee, phir teri kahaani and many more..
It was an official Hindi remake of the Tamil film. The producers of the Hindi movie had officially bought the copyrights from the Tamil movie. So 3 original compositions from Tamil version were re-used without any change in tune or instrumentation for Hindi version. There was a note thanking A.R. Rahaman in the opening credits in Hindi.
If ARR was thanked then why the credit for those songs given to Anu Malik. And if his songs are used in movie then why Anu Malik getting such project it is utter waste of money.
Whenever you show a song, you should silence the background music of your video (in this case the piano). It sounds completely out of tune and chaotic. Just a suggestion.
Its the mistake of Makers. Woh hindi Versions bhi AR Rahman ne hi banaye the aur sirf woh last wala song Anu Malik ne banaya tha. Just because uss time Anu Malik ke naam se audio chal jati thi credits mein AR Rahman ki jagah Anu Malik ka naam de diya.
Here in Chennai lots of fans to Anu Malik, 90s hits shown his class. in fact we don't know the Hindi lyrics but his tunes impressed us always. GENTLE MAN movie was remade to Hindi along with songs had recreated, not copied. The reason would be rahmans busy schedule.
@@aparajithanr Brother, 1993 tamil hit GENTLEMAN(original) directed by Shankar. The story rights bought by Allu aravind(producer) and directed by Mahesh Bhatt named the film THE GENTLEMAN(1994). this process called REMAKE. do you say 'the producer stolen a movie? and the director stolen a story?. When the original director and music director are committed into other projects obviously the producer will move to alternate creators to make a same plot(including songs). Usually the copy songs stealing from unknown countries hit, nearby states songs cannot be copied. You know? some older tamil song tunes has been imitated by ARR, we never say he is a copycat. we like that songs and appreciate his furnishing style of old tunes.
@@YogeshKumar-ly8ny I appreciate your attempt but you are comparing apples to oranges again! Producer paid for the story for remaking purposes. It doesn't come with free copyrights for the music as well because the original score has its own copyright. Until & unless, you are able to prove that Anu Malik had actually paid ARR or given credits to ARR on the public media, we must agree that they didn't do the right thing. To your comment about remixing old songs, the credit to the original composer was well-established for years & they enjoyed their credit for decades before ARR was asked to touch it unlike in the case of Gentleman movie, it was done in a sneaky way within a year! If Anu Malik had remixed, it could have been more acceptable instead he simply copied the musical notes 100% as-is. Sorry to say, it's unacceptable!
@@aparajithanr As you said 100%, it so obvious that the entire music had been reused(recreated). Usually the copycats grabs 10-20%, but 100% reusing, doesn't meant a copy. Separate copy rights are probably not followed by early 90s. Still here a debate for seperate copy rights for musicians while they got complete salary for each movies. Simply say, Anu Malik was asked to recreate the original score, so he did. When a producer bought a remake rights, he doesn't like to lose the original music score(especially the original songs got a massive hit. One more thing, no one asked ARR to touch a old tune(he used that tune for first line only, it doesn't comes under remix)
@@YogeshKumar-ly8ny let’s settle on the early 90s there was no proper system in place for musical copyrights. Which song are you talking about the copy?
Hey guys do you know anything about Asoka, which was supposed to be composed by AR Rahman who later got replaced by Anu Malik... the music and Sandeep Chowta's score of Asoka sounds so much ARR style.... Especially the Asoka Theme sounds so much like AR Rahman and still feels great...
I was in high school at that time and was already familiar with composers lifting Ilayaraja's and AR Rahman's tunes right and left. I think it was Nadeem Shravan duo who shamelessly lifted Rajan Nagendra's top notch compositions.
Bollywood hamesha se copy hi karta aya hai .South movies . Hollywood movies..very few originals. Specially during 90s..that's was completely copy paste time. If we had internet then then these so called musicians like annu mallik ko koi bhi puchta nahi..ARR..very respectful and orignal to the core. Love you ARR❤❤❤❤
Actually, Bollywood mein itne gaane bante hain ki originals banana na mumkin hai...movies mein ek aadha OST and BGM hi hona chahiye. .however, movies pattern are changing now.You would not ask more you wouldn't hear lies.
It was common during earlier period for Hindi music director's name appearing and getting full credit for dubbed / remake movies. Nowadays credits are detailed for each song. Earlier some songs composed by assistants have been published under main music directors name. I think this decision was mainly producers not the music directors.
That's why when Rahman started his Bollywood career with Rangeela he completely ruled the industry bagging back to back awards, nobody could come closer
People will know the Quality of Class Music and its still sustaining in Music Industry in both India and all over the World. There is no comparison between Fluke Music & CLASS Music.
Plagiarism Malik has faced criticism for using music written by other composers, for instance in the film The Gentleman where the music of several songs credited to Malik was written by A. R. Rahman,
We all know Anu Malik but dont we know Mahesh Bhatt - Almost everything baring a few are 'Inspired Rip Offs' right from Music, Storylines, Lyrics and even Posters. Am sure he would have asked Anu to ape the tunes 9as they were super hits in Tamil) and Anu gladly obliged.
I don’t think Anu Malik copied these songs intentionally. It is probably just how the movie producer negotiated the deal with the original movie producer.
Annu Mallik was an established Music director and made some good musical numbers,copying ARR music was unethical, it not only made Annu M a copycat it also tarnished his image.
Have you guys heard Dum Laga ke Haisha songs? Check out the composition of Yeh Moh Moh ke daage and compare it with the rest of the songs in the movie. Every other song in that movie has the 90s style typical Anu Malik style including the sounding / instrumentation used. I have my own doubts (almost conclusively) that Moh Moh has been composed by Papon himself but Anu bought or did a deal to credit himself with that song. I have heard Papon sing this in many shows and he truly owns this song (figuratively & perhaps literally) when he sings his heart out.
Hi, as much I remember, I am sure that the credits on the audio cassettes were given to AR Rehman, bro please check the online prints of these cassettes as they may have shown the actual credits
As many people have rightly pointerd out, there was no controversy here. In fact I was glad that Malick tried to replicate what ARR created. I am forever grateful to Malik for showing the world class quality of ARR and his team in sound production and editing. If we didn't have this reference to compare, we would not know how FAR ARR and his team were from the rest of the pack in this time!!
How can you say Anu Malik is not talented in himself. He has given us the best music . They both are highly talented.Only Difference is one is great in producing his own music and one is in stealing it
Actually speaking,.. the entire hindi recordings (from the original ) would have been done and completed by the Record Label or Record Company with experienced Music Assistants, without any music director after getting the music onlyTrack and the Rights from the Tamil Producers. Now, To sell the album, they would require a well known name in the hindi industry,..but at the same time the cassette company (Record Label) would have not interested to promote a New Comer like A R Rahman (at that time )in the North..so the the Record Label would scout for a popular Hindi Music Director with whose NAME (just the name) they can market the HINDI Gentleman movie music in a better way,.ofcourse with a corpose fee..so thats how Any Malik would have been brought into this film...I believe.
Anu malik said inspiration comes from even a babys voice when it cries . True legend . And his owrk is an legendary inspiration of what bollywood music industry is right now.
Anumalik's 'talent can't be challanged.He is creative. Probably, the production house must have insisted on a carbon copy,as new composition changes presentation style.
ARR is 99.99% original. The second song you mentioned is not an ARR original, he used it from a private album by Koti who was ARR's mentor prior to his foray into films. th-cam.com/video/i2TjLUsnCwQ/w-d-xo.html. ARR also used several samples that are freely available for anyone to use. Nevertheless, what he achieved is a sound engineering marvel that now still aim to achieve. IMO his command of western classical and understanding of Indian classical music is quite deep.
Anu Malik's version of these songs sounds like second hand copy of the original. Copying Rahman's stuff is also not easy. Music production and quality on another level.
Ha ha , super.. Second hand copy..
yes 100%, mee too feel the same.. Anu may use the tune but not the qulity
Music was not a copy anu malik didn't took music right of tamil version
@@ArchitArya275 That is why it is called copy.
@@armageddon9241 it's not copy ...It's issue between producer
ARR doesn't not like talking about past... He always stays humble and down to earth nature. He till today doesn't want to talk about his success at all, but always strive to encourage young musician to aim for the skies the limits. Who is the best, he doesn't want to know... But putting Indian music to the top of the world is what's matters most for him.
❤♥️🙏🏻
Nice to say ❤️🙏🙏
Because tamilan da.... 🔥
Anu mallik apme original profile se comment karo😂
I don't think AR RAHMAN is not down to earth.he always think he is God.he never respect Illayaraj sir and never tells the masters he worked at telugu music directors
He has superior attitude problem
Sound quality arr🔥🔥 never fades
H sridhar
Shameless
ARR is an original musician and whatever credits he gets are not important to him. People have passed the verdict and he also has Oscars to his credit after innumerable awards at home. Standing head and shoulders above most others, he is humble and trains youngsters giving breaks to unknown people with skill. His works transcends music and reaches the soul.
ARR isn't an original composer. No one is original composer if you think that way. Rahman lifted countless songs from wastern music and also Indian folk music.
@@pinakiroy1051he is the clostest to original it gets, certainly you or anybody in india isnt close to his originality.
Yes, Arr also walks with his feet on the Earth! Others walk with their feet in the sky! ARRogance is his 2013 BBC interview in which he was boasting FALSELY that before he came, it was all just Dholak, Violin and Flute, just to overproject himself over his greater / humbler seniors! Arr has been ACCUSED of PLAGIARISM / Outsourcing THRICE by his peers (Ismail Darbar, Ouseppachan, and Hindustani musician's family), and he got almost sued by Ouseppachan in 2018! RAM GOPAL VARMA said Slumdog songs were OUTSOURCED! He also said Arr had a rift with Subhash Ghai over the same issue!
ARR is the music composer from 90's still working continuously for the last 34 years
What controversy? There's no controversy here! A shameless Anu Malik lifted A R Rehman's songs lock, stock and barrel!
Anu malik is the best the proof is in pudding. And look at AR idiotic music nobody remembers them. But anu maliks song every common man remembers
@@sanatanihindu7477 Chup Kiddo kuch bhi bolta ha
@@priyanshusinha6541 You fools have brilliant music directors in Hindi like shankar jaikishen, sd burman da, KJ, Ravi, LP etc... yesteryears and Nadeem Shravan, Jatin Lalith, Anu Malik Modern yet you dont value them. But you consider Consider AR music which i consider like artificial Fast Food full of synthesizers etc..... will cause Only constipation😁🤣😂 Just because he have got some Oscar Award people think he is great Music Director. I m not saying allhis compostions are bad.
If you dont understand still Just compare Illayaraja music with AR Rehman.
@@sanatanihindu7477guys don’t go by TH-cam video. I pretty sure AR Rehman might be busy with next project and couldn’t do Hindi remark BGm and recording. Producer might have managed to pay enough money to Anu to do recording work with existing songs. AR Rahman is an artist, producer owns all rights of the song legally. It’s up to them if they want to reuse.
Hope that gives clarity. If a music director want to copy they won’t do in exact same movie remake at exact same spot. It’s just song remake job for Anu just like the director.
@@sanatanihindu7477 I appreciate your love and Respect for Anu Malik, I guess he is the same Music Director who was charged for Se xual harassment against most of the Female Staff Like Alisha Chinnoy. Also Sound Engineer Hardwares Used by Anu Malik are the ones which ARR started Using in 2004. If you are a 50+yr old Fat Jack and listen to songs in a cassette player with no clue of Mixing then I completely agree with Your Choice. Spend some time listening to Tracks which he mastered in 1990s , Its music is as clean as his Character
Whatever dispute between copying issues is human nature. But what’s the end result. Look at Anu Malik n AR.Rehman Level.
It’s simple as that , “The best man wins!
Copy cat is dhuan dhuan wala Raja u know right my indication.
@@rijeshmathewsboth the songs displayed in video composed by A R Rahman is a total bullshit. I Don't know why you people lick his feet so much. A R Rahman is the most overrated composer ever, he is nowhere near Anu Malik.
@@parmadola4993AR Rehman Music is sickening
@@sanatanihindu7477 just sanki thing
@@parmadola4993if those songs were bad, why Anu malik copied it? You mean he has no sense? 😂 Let's admit, the song Anu malik actually composed in this film is a very mediocre one. It just sounds like his other songs.
I'm Sri Lankan and A.R Rehman is my favourite musician ever from my childhood. He is a living God of music .
😂😂😂
AR Rahman is a natural original composer
True gift to the world 🌍❤️
Copycats will remain copycats
AR is a legend ❤️👍🙏
Actually Gentleman movie is originally made in Tamil... dubbed in Telugu and Remade in Hindi.
AR Rehman is Legend but Alu Malik also given masterpiece hits
@@shubhamdhanave8926true
@@upendraprasad5171both the songs displayed in video composed by A R Rahman is a total bullshit. I Don't know why you people lick his feet so much. A R Rahman is the most overrated composer ever, he is nowhere near Anu Malik.
@@shubhamdhanave8926😂😂😂😂😂
Anu malik- good music director(with some copies)
AR rahman- an era representing perfect blend of Indian and western touch.
AR Rahman is an era r u joking?
@@soumalyachatterjee6974Yess he is no music composer close him i don't think you know about best work's of Ar
Bombay, Roja, Alaipayuthey, Jeans, Kadhal, Thiruda Thiruda, vendukondain vendukondain, Minsara kanavu, Dil se, Mudhu, kadhalan, Duet, Gentleman, Jeans, Vinnaithandi varuvaaya, Sillunu oru kadhal, Guru, Ok kamnani And Many More Albums
@@introvert1232 You Are True... But Small Mistake in Album name it's not vendukondain vendukondain, it's Kandukondain Kandukondain...
@@introvert1232both the songs displayed in video composed by A R Rahman is a total bullshit. I Don't know why you people lick his feet so much. A R Rahman is the most overrated composer ever, he is nowhere near Anu Malik.
@@soumalyachatterjee6974 Yes, history will have it as an era of ARR.
just one song "dil hai chota sa" from roja movie's beginning music can eat the whole career of anu malik...
Couldn’t have been said any better, Infact the song actually started playing in my ears the moment you mentioned it, truly the most befitting example, your comment should get 10 million likes !
Kya bakwas kr rahi ho khuch gane anu malik ke bhi jo ar rahman bhi nahi bana skta itna halke me mat anu malik Bollywood ke legend rahe h
@@arifkha1929 still......."dil hai chota sa" from roja movie's beginning music can eat the whole career of anu malik...
AR Rahman is a very average music composer
😂😂😂
He copied the music but cannot the sound quality..... funny
Apart from composition, the sound engineering was way above contemporaries in his songs..He invested in best equipments even before his first film. That quality could not be copied.
Yes exactly and if you have an ear for music you will notice it vividly all the music at those times sounded muddy compared to the clarity of sound engineering that a r rahmans music had.
@@tumbakiranexactly....!!
He KNEW that his tunes will sound abysmal with the usual recording quality! CLEVERNESS.
@@BC999 😂 dekh Bhai music is subjective but when you mentioned the word tunes I understood it's quite difficult for you to appreciate melodies , harmonies and rhythms which doesn't come under your capabilities to understand it .... He's the only composer after Ilayaraja and rd Burman to give us such quality melodies and quality recordings...when you go the extra mile it's not only cleverness but also sincerity and he's not taking you and me i.e. the listeners for granted ...Anu Malik and Nadeem shravan and jatin lalit can only dream of making such songs with grand arrangements, harmonies and such crystal clear rhythms ....it's okay if you don't like his music but to call it mediocre not happening ...this guy can compose gazals , hindustani , carnatic , western classical, pop , edm etc. with equal eaze ...the other composers who are good but can only dream of what arr has achieved....you and I can be fools but berkley and other top universities who have given him doctorate are not ... anyways man I hope you're open to new music which don't fit your regular pattern ....watch gulzars video on ar rahman
@@kalunaga1582 Just because Arr is better than the 90s' crop of Bollywood music directors, it does NOT mean he is in the "top" tier. That doctorate means nothing, just like the Acadummy awards. The same Gulzar said it was DIFFICULT to write for Ilayaraja's tunes! So, Ae Zindagi was COMPOSED FOR Gulzar's lyrics! Moreover, Arr's style of working is a mix of things; sounds, production, sampling, outsourcing, and plagiarizing - all powered by corporate PR team! STOP dropping words like harmonies, rhythms etc. Coming to RDB, he had assistants to arrange. That leaves Ilayaraja whose compositions are 100% his own, with WRITING SCORES for each instrument for 1000+ movies and counting!
Tunes may copy, but the quality can not be recreated as like as the original song.
Even replicating an AR Rahman composition seems not easy for others..
AR REHMAN IS NOT A GENIUS ........... ANU MALIK IS REAL GENIUS......... HE HAS MANY MANY FLAVORS OF WORKING........ ALL ROUDER......... AR REHMAN IS CHEAP AND LIMITED
The truth is Anu malik is running a light music troupe where he stages others music. Calling him a music director was the mistake of bollywood!
both the songs displayed in video composed by A R Rahman is a total bullshit. I Don't know why you people lick his feet so much. A R Rahman is the most overrated composer ever, he is nowhere near Anu Malik.
Sir.. tamana .najayz .Shabnam.janam.beggana.ponam.chahat.badshah.chamtkar.bazziggar.
gentle man(1993) is tamil movie dubbed in telugu in same year .even after 30yrs movie songs trending in dance shows ,realty shows ,tik tok videos .
ARR is great and that is the reason why he made it upto oscar and its sad that bollywood prefer copy paste composer after having a gem like ARR
Arr king of music🥰
😂
AR REHMAN IS NOT A GENIUS ........... ANU MALIK IS REAL GENIUS......... HE HAS MANY MANY FLAVORS OF WORKING........ ALL ROUDER......... AR REHMAN IS CHEAP AND LIMITED
@@POMI_Singing_Guru Anu Malik is not genius. He is cheap copycat and limited. He is a fraud who steals other's hardwork.
AR Rehman is real genius. He has many flavours of working. He makes songs in different genres and styles.
@@joshuaanandroy2903chuthe tho😂😂 arr is legend anu malik is good
I like the thumbnail expression of ARR that's very pure and innocent.. 😍
Its from mersal audio launch when one of the guest said mersal will get Oscar he laughed at it
AR REHMAN IS NOT A GENIUS ........... ANU MALIK IS REAL GENIUS......... HE HAS MANY MANY FLAVORS OF WORKING........ ALL ROUDER......... AR REHMAN IS CHEAP AND LIMITED
If one is a listener of many languages, and have heard Tamil music, you can most of the times identify if the song is originally in Tamil or not. Many Hindi songs were originally made in Tamil and when remade in Hindi, you can still feel the Tamil flavour in it.
AR Rehman songs carry his signature in his creations.Despite being copied,the songs are giving AR Rehman vibes.
😂👍
It's exactly copied bro just language & singers are different
If this is completely true, then it's a shame on Anu Malik. But from comments I see that in the movie they had thanked ARR for using his tunes for 3 songs.. I think that's totally acceptable
Its a remake film. The producer wanted to use copies of the original 3 songs. The producer has the right to do that as he had bought the right to remake the movie. So even those 3 songs were remade.
@@prismaticindia9046 Exactly. People bash here without knowing these details.
Mr . A. R. Rahman Sir Worlds One Of The Best Music Director ..
Rahman Sir's Music Is Truly Original Music ..
Rahman Sir Know All World About Their Great Music ..
They even didn't mentioned the name of music maestro the melody king in Hindi version of saathiya tune kya kiya. It's original song is from Telugu composed by Ilayaraja garu but when you watch the Hindi version it shows Anand-milind as music composer and many films too even in kaadhal psycho (saiyaan psycho) they changed the music director name of Hindi version
Anu Malik can't compose original , that is why he is a Judge in the reality show.
AR REHMAN IS NOT A GENIUS ........... ANU MALIK IS REAL GENIUS......... HE HAS MANY MANY FLAVORS OF WORKING........ ALL ROUDER......... AR REHMAN IS CHEAP AND LIMITED
I dont agree with this. Anu malik never took credit. Because in the titles of the hindi version they mentioned special thanks to a r rehman, for using his composition for 3 songs.
Ar rahaman legend forever... ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Gentlemen music shook india that time..i still remember first time i heard chik buk chik..usula patti...blew my mind...
And so many other amazing music followed for a decade from ARR. those were at a different level.
@@sln7839 exactly countless.
AR Rahman is an enlightened being and I am pretty sure he is least bothered with all this.
AR Enlightenef my foot!!!🤣😂😁🤣
The dance by Prabhu Deva from @1:41 is GOAT...along with the music
It’s a 100 % remake - so they retained the tunes of the original Tamil movie - one because they liked , second they also felt that these songs were a hit & will help in making the Hindi remake also a success - they would have definitely taken the necessary permissions from the source - there was no controversy till now - 😊
Then shouldn't the credits have mentioned arr's name as well??
If this is a case the music credits should have gone to Ar Rahman
@@delugeakrp when a artist sold his songs to movie producer or label the rights goes to label and
its labels decision whether to use it anywhere or sold that composition/song to anyone
@@princesolanki5914 does that mean anyone with money can buy another person's songs and pass it of as their own... Without any mention... Asking because I don't know how this works
@@delugeakrpyes. A r rahman is overrated
No comparison! ARR is the best
Anu malik's sound production & musical harmony sounds absolutely horrendous. Nowadays even cover bands singing in pubs & bistros do a much better job in those departments.
Even in Virasat, paayale Jhunmun jhunmun is the same tune as in Tamil original. But it is still beautiful. And the other songs in the movie are also awesome. Anyways Anu Malik's work in Border, Baazigar, Munna Bhai, Viraasat etc is really special.
The technicalities of the original was far better right from the tempo and the mixing of the songs...you could hear each and every instrument used in the original songs...!!
He couldn't even copy the sound quality 😁
Wrong post. He didn’t copy. Malik got the rights from ARR because the film was a remake
Remake means movie only ...
Music is all about creativity
AR cannot be compared with any composer alive or dead …. All his compositions touch the soul and make us feel emotions that are hidden within … nobody can surpass him in any form .. I still get goosebumps listening to his songs be it any language
Listen to Shankar jaikishan sd rd Burman kalyanji anandji . Ar comes close rarely to them
Abe kaun sa soul no 1 burst music and aam public me kaun sa song h but anu malik ke sare songs truck driver se lekar ..
Nice Joke. 😂😂 both the songs displayed in video composed by A R Rahman is a total bullshit. I Don't know why you people lick his feet so much. A R Rahman is the most overrated composer ever, he is nowhere near Anu Malik.
Ilaiyaraja ❤ only guy I know close to ARR.
@@saravanabalajik not really. Ilaiyaraaja is the greatest Indian music director of all times. Only composer near his level are Hemanta Mukhopadhyay, G. Devarajan, Shankar-Jaikishan, M. S. Viswanathan, K. V. Mahadevan and K. Chakravarthy.
ARR tunes were ahead of that generation. Anu malik's actual song in this movie sounds routine as eating same moong dal kichdi daily.
Its not Anu Malik's fault. Composers took projects on condition that the credits of entire album should go to them...
You can buy rights, not the credits.
@@circuits00 yup but if you sue a producer for credits then you get black listed and then no one wants to work with you...
@@circuits00both the songs displayed in video composed by A R Rahman is a total bullshit. I Don't know why you people lick his feet so much. A R Rahman is the most overrated composer ever, he is nowhere near Anu Malik.
Thank you for the video, I got to know about yet another gem by Rahman sir, I’ve immediately downloaded all the songs :)
Great 👍. Thanks.
The last song u mentioned also sounds like a portion from- How can I go on, by Freddie Mercury.
A R RAHMAN sir has just won his 7th National Film Awards....!!!
It show that his very very far ahead of Anu Mallik.
He composed some original but dir/ producer rubbished it & then they took the easy way out -xeroxed it. Mutlub- Aag aag laga di.
Not only this .
Anu Malik is just following what is seniors did in Bollywood.
For eg .the song from Kalakar Neele neele ambar pe Chand jab .....
Original version was by Ilayaraja in Tamil in the Payanangal mudivathilai .
Actually Producer and Anu Malik had rights for Hindi Gentelman music ...ARR originally composed music
Totally agree with you on not giving credit to ar rehman, should have been given ..but Anu Malik had his own style of music, although some of his music is copied but I still have his tracks on my playlist like judwaa, baazigar,border, main hoon na, refugee, phir teri kahaani and many more..
The actual film was remade in Hindi along with song and dance sequences.. . This is not good to create controversy which never existed
2:28 evenn this song is not original. It is taken from the 1960's Movie Madan Manjri, sungh by Asha Bhonsle and composed by Sardar Malik
Good piece of info.. but the tunes are different.. 😊
It was an official Hindi remake of the Tamil film. The producers of the Hindi movie had officially bought the copyrights from the Tamil movie. So 3 original compositions from Tamil version were re-used without any change in tune or instrumentation for Hindi version. There was a note thanking A.R. Rahaman in the opening credits in Hindi.
1
If ARR was thanked then why the credit for those songs given to Anu Malik. And if his songs are used in movie then why Anu Malik getting such project it is utter waste of money.
11001q1
Whenever you show a song, you should silence the background music of your video (in this case the piano). It sounds completely out of tune and chaotic. Just a suggestion.
Original composer Rahman sir all time
Its the mistake of Makers. Woh hindi Versions bhi AR Rahman ne hi banaye the aur sirf woh last wala song Anu Malik ne banaya tha. Just because uss time Anu Malik ke naam se audio chal jati thi credits mein AR Rahman ki jagah Anu Malik ka naam de diya.
Arr composition sounds really clean
Malik! Good try lol
Here in Chennai lots of fans to Anu Malik, 90s hits shown his class. in fact we don't know the Hindi lyrics but his tunes impressed us always.
GENTLE MAN movie was remade to Hindi along with songs had recreated, not copied.
The reason would be rahmans busy schedule.
If someone is too busy, how is it okay to steal their work? Please avoid writing comments which are fundamentally wrong!
@@aparajithanr
Brother, 1993 tamil hit GENTLEMAN(original) directed by Shankar. The story rights bought by Allu aravind(producer) and directed by Mahesh Bhatt named the film THE GENTLEMAN(1994).
this process called REMAKE.
do you say 'the producer stolen a movie? and the director stolen a story?.
When the original director and music director are committed into other projects obviously the producer will move to alternate creators to make a same plot(including songs).
Usually the copy songs stealing from unknown countries hit, nearby states songs cannot be copied.
You know? some older tamil song tunes has been imitated by ARR, we never say he is a copycat. we like that songs and appreciate his furnishing style of old tunes.
@@YogeshKumar-ly8ny I appreciate your attempt but you are comparing apples to oranges again! Producer paid for the story for remaking purposes. It doesn't come with free copyrights for the music as well because the original score has its own copyright. Until & unless, you are able to prove that Anu Malik had actually paid ARR or given credits to ARR on the public media, we must agree that they didn't do the right thing. To your comment about remixing old songs, the credit to the original composer was well-established for years & they enjoyed their credit for decades before ARR was asked to touch it unlike in the case of Gentleman movie, it was done in a sneaky way within a year! If Anu Malik had remixed, it could have been more acceptable instead he simply copied the musical notes 100% as-is. Sorry to say, it's unacceptable!
@@aparajithanr
As you said 100%, it so obvious that the entire music had been reused(recreated).
Usually the copycats grabs 10-20%, but 100% reusing, doesn't meant a copy.
Separate copy rights are probably not followed by early 90s. Still here a debate for seperate copy rights for musicians while they got complete salary for each movies.
Simply say, Anu Malik was asked to recreate the original score, so he did.
When a producer bought a remake rights, he doesn't like to lose the original music score(especially the original songs got a massive hit.
One more thing, no one asked ARR to touch a old tune(he used that tune for first line only, it doesn't comes under remix)
@@YogeshKumar-ly8ny let’s settle on the early 90s there was no proper system in place for musical copyrights.
Which song are you talking about the copy?
Chiranjeeve, and Nagarjuna introduced me to Telugu industry as I watched their Hindi films.as a child.
Hey guys do you know anything about Asoka, which was supposed to be composed by AR Rahman who later got replaced by Anu Malik... the music and Sandeep Chowta's score of Asoka sounds so much ARR style....
Especially the Asoka Theme sounds so much like AR Rahman and still feels great...
I was in high school at that time and was already familiar with composers lifting Ilayaraja's and AR Rahman's tunes right and left.
I think it was Nadeem Shravan duo who shamelessly lifted Rajan Nagendra's top notch compositions.
Bollywood hamesha se copy hi karta aya hai .South movies . Hollywood movies..very few originals. Specially during 90s..that's was completely copy paste time. If we had internet then then these so called musicians like annu mallik ko koi bhi puchta nahi..ARR..very respectful and orignal to the core. Love you ARR❤❤❤❤
Anu Malik good his classic songs but other songs he always copy.. But there songs it's I stored a r rahman songs in my laptop rather Anu Malik songs
Actually, Bollywood mein itne gaane bante hain ki originals banana na mumkin hai...movies mein ek aadha OST and BGM hi hona chahiye. .however, movies pattern are changing now.You would not ask more you wouldn't hear lies.
It makes you wonder how many other lesser known singers he has stolen credit from over the years.
It was common during earlier period for Hindi music director's name appearing and getting full credit for dubbed / remake movies.
Nowadays credits are detailed for each song.
Earlier some songs composed by assistants have been published under main music directors name. I think this decision was mainly producers not the music directors.
I feel anu malik copied obviously...no doubt
That's why when Rahman started his Bollywood career with Rangeela he completely ruled the industry bagging back to back awards, nobody could come closer
Different is sound is clean and soulful
Anu Malik's original last song in this video is good to listen..but it is bad for him copyright other songs
People will know the Quality of Class Music and its still sustaining in Music Industry in both India and all over the World. There is no comparison between Fluke Music & CLASS Music.
Plagiarism
Malik has faced criticism for using music written by other composers, for instance in the film The Gentleman where the music of several songs credited to Malik was written by A. R. Rahman,
What else's do u expect from billywood
ar rahman is another level anyone can say tht anumalok was copied his songs bcoz rahman sir is a lehend he created mile stones in music industry 👍🏻
0:58 I think that beat was created by Raj-Koti. ARR used to work under them when ARR was very young.
The first songs rhythm actually stands out in original version , there is no definition in the recreated version
Never ever mess up with "South Indian Musicians" we have our own signature in every music track. cannot be reproduced without master copy...!
Keep ur AR music with urself. Good to relieve constipation😁😁😂🤣
""Hum Apne Gham Ko Sajakar Bahar Kar Lenge,,, 👌👌👌👌👍👍😌😌
It's not just Ar rehman musical, it's tamil's magical lyrics too.
We all know Anu Malik but dont we know Mahesh Bhatt - Almost everything baring a few are 'Inspired Rip Offs' right from Music, Storylines, Lyrics and even Posters. Am sure he would have asked Anu to ape the tunes 9as they were super hits in Tamil) and Anu gladly obliged.
Totaly song... AR rahmaan 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
I don’t think Anu Malik copied these songs intentionally. It is probably just how the movie producer negotiated the deal with the original movie producer.
Annu Mallik was an established Music director and made some good musical numbers,copying ARR music was unethical, it not only made Annu M a copycat it also tarnished his image.
Have you guys heard Dum Laga ke Haisha songs? Check out the composition of Yeh Moh Moh ke daage and compare it with the rest of the songs in the movie. Every other song in that movie has the 90s style typical Anu Malik style including the sounding / instrumentation used. I have my own doubts (almost conclusively) that Moh Moh has been composed by Papon himself but Anu bought or did a deal to credit himself with that song. I have heard Papon sing this in many shows and he truly owns this song (figuratively & perhaps literally) when he sings his heart out.
But i have seen recording where papon is rehearsing for the song and Anu Malik is giving directions.
Its director/producer's demand...
Music composer is not guilty.
Hi, as much I remember, I am sure that the credits on the audio cassettes were given to AR Rehman, bro please check the online prints of these cassettes as they may have shown the actual credits
As many people have rightly pointerd out, there was no controversy here.
In fact I was glad that Malick tried to replicate what ARR created. I am forever grateful to Malik for showing the world class quality of ARR and his team in sound production and editing. If we didn't have this reference to compare, we would not know how FAR ARR and his team were from the rest of the pack in this time!!
How can you say Anu Malik is not talented in himself. He has given us the best music . They both are highly talented.Only Difference is one is great in producing his own music and one is in stealing it
Tamil gentleman came first later remade in hindi with chiranjivi ,
Also the song from Suhag - tere liye jana highly inspired by Roja
ARR is a legend
The total audio outputs of rehman all the frequencies pitch variation ... Annu Malick lacks in the copied songs
Anu Malik copied no doubt....
Actually speaking,.. the entire hindi recordings (from the original ) would have been done and completed by the Record Label or Record Company with experienced Music Assistants, without any music director after getting the music onlyTrack and the Rights from the Tamil Producers.
Now, To sell the album, they would require a well known name in the hindi industry,..but at the same time the cassette company (Record Label) would have not interested to promote a New Comer like A R Rahman (at that time )in the North..so the the Record Label would scout for a popular Hindi Music Director with whose NAME (just the name) they can market the HINDI Gentleman movie music in a better way,.ofcourse with a corpose fee..so thats how Any Malik would have been brought into this film...I believe.
i dont know if any one noticed but AR Rahumans sounding is still fresh and high in quality😍
Anu malik said inspiration comes from even a babys voice when it cries . True legend . And his owrk is an legendary inspiration of what bollywood music industry is right now.
Anumalik's 'talent can't be challanged.He is creative. Probably, the production house must have insisted on a carbon copy,as new composition changes presentation style.
Hum apne ghum ko ...was really good one
kya faltu ka background music lagaya hai video me
Anu maliks good music director.. it's all doesn't matter over yah.. we can't assume that situation. Support From tamil nadu..
ARR is 99.99% original. The second song you mentioned is not an ARR original, he used it from a private album by Koti who was ARR's mentor prior to his foray into films. th-cam.com/video/i2TjLUsnCwQ/w-d-xo.html. ARR also used several samples that are freely available for anyone to use. Nevertheless, what he achieved is a sound engineering marvel that now still aim to achieve. IMO his command of western classical and understanding of Indian classical music is quite deep.
Thumbs up!
Arr was the one who is behind the arrangements of the song 😊
@@tejavenkatareddypadala7214 He could have been the one who composed it too but never got the credit for it....
Nadeem-shravan one of the best Music Composer