*Does 'Smartwater' have better memory than basic water and if you shout insults at it, will it have a witty comeback? Does it silently judge you for your social indiscretions? Is 'smartwater' a smug jerk? Is it "Smugwater?"*
Dude "smart water" is just water with minerals and electrolytes added to it that is suppose to make you "smarter" by drinking it. its questionable Marketting at its finest because you can get the same water for free instead of paying three dollars a bottle for it
Above and beyond that, the homeopathic 'active ingredient' isn't even real medication. It's usually something even dumber, like a landing wheel from a 747, shaken in water.
I was literally about to come in the comments to post about the dangers of homeopathy l, but what I can do is say go look up homeopathy on "In a Nutshell" or another science youtube channel, they go into detail of what they believe and why and why its absurd and dangerous.
he had the best memory he is made out of snow that is also water, he just told them all of the details of the story which back ups his fact that water has memory.
I got really scared when Matpat started quoting the original water memory study, that he was gonna claim that water does indeed have memory. I was very relieved when he kept going😂
me too, and the moment the study said that the water came from different sources, i was downright angry on how stupid the idea was. The dude in the study really failed 7th grade science
My alarm bells immediately went off when I heard that the siren call was based on the Dies Irae. If there is one thing I learned from Sideways it is that Dies Irae = Death. And (SPOILER) Elsa technically dies in the movie. And I think after the moment she 'died' you don't hear that call anymore. I legitimately am blown away.
Well dies irae means Day of Wrath and is about Judgement Day. You could argue that it could relate to this "A past wrong has to be made right", basically meaning that someone has to redeem the sins of the past. So basically the voice is calling Elsa to bring justice (which is the reason maybe why the call stopped. Not because Elsa died but because she found out the truth and brought Justice)
Mrs. T the way she sings it, yes, but the notes in particular are the dies irae which was never used for herding calls. There was also usually more variations in the notes
This one hits close to home. Ever since I watched that movie with my mom, she has completely believed that fact. Even tho, right after the movie I told her that I was coincidentally reading about it not a long time ago and that it was disproved many times. And I was really furious because they were pushing that message as a fact. Every since then she spreads the lie to everyone she knows and buys extremely expensive water because of it.
If it helps... Frozen is very clearly a fantasy movie. Just because some things that are true in real life are true in their world, that doesn't mean that everything that's true there is also true here. It's probably not great to believe everything a sentient snowman says...
@@terryfuldsgaming7995 oh,and believing that the universe exploded and everything formed is plausible? Ok. Because it totally makes sense that everything scientists tell you is real. I would like one to show me the universe explode into existence or show me an actual atom. Don’t try to use the old “show me God” trick,it doesn’t work.🙄 People automatically take God to have magical powers but nobody actually just thinks maybe he’s the one who wrote the law of science.
I had a friend with legitimate medical concerns for her children. She was convinced homeopathy (the idea that one particle of substance per biillion particles of water is effective medicine because water has a "memory") was how to treat her kids. Her kids didn't die and that convinced her that this philosophy is good medicine, so now she travels the US selling essentially water to people with legitimate health concerns. If they die, they did something wrong. If they live she is their savior. What we are talking about here is homeopathy and it is dangerous because people forego legitimate healthcare for distilled water.
@@Rocio.Suarez I think you're confusing homeopathy with naturopathy. homeopathy uses minute amounts of poisons (often untraceable) in usually either water or sugar to attempt to cure symptoms of disease.
When I heard the line, "Water has memory" I jokingly remarked, "Oh great, Olaf is a homeopath." In homeopathy, it's believed that diulting a chemical in the water, and agitating it, and then diluting it again, etc. makes the chemical stronger, because the water "remembers" the chemical that it held. I really thought that you were going to talk about the dangers of homeopathy and "alternative medicines"
Yes, exactly. The problem is not only that some random teenager runs around with this "funfact", but that this teenager grows up to be an adult fully believing in homeopathy and nobody will be able to tell them otherwise, since they have known this "fact" for so long.
@@itwasntme967 Just like any other Mandela effect... the Berenstein Bears were never a thing, neither was Smokey THE Bear, the Looney Toons are actually the Looney Tunes, and always have been, Nelson Mandela wasn't dead even though people thought he was (although he is now), and no, water doesn't actually remember anything.
It definitely gets downplayed but hats off to your editor. It's amazing how Every second of your videos are so full of energy and life and it's only accentuated by the editing
I always assumed the “water has memory” thing just comes from the fact that water is just so old and has been around since the beginning of life because of the water cycle. And they just extended that idea like any writer has when brainstorming and went “bUt WhAt iF wAtEr ReMeMbErS tHe PlAcEs iTs bEeN aNd ThInGs iTs SeEn”. Then made that a movie😂
Well, to contrast what you mention at the end, teaching children that water has memory could lead them to be more susceptible to alternative therapies, such as homeopathy; an alternative therapy specifically being based around this idea of dilution and water memory. Furthering what you mentioned, it teaches children to ignore the skeptics and just believe, a thought process quite at odds with critical thinking.
Ever think you are looking 2 far into it considing the story is based on ice and its telling the story through water and ice telling the history thro water it is completely fictional do you belive there are water filled horse controlling the sea or a fire salamander why do people nitpic when it's the theme how to the logic it all thro ice image memory's in the cave
And it’s not necessarily bad to use homeopathy, there are mental benefits and the sort, but it isn’t an alternative to modern medicine. Mediaeval medicine, for sure, that crap was just chopping limbs off and hurting people, something homeopathy didn’t do. Ancient medicine was doing bad, Vs homeopathy simply doing nothing, while now modern medicine DOES have good effects
@@Wooporexcept SOMETHIMES vaccines because doctors are basically saying "this MIGHT work but, we don't know ... anyway can you give us thousands of dollars for this vaccine."
The song Elsa hears is based off the Swedish/Scandinavian herding call tradition of 'kulning'. It's quite beautiful, high pitched, and is used to call cattle (though it works for other animals too, including humans, for certain strains) and also for communication since the high notes can travel further than low notes and ordinary speech. Jonna Jinton does some beautiful incantations of it!
Another cool thing about James Randi: He used to open almost every lecture by disproving the "water has memory" idea by downing an obscene level of homeopathic caffeine pills.
Given that “water has memory” is the central basis for the branch of homeopathy that tells people not to take prescribed medication, because you can instead just drink water that remembers what the medication is like... I think it could be a pretty dangerous thing to teach kids is real.
See, I interpreted "some people dispute it, but it's true" as Disney saying "this is bullshit, but it's integral to our plot, so get all the way off of my back about this."
I think it’s more thematic. Like in Tangled the series, the story catalyst is an environmental disaster caused by unfulfillment. Rapunzel is bored, Elsa wants a gf and Cass feels consumerism is the only way she can assert herself. And water having memory is more about the effects of those desires on the natural world. That’s what Moana confronting Te Fiti is about too.
Water: *has memory* Also water: *it's like dory's memory* Every aquatic creature has dory syndrome. But the real question is, what is Mantis's muscle density and mass in Kung Fu Panda?
0:26 - I just looked it up, and the intro to "When will my life begin" literally sounds like a more cheery, showtune-ish, major-ish version of the guitar in the beginning of "Pinball Wizard", like, wtf. How did I not notice that? I was exposed to 70s Rock my entire life, I should've immediately recognized the tune when watching the movie!
Water does have memory. Matt clearly does state that but also states exactly how quickly water loses those memories which make that memory practically useless.
I assumed everything Olaf said was untrue to begin. I assumed the “facts” were simply joking about the spread of false facts. I’m surprised that most of his facts were seen as true in this video.
I'm pretty sure when when Olaf says "it's disputed by many but it's true" he's talking about the people in the Frozen universe. He's trying to establish a sort of believable explanation for Elsa's power, but there will always be people who doubt things. Before Elsa's escape from the castle, I highly doubt anyone even knew magical powers like that are possible. Plus, even to this day we have science deniers, so it's highly likely that the in movie universe could have deniers, or just people who never seen any proof and doubting it
@@neofelisnebulosa3871 not really it does not say any thing about homeopathy or medication or treatment so how it's spreading false information regarding homeopathy it's bull I never once took it as factual or compared the 2 next ull ban Peter pan gor implying that children can fly or that toys are alive when your not looking as they slay let it go
The whole “water has memory” thing *is* dangerous. Some people take it to the extreme and believe that having 0.0000000000001% of some essential oil in a glass of water and drinking it is the same as taking actual medication.
Even as someone who has greatly benefited from "alternative" treatments, I know just how dangerous it is to believe half the stuff that comes from these people. With no real regulatory body, there's a lot of quack doctors, or even just deluded people thinking they have the cure to everything.
Hey Matpat, I'm actually an artist and now I'm actually inspired to draw elsa in a shining atmosphere with an ice castle,. Like that scene where he's hacking the door with the axe, just an ice castle, and elsa and olaf. I'd even send you the finished product of it if you'd like. It sounds like a fun drawing.
I’m really glad you emphasized the importance of the ‘replication and verification’ step of scientific discovery, because in today’s world, where all the news and general public seem to care about is next big discovery, this step is constantly undervalued and often straight up ignored. Which, like you said in the video, could have some serious consequences in the future.
Max Schwartz Not only undervalued but also underfunded. Not only does nobody really want to be the guy who discovered a thing the second time, but they're also aren't enough resources available to verify every discovery. So you have to prioritize and leave some findings unverified.
Teacher: why are you giving me a glass of water? Student: Well you see, my homework got destroyed by water, and then I remembered that water has memory so I gave you the water.
myhtical memory tier list: D Tier - *Fire* (doesn't even remeber the last thing it ate, before moving to the next one) C Tier - *Water* (as we've seen with the video, it "has" memory, it only last less than a trillionth of a second) B Tier - *Air* (cuz loud words and noises, can echo for more than a couple of seconds) A Tier - *Earth* (YOU CAN LITERALLY ETCH AND SKETCH STUFF ON IT, AND IT WILL TAKE FOREVER FOR IT TO BE ERASED!)
Matpat someone could argue that water does actually does have memory in the form of ice cores. That's what I thought the twist at the end was going to be. I'm curious to see what people think.
Sam H I was actually thinking of the (polerized?) property of water when I first heard it. Basically water is sticky. It sticks to itself and can retain its shape (for a few seconds). This is also what causes little droplets of water. I’m probably not the best to explain this.
Ice cores are more like a recording than a living memory though I can see the comparison. But saying ice/water have memory in that regard is like saying a map has a sense of direction, kinda right but not quite
Yes I actually thougt of the same thing. I mean its not tecnical a real memory but I think ist enough for a Disney movie. I actually heard scientists call ice at the northpole "memory of the earth", also in the Film the memory is only shown in the form of ice.
In all honesty I believe it depends on what you would consider to be a waters “memory.” For example, glaciers preserve a lot of substances. The substances and thickness of ice layers can help indicate the conditions that certain time periods would have possessed. This includes the climate, greenhouse gas and oxygen levels, as well as in some cases preserved specimen ( like Ötzi the Iceman).
Matt doesn't mention that Olaf is literally made of water and is capable of remembering things. Like I'm not saying water has memory, I'm just saying...THAT water has memory.
Scientific method: Replication and Verification eh... Life coming from non life is what Darwin teaches. Can this be replicated or verified in a lab? Nope, therefore it's not science.
4:40 "Did you know we blink 4 million times a day?" ... "Not even close!" I think Olaf researched all scientific facts by himself and just counted during a polar day on the north/south pole (edit: which lasts half a year), which would be pretty accurate. (Edit2: ... and "water has memory" is what fpr example makes him able to learn, so in that movie world that should be also true.)
For the second part, I agree it works, but only in the movie world. The problem is that there are people stupid enough to not understand that, and they’ll go “hey guys water has memory”. This is basically the exact same way ani-vaxers, flat earthers, etc. get their information, and that is terrifying.
if you disagree with matpat, please watch something else or else don't make criticism about his methods, because, in every theory he does, he treats it like the real world. #comeatmebro
@@stanfoutz2134 Please tell me a moment where he actually criticized MatPat. He didn't. He just stated his thoughts and there is nothing wrong with that, unlike what your dumbass has to say.
Pillager 6666 Dude, Matpat actively encourages us to disagree and challenge him. That's like the whole point of this video is not to trust people to just give you facts. Granted, he's right in this video but still.
Yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeesss as a child who was raised by parents who made me and my brother watch/listen to movies and songs they watched/listened to when they were kids and teenagers, I would very much enjoy that
MatPat: Tell any kids who are watching Frozen 2 about the scientific method & replication standards Me to my little sister when she is watching Frozen 2: Alright. Water has memory, but it only holds that memory for a femtosecond so DON'T go around saying water carries memory about you drinking it, okay?
My 8th grade English teacher used that "water has feelings" study as "scientific" reason for us to be nice to each other instead of just using actual studies on the effects of bullying I guess and as a fan of heavy metal I always questioned that study because rock fans are usually very nice so now I'm happy to know it was complete crap science
5:15 I have a theory on how they could have gotten to that number: a blink of an eye can be either how often you blink with your eyelids, or how long the eye takes in light for a single "frame" moving about 24 times per second and refreshing parts of your vision in memory. I you go by the latter definition and extrapolate from seconds in a day, you would get roughly the right number
Here’s a thought: water is a magical element and while it doesn’t remember physical attributes in real life it can remember metaphysical/magical attributes in a magical forest where the magic stems partially from the flow of a river
"Water has memory" is actually a particularly dangerous "Fact" as it's the basis of homeopathy. This is extra problematic when you consider that, with a company the size of Disney there is no way everyone involved in making this line happen didn't know about this.
Which part is the joke? This particular video or Frozen 2 including this theme? I’m not 100% sure which part of me commenting on this you think is me taking it too seriously.
I feel like one day we are gonna have a theory were matpat just lists up everything that Disney has copied.. And then he gets... COPYRIGHTED ohhhh the horror!!!!!😱😱😱
*I NEED TO CLIP TO THE TOP COMMENT TO SAY THIS, HE REALLLYY WANTS THAT WATCHTIME MONEY SINCE IT TOOK HIM 6 MINUTES ALMOST HALF THE VIDEO TO GET TO THE POINT* wow matpat
Plot twist: Olaf is trying to trick kids into staying hydrated. Drop your homework onto the water then drink it. You'll remember everything! You can also put the dictionary into water and drink it-
Is no one gonna comment on the fact Cinema Sins, HISHE, and MatPat all released frozen 2 vids within like 3 hours of each other? No? Okay I'll show myself to the door...
Wasn't there an alternative """""medicine""""" that was all about the water's memory? Like they dillude something in water, then dillude that dillution and do it again over and over until you have a literal nothing of the initial substance and say that will make you healthier?
@@OtakuJuanma2 the fact you said literally just blew your cover, beyond that, if you knew chemistry Its history... Health and the bigger games being played you wouldn't be so quick to quiet someone and bring nothing to the table. But ill leave you to your literal pill production.
@@trenaeturane976 homeopathic 'remedies' largely rely on taking a 'cure' (and I say this very loosely, because their idea of cure is a little odd to begin with) and watering it down again and again and again. Then, they sell the product as a very pricey 'remedy', which, by the time it gets to shelves, has less than one 1000th of what the original stuff in it was. Because people fall so badly for it, though, they don't seek proper medical attention. The way supporters say it's supposed to be that the water remembers what it originally had, so it works. This particular practice dates back to when bloodletting was a thing, so leaving ones body to get rid of bad stuff was always going to work out better than draining the evil red stuff in your veins, but now, it's dangerous misinformation.
@@trenaeturane976 Water having memory is used as a marketing ploy in homeopathy. Homeopathic practitioners claim that you can dilute medications in water to stretch their usage with the same efficacy as the pre diluted medication because the water remembers being the medication.
This also works in hand with Big Lie Theory. Keep repeating the same lie over and over and eventually someone will believe it to be true. More and more will slowly start to believe the lie, even if all they are doing is throwing their hands up and saying "Fine, whatever, just shutup about it already"
If it wasn't put in a list of scientific sounding facts, and tell people to ignore people who say it isn't true it wouldn't be as bad. It would also be better if they didn't mimic the language of homeopathy. Say if instead of the words water and memory it was the elements of nature remember what they have seen. It means something similar but isn't taking lines from homeopathy and sounds more mystical.
thought he was going to lead into that but then said that it wasnt going to do anyone harm... placebo is not an effective way of curing diseases like corona lmao
The little mermaid’s “part of your world” bears a striking resemblance to Little Shop of Horrors’ “somewhere that’s green”. That could have more to do with the two songs having the same composer, but it’s something I noticed.
@@terryfuldsgaming7995 No, Jason Voorhees isn't made of water or is a mermaid - he's just heavily associated with water like the other characters I mentioned
Discovered this new channel, not regretting at all. It's awesome plus I love all the jokes he makes. Addicted to these videos now. Watch about 5 or 6 a day.
Someone who is not an asshole PERIOD. - I just asked. It said “no”. Then again a voice under the bed said the same thing when I asked if there were any monsters hiding under the bed last week, yet every morning I keep losing socks overnight! :-/
I could be wrong but I think it’s also in some motifs in The Nightmare Before Christmas. Either in This is Halloween or Making Christmas, more likely the latter, and maybe also the little theme that plays when Sally picks the flower.
"I don't think anyone believing that water has memory is going to do them any harm". This is literally the basis of homeopathy, an industry that makes money by convincing you not to seek proper medical help
Thank you, I was so shocked when he said that and didn't once address homeopathy when it is actually very much dangerous... Pseudoscience like believing stuff diluted to nonexistential concentrations cures cancer most definitely gets people, even innocent kids of very ignorant and gullible parents, killed.
Watching this with my 8 year old daughter and she says “am I getting a history lesson or learning about frozen?” both my dear, welcome to FiLm ThEoRy 😛
Actually, the four chords used in into the unknown as well as shining isn't something the two just happen to have in common. They are used all across cinematography in soundrecks in moments associated with death. The four chords play when Luke finds his home farm destroyed for example. In Frozen they are an indicator of Atohalan's connection to the past and by extention a whole lot of death.
I’m glad I’m not the only one who was bothered by the “water has memory” thing. Not only is it listed as a scientific fact alongside things that are actually true, it’s part of the main theme of the movie, meaning it gets repeated more than the actually true facts.
And there's also homeopathy a pseudoscience that says diluted medicine is as effective as actual medicine so people take that stuff instead and die of treatable diseases
Tbh when I saw Olaf in frozen 1 I loved him. His an adorable character, he is sweet, his like a new born baby, his ambition to find summer was so cute and I’ve realized that I was around 7 or 8 years old that time, I thought he was an innocent character, his character didn’t feel deep, and I loved him. When I saw Olaf in frozen 2........ I still loved him but I feel him at the same time. He changed into that kid that became very curious about life and every matter that surrounds him. He began to “grow up” and loses sanity as he asks more questions about anything and everything, heck he’ll even listen to conspiracies and uncle mattpat’s theories, other than that he even sang a song about it(when I am older). And tbh I was 12 the age of curiosity and awareness when I watched the second movie. I guess I’m saying that they were aiming for viewers whose watched the 1st movie(those were intended to be children younger than 9) then growing a bit older with the characters as we see them again with more maturity. I’m not sure what the main lesson in frozen was, like was it meant to be about always sticking with your loved ones and don’t take them for granted or something, but I’m guessing that if Frozen was from a book, there wouldn’t canonically be a talking snowman.. Olaf’s story is just teaching us a side lesson about growing up and that some things just won’t stay the same. Even if Anna sings some things never change, it wouldn’t feel as deep as Olaf’s jokes
I mean some people believe that diluted medicine is as effective as actual medicine and take that instead of actual medicine to then die of a treatable illness
@@myrmesuwu607 just finished watching all of it... It's only 50 minutes, and if nothing else it has a long interview with the team leader of the team that discovered the HIV virus, which is cool. Academic input is far better than some guy/girl with a crystal ball yelling at water as I'm sure you would agree 😆😆😆
My first thought walking out of the theater: "Is Disney trying to promote homeopathy with this film?" Glad to see someone else picked up on the problematic nature of pushing "water has memory" as a scientific fact.
It’s the dies irae is an audible effect used to signify something bad happen(death) . So yeah, having it in jack skeleton’s song is just because he is dead
Mrs. T but the tones here are specifically the dires irae, and traditionally the tone variations are faster and higher. th-cam.com/video/eUwiOdXY4ic/w-d-xo.html is an example of traditional hoarding call or “lokk” as we call it in Norwegian. The dies irae is made to be eerie as it is essentially about doomsday and death
*Does 'Smartwater' have better memory than basic water and if you shout insults at it, will it have a witty comeback? Does it silently judge you for your social indiscretions? Is 'smartwater' a smug jerk? Is it "Smugwater?"*
A combfent or a comment
Just report the idiot and his video maybe he gets a strike
Yes
I can hear the vine
Dude "smart water" is just water with minerals and electrolytes added to it that is suppose to make you "smarter" by drinking it. its questionable Marketting at its finest because you can get the same water for free instead of paying three dollars a bottle for it
"People thinking water has memory isn't going to hurt them"
Wait is that actually a thing?
@@aisyahshukor2492 homeopathy my dude the fucking dumbest thing since the square wheel
Above and beyond that, the homeopathic 'active ingredient' isn't even real medication. It's usually something even dumber, like a landing wheel from a 747, shaken in water.
I was literally about to come in the comments to post about the dangers of homeopathy l, but what I can do is say go look up homeopathy on "In a Nutshell" or another science youtube channel, they go into detail of what they believe and why and why its absurd and dangerous.
You ever hear about the homeopathist that drank distilled water? Dude died of an overdose!
MatPat: talks about the most iconic part of the movie
Doesn't mention the scene when Olaf acted out the first movie
Or the "Samantha?" scene
he had the best memory he is made out of snow that is also water, he just told them all of the details of the story which back ups his fact that water has memory.
I loved that so much!
"At least we still have our parents!"
*Stands in corner* "The parents *died*
RIGHTT!!!!
Omar Abuokada that is what I thought he was talking about at first lol
I got really scared when Matpat started quoting the original water memory study, that he was gonna claim that water does indeed have memory. I was very relieved when he kept going😂
me too, and the moment the study said that the water came from different sources, i was downright angry on how stupid the idea was. The dude in the study really failed 7th grade science
Same, same!
My alarm bells immediately went off when I heard that the siren call was based on the Dies Irae. If there is one thing I learned from Sideways it is that Dies Irae = Death. And (SPOILER) Elsa technically dies in the movie. And I think after the moment she 'died' you don't hear that call anymore. I legitimately am blown away.
H O M E yes!! Sideaways thought me about the dies irae aswell!! And ever since I keep hearing it in every movie I watch!
Well dies irae means Day of Wrath and is about Judgement Day. You could argue that it could relate to this "A past wrong has to be made right", basically meaning that someone has to redeem the sins of the past. So basically the voice is calling Elsa to bring justice (which is the reason maybe why the call stopped. Not because Elsa died but because she found out the truth and brought Justice)
Mrs. T It's their mum 😳
Mrs. T the way she sings it, yes, but the notes in particular are the dies irae which was never used for herding calls. There was also usually more variations in the notes
Mrs. T th-cam.com/video/eUwiOdXY4ic/w-d-xo.html this is an example of traditional hoarding call, or “Lokk” as we call it in Norwegian.
This one hits close to home. Ever since I watched that movie with my mom, she has completely believed that fact. Even tho, right after the movie I told her that I was coincidentally reading about it not a long time ago and that it was disproved many times. And I was really furious because they were pushing that message as a fact. Every since then she spreads the lie to everyone she knows and buys extremely expensive water because of it.
If it helps... Frozen is very clearly a fantasy movie. Just because some things that are true in real life are true in their world, that doesn't mean that everything that's true there is also true here. It's probably not great to believe everything a sentient snowman says...
No offense to you (plenty of offense to your mom though), but your mom's an idiot.
Bruhhhhhh
@@terryfuldsgaming7995 This might sound weird, but I'm actually a Christian-
@@terryfuldsgaming7995 oh,and believing that the universe exploded and everything formed is plausible? Ok. Because it totally makes sense that everything scientists tell you is real. I would like one to show me the universe explode into existence or show me an actual atom. Don’t try to use the old “show me God” trick,it doesn’t work.🙄
People automatically take God to have magical powers but nobody actually just thinks maybe he’s the one who wrote the law of science.
“Water has feelings”
Me: *stops mid drink*
Imagine the water crying because you're drinking it... Infinite water
Your pfp really fits this comment,,
@@mae5167 *hits blunt*
@@YoungAlienBoy do you are have stupid?
"It's unpleasantly like being drunk." "What's wrong with being drunk?" "Ask a glass of water."
I had a friend with legitimate medical concerns for her children. She was convinced homeopathy (the idea that one particle of substance per biillion particles of water is effective medicine because water has a "memory") was how to treat her kids. Her kids didn't die and that convinced her that this philosophy is good medicine, so now she travels the US selling essentially water to people with legitimate health concerns. If they die, they did something wrong. If they live she is their savior. What we are talking about here is homeopathy and it is dangerous because people forego legitimate healthcare for distilled water.
Your friend needs to be taught that science is a thing that exists
@@calebfarmer176 don't you know science is controlled by the illuminati and big pharma!
@@junkmalme Ikr LOL 🤣
That is not homeopaty that is water therapy! Homeopat mds cure a síntom with the similar meds for that sintom. Your friend is crazy
@@Rocio.Suarez I think you're confusing homeopathy with naturopathy. homeopathy uses minute amounts of poisons (often untraceable) in usually either water or sugar to attempt to cure symptoms of disease.
Me: Drinks water
Water: Starts to cry from pain
Also me: Why is there more water in my drink?
That's a nice life-hack. You should tell it to all the countries which suffer from drought.
@@YoungAlienBoy ??????
@@YoungAlienBoy stfu
@@YoungAlienBoy Milk
@@YoungAlienBoy Go away
My therapist: Axe-murdering Olaf isn’t real, he can’t hurt you
Axe-murdering Olaf:
Hereeeeeeees Olaf!
Me if i went to the therapy session : *screams like the smallest child ever*
*Terrified screamsss*
He can't even lift that axe
His arm are STICKS
So that's what the movie "The Snowman" was about!
When I heard the line, "Water has memory" I jokingly remarked, "Oh great, Olaf is a homeopath." In homeopathy, it's believed that diulting a chemical in the water, and agitating it, and then diluting it again, etc. makes the chemical stronger, because the water "remembers" the chemical that it held. I really thought that you were going to talk about the dangers of homeopathy and "alternative medicines"
Olaf is a Snowman.....and he remembered that fact plus everything else Elsa stuck into his personality. ❄⛄❄
Okay I have a question when elsa dies I'm guessing olf melts
Yes, exactly. The problem is not only that some random teenager runs around with this "funfact", but that this teenager grows up to be an adult fully believing in homeopathy and nobody will be able to tell them otherwise, since they have known this "fact" for so long.
@@itwasntme967 Just like any other Mandela effect... the Berenstein Bears were never a thing, neither was Smokey THE Bear, the Looney Toons are actually the Looney Tunes, and always have been, Nelson Mandela wasn't dead even though people thought he was (although he is now), and no, water doesn't actually remember anything.
I'll summarise. Homeopathy is fucking retarded and people who believe it are fucking retarded.
It definitely gets downplayed but hats off to your editor. It's amazing how Every second of your videos are so full of energy and life and it's only accentuated by the editing
I always assumed the “water has memory” thing just comes from the fact that water is just so old and has been around since the beginning of life because of the water cycle. And they just extended that idea like any writer has when brainstorming and went “bUt WhAt iF wAtEr ReMeMbErS tHe PlAcEs iTs bEeN aNd ThInGs iTs SeEn”.
Then made that a movie😂
No it comes from this
th-cam.com/video/R8VyUsVOic0/w-d-xo.html
Check it out, it's quite interesting
It's an old, old idea that serves as the basis for Homeopathy and is basically poo.
th-cam.com/video/R8VyUsVOic0/w-d-xo.html
@@MrMooagi977 Yeah I saw it the first time. Still bullshit.
Ok so here's the REAL theory,
If Olaf is made of snow, stones, twigs, and a carrot,
WHERE.
DID.
THE.
EYEBALLS.
COME.
FROM?
They’re elsas egg sacs
people
Easy he magic uwu
IceWolf123Oak *stop*
ROYHEH
“Sticks and stones may break my bones, but I don’t have any bones lol”
-Olaf
Sticks and stones make up your dang nab body Olaf, lol.
@@galonath218 the snow: am i a joke to you?
Nice one Olaf
So your telling us to beat Olaf to death?
@@cannoxgd7391 sure why not
Well, to contrast what you mention at the end, teaching children that water has memory could lead them to be more susceptible to alternative therapies, such as homeopathy; an alternative therapy specifically being based around this idea of dilution and water memory. Furthering what you mentioned, it teaches children to ignore the skeptics and just believe, a thought process quite at odds with critical thinking.
Yeah, that's a great thing to be teaching children!
Ever think you are looking 2 far into it considing the story is based on ice and its telling the story through water and ice telling the history thro water it is completely fictional do you belive there are water filled horse controlling the sea or a fire salamander why do people nitpic when it's the theme how to the logic it all thro ice image memory's in the cave
And it’s not necessarily bad to use homeopathy, there are mental benefits and the sort, but it isn’t an alternative to modern medicine. Mediaeval medicine, for sure, that crap was just chopping limbs off and hurting people, something homeopathy didn’t do. Ancient medicine was doing bad, Vs homeopathy simply doing nothing, while now modern medicine DOES have good effects
@@Wooporexcept SOMETHIMES vaccines because doctors are basically saying "this MIGHT work but, we don't know ... anyway can you give us thousands of dollars for this vaccine."
The song Elsa hears is based off the Swedish/Scandinavian herding call tradition of 'kulning'.
It's quite beautiful, high pitched, and is used to call cattle (though it works for other animals too, including humans, for certain strains) and also for communication since the high notes can travel further than low notes and ordinary speech.
Jonna Jinton does some beautiful incantations of it!
When Anna says "Hello darkness...", I was like, "MY OLD FRIEND, I'VE COME TO TALK TO YOU AGAIN!!!!" Am I alone here?
Yes! Her stuff is mesmerizing.
Kulning is also sometimes refered as/used for 'spirit calling', so it is extra fitting.
You mean this Joana Jinton?
th-cam.com/video/KvtT3UyhibQ/w-d-xo.html
reeeeee imma be that guy, lower frequencies travel further than higher ones
Um. Ok.
Another cool thing about James Randi: He used to open almost every lecture by disproving the "water has memory" idea by downing an obscene level of homeopathic caffeine pills.
I watched his TED talk session when he did that; pretty cool
THAT Channel yea I think he even used sleeping pills with a warning on the bottle for the ted talk
At first I thought it said homophobic caffeine pills
blogsimplegirl.link/YA6wF0lsJo0c
Matt pat: says that it shouldn't kil anyone to believe water have memory
Homeopathy: hold my beer
Given that “water has memory” is the central basis for the branch of homeopathy that tells people not to take prescribed medication, because you can instead just drink water that remembers what the medication is like... I think it could be a pretty dangerous thing to teach kids is real.
Lol yeah some people are extremely stupid.
It's not even medication, it's extracts that cause the same symptom the homeopathic remedy seeks to cure.
Transformers2Fan1 Well then. Don’t really know how to respond to that.
@@trackernivrig It's based on an idea that like cures like, or fighting fire with fire.
preciousinfinity Well, I mean that’s true to an extent. That’s how vaccines work, but this doesn’t really sound like it’ll do anything.
12:40 wait a minute, *frantic clicking on youtube*
“Dory is faking her memory loss” -MatPat
We’ve entered a paradox
Oh noo nooo nooo
Not again
Not here.
See, I interpreted "some people dispute it, but it's true" as Disney saying "this is bullshit, but it's integral to our plot, so get all the way off of my back about this."
This is literally it lol.
Oh ok let me get off of that thing :)
Super easy, barely an inconvenience.
I think it’s more thematic. Like in Tangled the series, the story catalyst is an environmental disaster caused by unfulfillment. Rapunzel is bored, Elsa wants a gf and Cass feels consumerism is the only way she can assert herself. And water having memory is more about the effects of those desires on the natural world. That’s what Moana confronting Te Fiti is about too.
yeah yeah yeah
Water: *has memory*
Also water: *it's like dory's memory*
Every aquatic creature has dory syndrome.
But the real question is, what is Mantis's muscle density and mass in Kung Fu Panda?
this man, he is too dangerous to be kept alive.
why
lettuce
"He used that million-dollar bribe to lure fakers on to television and then totally dunk on them in public."
*MY MAN*
@@francelol8049 Why are you like this.
@@thewatcher9237 ikr
When MatPat said ‚ Here comes Olaf‘ I looked behind my back. TWICE.
☁️☁️☁️☁️☁️☁️
☁️😁😄☁️☁️☁️
☁️😁😄☁️☁️☁️
☁️😁😄☁️☁️☁️
☁️😁😄☁️☁️☁️
☁️😁😄😂😄☁️
☁️😁😄😂😄☁️
☁️☁️☁️☁️☁️☁️
☁️😁😄😂😄☁️
😁😄☁️☁️😁😄
😁😄☁️☁️😁😄
😁😄☁️☁️😁😄
😁😄☁️☁️😁😄
☁️😁😄😂😄☁️
☁️☁️☁️☁️☁️☁️
☁️😁😄☁️☁️☁️
☁️😁😄☁️☁️☁️
☁️😁😄☁️☁️☁️
☁️😁😄☁️☁️☁️
☁️😁😄😂😄☁️
☁️😁😄😂😄☁️
☁️☁️☁️☁️☁️☁️
0:26 - I just looked it up, and the intro to "When will my life begin" literally sounds like a more cheery, showtune-ish, major-ish version of the guitar in the beginning of "Pinball Wizard", like, wtf. How did I not notice that? I was exposed to 70s Rock my entire life, I should've immediately recognized the tune when watching the movie!
FiNNiK
Disney becomes more unoriginal the second!
so true! I love them both but pleaseee Disney, make it a bit less obvious that you copied it lmao-
Matpat: “Waters memory is worse than Dory’s”
Me: “wait, didn’t you disprove her memory loss?” *Gasp* “Water does have memory then!”
Also dory lives in the water *gasps* THEORY: DORY STOLE THE WATER'S MEMORY
Yes I know it makes no sense... Just don't question it 😂😂
That's a good joke and all but that's not how being less workd
Water does have memory. Matt clearly does state that but also states exactly how quickly water loses those memories which make that memory practically useless.
Didnt finding dory 2 disprove his theory or am I thinking of the wrong video
Nice
I assumed everything Olaf said was untrue to begin. I assumed the “facts” were simply joking about the spread of false facts. I’m surprised that most of his facts were seen as true in this video.
Elsa's Ice Sorcery made him in the personality her and Anna used to pretend he has so the Eyes are magical
DekuShrub 99 ikr this is kind of a stretch
DekuShrub 99 Broccoli boi has spoken!
you like majoras mask yeey
no but really, yeey
That makes it worse actually, to have a lie buried in innocuous truths.
I'm pretty sure when when Olaf says "it's disputed by many but it's true" he's talking about the people in the Frozen universe. He's trying to establish a sort of believable explanation for Elsa's power, but there will always be people who doubt things. Before Elsa's escape from the castle, I highly doubt anyone even knew magical powers like that are possible. Plus, even to this day we have science deniers, so it's highly likely that the in movie universe could have deniers, or just people who never seen any proof and doubting it
That’s all well and good in universe but it does spread misinformation regarding homeopathy
@@neofelisnebulosa3871 not really it does not say any thing about homeopathy or medication or treatment so how it's spreading false information regarding homeopathy it's bull I never once took it as factual or compared the 2 next ull ban Peter pan gor implying that children can fly or that toys are alive when your not looking as they slay let it go
Matt: That water has memory is not gonna cause harm
Homeotherapy: Allow me to introduce myself
"Elemental spirit of 80's radness"
Love that.
It's me.
😂😂😂😂😂
So funny
The whole “water has memory” thing *is* dangerous. Some people take it to the extreme and believe that having 0.0000000000001% of some essential oil in a glass of water and drinking it is the same as taking actual medication.
🐶🐶🐶
Even as someone who has greatly benefited from "alternative" treatments, I know just how dangerous it is to believe half the stuff that comes from these people. With no real regulatory body, there's a lot of quack doctors, or even just deluded people thinking they have the cure to everything.
Hey Matpat, I'm actually an artist and now I'm actually inspired to draw elsa in a shining atmosphere with an ice castle,. Like that scene where he's hacking the door with the axe, just an ice castle, and elsa and olaf. I'd even send you the finished product of it if you'd like. It sounds like a fun drawing.
But Pocahontas said "you never step into the same river twice, the waters always changing, always flowing"
*N O*
That's deep
Someone tracking water with a special molecule.
"Laughs in madness"
*makes a river in Minecraft and steps in it twice*
That dosent disprove the Theorie that water has memory
I can change as a person and keep my memory
To people i knew before i will still seem different
I’m really glad you emphasized the importance of the ‘replication and verification’ step of scientific discovery, because in today’s world, where all the news and general public seem to care about is next big discovery, this step is constantly undervalued and often straight up ignored. Which, like you said in the video, could have some serious consequences in the future.
Max Schwartz Not only undervalued but also underfunded. Not only does nobody really want to be the guy who discovered a thing the second time, but they're also aren't enough resources available to verify every discovery. So you have to prioritize and leave some findings unverified.
Teacher: why are you giving me a glass of water?
Student: Well you see, my homework got destroyed by water, and then I remembered that water has memory so I gave you the water.
Mom can I have a pet glass of water?
Fucking smartass
Omg that made me laugh you genius
You got a witness🤣🤣🤣
Wow
Lol
5:38 zeus you sly man
Olaf: * science facts *
Matpat: *I'm about to end this snowman whole career*
myhtical memory tier list:
D Tier - *Fire* (doesn't even remeber the last thing it ate, before moving to the next one)
C Tier - *Water* (as we've seen with the video, it "has" memory, it only last less than a trillionth of a second)
B Tier - *Air* (cuz loud words and noises, can echo for more than a couple of seconds)
A Tier - *Earth* (YOU CAN LITERALLY ETCH AND SKETCH STUFF ON IT, AND IT WILL TAKE FOREVER FOR IT TO BE ERASED!)
A+ Tier - Moon, a crater or marking of the moon can last millions of years
@@zaclegoattack forever since no erosion or tectonic activity
Earth is definitely S tier when it comes to “memory”. Fossil record, geological events, and carbon dating are just a few methods
Spirit- the feeling of existence through memory
@@EndEverEsports lasts only as long as ones life... Well what most would tell you
Matpat someone could argue that water does actually does have memory in the form of ice cores. That's what I thought the twist at the end was going to be. I'm curious to see what people think.
Sam H I was actually thinking of the (polerized?) property of water when I first heard it. Basically water is sticky. It sticks to itself and can retain its shape (for a few seconds). This is also what causes little droplets of water. I’m probably not the best to explain this.
Ice cores are more like a recording than a living memory though I can see the comparison. But saying ice/water have memory in that regard is like saying a map has a sense of direction, kinda right but not quite
Well if ur going to go ice core, you can go ocean and animal brain matter... What is memory? How long is "too short" is memory the same as recall?
blogsimplegirl.link/wccWqFQ1A30v
Yes I actually thougt of the same thing. I mean its not tecnical a real memory but I think ist enough for a Disney movie. I actually heard scientists call ice at the northpole "memory of the earth", also in the Film the memory is only shown in the form of ice.
In all honesty I believe it depends on what you would consider to be a waters “memory.” For example, glaciers preserve a lot of substances. The substances and thickness of ice layers can help indicate the conditions that certain time periods would have possessed. This includes the climate, greenhouse gas and oxygen levels, as well as in some cases preserved specimen ( like Ötzi the Iceman).
Matt doesn't mention that Olaf is literally made of water and is capable of remembering things. Like I'm not saying water has memory, I'm just saying...THAT water has memory.
in the movie yes he does remember stuff cuz, i mean, like c mon
Yeah... Olaf is magical after all :/
Unlike water that was talked about in the movie is practically Normal... 'without magic'
OOOOOOOOOOOOHHHH
Scientific method: Replication and Verification eh...
Life coming from non life is what Darwin teaches. Can this be replicated or verified in a lab? Nope, therefore it's not science.
4:40 "Did you know we blink 4 million times a day?" ... "Not even close!"
I think Olaf researched all scientific facts by himself and just counted during a polar day on the north/south pole (edit: which lasts half a year), which would be pretty accurate.
(Edit2: ... and "water has memory" is what fpr example makes him able to learn, so in that movie world that should be also true.)
For the second part, I agree it works, but only in the movie world. The problem is that there are people stupid enough to not understand that, and they’ll go “hey guys water has memory”. This is basically the exact same way ani-vaxers, flat earthers, etc. get their information, and that is terrifying.
if you disagree with matpat, please watch something else or else don't make criticism about his methods, because, in every theory he does, he treats it like the real world. #comeatmebro
Pillager 6666 Well, I agree with most of that. If he wants to leave criticism that’s fine as long as he’s respectful when doing so.
@@stanfoutz2134 Please tell me a moment where he actually criticized MatPat. He didn't. He just stated his thoughts and there is nothing wrong with that, unlike what your dumbass has to say.
Pillager 6666
Dude, Matpat actively encourages us to disagree and challenge him. That's like the whole point of this video is not to trust people to just give you facts. Granted, he's right in this video but still.
"You're the worst water EVEEEEERRRRRRRRRRRR" sounds like it would be in a bad ATLA Zuko x Katara fanfiction
pudding and kpop yes 😂 I love this
Maybe, but can we all talk about how stupid it is that Elsa is the avatar
Lol true
@@ninjay204 bN
Fjjjnuvy
Omg that ship is still alive?
Lost in the woods and your the inspiration by Chicago sounds exactly the same.
Even cinemasins pointed it out
I thought it sounded familiar.
6:50 "Does Water have Memory?"
No I have chronic alzheimers.
The water has spoken.
@@shion8030 对，我(水)说了。
JSKJSJSKSJJSJNANKAMAK 😂😂😂
You deserve more upvotes.
Corect my brother you do forget stuff
2013 :let it gooo
2019: into the unknown
Well actually lost in the woooooooods
Spooky Filmz Ent.
Tf
lmao?
@@YoungAlienBoy is this what you creatures are reduced to now? Instead of begging for likes you're begging for any form of "engagement"? Disgusting.
@@Nidvex they've done it on every comment I've seen so far I've reported it for spam
Heared kinda like old song
"Water has memory"
The kid's pool**screams in pee**
this theory made me woder if you can overtake ages
if ana was the youngest than elsa why did ana get love
earlier than elsa
Okay, I know it was a joke, but I would LOVE to see a 6th element, the 80's radness element🤣
Yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeesss
as a child who was raised by parents who made me and my brother watch/listen to movies and songs they watched/listened to when they were kids and teenagers, I would very much enjoy that
MatPat: Tell any kids who are watching Frozen 2 about the scientific method & replication standards
Me to my little sister when she is watching Frozen 2: Alright. Water has memory, but it only holds that memory for a femtosecond so DON'T go around saying water carries memory about you drinking it, okay?
It's 私の名前 *が* sky, not はsky
@@TP-tg8cc wut
Theodore Patterson he wants publicity
My 8th grade English teacher used that "water has feelings" study as "scientific" reason for us to be nice to each other instead of just using actual studies on the effects of bullying I guess and as a fan of heavy metal I always questioned that study because rock fans are usually very nice so now I'm happy to know it was complete crap science
not Ella me too XD
I mean they did kinda teach you to be nicer to others since humans are made mostly of water so...
Mission success?
I didn’t even know that “water has feelings” was a thing.
I don't understand
Theory Bingo:
-MatPat says an answer is "a lot more nuanced than you think"
-Dad jokes
-"Literally one of the coolest guys ever"
Michael Connor bingo
@@drakencourtorielle Ifuyrg
William Barnes what?
5:15 I have a theory on how they could have gotten to that number:
a blink of an eye can be either how often you blink with your eyelids, or how long the eye takes in light for a single "frame" moving about 24 times per second and refreshing parts of your vision in memory. I you go by the latter definition and extrapolate from seconds in a day, you would get roughly the right number
Here’s a thought: water is a magical element and while it doesn’t remember physical attributes in real life it can remember metaphysical/magical attributes in a magical forest where the magic stems partially from the flow of a river
And if the horse is made of water then the water is magic water because movie about magic
@Brian Nguyen Olaf is a magic snowman whose whole premise is water memory and most people would take what he says with a grain of salt...
You cant tell 3 truths and one lie and talk how your character is made up.
THANK YOU luv perseus son of the sea god
Oh yeah! Most of the animals he talked about WERE water animals so I think you’re right
"Water has memory" is actually a particularly dangerous "Fact" as it's the basis of homeopathy. This is extra problematic when you consider that, with a company the size of Disney there is no way everyone involved in making this line happen didn't know about this.
My first reaction was "Oh no, gotta battle this with the future generation even more"
Didney supports homeopathy lewl
It is a joke for God’s sake
Which part is the joke? This particular video or Frozen 2 including this theme? I’m not 100% sure which part of me commenting on this you think is me taking it too seriously.
@@AstraAtlantis its a joke scene about him saying spurious facts. That one being true is about magic, nothing else
"The water has memory"
Me: I am officially killing water while drinking it.
Technically no ur absorbing it knowing more
does that mean smart water is normal water?
That means water remembers passing through you and...coming out the other end ;^;
@@ppizzanoob8000 Well it's memory wouldn't be long enough to remember that at all so no it doesn't......
No you absorb it then egecte it
0:43 When I first heard the "voice" I definately reconized and eventually it came to me, they use a similar call in the Xenosaga series on PS2
I feel like one day we are gonna have a theory were matpat just lists up everything that Disney has copied..
And then he gets...
COPYRIGHTED ohhhh the horror!!!!!😱😱😱
actually disney would probably get their army of lawyers to sue for defamation
You mean then he gets the video demonetised/pulled or his channel receives a strike for copyright violation. All of his videos get copyrighted
Matpat: "7 hours of sleep a day"
Pro gamers: "3 take it or leave it"
Pro Gamers who live in Asia: Dies of Sleep Depravation
Schools: *nervous sweating*
High schoolers: Yall are getting sleep?
College: Sleep? What is that mean?
Of course it's dangerous: there's a girl who controls ice and snow. Like, what if she became a villain- OH WAIT
Elsa is killer frost confirmed! *not clickbait *gone wrong *gone sexual *sued
Cats sucks At smash YeŚ
@@mokkecandy_5406 he's clickbaiting views. ignore him
@@YoungAlienBoy "Comtsgment"
🧐
3:46 i love this part💀 "for science👀"
Matpat: _”Does water have memory? And what would that mean?”_
TH-cam Commenters: *”You know, I’m something of a homeopathologist myself.”*
Like, every comment is talking about how the water has a memory.
"Does water have memory?"
Me looking suspiciously at the water bottle on my desk
Lol
Check out this video
th-cam.com/video/R8VyUsVOic0/w-d-xo.html
*slurp*
Newspaper: The CIA's new recruit is water.
The Water sitting next to me: My cover's been blown!
My brother was spoiling the movie saying 'spoilers alert the fifth element is Elsa ' so I told him this 'spoilers alert Olaf is the villain '
Wombats have a little wallee in them compacting waste
6:29 “water has memory”
me: *goes to toilet*
my pee: pls no not again.
Huh. Is it the smell that gives it away? I thought that was only grass...
[Research if you don't get it.]
It's three am and I have to wake up early.. why am I here reading this smh.
*I NEED TO CLIP TO THE TOP COMMENT TO SAY THIS, HE REALLLYY WANTS THAT WATCHTIME MONEY SINCE IT TOOK HIM 6 MINUTES ALMOST HALF THE VIDEO TO GET TO THE POINT* wow matpat
This comment had 400 likes and I come back 5 minutes later and this has 462 likes?
Bruh
@@monicamoigradan841 2 more were recently added, and I don't think it's going to stop rising through the ranks.
Plot twist:
Olaf is trying to trick kids into staying hydrated. Drop your homework onto the water then drink it. You'll remember everything! You can also put the dictionary into water and drink it-
So if I drop my computer into water and then drink it....
@@loonylovegood2555 you become Albert Einsten
@@Al-uw1qy lol
Huh
That's not how it works but hey, who am I to judge?
Is no one gonna comment on the fact Cinema Sins, HISHE, and MatPat all released frozen 2 vids within like 3 hours of each other? No? Okay I'll show myself to the door...
Probably because the blu-ray recently came out
Not to mention honest trailers...but yh I think the bluray came out.
Secretly they’re all the same person
I WAS THINKNG THATTTT
SHOW YOURSELF back to your seat because i realized that too
7:52 You're allergic to dogs?!😢
I'm so sorry MatPat🥺
Wasn't there an alternative """""medicine""""" that was all about the water's memory? Like they dillude something in water, then dillude that dillution and do it again over and over until you have a literal nothing of the initial substance and say that will make you healthier?
Yes. It's called homiopathy and is mentioned in other comments.
Yeah like prescription pills. 99% petroleum byproducts...
@@thcrtn
Hello, I literally work making those pills. What you said is wrong.
@@OtakuJuanma2 the fact you said literally just blew your cover, beyond that, if you knew chemistry Its history... Health and the bigger games being played you wouldn't be so quick to quiet someone and bring nothing to the table.
But ill leave you to your literal pill production.
@@thcrtn
I said literally because it's true. I'm a Biotechnology graduate. I have the studies necessary to make medicines, and I'm certified to do it.
7:10 I love how they just put *NOT CLICKBAIT * at the end of a video title filled with science words 😂😂
Please no one listen to the previous reply. You should never be rude to anyone no matter what
"I don't think it's harmful"
Homeopathy would like to have a word with you.
Kwabi explain.
@@trenaeturane976 homeopathic 'remedies' largely rely on taking a 'cure' (and I say this very loosely, because their idea of cure is a little odd to begin with) and watering it down again and again and again. Then, they sell the product as a very pricey 'remedy', which, by the time it gets to shelves, has less than one 1000th of what the original stuff in it was. Because people fall so badly for it, though, they don't seek proper medical attention. The way supporters say it's supposed to be that the water remembers what it originally had, so it works.
This particular practice dates back to when bloodletting was a thing, so leaving ones body to get rid of bad stuff was always going to work out better than draining the evil red stuff in your veins, but now, it's dangerous misinformation.
@@trenaeturane976 Water having memory is used as a marketing ploy in homeopathy. Homeopathic practitioners claim that you can dilute medications in water to stretch their usage with the same efficacy as the pre diluted medication because the water remembers being the medication.
This also works in hand with Big Lie Theory. Keep repeating the same lie over and over and eventually someone will believe it to be true. More and more will slowly start to believe the lie, even if all they are doing is throwing their hands up and saying "Fine, whatever, just shutup about it already"
The first thing I thought when he said, "Water has memory", was _oh no, Disney is pushing homeopathy on unsuspecting children._
Actually the 5th element is wood and the 6th one is actually metal so you’re partially right about the electric guitar sound.
5 element not in science is dna theory's thro 5th element the movie which came out years before frozen so probly where they got the idea
I feel like that study was just a science experiment on how to raise your kids, treat them with love and not hate and heavy metal? Lol 😆
HumbleDucky quick question: do you know what the word ‘subjective’ means?
You talking about the guitar in the woods?
@HumbleDucky 1¹1¹1
@HumbleDucky It kinda is
metallica has left the chat
I just saw the whole "water has memory" thing as a story element
limited to the world of frozen.
Same, some people look into things way too much.
Priming can be very insidious indeed
If it wasn't put in a list of scientific sounding facts, and tell people to ignore people who say it isn't true it wouldn't be as bad. It would also be better if they didn't mimic the language of homeopathy. Say if instead of the words water and memory it was the elements of nature remember what they have seen. It means something similar but isn't taking lines from homeopathy and sounds more mystical.
But you aren't 4, I assume.
“Water has memory”
*Homeopathy has entered the chat*
“... it’s science fiction”
*Homeopathy has left the chat*
@@thaias9654 but it is science fiction on it's own
thought he was going to lead into that but then said that it wasnt going to do anyone harm... placebo is not an effective way of curing diseases like corona lmao
Matpat: tell any kids in the room about it
Me: should I tell my twin?
Disney did the same thing with Ever After High.. Stole eeeeverything about EAH and just... turned it into Descendants.
And honestly Ever After High is miles better.
The little mermaid’s “part of your world” bears a striking resemblance to Little Shop of Horrors’ “somewhere that’s green”. That could have more to do with the two songs having the same composer, but it’s something I noticed.
Disney: Water has memory
Aquaman, Namor, Ariel, Gillman, and Jason Voorhees: Bullsh*t
Hehe yes
And me ÙnÚ
You’d be surprised at how many people don’t know who namor is
@@3down4togo Unfortunately I know
@@terryfuldsgaming7995 No, Jason Voorhees isn't made of water or is a mermaid - he's just heavily associated with water like the other characters I mentioned
Discovered this new channel, not regretting at all. It's awesome plus I love all the jokes he makes. Addicted to these videos now. Watch about 5 or 6 a day.
“Water has memory.” That explains why i hear screams from the toilet when I walk in to the bathroom. 😮
I'm pretty sure that's just some ghost f**king with you.
Hold up
Friend, are you sure you're bathroom isn't haunted?
Spooky Filmz Ent. Ok stop I seen it
Someone who is not an asshole PERIOD. - I just asked. It said “no”. Then again a voice under the bed said the same thing when I asked if there were any monsters hiding under the bed last week, yet every morning I keep losing socks overnight! :-/
The Dies Irae has also been used in many other movies. Some examples include The Lion King, It's A Wonderful Life, Sweeney Todd, and Star Wars.
I could be wrong but I think it’s also in some motifs in The Nightmare Before Christmas. Either in This is Halloween or Making Christmas, more likely the latter, and maybe also the little theme that plays when Sally picks the flower.
The shaping of water cristals could also have been formed due to the airwaves/vibrations produced by the heavy metal I suppose?
Make more sense than saying water have feeling
I thought of that too but I think the sound waves are too big/long to affect the water molecules in such a level
I grew up blindly believing "The Hidden Messages in Water" and now I can say, thank you for the counterarguments that I was missing.
"I don't think anyone believing that water has memory is going to do them any harm".
This is literally the basis of homeopathy, an industry that makes money by convincing you not to seek proper medical help
Thank you, I was so shocked when he said that and didn't once address homeopathy when it is actually very much dangerous... Pseudoscience like believing stuff diluted to nonexistential concentrations cures cancer most definitely gets people, even innocent kids of very ignorant and gullible parents, killed.
Bullshit. homeopathy can help
@@trueblade3636 Yeah and by some reason it stops working when properly tested with scientific methods. That's because science kills magic i think!
@@TrueKpblcko ignorant person
@@trueblade3636 your argumentation is astonishing
Kristof’s song was happening in his head. It was like “In Summer” from the first one.
I'm sure he knew that, and was only poking fun.
Watching this with my 8 year old daughter and she says “am I getting a history lesson or learning about frozen?” both my dear, welcome to FiLm ThEoRy 😛
And that's my friends is how we should raise children. Congrats.
Actually, the four chords used in into the unknown as well as shining isn't something the two just happen to have in common. They are used all across cinematography in soundrecks in moments associated with death. The four chords play when Luke finds his home farm destroyed for example. In Frozen they are an indicator of Atohalan's connection to the past and by extention a whole lot of death.
MatPat: Shows book saying "The hidden messages in water"
Also MatPat: "It's called Messages from water"
I’m glad I’m not the only one who was bothered by the “water has memory” thing. Not only is it listed as a scientific fact alongside things that are actually true, it’s part of the main theme of the movie, meaning it gets repeated more than the actually true facts.
And there's also homeopathy a pseudoscience that says diluted medicine is as effective as actual medicine so people take that stuff instead and die of treatable diseases
"Anna?
Elsa?
Sven?
Samantha? Ahahaha I-I dont even know a Samantha!" -Olaf
Ouch I'm here.......
Right here
@@Jellybeansatdusk PFFT-----
@@VoidWilbyte The title here is way more accurate than people think.
Pseudo-Science is truly and literally very dangerous.
Ever since I watched the movies that line lives rent-free in my head
Tbh when I saw Olaf in frozen 1 I loved him. His an adorable character, he is sweet, his like a new born baby, his ambition to find summer was so cute and I’ve realized that I was around 7 or 8 years old that time, I thought he was an innocent character, his character didn’t feel deep, and I loved him. When I saw Olaf in frozen 2........ I still loved him but I feel him at the same time. He changed into that kid that became very curious about life and every matter that surrounds him. He began to “grow up” and loses sanity as he asks more questions about anything and everything, heck he’ll even listen to conspiracies and uncle mattpat’s theories, other than that he even sang a song about it(when I am older). And tbh I was 12 the age of curiosity and awareness when I watched the second movie. I guess I’m saying that they were aiming for viewers whose watched the 1st movie(those were intended to be children younger than 9) then growing a bit older with the characters as we see them again with more maturity.
I’m not sure what the main lesson in frozen was, like was it meant to be about always sticking with your loved ones and don’t take them for granted or something, but I’m guessing that if Frozen was from a book, there wouldn’t canonically be a talking snowman.. Olaf’s story is just teaching us a side lesson about growing up and that some things just won’t stay the same. Even if Anna sings some things never change, it wouldn’t feel as deep as Olaf’s jokes
In a nutshell:
Olaf is trying to brainwash kids with homeopathic conspiracies.
wooooooooooooooooooow
No stop Olaf stop brainwashing kids
Homeopathy isnt conspiracy dude, its just large scale placebo effect. And like placebos, it does work
@@extinctsss ummm I don't know homeopathy and conspiracy but smart :) I'm a kid that's why ....
Niketh Hyuga if you wanna learn more about the placebo effect, here is an interesting video about it:
m.th-cam.com/video/fC7oUOUEEi4/w-d-xo.html
theory: disney is about to open their own homeopathic business
Don't give them ideas...
Kirsten Marie That’s just Disney +
Ur pfp is amazing
@@papyrusthecool8321 that's just a theory
A Disney film theory!
Great. Homeopathy is good. Unless Disney would abuse it
Me, if water had memory:
"Finally, I will no longer be forgotten"
I mean some people believe that diluted medicine is as effective as actual medicine and take that instead of actual medicine to then die of a treatable illness
You will get your 50 femtoseconds of fame after all.
@@myrmesuwu607 absolutely, they do... Check out this documentary
th-cam.com/video/R8VyUsVOic0/w-d-xo.html
@@MrMooagi977 yep that look like a "documentary" to me (I just watched random bits maybe they debunk it making it a legit scientific documentary)
@@myrmesuwu607 just finished watching all of it...
It's only 50 minutes, and if nothing else it has a long interview with the team leader of the team that discovered the HIV virus, which is cool.
Academic input is far better than some guy/girl with a crystal ball yelling at water as I'm sure you would agree 😆😆😆
I remember when my science teacher showed me masaru’s research and presented them as a legit study
Thank you for this video matpat
My first thought walking out of the theater: "Is Disney trying to promote homeopathy with this film?"
Glad to see someone else picked up on the problematic nature of pushing "water has memory" as a scientific fact.
And funnily enough, they make propaganda for this bullshit right as Corona is on the rise.
The call of the spirit in "Into the Unknown" reminds me of Jack skelinton's song from nightmare before Christmas
Yh I always thought that
Just report the idiot with and his video maybe he gets a strike
He uses it as a promotion it's the channel of the video
It’s the dies irae is an audible effect used to signify something bad happen(death) . So yeah, having it in jack skeleton’s song is just because he is dead
@@makuru.42 I've reported every single reply it's on almost every comment
Mrs. T but the tones here are specifically the dires irae, and traditionally the tone variations are faster and higher. th-cam.com/video/eUwiOdXY4ic/w-d-xo.html is an example of traditional hoarding call or “lokk” as we call it in Norwegian. The dies irae is made to be eerie as it is essentially about doomsday and death
Me, five minutes in: huh, he’s not gonna talk about water memory? Okay.
“Number five: did you know water has memory”
Me: I KNEW IT!
That haunting call 📞 actually scared the heck out of me a bit.