I enjoyed listening to you because the depth with which you have covered Arthasastra. It is rather amazing that Kautilya did such an in-depth theoretical analysis of the political economy. We Indians are proud of Kautilya. The whole world has much to learn from him. Hope we all will avoid open war and solve problems through diplomacy. Let us all believe in peaceful coexistence instead of increasing one's power through destruction, killings and spoiling earth's atmosphere.Unfortulately all politicians are power hungry!!
Gandhi was inspired by the Bhagavad Gita which contains the direct word of God. It was this that defeated the British without firing a single shot. Lord Shiva and Lord Krishna's teaching also went on to found Buddhism. When the Mongolians came to India, they were converted to Buddhism and sent away peacefully, without bloodshed. No, India should not adopt the Arthashastra. The world should adopt Sanatana Dharma. Aum shanti shanti.
@@abhishekkumar-js7krGandhi was doing it for British. He didn't follow Gita. Otherwise he wouldn't have said to fought for British. It is written " Tolerating injustice is as much a crime as committing injustice. It Is Your Duty To Fight Injustice"
Aptly noted at the end, ''maps are not permanent.' If statecraft (and its subset warmaking) were to be compared to the running of rapids in rafts or canoes, then the Arthashastra of Chanakya Kautilya is something like a handbook for rivermen. The water is constantly changed, and the character of a river, though cyclically similar to its prior conditions, is infinitely variable in its speed, depth and the changing likelihood that it will carry one's craft over a rock, onto a rock or into a stultifying edy. The riverman/statesman must attempt the passage with either an inherently buoyant, flexible but hardly steerable raft or with a faster, more dirigible, but also more fragile canoe: Sometimes there is a choice of craft, other times there is no option.
@@Nanipuchi13189 What, is it your first time learning about this? 😂😂 You can check other comments correcting them 😂 BBC documentaries, Doing Yoga in yoga pants, understanding Hinduism /Indian culture, caste system. Westerners do it every time to paint poor picture of India.
The problem with Indian is they blindly follow western education. I studied sanskrit st young age. So I was able to enjoy kalidasa Basa chanakya. KAUTILYA means who us KUTILA That crafty cunning and scheming.In fair war Dharma yudha there are rules. KAUTILYA was determined to defeat Nava Nandas. In the process he was researching the the process resulting in Arthasha😊
I consider one of the great contribution that I have made to the humanity (archaeology in particular) is my discovery of the Asokian Four Directed Lions symbol may be referring to the original home of the Moryan kings as Chandra Gupta (Ashoka's grand father and founder of the Moryan empire) is from a place called Tak-Ka-Shi-La (which in Tibetan language means "Four Directed Lion's Pass") in present day Afganistan-Pakistan Border area.......... so I discovered that Ashoka could be of Tibetan ethnicity...... It would be hard to believe that Chadra Gupta came from a place called, in Tibetan sounds like, four directed lions pass ("Tak kah si la") and his grandson choosing four directed lions as his signature (or amblem) could be coincidental....... I think Ashoka chose the four directed lions as his emblem to indicate the name of his lineage's original home land (since its in Tibetan, he must know Tibetan to interpret it correctly....)
interesting lecture, very well presented, but sadly the selection of font colours in the slides, is very bad. there used to be a red book for editors back in the day when there used to be books. slide craft could benefit from knowledge of book craft.
You can design strategies but warfares have gone through drastic changes and warfares shouldn’t be there at all decimating lives bombings have never resolved anything Entire History of warfares is full of these facts you can resolve issues in so many other ways
Mispronunciation is nothing. It is the content, essence, how to implement the essence what matters. If you waste your energy on these non important things, you have less for implementation.
@cobra-jf3kq😂😂😂 which curriculum kautilya taught?? Even at defence ,war studies. If any Hindu literature is mentioned anywhere just read comments what so called liberals,secularism studied on congress syllabus.thinks. but they don't give respect to even😂😂 Ayurveda as Hindu literature
Dr Goodson made a few geographical faux pas in his lecture. To a good military strategist, sound knowledge of geography is as critical as warcraft or diplomacy. A wrongly quoted grid reference will certainly change the course of battle, if not war. Also, correct way of pronouncing the original word is too, important, for, in some ancient languages like Sanskrit, wrongly pronounced word would certainly change the meaning and context too. You don't need this during war, I guess.
So pathetic to have a lecture on one of the greatest scholars of all time and Dr Larry didn't bother to get correct pronunciation of Kautilya. It is like calling Dr. Larry Goodson as Dr. Arry Goodson. Bloody ignorant.
Cut the guy some slack, He understood the philosophy of Kautilya, that's more than enough, and I don't think Kautilya would mind the mispronunciation of his name.
Actually English dpesnt have as many vowels consonents and syllables as indian languages. So even if they know, it might not roll off their tongue correctly.
@@raicooks1382 Hello Einstein, I am just talking about plain and simple L here. No complex stuff. It is available in English as well. It is even present in word ENGLISH.
@@TheKuldiips It seems simple to you. Its not. It depends on the syllable. The Japanese cannot pronounce L. They called Michael Jackson as makeru. You have no idea how tongue gets trained. The brain doesnt even register the mistake Einstein!
Lord Vishnu should be noted as the greatest military commander of all time. He defeated The British and the Mongolians without spilling a single drop of blood. Who else in history has ever pacified the greatest military forces of their day? You should not be teaching The Art of War or Arthashastra, you should be teaching The Bhagavad Gita, Upanishads and Yoga Sutras.
Bro you really need to read history.. War is the ultimate option & every country who were being ruled, fought for their freedom. No one can gain freedom by non-violence cause the oppressor will never give up.
Half baked knowledge. And yeah empty vessel sounds more. Dude needs some practical and historical knowledge. You have to come out from your delusional world. Bhagvad geeita itslef is the word of Shree Krishna answering to Arjuna during Mahabharata war. If shree krishna himself was not able to stop war , he dude is yelling some Gandhi ahimsabad. Lol. Big lol to you.
@@hogriderhogw1696 some born racist like you, will hate other civilizations till end of your life. You have been nurtured by giving a tonic of superiority complex. No medication for you.
We have a history of thousands years. We are the oldest living civilization on earth. Tons of religion came and vanish. SANATAN will survive all times. Even your faith will be vanished pretty soon. ISSA and MOOSA will fight and kill each others. Only Sanatan will be there at end. 😂😂😂
Ups and down are always there. There's a minima after maxima. What matters is that we fought back and after all that many societies have sccummbed but we survived and we have preserved our culture and are reclaiming our place that we once had.
Lol, that was centuries after the mauryan empire disintegrated, which is basically also what happened to sun tzus country, and klausewitz's so not sure what your logic is
I enjoyed listening to you because the depth with which you have covered Arthasastra. It is rather amazing that Kautilya did such an in-depth theoretical analysis of the political economy. We Indians are proud of Kautilya. The whole world has much to learn from him. Hope we all will avoid open war and solve problems through diplomacy. Let us all believe in peaceful coexistence instead of increasing one's power through destruction, killings and spoiling earth's atmosphere.Unfortulately all politicians are power hungry!!
I didn't like this man's lecture. He was explaining so unprofessionally. He didn't put effort in making us understand
Patliputra is not in Bangladesh, its in India
Patna
@@abhishekkumar-js7kr Patna is in India, unless Bihar isnt a part of our land
@@gouriverma Patliputra is the old name of Patna, I was clarifying that.
Patliputra isn't Patna but slightly far way @@abhishekkumar-js7kr
Ancient patliputra city and modern day patliputra are not the same.
@@b.l.0427
Wow, ancient India was an amazing place
😂 because they fought in the war
@@jerrygraves6531They were more warlike in nature before getting thoroughly washed by Buddhism
India should adopt Kautilya arthashastra not Ghandi non violence
Gandhi was inspired by the Bhagavad Gita which contains the direct word of God. It was this that defeated the British without firing a single shot. Lord Shiva and Lord Krishna's teaching also went on to found Buddhism. When the Mongolians came to India, they were converted to Buddhism and sent away peacefully, without bloodshed. No, India should not adopt the Arthashastra. The world should adopt Sanatana Dharma. Aum shanti shanti.
@@dharmendra.singh.1985 🤔🤔
Sale gobarbhakt Katilya is mythological character what I think.
@@dharmendra.singh.1985 A wise king shouldn't seek war but should always be prepared for it.
@@abhishekkumar-js7krGandhi was doing it for British. He didn't follow Gita. Otherwise he wouldn't have said to fought for British. It is written " Tolerating injustice is as much a crime as committing injustice. It Is Your Duty To Fight Injustice"
If you want to learn indian pschye at military perspective, kautilya philosophy and principles can be a way toward it.
This is the greatness of the US .. they properly study the other world philosophy and take the good from it
it is not greatness. It is being clever
I liked it .....well covered
Aptly noted at the end, ''maps are not permanent.'
If statecraft (and its subset warmaking) were to be compared to the running of rapids in rafts or canoes, then the Arthashastra of Chanakya Kautilya is something like a handbook for rivermen. The water is constantly changed, and the character of a river, though cyclically similar to its prior conditions, is infinitely variable in its speed, depth and the changing likelihood that it will carry one's craft over a rock, onto a rock or into a stultifying edy. The riverman/statesman must attempt the passage with either an inherently buoyant, flexible but hardly steerable raft or with a faster, more dirigible, but also more fragile canoe: Sometimes there is a choice of craft, other times there is no option.
A very good example.
Mean while my nation watching seminar on koutilya from a US guy.
We Indians are just checking if Americans are in anyway misrepresenting Indian history and culture. Just here to correct them
😂😂
@@shrin210 🙄
@@Nanipuchi13189
What, is it your first time learning about this? 😂😂
You can check other comments correcting them 😂
BBC documentaries, Doing Yoga in yoga pants, understanding Hinduism /Indian culture, caste system.
Westerners do it every time to paint poor picture of India.
Indian is suffering from stpds like Gandhi version of non-violence
The sad truth is we didn't learn about our culture more, I am trying to change that by learning as much as I can about my country.
In the 4 approaches the 2nd one is "Dama" not "Dana". It means securing the outcome with money or bribe. "Dana" means charitable giving.
Do you think “dama” is a Sanskrit word? 😂 Dana is the correct word here.
Dana is the correct word. "Daam" is just a Hindi corruption of the word Dana.
Salamanca brothers studying Arthashastra is the highlight ig XD
Glad to have found this, as an Indian i wanted to get into especially as I belong from the area which was ancient Patliputra.
Intrested may watch the series... Chanikya..... In youtube to understand a luttle if you have some time
That makes USA a great country. They look for inspiration every corner of the world.
The problem with Indian is they blindly follow western education. I studied sanskrit st young age. So I was able to enjoy kalidasa Basa chanakya. KAUTILYA means who us KUTILA That crafty cunning and scheming.In fair war Dharma yudha there are rules. KAUTILYA was determined to defeat Nava Nandas. In the process he was researching the the process resulting in Arthasha😊
Excellent Presentation
Sun tzu, Machiavelli, and Marcus Aurelius are happy to listen .
I consider one of the great contribution that I have made to the humanity (archaeology in particular) is my discovery of the Asokian Four Directed Lions symbol may be referring to the original home of the Moryan kings as Chandra Gupta (Ashoka's grand father and founder of the Moryan empire) is from a place called Tak-Ka-Shi-La (which in Tibetan language means "Four Directed Lion's Pass") in present day Afganistan-Pakistan Border area.......... so I discovered that Ashoka could be of Tibetan ethnicity...... It would be hard to believe that Chadra Gupta came from a place called, in Tibetan sounds like, four directed lions pass ("Tak kah si la") and his grandson choosing four directed lions as his signature (or amblem) could be coincidental....... I think Ashoka chose the four directed lions as his emblem to indicate the name of his lineage's original home land (since its in Tibetan, he must know Tibetan to interpret it correctly....)
😂😂?? Tibetan yeah right😅
Whole tibataian language is coming from prakrit
It's takasha Shila
According to ancient Greek records Emperor Chandragupta was dark skinned
Jai shree Ram.
India has a lot to offer.
interesting lecture, very well presented, but sadly the selection of font colours in the slides, is very bad.
there used to be a red book for editors back in the day when there used to be books. slide craft could benefit from knowledge of book craft.
Great presentation
You can design strategies but warfares have gone through drastic changes and warfares shouldn’t be there at all decimating lives bombings have never resolved anything Entire History of warfares is full of these facts you can resolve issues in so many other ways
Kautilya is not from Middle East. He is from south east that is India.
Kou-ti-llya
The pronounciation🙏
Mispronunciation is nothing. It is the content, essence, how to implement the essence what matters. If you waste your energy on these non important things, you have less for implementation.
It depends on whether the people you want to talk with later can recognize what you're saying.
It's not taxila, it's tak-sha-shi-la
it was called taxila only takshasila was a latter adopted name
But in India if you take any Hindu philosopher's name, your are not secular 😅😅😅😅
Ridiculous because Hinduism embodies the original concept of Secularism whereas Christianity and Islam are opposite of that.
@cobra-jf3kq why.?
@cobra-jf3kq you seem like a dum moron and super clueless. Time to do some deep dive and not learn from brainwashed material
@cobra-jf3kq😂😂😂 which curriculum kautilya taught?? Even at defence ,war studies. If any Hindu literature is mentioned anywhere just read comments what so called liberals,secularism studied on congress syllabus.thinks. but they don't give respect to even😂😂 Ayurveda as Hindu literature
Ancient Greece and ancient India is equal in terms of knowledge
U guys study kautaliya in USA …. Wow😮😮
According to ambedkerites of India he was fictional and chandragupta was buddhist 😂😂😂
The west has started looking farther to the east than Machivilli, Kant and Descartes !
I'll say Maichiavali was the Kautilya of Germany.
Italy
Dr Goodson made a few geographical faux pas in his lecture. To a good military strategist, sound knowledge of geography is as critical as warcraft or diplomacy. A wrongly quoted grid reference will certainly change the course of battle, if not war. Also, correct way of pronouncing the original word is too, important, for, in some ancient languages like Sanskrit, wrongly pronounced word would certainly change the meaning and context too. You don't need this during war, I guess.
You should add Shivaji & Bajirao I in your non western general 's list.
After 2400 years i am still way too dumb to read Chanakya
He mispronounces the name Kautilya and makes no attempt to get it right!
His research is outdated
So pathetic to have a lecture on one of the greatest scholars of all time and Dr Larry didn't bother to get correct pronunciation of Kautilya.
It is like calling Dr. Larry Goodson as Dr. Arry Goodson. Bloody ignorant.
Cut the guy some slack, He understood the philosophy of Kautilya, that's more than enough, and I don't think Kautilya would mind the mispronunciation of his name.
Actually English dpesnt have as many vowels consonents and syllables as indian languages. So even if they know, it might not roll off their tongue correctly.
@@raicooks1382 Hello Einstein, I am just talking about plain and simple L here. No complex stuff. It is available in English as well. It is even present in word ENGLISH.
@@TheKuldiips It seems simple to you. Its not. It depends on the syllable. The Japanese cannot pronounce L. They called Michael Jackson as makeru. You have no idea how tongue gets trained. The brain doesnt even register the mistake Einstein!
@@raicooks1382 He is a bloody American. Where does Japanese pronunciation comes into this? He can very well pronounce L.
Distorted logic.
th-cam.com/video/7fKrLdRVkGw/w-d-xo.html
Lord Vishnu should be noted as the greatest military commander of all time. He defeated The British and the Mongolians without spilling a single drop of blood. Who else in history has ever pacified the greatest military forces of their day? You should not be teaching The Art of War or Arthashastra, you should be teaching The Bhagavad Gita, Upanishads and Yoga Sutras.
Can you explain?
Wtf, u wrote it on purpose. You are probably chuslim.
All texts are great
What is bro yapping?
Bro you really need to read history.. War is the ultimate option & every country who were being ruled, fought for their freedom. No one can gain freedom by non-violence cause the oppressor will never give up.
Half baked knowledge. And yeah empty vessel sounds more. Dude needs some practical and historical knowledge. You have to come out from your delusional world. Bhagvad geeita itslef is the word of Shree Krishna answering to Arjuna during Mahabharata war. If shree krishna himself was not able to stop war , he dude is yelling some Gandhi ahimsabad. Lol. Big lol to you.
22 minutes in and nothing...
Garbage brains can’t take it.
If you don't have this much patience then these texts are not for you
No information
High school kids can’t understand.
@@UmeshSharma-ok5vuthey can and if they can't the teacher is the problem, this guy gives narcissistic vibes
@@hogriderhogw1696 some born racist like you, will hate other civilizations till end of your life. You have been nurtured by giving a tonic of superiority complex. No medication for you.
So that's what an academic job is about mostly. Selling yourself in the most ridiculous ways possible. Gatcha.
Yet they lost war and invaded by Arabs and British
it wasnt one country then - more like 500
We have a history of thousands years. We are the oldest living civilization on earth. Tons of religion came and vanish. SANATAN will survive all times. Even your faith will be vanished pretty soon. ISSA and MOOSA will fight and kill each others. Only Sanatan will be there at end. 😂😂😂
Ups and down are always there. There's a minima after maxima. What matters is that we fought back and after all that many societies have sccummbed but we survived and we have preserved our culture and are reclaiming our place that we once had.
Yes so you shouldn't be here then
Lol, that was centuries after the mauryan empire disintegrated, which is basically also what happened to sun tzus country, and klausewitz's so not sure what your logic is
This is the greatness of the US .. they properly study the other world philosophy and take the good from it
Except the fact that current generation seems extremely bad in geography(it looks like that in interviews).