Great documentary, I like the style of you actually being in these places along the way. What a BRUTAL existence back then. I know this one took some time in the editing room, nice job!
This is OUTSTANDING!!! Can't wait to binge your channel. I've visited so many of these places, but this history and context is incredible! Thank you for all the work.
I've learned a lot about Apache history throughout my life and it's great to see that the information you shared (aside from the pictures, but you made that clear) is very accurate as far as I can tell. It's amazing to see all these original places, thank you for your effort! Greetings from Germany.
Lt. Charles Gatewood is my 5th great-grandfather. I've been on a research project learning all I can about my Gatewood family history. Though I have had some reluctance from my ancestry and 23andme DNA matches that don't look like me to tell me stories about what they know about our shared lineage, this video is appreciated! It helps tremendously. Thank you.
I have seen similar videos and have read many more historical sketches and I think this one is very good and worth watching. Thank you for your hard work in creating this video. 🙈🙉🙊😎🇺🇲
This was fantastic. Excellent research and presenting locations. I recognize many of the Sky Islands you filmed including the Organs, Dragoons, and Chiricahuas.
I'm a Warm Springs Chiricahua Apache that is a 3x great grandson of Warm Springs Chiricahua Apache chief's Victorio, Mangas Coloradas, (descendant of Seth-mooda and Carl Mangas),and Loco, I am also a 2x great grandson of US Chiricahua Apache scouts Charles Martine Sr and Paul Guydelkon Sr. My grandmother Evelyn Martine was the last Chiricahua Apache born as a US prisoner of war in Ft Sill, Oklahoma in 1912. My mother passed away a little over a month ago and she was one of a few full blood Warm Springs Chiricahua Apache left anywhere. I am also Menominee, Badriver Ojibwe and Norwegian hence my Fossum name....
I’d like to learn from you I’m learning my heritage from my dad side he was Apache also Chiricahua I been down to sancarlos and mascalero do get info on the family no luck word is my grandma is a grand daughter of victorio and I want to know if that’s true I’ve read every book about victorio as much as written about him on his kides his sons
@willgonzales5140 There's a book on my family's history from Victorio, it's titled, "Apache Mothers and Daughters ". By Ruth Macdonald Boyer and my mom's aunt Narcissus Gayton. That has our family tree from Victorio and Mangas Coloradas check it out.
Geronimo looks like my old uncle, brother to my grandmother on my mother's side of the family, fiercely independent, rugged leathery sunburn skin, and very wise and he even had a son named Geronimo. He died after putting in a hard day's work out in field in his late 80's.
@ Yes, Yes, how dumb of me. Of course, Mildred. I had the privilege of spending time with her many years ago. She was close friends with one of my mentors as well.
And the photos I see here and elsewhere of mangas Colorado's are not correct. It is his son Mangas. No photos exist of Mangas CV Coloradaa or Cochise. Another pic I saw that was supposed to be Cochise was really Taxa, his son. There are many pics of Naiche however. That is Cochise son that lived, thus was chief. Geronimo was a healer and visionary but not a chief. As far as misidentifying photos of Apaches of that time I've seen tons of caption errors in books.
They did have the right to do so and some of them did but they were outnumbered and outgunned a lot of them died for it but it was sad a lot of people were slaughtered and then what happened to the buffalo insane I was wondering who was in charge in those days very hard to believe they did not read the Constitution.???
Today!! 12/28/24 San Carlos Apaches are still fighting to protect and save their sacred land “OAKFLAT” in Superior AZ. They are waiting for the Supreme Court to pick up the case.
Amongst various theories this one belongs to it, but there are a few others too...that's why no one knows for certain what's the original source for the name.
Some of your story in this video is false not true. This is an Apache story told by a White man. Not an actual Apache like myself whom is a direct decendant to Geronimo. If you want facts on Geronimo and my NDEE Apache relatives find an Apache listen to his story not the White eye
Trust Jesus Christ the SON of GOD!!! Roman’s 10:9 That if thou shalt Confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus, and shalt Believe in thine heart that God hath raised Him from the dead , thou Shalt be Saved . John 14:6 Jesus saith unto them, I am the Way, the Truth, and the Life: No man cometh to the Father, but by Me. 1 John 1:9 If we Confess our sins , He is Faithful and Just to Forgive us our sins , and Cleanse us from All unrighteousness. Confess to Jesus. He Forgave the Murder 👈👈👈Paul who murdered Christians, as Galatians chapter 1 says !!!! If Christ was Not real you would NOT be here because he is the Creator who became Flesh / Human to die for YOU!!!
Strange how Leftists get their collective panties in a bunch when they hear the truth. Just keep believing the lies told by your fearless leaders. Eh, Kameradski?
What is the greatest of all Protestant heresies? Perhaps justification by faith? Perhaps Scripture alone, or one of the other Reformation watchwords?" The greatest of all Protestant heresies is assurance. "The great diversity of Protestant doctrines stems from the doctrine of private judgment, which denies the infallible authority of the Church and claims that each individual is to interpret Scripture for himself. This idea is rejected in 2 Peter 1:20, where we are told the first rule of Bible interpretation: “First of all you must understand this, that no prophecy of Scripture is a matter of one’s own interpretation.” A significant feature of this heresy is the attempt to pit the Church “against” the Bible, denying that the magisterium has any infallible authority to interpret Scripture. This doctrine of private judgment has resulted in thousands of different Christian denominations and quasi-Christian splinter groups throughout history. The Protestant Bible is missing seven books compared to the Catholic Bible, meaning it is incomplete. Missing books are known as the Apocrypha or deuterocanonical books, including Tobit, Judith, Maccabees, Wisdom of Solomon, Baruch, and Sirach. King Henry did not like having to yield his royal authority to the Vatican in matters concerning how he maintained the religious institutions of his own kingdom. He was motivated to make the reforms so that he could divorce his first wife who had failed to provide him with a male heir. Divorce was forbidden by the church that was founded by Christ, Mathew 16-18 And I say to thee: That thou art Peter; and upon this rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it. Leviticus 20-13 read it and understand.
I feel blessed to have been born and raised where Geronimo was born and lived. One of my best friends is Bylas Apache. I hunted n grew up on the Chiricauhuas n eating the deer, rabbit, n quail. San Carlos n Bylas Apaches are the last of the true warriors. They do NOT like the White Mountain apaches, because they were traitors and scouts for the white invaders. Warning to this day, do NOT drive through the San Carlos Apache rez after dark if you are white, you may not get through safely...and there's not a police officer for miles n miles. Travel at your own risk... We are still mad...
Great documentary, I like the style of you actually being in these places along the way. What a BRUTAL existence back then. I know this one took some time in the editing room, nice job!
Great job, brother! I know a ton of work went into this and it shows!
Good information! I learned a lot!
Man so much good information in this. Glad to see this! Never a disappointment when clicking on this channel.
This is OUTSTANDING!!! Can't wait to binge your channel. I've visited so many of these places, but this history and context is incredible! Thank you for all the work.
Thank you for the kind words!!! I hope you fully enjoy the vids!
I've learned a lot about Apache history throughout my life and it's great to see that the information you shared (aside from the pictures, but you made that clear) is very accurate as far as I can tell. It's amazing to see all these original places, thank you for your effort! Greetings from Germany.
Lt. Charles Gatewood is my 5th great-grandfather. I've been on a research project learning all I can about my Gatewood family history. Though I have had some reluctance from my ancestry and 23andme DNA matches that don't look like me to tell me stories about what they know about our shared lineage, this video is appreciated! It helps tremendously. Thank you.
I have seen similar videos and have read many more historical sketches and I think this one is very good and worth watching.
Thank you for your hard work in creating this video.
🙈🙉🙊😎🇺🇲
I REALLY appreciate your kind words. Thank you for taking the time to watch the video and for your comment. :)
Amazing narration. Happy holidays!
Really enjoyed this video!!!! Very well done.
Great job on this one Steve!
Everybody probably hated Geronimo but I love him awesome Shaman I could learn a lot more than what I know now from him
❤ from my part of the Rez
Great work!
This was fantastic. Excellent research and presenting locations. I recognize many of the Sky Islands you filmed including the Organs, Dragoons, and Chiricahuas.
I've never been out West until this past week hiking around the Superstition Mountains and Bell I'm hooked it's magical ✨️
I'm a Warm Springs Chiricahua Apache that is a 3x great grandson of Warm Springs Chiricahua Apache chief's Victorio, Mangas Coloradas, (descendant of Seth-mooda and Carl Mangas),and Loco, I am also a 2x great grandson of US Chiricahua Apache scouts Charles Martine Sr and Paul Guydelkon Sr. My grandmother Evelyn Martine was the last Chiricahua Apache born as a US prisoner of war in Ft Sill, Oklahoma in 1912. My mother passed away a little over a month ago and she was one of a few full blood Warm Springs Chiricahua Apache left anywhere. I am also Menominee, Badriver Ojibwe and Norwegian hence my Fossum name....
I have alot of history of Goyathlay in my head from elders and I grew up with 7 of his great grandsons...
I love your heritage, where do you live now?
@@billybakey9139 I live on the Mescalero Apache reservation where the Chiricahua Apache came after POW release in 1913
I’d like to learn from you I’m learning my heritage from my dad side he was Apache also Chiricahua I been down to sancarlos and mascalero do get info on the family no luck word is my grandma is a grand daughter of victorio and I want to know if that’s true I’ve read every book about victorio as much as written about him on his kides his sons
@willgonzales5140 There's a book on my family's history from Victorio, it's titled, "Apache Mothers and Daughters ". By Ruth Macdonald Boyer and my mom's aunt Narcissus Gayton. That has our family tree from Victorio and Mangas Coloradas check it out.
Keep it up brotha. Good one
Geronimo looks like my old uncle, brother to my grandmother on my mother's side of the family, fiercely independent, rugged leathery sunburn skin, and very wise and he even had a son named Geronimo. He died after putting in a hard day's work out in field in his late 80's.
Back for a 2nd watch. Glad this one is finally catching the traction it deserves!
Good stuff, Steve!!! Wow what rugged land, that I NEED TO SEE
Beautiful country my backyard backs up to the superstitions.
Wow, ONE of the best WARRIORS EVER! John P.
Where’d u source the imagie at 1:21 old crown dancer crowns have always been interesting to me
I live 7 miles from the San Carlos reservation. This history never stops amazing me
He was born approximately 4 miles or so from Clifton Arizona near my hometown of Morenci.
Do you have one on Victorio I would realy love to hear that one
Geronimo must be one of the toughest humans ever to walk on this earth.
That one shot was from Blue Vista Outlook.
Surprised that video of the ruins of Fort Bowie were shown but no mention of the fort and its importance.
My great grandmother was born a P.O.W on fort sill during that time when He was there. She was a niece.
I already knew all these about apaches
Hit Like and Subscribe!
Talk about a tough breed of brave warriors! What a tragedy!
I love it please next American native tribes video shows me sir thank you very much
Edwin R. Sweeney wrote some exellent books about Magas Coloradas and Chochise.
I knew Geronimo’s granddaughter, Margaret Cleghorn. She was president of the Ft. Sill, Ok. Apaches for decades.
Do you mean Mildred Cleghorn?
@ Yes, Yes, how dumb of me. Of course, Mildred. I had the privilege of spending time with her many years ago. She was close friends with one of my mentors as well.
I went to his grave in Fort Sill. It’s actually a very nice resting place.
I see you found the Stronghold with the drone.
And the photos I see here and elsewhere of mangas Colorado's are not correct. It is his son Mangas. No photos exist of Mangas CV Coloradaa or Cochise. Another pic I saw that was supposed to be Cochise was really Taxa, his son. There are many pics of Naiche however. That is Cochise son that lived, thus was chief. Geronimo was a healer and visionary but not a chief. As far as misidentifying photos of Apaches of that time I've seen tons of caption errors in books.
You didn’t watch the whole vid did you? I said those weren’t the actual pics and I also stated Geronimo wasn’t a Chief. Goodness man.
The photo of Cochise is not him but Chato
True.There are no known photos of Cochise.
You mean Charles Bronson !
We are Half Apache,From Stecker and Apache Oklahoma!
There are on photos of Cochise, therefore the photo at 7:35 definitely is not him.
Yep. I know.
The Apache name comes from the Zuni Tribe means "Enemy"
Yes God bless 🙏❤️😇
Yelling "Geronimo" came from the first American to jump out of an aircraft. It's why the 509th airborne goes by "Geronimos"
Would have been good to list your sources.
yeah probably, but I didn't. Thanks for the click!
it’s Jicarilla, the J sounds like an H. And the L’s are silent. it’s pronounced hikaria.
Thanks. I’ll remake the entire to reflect this pronunciation. Just kidding.
Hickaria sounds like where I am…
@@Wiibade gicariLLa? jk. Alien City lol
Today most Americans say they have the right to protect their family and property, but Natives did not have their right to do so.
They did have the right to do so and some of them did but they were outnumbered and outgunned a lot of them died for it but it was sad a lot of people were slaughtered and then what happened to the buffalo insane I was wondering who was in charge in those days very hard to believe they did not read the Constitution.???
...life is and can be tough!
That was a different time. Doesn’t make it right, necessarily, but it was the time.
@@JuanLopez-zp1wxit’s tougher if they’re stupid.
John 3:16
Old saying forgive your enemies but remember their names
Can you do one on captain Lawton and how he died in South America wearing a banana yellow suit?
The title should be "The Wars Against The Apache"
Just like a conqueror. Trying to decid what other things should be called. Gringo es muy tanto.
Today!! 12/28/24 San Carlos Apaches are still fighting to protect and save their sacred land “OAKFLAT” in Superior AZ. They are waiting for the Supreme Court to pick up the case.
He was kept in a dank casemate as a prison cell in Fort Pickens, Pensacola, Florida
Geronimo was despicable. He was a beast, sub human.
Apache is a Zuni world for enemy, my understanding.
Amongst various theories this one belongs to it, but there are a few others too...that's why no one knows for certain what's the original source for the name.
When I was in the army…Apache was a helicopter
Good content but please do your research on pronouncing some of your words
Ok “anonymous person.”
Looks like you ripped off Mr. Hutton's book.
Some of your story in this video is false not true. This is an Apache story told by a White man. Not an actual Apache like myself whom is a direct decendant to Geronimo. If you want facts on Geronimo and my NDEE Apache relatives find an Apache listen to his story not the White eye
That was messed up doing that to the Apache people. What a way to mess up the Apachees .
Jicarilla = Hic-A-Ria.
DUDE. I KNOOOOOOWWW. Im not remaking the damn video because I mis-pronounced something.
Several others.....leaving out the NAVAJOS LOL like we aint got a whole nation
I am well aware of the Navajo's - they are a storied tribe. What role did they play with Geronimo?
@GoWildHistory man that Apaches and Navajos go way back
@GoWildHistory are you native American
Trust Jesus Christ the SON of GOD!!! Roman’s 10:9 That if thou shalt Confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus, and shalt Believe in thine heart that God hath raised Him from the dead , thou Shalt be Saved . John 14:6 Jesus saith unto them, I am the Way, the Truth, and the Life: No man cometh to the Father, but by Me. 1 John 1:9 If we Confess our sins , He is Faithful and Just to Forgive us our sins , and Cleanse us from All unrighteousness. Confess to Jesus. He Forgave the Murder 👈👈👈Paul who murdered Christians, as Galatians chapter 1 says !!!! If Christ was Not real you would NOT be here because he is the Creator who became Flesh / Human to die for YOU!!!
Shame on you for making such an insensitive comment here.
Strange how Leftists get their collective panties in a bunch when they hear the truth. Just keep believing the lies told by your fearless leaders. Eh, Kameradski?
What is the greatest of all Protestant heresies? Perhaps justification by faith? Perhaps Scripture alone, or one of the other Reformation watchwords?" The greatest of all Protestant heresies is assurance. "The great diversity of Protestant doctrines stems from the doctrine of private judgment, which denies the infallible authority of the Church and claims that each individual is to interpret Scripture for himself. This idea is rejected in 2 Peter 1:20, where we are told the first rule of Bible interpretation: “First of all you must understand this, that no prophecy of Scripture is a matter of one’s own interpretation.” A significant feature of this heresy is the attempt to pit the Church “against” the Bible, denying that the magisterium has any infallible authority to interpret Scripture. This doctrine of private judgment has resulted in thousands of different Christian denominations and quasi-Christian splinter groups throughout history. The Protestant Bible is missing seven books compared to the Catholic Bible, meaning it is incomplete. Missing books are known as the Apocrypha or deuterocanonical books, including Tobit, Judith, Maccabees, Wisdom of Solomon, Baruch, and Sirach. King Henry did not like having to yield his royal authority to the Vatican in matters concerning how he maintained the religious institutions of his own kingdom. He was motivated to make the reforms so that he could divorce his first wife who had failed to provide him with a male heir. Divorce was forbidden by the church that was founded by Christ, Mathew 16-18 And I say to thee: That thou art Peter; and upon this rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it. Leviticus 20-13 read it and understand.
Just stop.
I feel blessed to have been born and raised where Geronimo was born and lived. One of my best friends is Bylas Apache. I hunted n grew up on the Chiricauhuas n eating the deer, rabbit, n quail. San Carlos n Bylas Apaches are the last of the true warriors. They do NOT like the White Mountain apaches, because they were traitors and scouts for the white invaders. Warning to this day, do NOT drive through the San Carlos Apache rez after dark if you are white, you may not get through safely...and there's not a police officer for miles n miles. Travel at your own risk... We are still mad...
❤❤❤❤