Can you please do an updated video on wearable pumps? I’d like to hear your thoughts on these pumps as well as other wearables now that willow go has been out for a while. It would be awesome to see a video of wearable pumps like you have for portable pumps comparing them best to worst in different categories!
I need the suction, which puts Willow brand above Elvie for me. Elvie stride is out - if I want to deal with tubes, I'll use my regular pump. The Willow Go is my pic over Willow 3.0 because 1) You can move between stimulation and expression mode. I always have issues with my let down and the 3.0 didn't give the flexibility I need. 2) I don't want to use the app (I use Huckleberry so all my baby stuff is right there together). But I like that if needed I can see the suction level. (Big fail by Medela on their new pump that's replacing the pump in style ☹️). 3) The 3.0 had a lot of bad reviews with troubleshooting and error messages. Only two things to clean but they seemed to always throw an error. When I'm ready to pump, it's go time. No time for playing around with an error message. 4) I just need to be able to wash the dishes or change a diaper or watch the kids outside while pumping, I don't need to turn upside down while pumping or try to sleep while pumping. Plus 360 movement was only possible when using the bags with the 3.0, which are expensive. Willow Go is my pic over Elvie because 1) suction. (However, I found no matter what pump, it's gotta be TIGHT to get enough suction for me.) Otherwise they seem the same - same mobility, same pumping features. Elvie's app let's you operate the pump from the app, which women looking for discretion might like better. But again, I have no intention of using the app. And Willow Go has the option of buying larger storage, but really, I never pumped over 3 oz per breast. I always find it funny when women say they get 25 oz from one pumping session. Not sure what that's all about, but hasn't been the case for me.
I got the willow go and so far have been really happy with it! My 5th son that was born in Dec has been having milk transfer issues but with having 5 kids I needed something mobile to have any hope of pumping with any consistency. So far I like it and I feel like the spectra and I get about the same output.
I do the fridge hack with my willow go, but pushing the flange into the hole after I take the motor out and it works great and takes up little to no space!
@@tehziashaheen5714for my spectra, the fridge hack works great! I pumped every 2 hours and it helped out so I didn't need to clean after every pump. It's where you put your flange/bottles in the refrigerator between pumps rather than cleaning after each use. It's not recommended by cdc. Obviously cleaning after each use is more sanitary and the better option if you have the time. I used it while working to save some time.
Thanks for the review. I ended up selling the willow go. It weighed me down so much I had to really tighten my bra straps to keep the pumps in place then I just felt like I was stretching out and ruining my expensive nursing bras. I did like the suction. The other thing that annoyed me though was you can only turn it off and on and adjust the setting from the pump it’s self not the app. The app only tells you what setting you have it on and the time which isn’t very useful. I got the pump because I wanted to be more discreet but it’s not very discreet when I have to lift up my shirt to turn it on or adjust the settings. Im now considering the Elvie stride. I originally decided against it because of the tubes but now I think it will be nice to adjust the settings from a pump that is separate so I don’t have to worry about lifting up my shirt in public and also hoping it won’t be so bulky since it’s just the cups.
Alison, love your pump comparisons! You do such a great job and are so helpful for practical tips and tricks with all these pumps. I'm also an IBCLC but getting to be a "pump expert" is a job of it's own. THANK YOU SO MUCH for taking this on. I'm a big fan!
I’d be interested in the weight difference between them! I find the willow 3.0 quite heavy and the elvie stride quite lighter. Obviously, it doesn’t have the motors and cups together but I would be interested to see a weight comparison between the 4.
@@darktalesmystic I’m so glad I saw this comment! I was going to purchase the Willow go, but I wondered how it would compare with ouput vrs the Freemie.
I bought the Tommie Tippee hands free pumps and I’m extremely disappointed. I was only able to get one pump to work correctly and only once. It’s so weird and finicky. Now I’m nervous to buy another hands free pump because of the horrible experience with the Tommie Tippee. Ugh. It’s overwhelming to find the right pump for my needs but glad I found your channel last week. Have been researching as much as I can before I purchase a new one.
I hear a lot about how wearables are not good primary pumps because it doesn’t empty well, which I do understand! But is there research done to see what some of those factors are? Such as breast cup size, flange size, etc.? They always advertise as hospital grade so to a normal consumer it sounds the same as electric pumps so I am confused by all the options.
Can you make a video with your top suggestions for someone who exclusive pumps? I plan to with baby #2 but I travel across the country in the states and am on the road quite often. Definitely need something portable as we are in the car for 6+ hours at a time very often.
Hi Allison! This is so helpful! I know you said you don’t recommend the elvie stride as the primary pump but do you feel the same about the willow go? I have a spectra from my first but really want to be primarily hands free and considering the willow go as my primary pump! Thanks in advance!
I had the same question! I want to buy one pump and be one and done. Do you think the Willow Go would cut it for most people? Or would you still recommend having another pump? This momma can't buy two.
@@laurenkline3321I've always heard from my lactation consultants that your primary pump should be something like the spectra. These ones that go in the bra shouldn't be primary pumps. I'm hoping the willow go is comparable though.
Can you talk about the noise, how loud are they and also how do the suctions feel compared to the spectra pumps? Can willow go be a good option for working moms?
I don't think the willow go was ready for the market. I have seen so many cases of people who've gotten the willow go, they use it, and then they have issues. Milk in the motor, everything not snapping together, one side not connecting etc. It's crazy to me.
Thank you for this comparison. I was considering the Elvie original before watching this and now thinking I will purchase the Willow Go. I am curious though, I was recently reminded that I dealt with vasospasms with my first baby. I may have blocked out the trauma from that but from what I remember, it was worse when nursing than when I pumped. I have a Spectra S1 that I plan to use as my main pump for baby #2 and the Willow Go would be for convenience when not wanting to lug around the Spectra. You mention that the Elvie has a gentler suction than that of the Willow. Do you think that would be better should I be dealing with vasospasms again this time around?
I love my willow go and get the same output as my lanisoh. I just got the 7oz containers at target and I'm super happy it comes with higher capacity as I totally over flowed one cup yesterday 😂
So with the willow go you are not able to use the fridge hack? Can you explain further why? I see that the motor is in the middle but milk shouldn’t be touching it so I’m just wondering why?
I’d like to know if these portable wearable pumps work on all chest sizes. I wear a 38-40 DDD normally and I have breastfed 3 going on four children. So I just wanted to see if this may be a good fit for me since I’m still chasing littles around. I’d like to pump in the go if possible.
Hi! Thank you for the reviews! I'm a FTM, I work in healthcare, on my feet all day. I'm wondering, can elaborate on why the elvie stride isn't good for a primary pump and why you recommend it moreso only for house moms? Is the Willow Go okay for a primary pump? Thank you for your vids!! 🧡
Thank you for your reviews! I decided to get the Willow Go for myself when I go back to work + use my Spectra as my base pump! I love your videos + have learned so much. This will be my third pregnancy + I’m very hopeful of having better success with breastfeeding with this Babe after educating myself with all your information from your channel ❤
I’m so happy to hear this Janell!! 💙 if you want even more personalized support, let me know. I love working with moms like you! Www.Newlittlelife.Com/pumping-for-working-moms
Hi ! I wanted to know which is easier to express more milk and maintain milk supply for mommies that have had a dificult time increasing and maintaining milk supply ? Like si hace a medela sonata and it helped me sometimes I hace tongo and do things ( baby number 2 in the way ) so which one would you recomend in these cases?
Would you choose zomee fit, Willow go, or elvie stride? These are all upgrades through my insurance and I’m having a hard time deciding… It looks like most of TH-cam pump reviews are sponsored ads
Hi Alison...thank you so much for all your work...could you please advise between willow go and elvie stride which one would you choose as secondry pump for full time working in a office...thank you so much
@@NewLittleLife Hi Alison...thank you so much for the helpfull information....i watched it all and i would love to be aware everytime you have webinar...however still unsure if the pumpable GA could be used as main pump or not...i know its a good pump...but wanted to make sure before purchasing....many thanks
@@NewLittleLife thanks for your replay....i wont be puming to have too much frezer staches...but would like to have 2 pumps...1 to be my main and 1 to use it at work...which i get the Pumpable GA for the main one and not sure which one for secondary pump...maybe elvie stride..not sure hunestly....just want something very quiet...as our office is very quiet...thanks
If you were to choose 1 pump between the Elvie original, Elvie Stride/Plus, Willow 3.0, or Willow Go, which would you choose? I think I'm between the original Elvie and the Willow Go but would love an expert's opinion! Thank you!
It kinda depends I guess! I’m super impressed with the new Willow Go so far, both with price and functionality. But, make the choice that seems to fit you best :)
Wait! You have to explain why you think the stride isn’t enough for a working mom. I put baby on the breast every time I can, but I used the original elvie with my first and pumped 2-3 times per day (had to-medical field), and plan to do the same with the stride now with my second baby! Any input?
What is it about the Elvie Stride that makes you feel like it ‘won’t cut it’ and you would need another pump too? I’m the momma of a preemie who had a c-section and I have really had to work at my milk supply because of it. I ended up having to rent the hospital Madela pump to help my supply along, as I think I needed a little strength to help. I’m returning to work soon and just want to provide for my little guy.
From what you describe, definitely not the stride! The gentle suction along with the cups style flange likely would be a bad combo for you. I help moms just like you inside my program if you want help all along he way! Www.Newlittlelife.Com/pumping-for-working-moms
I think it can work, but I hesitate to make a blanket recommendation for everyone because In my experience it’s kinda hit a miss. So if you think it would work for you, take my recommendation with a grain of salt! You know you best, what features are important to you, and what you need. Don’t be afraid to do it if it still feels right! I guess my only recommendation would be to be open to MAYBE buying another pump if you find it doesn’t work well for you. If you’re ok with that risk, give it a go for sure. It might be just fine!
@@NewLittleLife Thank you for responding! I do have the Spectra Gold as well I just want the stride for mobility with my toddler too. and if it works more than my spectra then ill stick with it! I love your content!
I started using the original elvie just a few days ago and the first day I saw an increase in milk production. I was using medela pump in style…horrible pump for me.
Alison, I am a fan of your videos! I am considering buying Willow Go or Imani wearable pump. I am currently using super genie advanced as main as it works better than my S2. I respond well to LM cups too. Besides the pricing and visual difference, do you have any opinions between the two?
Willow Go is sold out everywhere. I asked them to refund me after one week of no shipping updates. Giving Elvie stride a shot because….well…it’s available and I want a handsfree pump lol
Hospital grade isn’t really thing, and I definitely wouldn’t classify the elvie stride in the same category as a pump found in a hospital. The pump is pretty good, but small and likely won’t hold up to heavy use. Paired with the cups makes it even tricker to get right. If you’re just pumping occasionally, it’s likely just fine! Heavy use though I’d be a little worried about it doing a good enough job. Works for some people though!
I purchased the willow go a few days after it came out. So far I am having a great experience. I bought this pump because my newborn is having latch/milk transfer issues and I am pumping most of her milk. I'm using this pump at least 4 times a day. There are pros and cons though. Pros: No wires or tubes which is great if you are trying to care for a baby at the same time. It's also great for house work and in the car (while you aren't driving). The suction is pretty good and I get comparable milk output to my spectra S1 pump. Cons: it makes you look ridiculously busty and is hard to fit in some nursing bras. My husband giggled a bit and asked me to please never get implants after he saw it 🤣 It is very hard to use compression/ breast massage with this pump so I am alternating with the spectra pump I have. Cleaning it and drying it multiple times a day is time consuming.
My Elvie stride died after three weeks. But I bought it during pregnancy and the shop I bought it from won’t help me now and Elvie doesn’t even answer to my mail. I really liked the Elvie stride though. I’m wondering now if the stride cups will work with another mobile pump, like the Duette or genie advanced. Or maybe I should buy the willow….I need a hands free pump for work.
I am due in July with baby number 5 and am trying to choose the best wearable pump I can use full time can I ask why you don’t think the stride would be good full time and if you think the willow go would be better for full time use?
Hi Alison. Im so glad to have found your video ❤❤❤ If you can assist me, im a working mom and an exclusive pumping mom too. I work as a customer service consultant and need to be at my desk most of the time, to answer call. There will be time that require me to meet up with my client as well.. So i really need an effective pump, to ensure i can maintain my milk supply and at the same time i need a discreet pump as well. Im thinking of purchasing elvie stride. Do you think this pump will work for me? Really appreciate your kind feedback on my concern 🤗🤗🥰🥰
I’d love to help and support you through it all! I work with moms to help protect your milk supply after returning to work by pumping fast and efficiently. We can chat about the best pumps for you inside the program, we do that often! Feel free to apply here, it sounds like exactly what you’re looking for! calendly.com/d/d3c-8c2-jvj
For some they work well! For others, they don’t. Typically, I don’t recommend them as a general rule but it depends on the individual. Sometimes I do for members in my program who I get to know a little better!
I heard Willow Go has similar suction to the Spectra S1. Is this true? If not, what wearable (or at least portable) pump would you recommend if I use the Spectra as my main pump and respond well to it?
The willow go is a very “standard” suction pattern, similar to a lot of non-wearable pumps. The genie advanced from pumpables is my favorite portable pump for users who like the spectra.
I am a person that needs soft suction bc I have sensitive breast. I am leaning toward the Elvie pumps. How do you think i would like the willow go since they have changed the suction
Thank you as always for an awesome, informative video. I’m still debating if I am going to get a fancy wearable but the WG or original Elvie are my top two right now… it’s a large investment and it’s always so polarizing with superb reviews and terrible ones 🤷🏻♀️ I’m curious about the sound levels while in use?… and the battery life for the Willow Go? If any one has insight, I would love to hear it!
Yes the noise level and the battery life are my 2 concerns as well. Did you happen to make a choice and complete purchase? If so can you please tell me which one you went with and how you’re liking it??
I use the mortif duo and I pump on 3 for stimulation then in expression I pump on 4 then I up it to 5 then into 7 over the 15 minutes I pump. Im thinking the willow go would be just fine for me and I usually only get 2-3oz for each breast even in the morning right now. I exclusively breast feed but am going back to work.
I bought the elvie and no milk comes out. I contacted elvie company and they sent me a new set. But no difference was noticed and no milk is collected.
Hi! Does nipple size affect the productivity of the wearables at all? And can you modify at all if you’re not one of the offered flange sizes (e.g., I use a 15mm with my Spectra). Thanks!
Can you do the fridge hack with the Willow Go? I’m a FTM who has been exclusively breastfeeding for the past 4 months but I have to go back to work soon and I don’t know if I’ll have the time to clean all the parts between pumping sessions. Trying to decide if the Willow Go is right for me! Thanks!
Good question! Any of these, if you’re pumping while moving around, only the Willow can accommodate a leak free solution. If you’ll be more stationary while actually pumping, look at cost, size, and features you may want.
Ok for a FTM who needs to make a decision before first baby is born for insurance purposes HOW do we know?!? So much of this video is dependent on what you like, how your boobs are etc. But we don't know the answer to these things yet! It's still a very informative video especially with the graphs to help visualize. But I'm no less confused on what I'm going to buy.
I know, I’m so sorry! At the end of the day, you just need to make a decision based on your budget and the situation in which you’ll be pumping. If you’re a working mom, I do have additional resources to help with this decision!! www.Newlittlelife.com
Any time I look at pump comparisons, it seems like higher suction is preferred. Personally, I need very little suction. Too much suction actually is painful for me. Do people tend to need more suction?
It really varies a lot! For those that like or need a gentler feel, these Elives tend to be great options. They all have plenty of suction capabilities for most all users so no worries there.
The Mommed pump works great for me as far as emptying me, but the motors are unreliable. I’ve had to buy it multiple times. I’ve given up on it because one of the motors almost gave out on a trip. I just ordered the WillowGo. I’m hoping the suction will be gentle enough. I tried out the MomCozy 12 Pro. That pump felt like it was ripping my nipples off even on the lowest setting.
So far the Willow Go has been working great for me. It doesn’t have super strong suction which is great for me. I don’t need high suction to be emptied. The app is neat and convenient. With the 7 oz containers which I use because I’m an oversupplier, they are bulky and I’m big chested already. The parts are a bit confusing at first. Also, you can’t steam sterilize the parts which is kind of a pain. Another downside is that they don’t seal so you can spill.
I already have the spectra S1. I am looking for a more portable pump. Do you recommend the Willow go vs the medela freestyle flex? Really stuck here. Any help would be great!
@@NewLittleLife I am ok with either. I work from home and will soon have 2 under 2. I am going to get the legendary cups as well. I’d just like more portability in case I have to run and do something or check on the kids.
@@karlavillagomez6521 I ended up getting the Willow go and the pumpables genie advanced during their Black Friday sale. I use my spectra S1 and pumpables GA daily. I love it. The Willow go is great when I’m on the go but it doesn’t fully empty me so I end up pumping for a longer time.
Does anyone know if the Elvie Stride or Willow Go have a sensor to let you know when your cups are full and do they auto-stop? I love this feature on the Elvie (original).
Hi Allison. Question for you about the Willow 3.0; I’m currently battling a low milk supply and am looking for a new wearable to pump to help me miss less pump sessions. You had mentioned needing a certain volume for the Willow to switch to expression mode. Is there also a time limit before it would switch? Or do you just get stuck in stimulation mode if you make under 0.5 oz/breast? I own the Elvie, but unfortunately my body doesn’t respond well to its gentle suction…
Ok..so..iknow the elvie curve/haakaa are essentially manual pumps. But, do you think they compare to the wearable breast pumps as far as milk yielded? Because I can't decide if I want to get the elvie curve or if I should invest in an actual wearable pump like the willow or elvie for occasional use when I can't use my spectra.
The elvie curve and haakaa are NOT manual pumps. They are simply milk catchers that have a little extra suction. If you can’t make a pumping session with your spectra, you’ll need an actual pump like the ones in this video to remove the milk. A milk catcher (even with suction) will not remove milk effectively. Hope that helps!
If anyone has used willow 3.0 and now the willow go, would you say it’s better for elastic nipples? I might have to sell my willow 3.0 because I used it again after so long since I just went back to work and it bruised my nipples soo bad, I dunno how I used it as my only pump for so long! I need something wearable at work
I'm due with baby #3 in Sept. This will make 3 kiddos 3 & under when this one comes... so I need portable. I know I have elastic nipples, is there one that you would recommend that works better with elastic nipples?
Hi Andrea. I have 3 kids 3 and under with my youngest being almost 5 months old. I also have elastic nipples. I have tried the original elvie and the willow 3.0. I respond much better with the elvie however it does not have the leakproof capability. I purchased the willow 3.0 with this baby bc the leakproof bags, but I just don’t respond to it well at all. I plan on selling it to try the willow go.
I’m curious why you believe stride wouldn’t be an everyday pump and you say more than likely if we get it we will need another? Do you feel the same about the willow go? I have a back up pump in case this happens but I’m just curious as to why you believe this. Thanks for your time 🙏🏼
Good question :) this is COMPLETELY my own opinion. Im not confident that a wearable pump (and especially the elvie stride due to how gentle the suction is) can empty quite as efficiently as a traditional flange. For some people it does well, but in a general video like this I hesitate to recommended it as a good option in a blanket general statement. For the students in my program who I know their situations, they needs, and their milk supply, I could more confidently recommend something like this if it was appropriate. Does that make sense? The elvie stride in particular though has a unique suction feel and the reviews on it have been mixed so far. So without taking directly to someone, I choose to create my opinion in the way I stated it in the video. If you want to hear me talk about about this topic, I do in my webinars! www.newlittlelife.com/breast-pump-webinars/
The only thing holding me back is the fear of fitting my large breasts in portables. Size 36H bra with 15mm flange. Do you have input from large breasted clients?
![[TH] 2024 PMGC League | Survival Stage วันที่ 1 | PUBG MOBILE Global Championship](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FVFT-PFwU80/mqdefault.jpg)
![BOWKYLION - วิงวอน (ex-change) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cLdnZWDaO-w/mqdefault.jpg)
Can you please do an updated video on wearable pumps? I’d like to hear your thoughts on these pumps as well as other wearables now that willow go has been out for a while. It would be awesome to see a video of wearable pumps like you have for portable pumps comparing them best to worst in different categories!
I need the suction, which puts Willow brand above Elvie for me. Elvie stride is out - if I want to deal with tubes, I'll use my regular pump. The Willow Go is my pic over Willow 3.0 because 1) You can move between stimulation and expression mode. I always have issues with my let down and the 3.0 didn't give the flexibility I need. 2) I don't want to use the app (I use Huckleberry so all my baby stuff is right there together). But I like that if needed I can see the suction level. (Big fail by Medela on their new pump that's replacing the pump in style ☹️). 3) The 3.0 had a lot of bad reviews with troubleshooting and error messages. Only two things to clean but they seemed to always throw an error. When I'm ready to pump, it's go time. No time for playing around with an error message. 4) I just need to be able to wash the dishes or change a diaper or watch the kids outside while pumping, I don't need to turn upside down while pumping or try to sleep while pumping. Plus 360 movement was only possible when using the bags with the 3.0, which are expensive. Willow Go is my pic over Elvie because 1) suction. (However, I found no matter what pump, it's gotta be TIGHT to get enough suction for me.) Otherwise they seem the same - same mobility, same pumping features. Elvie's app let's you operate the pump from the app, which women looking for discretion might like better. But again, I have no intention of using the app. And Willow Go has the option of buying larger storage, but really, I never pumped over 3 oz per breast. I always find it funny when women say they get 25 oz from one pumping session. Not sure what that's all about, but hasn't been the case for me.
😢😢😢😢😅😅😅😅😮😮😢😢😊😅😊😅😅😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
I got the willow go and so far have been really happy with it! My 5th son that was born in Dec has been having milk transfer issues but with having 5 kids I needed something mobile to have any hope of pumping with any consistency. So far I like it and I feel like the spectra and I get about the same output.
Thanks for your input! I’ve been impressed with it as well.
@@NewLittleLife is it gentle?
Much gentler than the original willow! Not as gentle as the elvie pumps.
I do the fridge hack with my willow go, but pushing the flange into the hole after I take the motor out and it works great and takes up little to no space!
What does that mean & what is fridge hack
Did the suction stay the same after you use it again?
@@tehziashaheen5714for my spectra, the fridge hack works great! I pumped every 2 hours and it helped out so I didn't need to clean after every pump. It's where you put your flange/bottles in the refrigerator between pumps rather than cleaning after each use. It's not recommended by cdc. Obviously cleaning after each use is more sanitary and the better option if you have the time. I used it while working to save some time.
Can you do an updated video on these pumps and also include noise levels? Really curious how the stride compares with Willow Go
I’m a community health nurse and currently 20 weeks pregnant. Thanks for this review and for making the mannequin wear scrubs 😂
Thanks for the review. I ended up selling the willow go. It weighed me down so much I had to really tighten my bra straps to keep the pumps in place then I just felt like I was stretching out and ruining my expensive nursing bras. I did like the suction. The other thing that annoyed me though was you can only turn it off and on and adjust the setting from the pump it’s self not the app. The app only tells you what setting you have it on and the time which isn’t very useful. I got the pump because I wanted to be more discreet but it’s not very discreet when I have to lift up my shirt to turn it on or adjust the settings. Im now considering the Elvie stride. I originally decided against it because of the tubes but now I think it will be nice to adjust the settings from a pump that is separate so I don’t have to worry about lifting up my shirt in public and also hoping it won’t be so bulky since it’s just the cups.
Alison, love your pump comparisons! You do such a great job and are so helpful for practical tips and tricks with all these pumps. I'm also an IBCLC but getting to be a "pump expert" is a job of it's own. THANK YOU SO MUCH for taking this on. I'm a big fan!
Thank you Cindy! I’d love to connect with you sometime if you’d like :) allison@newlittlelife.com
I’d be interested in the weight difference between them! I find the willow 3.0 quite heavy and the elvie stride quite lighter. Obviously, it doesn’t have the motors and cups together but I would be interested to see a weight comparison between the 4.
Is the Willow Go a pump you recommended as the only pump? You said you don’t recommend it for the stride but how about the Willow go ?
I switch back & forth between the freemie and Willow go.. i get about 10 oz less a day with the Willow go, but it’s way more convenient without tubing
@@darktalesmystic I’m so glad I saw this comment! I was going to purchase the Willow go, but I wondered how it would compare with ouput vrs the Freemie.
I bought the Tommie Tippee hands free pumps and I’m extremely disappointed. I was only able to get one pump to work correctly and only once. It’s so weird and finicky. Now I’m nervous to buy another hands free pump because of the horrible experience with the Tommie Tippee. Ugh. It’s overwhelming to find the right pump for my needs but glad I found your channel last week. Have been researching as much as I can before I purchase a new one.
I hear a lot about how wearables are not good primary pumps because it doesn’t empty well, which I do understand! But is there research done to see what some of those factors are? Such as breast cup size, flange size, etc.? They always advertise as hospital grade so to a normal consumer it sounds the same as electric pumps so I am confused by all the options.
Curious about the go vs stride as far as leaking/ spilling and also info about flange insert?
Can you make a video with your top suggestions for someone who exclusive pumps? I plan to with baby #2 but I travel across the country in the states and am on the road quite often. Definitely need something portable as we are in the car for 6+ hours at a time very often.
Hi Allison! This is so helpful! I know you said you don’t recommend the elvie stride as the primary pump but do you feel the same about the willow go? I have a spectra from my first but really want to be primarily hands free and considering the willow go as my primary pump! Thanks in advance!
I had the same question! I want to buy one pump and be one and done. Do you think the Willow Go would cut it for most people? Or would you still recommend having another pump? This momma can't buy two.
@@laurenkline3321I've always heard from my lactation consultants that your primary pump should be something like the spectra. These ones that go in the bra shouldn't be primary pumps. I'm hoping the willow go is comparable though.
Can you talk about the noise, how loud are they and also how do the suctions feel compared to the spectra pumps? Can willow go be a good option for working moms?
Original willow is noisy, that what I have just known from another vedio
You mention the suction strength is stronger with the Willow Go. How do these compare to the Spectra pump suction strength?
Thank you for the comparison! Very helpful! What do they sound like???
I don't think the willow go was ready for the market. I have seen so many cases of people who've gotten the willow go, they use it, and then they have issues. Milk in the motor, everything not snapping together, one side not connecting etc. It's crazy to me.
Thank you for this comparison. I was considering the Elvie original before watching this and now thinking I will purchase the Willow Go. I am curious though, I was recently reminded that I dealt with vasospasms with my first baby. I may have blocked out the trauma from that but from what I remember, it was worse when nursing than when I pumped. I have a Spectra S1 that I plan to use as my main pump for baby #2 and the Willow Go would be for convenience when not wanting to lug around the Spectra. You mention that the Elvie has a gentler suction than that of the Willow. Do you think that would be better should I be dealing with vasospasms again this time around?
How did it go? Are you liking the willow go?
I'd like to see an in clothes comparison between the Willow 3.0 and the WillowGo!
Mama shark has a video comparing both
I love my willow go and get the same output as my lanisoh. I just got the 7oz containers at target and I'm super happy it comes with higher capacity as I totally over flowed one cup yesterday 😂
Yay! Sorry about the overflow but seriously awesome at the same time 😂
So with the willow go you are not able to use the fridge hack? Can you explain further why? I see that the motor is in the middle but milk shouldn’t be touching it so I’m just wondering why?
I saw someone else said they just took the motor out and did the hack?
I’d like to know if these portable wearable pumps work on all chest sizes. I wear a 38-40 DDD normally and I have breastfed 3 going on four children. So I just wanted to see if this may be a good fit for me since I’m still chasing littles around. I’d like to pump in the go if possible.
Hi! Thank you for the reviews! I'm a FTM, I work in healthcare, on my feet all day. I'm wondering, can elaborate on why the elvie stride isn't good for a primary pump and why you recommend it moreso only for house moms?
Is the Willow Go okay for a primary pump?
Thank you for your vids!! 🧡
I talk about it more in this webinar!
www.newlittlelifelessons.com/pl/2147586053
@@NewLittleLife awesome! Thank you!!
I am curious how you test it and get these graphs???
Thank you for your reviews! I decided to get the Willow Go for myself when I go back to work + use my Spectra as my base pump! I love your videos + have learned so much. This will be my third pregnancy + I’m very hopeful of having better success with breastfeeding with this Babe after educating myself with all your information from your channel ❤
I’m so happy to hear this Janell!! 💙 if you want even more personalized support, let me know. I love working with moms like you! Www.Newlittlelife.Com/pumping-for-working-moms
As of May 1st the stride plus will be available at target!
Hi ! I wanted to know which is easier to express more milk and maintain milk supply for mommies that have had a dificult time increasing and maintaining milk supply ? Like si hace a medela sonata and it helped me sometimes I hace tongo and do things ( baby number 2 in the way ) so which one would you recomend in these cases?
Willow go vs original elvie?
What’s easier to clean? The Willow go or OG elvie?
Would you choose zomee fit, Willow go, or elvie stride? These are all upgrades through my insurance and I’m having a hard time deciding…
It looks like most of TH-cam pump reviews are sponsored ads
Thank you. Your videos are very helpful. Can you compare the new Tommee Tippee Made For me with the original Elvie and Willow 3.0?
What’s the best wearable pump for the fridge hack?
Hi Alison...thank you so much for all your work...could you please advise between willow go and elvie stride which one would you choose as secondry pump for full time working in a office...thank you so much
I talk about that here!
Best Breast Pumps for Working Moms Recorded Webinar: www.newlittlelifelessons.com/pl/2147586053
@@NewLittleLife Hi Alison...thank you so much for the helpfull information....i watched it all and i would love to be aware everytime you have webinar...however still unsure if the pumpable GA could be used as main pump or not...i know its a good pump...but wanted to make sure before purchasing....many thanks
@@Setareh-tr7se It's a great pump honestly, will you be using it for exclusive pumping?
@@NewLittleLife thanks for your replay....i wont be puming to have too much frezer staches...but would like to have 2 pumps...1 to be my main and 1 to use it at work...which i get the Pumpable GA for the main one and not sure which one for secondary pump...maybe elvie stride..not sure hunestly....just want something very quiet...as our office is very quiet...thanks
If you were to choose 1 pump between the Elvie original, Elvie Stride/Plus, Willow 3.0, or Willow Go, which would you choose? I think I'm between the original Elvie and the Willow Go but would love an expert's opinion! Thank you!
It kinda depends I guess! I’m super impressed with the new Willow Go so far, both with price and functionality. But, make the choice that seems to fit you best :)
Ok now I'd love to see the Momcozy line!! Especially the effectiveness and suction tests..
For sure! I’m just working on getting those pumps ordered and tested, they keep coming out with new ones 🙈
Wait! You have to explain why you think the stride isn’t enough for a working mom. I put baby on the breast every time I can, but I used the original elvie with my first and pumped 2-3 times per day (had to-medical field), and plan to do the same with the stride now with my second baby! Any input?
Those graphs are awesome! 🙌🏼 I really like the Willow Go but never tried the Stride.
Would you recommend the willow go for an under supplier
What is it about the Elvie Stride that makes you feel like it ‘won’t cut it’ and you would need another pump too? I’m the momma of a preemie who had a c-section and I have really had to work at my milk supply because of it. I ended up having to rent the hospital Madela pump to help my supply along, as I think I needed a little strength to help. I’m returning to work soon and just want to provide for my little guy.
From what you describe, definitely not the stride! The gentle suction along with the cups style flange likely would be a bad combo for you.
I help moms just like you inside my program if you want help all along he way! Www.Newlittlelife.Com/pumping-for-working-moms
I'm kind of surprised that you don't recommend the stride for full time, I'm in a stride group and a lot of women use it to EP. hmmm now I'm torn.
I think it can work, but I hesitate to make a blanket recommendation for everyone because In my experience it’s kinda hit a miss. So if you think it would work for you, take my recommendation with a grain of salt! You know you best, what features are important to you, and what you need. Don’t be afraid to do it if it still feels right! I guess my only recommendation would be to be open to MAYBE buying another pump if you find it doesn’t work well for you. If you’re ok with that risk, give it a go for sure. It might be just fine!
@@NewLittleLife Thank you for responding! I do have the Spectra Gold as well I just want the stride for mobility with my toddler too. and if it works more than my spectra then ill stick with it! I love your content!
Thank you very much,I want to ask about the original elvie pump if I need pump to sue during the day and I am able to move is it the best or willow ?
I started using the original elvie just a few days ago and the first day I saw an increase in milk production. I was using medela pump in style…horrible pump for me.
Alison, I am a fan of your videos! I am considering buying Willow Go or Imani wearable pump. I am currently using super genie advanced as main as it works better than my S2. I respond well to LM cups too. Besides the pricing and visual difference, do you have any opinions between the two?
The willow go is pretty conviennent! If it’s in your budget, I do really like it.
Willow Go is sold out everywhere. I asked them to refund me after one week of no shipping updates. Giving Elvie stride a shot because….well…it’s available and I want a handsfree pump lol
Can you explain why you'd need a second pump if you go with the Elvie Stride? My understanding is that the Stride is Hospital Grade.
Hospital grade isn’t really thing, and I definitely wouldn’t classify the elvie stride in the same category as a pump found in a hospital.
The pump is pretty good, but small and likely won’t hold up to heavy use. Paired with the cups makes it even tricker to get right.
If you’re just pumping occasionally, it’s likely just fine! Heavy use though I’d be a little worried about it doing a good enough job. Works for some people though!
I have been looking so forward to this video! 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
I purchased the willow go a few days after it came out. So far I am having a great experience. I bought this pump because my newborn is having latch/milk transfer issues and I am pumping most of her milk. I'm using this pump at least 4 times a day. There are pros and cons though.
Pros: No wires or tubes which is great if you are trying to care for a baby at the same time. It's also great for house work and in the car (while you aren't driving).
The suction is pretty good and I get comparable milk output to my spectra S1 pump.
Cons: it makes you look ridiculously busty and is hard to fit in some nursing bras. My husband giggled a bit and asked me to please never get implants after he saw it 🤣
It is very hard to use compression/ breast massage with this pump so I am alternating with the spectra pump I have.
Cleaning it and drying it multiple times a day is time consuming.
My Elvie stride died after three weeks. But I bought it during pregnancy and the shop I bought it from won’t help me now and Elvie doesn’t even answer to my mail.
I really liked the Elvie stride though. I’m wondering now if the stride cups will work with another mobile pump, like the Duette or genie advanced.
Or maybe I should buy the willow….I need a hands free pump for work.
The cups will work with pumpables genie advanced
Can u do a more updated video on the 2? Why do u not recommend elvie stride as your only pump?
I am due in July with baby number 5 and am trying to choose the best wearable pump I can use full time can I ask why you don’t think the stride would be good full time and if you think the willow go would be better for full time use?
Can you please do a review of elvie stride vs freemie independence?
Thank you for the graphs!
Always fun to break out the Boobie Barometer and get some fun data!!
@newlittlelife what did you mean down the road you need more pumps ?
Hi Alison. Im so glad to have found your video ❤❤❤ If you can assist me, im a working mom and an exclusive pumping mom too. I work as a customer service consultant and need to be at my desk most of the time, to answer call. There will be time that require me to meet up with my client as well.. So i really need an effective pump, to ensure i can maintain my milk supply and at the same time i need a discreet pump as well. Im thinking of purchasing elvie stride. Do you think this pump will work for me? Really appreciate your kind feedback on my concern 🤗🤗🥰🥰
I’d love to help and support you through it all! I work with moms to help protect your milk supply after returning to work by pumping fast and efficiently. We can chat about the best pumps for you inside the program, we do that often!
Feel free to apply here, it sounds like exactly what you’re looking for! calendly.com/d/d3c-8c2-jvj
You do not recommend Elvie Stride as the main pump. Do you think other wearable pumps (Elvie Original, Willow Go, etc) can be used as main pumps?
No she does not. They don’t empty a breast completely and can lower supply
For some they work well! For others, they don’t. Typically, I don’t recommend them as a general rule but it depends on the individual. Sometimes I do for members in my program who I get to know a little better!
I hated the stride. I really wanna try the go!
I heard Willow Go has similar suction to the Spectra S1. Is this true? If not, what wearable (or at least portable) pump would you recommend if I use the Spectra as my main pump and respond well to it?
The willow go is a very “standard” suction pattern, similar to a lot of non-wearable pumps. The genie advanced from pumpables is my favorite portable pump for users who like the spectra.
@@NewLittleLife Thank you!
I am a person that needs soft suction bc I have sensitive breast. I am leaning toward the Elvie pumps. How do you think i would like the willow go since they have changed the suction
It’s still a constant suction pump, so it feels very unique. If you want the most sensitive option, go with the elvie.
Thank you as always for an awesome, informative video. I’m still debating if I am going to get a fancy wearable but the WG or original Elvie are my top two right now… it’s a large investment and it’s always so polarizing with superb reviews and terrible ones 🤷🏻♀️ I’m curious about the sound levels while in use?… and the battery life for the Willow Go? If any one has insight, I would love to hear it!
I have the original Elvie and it’s super quiet and I love it! I have no complaints about the pump, it’s actually been a live saver having two kids!
Yes the noise level and the battery life are my 2 concerns as well. Did you happen to make a choice and complete purchase? If so can you please tell me which one you went with and how you’re liking it??
I have the willow go and I find it kind of loud. Especially if you have it above a 6.
I use the mortif duo and I pump on 3 for stimulation then in expression I pump on 4 then I up it to 5 then into 7 over the 15 minutes I pump.
Im thinking the willow go would be just fine for me and I usually only get 2-3oz for each breast even in the morning right now. I exclusively breast feed but am going back to work.
@@katelyndavis8798when I go to their insta page, there are only negative comments. Also heard it keeps leaking. Can you say more about it
Does anyone know how the Willow Go compares to the original Elvie in terms of size??
Willow is bigger
I bought the elvie and no milk comes out. I contacted elvie company and they sent me a new set. But no difference was noticed and no milk is collected.
Hi! Does nipple size affect the productivity of the wearables at all? And can you modify at all if you’re not one of the offered flange sizes (e.g., I use a 15mm with my Spectra). Thanks!
Yes it does affect it! I’d definitely get an insert if you’re measuring 15 :)
Would you recommend the elvie stride for a first time pumper?
Probably not 😕
Can you do the fridge hack with the Willow Go? I’m a FTM who has been exclusively breastfeeding for the past 4 months but I have to go back to work soon and I don’t know if I’ll have the time to clean all the parts between pumping sessions. Trying to decide if the Willow Go is right for me! Thanks!
Maybe i missed it but i dont really like the apps, which one can be used without the app as well as with if i wanted?
Thank you for this video!
What is the best wearable pump for moms who work in a warehouse and move a lot?
Good question! Any of these, if you’re pumping while moving around, only the Willow can accommodate a leak free solution. If you’ll be more stationary while actually pumping, look at cost, size, and features you may want.
Ok for a FTM who needs to make a decision before first baby is born for insurance purposes HOW do we know?!? So much of this video is dependent on what you like, how your boobs are etc. But we don't know the answer to these things yet! It's still a very informative video especially with the graphs to help visualize. But I'm no less confused on what I'm going to buy.
I know, I’m so sorry! At the end of the day, you just need to make a decision based on your budget and the situation in which you’ll be pumping. If you’re a working mom, I do have additional resources to help with this decision!!
www.Newlittlelife.com
What is the company callled for the portable pump bag? It's so cute!
The Harper Bag: www.mimiandpal.com/
---Discount code $5 off: NEWLITTLELIFE
Any time I look at pump comparisons, it seems like higher suction is preferred. Personally, I need very little suction. Too much suction actually is painful for me. Do people tend to need more suction?
It really varies a lot! For those that like or need a gentler feel, these Elives tend to be great options. They all have plenty of suction capabilities for most all users so no worries there.
The Mommed pump works great for me as far as emptying me, but the motors are unreliable. I’ve had to buy it multiple times. I’ve given up on it because one of the motors almost gave out on a trip. I just ordered the WillowGo. I’m hoping the suction will be gentle enough. I tried out the MomCozy 12 Pro. That pump felt like it was ripping my nipples off even on the lowest setting.
Let me know what you think of the willow go! I always love user feedback :)
Will do!
So far the Willow Go has been working great for me. It doesn’t have super strong suction which is great for me. I don’t need high suction to be emptied. The app is neat and convenient. With the 7 oz containers which I use because I’m an oversupplier, they are bulky and I’m big chested already. The parts are a bit confusing at first. Also, you can’t steam sterilize the parts which is kind of a pain. Another downside is that they don’t seal so you can spill.
Do you recommend the elvie stride or the willow go more for a hands free pump?
The willow is more convenient because of the lack of tubing. But both are technically hands free!
I already have the spectra S1. I am looking for a more portable pump. Do you recommend the Willow go vs the medela freestyle flex? Really stuck here. Any help would be great!
Well, do you want a small portable pump or an expensive wearable one? What is the most important factor pushing you towards a smaller pump?
@@NewLittleLife I am ok with either. I work from home and will soon have 2 under 2. I am going to get the legendary cups as well. I’d just like more portability in case I have to run and do something or check on the kids.
I have the same problem. By any chance which one did you end up choosing?
@@karlavillagomez6521 I ended up getting the Willow go and the pumpables genie advanced during their Black Friday sale. I use my spectra S1 and pumpables GA daily. I love it. The Willow go is great when I’m on the go but it doesn’t fully empty me so I end up pumping for a longer time.
@@OhSoGlamorous14 thank you so much for replying you’re so sweet ! Ok thank you 🙏🏻
Which willow gen are you using in this video? Wanting to get the 3.0 but scared about the suction
Hi, which hands free breast pump do you recommend for a women with DD size breast?
Does anyone know if the Elvie Stride or Willow Go have a sensor to let you know when your cups are full and do they auto-stop? I love this feature on the Elvie (original).
Hmm good question!
The Stride does not
Hi Allison. Question for you about the Willow 3.0; I’m currently battling a low milk supply and am looking for a new wearable to pump to help me miss less pump sessions. You had mentioned needing a certain volume for the Willow to switch to expression mode. Is there also a time limit before it would switch? Or do you just get stuck in stimulation mode if you make under 0.5 oz/breast?
I own the Elvie, but unfortunately my body doesn’t respond well to its gentle suction…
There is no time limit. It’s all about milk amount. I prefer the willow go for this reason :)
Ok..so..iknow the elvie curve/haakaa are essentially manual pumps. But, do you think they compare to the wearable breast pumps as far as milk yielded? Because I can't decide if I want to get the elvie curve or if I should invest in an actual wearable pump like the willow or elvie for occasional use when I can't use my spectra.
The elvie curve and haakaa are NOT manual pumps. They are simply milk catchers that have a little extra suction. If you can’t make a pumping session with your spectra, you’ll need an actual pump like the ones in this video to remove the milk. A milk catcher (even with suction) will not remove milk effectively. Hope that helps!
@@NewLittleLife ohhhh!! Ok that makes sense, thank you! 😊
You bet :)
Do you like Imani 2, elvie stride or mom med21
Why do you not recommend the stride as your only pump?
I talk about it more in my webinar which you can see here if you want!
www.newlittlelife.com/breast-pump-webinars/
If anyone has used willow 3.0 and now the willow go, would you say it’s better for elastic nipples? I might have to sell my willow 3.0 because I used it again after so long since I just went back to work and it bruised my nipples soo bad, I dunno how I used it as my only pump for so long! I need something wearable at work
Thank you!
I'm due with baby #3 in Sept. This will make 3 kiddos 3 & under when this one comes... so I need portable. I know I have elastic nipples, is there one that you would recommend that works better with elastic nipples?
Hi Andrea. I have 3 kids 3 and under with my youngest being almost 5 months old. I also have elastic nipples. I have tried the original elvie and the willow 3.0. I respond much better with the elvie however it does not have the leakproof capability. I purchased the willow 3.0 with this baby bc the leakproof bags, but I just don’t respond to it well at all. I plan on selling it to try the willow go.
What is an IBCLC
International Board Certified Lactation Consultant 🙂
I’m curious why you believe stride wouldn’t be an everyday pump and you say more than likely if we get it we will need another?
Do you feel the same about the willow go? I have a back up pump in case this happens but I’m just curious as to why you believe this. Thanks for your time 🙏🏼
Good question :) this is COMPLETELY my own opinion.
Im not confident that a wearable pump (and especially the elvie stride due to how gentle the suction is) can empty quite as efficiently as a traditional flange. For some people it does well, but in a general video like this I hesitate to recommended it as a good option in a blanket general statement. For the students in my program who I know their situations, they needs, and their milk supply, I could more confidently recommend something like this if it was appropriate. Does that make sense?
The elvie stride in particular though has a unique suction feel and the reviews on it have been mixed so far. So without taking directly to someone, I choose to create my opinion in the way I stated it in the video.
If you want to hear me talk about about this topic, I do in my webinars! www.newlittlelife.com/breast-pump-webinars/
Elvie original or willow go!?
Isn’t that the million dollar question…. 😅
The only thing holding me back is the fear of fitting my large breasts in portables. Size 36H bra with 15mm flange. Do you have input from large breasted clients?
I sold my Willow Go because it felt like the weight of the pump pulled down my bra and misaligned my nipples and I never got good output. I'm a 36 E/F