@@Jt61603 as someone who voted for the NDA, I’m thankful of a strong opposition. The administration of the country needs to be challenged. And if the opposition prevails as a better solution, I’ll vote for them in the upcoming elections
@@gurupadappakabbur6648who cares, he is actually right anyway. When it comes to country, its no opposition or the one you support. Its what is good for the country, and sustainable development. We need whats right. Be it modi or rahul or whoever. Whoever is right is to be supported but our media and rich has manipulated the people in a way that no matter how right you are, you will support the one being favored.
Worst finance minister.. once a person had asked her abt finances and profits tht govt earns more as a sleeping partner whts the profit thn a man makes and she said well as u said we are a sleeping partner and how cn a sleeping partner answer. Wow!
@@Happiness_pro_max first consider her economic policies before commenting anything, she is one of best FM after MMS, other than going for cheap politics, she went for process reforms, macroeconomic stability and reducing fiscal deficit
@@dheerkapoor2398 17800 rupees mtlb ek din ka ₹48, bohot zyada nhi hai 😅 aaj desh ka middle class desh ke corporate se zyada tax %wise de rha hai aur usko facilities kya mil rhi hai? Train mein travel karo toh accident ho jata hai , roads pe niklo toh baarish ka paani laga hua hai. Bridge gir rahe hai. Mai bihar se hoon aur mujhe bohot achi tarah se pta hai ki jo paisa bihar govt ko milega vo sirf politician ke pocket mein jayenge aur infrastructure ke naam pe vaise bridges hi bnange jo 6 months bhi na chale. Itna tax collection ho rha hai toh paisa ja kha rha hai. Aur iss govt se kuch bhi pucho toh ulte sidhe jawab dekar nikal jate hai.
@@sirakayakomzin3926 Oh yes talks a lot of BS.. has he done anything other than talking in all these years? Maybe led a state? nothing! Just dreams of becoming PM 😂
Nirmala Sitharam can never win against shashi Tharror in his life... If they werent so family bias or Shashi Tharoor ever fight as Candidate as PM of India He would have never lost in his life.... This dude is something else ^^ He have Defended India far more then Any Party or entire political all members all Combined itself
He talks decently no doubt unlike RaGa and his lot, but Tharoor also tries to logically present the most erroneous facts, masking it with his elite English.
Do you only see the income tax which only rich people pay? Why is that tax not visible, which is being taken from the common man in thousands of ways in the name of small taxes? On one hand keep increasing taxes on the work done by the common man and on the other hand keep reducing corporate taxes for the rich. Why did you increase the long term capital gains tax?😡
Is this a responsible reply to the member's question? Staffing is the focal point of the question. Why should the FM starts with a retort* "its interesting"? Arrogance will vanish if elected from a LS constituency.
Shashi Tharoor started of with the comment of laundry list so she answered that. But yes, she could answered in a bit more details to the staffing question.
This is a great example of what the dynamic should be between the ruling party and the opposition during the Parliament session. Points and rebuttals are respectful and meaningfully submitted. Refreshing to see this exchange instead of the usual screeching dialogue.
Heartening to see questioning and answering in peaceful ambience. Ours being the most populous country with diversified culture spread over different regions, many many issues financially based, so its tough ask to satisfy all segments/ regions. This apart, country witnessed mammoth all round growth in the last ten yrs. Surely the present GOI do maintained momentum essential biased to the welfare of of commoners.
This kind of discussion is most expected & appreciated in Parliament. Opposition asking right questions & respective minister obliging the question. Answering in very constructive way. Not too much debate or arguing to drag too much on it. Even more appreciable is proper language
Budget is meant for action tobe taken and not meant for action taken.... Tharoorji well pointed "action to tobe taken" where as FM moved around "action taken" Well done Tharoorji❤
I want to see the opposition pose strong questions to the current government instead of raising slogans. I hope this peaceful manner of debate continues.
Now when the opposition is strong she's now started to take their points seriously and at least acknowledging the issues. Previously she used to discard their points immediately. This is the power of democracy.
No one has voted nirmala but how she became mp... Do indians look fool to her??? All others have gained their respect except few people like nirmala... Public challenges that she cant even get 25 votes in india combined together😂😂😂... Comments said by people in X
Its easy to say laundry list but during her tenure as FM she has worked hard from post covid and even though the world economy with geo political ramifications is growing at 3.2% but our economy is growing at 8.2%.
And what was the growth rate before COVID and list the reforms she has done during her tenure. Just because you bring in random numbers don't think people are fools. Idiots choosing idiots
One the question concerning the NCLAT, MP Tharoor is correct. FM Sitharaman should take this into consideration. The purpose if Company Law Tribunal is to create an specialised forum to adjudicate disputes within a fixed period of time assisted by a moratorim. Understaffing an appellate tribunal is just counter productive.
![[#2024MAMA] G-DRAGON - 무제(Untitled, 2014)+POWER+HOME SWEET HOME+뱅뱅뱅+FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ox29z5Nf1Uk/mqdefault.jpg)
Good to see a strong-question-asking Opposition!
@@Jt61603 as someone who voted for the NDA, I’m thankful of a strong opposition. The administration of the country needs to be challenged. And if the opposition prevails as a better solution, I’ll vote for them in the upcoming elections
@@insert-name10150 cr scam done and no responsibility and now strong question.
They always did just they were very low in numbers during previous 2 terms we didn't listen to them. (yes I Am counting myself too)
@@MC-io4fgbhaie tue raata maar le 😂
@@MC-io4fg 14000 Cr Electoral bond scam Which is declared illegal by Supreme Court 🤣🤣
She eats only Tax no Onions 💀💀💀
Tukde gang feku leaders have systematically swallowed public money
Bro 👍🏻💀
☠️
u are only interested in eating..
Haha good one😂😂😂😂 next she l say I don't use insurance adani and ambani takes care of her. Ifnu can afford one then buy one 😂
Dr Shashi Tharoor is back again 🔥🔥
@@തങ്കൻ-ഞ2ശ He will come back several times. That is Shashi Tharoor..😃😃😃
Only dialogue from Tharoor.
What is the use.he is an opportunist and always play safe game.
@@vinodhvp1regret to inform that he is not a dedicated full pledged fighter.
@@gurupadappakabbur6648who cares, he is actually right anyway. When it comes to country, its no opposition or the one you support. Its what is good for the country, and sustainable development. We need whats right. Be it modi or rahul or whoever. Whoever is right is to be supported but our media and rich has manipulated the people in a way that no matter how right you are, you will support the one being favored.
Speaker is not understanding single word for sure.
😂😂 rightly said
😂😂🤣
😂
Absolutely 😂😂😂😂
I bet you do
I dont understood why she gets so angry in answering simple questions
@@satyam_krishna true - she got very angry and it went offboard as well
she insecure bruh
Maybe eating onions might help,
She looks like a confident woman who doesnt know shit about people of India but is proud cause daddy has her back.
Vrna chunav ladti toh haar jati fir mantri banne ka mauka jata vrna
💯
😂😂
Good that questions are asked instead of making boring slogans in the well of the House.
If arrogance & egotism had a face, that would definitely be our FM. I mean, just look at her.
Dont bother about her looks. Tharoor needed a strong and bold reply. He often comes up fancy but silly comments.
Yeah just look at her you will know what is boldness and attitude
Keep looking and cope 😂
@@JayashreeMahapatra-yg6fw It's not boldness it's audacity.
@@madhavant9516 ye aaya Mahamurkh. Comment wasn't about her looks but you didn't understand simple comment shows your level.
Shashi Tharoor 🔥🙌🇮🇳
@@Anand_Ram Zandu.🙏
her mike was NOT off😂
victim card used in between
Her action at last literally boiled my blood
What a person she is ..mmm
out of 2 mics, one of them got off
That's not an issue
She already byhearted the dialogue
She must use it right?😂😂
Honourable finance-Minister should step down for the betterment of India
Waste FM
@@anupinkumar7398😂😂😂
😅😅@@anupinkumar7398
@@anupinkumar7398Aanaj khate ho ya gober?
Or you are filthy rich not middle class.
Reason brother?
@@anupinkumar7398 charanvandana
Tomato 🍅🍅🍅 price Rs 100+ in retail market.
FM should resign immediately now 😊😊😊
She won't
Wo tomato bhi nahi khati
She doesn't eat tomato so not aware of it. May be she is on intermittent fasting😂😂
here it isnt
Her reply for you "Ham Tamator nahi khaatey hamko nahi pata"
Be accountable. Give a timeline by which it will be done
as a bjp supporter. bjp needs to change the FM and education minister..
This is the least they can do
Worst finance minister.. once a person had asked her abt finances and profits tht govt earns more as a sleeping partner whts the profit thn a man makes and she said well as u said we are a sleeping partner and how cn a sleeping partner answer. Wow!
Yeah, so Tharor will make a good one or Pappu or Chidu...all waiting to go to Tihar...so much of credibility.. in Khnagres
@@arnipskumar3245 cry more baby 🍼
@@arnipskumar3245 its ok bro sojaao dimaag mt lagao
@@Happiness_pro_max first consider her economic policies before commenting anything, she is one of best FM after MMS, other than going for cheap politics, she went for process reforms, macroeconomic stability and reducing fiscal deficit
@@avisekghosh6375we can see who's crying 😂😂😂 khangressi
Her mic was not off.. I heard her loud and clear...
Worst fm ever india seen🤮🤮🤮
Horrible state of our country having a finance minister blindfolded with arrogance
Apart from increasing tax what reforms helped middle class for their quality of life?
Middle class Is this countries most silent minority
@@dheerkapoor2398 middle class is in majority 😂 rich people are in minority.
@@AanyaSingh235 sorry I meant the tax paying class
But one good thing about this budget is that Salaried employees will save around 17800 rupees
@@dheerkapoor2398 17800 rupees mtlb ek din ka ₹48, bohot zyada nhi hai 😅 aaj desh ka middle class desh ke corporate se zyada tax %wise de rha hai aur usko facilities kya mil rhi hai? Train mein travel karo toh accident ho jata hai , roads pe niklo toh baarish ka paani laga hua hai. Bridge gir rahe hai. Mai bihar se hoon aur mujhe bohot achi tarah se pta hai ki jo paisa bihar govt ko milega vo sirf politician ke pocket mein jayenge aur infrastructure ke naam pe vaise bridges hi bnange jo 6 months bhi na chale. Itna tax collection ho rha hai toh paisa ja kha rha hai. Aur iss govt se kuch bhi pucho toh ulte sidhe jawab dekar nikal jate hai.
Arrogant sitaraman clearly on the backfoot...❤
Ghosh as no clue...
Arey itna sashi who showed arrogance and said its laundry list
@@KarthikSankarasubramaniamwaste Sitaraman doesn’t have no clue
she is the most arrogant finance minister, she doesn't answer any question. Just search on TH-cam you will get many videos proving that.
Logic is simple.tit for tat.
Shasi what is 1+1=?
Her ans:bottom of the sea.
First they will say thanks to modiji😂. Self proclaimed god and his party thinks they got 400 seats
@@satvikhegde325and u thinks congress got 400 seats 😂😂
@@akhilsunke2507 nope. But they r working for betterment of nation. Bjp doesn't represent Hindus. They r destroying the nation
@@satvikhegde325 are you joking? 😂😂
@@satvikhegde325I mean we need strong opposition but you people are brainless definitely bjp isn't face of Hindus but destroying nation??
Worst Finance Minster
Am I the only one who didnt watch FM's response? because, don't see a logical response coming.
Worst FM
maybe Raga can fill the role? He's cambridge educated no? 😂
RaGa is still a better than our non biological PM. RaGa atleast has the guts to answer questions in a press conference unlike the '56 inch Romeo'.
How so?
@@savantdude pawpaw ka “kaun rahul” aj unki neend bigad rha hai.. wait sorry pawpaw doesnt sleep, he works 25 hours in a day
@@sirakayakomzin3926 Oh yes talks a lot of BS.. has he done anything other than talking in all these years? Maybe led a state? nothing! Just dreams of becoming PM 😂
Worst finance minister of India 😢
Suggest a better replacement.
@@Viper60589there are more than 100+ members to replace him but nirmala mam is not the right person for Indian economy
@@mukeshk5542 who then???
Hamare suggestion se jaise change kar denge😂
Yeah bring back PC cabbage farmer please.
What's the process for making her re-sign from FM post?
Protest 😂
Just remove rulling party next time
I want her resigned now too
Nirmala sitaraman is the epitome that just speaking good English means nothing...
Nirmala Sitharam can never win against shashi Tharror in his life...
If they werent so family bias or Shashi Tharoor ever fight as Candidate as PM of India
He would have never lost in his life....
This dude is something else ^^
He have Defended India far more then Any Party or entire political all members all Combined itself
He talks decently no doubt unlike RaGa and his lot, but Tharoor also tries to logically present the most erroneous facts, masking it with his elite English.
Do you only see the income tax which only rich people pay?
Why is that tax not visible, which is being taken from the common man in thousands of ways in the name of small taxes?
On one hand keep increasing taxes on the work done by the common man and on the other hand keep reducing corporate taxes for the rich.
Why did you increase the long term capital gains tax?😡
My Mic is off ?? What a hoax
After Reading and analysing the comments I can say that our Honourable Finance Minister should be replaced ASAP ! 🚨
Arrogance because not chosen by Janta but chosen by the Supreme leader
Is this a responsible reply to the member's question? Staffing is the focal point of the question. Why should the FM starts with a retort* "its interesting"? Arrogance will vanish if elected from a LS constituency.
Shashi Tharoor started of with the comment of laundry list so she answered that. But yes, she could answered in a bit more details to the staffing question.
High taxes in india spacial gift for indians
Very relevant question raised.
Bring back Mr Raguram Rajan to RBI and Mr Chidambaram as FM!! Its enough of looting irrational taxes
Chidambaram ? Seriously? He is one of the biggest fraudsters of this country.
Oh. God.
Chidambaram is number one scammer 😂😂😂 has 2 serious scams and even proved still need him 😂😂😂
@@Naveen-os3qi goodness! PC was the most corrupt FM who only filled Sonia's coffers and Raghuram Rajan was utterly useless as RBI governor
@@kavitagera6101 raghuram rajan was the true mastermind behind UPI, useless minister, aya whatsapp university graduate.
This is a great example of what the dynamic should be between the ruling party and the opposition during the Parliament session. Points and rebuttals are respectful and meaningfully submitted. Refreshing to see this exchange instead of the usual screeching dialogue.
Fun fact is, Our speaker can't understand Shashi Tharoor speech.😂😂😂
Even the glass is falling, even it is not satisfied by the answer
She thinks party have 400 seats.😂😂
Heartening to see questioning and answering in peaceful ambience. Ours being the most populous country with diversified culture spread over different regions, many many issues financially based, so its tough ask to satisfy all segments/ regions. This apart, country witnessed mammoth all round growth in the last ten yrs. Surely the present GOI do maintained momentum essential biased to the welfare of of commoners.
Our Speaker is literally lost and pale between their communication. .😂😂😂 He understood nothing hopefully
This kind of discussion is most expected & appreciated in Parliament. Opposition asking right questions & respective minister obliging the question. Answering in very constructive way. Not too much debate or arguing to drag too much on it. Even more appreciable is proper language
Strong opposition is the urgency for healthy democracy ❤
This is the first time they said we agree with the opposition....🤔🤔 And no the mic is not off we can hear the FM clearly.
Whatever be your political inclination, I think this is how discussion should happen where atleast the problem is acknowledged.
Dr. Tharur my favorite. So Knowlahble gentleman.
NIRMALA SITARMAN SHOULD RESIGN 😅😢
Answers in lok sabha should be meaningful and to the mark. Not like taking a question as personal debating topics.
When did the mic go off
Shashi Tharoor always speaks right things
Right or wrong.
But
Look at both of them highly educated 2 individuals debating and cross questioning is something this country needs.
If incompetence has a face, it would be that of Nirmala tai
Dr Tharoor is fantastic ❤
Speaker says " maanya mantriji😂😂😂
Best answer heard from a leader after a long time
Most Educated and Elite persons are in Congress party 👍✊✊...जय काँग्रेस 👍✊
Exactly. So they know the art of looting like their elite masters- the colonialists.
How is her mic off, could hear her more clearly when she claimed her mic is off😂
What a great pronunciation of Mr Tharoor❤
This is not Cambridge English class.
Read recipe list for halwa ⁉️
This type of constrative opposition
is needed in parliament not like Rahul Gandhi or Mohua Moitra. This
type of questions are rarely asked nowadays.
JNU English Vs UN English
Dr. Shasi Tharur 🌟🌟🌟
Budget is meant for action tobe taken and not meant for action taken....
Tharoorji well pointed
"action to tobe taken" where as FM moved around "action taken"
Well done Tharoorji❤
I want to see the opposition pose strong questions to the current government instead of raising slogans. I hope this peaceful manner of debate continues.
Tharoor😊
A top former UN diplomat poses questions very carefully.
From tomorrow onwards everybody will start liking him🎉🎉advance congratulations
We see that not a single citizen of our nation accepts our FM. But the Govt does not realise this since 2019.....
How does this lady communicate with her husband who is one of the greatest critic of this govt????? Pride all over her face.
❤❤❤ Love Sitaraman .bow down to SriMahalakshmi of India.
Now when the opposition is strong she's now started to take their points seriously and at least acknowledging the issues. Previously she used to discard their points immediately. This is the power of democracy.
Glad we have members like Shashi Tharoor in lok sabha.
Why how and what made her FM again.. God save our country by this lady.
Mic kab off hua..??🤔 Awaaz toh clearly sunai diya...
Finance minister is on the right track in my view
no one defeat shashi tharoor in english 😀
Om Birla needs sub titles...
Nirmala mam always replies outlandishly.
Modi and amit shah are like....ye log kia bol rai 🤔
This how a well educated person do debate.... lovely
Best quality of tai. She never understand the question and gives ans by her own
No one has voted nirmala but how she became mp... Do indians look fool to her??? All others have gained their respect except few people like nirmala... Public challenges that she cant even get 25 votes in india combined together😂😂😂... Comments said by people in X
Our finance is the best 😂😂😂 , so much knowledge, so much experience to rip off the hard work of the middle class people.
Finance minister Nirmala mam Is Op for sure ❤❤🎉
FM must have been a back bencher sleeping in most of her classes.
Its easy to say laundry list but during her tenure as FM she has worked hard from post covid and even though the world economy with geo political ramifications is growing at 3.2% but our economy is growing at 8.2%.
And what was the growth rate before COVID and list the reforms she has done during her tenure. Just because you bring in random numbers don't think people are fools. Idiots choosing idiots
Shashi tharoor is king
Shashi Tharoor sir❤
This FM needs to Go
Useless FM of our country miss nirmala sitaram 😮
The policy of FM is not her own policy, it is her own policy, but she is very arrogant, her attitude is being very aggressive towards any criticism.
Middle Class is crushed from all sides.
Best Finance minister of India
One the question concerning the NCLAT, MP Tharoor is correct. FM Sitharaman should take this into consideration.
The purpose if Company Law Tribunal is to create an specialised forum to adjudicate disputes within a fixed period of time assisted by a moratorim. Understaffing an appellate tribunal is just counter productive.
Laundry list is the very precise word used by Tharoor Ji.
She is the best FM ❤
She was the finance minister last 15 years, then what is the current situation of india financial growth is still very bad
Its actually a laundary list