John Williams vs Hans Zimmer - Piano Battle Mashup/Medley #2 ft. Samuel Fu
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 ต.ค. 2024
- Two composers. Two pianists. One winner. Decided by...YOU.
Join me on Patreon! ► / jonpumper
Learn piano quick and easy! ► tinyurl.com/Jon...
I stream piano on Twitch! ► / thepumperpair
= = = = = = = = = =
EQUIPMENT ► www.amazon.com...
All my equipment (piano, etc.) is listed above!
(It’s an affiliate storefront, so if you buy from here you’ll support me too!)
= = = = = = = = = =
PUMP up the MERCH ► teespring.com/...
Stupid t-shirts conceived by yours truly.
= = = = = = = = = =
SUBSCRIBE ► bit.ly/jpumper
Follow Jon on:
/ jonpumper
/ jon_pumper
/ jon_pumper
= = = = = = = = = =
MORE VIDEOS
TOTO ► bit.ly/totoinyo...
Medleys ► bit.ly/2J0mtvF
Marvel Piano ► bit.ly/2GQG5As
FUNNY VIDEOS ► bit.ly/2TAiqMC
LEGO Movie 2 Piano ► bit.ly/2U7iuzG
Steven Universe Piano ► bit.ly/SUPiano
Game of Thrones Piano ► bit.ly/2ZVY67C
Greatest Showman Piano ► bit.ly/2lijWPj
Piano Battles Ft. Samuel Fu ► bit.ly/2Y3qVNR
= = = = = = = = = =
THE PLAYERS
Samuel Fu (Hans Zimmer) → / @samuelfupiano
Jon Pumper (John Williams) → / jonpumper
= = = = = = = = = =
THE MUSIC
John Williams
► Theme from “Jaws”
► “Duel of Fates” (Star Wars)
► “Hedwig’s Theme” (Harry Potter)
► Theme from “Jurassic Park”
► “May the Force be with You” (Star Wars)
► “Raider’s March” (Indiana Jones)
► Theme from “Superman”
► Theme from “E.T.”
► “Imperial March” (Star Wars)
Hans Zimmer
► “Now We Are Free” (Gladiator)
► “Themes from Pirates of the Caribbean
► The Dark Knight Overture
► “160 BPM” (Angels and Demons)
► “Flight” (Man of Steel)
► “Time” (Inception)
► “First Step” (Interstellar)
NOTE: for obvious reasons, we weren't able to include all the AMAZING scores from either composer since there are so many, and we had to find ones that were compatible for our arrangement.
= = = = = = = = = =
CREDITS
Arrangement by Jon Pumper and Samuel Fu
Video Editing by Samuel Fu.
Check out the synthesia tutorial: • Video
Check out our first piano battle (DC vs. Marvel) here: bit.ly/2h6VK3H - เพลง
![MARVEL EVOLUTION EPIC PIANO MASHUP [2000-2023] from X-Men to Quantumania](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/w5RnifvT-Og/mqdefault.jpg)
![MARVEL EVOLUTION EPIC PIANO MASHUP [2000-2023] from X-Men to Quantumania](/img/tr.png)
PIANO BATTLE #3 is up!! bit.ly/2MmriNy
Jon Pumper yeah boy!
Jon Pumper
Do more!!!!!! lol!!!! I love them!!!!
Jon Pumper r
the list of schindler was missing, this Soundtrack is really art
John Williams is a colorful guy painting the picture. Hans gets in deep and brings out your true emotions. They are both great.
Brilliant comment! It's exactly what I've been thinking.
I think what williams does with the ET score bring out more emotion in me than any score out there
John made some of the most iconic scores of all time he has no competition from schindlers list to indiana jones to jurassic park to star wars to ET, i feel like more people will forever know more of hes scores than hans
@@andresparra114 Superman :(
Andres Parra Harry potter
John Williams make us remember certain moment in the movie with his iconic high notes soundtacks . Hans Zimmer make certain moments super intense with low notes and its almost like we're living that moment . John Williams' music is memorable . Hans Zimmer's is intense .
True
I get what you're saying but Williams can get very intense sometimes (like in star wars for example) while it's true that Zimmer mainly focuses on that aspect
I like oogway ascends from Zimmer
Welll...
*Wonder woman bvs theme*
I had a similar thought. You will remember the music in an epic scene if it's John Williams, and you will remember an epic moment because it's Hans Zimmer's music.
This is less of a battle and more of the best duet ever.
Hey I'm not complaining.
RILLA tbh, i like their dc vs marvel better
RILLA do
Hey I only like Hans Zimmer because he respects the cello.
Seriously search pirates of the Caribbean cello pieces. Prime example of Hans Zimmer respecting the cello. But otherwise John Williams.
Richard Caywood the force is strong with you boy!
John: Its over Hans I have the highground!
Hans: Ive got a jar of dirt
Lol perfect
This is one of the funnest coment i ever seen
Hey katzly go back and continue the fakob jacob campaing
@@baseddepartment4982 I am
Good
I think the real winner is the editor
Definitely
DragonSlaya817
You
420 LIKES #blazeit
666 Likes now
You and me both just saw it
John Williams vs Hans Zimmer
*Top 10 Best Anime Battles*
8-bit Lols ggh
I could see them using oversized composer sticks as swords
Alexander9924 xd
Captain America vs iron man: civil war
John Williams vs Hans Zimmer: world war
But Finally John is a winner
Hehehehehehehe
@@solomona1300 pirates of the caribbean can beat all of john williams soundtracks. poftc has over 50 special themes.
@@kagm5921 no it cant dumbass
@@funnier_valentine4204 Indeed It can't. *Imperial March intensifies*
John Williams: "It's over Hans I have the high ground"
Hans Zimmer: "You underestimate my power!"
John Williams: "Don't try it!"
Hans Zimmer: *plays Inception Soundtrack*
John Williams: *cut off Zimmers legs*
Jakob Targaryen der 1. seines Namens You were the chosen one !
zdgag Ya, but then Obi wan became more powerful than we could ever imagine
And than hans just grab a magic broom outta no where
zdgag No, because Obi Wan become one with the force. So he didnt die.
high notes*
Who won
Who's next
You deci-
Oh w8 wrong series.
I gotchu and I applaud the reference
Michael Giacchino VS Alan Sliverstri!
CDHfilms who's Michael Giacchino?
Epic rap battles of History!
Vriska Serket I
1:53-2:22 My God The Dark Knight Theme mixed with Star Wars theme sounds terrific that's why I had to like this vid
That's so true, many of them sounded quite good together, It sounded like the music from Hans complemented John's
Totally agree. Two of the most dramatic and badass themes in history blended. I really want to hear those with the Avengers theme blended in too. If they were in sync the right way it could be amazing.
It does!!!
Adam Arellano that’s my favorite part of the vid too
Seems like it'd be for a dark epic seedy star wars story .
Like maybe *1313* !!!!
DUEL of fates = BRILLIANT beggining!
Fontenele NXT especially on a cello! It sounds fantastic that way! Trust me I play cello and it's always so fun to play!
I played it in my band class and it was amAZING.
Duel of the Fates was the only good thing that came out of the prequels
yea
Fontenele NXT yup
Choosing whether you like John Williams or Hans Zimmer is like choosing mom or dad
True tho
Nope Bc out of all of Hans I heard one I knew lol I knew all of the John Williams ones
lol no zimmer is a poor composer, like, really
Peter445 how so? Have u heard Time or No time for caution
@@indusarasenanayake3889 Its long im sorry hope youll read that. So (and keep in mind thats all my point of view), the point of film scoring is not that much to make beautiful music than music that tell the story as much as images, and the perfect example for that are leitmotivs (a musical motif related to something of the story like the empire march that represent the empire). Zimmer dont use leitmotivs or he dont use them well.
Another thing is that in some of Zimmer musics, for 5 minutes, he plays the same 4 chords with the same melody with the orchestration as only changes. How can you tell a story with 4 chords! You cant, or way worse than with a more "thought" harmony.
Williams does all of that extremely well, better than Zimmer anyway.
I would also say that in many of his film (not all) he try to use the classical orchestra but he dont use it as well as he could. And thats not a default, just that he doesnt know how to correctly orchetrate and hes way better with a more synth based sound. But he use the orchestra and he end with overuse of brass section and percution for no reason and the woodwinds that are truly under used which is bad..
So yes, Time is beautiful, Interstellar is beautiful but it dont make him a good film composer when Williams truly is.
Edit: Even though I think Zimmer is really good at creating atmospheres
the interstellar scene tho 😂😂😂
Eymardian Love it
lol
Hans zimmer strikes my emotional chords more. Williams makes me feel like a badass more.
Niraj yeah
Niraj yh
Niraj more of the other way around
Niraj opposite for me
Niraj Reverse.
Williams tells whole stories in his pieces.
Zimmer tells specific emotions, powerfully.
Hans Zimmer’s background music is cinematic.
Yet, John Williams’ Melody is so strong.
Both are excellent producers😂😂
Everyone's going to have different opinions/reasons why which composer is better than the other. But I actually love both of them. They both are unique and great in their own respective ways.
Caden Presley well said
i'm a star wars fan so obviously John williams because he has the highground
Revan lol
Revan he also has a new force ability he silenced 1000 people by raising his hand and they all said hushed at once
Lolz also, he has sand
Hans doesnt like sand its course rought and it get everywhere
To Zimmer fans (sounds like Zimmerframes😂) ‘Don’t try it’
John Williams: Its over Hans! I have the *high ground!*
While Zimmer can write some hella intense songs, you can’t beat Williams for iconic themes
@@gennabraun6126 what numbers?
Genna Braun williams has way more awards than Zimmer, what numbers are you talking about?
@@gennabraun6126 woossh
Something interesting is that a lot of john Williams work are almost copies of composers like Gustav Holst and Stravinsky.
Hello there and I agree master Obi wan am I a Jedi master now and on the counsel
Can't believe you didn't play This Land from Lion King for Hans Zimmer.
There are some tracks they didn´t play... The Rock, Crimson Tide for example
bro!!!!! when that pirates of carib. came on!!! but!...when that jurassic park came on!!!!! DAMN!!!! BATTLE OF THE YEAR!!!!
Legitimately my two favorite composers of all times. Not to mention all of my favorite franchises and soundtracks. Love, love, love this 💕💕💕
Morricone beats Zimmer hands down in my book. He might be the only worthy challenger of Williams. Zimmer is good, but no John Williams.
Sorry but John Williams is a legend in my book. He wins hands down (on the keyboard).
^I see what you did there. :)
Yeah true. He has more iconic tunes although Hans' tunes evoke a more emotional theme if u get what I'm saying
Piano Man No offense but so is Hans. Though I didn't get to see enough of the soundtracks I grew up with. He does a lot of kids soundtracks and yet they're still amazing. Can't wait for some other battle like " Henry Jackman vs Brian Tyler" or "Harry Gregson-Williams vs Rupert GregsonsomethingIcan'tremembercorrectly"
Piano Man, yes, same here!!!!
Piano Man you mean hans down
John: Makes all the classic songs
Hans: Touches your soul
True
Touches?? More like grabs it and shakes it around a bit
Sorry John Touches the soul more. Look at the binary sunset scene in Star Wars
Milaan Vigraham It’s not as good if you aren’t a star wars fan. When listening to Hans Zimmer, it’s always as good.
@@breakingmad2645 Which means his music is more shallow. It doesn't take much for it to move people because it doesn't need any context, it plays on people's existing sensibilities and emotions. The binary sunset theme is evocative of entirely new emotions for those who know what it's about, it's much more complex and deep than anything Zimmer has made. But to those who don't "get" Star wars, that theme will mean very little
They're both equally awesome. William's made many beautiful iconic scores, like Superman, Star Wars, and Indiana Jones, etc. Zimmer, on the other hand did emotional themes, invoking so much power into his compositions, such as He's a Pirate, The Dark Knight trilogy, Man of Steel etc.
CygamerMC Hans Zimmer didn't write He's a pirate. Clause Badelt did. And John Williams music has tons of emotion.
+Scott Horton First, it's spelled Klaus. Second, he wrote He's a Pirate, whereas Klaus wrote the rest of the soundtrack with his assistance.
Scott Horton no Hans Zimmer wrote He's a Pirate. Klaus just helped him.
CygamerMC I don't know who you think you are, but Hans Zimmer being a great composer is almost nothing compared to Johnny Dubbs
+Jay Studios Johnny Dubbs ain't got nuthin on Howard Shore.
The editor by far won the movie scene was amazing
Kyle and Friends React yessssss
I would have done Davy Jones vs Darth Vader. It's like the approach of two composers to villains. Williams worked on my favorite movies, bui i've got to stand with Zimmer
I would say that Williams win just for the sbillity to recognize it just by the tone. ^Force theme in quarter notes only plays* instant recognize!
Well the same works for Zimmer, i mean "He's A Pirate" and "Time" can be recognized by just two or three notes. And i think Zimmer is better at musically exploring the elements of the movie ( while Williams has never seen Star Wars )
Williams has never seen Star Wars?!?!?!? You are wrong. Williams always wrote his film scores FROM watching the films he wrote them for. Yes, he saw Star Wars...then he made it 100 times better with his soundtrack. Even George Lucas admitted that out of all the elements in the film, ONLY the soundtrack exceeded his hopes. You can take any 10 films Williams did and hum the melodies he created for them. Zimmer has at BEST maybe 3...and he collaborated with another composer on them. Zimmer is criminally overrated as a film composer.
Prince of Egypt and Lion King: am I a joke to you?
I like Zimmer, but John Williams is THE grand master. No question.
hanz zimmer is THE boss of music...
disagree but everyone has his own opinion
John Williams is in the past century, now it is Hans Zimmer and sry listen then you know that Hans Zimmer is THE Motherf.....
Hans Zimmer is just very good. But John Williams is indeed the grand master of film music. No matter what genre, he makes a perfect score.
Yep, Hans Zimmer is good and all. He knows how to create some sort or "musical carpet" with long notes and epic moments, that is like a layer underneath the movie and accompanies it nicely. But Williams, man, he writes complete storylines into his arrangements, melodies that exactly resemble what is happening in the movie, as if everything was working together in a perfect choreography. Not many composers are on his level.
But it's simple to decide who is better: ask anyone on the street at any time to hum the melody of Star Wars or Superman and then the music of Gladiator or Interstellar. We all know who wins ;)
Pirates of the Caribbean and harry potter and jurassic park those are my favorite
This was pretty damn great. Was hoping to hear some of Zimmer's TASM 2 score but still, really well made.
Might I suggest Giachinno vs Elfman for a potential video idea?
Damian Levy That would be AWESOME!
For hanz zimmer, i was hoping to hear some Sherlock Holmes
I will choose Michael Giacchino...He made my childhood
Yes
You asked who the winner in that piano battle is? Sorry Sam, but Jon is always the winner to me. I give props to Jon for avoiding those laser beams that shot from Sams eyes. Freaking hilarious.
john hands down because harry potter. you cant go wrong
harry potter is meh
But Sam fought a dinosaur
John Williams has the high ground
GORILLAZILLA G and sand
GORILLAZILLA G This is one of the most smart comments I've ever read.
I adore you, and may the Force be with you.
(Fellow Star Wars Nerds Unite)
GORILLAZILLA G I get it
That reminds me of this scene: th-cam.com/video/K2ScVx4mRDE/w-d-xo.html
NinjaNat052906 C But Hans Zimmer is Obi-wan
U guys should do video games vs movies next. I'd love to hear u guys do Assassin's Creed 4 vs Pirates of the Caribbean and/or Injustice vs Avengers.
Zelda vs Mario would be cool.
Well that's video game vs video game.
nahor88, that would be cool!
TheHappyCrafter u could also
Have wet hands and subwoofer lullaby from minecraft
nahor88 Or Mario vs Sonic
I’m a huge fan of both!
John Williams is like more prodigious, some of his music sound like real symphonies, for exemple The Duel Of Fates, or the music ending the StarWars III is a true Requiem 🖤
But Hans Zimmer is able to create that atmosphere like nobody else, and make me feel real emotions during many scenes of movies
Sorry it’s to hard 😆
I'm gonna have to go with John Williams.
OMG 4:20
The feels
Kevin Khoa blaze it
lol ikr 😂 😝 😂 😝
Kevin Khoa f
I knew they couldn`t do Hans Zimmer without Interstellar.
And Inception
So true
While I love Zimmer's epic and emotionally appealing music very much, I must say Williams in on another level with more interesting style and variety.
I was about to comment where is inception ❓❔❓❔
Music Time I was about to comment where is Interstellar lol
I was about to comment where are Zimmer's two best works. Well, you two got it
Not intense enough
I was relieved when pirates of the Caribbean came on
4:03
I keep rewatching this lol. It's so good.
Same
JoeyGaming HQ me to
I can’t be the only one that got goosebumps from 2:57
For me the best part 4:01 - 4:27
I remember always watching this Piano Fight in 2018-2019.
It gives so much memories xD
Nostalgic.
Yep. Summer 2019 was huge because of this. But I quickly became disillusioned of films in general so watching this again felt like a healing ointment.
Who won?! John Williams or Hans Zimmer?
samuel fu!!!!
Jon Pumper Hans Zimmer
Jon Pumper this is not fair, i love pirates of the caribbean, and i love harry potter, but i choose Samuel Fu
Hans Zimmer
John Williams
YEAH!! STAR WARS!! LETS GO JOHN WILLIAMS!!!
Yesss!!!
This was excellent. My heart will always lie with Williams due to his orchestral knowledge and complex writing. Not to mention his consistency. However I respect Zimmer for his experimentation and the sheer power he brings to his music. They are both film composer giants for a reason. And I loved the focus on Star Wars vs. The Dark Knight (two of the most popular works from each composer) and of course Man of Steel vs. the original Superman.
That's not fair. For Hans he's playing low notes whereas for John he' splaying high notes. Obviously high notes are sounds good to ears
it makes sense
EXACTLY
In other words , John has the " high notes " ...
@@infinitygauntlet101 time to go kms after that joke
I disagree. Low notes are way more beautiful to me
I cant believe just how perfectly Man of Steel and Superman sounded together.
Stop comparing and appreciate greatness
Salah Al-Saleh Humanity will always want to know who's greater.
Salah Al-Saleh But I do agree
Salah Al-Saleh true
I agree John Williams is greatness
Sadly, John Williams is playing louder, so usually you can't even hear Zimmer (for example Dark knight theme)...
me: **listens to the Lord of the Rings soundtrack**
Howard Shore is also an excellent composer
JW: It's over Zimmer, I have the high ground!
HZ: You underestimate my power
Instead if these versus vids, why don't you guys also start working on full fledged arrangements of orchestras using two pianos? Something like you do at the end of these vids...
Interstellar, by Hans Zimmer
Enough said-
Friar Jean the most beautiful soundtrack in the world. Insane
Friar Jean Great soundtrack, but nearly every track by John Williams is better
Happy 7 year birthday to this absolute masterpiece. I grew up HATING music. Not to sound dramatic but this video changed me and I think about it so often
what only 20 000 views?! thery are fantastic! AWEWSOME
Star Wars alone is enough to have Williams win, but he's also got Jurassic Park, Indiana Jones, and THE ORIGINAL SUPERMAN!!!
That Interstellar thing was hilarious, by the way XD
DON'T FORGET HARRY POTTER!!!
@Antoine Gauthier there is one sure thing in films. Classics always win.
Antoine Gauthier Then you haven’t heard most of Star Wars themes. Leia theme, Anakin theme, A. betrayal theme, the force theme...
Of course he made 100 star wars themes do you think it's enough?
See in my opinion Zimmer is far better. Williams borrows almost everything from other composers and slaps them together in a great way but all of zimmers are not just original but they make you feel real emotions.
Hans Zimmer: Do you know, how i got the scarfs?
John : I have the high ground
Hans : and i thought my jokes are bed.
John : don't try it
Hans : I have a trick for you.
I let this pencil...
John : I have a shark for you
Hans : why so serius ?
He jumps
John : cut han's legs
Music studios: I think Hans is alive .
1 hour later:
Hans : ksssssss khhhhhh ksssssss khhhhhh
Music studios : welcome back
DARTH ZIMMER
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
What
I like how you guys are playing against each other, but still helping each other
Its great, but it didn't flow as good as the Marvel vs DC one. Not your fault though, Williams and Zimmer's style are pretty different, while Superhero movies usually have the same tone and can go together better. Great content nonetheless!
IKKKKKK
I don't think you know what tone means lol
Moises Mallet Official I dont mean a literal musical tone, i just mean the setting and style of the movie.
+Moises Mallet Official tone can be applicable to different aspects of a song, not only what note is being played or how well the sound is produced.
Alex Bernal Completely Agree
Love them both but john Williams totally won
Do Michael Giohccino vs Danny Elfman
Oh yes...
AlexMessi18 *Giacchino
AlexMessi18 oh yeah btw Michael wins
YES YES
Oh my
Hanz Zimmer just has an epic effect that wins me!
I absolutely love your "battles". Can't stop listening to them !
Are you going to do more ?
Ps : just can't decide who won this time !
Yes we are, stay tuned! :)
Best part of all 4:21
Yes
I agree :D
1:40
I literally cried listening to this omg its so good😭😭👌👌
Nice job mixing Indiana Jones Theme on Angels & Demons, especially being on 7/8. The whole thing was amazing.
I love them both equally. I will never choose between them.
John Williams all the way for his terrific work with Star Wars but Hans is closely second because some pieces in PotC are simply stunning
Anyone else get chills listening to this
EPIC! great work!
Simply astonishing... Both of you!
Duel of the Fates carried.
Sigh... As much as I respect the prequels, they did lay down the trend of low quality synthetic music. Neodammerung is hard to listen to, but even that can wreck Duel of Fats into dust. Duel of Fats is a meme, it's an inspirational track that rubs in like some pop trash, PPAP and such. It's like Inception. On the outside, Inception looks like something you can get off to, but when you dig a bit deeper, maybe put it in playlist circulation of 24bit music on the appropriate level of hardware - you find that something is missing. To quote Mr. Riddick: "In this case - a spine". Duel of Fats is spineless. Once the meme wears off, it's noise. Once you get over the motiff of Inception, it's noise.
Compared to that, the classic trilogy has the instrumental tracks that stick through the years, because they don't rely on indiscernible vocals, like a second-grade TSFH mashup...
I thing hanz zimmer is better but John Williams is awsome too . I love them
Duel of Fates as beginning is perfekt
Laurent Undertale :D
Anda and Nao. No shit?!?!
OMG!!!!!! Wooow!!! The editing is out of this world!!
John Williams wins
Yeyy!!! :D
Yes he is the best
Brendan Wilmarth Zimmer is very close, and it's personal choice thought
Of course he won... he has the high ground!!!
+JonDoesGaming you clever son of a b-
You should do one worth Alvin Silvestri. Idk who he’d be against
Danny Elfman
Can everyone just agree interstellar was the highlight
Ravi Productions sure
No
omg yes I love Interstellar
Ravi Productions The Imperial March for me
Ravi Productions Inception too
I keep watching this video every week, again, and again.
Maaaaannnn i always love to see this
The star wars vs dark knight was the BEST OF THE BEST!!!!!
OMG angels and demons vs indiana jones. It the duet i never knew i wanted
Haha! That's the fun of making these arrangements - discovering what songs go well together. :)
This is incredible 🔥🔥🔥
Every note he played on Star Wars I got goose bumbs
I love both. My favourite themes are Star Wars, Pirates of the Caribbean and Harry Potter.
Woah dark night and binary sunset sound great together
Luca Frankel thats actually not binary sunset... its just the force theme. And binary sunset uses it as main melody but its used in many songs in Star wars
Hans Zimmer’s scores do the perfect job of creating a huge amount of suspense and creating emotion but they’re not the most memorable. Pirates of the Caribbean is the only Zimmer score I can call iconic. John Williams’s scores do an amazing job of creating suspense and emotion but also a sense of wonder, excitement, scores that makes you feel like you’re in the world of the characrers.
Both are 20/10 composers though
...Lion King?
The most popular theme from Pirates of the Caribbean "He's a Pirate" is the Klaus Badelt score, not Hans Zimmer score ;)
These two guys are NOT only great musicians, but they have decent acting skills at their disposal.
They could make a jaw dropping duo.
Winner John Williams
WOW, this is so AWESOME! Ireally love the music of Hans Zimmer. harry Potter also sounds cool.
I heard the Avengers theme for a second somewhere between the part they were playing Gladiator and Star Wars
Also I kind of hear the Ant-Man theme in Angels & Demons
hans zimmer has influenced many of todays composers who have found more success but less fame than him
Silverbolt Bluefire except he's better they're all better then Zimmer
Hans Zimmer wins by a landslide.
He really does. A lot of people don't realise how intricate Hans's creative thought process is - he's the kind of composer where you'd be able to point to any aspect of the music (a note, a particular timbre, etc.) and he'll be able to tell you exactly why he included it. A lot of other composers who seek out Hans's 'signature' sound don't realise exactly why Hans chose the sounds that he did, and that's why most of their stuff sounds B-Grade (at least to myself). It's the same with composers who try and copy John Williams's music - Williams knows exactly why he orchestrated his music the way he did, whereas other composers don't - again causing the same B-Grade 'John Williams' style problem.
That being said, I also believe it isn't exactly right to say one composer is better than another, seeing as they all have different sounds, styles, thought processes and motivations to begin with anyway. There will always be some who will copy others, even unintentionally (Isn't that true for every creative industry? Something new happens to work, and literally everyone copies it?) but at the end of the day, all us artists have our own style / voice. You can't compare Hans with Michael Giacchino, John Williams with Brian Tyler, Beethoven with Mendelsohhn, Pablo Picasso with Van Gogh... there's too many factors to consider.
I've actually been waiting forever for this! Two musical legends.
I say John Williams because I have personally played his music before on the Trumpet before, no bias there 😀
Pigman 782 yes that is bias.
Muy difícil, pero es mejor John Williams
Very difficult, but John Williams is better.
Felicidades, gran vídeo.
Congratulations, great video
El Árbol Rojo exacto compañero
Interstellar*
coincido contigo
Yo creo que ambos son geniales, empate
Por fin alguien que habla español
Amazing!!!!
John Williams!!!
This was utterly fantabulous such a an entertaining video eduthata with all those edits in. XD I loved it great work
3:33 Lol “Star Wars? More Like Star Bores.” At Least I didn’t make an orchestral version of “SPIDER-PIG”
Hahahaha that was funny
John Williams ❤️
C'est le meilleur // It's the best
I love this and these types of of duets, but He's a Pirates was technically composed by Klaus Badelt, not Hans Zimmer who mostly arranged it for the sequels
Both composed it
Actually Zimmer wrote He's a Pirate originally, but then he got wrapped up in other stuff so Klaus took over using the themes he'd already written.
You cannot decide on one better winner. I think William’s scores are probably more well known and iconic, while Zimmer’s work digs into your soul.
Just be happy we all got to live in an age at the same time as these two musical gods.
John Williams: Its over Hans i have the high ground
Hans Zimmer: Parsnip...par... PARLAY