Eye Conqueror no it means if there arent 10 godlike players out there dont jus pick a avg one for ex peyton bein a dog and eli a cat jus cuz theres not 10 peytons dont pick a eli
@@jpatt85 yeah remember when he had earth,wind,and fire as his runningbacks Jacobs,ward,and Bradshaw?..now that I think of it he has plenty of weapons more than the average qb
Rutik Patel also threw 14 picks. To Brady’s 7. Had a worst completion record and yds/game. And that wasn’t one of Brady’s best years by any means. So if an average year for Brady (at least for the last 12-13 years is Eli’s best year...not sure what point you’re tryna make. Oh wait. You’re just saying that for 1 year of his entire career he was “maybe” the 4th best quarterback. My bad. That does sound HOF worthy.
SpaceTurtle Eli is not a hall of famer. The regular season matters. I’m tired of this 2x super bowl champions/Super bowl mvp. The hall of fame is about being elite for at least 8 to 10 years or extraordinary for a few years for example BO Jackson or Sean Taylor. Eli is none of those
@eoe123321 I think that's the point and i'm sure most people are fine with that. It's for the best of the best, whether it be ten inducted that year or none at all.
High Life Can’t believe Stephen A didn’t mention that. That is the only thing he would have had to say. Dude was never the best in the league not even for a single year lmfao.
Dino's Games988 hea clearly letting his feelings for NY/eli get in the way of the actual fact that eli is average at best. Had two great playoff runs but take that away he is as good as stafford, dalton lol
It's not even that the stats show him too be bad, he is shown too be average and THAT IS FINE. He is an "aight" QB for 16 years. How many people get too say even that ? He's earned his money, his body probably has the miles too show for it. Let him retire gracefully. All this conversation shows is that too much emphasis is placed on the individual when it comes too SB wins. Which is BS, I hear that it is two wins against the Patriots, but those wins are significant because of how good the Patriots were in comparison too the Giants, not because it was two equally matched QB's going too war. Too put Eli Manning in the HOF as a first ballot means that if aliens came too earth they could rightfully assume that if you had 2 SB rings and a HOF induction, then you were about the same level of player, which means Eli and Peyton are the same. It can't be allowed too happen like that.
@@textbook1263 : agreed. Football is more of a team sport than any other. Almost no one plays both offense and defense. Eli Manning should NOT be in the Hall of Fame.
It also implies only specifically to Eli situation that he is/was the beneficiary of Nepotism. Can anyone honestly say Eli is a Better Quarterback than Nick Foles? forget the team accomplishments from what you have seen watching the games who plays the position better? yet and still no one should argue Foles is a HoFer either, football is a game of a million moving parts and small sample sizes and Eli is the result of a mathematical anomaly that will appear when those two things collide.
You also have to put into account the competition Eli had to go through to win both those chips. On top of the clutch plays he made to get them thru. I agree with Max that he’s right on the line
Brady and Eli are the same prototype.... as for Russel Wilson and Mahomes. Eli has more super bowl rings and MVP‘a than both of them so far. Yea, I’d take 2 Super Bowls and 15 years of never missing a game from a starting quarterback.
So being able to beat the Patriots when nobody else in the league beat them and to beat them when it counted most not once but twice?? That’s crazy but with put people in the HOF who haven’t won the big game at all???
Victor Cruz Plaxico Burress Steve Smith Odell Beckham Mario Manningham hakeem hicks Do you know what they all have in common right now they have never had a better season without Eli
Because you can’t fire her because certain people don’t like when she opens her mouth. It’s hypocritical to get on her when everyone else on this show is just as loud. Grow up
Carl Rice you do get that employees that have a little pull in the company have a say in the hiring and firing of individuals right? Welcome to the real world lol
"Eli usually didn't have offensive weapons." - Max Kellerman. "But Carson Wentz should elevate the players around him without top tier offensive weapons." - also Max Kellerman. This is exactly the example of why these media clowns are impossible to support or understand 😂
@@hiitsme3039 Are u stupid or a Giants fan? Eli SUCKS!! Those 2 SB's mean not much. The HOF should be for the best of the best. Eli isnt. And if you say he is, Im sorry but you dont understand football.
Mr Bigchest but you cannot look past them though.. his accolades propelled him into the hall of fame. Know one is debating if he’s skilled enough to be in the hall of fame but we cannot ignore is Super Bowl MVPs
CEO_GetBucketz that's what I'm saying not to mention he won those against the best teams probably in the patriots WHOLE dynasty and this is coming from a pats fan
Oh come on now, so a team paid him millions because of his last name, that doesn’t make any sense. He was a decent to good quarterback and deserved his position based on his play. But he does not deserve to be in the hall of fame in my opinion.
This makes no sense. 10 years ago he had already won a title. You guys have no idea what u are talking about when it comes to Eli. If he wasn't peyton's brother he would be appreciated more. You guys act like Eli lucked his way to two titles when in reality those 2 runs were 2 of the best 7 runs in NFL history. The Eli slander is nuts.
Don't be disrespectful. he was the best QB in the 04 class and he was better Romo for Dallas who he played against alot and who you're probably a fan of
Not first take excuse me, the Chris Carter and nick Wright led commentary program I forget the name but jenna fisher is common to appear and she brings genuine insight and questions that are relevant.
She Absolutely clueless!! She is a arbiter that's it!! She makes no sense on neither show that she has done. Just be quiet and read the teleprompter chick!!
@@dexterroberts5569 People don't seem to grasp the idea of a team like you two seem to do. While I won't penalize the overall team record of 117-117 with him as a QB, I won't reward him for two SB's primarily won by the defense. The SB MVP award is a joke. It's almost always given to the winning team QB. SAS is right about the Giants defense deserving the award. Being considered for the HOF needs to be primarily based on individual accomplishments. Dan Marino didn't need to be on any winning SB teams to deserve his spot in the HOF since he had a tremendous career as an individual performer.
@@stevensegura9925 Super Bowls don’t mean everything. If that were the case legends like Marino, Tarkenton, Munoz and Bruce Smith wouldn’t be in the HOF
@@chadbinger8700 have no problem with anyone saying Eli is not a hof'er, long as y'all agree that qbs without a ring like Dan Marino, Jim Kelly, Fran Tarkenton, & Dan Fouts are not hof'ers as well. Eli was the mvp of 2 superbowls, defeating the goat Tom Brady twice in his prime when the Patriots were undefeated going into one of the superbowls. So basically all I'm saying is.. keep that same energy
Nooo that’s bs they needa stop adding good players in there and keep it exclusive to the people the elevated the game of football or any sport for that matter
"He threw in a bad weather stadium so that affect stats" Um, hello, look at Brett Farve at Lambeau on a bad weather stadium. Farve threw a lot of Ints like Eli but his arm is on another level than Eli.
@Jonathan McCully First of all...Dont call me dummy unless you can name all 206 bones in your own body in which as a therapist I can. 2nd..The Football vernacular is This QB beat that QB. We all know QBs dont actually face one another. I'm sure hear sports analyst say all the time QB A. beat QB C. etc. It's just sports cli'che!
@King Swift Big Ben NEVER had the 31st ranked defense. The worst they were ranked was 18th with an average rank of 7th during his career (with 11 Top 10 finishes).
Imo, Dion is the GOAT football player...he is the best cornerback of all time, and not just that, he played both offense and defense, while winning a super bowl wit two different teams..and not to mention, he's the only athlete to appear in a championship in two different sports..🤷
JAMES HARDEN 3time dpoy there’s no nba HOF it’s basketball HOF if your a great college player and win NCAA championships you’ll get in the basketball HOF even if your a average nba player
@@bigda6407 there's validity to that. However you can argue Christian Laettner, perhaps the greatest college player of the modern era. Had a so-so NBA career, 1 Allstar appearance, a few above average seasons. He's not in the Basketball HOF as a player (in as part of the Dream Team).
@@bigda6407 I think its easier to make the basketball hall of fame than the NFL hall of fame. Average players make it into the hall of fame all the time. There are still players in the NFL that probably deserves consideration that has not made it in the hall of fame yet. People like Andre Rison and a few others were pretty good and have decent resumes have not made it yet.
They say no with no context which Max provided. A lot of these former pro's have no concept of the history of the game. Look at other QB's that are in, what they did in their careers in comparison to Eli. Look at guys like Moon, Fouts, Namath, Kelly, Aikman, Bradshaw, and compare the numbers and career accomplishments to Eli. Aikman is a guy even for the 90's his passing stats suck.. Why is he in? 3 rings.. Well Eli has 2 and finished top 10 in passing stats. Did Aikman finish top 10 in anything? Young, Elway, Favre, Marino all put up numbers in the same era.. Aikman spent a lot of time handing off to Smith.. Eli is an easy HOF lock..
@@dbreiden83080, please compare Eli to his contemporaries and not to QBs in other eras. When you do that you realize that he wasn't even top 6 in his era. During the last 4 decades name the QBs that were ranked 6th or lower who made it to the HOF? Eli is getting a HOF participation trophy because his team beat Brady's in 2 SBs. Other than that he average. He's not better than the Rivers and Roethlisberger who in his draft class. He's not better than Rogers, Brady, Brees, or his brother. That's at least 6 ahead of him.
@@carlosm.6348 Yea I might've gassed it after thinking about it. Other sports definitely are crazy tough as well. But if you looked at the line of NFL guys waiting to get in, its a lot of players you'd expect were already hall of famers.
@@ethancollins5884 yea I wonder why a sport that has a 53 man roster with 32 teams has more hall of famers than a sport like basketball that has 15 man roster and 30 teams. And, baseball has more hall of famers.
Depending on the season, Eli was good, to average, to below average, through out his 16 seasons. He has two SB rings, because he had a great defense, excellent running game, and a great coach. In all honesty Phil Simms was better in his era than Eli was. And Phil Simms has 2 SB wins as well... and Phil Simms is not in the Hall of Fame.
In the 99 years of professional football there have been 23,204 players. Of those, 326 have made it into the pro hall of fame. That is an admittance rate of 1.4%. The NFL HOF is definitely not too easy to get into.
Yea but it’s trending towards where good players can get in not just ALL TIME GREATS Brady brees Rodgers Peyton Montana Marino Elway these are all time greats they’re game changers Eli is not an all time great nor a game changer
S T when i hear Eli Manning i think pro football Hall of Famer Eli was apart of the QB draft class of 04 1st overall pick which included Steelers Big Ben Chargers Philips Rivers Packers Aaron Rodgers Giants Eli Manning All future Hall of Famers
Edward Raymond He sure wasn't he was in 2005 draft the rest where and Eli Manning kepted up with these future Hall of Famers QBs, Eli has 2 bowl titles, Big Ben has 2, Rodgers has 1, Rivers has none
Eli Manning is 1 inch from David Tyree dropping the luckiest catch in the history of football and having 1 Super Bowl title and not even being in the conversation. Let's be real.
@@Mercenary-1914 Because catching a ball off the crown of your helmet while falling backwards is a routine catch. Every week throughout the NFL, right ? Can you hear yourself ? Stop it.😂🤣😂
The only people cheering Molly are giant fans. He’s a giants HOF, but not an NFL HOFer. He may have started a lot of years, but he certainly lost a lot of them. He really only started towards the end of the year because of nostalgia.
If Eli Manning is a Hall of famer then Julian Edelman is a Hall of famer 3 super bowl championships and 1 MVP Second behind Jerry Rice in receiving yards in the playoffs.
@@DMT_Zel yet they still beat the 13-3 Cowboys with TO, Jason Whitten & Tony Romo, then beat the Green Bay Packers, followed by the 16-0 Patriots with Brady, Randy Moss, Wes Welker
sick of hearing qbs get all the love for winning sbs when so many other positions play a part. i never once watched eli manning, and said that dude right there is elite. maybe a homelessmans peyton manning but never elite.
jeffx40 No doubt Eli Manning is going to be enshrined in Canton, OH he kepted up with one of the greatest QB draft class in NFL history the 2004 draft Giants Eli Manning Ole Miss Chargers Phillips Rivers NC Packers Aaron Rodgers Cal Steelers Big Ben Miami, OH All of these guys are Hall of Famers Aa
@@Jjbarrea124 being in the HOF is a career award bro. He has never played at an elite level and both those Superbowls his offense scored less then 21 points.
HyD3PH THA REAL I’m not arguing he should be there. But Participation you get for showing up. He did a little bit more than just show up. Whether you think he deserved the super bowls or not. He won them.
@@Jjbarrea124 yeah and so did the other 53 players winning the Superbowl is a team accomplishment especially win he arguably had one of the best defenses in the league. Not taking away from that just putting it more into perspective.
@eoe123321, actually he was considered a top QB in the league from 2000 until about 2000 - 2003. Then injuries derailed his career from there. Regardless of Fisher holding McNair back as a QB or not, McNair was always considered a warrior in the NFL and he led his team to playoff success, his defense didn't have to carry majority of the load. Not to mention, McNair won the regular season MVP trophy and he was the MVP for his team the year they went to the Super Bowl. With all of that said, I'm with SAS and Deion on this discussion. I don't think Eli should be a HOF'er because he won two Super Bowls and won MVP's for those games when anyone on his defensive unit should have won those awards. If Eli gets in, the bar is being lowered by the NFL on who is allowed into the HOF and you are opening the gates from guys like Nick Foles and Joe Flacco to get into the HOF, two guys that shouldn't even sniff the HOF.
![“อาร์ต พศุตม์” เกือบเอี่ยวทุกคดีดัง เอ๊ะไว้ก่อน ไม่มีอะไรได้มาง่ายๆ | แฉ 16 ต.ค. 67 [2/3] | GMM25](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/0Gx-0-kUBv8/mqdefault.jpg)
![일상 속 기분 좋음 [Proto disco meme]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/DwmEIaZ7XGQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Molly was feelin herself a lil too much today
No one is happy about that
Guandeep Mann lmao!
Lmao
Literally went to the comments to post that, guess others feel the same, good lookin out.
Very disrespectful @Guandeep Mann
I mean if she was feeling herself in the other why I wouldn’t mind
I’m not on the Molly hate train but she does this to herself lol
Jumbo Storm I’m definitely on that train 🚂
I'll get in on the train for Molly
You guys need to STFU talking about Molly!
@otherzinc or what 😂
@@TheyCallMeTim he'll dislike your comment 💀
Deion had the perfect quote on undisputed "if there aint 10 dogs out there, dont pick a cat"
Facts
Is this a dog fighting analogy loo
Eye Conqueror no it means if there arent 10 godlike players out there dont jus pick a avg one for ex peyton bein a dog and eli a cat jus cuz theres not 10 peytons dont pick a eli
For real!!!
Duckrockerz4life 😂
“Didn’t have too much offensive weapons”
Victor Cruz? Odell Beckham? Mario Mannigham? Plaxico Burress?
,amani toomer prolly one of his best and hakeem nicks
Snewz see I forgot bout them two , he had plenty and successful receiving cores
Tiki Barber, Brandon Jacobs, Jeremy Shockey
@@jpatt85 yeah remember when he had earth,wind,and fire as his runningbacks Jacobs,ward,and Bradshaw?..now that I think of it he has plenty of weapons more than the average qb
Bear Pascoe, Jake Ballard, Steve Smith
"Never even a Top 5 QB in the League during any year of his Career"...That is such a GREAT Point!...
joe chrow 2015. He had 35 tds (Tied with Brady and had over 4,200 yards)
@@rutikpatel7700 Probably Eli's best statistical season. But he was still 7th in yards and 12th in QBR that year. Plus his team went 6-10.
Rutik Patel
also threw 14 picks. To Brady’s 7. Had a worst completion record and yds/game. And that wasn’t one of Brady’s best years by any means. So if an average year for Brady (at least for the last 12-13 years is Eli’s best year...not sure what point you’re tryna make.
Oh wait. You’re just saying that for 1 year of his entire career he was “maybe” the 4th best quarterback. My bad. That does sound HOF worthy.
joe chrow 2011 and 2015
Rutik Patel never threw for over 300 yards..
Does Molly get that yelling at someone doesn’t make your point any more significant or correct?
StudioSJS she gets it from Screamin A Smith
I don't think any of them get that.
women
StudioSJS she learned from Stephen a
Does Steven A? All he does is yell.
I've been saying that for years. The hall of fame should be for the absolute best of the best players of their era.
Meester Chris I never knew why they let people in the HOF eventually, people in the mid 70’s that I never heard of will eventually get in 😂
Your right, it should be that way for most if not all the HOFs.
SpaceTurtle Eli is not a hall of famer. The regular season matters. I’m tired of this 2x super bowl champions/Super bowl mvp. The hall of fame is about being elite for at least 8 to 10 years or extraordinary for a few years for example BO Jackson or Sean Taylor. Eli is none of those
@eoe123321 I think that's the point and i'm sure most people are fine with that. It's for the best of the best, whether it be ten inducted that year or none at all.
@@tjrose9830 You know nothing about sports to mention those guys. Neither one of them did close to what Eli did.
0 all pros in 16 years, thats the end of the discussion
Agreed
High Life Can’t believe Stephen A didn’t mention that. That is the only thing he would have had to say. Dude was never the best in the league not even for a single year lmfao.
2 ring 2 super bowl mvp end of discussion 🤷🏽♀️🤝
Salman Adan Lead the league in Interceptions 3 years in a row. End of discussion
Salman Adan so If I did that and had trash seasons after that I guess I’m one🤦🏽♂️🤨
I’ve never heard of a coach say he’s looking for the next Eli Manning...
DownSouth BearsFan901 😂😂😂
DownSouth BearsFan901 facts
I'm sure I've never heard of a coach saying they want a Mitchell Trubisky
DownSouth BearsFan901 the giants just did this
Julian Rodriguez @ Facts but that not the ?. You Giants fans have hated Eli for the last 5 yrs now all of a sudden he’s a HOFer.GTFOH😂😂
“Very Disrespectful Stephen A” - Molly Qerim
No one asked for your opinion
She was so annoying this segment. No valid points, just a lot of yelling.
100%
And yet here you are not getting paid to talk....and you still subject us your ignorance. Cut her some slack.
TOPSPOT She, what about Stephen A. Smith big loud mouth screaming i'm not even halfway through it and is getting a headache
She make my stomach hurt
Max: so no one will make it in the HOF unless you are an All-Time Great?
YES!!
Dino's Games988 hea clearly letting his feelings for NY/eli get in the way of the actual fact that eli is average at best. Had two great playoff runs but take that away he is as good as stafford, dalton lol
That's the point lol. Max is biased.
Ok name me guys who should be hall of fake who are currently playing
@@Phoneybeetlemaniacxs tom brady. aaron rodgers. Drew brees. Russell wilson. Deshaun watson. Pat mahomes.
@@pinkbeavers I'm with you until D Watson and pat. They haven't built the resume yet.
Stepha A Smith: stats show he’s bad.
Max: he’s been an iron man.
That only implies that he’s been bad for a very long time.
It's not even that the stats show him too be bad, he is shown too be average and THAT IS FINE. He is an "aight" QB for 16 years. How many people get too say even that ? He's earned his money, his body probably has the miles too show for it. Let him retire gracefully.
All this conversation shows is that too much emphasis is placed on the individual when it comes too SB wins. Which is BS, I hear that it is two wins against the Patriots, but those wins are significant because of how good the Patriots were in comparison too the Giants, not because it was two equally matched QB's going too war.
Too put Eli Manning in the HOF as a first ballot means that if aliens came too earth they could rightfully assume that if you had 2 SB rings and a HOF induction, then you were about the same level of player, which means Eli and Peyton are the same. It can't be allowed too happen like that.
@@textbook1263 : agreed. Football is more of a team sport than any other. Almost no one plays both offense and defense. Eli Manning should NOT be in the Hall of Fame.
LeBron has been to 9 finals, I bet he wished we went to just 3 good ones :P
@@23ElCaliente : what? LeBron HAS three rings.
It also implies only specifically to Eli situation that he is/was the beneficiary of Nepotism.
Can anyone honestly say Eli is a Better Quarterback than Nick Foles? forget the team accomplishments from what you have seen watching the games who plays the position better?
yet and still no one should argue Foles is a HoFer either, football is a game of a million moving parts and small sample sizes and Eli is the result of a mathematical anomaly that will appear when those two things collide.
Max's argument is just like having a great attendance record at school but being a c-minus average student 😂😂😂
Perfect way to explain it
Hit it on the money😂😂😂
But if you get a perfect score on the ACT / SAT you getting into nearly every college
😂😂😂
You also have to put into account the competition Eli had to go through to win both those chips. On top of the clutch plays he made to get them thru. I agree with Max that he’s right on the line
“You all hear the crowd?” What is this, a episode of smackdown?
basically yeah
Dawg 😭😭😭
Selleck Fiataugaluia nothing just another episode listening to loud big mouth Stephen A. Smith scream about stuff he knows absolutely nothing about
🤣☠️
@@elhombrenegro4999 Eli is not a hall of famer
You hear GMs say we're looking for the next Brady, Russell Wilson, or Mahomes but I've never heard a GM say we're looking for next Eli
Rodan 99 facts
Then whats Daniel Jones?
Cause Eli is what GM is looking for. 6'5 strong arm, good mobilty not a scrambler, accurate passer thats what every GM hunt if available
Brady and Eli are the same prototype.... as for Russel Wilson and Mahomes. Eli has more super bowl rings and MVP‘a than both of them so far. Yea, I’d take 2 Super Bowls and 15 years of never missing a game from a starting quarterback.
@@dylanspurlock6150 his defense won those super bowls let keep it real he was ok in those games
Deion is right. And Eli Manning is a "C" level QB at best not a HOF.
Absolutely disrespectful. A C? That's bull. Phillip Rivers is a C level. Eli's at least a B.
So being able to beat the Patriots when nobody else in the league beat them and to beat them when it counted most not once but twice?? That’s crazy but with put people in the HOF who haven’t won the big game at all???
Papermanfla that’s cap but he might not be hof
Rastik Reviews you are literally giving Eli all the credit when the giants defense won them those chips
@@rastikreviews4586 : _{you said} "beat them when it counted most"_
Dude, bottom 5 teams have beaten top 5 teams in the NFL in a given week.
Bro Molly needs locking up
Dis comment so funny g 💀💀deadass doe
😂😂😂
She's hot
🤣🤣
Lmao
She should never get in anyone’s face like that.
AJ Astar Miami is getting to her head
“At no time, AT NO TIME” 😂😂😂
I’m a giants fan and I agree! Every time Eli threw the ball I was nervous.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 I'm in danger /Ralph Wiggum meme comes to mind.
An interception was possible on most of his throws.
Does anyone else find Molly’s voice extremely annoying?
Smh
Everything about her is annoying
What took u so long to notice lol
Stephen is the most annoying voice
She’s wonderful
“He threw in a bad weather stadium”.... !?!?😂😂😂😂... Max , you wylin.
For real.... Like has he never heard of Aaron Rodgers.... Or Ben Roethlisberger..... Or Russell Wilson?
Lmao
Ikr???😊
Hel I'm like so did Bret Farva, Jim Kelly Phil Sims.. Eli was good but not a HOF player like his big brother..
excuse me but he beat Tom Brady twice
Molly them dudes just wanna smash don’t listen to them
Lmao
facts
she needs to shut up
I'm dead 💀
its ight, we don't listen to molly either LOL
Eli will be remembered for 2 things
1 haveing a defemse that beat brady 2 times
2 being peytons little brother
That does not make you a hall of famer
He deserves credit for his clutch play!
Straight facts
@@AmirKhan-yv8jm Manning wasn’t clutch, David Tyree was though.
Stephen A is right.
Also I never hear Max bring up the lack of weapons of playing in bad weather with Brady.
Max hates on TB12
because Max is a delusional Giants fanboy
Victor Cruz Plaxico Burress Steve Smith Odell Beckham Mario Manningham hakeem hicks Do you know what they all have in common right now they have never had a better season without Eli
Brady had the refs...the ultimate weapon
@@fredwright987 Nothing more pathetic than losers who blame the refs for losses.
Molly: “Very disrespectful Stephen A”
Everyone on the comment section: 🥱 🥱🥱
Stephen is a drama queen
😂😂😂
Why is Molly still on this show
herkeda bingo
Yep. I miss Carie
Because you can’t fire her because certain people don’t like when she opens her mouth. It’s hypocritical to get on her when everyone else on this show is just as loud. Grow up
Carl Rice you do get that employees that have a little pull in the company have a say in the hiring and firing of individuals right? Welcome to the real world lol
StudioSJS that was such a stupid comment
When molly tried to jump in with and talk. 💀💀💀💀💀😭😭
"Eli usually didn't have offensive weapons." - Max Kellerman.
"But Carson Wentz should elevate the players around him without top tier offensive weapons." - also Max Kellerman.
This is exactly the example of why these media clowns are impossible to support or understand 😂
Brenden Clifford yes he should because Eli did that which shows in his rings
@@hiitsme3039 Eli didn't win those rings fam lmao. And Eli was also mediocre for 80 percent of his career. You clearly missed the point here.b
Carson wentz is not a top tier QB
Its just that Max is crazy
@@hiitsme3039 Are u stupid or a Giants fan? Eli SUCKS!! Those 2 SB's mean not much. The HOF should be for the best of the best. Eli isnt. And if you say he is, Im sorry but you dont understand football.
Stephen A said they giving Eli a participation HOF award. 😂😂😂
Yea those 2 Superbowl plays that will be remembered for all time prob best plays in Superbowl history was just participating
Mr Bigchest but you cannot look past them though.. his accolades propelled him into the hall of fame. Know one is debating if he’s skilled enough to be in the hall of fame but we cannot ignore is Super Bowl MVPs
CEO_GetBucketz that's what I'm saying not to mention he won those against the best teams probably in the patriots WHOLE dynasty and this is coming from a pats fan
@@ceo_getbucketz6761 Charlie Batch got a SB ring and your point exactly?
@@ceo_getbucketz6761 Trent Dilfer got a SB ring and your point is?
20 seconds into the vid, I already shouted "SHUT UP MOLLY!"
His last name is “Manning” if he wasn’t a Manning he would have been out of the league 10 years ago!
Rozilla2006 nah cause 10 years ago he was still leading a team to the Super Bowl
Oh come on now, so a team paid him millions because of his last name, that doesn’t make any sense. He was a decent to good quarterback and deserved his position based on his play. But he does not deserve to be in the hall of fame in my opinion.
@@joncoish his name didn't get him two super bowls
This makes no sense. 10 years ago he had already won a title. You guys have no idea what u are talking about when it comes to Eli. If he wasn't peyton's brother he would be appreciated more. You guys act like Eli lucked his way to two titles when in reality those 2 runs were 2 of the best 7 runs in NFL history. The Eli slander is nuts.
Don't be disrespectful. he was the best QB in the 04 class and he was better Romo for Dallas who he played against alot and who you're probably a fan of
5:02 Molly does the opposite of what a moderator is supposed to do
dude thank you. she's a horrible moderator.
Wow Molly is extra today
shes high on pcp clearly
She’s a Giants fan so she gets a pass this time
OMG....PREACH!!! I can't stand her!!!
Molly doesn’t even know where she’s at right now or what’s going on
😂😂 based on a true story
Why Molly talks is the biggest mystery of the century
Clash Smchitcle 😂😂😂
The HOF should be a very exclusive club. Agree with Sanders
I think I finally understand why viewers don’t like molly. As well, Ros Gold makes Molly look like a novice amateur.
J R molly IS a novice amateur lol
Ros isn't that great either js
I prefer jenna from first take or undisputed
Not first take excuse me, the Chris Carter and nick Wright led commentary program I forget the name but jenna fisher is common to appear and she brings genuine insight and questions that are relevant.
Here is the reason why undisputed is better than first take:
1. Molly
2. Please refer to number 1
Cant stand her
@@alanmontandon4452 what did she do to you for you not to stand here
@@eugenerollins985 Only time I find her annoying is when she speaks....
If molly didn’t speak undisputed would be so much better
they need ros back
Max: "I LET YOU SPEAK!!!" 😂😂😂
Stephen a was not a fan of that
For once max let someone speak
4:47 😂Marcus Spears reaction after Molly's ("WHT ARREE U WAiiiTiiiNNNG FOOOORRR!" From the Movie Scream voice Outburst)
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
This chick can’t name 10 hall of famers to save her life
Crankmasterg * a could only can name around maybe 200 to 225 myself on a piece of paper
She Absolutely clueless!! She is a arbiter that's it!! She makes no sense on neither show that she has done. Just be quiet and read the teleprompter chick!!
Watching Molly moderate First take makes me appreciate Jenny Taft from Undisputed so much more.
CoolKid50 facts
Ros needs to replace her
JINNYY
As much as I love Eli, Stephen A is right in my opinion 😭😭😭
Adrian Gonzalez
yes, Eli is basic, with two lucky super bowls
@@dexterroberts5569 People don't seem to grasp the idea of a team like you two seem to do. While I won't penalize the overall team record of 117-117 with him as a QB, I won't reward him for two SB's primarily won by the defense. The SB MVP award is a joke. It's almost always given to the winning team QB. SAS is right about the Giants defense deserving the award. Being considered for the HOF needs to be primarily based on individual accomplishments. Dan Marino didn't need to be on any winning SB teams to deserve his spot in the HOF since he had a tremendous career as an individual performer.
Won two Superbowls
@@stevensegura9925 Super Bowls don’t mean everything. If that were the case legends like Marino, Tarkenton, Munoz and Bruce Smith wouldn’t be in the HOF
@@chadbinger8700 have no problem with anyone saying Eli is not a hof'er, long as y'all agree that qbs without a ring like Dan Marino, Jim Kelly, Fran Tarkenton, & Dan Fouts are not hof'ers as well. Eli was the mvp of 2 superbowls, defeating the goat Tom Brady twice in his prime when the Patriots were undefeated going into one of the superbowls. So basically all I'm saying is.. keep that same energy
For the sake of Deion's case there needs to be a new group on the HOF called the HOF Elite.
In Australian football, we fixed this issue. Added the category ‘legend’. With a longer period before induction.
Nooo that’s bs they needa stop adding good players in there and keep it exclusive to the people the elevated the game of football or any sport for that matter
There is a Top 100 players of all-time list, not everyone in the HOF is on that list. But everyone on that list is or will be in the HOF!
Lmao crowd got Molly wet 😂😂😂
Stephen A Smith: His Reckerrrrd
😂😂😂
Lol
Lmfao I caught that too. 😂
Please explain how any pro athlete who won 50% of their games should be in the HOF.
Molly has to go now, she is feeling herself way to much
Tiger Hoods you don’t feel like that’s getting old and corny
bradders344 didn’t know molly has a burner account
Jkap Pakj it’s true tho
I want ROS!
She’s got garbage
"He threw in a bad weather stadium so that affect stats" Um, hello, look at Brett Farve at Lambeau on a bad weather stadium. Farve threw a lot of Ints like Eli but his arm is on another level than Eli.
Molly must've had a few drinks this morning lol. She feeling it 🤫
She talking that talk today ha
Whenever Molly talks i just wish i could turb into The Rock an scream IT DOESNT MATTER WHAT YOU THINK !
I agreed
What is it going to take to get her off of this show
TrunksCell haha you're opinion is a lot less important, and wanted than molly's😁
thetrib1 just because she is a girl doesn’t mean she should be on the show to be respectful to girls. They know so much more than her
all the ugly feminist and beta boys will crucify you
Eli Manning is not a Hall of Famer, period, point blank.
Eli is gonna be inducted just for his 2 SB victories over Tom Brady!
@Jonathan McCully First of all...Dont call me dummy unless you can name all 206 bones in your own body in which as a therapist I can. 2nd..The Football vernacular is This QB beat that QB. We all know QBs dont actually face one another. I'm sure hear sports analyst say all the time QB A. beat QB C. etc. It's just sports cli'che!
@King Swift Big Ben NEVER had the 31st ranked defense. The worst they were ranked was 18th with an average rank of 7th during his career (with 11 Top 10 finishes).
I love how the crowd came to a screeching silence when Molly tried to make an emphatic case for Eli. (Crickets) 🤣😂🤣👆🏾
Imo, Dion is the GOAT football player...he is the best cornerback of all time, and not just that, he played both offense and defense, while winning a super bowl wit two different teams..and not to mention, he's the only athlete to appear in a championship in two different sports..🤷
You mean best (athlete). baseball championship doesn't have anything to do with football play
Hes the only player to play in the Superbowl and world series he didn't win a world series with Atlanta get your facts straight 💯
What about Bo Jackson?
@@m.r.h4176 I know, I'm just throwing that in there lol
Kurt Warner shouldn't be in either.
Molly’s voice makes me turn off the tv literally every time I hear it
Offers nothing to the conversation and sounds like the crazy fans
You're far from being alone with that thought...
I don't know they don't get rid of her
No need to share your gayness
Carlos 27 that’s crazy bro
Max already messed up comparing the NBA and NFL HOF
JAMES HARDEN 3time dpoy there’s no nba HOF it’s basketball HOF if your a great college player and win NCAA championships you’ll get in the basketball HOF even if your a average nba player
BIG DA my fault but you’re right about average players making it
@@bigda6407 there's validity to that. However you can argue Christian Laettner, perhaps the greatest college player of the modern era. Had a so-so NBA career, 1 Allstar appearance, a few above average seasons. He's not in the Basketball HOF as a player (in as part of the Dream Team).
@@bigda6407 I think its easier to make the basketball hall of fame than the NFL hall of fame. Average players make it into the hall of fame all the time. There are still players in the NFL that probably deserves consideration that has not made it in the hall of fame yet. People like Andre Rison and a few others were pretty good and have decent resumes have not made it yet.
NBA hall of fame has some suspect entries too.
Molly at 4:47 is sickening you can see it on their faces lmaoooo
Marcus Spears was so frustrated by Molly 🤣🤣🤣🤣
We all were.
1:50
*Stephen A:* "When you look at his recuurd, even his recuurd"
I wish he would cut his hair off
@@dwaynejohnson7287 lmao. leave that mans hairline alone
DWAYNE JOHNSON you that concerned over another mans haircut? 😂
I wish they’d chant “molly shut up”
Nobody:
Molly: @4:47
Lady just starts yelling out of nowhere haha
We got a Molly chant... My god
Kevin Carmody they confused .... the was just praising Eli like he was the greatest 🤦♂️
Kevin Carmody it’s miami, they will root for pretty women all the time. It’s a party city.
They just tryna hit
thanks for the warning, Im not gunna watch the vid now. You doing gods work
They just gassed her head up for atleast 30 episodes 🤦🏾♂️🤦🏾♂️🤦🏾♂️
Max wasn't prepared for them to answer "no" to the Billups question.
They say no with no context which Max provided. A lot of these former pro's have no concept of the history of the game. Look at other QB's that are in, what they did in their careers in comparison to Eli. Look at guys like Moon, Fouts, Namath, Kelly, Aikman, Bradshaw, and compare the numbers and career accomplishments to Eli. Aikman is a guy even for the 90's his passing stats suck.. Why is he in? 3 rings.. Well Eli has 2 and finished top 10 in passing stats. Did Aikman finish top 10 in anything? Young, Elway, Favre, Marino all put up numbers in the same era.. Aikman spent a lot of time handing off to Smith.. Eli is an easy HOF lock..
dbreiden83080 😭😭 bro Eli is 117-117 case done he belongs in the hof for good players not the best sorry 🤷🏽♂️
dbreiden83080 ridiculous. The man was never a top 5 qb. Heck I can make a case for never being a top 10. Look Eli is good but he was never ever elite.
Facts.😂😂😂😂
@@dbreiden83080, please compare Eli to his contemporaries and not to QBs in other eras. When you do that you realize that he wasn't even top 6 in his era. During the last 4 decades name the QBs that were ranked 6th or lower who made it to the HOF? Eli is getting a HOF participation trophy because his team beat Brady's in 2 SBs. Other than that he average. He's not better than the Rivers and Roethlisberger who in his draft class. He's not better than Rogers, Brady, Brees, or his brother. That's at least 6 ahead of him.
“Very disrespectful Stephen A.” Suppose you would know Molly...
SuntanSuperman8 I hate her but she has a point
Truth hurt......
@@jaketalbot1863 why do you hate her.
Molly makes me mad 😂 she don’t be saying sht valuable 😭‼️
She’s all look
4:46 lol
Facts💯💯
Other sports HOF's are significantly easier to get into. Look at the list of NFL players in line waiting to get in the NFL HOF
David Rodriguez baseball might be the hardest
Dude, football has way more players than other sports.....
@@carlosm.6348 Yea I might've gassed it after thinking about it. Other sports definitely are crazy tough as well. But if you looked at the line of NFL guys waiting to get in, its a lot of players you'd expect were already hall of famers.
@@ethancollins5884 yea I wonder why a sport that has a 53 man roster with 32 teams has more hall of famers than a sport like basketball that has 15 man roster and 30 teams. And, baseball has more hall of famers.
Idgaf This HOF is Bs !!! When is my boy tom flores going in!!??
Ask 70’s All-Decade, Dallas Cowboys Wide Receiver, Drew Pearson if it is easy to get into the Hall of Fame. 🤷🏿♂️
Flores??? Plunkett???? Branch??? SMDH!!!!!
IamofIAM144 You mean 1970s
PUT DREW IN 💯
TheLuscious Thank you for the correction! 💯
After being only one of three quarterbacks elected to the all Decade Team, Ken Stabler had to wait his whole life and then die, to get in.
If Eli’s last name wasn’t Manning, he wouldn’t even be in the discussion for HOF; there I said it.
was looking for this comment. THANK YOU!
Clipper and the rest of his career he was average to below average
@Clipper Only 4 pro bowls, never been a top 5 qb. He is NOT a hof.
Clipper it’s scrubs who’ve won Super Bowls and mvps like Flacco had he won one more he would be hof?
Clipper u don’t need a super bow to be a hof dan marrio didn’t win but he is a hof
Depending on the season, Eli was good, to average, to below average, through out his 16 seasons. He has two SB rings, because he had a great defense, excellent running game, and a great coach. In all honesty Phil Simms was better in his era than Eli was. And Phil Simms has 2 SB wins as well... and Phil Simms is not in the Hall of Fame.
Facts, and true about Simms.
I can't believe Stephen A. had the guts to say all that when Eli was there the whole time 1:29
Lol
😂😂😂
I never watched football and thought Eli was an elite QB. He was okay 🤷🏾♂️
Sgt R Right
Facts
Nah he was hella mid.
I don’t mind molly but in this video she reminds me a Vicky guerrero
EXCUSE ME!!!
Lol
Omg that’s the perfect comparison
Dead!! ☠️☠️
Molly was just elected to WWE HOF
This show should win an award for it's comedy. I was dying the whole segment.
Molly “Always Doing The Most “ Querim
annoying AF
Ima start a petition to get her out of first take🤣
Yessir
@@pat72396 too late theres like 100 out there lol
@@crazyace88 where they at?! I need to sign all dem🤣🤣
And once Eli gets in, Deion’s point will be made even stronger
Too late to make the point NOW...HOF been letting "Not so great" guys in since the 1970s.
@@ellannamcdonald9986 I agree Terry Bradshaw wasnt a hall of Famer
John Doe you cant tell a guy who led a team to 4 SBs that he shouldn’t be in the HOF
@@mikeldenslow2368 bro go watch him play then get back to me. He had great receivers. Majority of that Steelers squad made the hall of fame
John Doe your point?
“Molly rolls up sleeves” 🤣🤣🤣 she always out of pocket
Positive Momentum HAHAHAHH yess so true
Shut up molly
In the 99 years of professional football there have been 23,204 players. Of those, 326 have made it into the pro hall of fame. That is an admittance rate of 1.4%.
The NFL HOF is definitely not too easy to get into.
Yea but it’s trending towards where good players can get in not just ALL TIME GREATS Brady brees Rodgers Peyton Montana Marino Elway these are all time greats they’re game changers Eli is not an all time great nor a game changer
Thank you sir..For truth and common sense.
4:48 i was eating and then i laughed and almost died. Thanks
William Sohn Same
When she gets like that I can’t even stand to watch 🤦♂️
Like molly duh we obviously know and have acknowledged those during the debate lmao
Jalen gave molly some confidence I see!
Stephen A’s has been going to the same hair clinic LeBron has been going to I see 😂😂. Good to see though 👏🏿
@benjamin I think they use flex seal.
At least Stephen A doesn't have a silly rag over his head
You new age fruit loops running around jockin other dudes hairlines.💀💀
Fkn beta males.
Eli Manning is not a HOFer
Max and Molly gotta chill out
Me when Molly talks: 😤🤬
👎👎
When you hear a players name you know instantly if they are HOF worthy. If you have to think about it, they aren't HOF material.
S T when i hear Eli Manning i think pro football Hall of Famer Eli was apart of the QB draft class of 04 1st overall pick which included Steelers Big Ben
Chargers Philips Rivers
Packers Aaron Rodgers
Giants Eli Manning
All future Hall of Famers
El Hombre Negro Aaron Rodgers was not in that class
Just to let you know
Edward Raymond He sure wasn't he was in 2005 draft the rest where and Eli Manning kepted up with these future Hall of Famers QBs, Eli has 2 bowl titles, Big Ben has 2, Rodgers has 1, Rivers has none
El Hombre Negro yea but they are all better than him... even Rivers
4:48 molly really got into this mans face and screamed wow get her out of hete
it got personal 😂
The Molly hate is really pathetic.
@@darnell16player She doesn't need you white knighting for her. She won't give you any play.
@@subzero-ws7wt It's more of the principle that people always attack her.
@@subzero-ws7wt she doesn't need the constant childish attacking either....but here we are.
Lol I love how they basically just ignore molly
Eli Manning is 1 inch from David Tyree dropping the luckiest catch in the history of football and having 1 Super Bowl title and not even being in the conversation. Let's be real.
Non argument sports don’t work that way. He caught the ball And they won..
Catch wasnt lucky tho
@@dbreiden83080 that play is why he got mvp...cause someone on the Defense definitely deserved it over him.
@@Mercenary-1914
Because catching a ball off the crown of your helmet while falling backwards is a routine catch. Every week throughout the NFL, right ? Can you hear yourself ? Stop it.😂🤣😂
@@thetrib1 Well when it's your NFL, you can decide who gets the MVP. Obviously someone disagreed with you.
*MOLLY IS SO CRINGE!* OMG
Do you think she's aware of this?
Robert French I think she knows, but women in this society don’t have to care.
What’s sad is the network can’t get rid of her cause you know the snowflakes will be up in arms
She knows, but she has a job to do...
Tackleqb dude, you’re the snowflake lol
That was cringy af
How dare you be disrespectful by having a different opinion.....that is right IMO.
She's just kidding around as a fan
9-14 152 yards 2 tds in the fourth quarter against the Undefeated Patriots. The defense did great that game but we can’t forget this
2:30 Molly Swear This Battle Rap like somebody just said a Fire bar 😂😂😂
LMFAOO
@@cheerioss-9121 LIGHT BARS 🔥🔥😂😂
Stephen A got this one.
I love Molly but she legit sounded HURT in this conversation.
Ecks Hail You can never have a debate with a woman they move off of emotion not logic. Molly is no different
not many love molly unless u r speaking pills
The only people cheering Molly are giant fans. He’s a giants HOF, but not an NFL HOFer. He may have started a lot of years, but he certainly lost a lot of them. He really only started towards the end of the year because of nostalgia.
it took 6 straight loosing seasons . to put Eli at .500. if he retired in 2014 he would be a hof
welp buddy “if”
@@welpbuddy4417 No he wouldn’t, still was never top 5 in the league, still never all pro or MVP.
If Eli Manning is a Hall of famer then Julian Edelman is a Hall of famer 3 super bowl championships and 1 MVP Second behind Jerry Rice in receiving yards in the playoffs.
Molly “Who got them there?”
That shity division got them there. 🤦🏽♂️😂
Lmaooo
Who won it
They was literally like 10-6 they barely got in the playoffs
@@DMT_Zel don't worry about the journey what was the destination
@@DMT_Zel yet they still beat the 13-3 Cowboys with TO, Jason Whitten & Tony Romo, then beat the Green Bay Packers, followed by the 16-0 Patriots with Brady, Randy Moss, Wes Welker
I'm a Giant's fan and I must admit that Eli is definitely a Hall of Very Good player, with a few all time great moments
Thank You for being rational.
Only thing your admitting is your delusional 😂
sick of hearing qbs get all the love for winning sbs when so many other positions play a part. i never once watched eli manning, and said that dude right there is elite. maybe a homelessmans peyton manning but never elite.
FrahRF 😅
The people cheering molly should be ashamed of themselves
😂🤣😂
😂😂
SAS is so real
Much respect
Good thing it’s the Hall of “Fame” and not the Hall of “Good Players”
Sorely underrated comment
then why is Deion's pal Troy Aikman in the HOF? He wasnt even top 2 QB for any year
Hall of "Longevity"
Well, Eli Manning is famous and so was Aikman. So if you go by the literal definition, they do deserve to be in!
jeffx40 No doubt Eli Manning is going to be enshrined in Canton, OH he kepted up with one of the greatest QB draft class in NFL history the 2004 draft
Giants Eli Manning Ole Miss
Chargers Phillips Rivers NC
Packers Aaron Rodgers Cal
Steelers Big Ben Miami, OH
All of these guys are Hall of Famers
Aa
Max Kellerman just wants to give out participation trophies lol
That’s what you doing lol 😂 they got him on that one
Participation trophies for winning Super Bowls...
@@Jjbarrea124 being in the HOF is a career award bro. He has never played at an elite level and both those Superbowls his offense scored less then 21 points.
HyD3PH THA REAL I’m not arguing he should be there. But Participation you get for showing up. He did a little bit more than just show up. Whether you think he deserved the super bowls or not. He won them.
@@Jjbarrea124 yeah and so did the other 53 players winning the Superbowl is a team accomplishment especially win he arguably had one of the best defenses in the league. Not taking away from that just putting it more into perspective.
If Eli Manning makes it into the HOF, Steve McNair should be in the HOF.
Facts former MVP
Big facts
@eoe123321 MVP of the league was they best player in the NFL for at least 3 seasons
..racist Jeff Fisher held him back
With what achievements?
@eoe123321, actually he was considered a top QB in the league from 2000 until about 2000 - 2003. Then injuries derailed his career from there. Regardless of Fisher holding McNair back as a QB or not, McNair was always considered a warrior in the NFL and he led his team to playoff success, his defense didn't have to carry majority of the load. Not to mention, McNair won the regular season MVP trophy and he was the MVP for his team the year they went to the Super Bowl.
With all of that said, I'm with SAS and Deion on this discussion. I don't think Eli should be a HOF'er because he won two Super Bowls and won MVP's for those games when anyone on his defensive unit should have won those awards. If Eli gets in, the bar is being lowered by the NFL on who is allowed into the HOF and you are opening the gates from guys like Nick Foles and Joe Flacco to get into the HOF, two guys that shouldn't even sniff the HOF.
I totally agree. Especially with the Eli talk.