The Great Divide: Sunni vs. Shi'a - Full Episode
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ต.ค. 2024
- From the conflicts in Iraq and Syria to the tension between Iran and Saudi Arabia, the struggle between Sunni and Shi‘a groups for hegemony is tearing apart the region and shows no signs of abating. But for all the religious discourse permeating the conflict, much of its roots are political, not religious.
How does sectarianism fit into a larger narrative of the Middle East? How have governments manipulated sectarian differences? And finally, what is the U.S. doing about it?
Full episode from the Great Decisions PBS series:
www.greatdecisi...
Visit our website for more information: www.fpa.org/
Narrated by Academy Award nominated actor David Strathairn and produced by the Foreign Policy Association, each half-hour episode of the Great Decisions documentary series tackles a different challenge facing America today.
This episode first aired in January 2015.
Executive Producer: MacDara King
Lead Editor: David Heidelberger
info@fpa.org
Very illustrative. Thank you for sharing.
That one guy sums it up perfectly. " We went to kill some monsters, we found some, but created a lot more, and now there following us home. That wasn't smart." The exact reason I was a democrat until Obamas colossal letdown but the entire Iraq situation has been a never-ending nightmare.
I am not an American, but the decision to invade Iraq by Bush was a wrong one.
You didn’t find anything ? You didn’t find guns or nukes you found a president that ran a country perfectly fine for over 20 years and even had the currency worth more than the dollar at one point ? Lol do more research buddy you wanted our money and oil
@@TinestManager6 yeah thats my point bro. It was all a lie and I agree that we should have left well enough alone cause all we did was destabilize a region. I'm old enough to have protested against the war in Iraq. And happily even my republican family members now admit it was a horrible idea.
Literally what Israel is doing rn
...... If you voted any Democrat since Carter?.... You got exactly what you voted for. Carter gave away Iran, Obama/Biden gave away Afghanistan. Democrats have always been sold on terrorism. They see them as cheap votes. That's how you have POS, Omar, Thlieb, Pressley & the rest of the "squad"....No such Islamic terrorist-supporters in the Republican party.
I am in a German language class with 22 others 14 of whom are Syrians, half are women and 4 of them are Christian, they had no problems in Syria, all the Syrians would go back if there was peace they miss their country. One of them a 24 year old young man was severely injured by a barrel bomb in Aleppo and ended up permanently in a wheelchair. I have seen photos of his injuries they made me physically sick and also made me cry. He is a real comedian and always smiling I call him my little brother,. He still faces many more operations. They are all desperate to pass the exam today so they can get jobs. They want to work and pay their way. They don't care about who is Sunni or Shiite or Christian they just want to get on with their lives.
Wow. Send pictures of that man in a wheelchair please!
@KUNG FU WARRIOR-KING Would need plenty of explanation! In 1 sentence it would delight me
@KUNG FU WARRIOR-KING no why would you think that.
"Securing their interest in the area"
Yep....code for Imperialism.
I thought that it was a good video that tells differences, but video is all about political. Anyways, i believe that 99% of muslims have been blaming Israel, America and some Western countries about creating conflict between muslims. They haven't done anything, but they used this conflict to creat chaos between muslims. Islam had already been divided while prophet Mohamed was sick. Some Arab tribes claimed that their chief must have been the new prophet, some tribes left Islamic ideas etc. Somehow, 4 khalifas stabilized the order, but when Moaviye killed Hasan who was grandson of Mohamed, started conflict between muslim. King Moviye converted Islam to his advantage. He made up hundreds of hadises. Followers of Ali refused them. Since then, there's no peace in the Middle East. CIA,MOSSAD didn't start the war
Vidmar Simic the problem didn't start when the Prophet was alive. It started a few years after the Prophet death when Muslims were bring fooled by hypocrites
Muaaviya didn't kill Hassan (atleast that's what i was taught).yaseed , son of him, did.
@@shahsadsaadu5817 is that Hussein RA
i am muslim, We never like blood and gore.
This statement of yours is due to the psychological warfare of your politicians. The President of France insulted the Prophet of Islam, peace be upon him and his family, and we opposed it. We Muslims consider Jesus Christ as the helper of Mahdi and we love him and we are happy with Christians at Christmas. We consider the Prophet Moses (pbuh) as the great prophet of God and we teach the story of this divine prophet to our children and adolescents. Be sure to read Ayatollah Khamenei's letter to the youth of the West, which shows the true face of Islam.
“Died without leaving an heir” says who?! His cousin and brethren in faith and the first embracer and supporter of his message, Imam Ali, is his heir not by blood as the Sunnis try to misguide the world into. Prophet Mohammad said “The disciples following me are twelve, they will not be hurt by people’s desertion” الائمة من بعدي اثناعشر لا يضرهم خذلان من خذلهم
Lol Islam isn't an Empire of something to leave a heir.
And Believers are equal in Islam and Rashidun Caliphs are mentioned in Qur'an but I know debating is useless. Allah knows best.
@@warwarrior929 Rashidun Caliphs helped dictate writing of the Qur'an so imagine the possibilties there bro
I am sunni, i pray,eat,play nd study with shias we are Muslims nd Islam unite every Muslim on a single platform on a single flag as prophet said Religion makes the nation not pieces of lands so Muslim is nation of diffrent peoples united by Islam , the word shia nd sunni is not in the quran then why peoples are divided the, Yazidiat was vanished thousands years ago but the fitna is still alived Yaizid nd his fellows was already died but the fitna "who is shia who is sunni " is still alived dividing peoples no scholar of islam said that shia is kafir or sunni is kaffir but if anyone says he itself is a kaffir nd a yazidi
اهلا بک صدقت اخی
Catholics and protestants learned to stop fighting.
Why are you giving fitwa here did not hussain was betrayed by kufaa people kufaa was shia people shia betrayed husain
Where can i find a balanced non sided video?
whats Balanced ? I think this is reflective I am a sunni but since our number are much greater we have more bad groups and the actions of some of our leaders are extremely oppressive to minoraties.... Generally speaking
make one yourself because you aint gonna find it on the internet
Listen to the beautiful lectures by Dr Syed Ammar Nakshwani on utube.
Nil
The US of A should stay out of it.
wayneyd2
absolutely
Lol the us of a
Exactly!😡
kill each other and blame us and Israel
lufftwaffapilot1939 gorring United States (of) America
This fight has been going on so long for all of written history I don’t think it ever “sorts itself out “.
That dude's voice is great.
Bahrain’s leading cleric Sheikh Isa Qassim says there exists no divide between Shia and Sunni Muslims, but the Islamic world is in fact split into a camp that champions normalization with the Tel Aviv regime and one that adheres to the cause of resistance against Israel and the United States.
The Qur'an says: وَلَا تَبْخَسُوا النَّاسَ أَشْيَاءَهُمْ وَلَا تَعْثَوْا فِي الْأَرْضِ مُفْسِدِينَ: And do not neglect the rights of the people and do not corrupt the land "
The comprehensive and general principle is that whether in the national and local context, ie within the Islamic realm, in the regional realm, ie within the realm of monotheism with the People of the Book and the atheists, or in the international realm with human society, whether infidels, pagans or non-idolaters. In all three sections he said: " And do not neglect the rights of the people and do not corrupt the land ".This is also one of the comprehensive principles
jazakallah kheyra and goodluck🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷
JAWADI.Amoli ------ take from Ar rahman 5
my father is sunni and my mother is shiaa
Belinda Babette you are wrong.
So sushi?
@ 2:39 did you hear what he said: Now Israel (the Palestinian territory ).. Now they admit Israel is Palestinian territory
No , read a bible ! God has his map !
Lisa Morgan lmaooo what does god have to say about modern Europe and Central Asia? Nothing. If he was an almighty, all knowing god, he’d have anticipated modern society and directed us on it.
daniel douglas just stfu stop dissing god he has his own plan for us worshipers
Everyone knows it was British Mandated Palestine. All religions should be allowed to live peacefully in Israel though. Whats done is done. There would be more bloodshed if you try to force non-Muslims out.
They do that all the time
"Shia and Sunni lived better togeher as protestants amd catholics in Europe until very recently" Very recently as to "recently" as before the existence of the United States , or to which conflict is this referring from before the 18th century?
+Alta Luz Northern Ireland
Alta Luz i think they were referring various regions in Europe such as the Balkan and Northern Ireland.
Look up the protestant revolutions after Martin Luthers death.
Shia❤️
@You Mom is Green Black Muslim 🤣
@@guccianddodul Alhamdulillah Black color is favorite color of God
Go back to your native religion good man! Your forefathers were nature worshippers!
@@guccianddodul Plz explain
Alhamdullah I'm shia
If Mohammed was 'last' prophet...why these knuckleheads arguing over a successor!!???
After the prophet S.A.W died we needed one in control
Haider Hussain no allah decides prophets not people
@OP_ KC7186 please read yanabee mawadda volume 3 page 399 Bukhari
@OP_ KC7186 I'm Muslim it's haram to call yourself sunni Or shia
Just like christianity has someone to lead them, we wanted someone to lead us as well
We are brothers, we are not divided.
🤣🤣🤣
This documentary is much more truthful and unbiased than any other Islamic documentaries where one side attacks the other calling them conspirators and kafir.
At 1:40 it is said, "who should wield authority after the prophets death?" I might be an atheist but if I were a Muslim & asked that question, I would say God. I find it strange that its the cause for so much hate & violence between the two groups. As far as I know, neither Christianity nor Judaism bear a supreme leader of the religion. The Pope is the closest thing to one for Christianity but, in reality, he's only responsible for Catholicism. I was baptized a Methodist but there's no way in hell I could've ever see myself killing Lutherans for reasons similar to why the Sunni & Shi'a are.
Well you're right and wrong here and I'll elaborate why. Shi'a theology stands on that a fallible cannot make laws on behalf of God or execute judicial laws without an authority from God: as such, the shi'a theology is based on pledging allegiance to those thought to be and believed to be infallible from the bloodline of the prophet, the 12 leaders that descend from Mohamed's bloodline through his only daughter Fatima and through his son in law and first successor Ali.
The sunnis follow and pledge their respect to the selection process that Mohamed's companions underwent in a state when the nation was busy with burials of the prophet and therefore the selection process was done in the dark and secretly among a selected few that took upon themselves to decide the fate of the faith. They hold the view that neither God or his prophet thought about who is to lead the nation after the prophet passes away. A view vehemently rejected by the shi'as and consider the actions of the so-called companions as nothing less than treason. Why does this matter and what are the implications for that today?
Shi'as historically and until today followed a system that extracted the foundations, legislations, and jurisprudence of the faith from the 12 successors despite the sunni majority taking power forcefully, and this the shi'as regardless of the power seize by the sunnis, kept to their instructions of following only the infallibles. Whereas, sunnis followed the faith of the King (khalifa), and the khalifa appointed students of faith who decided what is right or wrong and this created endless new creeds being born, some of which later on gave rise to the theology that some brands such as Al-qaeda and ISIS follow.
You see historical aspects can make a huge difference on out times.
History mentions that the ruling khalifs who enjoyed the support of the majority of the populace, whether by means of the sword or the word, fell into conflict with the infallible shi'as leaders because they represented a direct threat to their rulership and governance as they enjoyed the support and devotion of a large sector of a population in the heart of the early Islamic lands... and this lead to persecution of shi'as and shi'a imams throughout the times pushing both sides further away from each other in addition to the pre-existing differences that make them almost completely different faiths to one another.
Shi'as today are facing mass murders and genocide almost everywhere they are in because some extreme elements or more accurately, more literalist fundamentalist sunnis adopt the view that killing shi'as is an Islamic duty since they are a group that left the ranks of the majority and some of their religious practices falls in their categories of people who became kaffir such as the concept of intercessions or visiting the shrines of their imams.
It's a topic that I can talk about in length but I'd rather not because writing thousands of words would probably tire both of us.
ISIS BECAME ISIS DUE TO IRAQI GOVERNMENTS BACKING ON THE PROMISES THEY MADE TO SUNNIS WHICH WERE SHIITES AND YOU ARE SAYING THIS.
THIS IS SHIITES FAULT.
NO THIS IS ALTOGETHER AMERICAS FAULT.
The American Government gave the weapons to terrorists to encounter russia which was invading afghanistan it is americas fault
NO SUNNI NO SHIA.. ONLY MUSLIM.. PROUD TO BE A MUSLIM.. FROM PAKISTAN
Sunni is real Islam. 90% of Muslim are Sunni. The name Sunni was given to original Muslims who follow Quran and "SUNNAH". Shia, Ahmadiyyah, Mahdavi, Bahai's, etc all deviated from the truth and changed things
Taimoor Abdullah agreed
Nihaar Warrior you can’t say Sunni is true Islam since there was no such this as Shia or Sunni from the beginning plus just because there are more Sunnis than Shia doesn’t mean that it is necessarily correct, for example you can’t say Christianity is the correct religion because there are more Christians in the world, you shouldn’t listen to the comment section because each person has their own opinion about religion so to truly learn about a sect or religion you must truly do your research independently so you can choose what you can become
My vote is for Shia. From my experience with them, they are a lot more liberal, loving and rational people compared to Sunnis
It's like the divide between Catholics And Protestants
Sort of. Except for the bloodshed.
They don't want to live, nor do they want you to live
Prophet of Islam left a successor after his last Hajj. But Sunnis did not follow prophet's order and form a shura didn't even attend funeral of Prophet. The one prophet appointed Ali Ibn Abi Talib was busy in burying prophet Muhammad. Shura took advantage of this and appointed Abu Bakar as a caliph. Imam Ali kept quite and did not ask for his right to save Ummah. Followers of Imam Ali and companions of Prophet Muhammed were killed by these self imposed caliphs. Thus the people who listen to prophet's advise start following Imam Ali and rest were prosecuted by caliphs or exiled. But the followers of Prophet and Imam Ali stayed on sunnah of Prophet.
Things became so complicated that Islam was slaughtered but not by Imam Ali because he never rise for his right.
So this is where we're today.
Syed, first of all Ali Ibn Abi Talib (RA) was not opposed to being the 4th Caliph. Shi'ism was founded by Yemeni Jew named Abdullah Ibn Saba who made his own sect and Shia deviated from real Islam and changed many of beliefs. Today 90% of Muslims are Sunni and around 10% are Shia.
Nihaar2121Dharmicwarrior
Hi the majority is not a reason of truthness of them
How much minor crowd defeated the great corwd!!???
NO, Imam Ali (as) did not stay quiet, but he did avoid violence and uprising and war due to lack of support from Muslims.
Nihaar2121Dharmicwarrior sorry meant for that shia rafidi
Syed Sarim read me message you pig
Well my opinion is Sunnis must accept the honour of Ali,Fatimah, Hasan wa Hussain wa Hussain Alaihimussalam n shia must accept that the greatest after Rasoolallah imam Ali Alaissalaam accepted n gave respect to sahabas ....don't accept those sahabas whom.imam.ali didn't accept
shut up
Hey, Mohammed. I think I know your brother. Suq Madiq. And your uncle; Liqa Madiq. Oh your aunt, who kept her maiden name Munchma Quchi.
@@dicktrickle7450 lmaooo
Sunni always respect them...but it's stupid nonsense shia who are illiterate emotion fools don't know abc of islam bark like dogs on sahaba...Allah Praised the Sahaba ansar and muhajireen...Allah says "radiallahu anhu wa radu anh"..ALAAH will be pleased with them, and they with Him.
That is for him who fears his Lord"
[Surah Al-Bayyina, Ayat 8 (Surah 98: Verse 8, Qur'an)] ....The first three Caliphs are also from muhajireen sahaba who migrated with prophet saw and they are praised by Allah and Allah is pleased with them...!
There is only one God and prophet Muhammad is the last messenger... i dont believe in all these divisions..
Akram Mikrani the problem is the majority of moslems are not like you.
who cares your prophet ?? only garbage like you
And guess what i dont belief prophet muhammad😂😂😂
This statement of yours is due to the psychological warfare of your politicians. The President of France insulted the Prophet of Islam, peace be upon him and his family, and we opposed it. We, the Muslims, consider Jesus Christ (peace be upon him) as the helper of Hazrat Mahdi (as) and we love him and we are happy with the Christians in Christmas. We consider Hazrat Nosiyyah as the great prophet of God and we teach the story of this divine prophet to our children and adolescents. Be sure to see Ayatollah Khamenei's letter to the youth of the West, which shows the true face of Islam.
Shias are the peaceful people and they love humanity also.
Just 5 years later, the US turned into a banana republic. 😂
Genesis 16 "The angel of the LORD said to her further, “Behold, you are with child And shall bear a son; You shall call him Ishmael, For the LORD has paid heed to your suffering.
He shall be a wild man; His hand against everyone, And everyone’s hand against him; He shall dwell alongside of all his kinsmen.” Ishmael's descendants are just like him fighting with everyone and amongst themselves.
This statement of yours is due to the psychological warfare of your politicians. The President of France insulted the Prophet of Islam, peace be upon him and his family, and we opposed it. We Muslims consider Jesus Christ as the helper of Mahdi and we love him and we are happy with Christians at Christmas. We consider the Prophet Moses (pbuh) as the great prophet of God and we teach the story of this divine prophet to our children and adolescents. Be sure to read Ayatollah Khamenei's letter to the youth of the West, which shows the true face of Islam.
THIS VIDEO IS DATED 2016…. ITS 2024… THE VIOLENCE HAS NOT CHANGED… 😢😮🫣👎👎👎
THEN AGAIN WHEN HAS THIS REGION EVER BEEN AT PEACE…
Quick updates in 2024, Lebanon is no longer majority Shia, and Iraq is slowly becoming majority Sunni, soon Iran and Azerbaijan will be the only Shia majority countries.
In order to fix something, we must understand why it is broken. This issue is so deeply complex I don't know where to start.
Evin Grost Both sides have similarities in common and Sunnis and Shias should understand each other's sides to live in harmony, not annilihation through historical revenge.
Did you ask yourself; why they had been living in peace for more than 1400 years and suddenly turned in blood shed and violence since the American invasion of Iraq? do you think Sunni and Shia just formed yesterday? as they say in the USA ( god bless your heart)
So basically Sunni = Protestant and Shia = Catholic
Big Ronnie well yeah technically
This statement of yours is due to the psychological warfare of your politicians. The President of France insulted the Prophet of Islam, peace be upon him and his family, and we opposed it. We Muslims consider Jesus Christ as the helper of Mahdi and we love him and we are happy with Christians at Christmas. We consider the Prophet Moses (pbuh) as the great prophet of God and we teach the story of this divine prophet to our children and adolescents. Be sure to read Ayatollah Khamenei's letter to the youth of the West, which shows the true face of Islam.
The life of Rasoolallah and Ali,Fatimah,Hasan wa Hussain Alaihimussalam is the solution of all the problems of earth...sad we Muslims couldn't solve our own problems inspire if having such greatest personalities
Imposing your beliefs on other is the reason of all violence.
Then people will start marrying children keep sex slaves complete breakdown of society.
Why do we enforce democracy, like democracy is going to end all problems
Ayo can anyone gimme a summary of dis I gotta do this for world civ I gotchu with a PayPal
During the Ottoman perion of the mid. east the ottomans support the sunni land lords and these sunni land lords became more powerful and more loyal to the Sultan.ottomand did that to limit the effects of İran at that time.In fact today the scenario is almost same
so what ottomans were also sunni themselves and 90% majority is sunni muslims in 1.7 billion population so they could have and 55 countries and you dont misunderstand us as Catholic and protestant difference we had no such difference in teaching but only in history and politcially..
No mentioning Ottoman Safavid war makes.this documentary useless...
Lion King why ?
There is NO Sunni or Shia in Islam
Shia is not Islam, they are not following Abu Bakar and the rest, while sunny follow Ali and the rest of the prophet companion.
ahlul bait is the sahaba. Like Ali, Abu Bakar, umar and Usman. Is not just Ali.
I can read a little Arabic. There is no Wahabis . Wahabis words are fitnah mentioned by people who hate Sunnah and the prophet companion.
If you love ahlu bait why you hate Abu bakar, Umar and Usman, Aisha . Muslim love all of the prophet companion including Ali and Aisya. They are the chosen people that are guided people.
Wali Allah also referrer to all four khulafu rasyidin (the guided leader which are , Abu bakar, Umar, Utsman and Ali. ) . And alos battle of jamal, did the Muawiyah Kill Ali Radiallhu anhu???. NO. Did Ali Kill the shia , Yes personaly ALI Radiallahuanhu kill most of the shia .
The Shia Iraq Cadet Massacre would bring a tear to your eye.
shia and sunni are brothers
Shia not Muslim
is kilr 2 mlion and
Sarah R S N first of all,learn how to spell and sunnis are the ones who started isis
II HOLD LZZ II if Sunnis have ISIS,Shias have Hezbollah.
amrican and uk who made isis
I got about 4 minutes into the video and felt compelled to stop watching due to the inaccuracies and insincerity of the reporting.
Sulaiman Abdul Aziz
The lies you can hear, can help you understand the agenda their pushing.
Sulaiman Abdul Aziz you would have continued watching it if the idolize Pedophile Muhammad
Some people just cant handle the truth
Yess
Great Warrior he is sadly in hell
This conflict is one that cannot finish, because it can't be resolved. It's a history dilemma, that stems from ancient time's and its about control and power also greed. Has the question ever been put to the two leaders of sunny and shia reglion. If both sides want peace forever they have to the step into brave man's land and answer the awkward questions honestly. A simple question to each leader , the question, what does each want from the other.
Why is the English writing "The Great Divide: Sunni vs Shia" is made to look like Hindi?? Why not make it look like Russian or Chinese? Ignorance is a bliss, isn't it?
I've seen it in a couple different documentaries actually.
i believe you Jacob. ignorance has a way to infecting other simpletons...
Maybe the skin color is far different then Russian or Chinese
Iraqi writer Ali Al Wardi (علي الوردي) writes:
Sectarianism is not a religion, rather it is a kind of tribal affiliation to a certain sect or person, and when a sectarian individual becomes fanatic for his sect, he does not care about the moral or spiritual principles in the sect. For his group and hostility to others, in other words, he looks at his sect as the Bedouin looks at his tribe"
background music quite annoying... a pity...
Can someone help for an assignment: What caused the Christian/Muslim ratio to flip in 2011
Palestinians and Syrian refugees in Lebanon. Israel will of course not allow Palestinians back and Syrians won't go unless Assad is toppled so basically Lebanon is stuck with over a million mostly Sunni refugees.
Woop woop, I'm finally, after all these years - first.
"The U.S wasn't happy that it was quiet."
There you have it is a family feud. We'll make friend to the winner.
Prophet Mohammad said after he died my successor is Imam Ali man kunto moula fahaza Ali un moula
Shia & Sunni in China = No Problem
Shia & Sunni in Egypt = No Problem
Shia & Sunni in Oman = No Problem
Shia & Sunni in Russia = No Problem
Shia & Sunni in Balkan = No Problem
Shia & Sunni in Algeria = No Problem
Shia & Sunni in Lebanon = No Problem
Shia & Sunni in Malaysia = No Problem
Shia & Sunni in Pakistan = No Problem
Shia & Sunni in Morocco = No Problem
Shia & Sunni in Indonesia = No Problem
Shia & Sunni in West Africa= No Problem
Shia & Sunni in Central Asia = No Problem
Shia & Sunni in Afghanistan = No Problem
Shia & Sunni in Kurdistan Region = No Problem
Shia & Sunni in Europe & North America = No Problem
and so on...
But because Shia & Sunni are fighting eachother in Iraq, Syria and Yemen. Everyone things they are fighting since 1400 years but overall there was 1200 years of Peace and now in Iraq Shias & Sunnis fight together against ISIS. The Problem is the Wahhabi Lobby of Saudi Arabia and Iran.
SanyarKurdBiker I'm assuming you've never lived in england lol the sunni hate the shia here
Bro stop blaming Saudi state all the time. Iranian Shia Regime and Iraqi Shia Government along with Syrian Alawi Shia Government has been systematically arresting, detaining, persecuting, and killing Sunnis in the region. Thats why we have conflict right now
The Ottoman Empire and the Safavid had many battles.
Those who said this divide already existed........
Tell us how many Holy Sites in Iraq or Afghanistan or Pakistan were stuck by suicide bombings before US invasion of Iraq or Afghanistan?????
Wait... is that an American uniform? 4:15
Blaming sectarianism on colonialism is ridiculous, everything isn’t the west’s fault, to claim that sectarian differences only mattered post WW1 is false.
I love the comments on here that claim there were no wars btwn sunni and shia until the west was involved. The west was involved very very early... I have read about the sunni extermination if shia as far back as the 1300's so clearly it wasnt all kisses and cuddles.
though this video is a load of rubbish....
@1:33 you lying, the companion of the prophet never fought each other over heir….They were the best people ever existed in terms of moral grounds and justice for all
So why were there 3 civil wars in 4 years fought against Imam Ali (as). A lot of 'sahaba' hated him.
@@LR78627 کسانیکه از ایشون اهل باطل بودند.امام علی بهترین بنده خدا بعد از پیامبر اسلام هستند.
فتح خیبر توسط امام علی رخ داد
2: 154. *you don’t say about the one who is killed in the way of Lord Allah as: “They are dead!”; nay, they are living even though you perceive it not.*
The battle of Bad’r was taken place to realize whether the Truth is with the believers or disbelievers as told in verses 8: 19 and 41. The battle of Uhud was taken place to identify the hypocrites and the believers among the Messenger’s followers as told in verses 3: 166-167. This verse is revealed as a reply to the sayings of hypocrites about the martyrs: “If they had obeyed us and had kept away from the battle, they would not have been killed”. The aimless hypocrites are thinking and propagating that by death, everything is finished. They are knowingly hiding the Criterion and Balance Adhikr with which one can identify the believer and the disbeliever. The hypocrites are those who have the body without the soul as told in verse 9: 55 and 63: 4. They will enter the Fire even without the Trial as told in verse 4: 145.
It is told about martyrs in the way of the Lord in verses 3: 169-170 as: “You shouldn’t reckon those believers who are killed in the way of the Lord as dead. Nay, they are living near their Lord enjoying their sustenance, rejoicing with whatever the Lord has bestowed from His Bounty, and heralding with those left behind who have not yet joined with them that no need to fear upon them and for them will not be grieved”.
Today, as Adhikr is codified as the Best Interpretation of Lord’s Book as told in verse 25: 33, and as there is no group of believers anywhere in the world, there is no Jihad with weapons. The odd believer should do Jihad with Adhikr against the hypocrites and Kuffar testifying verses 9: 73; 25: 52 and 66: 9. Through verse 14: 30 the believer is ordered to say to the Arabic Quran reading Fujjar who reject Adhikr: “You enjoy here a little; indeed, your returning is into the Fire”. The odd believer who holdfasts Adhikr, he did holdfast Lord and is guided into the Straightpath as explained in verse 5: 48. So the odd believer of these days will have more dignity than believers of the Messenger's period. See explanation 2: 3, 9-12, and 94-96.
*From Adhikr-the Best Interpretation of Lord's Book*
www.straightpathonline.com
Pakistan founder muhammad Ali jinah and his family shias Pakistan 45 people's are shias but no liberty 😳😳
Muhammad Ali Jinnah had converted to Sunni Islam later on in his life
So he switched from Shia to Sunni
Zubair Azam can't we live untied?
Is is called "sectarianism"....but is it really a full blown religious schism and war? Both sides consider each other Kafir?
22:56 scary
These Conflicts at their best intentions demonstrate that "Democracy" does NOT Necessarily Bring about effective Governnence! The way forward is surely Spiritual, inasmuch as All cultural, religious, social, economic differences must align to ONE, SINGULAR SPIRITUAL ETHOS?
Religious thinking is single universal reason for all conflicts and violence everywhere.
Nah, this was gonna happen with religion or without. People are cunts, that's the whole of it.
Not religion but any sort of identity leads to conflict, your identity vs my identity
Wars arise very rarely over ideology and much more commonly over resources/land/power
What Azza said. Power. People just use Religion and ideologies to push people into fighting for them.
Like the pope in the crusades, like the Nazis in world war two, like isis today.
Ur an idiot if u think that over money and power
To see all religions live along side each other, just look at Lebanon.
Not mentioned is the fact that the U.S. supplied the chemical weapons used by Saddam Hussein.
اما از او حمایت کرده است بزرگوار
@@hfhovoc2320 Sorry, Arabic is unintelligible to me.
@@davidleahy6141 Hello, how are you? I said Persian. The United States had supported ISIS.
I'm Muslim not important Shia or Sunni.
از طرف یکمسلمان به این درک شما درود می گویم.
You do not speak for God. Whatever will be, will be. Even if your religion, its stories, affect 1 group that might kill us all... hypocrites. Do you not see we concept is the same? We all believe in something. That is the point. We live in different areas, we speak different languages, we preach differently for a reason. Our genes, faces, races, etc. are different for a reason, yet we are all called HUMAN collectively. That is the same for RELIGION. It is all the same, it is about the concept and nothing else. Stop with your idiocracies, please.
Vee Vee hi
Never concider SHIA AND SUNNI are different we r MUSLIMS
Ali zawar dream on. Sunnis hates Shias and Shias hates Sunnis. There is no such thing as Muslims
Great Warrior Shias don’t hate Sunnis Sunnis hate Shias
Who ever claims Arab spring is an act of apostasy
does this channel favour any country or religion because most channels do anđ they dnt show the reality and thus it just gives us half knowelege which is dangerous i guess !
hisory class anyone?
DO PEOPLE NOT SEE HOW RELIGION PUTS SUCH FEAR INTO PEOPLE, WHERE THEY ARE DRIVEN TO DO SUCH DISGUSTING AND CRAZY RADICAL THINGS? YOUR PROPHECY IS FLAWED. The world will end, only through and by you, me, and everyone else. You, and I, and others who sit back and just watch do not nourish, love, peace, and good health as all religions suggest they give. We do not practice what we preach, that is disconcerting.
Vee Vee hi 😍
Clear explanation.
This statement of yours is due to the psychological warfare of your politicians. The President of France insulted the Prophet of Islam, peace be upon him and his family, and we opposed it. We Muslims consider Jesus Christ as the helper of Mahdi and we love him and we are happy with Christians at Christmas. We consider the Prophet Moses (pbuh) as the great prophet of God and we teach the story of this divine prophet to our children and adolescents. Be sure to read Ayatollah Khamenei's letter to the youth of the West, which shows the true face of Islam.
Sadam Hussain killed my mom's dad
And he was sunni
The division created by Britain and France of Arabia also divided the people and by doing so also did injustice to the peoples of the divided/mandated Arabia by favoring one and disfavouring another. When the divided peoples saw this and actually started to absorb this that their neighbours who were equal with them once are now becoming more privileged than the other started to differentiate/discriminate themselves from the other.
At this point,the peoples of the lesser privileged divisions suddenly begat a need to become better because the white people had started to favour/disfavour peoples of the same sect that have had mutuality before the mandation, needed someone worthy to lead them. Thus the peoples started to strategize a course where they appointed their leaders. Thus caused an awareness in the western stance and they started to counter it of which we see results today! A good example is USA support for Iraq against Iran. The same strategy had been used today-Muslims of a favored Arabian nation is set against a unfavoured Arabian nation(s). These are the ones that are of
'Axis Of Evil'.
If this matter is concluded than this ridiculing stand for democracy by the concerned western nations for their personal interests in a foreign country should be clarified in the minds of the peoples whose lives are affected by this!
The stand for democracy is just a faked reason (s) to implement their own idealisms on a peoples nations that they are still trying/starting to understand and have to, yet.
Elliot Abrams? We're listening to Eliot Abrams?
I was enjoying this vid until theat Devilish Abrams came on....paused the vid, wrote this comment and now I'm moving on to another vid...
Toyota and U.S got a finger in every war
So Ottoman Empire was Protecting the Arab Territories
From the start of the video the information are bullshit, Shitte came after the death of Hussein bin Ali not the prophet PBUH and they where regarded as repels at the time (khawaridj) then the 12 Imams story starts, which Sunnis respect all of them from Ali (رضي الله عنه)until the last one because they are the prophet descendants. Long story short:
- It didn’t started after the death of the prophet PBUH, it started later, and took the frame of today because of the Safavids dynasty era and the 1979 Iranian revolution.
-Shiite are the one blaming and reviling prophet wives, companions and every Sunni, even the ones how didn’t fight at that time and the Sunnis of this day!
- “some” Shiite believe in things that not logical and forbidden practices can be explained by just to form an independent identity outside of the surrounding Sunnis, because otherwise if the differences is only on whom to rule not about the afterlife it will be short lived struggle, also because the source of Islamic theology is the prophet’s companions which are the ones that cause all this Calvary (as some Shiite believe) not the stupid need for power and following family blindly, examples like: praying to tombs, infallibility of the Wali and Imams, and that the 12th Imam is still missing but alive!
-Both Sunni and Shiite believe that Jesus PBUH will descend down from heaven to fight along Mahdi in Armageddon
-IT IS PURELY POLITICAL, surly 2003 breaks hell loose.
There are many sects inside Sunni grand-sect and Shiite grand-sect and they differ as if they are different religion all together, think of it as spectrum of sects inside Islam, some CANNOT be considered Muslims even if they claim that and some are tolerable.
It is not about shia-sunni. It is about oppression. Shiites along with sunnis were fighting oppressive leaders,
Islam is more of gaining political power using religion rather than spiritual seeking. Religion can teach morality but it can never teach spirituality. Spiritually is humanity, it does not need religion or even God.
And who created the division ?
Muhammad's death.
@@CedricThePlaystation نه ابوبکر با غصب خلافت علی بن ابیطالب باعث این اتفاق شد و رهبر ایران برای حفظ وحدت مسلمانان گفت :توهین به مقدسات اهل سنت حرام است.
This statement of yours is due to the psychological warfare of your politicians. The President of France insulted the Prophet of Islam, peace be upon him and his family, and we opposed it. We, the Muslims, consider Jesus Christ (peace be upon him) as the helper of Hazrat Mahdi (as) and we love him and we are happy with the Christians in Christmas. We consider Hazrat Nosiyyah as the great prophet of God and we teach the story of this divine prophet to our children and adolescents. Be sure to see Ayatollah Khamenei's letter to the youth of the West, which shows the true face of Islam.
What matters is that bad guys in both camps kill each other and rest ones are rulled by a non Muslim good guys
Where does it say in the Bible Muhammed is the final prophet? Muslims are told to ask the Jews and Christians for truth. I've seen Jesus Christ. I know He's the Son of God.
The Old Testament says Elijah is the final prophet. The New Testament speaks of the spirit of Elijah through John The Baptist.The spirit of Elijah acknowledges and glorifies the Messiah (Jesus Christ).
In the Old Testament (Malachi 4:5-6) Elijah will return in the End Times. And by Jewish law all matters are settled by the testimony of two or three witnesses.
In the New Testament (revelation 11:3) God appoints His Two Witnesses to prophesy for 3 1/2 years. When Elijah walked the earth he stopped the rain from pouring down on Israel for 3 1/2 years, because King Ahab refused to listen to the God of Israel.
If we compile all the information from the Bible, the Two Witnesses will have the spirit of Elijah and Moses. These are the final prophets. Not Muhammed.
Through some of the scripture, we can see that Islam and the Quran are false. This is based off Jewish laws in the Old Testament.
I don't want anyone to perish because of Muhammed's lies. True worship belongs to my Father alone. Muslims worship the wrong God. Jews refuse to recognize and worship the Messiah.
Jesus Christ is the Only Way. He is the only mediator between God and man. He is the Savior of the world. He loves and cares for all people. He will return to judge the earth.
Matthew 17:10-13
10The disciples asked him, “Why then do the teachers of the law say that Elijah must come first?”
11Jesus replied, “To be sure, Elijah comes and will restore all things. 12But I tell you, Elijah has already come, and they did not recognize him, but have done to him everything they wished. In the same way the Son of Man is going to suffer at their hands.” 13Then the disciples understood that he was talking to them about John the Baptist.
John 1:21
They asked him, “Then who are you? Are you Elijah?” He said, “I am not.” “Are you the Prophet?” He answered, “No.”
1 Kings 17:1
Now Elijah the Tishbite, from Tishbe in Gilead, said to Ahab, “As the LORD, the God of Israel, lives, whom I serve, there will be neither dew nor rain in the next few years except at my word.”
James 5:17
Elijah was a human being, even as we are. He prayed earnestly that it would not rain, and it did not rain on the land for three and a half years.
Deuteronomy 19:15
“One witness shall not rise up against a man for any iniquity, or for any sin, in any sin that he sinneth: at the mouth of two witnesses, or at the mouth of three witnesses, shall the matter be established.”
2 Corinthians 13:1
This will be my third visit to you. “Every matter must be established by the testimony of two or three witnesses.”
Revelation 11:3-6
3And I will appoint my two witnesses, and they will prophesy for 1,260 days, clothed in sackcloth.” 4They are “the two olive trees” and the two lampstands, and “they stand before the Lord of the earth.” a 5If anyone tries to harm them, fire comes from their mouths and devours their enemies. This is how anyone who wants to harm them must die. 6They have power to shut up the heavens so that it will not rain during the time they are prophesying; and they have power to turn the waters into blood and to strike the earth with every kind of plague as often as they want.
Malachi 4:5-6
5 Behold, I will send you Elijah the prophet before the coming of the great and dreadful day of the Lord: 6 And he shall turn the heart of the fathers to the children, and the heart of the children to their fathers, lest I come and smite the earth with a curse.
Daniel 7:13-14
"In my vision at night I looked, and there before me was one like a son of man, coming with the clouds of heaven. He approached the Ancient of Days and was led into his presence. He was given authority, glory and sovereign power; all peoples, nations and men of every language worshiped him.
Matthew 1:23
"Behold, the virgin shall be with child, and bear a Son, and they shall call His name Immanuel," which is translated, "God with us."
Matthew 28:18-20
18And Jesus came and spake unto them, saying, All power is given unto me in heaven and in earth. 19Go ye therefore, and teach all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost: 20teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you: and, lo, I am with you alway, even unto the end of the world. Amen.
1John 5:1-5
1 Everyone who believes that Jesus is the Christ is born of God, and everyone who loves the father loves his child as well. 2 This is how we know that we love the children of God: by loving God and carrying out his commands. 3 In fact, this is love for God: to keep his commands. And his commands are not burdensome, 4 for everyone born of God overcomes the world. This is the victory that has overcome the world, even our faith. 5 Who is it that overcomes the world? Only the one who believes that Jesus is the Son of God.
John 5:25-27
25Very truly I tell you, a time is coming and has now come when the dead will hear the voice of the Son of God and those who hear will live. 26For as the Father has life in himself, so he has granted the Son also to have life in himself. 27And he has given him authority to judge because he is the Son of Man.
Matthew 25:31
31 “When the Son of Man comes in his glory and all his angels are with him, he will sit on his glorious throne. 32 The people of every nation will be gathered in front of him. He will separate them as a shepherd separates the sheep from the goats. 33 He will put the sheep on his right but the goats on his left.
Acts 17:31
For he has set a day when he will judge the world with justice by the man he has appointed. He has given proof of this to everyone by raising him from the dead.”
Matthew 16:27
For the Son of Man will come in the glory of His Father with His angels, and then He will reward each according to his works
John 3:16
“For God so loved the world, that he gave his only Son, that whoever believes in him should not perish but have eternal life.
John 20:26-29
26A week later his disciples were in the house again, and Thomas was with them. Though the doors were locked, Jesus came and stood among them and said, “Peace be with you!” 27Then he said to Thomas, “Put your finger here; see my hands. Reach out your hand and put it into my side. Stop doubting and believe.”
28Thomas said to him, “My Lord and my God!”
29Then Jesus told him, “Because you have seen me, you have believed; blessed are those who have not seen and yet have believed.”
Psalm 98:9
let them sing before the LORD, for he comes to judge the earth. He will judge the world in righteousness and the peoples with equity.
Revelation 1:8
8 I am Alpha and Omega, the beginning and the ending, saith the Lord, which is, and which was, and which is to come, the Almighty.
The Importance of Art
Without art, humanity can’t prospure. Art inspires people to be innovative and educates people to choose good.
eyewazear I am an Artist. I agree. Art can do much to benefit society. On many different levels.
Focus on the topic from the start.stop watching on d 3minute
Also makes a lot sense to me now. England/Britain, same thing, cause wars.
France too.
shia Islam true Islam..I hate sudia king..I hate Isis and Wahabi...
Western powers creat problem ,ignite war ,then shedding tears. Seriously you rapped this reigns and muslims for centuries.
Yes you are right they always have some sort of part in things but so does Saudi Arabia. No one mentions them just the West like the West is the big problem. Did the West start the battle of the camel the first civil war between Muslims shia and Sunni? I think not. This division has been going on since the beginning of Islam.
Islam has such a rich & storied history. i hate to see what's happening to many Muslim countries & the people.
@Adrian Wheeler
Hello. Wanna show you the end of it?
tip: just don't miss this opportunity ;)
@@amink6291 Allahu Akbar.
@@adrianwheeler4625
Yes Adrian. God is greater for sure.
For warm up:
ALLAH IN ARAMAIC = ܐܠܗܗ = ALAHH ALLAH IN ARABIC = الله = ALLAH
The only difference between pronouncing these two is that there is no emphasis on L in its Aramaic form.
If Christians google “ܐܠܗܗ” , they will see a bunch of biblical websites. “ܐܠܗܗ” is translated as "GOD".
Psalm 145/3
3-4 Revised T: "Great Yahweh and to be praised greatly, and for His great Allah not a searching".
וְ֝לִגְדֻלָּתֹ֗ו = Great Allah
Now let's start:
יְשׁוּעָֽה = YESHUA = JESUS
Isaiah 12/2 & 3
2-4 Revised T: "Behold, I will trust God (of) my Jesus and not I shall be afraid, for the Lord Yahweh (is) my strength and song, and He was to me (and) to Jesus".
3-4 Revised T: "And ye shall draw water with joy out of the spring (of) the Jesus".
If what are just revealed to you could warm you up, so we can continue.
Ready for the next part? NO !
Mr. Adrian, I think it's better to let the facts stay hidden.
Bye my friend.
AMIN K
A TWELVER SHIA MUSLIM
@@amink6291 thank you so much.
so sorry for using the name Allah out context of the glory of HIS WILL. i pray HE deigns to grant me a single granule of HIS MAJESTY and MEASURE of HIS MUNIFICENT glory.
Democracy is not the answer an Islamic republic is.
Sharia, not democracy will rule. You fought to achieve your democracy, people shall fight to achieve their Sharia.
people wanna live the lifestyle and values of 10th century go ahead without the ideas of west and democracy their would no technolgy medicine etc
@@backstabber3537 history of science says false
@@hassandiallo5326 you’re using internet 😭😂 sharia law didn’t invent that would never have even if the opportunity came imams and religious leaders won’t allow it I can sense your life is guided by religious ideas rather than rational ones
Totally wrong voting Shia people mustly majority
say Prophet PBUH
At 3:58 is Map of the geographical Sunni / Shia division... Iraq and Iran are Shia.
Poor us being puppets of the west, easily moved by sectarian bs.
But truth be told we deserves it, as we blindly follow the word of Islam without understanding what Islam is, fuck sunni/shia bs, Islam is to love, not to hate, that in essence shows how we are flawed in so many ways, that's why we deserve it. We think Islam is only praying, fasting or whatever but we discern the most valuable teachings of Islam, to be good people.
4:20. "I don't know how it's going to sort itself out. "
....ANSWER....
1. let them kill each other off
2. They run out of oil
irish K hi
shia🇮🇷from iran
Sunni Muslim from India
@@travellingwithorfee3600 Shia Muslim from Pakistan 🇵🇰
Muslim should be united and peaceful
@@westgaterealestate7283 I agree with you
Finally a reply section where no one fights over Shia and sunni Alhamduila:)