Teddy Stoyanova you have neatly summed up Mr Cleaver's great skill of simplifying and make everything concise enough to retain and yet sufficiently in depth to delve!
I think it's time they open the 'Marcus Cleaver' no nonsense law school, we would all graduate in 5 months with top grades haha. You are so amazing!!! You have made exam revision bearable and so much easier than the complex way my lectures makes it. Thanks Marcus aka Sheldon! haha :)) xxx
I hope that all good things come your way Marcus Cleaver. You are a man of great generosity, knowledge, and kindness simplifying the law in areas that some of us find difficult. EU law has not been kind to me so far, but I am going to keep watching your videos until it sinks in. Thank you, Marcus - you the man !
Marcus, I wish you were my lecturer lol, really enjoyed your style as opposed to my boring lecturer at Uni. If I pass my EU trade law exam, full credit will go to you mate.
you are an absolute donny mate! you've condensed the inaccessible waffle that my lecturers have been dishing out all term into something easy to understand. thank you
Teaching is a skill. I wished more universities understood that. My lecturers have the knowledge but they don't have the skill required to relay that information to us in a way that we understand. You have that skill. Thank you.
Hi Marcus. I absolutely love your videos. I have been studying the GDL for less than two months and have become a firm follower of your tutorials and lectures. The way you explain the concepts is so simplified and helps me no end. Please carry on making videos on key parts of the various modules because you're fantastic!
I’am law student on 4th course and we learn EU economics law discipline , so as I read comments, I thought I’am the only one who get more questions than answers, but anyway thank you for giving me more food to thinking about!!!)
Hey Marcus, thanks for this. I'm doing the i-GDL and we get minimal lectures and seminars and really struggled so far with FMoW, but this has cleared things up for me! Thanks again
Funny how the whole semester I could not understand anything my lecturer was trying to teach us and looking at 3 of your videos I feel like I could smash my exam
Would be great if you could write down the info that's on the slides in the decription box, just makes it easier for note taking. Either way, I love your videos and everything just makes sense!
Perfect! I have written down the content of the slides for EU Art 30, 34, 35, 36 and 45 into a word doc if you want to save yourself some time, I can send them to you. Also, thank you for probably saving me from failing :)
Are you able to explain more about the development of the concept of EU citizenship? I understand that Directive 2004/38 consolidated other legislation relating to free movement of persons but there seem to be so many cases that it's difficult to spot which CJEU judgement's had the most significant impacts on the development.
This is great, thank you. Only critizism that I have is that for time to time I wasn't sure if you are talking about TFEU or some directive (slide at 5:41). And also it could be clearer to put the article on the slide when you are talking about it.
Thanks Marcuscleaver..... Your explanation is very clear but I have a doubt concerning the Right to be a citizen after 5 years. Does it apply only for member states??
If you are a TCN (third country national) other rules will apply. But if you are a TCN and are a family member of a Union citizen you will pretty much have the same rights as them. You can find the definition of family in the Citizens Directive 2004/38 Article 2
Hi Marcus, are EU citizens accepting a job offer in another Member State also covered by EU law.. Because it's a bit confusinf if they fall under the category of a worker as they haven't been paid yet.
Great video! Do work seekers have the same rights as workers? And would their family members be able to claim social and tax advantages if the person they have come with is only a worker seeker?
Hi Marcus - thanks so much for this video! I have a bit of a unique circumstance and was curious what your thoughts were. Here is the situation I'm a dual citizen (USA and Luxembourg) and currently live in the U.S. I have been inquiring with my employer about working remotely within an EU country. Would I be able to live in any EU country with Passport Luxembourg documentation? (Let's say I want to live in Hamburg, Germany and my work is remote/online in Amsterdam) I know you mentioned needing proof of work to register after 3 months - does this work/employment have to originate in the country of residence (Germany in my example)? Or can I simply prove that I have income from somewhere and the means to support myself? If the above situation isn't possible, I suppose I could get part-time work on the weekends, as you mentioned, to submit as proof of work. Then could continue working my other career job remotely during the week.
This is good but is it mainly applied to EU national? What about Non-Eu Nationals and their right to free movement, are they covered? Also what about the spouse/children (Non-eu nationals)?
+simran naseer Art 45 only applies to nationals from countries with an agreement with the EU. I've been meaning to put an annotation into the video about family members. Will try tomorrow.
Please do. Although this was extremely helpful, but when applying it to scenarios it becomes difficult as you know a lot of the problem questions for this topic have individuals who are either EU Nationals, or Non-EU National's Spouse. Sometimes the EU national has dual Nationality and sometimes there is a child involved as well and then it definitely becomes difficult to grasp the topic but overall you have honestly made law so much more enjoyable for all the law students! your videos are very much appreciated. Thank You. Please do Parliamentary Supremacy as well if you can.
Hi this is such a good video, i have few question regarding to freedom of good, worker and establishment. Would you mind if i email you the questions? Thanks!
For less than 15 minutes you succeeded in explaining me that material better than my EU professor for the whole semester. THANK YOU!
+Teddy Stoyanova haha thank you for taking the time to comment!
Teddy Stoyanova you have neatly summed up Mr Cleaver's great skill of simplifying and make everything concise enough to retain and yet sufficiently in depth to delve!
So true! lol!
I think it's time they open the 'Marcus Cleaver' no nonsense law school, we would all graduate in 5 months with top grades haha. You are so amazing!!! You have made exam revision bearable and so much easier than the complex way my lectures makes it. Thanks Marcus aka Sheldon! haha :)) xxx
Learned more in this 12 minutes than I did in a whole 2 hour lecture - thank you!
+Anna Goodfellow lol thank you for taking the time to comment!
I hope that all good things come your way Marcus Cleaver. You are a man of great generosity, knowledge, and kindness simplifying the law in areas that some of us find difficult. EU law has not been kind to me so far, but I am going to keep watching your videos until it sinks in. Thank you, Marcus - you the man !
Marcus, I wish you were my lecturer lol, really enjoyed your style as opposed to my boring lecturer at Uni. If I pass my EU trade law exam, full credit will go to you mate.
Cheers Husnaen!
you are an absolute donny mate! you've condensed the inaccessible waffle that my lecturers have been dishing out all term into something easy to understand. thank you
Your videos were a life saver for me 3 years ago and now I’m back again!! Thank you!
You Sir, are an absolute saviour.
+Dr.Mantis Tobbogan And you Dr, have a brilliant username :D
I was wondering if you could do a video on the Rylands v. Fletcher Rule in tort law. It would be extremely useful.
Thank you for all these informative videos! Thanks to you I managed to pass my EU internal market exam!
Congratulations!
Really well explained, thank you. Glad I found this just before my exam.
Thanks Haben!
honestly you've sorted my life out , i feel like i memorise everything from your videos you're so clear and amazing i wish you were my eu teacher
Thank you so much for all your videos!!! My friend, Nadia and I are very thankful for the content you put out!
Teaching is a skill. I wished more universities understood that. My lecturers have the knowledge but they don't have the skill required to relay that information to us in a way that we understand. You have that skill. Thank you.
he made my lecturer' s 60 slide powerpoint so pointless! Thank you Sir!!!!
You are more than welcome!
You're a legend
Haroun Jose
Hi Marcus. I absolutely love your videos. I have been studying the GDL for less than two months and have become a firm follower of your tutorials and lectures. The way you explain the concepts is so simplified and helps me no end. Please carry on making videos on key parts of the various modules because you're fantastic!
You are so helpful! You have made it so much easier for me to understand these topics for my upcoming exam. Thank you so much for making these videos.
Good luck in the exam!!
Could you do one on free movement on services and establishment please??
Dear my baby brother.you are amazing.may god bless you for your great efforts to help
Never disappointed, greatly done once again!
I'm so glad I came across this video! thank you !!
Excellent video. Like all the other ones you did. Any chance to have a one on free movement on services and establishment?
Great introductory lecture. Well explained and just in time for my EU examinations coming up! Thank you!
this video has just been an absolute lifesaver, I cannot thank you enough, I'm pretty sure you've just saved my grades😭😂
Thank you so much for all your videos. An absolute lifesaver. You're very skilled in teaching. :)
Thanks so much for elucidating EU law I feel much more confident for my exam tomorrow!
Great videos, such a clear study tool! Thank you so much!
Helped me so much with my second year exams! Thank you!
I’am law student on 4th course and we learn EU economics law discipline , so as I read comments, I thought I’am the only one who get more questions than answers, but anyway thank you for giving me more food to thinking about!!!)
Thank you Marcus. I found it useful in my preparation for the QLTS assessment
Powerful. God bless you, Marcus, for your videos and hard work. So helpful for my exams 🙌
Hey Marcus, thanks for this. I'm doing the i-GDL and we get minimal lectures and seminars and really struggled so far with FMoW, but this has cleared things up for me! Thanks again
+John Jarvis Cheers, check back in on some of the other topics too! ;)
you are so sweet and articulate your words very well thank u so much for this!
Please do one on free movement on services and establishment.... It will really Help for the exams coming up!
Could you do a video on free movement of services and est please? Your videos are so clear and comprehensive, it helps me immensely!
You remind me of sheldon from the BBT😭❤️
lmao 😂
Really good. so simple to absorb.
Thank you, this was so helpful and easy to understand!
+Aya Gontier Thank you Aya!!
Funny how the whole semester I could not understand anything my lecturer was trying to teach us and looking at 3 of your videos I feel like I could smash my exam
Great Video! Very helpful. Thank you!
Would be great if you could write down the info that's on the slides in the decription box, just makes it easier for note taking. Either way, I love your videos and everything just makes sense!
I've done that for more recent stuff (because for me it attracts more views too!) but haven't had a chance yet to go back and fill in the older ones.
Perfect! I have written down the content of the slides for EU Art 30, 34, 35, 36 and 45 into a word doc if you want to save yourself some time, I can send them to you. Also, thank you for probably saving me from failing :)
Thank you ! its definetly helpful btw could you upload a video on free movement of person and citizens ? :)
Love your videos: concise and mega helpful
excellent video..very informative. Thank you.
Love it mate, great lecture
Many thanks for same. Excellent. It will really help with the exam. Jan,
Thanks a ml.
Very easy to understand.
Just glad I got the video out in time :)
Thank you for this. These help alot
Are you able to explain more about the development of the concept of EU citizenship? I understand that Directive 2004/38 consolidated other legislation relating to free movement of persons but there seem to be so many cases that it's difficult to spot which CJEU judgement's had the most significant impacts on the development.
Even my lecture with Prof Laurent Pech and Dr Joelle Grogan wasn't that detailed. Although it was mostly based on the Regulation 492/2011
❤❤❤ma God bless you!!
thanks a lot for this !!! please keep going if you can
7 years later, still good 👍🏾
Good job, as usual.
This is great, thank you. Only critizism that I have is that for time to time I wasn't sure if you are talking about TFEU or some directive (slide at 5:41). And also it could be clearer to put the article on the slide when you are talking about it.
Thank you for making this video 😊
Thanks Marcuscleaver..... Your explanation is very clear but I have a doubt concerning the Right to be a citizen after 5 years. Does it apply only for member states??
There is a difference in becoming a citizen and being granted permanent residence.
If you are a TCN (third country national) other rules will apply. But if you are a TCN and are a family member of a Union citizen you will pretty much have the same rights as them. You can find the definition of family in the Citizens Directive 2004/38 Article 2
Thank you a lot 👍
Much Appreciated! Thank you somuch.. Really Useful! (Y) (Y)
Hi Marcus, are EU citizens accepting a job offer in another Member State also covered by EU law.. Because it's a bit confusinf if they fall under the category of a worker as they haven't been paid yet.
thank you Marcus great and helpful video
Thank you so much that was really useful!!
Please do free movement of services and establishment!!!
Really helpful, Thank you so much Marcus. :)
Thanks for the nice comment Sara!
Hi Marcus, I found this video really useful- thank you! Would it be possible to post a video regarding self-employed workers please? Thanks :)
Can you please cover free movement of services and establishment as well?
This video was very helpful! I was wondering if you could make a video about article 267 of the TFEU
Good idea for a topic that.
Great video! Do work seekers have the same rights as workers?
And would their family members be able to claim social and tax advantages if the person they have come with is only a worker seeker?
very helpful, thank you very much
Thank thank thank u!!
Hi Marcus - thanks so much for this video! I have a bit of a unique circumstance and was curious what your thoughts were. Here is the situation
I'm a dual citizen (USA and Luxembourg) and currently live in the U.S. I have been inquiring with my employer about working remotely within an EU country. Would I be able to live in any EU country with Passport Luxembourg documentation? (Let's say I want to live in Hamburg, Germany and my work is remote/online in Amsterdam) I know you mentioned needing proof of work to register after 3 months - does this work/employment have to originate in the country of residence (Germany in my example)? Or can I simply prove that I have income from somewhere and the means to support myself?
If the above situation isn't possible, I suppose I could get part-time work on the weekends, as you mentioned, to submit as proof of work. Then could continue working my other career job remotely during the week.
Hi Marcus, do you have any other videos where you delve in the rights which family members hold under Directive 2011/38? Thanks!
thank you very much!
+defne örnek You are more than welcome!
Hello, did you also make a video on 'the free movement of capital' ?
Your explanation is very good
+Febe Terryn Not quite yet I'm afraid.
+marcuscleaver Okay, ni problem :)! Thanks to answer
what if you studied in a country for 5 years, do you have the right to residence?
Thank you so much but can we rely on this for our final exam? kindly answer this as soon as possible.
Thanks Marcus this was really helpful :)
+Lara Micallef Thanks Lara :)
This is good but is it mainly applied to EU national? What about Non-Eu Nationals and their right to free movement, are they covered? Also what about the spouse/children (Non-eu nationals)?
+simran naseer Art 45 only applies to nationals from countries with an agreement with the EU. I've been meaning to put an annotation into the video about family members. Will try tomorrow.
Please do. Although this was extremely helpful, but when applying it to scenarios it becomes difficult as you know a lot of the problem questions for this topic have individuals who are either EU Nationals, or Non-EU National's Spouse. Sometimes the EU national has dual Nationality and sometimes there is a child involved as well and then it definitely becomes difficult to grasp the topic but overall you have honestly made law so much more enjoyable for all the law students! your videos are very much appreciated. Thank You. Please do Parliamentary Supremacy as well if you can.
clear, concise, accurate
+Alexis Feliz Thanks Alexis!!
So helpful 💯
Hi is free movement of workers question similar to free movement of persons?
Should Brexit occur what will be the legal consequences in article 45 TFEU between the UK and EU?
Very much depends on the deal that is struck between the UK and the EU. Hard Brexit or soft Brexit?
Hard Brexit. I don't for see soft Brexit happening knowing the reason for the referendum.
Love your videos, but this material is not sufficient for exams perspective although it really helped me to understand the basics.
is free movement of workers and free movement of persons the same thing`? thank you
very helpful thank you
I am an eu citizen I want to move to Germany but my kid is not an eu citizen can I still bring him?
Thank you
hi could you do one on free movement of establishment
Hi this is such a good video, i have few question regarding to freedom of good, worker and establishment. Would you mind if i email you the questions? Thanks!
What would happen if they have spouse as a non EU citizen and then they gwt divorce while they also have a child?
THANK YOU! I may just pass my exam now
Good luck! ;)
You freaking babe! Thanks
Ta :)
Spectacular video, keep up the good work brother! --> Subscribed
Thank you, byeeeeeeeeeeeeee x
Hi! Could you spare some time on citizenship
You should look up my video on Article 20!
3