The Worst Performance Ever?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ต.ค. 2024
- This week, I'm reacting to Ingrid Andress and her recent performance of the "Star-Spangled Banner" at the Home Run Derby. There were a lot of negative headlines - even after she explained the reasons behind it. Were any of them deserved?
For Behind The Scenes footage, tips on ball skills or to talk to me in a monthly Zoom Chat Night, head over to my Patreon: / jushawk
My Shirtless Season Festival Tour with The Darkness (SS24) continues across Europe. Find out where: www.thedarknes...
Get a Justin Hawkins Rides Again T-Shirt & Hoodie here: thejawsofvicto...
Join my Mailing List here: beacons.ai/jus...
To listen to previous episodes of Justin Hawkins Rides Again...The Podcast. You can listen on Apple Podcast, Spotify etc: open.spotify.c...
#reaction #review #ingridandress
"That's wasn't awful, maybe it wasn't ideal."
Justin Hawkins is the man I'd like behind the booth when I record vocals.
100% 😅
Straight facts facts facts....
I wonder if that would be his opinion if it was his national anthem.
@gomogo2000 Really dude? Did yer feewings get huwt because your national anthem wasn't sung well...
@@prehistoricturtlesaurus5309 Yes, we're not precious about ours.
18 years sober.. way to go.. Big thumbs up.👍👍
It just feels nicer to show compassion rather than go for cheap laughs and be mean. Well done Justin 👍❤
Justin's a good dude, cause that was pretty awful
Agreed. I'm reminded of the guy who played the voice for Jar Jar Binks (as directed) and the personal backlash he received. He talks about nearly ending his life...and none of this should be that serious. But so many people, especially those online, feel like people deserve the lols because those in the public put themselves out there.
@@revwillyg6450 Well! The begining are not bad. It's the middel part that she are singing really out of her range. And if you are watching her eyes. So is theor relling me. That you are watchong a person how are not experience the moment at all. She really seems to need some help.
@@RVZNKaraoke The kid who played king Joffrey in Game of Thrones also got a huge backlash for playing the part as written. Poor kid was just 13 and it was his first (big) gig. He stopped acting for 6 years. People are weird
@@oz_jones singing it as written would have been a good idea
"Maybe it wasn't ideal..."
Man, you would make a FANTASTIC International Diplomat if this music thing doesn't work out.
"She's fine..." to "This is really painful." in less than 30 seconds...
Went from "Oh." to "Oh, dear..."
🤣😂🤣It got a bit "wonky"
@@GazHogan Jabbawonky!
"I couldn't perform because I was drunk"
Every band from the 70's/80's: I'd ask you to hold my beer but there's none left
Not even a lie
They can be drunk or coked up out of their minds and still play tighter than a corset
@@KaaneDragonShinobi even Led Zeppelin could be sloppy as hell. The first night at Knebworth '79 was a disaster.
😂
@@KaaneDragonShinobi We've forgotten the terrible performances, largely because most concerts weren't as widely contributed as nowadays. Another thing is that, except for traumas, we tend to remember positive things and forget bad ones, leading to rose tinted glasses
In a world where so many want to kick the underdog... that was refreshing and kind. I for one am grateful my screw ups at that age were never televised. You're a class act Jus.❤
She’s 32. Most of us outgrew our screw ups in our early twenties.
@@SuziQ.ha-ha not me! I guess I was a late bloomer😜
@@lesliehutchins8365 I'm 48 and still fucking up haha
@@SuziQ.Really!? 😮😮😮 Oh dear.
@@ooberonfire I feel your pain my friend!😻👍
Not since Hendrix at Woodstock has a rendition of the National Anthem so perfectly captured the current zeitgeist of the American people. I knew she was a singer. But she’s more the that. She’s an artist. And this is her Guernica.
That made me chuckle
I felt the same...I quite enjoyed how creepy (and currently relevant) it was.
Well said
You mean she reused a song she had lying around?
Ha! Ha! Jimieeee......!!
I have so much respect for your approach to these videos.
I love how fireworks go off exactly in the moment where her singing is at its worst. It's almost comical to me 😅
"She's horrible! Quick...launch launch launch!!!"
@@MicksMom365 - 😅👍
lol it's obviously on higher parts.
It is REALLi funny.
Whom among us hasn’t been liquored up and sang the National anthem in front of thousands of people?🤷♂️ PLAY BALL!!!
I definitely have
@@natebash2004 exactly Nate! 🤘
Some guys can drink and drive, some cant, i mean...what is drunk?
Well said man. Well said! :D
I have, too. And the other spectators even tried to have me removed! Or words to that effect. But I'm pretty sure I nailed Sweet Caroline, in the 7th...
This is the most polite analysis I've seen.
Wings of Pegasus was even nicer about it!
Congrats on 18 years, Justin!!!!!!!!!
Justin verbally dancing around the fact that these were all hard to listen to without wincing. Very kind but also hilarious ❤😂
Why can't they just sing it straight? Why add all the frills and affectations?
Everyone has to outdo Mariah Carey’s version. 🤦🏼♀️
The affectations are done because they can't sing it straight.
They are trying to beat Whitney Houston! She sang the best national anthem! This girl is just as bad as Roseanne Barr. 😂
Because "muh personality"
*proceeds to have the same "personality" as every previous performer*
It's called being American.
That's a really good point about imposter syndrome, I haven't seen anyone else mention that possibility, and that makes a lot of sense. Apparently it takes a couple of Englishmen (you and Fil Henley from Wings of Pegasus) to bring some perspective and kindness to this national anthem situation.
Well, we said we were tired of autotune 🤷
😅
It’s so inexplicably bad, it almost sounds like she IS using autotune, but the settings are all wrong.
@@fromchomleystreet lol, would anyone be that cruel?
@@fromchomleystreet I'm pretty sure that's exactly it. You can hear it tuning but it's not set to the right key or she's switched keys so she's signing notes that aren't in the key it's set to so it's doing big jumps to nearest note that is the completely wrong interval.
😂👏👏👏👏👏
It's comforting knowing The Hoff is standing watch over you.
He watches over us all
The compassion you show here is nothing short of beautiful Justin!
i love your expressions when it went from “she’s fine,” to “ooh err…” 😅 i absolutely love your channel haha
Not a shining moment for her. However, both my dogs howled in sympathy.
I'll wager both sounded better.
@@markjackson6325 my chihuahua hit some sharp notes, but my black lab was on the money.
I saw her message before the performance and was very sad to see this after going to an Ingrid concert with my daughter in Manchester back in 2023. She was excellent at the Manchester gig with music (no autotune) that's far better than other artists in her genre. I hope everything is alright for her and that she gets back on her feet. Your insight Justin at the end of imposter syndrome is interesting to read, and nice that you showed compassion towards an artist who had a bad day
You are looking good. And no I’m not saying that because you are shirtless. Hair looking great. You look rested and happy.
"Im not saying it because you are shirtless" Honest. 😉
You gave this a proper amount of time and consideration.
Never heard of her ! No reason to start now.
Thank you for reminding me to skip this one
Good one.😅😅😅
Her rendition was the perfect accompaniment to current day USA
Spot-on.
Train wreck?
Just as Jimi Hendrix’s renditions were fitting at the time he played them….. However, Jimi’s versions were played that way intentionally.
Kinda fitting for the times eh.
Sad but true. Hope she gets the help she needs... hope we do, too!
IT'S ENRICO PALAZZO!
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I think people should stop taking the piss out of people when they fall and start being supportive. Keep banging on about being kind and helping each other over mental health, etc. well people want to start doing it or shut up. Don’t we all have a bad day or the thing we do best don’t always go the way we want it too? Yeah be kind and helping each other.
That's never going to happen. If you are placed infront of millions of people u have to justify why u are there.
If there is no justification then anyone can just get up and sing it.
Those are the strict rules of fame and fortune.
It's that vocal affectation that so many put on for talent show auditions that seems to be the issue. She's probably so used to not using her "non-famous" voice, and instead using the vocal affectation that's gained her popularity, that when she has to really belt it's just not there.
Or autotune😂
She usually (always?) sings in her head voice, which is the opposite of belting. Didn’t they do a sound check and a practice run? She has a soft, breathy voice. This song wouldn’t be in her wheelhouse if she was sober.
This probably. She doesn't sound like a very technical singer and seems to rely a lot on said affectations, from what her original music suggests, and it looks like she bit much more than she could chew. In fairness, quite a few tricky intervals in SSB, and if her monitoring wasn't good and she could hear too much of the echo wash from the stadium, that might have not helped either. Also probably wasn't too prepared/rehearsed, else she would probably have been able to just shut off all exterior noise completely and rely on muscle memory and inner voice.
Been trying to find that word after hearing it recently....yep, thank you!! "Affectation....affectation......" - *memorising it to simply make me even sicker of it than I was already* - ;-)
@@nicdee316 I was in a band with a singer who could either sing great or sing terrible. It was bizzare how much he knew nothing about music theory at all. Zero. Sad thing is 20 years in I've had to learn it and coulda fixed so many issues if I knew back then what I know now.
I saw an app the other day and it asks you to sing in different levels of loudness. It works out where u sing at, then only shows u songs in your vocal range. Neat idea for practice and learning where u can and cant go.
Justin, I appreciate your musical opinion and most importantly, your humanity. Your compassion is refreshing and as someone in recovery, I value your insight. You look well and I hope that you are. Best wishes from Canada.
It was painful to listen to. Doesn't make me feel like checking out any of her tracks.
Apparently she was drunk/high. she wants to go to rehab so i wish her the best
Carl Lewis is a sprinter who won nine Olympic gold medals.
Ingrid Andress is a singer with four Grammy nominations.
Carl Lewis was a long jumper who also did a bit of sprinting IIRC.
@@FlatDerrick He won Olympic gold doing both, albeit in 1984 when a large swath of the world didn't participate.
Sounds like her producer should get the grammy nod
@@jypsyjewels2854,
She didn’t win the Grammy awards. She was only nominated. One album got 3 nods: for best artist; for best country song, and best country album.
The 4th nomination was for best country duo on “Wishful Drinking” (cough cough).
@@SuziQ. 😁
Looking mighty handsome today, bravo 👍🏼
Take out a restraining order pronto, Justin...look at this person's account name.
Sounds like she's singing backwards
Haha that’s what I thought!
She sounds like me trying to do Kirsty Mcall, Fairytail of New York at Christmas while half tipsy on a few cheeky tipsy doos. xx 🤣🤣 Carrying it on as though you think you sound great and not caring...everyone cheering you on in their devilment of sarcasm.
Always a joy to see Justing sticking to rule #1, there are enough people on the interwebs doing the opposite, even some that only do negative, must be exhausting.
Great compassion and empathy. Humane reaction, but it will probably fall on those who really don't understand how hard is being on that stage, and also dealing with alcohol use. Good for her that she was open, honest and went to rehab.
I watched Fil from Wings Of Pegasus do a reaction to this, and he was very kind as well 🤗🦘🦘
Fil is always kind.
Fil like Justin is a gentleman and one can only feel pity for todays music is this girl is considered talented.
Fil’s attempt at fixing it was eye opening.
@@freefall8243 I know right! 😊
Fil is a legend
I've only just discovered your YT channel - thanks to you appearing in my newsfeed. It's the best news to see you here. Someone who was around music for years. As I'm 48 & so it's great to hear from a musician still going strong! I need this right now, as I traverse into middle age.
Justin your knowledge of 'Sport ball' rivals mine xx
"It contains a lot of letters" --> the extent of my knowledge too!
Thank you for your kindness and compassion Justin. She looked quite unhappy and zoned out. I hope she gets the help she needs.
I learned in 3rd grade, when I tried out for choir, that I have a TERRIBLE singing voice. I am okay with that fact. I do wish that others would realize they have the same issue.
I worry that some people would label themselves as having a bad voice, and then never explore it again. Everyone’s voice is different.
But if they did they would have to work for a living
Ha, yes, I hear ya!
I think it's always sad when people publicly deconstruct themselves. Thank you for being honest, funny but not nasty.
Justin, you're so kind .....this was truly appalling...she must know how bad it is..
thanks for not being a Dick. You are what the internet needs more of Justin. Love and appreciate what you do
The American dream summed up on social media. Pretty sad really.
They sound as good as our economy 😂
Kind and wise words Justin. Looking forward to your Latitude set Sunday!
Meanwhile at the Euros the England fans were all apparently singing 'God save the Kwing'
😂😂😂😂
That would take a lot of time getting used to. You've sung "queen" for 50 years afterall.
@@Kasino80 70 years! I'm not a huge royalist, but it did feel like she'd been Queen forever.
@@ZuzuTheLemon right! 70 years. Was thinking of the Danish queen.
Thank you. Coffee everywhere... 😂
JUstin, you've reached where I am in life as well. I'm a little over 50 and I have a different perspective on things. We don't want people to fail. We don't like to see people being embarrassed and certainly dislike people piling on afterward. Having a kid is certainly part of it. Maturity as well.
Having to have some over the top singer messing up the bloody song at sporting events, is always cringeworthy. There’s no need for it in the first place.
It does bring a lot of publicity though... I have to say, I had no idea about any of this or who she even was until this happened 😬 unfortunately it's not a great first impression
I've never been a fan of ppl who go to work drunk. No excuses really. 😮
I'm already out of the room before "by the duahhwn's early liiIIIIIIiiiiiIIIIIIIuuuhhhwoooaaaaaeeeerrrgghhhhiiiiiIIIIIIiiiight" soils the air. Every single time. Don't think I'll ever hear someone singing it straight again in my lifetime.
I legitimately feel bad for her. It's an extremely difficult song and she knows from the very beginning how bad it is. The fact that she's a professional singer and is there means she's capable of better, if she legitimately couldn't sing there's no way she would expose herself like that. Something just went wrong and it snowballed, you can see the panic on her face.
Ingrid Andress: "I was drunk. I can't perform while being drunk."
Ozzy Osbourne: "Bloody hell, she's an amateur."
Lemmy Kilmister: "What did she say? Amateur."
David Lee Roth: "That gal is an amateur."
Whitney: "I was on crack!" Jk
@@DWilliams-sf5th But she was. Just not while performing.
Keith Moon: nope
Eddie Van Halen : not so much
Axle Rose: lol
@@kmoecub I wasn't sure if she was smoking at that time. Thanks
@@DWilliams-sf5th😂💋🤘🏽
Yeah, there at the end she slipped and tried desperately to catch it and then panicked. 99% of those watching were just waiting for the game to start. The anthem is a tradition and a formality only a few are truly moved by. Who among us hasn't had a moment we wish we could "re-do" or delete all together? Forget about it and everyone else will follow. If they don't, F#¢k 'em.
Now, she actually became famous, as hardly anyone heard of her before
she is pretty well known in the world of Pop Country.
Yep! This had been my very first impression of her indeed! 😅
@@itsdavew5766I live in Nashville and never once heard her name.
I think I've said it under one of your other videos already, but I so so appreciate your professional and also empathic approach to topics and events like this here one, that are overcast by the sensationalism of the internet. You're a voice of reason. Thanks for that.
Flavor Flav sang the anthem a few months ago and his performance was better than this one. What a world we live in.
😂
My mum was an alcoholic and she lost her battle two weeks ago aged 51. People commenting negatively have no idea what addiction is, how it controls your life and behaviour and how much destruction it can cause. Thank you for handling this sympathetically Justin.
I'm so sorry for your loss. 💐
Sorry for you lost. Yes addition is not a thing to joke about. And watching Ingrid's eyes makes me feel that she really need help
@@AnjektusStudioThat doesn’t add up!
@@Dreyno If you subtract it, it does.
@@Dreyno And why do YOU think that? Please explaine then you just make a lazy remark. Have you for exampel some knowledge how you evaliuate body expressions?
As a Canadian , try having your national anthem butchered to the tune of O Christmas Tree ....lol
It's a socialist hymn origina!ly, the tune was just reused for Christmas tree
I have no shit had the same song stuck in my head since late Jan/ early Feb. It was maddening but it finally went away about a week ago. Now you pull this shit & I fear it's all gonna start over w/ O Canada Tree.
Thanks Don, ya lousy bastitch!
🍺
@@TheFreeBass Look on the brightside , it's a nice break from all the other shit going on in this country ....lol
I absolutely adore this channel, I find it so intriguing listening to critical analysis from you Justin, someone that actually has experience and knowledge in the industry that you’re commenting on. 👏🏼👏🏼
The singer got more publicity singing at worst of her ability than singing at the best of her ability.
No autotune
pretty good publicity stunt 😮
@@mootbooxleThat little thought whispered in my ear, too. I mean, you'd have to be doing that deliberately- surely? Even if we give her the benefit of the doubt, surely it was at least for a bet 😬
@@mootbooxlegood as a publicity stunt, but not good for her career! She’ll have to live that down FOREVER. Look what happened to Rebecca Black…
@@UseTheSupeRsonic it’s true, and that’s what makes me think it’s possibly just her being irresponsible…but you gotta admit, it put her name and face Everywhere for a minute there!
The public is always unforgiving for those who fail, regardless of the reason. They would all feel terrible if others trashed their own individual failures, but they gleefully dish it to others. That girl wasn't taking the piss out of it, she was drunk and clearly had an alcohol problem if she had to check herself into rehab. There's just a lack of empathy in general in the service of mockery and humiliation.
People have to know there's a consequence for ignorance. Otherwise every addict and their dog would be up on the mound with a microphone. Wait...that just happened, right!
@@JohnFoley-cm8lm Being honest with anyone about their addiction and the need to get help, or that they should improve at something, is not the same as publicly trashing and humiliating them and making them the butt of a collective cruel joke. There's a difference. It's a lack of empathy for whatever someone is going through, and a resistance to letting people make a mistake without utterly tearing them down for it and clamoring for their end. I never heard of this woman before this, but she didn't k-ll someone, she just flubbed a performance. Publicly failing is humiliation enough for anyone, people don't need to actively make it worse. At the end of the day, what goes around comes around, and those who willingly participate in humiliation of someone who isn't a pos will at some point experience what the person they targeted felt.
Always a good day when The Hawkins himself uploads 👊 You should check out these 4 young guns from Australia Mixed Up Everything. Their new song ‘would you be me’ is definitely up your alley!
Yep would love to see that. Their new stuff is impressive
Not what I expected Justin , but an interesting insight. Thank you for sharing your personal experience to contextualise the performance. It is nice when you stumble across content that actually makes the internet a better place
The music did originate from a British drinking song
That was a bit of a cruel prank, I think? Convincing a bunch of drunk people to try to sing all those melodic leaps? I can do There Is A Tavern In The Town.
The origin is deeper than that. It was first written to honor Anacreon (Greek god, loved wine) and was used for many songs before being set to the poem written by Francis Scott Key.
Every British song is a drinking song
@@kmoecub Francis Scott Off-Key, judging by recent renditions!
It's very refreshing getting your pov. I love you're channel so much
For the record, Carl Lewis was an Olympic track and field athlete. He won nine gold medals. Not a professional singer. Can't be judged the same way.
I agree that Fergie gets unnecessary hate, as if she sang badly. The problem is that she seemed to make the 'national' anthem about herself rather than the simple ritual that it was.
I didn’t know I was waiting for this reaction to listen to this but this was awesome. Glad you’re back!
That 12 string is gorgeous!
Hawkins is being incredibly kind.
He's a class act, is our Justin. Not an ungenerous bone in his body.
She's singing all the right notes .... just not necessarily in the right order or key. But its sad...
Justin is a proper gentleman and The Darkness is a proper rock band.
This is what happens when you’re brought up on autotune
Bless your heart Mr Hawkins, that was refreshingly kind and decent. Love you, love your work.
Agree with you Justin. I felt very sorry for her.
But anyone who thinks that rehab is “fun” is in for a real awakening!😜Thanks for being nice guy and not piling on the nastiness.😻👏🏻BTW, you look fab hon❤
Its so nice to get a straight view on things without all the hype and bullshit.
Her bomb surely was bursting in air.
I'm surprised they're saying Rosanne Barr's performance. that one caused quite an uproar in the 80s
We never imagined it could get worse. Now it has. 😂
The difference is she's not a singer. Same with Karl Lewis.
Rosanne was the first thing that came to mind.
I personally love the Rosanne Barr version. She didn't give two f**ks.
I bet she gives two f's now. Her mouth got her kicked off her own show. Lost millions, now she might make a few coins doing somebody's podcast.
I'm with you, Justin. Those of us who get on stage will invariably have a bad day/performance. I hope she gets the help she needs and for this experience to make her stronger as an entertainer. Thanks for your take.
You have to check out Chris Stapleton singing the national anthem at the Super Bowl, it’s amazing!
"Drink, Drink Drink" the lyrics to the song from the movie "The Student Prince." A bunch of Germans with Steins were drinking and singing beautifully. 0-)
9:22 p.m.
Hi Justin! Yeah. It's pretty painful to listen to.
As one who has been involved in the production of music (20 years a keyboardist worldwide and 30 years in education right up to university level) Mr Hawkins is absolutely right in his observations of voice production, intonation and pitch and general song delivery. There have been many times examples of the solo singer starting off 'a capella' singing eight or so bars of a tune and missing the real key by three or even four semitones. Accurate Pitching is a real test of pitch-memory skills. It is rarely done accurately. But then all of the other vocal inflections are perceived as "style". Vocal 'upper and lower mordents' where the voice bends a note for effect is commonplace in jazz and pop, but listening to the vocals here, remembering the original key seems to have left her in a precarious situation. I'm afraid that I had to stop at 4'15". It was too much.
Mr Hawkins, you took one for the team. I commend you upon your patience and diplomacy. IMHO if you set yourself up to do this job, you must face the backlash when it goes upside down.
i'm just checking to make sure Justin says "dahrby."
Your looking so healthy and well ❤ Love The Darkness
Our Ears had to go to Rehab after that Anthem Performance
It was a popular english tune that the US chose for their anthem...apparently written by an englishman named John Stafford Smith and sung in London pubs over 100 years before the US adopted it in 1931 to different lyrics...fun fact
The softer sung parts were lovely. I hope she goes to rehab and tries again and then does a great job.
Being drunk doesn’t make you tone deaf, it’s different if she couldn’t hear herself and was having in ear problems but that wasn’t the case she just has awful pitch control. Thats a song some just shouldn’t sing and she’s one of them
Too many singers these days have relied on Auto tune that they overestimate their actual abilities.
It can be defended, I guess, in some way... But they're also being paid probably quite well to do a job.
Put it this way, I'm an illustrator and if I hand over pictures as badly as they were singing, I don't get paid 😬
Fergie's version reminds me of 'The Club Singer Round' on Shooting Stars 🤣
Vic Reeves loved it 😂
When you skim through the cliff notes of the Dollar Tree version of "Sing Like Lana Del Rey in 12 Easy Lessons" while hungover the morning of the gig.
I once did a gig at a Freemason's lodge. They asked for the national anthem before the banquet and so I started playing the Spunk Spangled Banner solo, a la Jimi Hendrix version. Two bars in a voice boomed out, "Wrong one." Well I was in Bradford, northern England at the time. They were not amused, but it was well worth it.😊
Looking absolutely gorgeous Justin
The American National Anthem is one of those rare songs you can sing as badly as the last tone deaf egomaniac and still get a standing ovation. So god damn patriotic.
Lol true dat 😁
I've never sung with a little polyp.
How is Elton?
You're being very generous Justin.
They should just play a recording of Whitney Houston's version at all events. No more issues.
I'm pretty sure 'accidents' like this one are intended, just like all the other 'scandals' at such events, like Miley Cyrus twerking, Kanye interrupting Taylor, JT and Janet Jackson, etc.
The whitney version was a recording too! It wasn’t live.
Nice video Justin. I haven't dropped in for awhile and I enjoyed it. I like how you put up clips of other disastrous versions.
Oh no I feel for her
"when she gets there it's nice" She didd hold that note, but even without perfect pitch I can tell that was the wrong note. Relative to the notes she herself provided.