I love the fact that we think the whole time that matt Smith's doctor was HER doctor, but she says that HER doctor sjowed up in the suit and gave her the screwdriver and all that. Capaldi was her Doctor
It wasn't the regeneration that made the Doctor finally "hers", it was the experiences. I know you could interpret that to be what you said, but she wasn't thinking about a face, she was thinking about a presence.
I interpret it that for River it's based on how old he is rather than a specific regeneration as she discussed how young he was in his eyes. This is similar to when Missy is talking to Clara and says it doesn't matter which face, they're all the doctor to me
@@delcox8165 No, it was the 26 years of railing that she took before she got to this moment. He wasn't "hers" because they didn't spend time together to (in her mind) make him hers.
So, one thing ive always wondered is just how much time matt's doctor actually spent with river. We know they had constant side adventures, as well as him having a lot more stuff happen to him beyond what we see on screen. I saw someone mention that he could potentially be spending years out on a longer term adventure outside the tardis, all in the time it takes for his companions to sleep for the night due to how time works with the tardis (not sure how accurate this is though).
“I am the doctor” “Yeah, someday” The doctor had already been through so much, this absolutely infuriated him, but he goes through so much more with her
Doctor being like 500 years old at that point out of the 900 biological years she's used to would be like a person calling a 50 year old young because they are used to them being 70-80
I absolutely loved River. Her chemistry with all her Doctors is perfect. I wish some of the many off screen moments that River and the Doctor had were instead shown on screen. I think there are many people who don't realize the amount of time, dates (and *cough* nights), and adventures they spent together that we simply don't see. This episode, and every episode with River, hits so much harder when you realize the love and trust and respect that would build from sharing all the moments they shared.
A great example of this is their "last night together" at the singing towers. I believe its referenced a couple of times beforehand and we obviously assume it is just one final night together, only for the doctor to reveal that night will last 24 years 😂
@@jaimewallace6332 nah river did nothing but change the show from a kid’s show to a show that can’t stop referencing how loud she screams during when the doctor and her fuck.
The books! The audio radio uh, podcast thingy about River that’s her little stories! There is so much that is not in the tv series but you can still read about and it’s wild and lovely
@@travisgames2The 9th doctor states in the empty child that he had ‘900 years of phonebox travel’ and the 10th doctor claims to be 904 years old in ‘the voyage of the damned’ & states he is 906 in ‘the end of time’, 11 starts at 907 (or so he claims in ‘flesh and stone’), his younger self claims to be 909 in ‘The Impossible Astronaut’, in the same episode his future self claims to be 1103, in ‘a town called mercy’, he says he is 1200, he spends 900 years in Trenzalore, stated in the short story ‘Tales of Trenzalore’ and regenerates into 12 at 2100 (but rounds down to 2000), he does stay in the confession dial for 4.5 billion years in ‘Heaven Sent’, but doesn’t count that in his age. After that it gets a little hard to keep track of in all honesty, they never give an exact age after 11, only basic numbers like 2000, however he does claim to be 1 billion years old in ‘The Giggle’.
It's genuinely incredible how much of a risk this episode was. So much hung an impied future story that hadn't even been written yet, and if it had ended up not landing there was NO wiggling out of it.
what risk? This was designed as a one off episode. They then wrote the other episodes to fit the narrative set up in this one when Moffat got creative control
Except it wasn't. @@Engiflux They preplanned damn near everything for this episode to work out. They even had her speak of how the doctor took her to see the singing towers, which they then referenced a few more times before we finally get to see the episode of Capaldi taking her to those towers.
When Steven Moffat wrote this episode, he knew he would be showrunner for next season(s). So at the very least everything season 5 and possibly 6 related for River Song would be a safe bet to introduce here. I think this was Moffat teasing the future for his time as showrunner and introduce a new character to the audience before making her more important during the next seasons.
@@matthiashavrez Except now we have a dead person who apparently knows the Doctors NAME. HIS ACTUAL TRUE NAME. Which she whispers in his ear in THIS episode. The same episode where she says that she knows him VERY well. There was NO wriggling out of it. The name alone proves they have history. And if it wasn't his name, then it was something else to make it clear to him that she DOES know him and he CAN trust her. That's not something you can sweep under the rug. At least, not to people who actually watch every episode religiously. You know... Like all the people in England that gave it its cult following?
It's so funny because they really set up the dynamic between the Doctor and River but still, Ten is not River's Doctor, not yet. The word "spoilers" doesn't sound right because it's not "their word" yet, but by him starting to say it now, they set up the joke for later. It's just little things like that, I think, that makes rewatches so much fun.
Every time I rewatch, I 'get' some new connection or twist or joke I didn't catch previously. That's what GREAT writing, acting and all around production gives us.
I think that's what's so beautiful about it- all the stuff she remembers he does because he heard her saying he could. He didn't know you could open the tardis with a snap until she mentioned he does that later- and he only does it because she taught him he could
This isn't a Bootstrap Paradox. That's when an object has no origin point. Say you receive a lottery ticket that wins, only to discover you yourself sent you the ticket from the future. So you send that ticket that you still have back in time. That is a Paradox because nobody actually acquired the ticket originally. You can actually see the Doctor avoid this in the Big Bang episode. The Doctor sees he's the one who sent a letter to young Amelia because she's holding it. So instead of taking that very letter, he grabs a paper and writes on that, thus avoiding the paradox.
@@lukeroberson2115 I think the "finger snapping" thing is a bootstrap paradox. If River hadn't told him about Future doctor being able to do it, he would have never tried it. So who first told the doctor he could open the TARDIS that way?
@@redreaper3065idk what paradox this is but it’s a bit like Angels take manhattan, where because you read/say it therefore it has to happen no matter what
“I’ve seen whole armies turn and run away with my doctor 😭” Fair to say she definitely didn’t witness the Sycorax fiasco during the early 10th doctor’s era.
Now we know what the meeting before this was and how she went on a whole thing of how loving the doctor is like loving the stars and how its folly to ask the sunset to admire you back. This is the first time she went in knowing how truly deep the doctor loved her
This was such a missed opportunity, so when Smith regenerates to Capaldi is all good, but they should have made a spin-off of at least one season with the escapades of River and Matt traveling during her nights in prison, the chemistry between the two was really cool, could have seen that two doctor birthday celebration 😂
just a reminder that every single river episode was personally written by steven moffat himself! he had her entire story planned out since silence in the library!
The more I think about it, the more the theory of Eternalism applies to Doctor Who. Everything just is. Always has been, always will be. A 4th dimensional or higher being could see the full picture, but 3rd dimensional beings are forced to see little parts of it at a time
When I first watched this episode this scene did not affect me like it does now because once you realize exactly who river is and what she is to the doctor any scene with her will affect you if you have a heart
Dr Who uses It's continuity to almost It's fullest. I have never seen a time travel story about lovers travelling in opposite directions to eachother's personal timelines
I absolutely LOATHE this part. This makes it feel like the TARDIS is SUPPOSED to be treated like a butler or a dog. It's pathetic. The TARDIS is fully sentient and no one wants to acknowledge that.
I really like Clara Oswald as a character, but re-watching this scene remind me of the one where she's arguing with Matt Smith and snapping her fingers to close the TARDIS doors. It makes this scene a little bit less significant.
that's not 11, she does that with 12 when he has to go "'undercover'" 12: *snapping his fingers to open the doors* I'll see you when I see you" clara: *snapping her fingers to close the doors* "and when will that be?" 11: *snapping his fingers to open the doors again* "when I see you" also I'd like to disagree with you, idt clara's scene diminishes this one at all, it's the first time the dr tries it, and ofc it only works for the dr because she's his tardis, but clara's different from all the other companions because she became apart of all the dr's lives when she became the impossible girl, which means she also has a unique relationship with the tardis
@@tinkrebellewhile this may be true it's never clarified (clarafied lol). So in that instance it seems to come out of nowhere. While you may be correct and there is logic to what you said it's never actually addressed so there's no way an average viewer would see this. I would venture to guess that it was more likely just for a comedic gag than any actual lore reason. "The doctor can close the doors with his fingers, let's make a sit com scene of this with doctor and Clara." Or so thing similar
@@TristonNightshade lol :P yeah you're most likely right, tho I'd argue the the relationship between clara and the tardis isn't just background stuff like it usually is for the other companions, they make a point of showing that the tardis doesn't like clara at first, that she's gotta win over her trust in a way, plus there's that whole minisode where the tardis messes with clara because she wants to, so idt it comes entirely out of nowhere, but tbf half the fan theories/ handcanons/ and whatnots come from moments that have secondary interpretations so it's possible I'm just reading into things 🤷
Funnily enough this is a bootstrap paradox The doctor only realizes he can Open the tardis Doors by snapping his fingers because River mentioned he could in the future but river only knew he could because she saw him do it in the future but he only knew he could do it in the future because he started doing it after this episode XD
the fact that river recently met capaldi and they bid each other the final goodbyee and now river knows this is the day she will die and then shee meets the very first docter wrt the docters timeline
To think that at this point in time, the show was so great. Everything that Doctor Who is about was being produced perfectly. To think what they did to it at this point makes me very upset.
This makes me sad... I like 10. But. 11 is cool. Mad respect. 12 took time but grew on me. As for 13. I will watch the box set. But I'm just waiting for the box set to see 10 again and this "new kid" from a Netflix series from the UK. Sex Education is where i first saw him act for a few series. I like his attitude. 13.. i never heard good things OFF set wise. And no. The Doctor could have been any woman. Just not her.
No, I think she was describing Smith, remember he was always the good man who went to war and made armies run, also I remember he was always snapping his fingers around so it sounds more like him
I find it funny when he gets the chance to talk to the TARDIS, she complains about him pushing the doors instead of pulling, yet she opens them inwards when she snaps
At the time it was likely still Anita, with her visor darkened by Doctor's screwdriver (but with vashta nerada already attached to her feet). It took Doctor's boast later, not River's words, to look him up.
Tbh I kinda wish they did an episode with 13 and river. i don’t know how they would have done it, but it would have been interesting for River’s reaction Edit And 14, Seeing the face that was at the library. The one that saved her
I love the fact that we think the whole time that matt Smith's doctor was HER doctor, but she says that HER doctor sjowed up in the suit and gave her the screwdriver and all that. Capaldi was her Doctor
It wasn't the regeneration that made the Doctor finally "hers", it was the experiences. I know you could interpret that to be what you said, but she wasn't thinking about a face, she was thinking about a presence.
I interpret it that for River it's based on how old he is rather than a specific regeneration as she discussed how young he was in his eyes. This is similar to when Missy is talking to Clara and says it doesn't matter which face, they're all the doctor to me
@@delcox8165 No, it was the 26 years of railing that she took before she got to this moment. He wasn't "hers" because they didn't spend time together to (in her mind) make him hers.
@@willdavis3802 unnecessarily misogynistic framing, but go off
So, one thing ive always wondered is just how much time matt's doctor actually spent with river. We know they had constant side adventures, as well as him having a lot more stuff happen to him beyond what we see on screen.
I saw someone mention that he could potentially be spending years out on a longer term adventure outside the tardis, all in the time it takes for his companions to sleep for the night due to how time works with the tardis (not sure how accurate this is though).
His first and her last time together. But it's the Doctor so there are exceptions to the rule - spoilers
First and last in the flesh at least
Because of the bilateral regeneration he could go back at davids 14th and save her now…
@@somethingrandom617 I wish, but they'd have to recast, and I don't think anyone could do River justice
That would envolve erasing moments that are pivotal to the doctors own history.@@somethingrandom617
@@KiloBravoGaming Why would they have to be recast?
“I am the doctor”
“Yeah, someday”
The doctor had already been through so much, this absolutely infuriated him, but he goes through so much more with her
"You're YOUNG!"
"I'm really not."
"You're younger than I've ever seen you."
That had to have thrown him for a loop... 😳
Doctor being like 500 years old at that point out of the 900 biological years she's used to would be like a person calling a 50 year old young because they are used to them being 70-80
@Conissocool yes, correct, that's how it works. 😁
I absolutely loved River. Her chemistry with all her Doctors is perfect.
I wish some of the many off screen moments that River and the Doctor had were instead shown on screen. I think there are many people who don't realize the amount of time, dates (and *cough* nights), and adventures they spent together that we simply don't see. This episode, and every episode with River, hits so much harder when you realize the love and trust and respect that would build from sharing all the moments they shared.
A great example of this is their "last night together" at the singing towers. I believe its referenced a couple of times beforehand and we obviously assume it is just one final night together, only for the doctor to reveal that night will last 24 years 😂
@@jaimewallace6332 nah river did nothing but change the show from a kid’s show to a show that can’t stop referencing how loud she screams during when the doctor and her fuck.
Give praise to Big Finish Audio; always some more DW lore that way.
The books! The audio radio uh, podcast thingy about River that’s her little stories! There is so much that is not in the tv series but you can still read about and it’s wild and lovely
Alex Kingston is just fabulous as River. So much emotion in her face when she talks about the Doctor yet it is her first episode in the franchise.
Imagine being 900 years old and saving the universe repeatedly and hearing you haven't reached your prime yet.
The Doctor is older than that.
GIT GUD CASUAL 😂
@@travisgames2The 9th doctor states in the empty child that he had ‘900 years of phonebox travel’ and the 10th doctor claims to be 904 years old in ‘the voyage of the damned’ & states he is 906 in ‘the end of time’, 11 starts at 907 (or so he claims in ‘flesh and stone’), his younger self claims to be 909 in ‘The Impossible Astronaut’, in the same episode his future self claims to be 1103, in ‘a town called mercy’, he says he is 1200, he spends 900 years in Trenzalore, stated in the short story ‘Tales of Trenzalore’ and regenerates into 12 at 2100 (but rounds down to 2000), he does stay in the confession dial for 4.5 billion years in ‘Heaven Sent’, but doesn’t count that in his age. After that it gets a little hard to keep track of in all honesty, they never give an exact age after 11, only basic numbers like 2000, however he does claim to be 1 billion years old in ‘The Giggle’.
It's genuinely incredible how much of a risk this episode was. So much hung an impied future story that hadn't even been written yet, and if it had ended up not landing there was NO wiggling out of it.
what risk? This was designed as a one off episode. They then wrote the other episodes to fit the narrative set up in this one when Moffat got creative control
Except it wasn't. @@Engiflux They preplanned damn near everything for this episode to work out. They even had her speak of how the doctor took her to see the singing towers, which they then referenced a few more times before we finally get to see the episode of Capaldi taking her to those towers.
When Steven Moffat wrote this episode, he knew he would be showrunner for next season(s). So at the very least everything season 5 and possibly 6 related for River Song would be a safe bet to introduce here. I think this was Moffat teasing the future for his time as showrunner and introduce a new character to the audience before making her more important during the next seasons.
she dies at the end. they could have never went back to this storyline and it would still have worked. Not that big of a risk.
@@matthiashavrez Except now we have a dead person who apparently knows the Doctors NAME. HIS ACTUAL TRUE NAME.
Which she whispers in his ear in THIS episode.
The same episode where she says that she knows him VERY well.
There was NO wriggling out of it. The name alone proves they have history.
And if it wasn't his name, then it was something else to make it clear to him that she DOES know him and he CAN trust her.
That's not something you can sweep under the rug. At least, not to people who actually watch every episode religiously. You know... Like all the people in England that gave it its cult following?
That beaming smile on his face when the TARDIS opens with a snap of his fingers.
yeah thats the part where 11 was born
It's so funny because they really set up the dynamic between the Doctor and River but still, Ten is not River's Doctor, not yet. The word "spoilers" doesn't sound right because it's not "their word" yet, but by him starting to say it now, they set up the joke for later. It's just little things like that, I think, that makes rewatches so much fun.
Every time I rewatch, I 'get' some new connection or twist or joke I didn't catch previously. That's what GREAT writing, acting and all around production gives us.
Who is her doctor?
It’s easy to forget how incredibly good this episode was. These shorts are SUCH a reminder.
Imagine being the tardis, and he just snaps his fingers. I imagine she's just going "damn thats actually kinda hot"
I love the fact that everything River Said here the Doctor ends up doing in the episode. Its great
I think that's what's so beautiful about it- all the stuff she remembers he does because he heard her saying he could. He didn't know you could open the tardis with a snap until she mentioned he does that later- and he only does it because she taught him he could
And armies turn and run away... no doubt by order of certain Colonel Runaway.😂
The greatest bootstrap paradox ever written
To be fair he only went to the library at the point it closed due to rivers message, so something something timey-wimey what ever lead to this loop
This isn't a Bootstrap Paradox. That's when an object has no origin point. Say you receive a lottery ticket that wins, only to discover you yourself sent you the ticket from the future. So you send that ticket that you still have back in time. That is a Paradox because nobody actually acquired the ticket originally. You can actually see the Doctor avoid this in the Big Bang episode. The Doctor sees he's the one who sent a letter to young Amelia because she's holding it. So instead of taking that very letter, he grabs a paper and writes on that, thus avoiding the paradox.
@@lukeroberson2115
I think the "finger snapping" thing is a bootstrap paradox.
If River hadn't told him about Future doctor being able to do it, he would have never tried it.
So who first told the doctor he could open the TARDIS that way?
@redreaper3065 Not necessarily. River seems intimately aware of how the TARDIS works.
@@redreaper3065idk what paradox this is but it’s a bit like Angels take manhattan, where because you read/say it therefore it has to happen no matter what
Tennant was brilliant that smile like hundreds of years old and still things he doesn't know yet lol
Talking to the dead without knowing they're already dead
“I’ve seen whole armies turn and run away with my doctor 😭”
Fair to say she definitely didn’t witness the Sycorax fiasco during the early 10th doctor’s era.
Think she was referencing the events of Demon's Run
@ I know
I was think Pandorica Opens fits there too.
Demon's run when a good man goes to war.
Ahhhhh...but even the Doctor didn't get a Dalek to beg for mercy at the mention of his name.
Another words she was looking for 12 and his massive eyebrows. The Nashta Verada would’ve run away from his glare.
Vashta Nerada
The attack eyebrows
Funny seeing as her Doctor is Matt Smith
@@winterwulf1995you should rewatch the episode with the singing towers...
Another words? You mean "in other words"?
"Nobody can open a TARDIS by snapping their fingers"
What a character introduction
It was such a gamble to introduce a character at the END of their story.
And it's one of my favorite stories from almost any show
I like to think that it always did that, and he just never tried it for 900 years.
Now we know what the meeting before this was and how she went on a whole thing of how loving the doctor is like loving the stars and how its folly to ask the sunset to admire you back. This is the first time she went in knowing how truly deep the doctor loved her
Only for her to "look into that man's eyes and" for him not to recognize her at all... 😭😭😭
The goofy smile. God I love David❤
This scene hits way different than when you watch it the first time
Last time she saw him: first time he saw her!
Now the TARDIS don't start til i walk in
honestly shouldve seen the connection between amy and river sooner. Their not quite finished yet speeches are identical.
like mom like daughter
What amy speech are you referring to?
"Spoilers"
This was such a missed opportunity, so when Smith regenerates to Capaldi is all good, but they should have made a spin-off of at least one season with the escapades of River and Matt traveling during her nights in prison, the chemistry between the two was really cool, could have seen that two doctor birthday celebration 😂
just a reminder that every single river episode was personally written by steven moffat himself! he had her entire story planned out since silence in the library!
The more I think about it, the more the theory of Eternalism applies to Doctor Who. Everything just is. Always has been, always will be. A 4th dimensional or higher being could see the full picture, but 3rd dimensional beings are forced to see little parts of it at a time
When I first watched this episode this scene did not affect me like it does now because once you realize exactly who river is and what she is to the doctor any scene with her will affect you if you have a heart
The moment the camera shows that suits darkness head: "oooooh shit...."
Darkened by Doctor's screwdriver. At the time, it's likely still Anita though piranhas have already attached.
Dr Who uses It's continuity to almost It's fullest. I have never seen a time travel story about lovers travelling in opposite directions to eachother's personal timelines
I do not recall the characters or performers, or the name of the drama, but I do believe there is at least one drama with a similar plot.
I absolutely LOATHE this part. This makes it feel like the TARDIS is SUPPOSED to be treated like a butler or a dog. It's pathetic. The TARDIS is fully sentient and no one wants to acknowledge that.
nice detail that it goes outwards, hearing Idris complain about how the doctor opens her doors made me look at that scene differently.
Oh god
She was 100% talking to a corpse there wasn't she?
I really like Clara Oswald as a character, but re-watching this scene remind me of the one where she's arguing with Matt Smith and snapping her fingers to close the TARDIS doors. It makes this scene a little bit less significant.
that's not 11, she does that with 12 when he has to go "'undercover'"
12: *snapping his fingers to open the doors* I'll see you when I see you"
clara: *snapping her fingers to close the doors* "and when will that be?"
11: *snapping his fingers to open the doors again* "when I see you"
also I'd like to disagree with you, idt clara's scene diminishes this one at all, it's the first time the dr tries it, and ofc it only works for the dr because she's his tardis, but clara's different from all the other companions because she became apart of all the dr's lives when she became the impossible girl, which means she also has a unique relationship with the tardis
@@tinkrebellewhile this may be true it's never clarified (clarafied lol). So in that instance it seems to come out of nowhere. While you may be correct and there is logic to what you said it's never actually addressed so there's no way an average viewer would see this. I would venture to guess that it was more likely just for a comedic gag than any actual lore reason. "The doctor can close the doors with his fingers, let's make a sit com scene of this with doctor and Clara." Or so thing similar
It was with Capaldi, and Clara was meant to act as a doctor herself...
@@TristonNightshade lol :P yeah you're most likely right, tho I'd argue the the relationship between clara and the tardis isn't just background stuff like it usually is for the other companions, they make a point of showing that the tardis doesn't like clara at first, that she's gotta win over her trust in a way, plus there's that whole minisode where the tardis messes with clara because she wants to, so idt it comes entirely out of nowhere, but tbf half the fan theories/ handcanons/ and whatnots come from moments that have secondary interpretations so it's possible I'm just reading into things 🤷
She did such an amazing job in tgis first episode. Really made you believe there was a relationship there.
Funnily enough this is a bootstrap paradox
The doctor only realizes he can Open the tardis Doors by snapping his fingers because River mentioned he could in the future but river only knew he could because she saw him do it in the future but he only knew he could do it in the future because he started doing it after this episode XD
The only time that actually happens. The doctor never actually snaps his fingers to open the door again. At least not onscreen
What do you mean? It's happened loads, especially over Moffat's run
Happens again just 9 episodes later in the eleventh hour 😂
🎓🎓🎓🎓
But who invented the snap to open the tardis idea? 🤔😄
The Tardis overheard River and was like "Wait that's actually really cool"
River wasn't wrong, the TARDIS does only open for the Doctor
But only if the TARDIS wishes to be opened, after all, she has the power to refuse
HOLY SHIT I JUST REALIZED RIVER IS TALKING about the Pandorica opening
can't remember Matt Smith's doctor open the TARDIS doors with a finger snap.
Literally in his first episode
So stupid but 10 snapping his fingers always makes me cry.
the fact that river recently met capaldi and they bid each other the final goodbyee and now river knows this is the day she will die and then shee meets the very first docter wrt the docters timeline
To think that at this point in time, the show was so great. Everything that Doctor Who is about was being produced perfectly. To think what they did to it at this point makes me very upset.
This is a good episode
ah shes refering to captain runaway
Colonel run away.
@@matthewricker5526 he got demoted :3
This makes me sad... I like 10. But. 11 is cool. Mad respect. 12 took time but grew on me. As for 13. I will watch the box set. But I'm just waiting for the box set to see 10 again and this "new kid" from a Netflix series from the UK. Sex Education is where i first saw him act for a few series. I like his attitude. 13.. i never heard good things OFF set wise. And no. The Doctor could have been any woman. Just not her.
What's the name of this show?
Doctor Who
@CopperAxe_ thanks
Wat is this film/serie called
The Tardis exists in all space and time so this works.
Was she waiting for Capaldi?
No, I think she was describing Smith, remember he was always the good man who went to war and made armies run, also I remember he was always snapping his fingers around so it sounds more like him
@@humbertocastro9086No, the good man was Rory...
Hmm. I'm wondering if she's talking about Eleven or Twelve.
Probably both.
😢😢😢😭😭😭
Hadn't noticed before, but she says she's seen while armies run away.
And what did they do at Demons Run? They ran away.
I find it funny when he gets the chance to talk to the TARDIS, she complains about him pushing the doors instead of pulling, yet she opens them inwards when she snaps
was that the vasta nerada bloody hell just figured that out 😮
At the time it was likely still Anita, with her visor darkened by Doctor's screwdriver (but with vashta nerada already attached to her feet). It took Doctor's boast later, not River's words, to look him up.
@ no no the door when he clicks his fingers they not he or the tardis move the door from that point on its them 🤔
His firsts are her lasts his futures her past
Is she talking bout 11th or 12th? Or did she go even further than that?
Was she talking about his 11 or his 12 intonations
Clara can too lol
Causality loop
12th and 11th
Well she did say he doctor was not done cooking sooo…
Col Runaway
Tbh I kinda wish they did an episode with 13 and river. i don’t know how they would have done it, but it would have been interesting for River’s reaction
Edit And 14, Seeing the face that was at the library. The one that saved her
The tardis definitely heard river and Probably Some Weird Time Space Shenanigans She probably also Knows river