ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 ก.ค. 2019
- In this exclusive interview with The Quint's Nishtha Gautam, former union minister Yashwant Sinha discusses the journey of his life. His autobiography titled 'Relentless' was released recently.
"Great people don't carry bitterness with them" This is what i want to take away from this interview.
Oh, the irony! 😅
When I look at so many trolls in comment and see the high percentage of likes, I understand that wise people prefer to be silent, others just become trolls.
Are you assuming you are a wise one. Don't flatter yourself.
"I understand that wise people prefer to be silent", Question arises then why you chose to speak ?
Preach, fellow countryperson. Make this a tweet, it'll be super successful.
@@sanjayjoshi2828 tu Bhai Gujarati hai. Chorh Tere Matlab ki baat nhin hai
@@harir6316 tuu toh Modi ka Chutiya haim tuu mat soch itnaa dimaag mat lagaah.
Tere pass hai nhin
The interviewer was rightly neutral and seeking an opinion without giving out her own opinion.
Kudos! It's very rare to find interviewer today to be clean of any opinion and just be a seeker of perspective from the eyes of the interviewee.
Neutral lol, do you find any interview which uses words like bhakts and showing pictures of hitler to Modi. He is our PM atleast give respect to that, did they mention the positive impact on India by Modi nope, it is a clear one sided interview. It's 2019, no one cares about media when we have social media. Media is not at all required.
"Bhakts" 😂😂😂🤣 so just now i realized that the term "Bhakts" is unofficially official.
So is slave of Gandhi or gaandu family party.
Reddy from Andra drought
@cmtvsxyz They are also called Pappu ghulams 😂😂🤣
The Law of diminishing courtesy: Courtesy is directly proportional to the level of the discussion. BEAUTIFUL!
Thank you sir you said the truth.......very informative talk ...
If any opposition leaders raise their voice against BJP, they will targeted and put in jail so that others won’t raise their voice. It is the most dangerous situation. Amith Shah does this vendetta politics thinking that he has out right support of RSS. But I believe RSS don’t like this.
Proud Indian this is very sad, and I admire brave people like Yashwant Sinha who seem to live after ethical rules and who are standing in for such.
Which opposition leader has been put in just like that? The corrupt are being summoned by courts and after examining the charge sheet and hearing all parties, they may be sentenced to jail for their corrupt deeds. What is wrong with that? Isn't that's what happens in a democracy when a common citizen or a high and mighty are treated equally? Isn't the welfare of the nation of paramount importance?
do not bark like a street dog, liars like you are a disgrace on the society,
give exact examples, in comparison just see arnab asking a question and
how congress is harassing them, 10's examples you will find in congress rule
weak opposition.. is an issue in a democracy.
it's time for better party than Congress which lacks able leadership.
"...people also get the opposition they deserve", absolutely.
What a great intelligent interview.
BJP of Vajpayee era and Modi era has changed a lot in terms of factors like- Vajpayee govt: modesty, decency, ethical, more democratic, space for civil society, preserving of democratic institutions, absence of political vendetta, etc.
Modi Govt.: Lack of democratic spaces, near absence of civil society, autocratic , high on political vendetta, centralised govt., Manipulated governance, brutal removal of opposition....etc.
I think that why vajapayee ji can't repeat his term as a pm again
@@rishabhvarshney6396 A lot more factors goes into winning a election. In today's context more factors are:
1. Role played by social media
2. Politics of defections, manipulation, brand value creation and marketing.
3. Declining regional politics
4. State of economy: major factor. Vajpayee govt battling with high inflation and Modi Govt was provided much stable economic platform by UPA and again economic factors continued to be relatively stable in 2019.
5. Global factors
6. India's rising cult
7. Not to forget : very weak opposition.
@@Dev_G07 you forgot to add Vajpayee being dead😂.
The questions were sharp yet delivered with grace, to illicit the frame of mind of the target. Precise and planned .keep it up for the truth
What an interview...words were more sharp then blades...
Thanks a lot. :)
As a parlimentarian from Hazaribagh what's his contribution to the people who elected twice or thrice?
Zero contribution
@Ajay Phadkem m
🔔
mujhe laga tha ke public congress ke contribution ko bhul gayi he......lekin me dekh raha hu ke janta bjp ke contribution ko bhul gai..... means public is totally out of there mined
yashwant sinha wohi hai jisne vajpeyi ki sadak yojna ka dharatal per utara tha..... aur ye desh ke vikas me milestone tha................
aur ye wohi yashwant sinha jisne sabse pehle modi ka naam as a prime minister candidate declare karne ko kaha tha.... aaj yashwant sinha isi galti ki saza bhugat raha hai.... bhakto se galiya sunkar....
What Mr. Sinha is saying, is absolutely real fact of today's Indian politics.
Some united efforts are necessary to oppose these wrong policies.
i don't know the moment reporter start speaking..i just thought its a 90s interview.....so happpy to see someone.. Who is her ownself..fantastic fantanstic!!!! great respect mam...loved every aspect of yours..be it confidance in yours eyes or questioniong way..superb
Same feelings here bro.
I request Mr Sinha to take the roll ofJP to crub this type euphoria if he thinks democracy is in danger.
This guy has realised his limitations too late in life !
Good job host! intelligent questions. True the quality of life we live determines the character of politics.
SENIOR POLITICAL LEADER PROVED HE IS MORE INTELLIGENT EXCELLENT DEBATE THANKS TO RESPECTED YASHWANTH SINHA SIR AND THE Q TV .JAIHIND
Very few honest ppl left in Indian politics today
Gosh! I saw a Journalist here... Thought they are an extinct species now...! Btw, she did a brilliant job..
@Suman Kundu Absolutely. I can very well understand that the worse that was predicted has not come true...Look around us, we are still here! I mean...why should it be a big deal for Realists that the People are getting lynched, Economy is collapsing, Joblessness is on rise...how does it even matter as long as AK asks most pertinent questions about Mangoes! We are a nation of tough leaders after all...
@Suman Kundu few things: Lynching is not a Myth - It's a reality. Journalism - I am sure you must have figured this out already that We don't have Journalists anymore...we have Noise makers on both side of Aisles. The loudest voice is on the Right and it's full of Lies...I am sure you believe large part of it. Thirdly, whataboutism doesn't work...Nehru died more than 54 years back...How long do you want to blame him? Mixed economy model that India adopted was the need of 1947, did anyone expect a country to fully embrace capitalism and Globalisation soon after coming out of an Imperialist Invasion that the country faced. I am glad, you accepted the point on Joblessness..but again, adding additional dimensions (which can't be measured) to justify the current situation doesn't help. Does it? Also, this isn't really about being smart and stuff...This is just a civil dialogue between two people and I am glad we are able to conduct it with utmost sanctity.
The questions asked are unbiased and straight.
Answers justified as well.
Thank you.
Very different interview, reporter is not asking, what way you are eating mangos,and from where your energies are coming,
Loved watching this conversation
'Silence of graveyard' the ultimate truth,manipulation won over truthfulness.
This is what is happening to our country. The uneducated politicians are removing educated politicians from politics.
What is an educated politician. A person who is so far removed from the pulse of their own people and still cannot come to terms with the defeat they have faced and are in denial.
Real education lies in recognising our immediate surroundings and people who are our own. Especially in a country like India, where there is a huge disparity in thought between people living in the city and the remote villages. Where all of us unify is the common threads that bind us through culture and familiarity of people which is a direct reflection of the collective consciousness of being Indian. The soul of our country lies in the villages. If we gave that a chance to get stronger, I don't see anything wrong with it.
Also, frankly the education in our country has been sub-standard for a long time. It needs an overhaul.
Honest and correct analysis of the current situation.We are passing through a very painful and scary situation.
feeling hopeless to find this kind of personalities are not utilised for bringing up the country to reach the great heights.
What an interview! A very few people are realising the actuality! Glad to hear
This man has to come at the forefront.
Share karna bhai video ko ... Share kar .
1
Though this interview was conducted 4 years ago, the answers given by Yashwanth Sinha to the questions raised, are relevant. He was candid about himself, his party, and about the way the political dispensation from 2014 has been making use of communication media, and controlong the minds of the people of this country, which is not at all good for Indian Democracy.
I feel that this interview give an understanding about the quality of the maturity of the mind and experience of Yasvanth Sinha, as a family member, IAS Officer, as well as a politician. It throws light on why he followed a path of dissent within the party, yet he continued his interactions, quality relationship with part workers, while maitaining distance from the high level party leaders.
He comes across as a great gentle man.
👌👌👌
Mr Sinha is a great leader and sensible. He has guts to speak against Modiji.
There was a time when we didn't need guts to speak out against a leader's errors. The lack of freedom to do that is one of the things that's destroying democracy and freedom in India today.
This person says his guru was Chandrashekar who had no bitterness for IG even though he was prisoned by her but soon after we was not given the ministership in 2014 he started his rant right then till date.. so much of hate redness.
I don't sense hatred in his voice. He is staying out what he thinks is right.
He gave you the answer about your stereotypes in the video. Hope you watched carefully.
Thank You 🙏 God Bless this Political personality Yashwant Sinha a Realist in touch with Reality.
Great interview, fan of the channel, I agree with some of the points made by Yashwant-ji. The main problem is Indias Congress is out of its depth with am inept leader, and does not have any ideas left.
Great questions to churn out the best about him and the book. Kudos Ms Journalist.
During ur fm tenure onion price was all time high more rs 100 due remember that???
But he was from bjp, modi promised petrol to be at 50 rupees?? Comparing crude price during Congress was 7000 and today is 4200, kya hua tera vada ???
It is now 200😂😂
Before Modi government, India Inc. said "Policy Paralysis". During Modi Government, India Inc. got "Paralysed Policy"
What did you do when Advani Euphoria was happening , you didn’t remember Hitler during Ayodhya rath yatra...yaar you enjoyed your opportunities and now you being a cry baby . What’s wrong in me saying what I said ?
Abe bhakt
He had hope that bajpeyi very senior does not think that way, the hope for yashwant and other true bjp leaders was Bajpeyi ideology not Advani ideology, at current situation, there is no different ideology between members of BJP,
1. Manipulation or management of the media and thus influencing the sentiments of the electorate is a standard operating strategy of all political parties. Indira Gandhi too has done this for 4 decades!!!! What's new that Yashwant Sinha is saying here ???
2. What is the purpose of his saying "not enough is being done for minorities" ??? does he mean to endorse the Congress party's tradition of pandering/appeasing minorities & compromising/ignoring/neglecting/exploiting the majority ???
3. What prevented him from talking about what were the disagreements that led to his seperation from the BJP ??? It would certainly have been a revelation to the people
1. It was done during emergency and that's why there was so much protest at that time because that was WRONG. Leaders of BJP themselves opposed it.
2. To do enough you have make them feel safe. How would you feel if there is always a risk of getting lynched in false accusations when you are going out of town in night.
3. He told a lot reasons like the way party was operating and the discipline of the workers. If you want more you can actually read the book it should have some other things.
Speaking of Majorities during Congress when were they neglected or exploited can you give me an example.
By saying these things don't consider me a Congress lover as I also voted for Modi but it does not mean that I have to keep a blind eye on everything. People have the right to select a leader and also a right to protest when they don't work in the way which is acceptable to everyone.
@@mitbomb 3. The congress conveniently retained most of the governance policy's and laws of the British . Eg the donations at temples are considered as the government income and used for promotion of places of worship of other communities. Funds are not returned to the temples where donations are made. Nehru provided special subsidies to Muslims to travel on Haj to Mecca/Madina from the donations made by devotees at hindu temples. The supreme court order that interferes with the centuries old sacred customs of the Sabarimala temple in Kerala in favour of Leftists and Christian missionaries who are mere divisive activists and not devotees of the presiding deity of the concerned temple.
Indira Gandhi modified the constitution of India at the instance of leftist parties to add words such as "secular and socialist" during the emergency of 1975.
The history of India was altered to play down the barbaric atrocities inflicted by muslims towards other religious belief. Eg. You may read the book "Tipu Sultan the tyrant of Mysore by Sandeep BalaKrishna for a factual account.
@@zeaybaanoorie528 The facts that congress was wrong, doesn't make BJP right. BJP successfully fueling the communal hatred today. The mad power control, hiding and manipulating data, they stopped door to door surveys in India ( if you don't collect data, you don't have to show it right?), this is not the governance we asked for. I think an open dustbin is better than a closed land mine.
@@zeaybaanoorie528 What do you want? governance should be done on religion instead of constitution? in shabrimala incidence, the court ordered the same thing any democratic, secularist country would have made. Country comes before religion. Our constitution gives freedom of movement. if you want court to woo hindus or consider rules of hinduism as a law, there is no difference between you and a Muslim Mullah who wants Shariya law in this country. Thats what BJP does. they emotionally manipulate us to make us believe in these kinds of communal things. Thats not acceptable at all.
@Rashmi T sure it's not about being apologetic or justifying the bjp. Under the circumstances, it's about who has a better or worse proven record of inflicting more self damage than the other. The Congress and it's allies have set the benchmark with 60 years of power. It's time for another player to do better or worse or change the game & the playing field if needed
Brilliant man...!!! Hope the book is read by many youth of India.
They can manipulate main stream media but they cant do it with socialmedia n youth knows wats good 4 country
Abhi Roy really!!!!!!!
And youth knows what is good for the country wow
@Nitish Kumar haha.... You too
No we don't. Lol
@akshay Viswambharan yes there will be no Congress or any other party when EVM IS HACKED by BJP . Majorty of the people did not vote for them. Only andh bakhts like and majority with EVM . You BJP it cell th-cam.com/video/n6oRlkfc6KU/w-d-xo.html
@akshay Viswambharan Millions of Indians agree with you including ME. Now see www.thereligionofpeace.com
You are a great person with lot of guts.
This old man is so smart , n so true, respect u sir, u shud b our prime minister, plsss sir do something about this country , save our country
Indians surely will regret for having elected Modi as PM.. with in a short time
funny but true their r 2 types of people who fear modi and think his government is not tolerent ..frist is terrorists another is the opposition... And wait amir khan and naserudin.. 😂 😂 😂
@@arvindbaval7556 Time is the best judge.
@@lyrawrench7882 not only me but all the Indian people came out to vote for modi r so 😂 😂 😂 😂 that's why now Rahul ran away to mommy when his party was defited badly
@Sunanda P u know sunsnda was killed by sashi taroor... Be careful of congress men
Love you sir👍
Very good communication b/w both of them
Bro i am not talking about any political party and not against any of them
"Great people don't carry bitterness " Great.
Well said..👌👍
Mr Sinha talks about petrol and diesel prices. Those are old methods. Today
Very nice interview.. How a interview should be.. Nice reporter asking questions with impartiality and sense.. Something many mainstream news channel lack...
We need to listen to everyone and their experiences. One gets to know a lot.
This fellow is showing his frustration and nothing else.
Great speech sir. More leaders should come forward and speak the truth about the fakes.
Great people wont carry bitterness..what this gentleman doing
A nice conversation. Thanks.
Yashwant Sinha has lost it...
Poor guy. He has dig his own grave
yess . u r right sir . i used to be of openion we need dictator for this country like modi.but unfortunately i was wrong
I felt the same way. Have regrets now.
I was always for democracy and against dictatorship.
@- king- democracy means Vajpayee
@- king- democracy means right to ask questions now a days can u see people asking questions
If am not wrong Me. yeshwanth Sinha was finance minister in NDA headed by Atalaji, let him to explain why he abolished BSRB reasons are best known to the former minister.
Criticising the government is not bad.People has the right to do it.But your intention must be known by the people before they laud you.
What happened with Rafale case you were fighting... plz share some light on it too...
Santosh Nadagowda 😂😂😂😂 What rubbish ?? He just wanted cheap publicity which he got ! He doesn't care about any case .
Santosh nadagowda case proceedings is in court,
reshma varma the way they were doing press conference and all earlier ... are not visible now a days... even we don’t hear anything regarding court too..
Chandragupt bhai aapka matlab nahi samaja? R u saying those case and all are just gimmick to influence election against BJp ?
@@santoshnadagowda95 As there are many cases in court ,there is court proceedings going on but donno when is the next proceedings
Great man from one of the great PM Atal ji 'S cabinet
Jaswant-Babu, you r envious of Mr. Mod's success, no doubt about it..............
Envious of how he destroyed Indian economy 😪🤣
He is qualified and person of IAS cadre at least in his time as FM the economy was not in such shape
This government scares you becoz, none of the government has taken action like this government
Action is so hard, Giant Automobile sector of a country has been bought to its knees
@@adityabhansali7355 just merging banks like idiot
Because it's a dictatorship playing highly divisive politics. Wake up before its too late.
Case of sour grapes...Did this fellow resign from the party when Vajpayee didn't take action against Modi in 2002? This guys doesn't have Advani and MMJs grace and loyalty for the party
When you can't able to put things right in your term you start blaming others. You can't blame Modi. he is a one of the best PM that India ever had be it a international politics or Indian politics.he will be our prime Minister forever.....
Thank you Quint for interview
Sabka......
We are searching for all that in andhra pradesh,
We had it before
The lady interviewer is refreshing new journalist in the world of Bharkas and Sagarikas of the world . She looked intelligent and asked pertinent questions -- All the best
In the world of Anjana on modi and shweta singh.
mr sinha said the real facts
He spoke the truth...facts change.
Yashwant ji, what you said in this video is right and one day every one will accept your words for sure, well said
I have faith in my people , and at the same time you say that our minds are being manipulated , sinha saab we have our own mind and we know how to choose
Does he remember, as Finance Minister, how much amount he was demanding from the persons to appoint them as Chairman of nationalized banks ? Did he not manipulate the data to suit for him as finance minister?
That's what he is saying 'no other govt' did such huge manipulation of data, he is not denying manipulation done previously!
8
9
This is the first time I have seen this gentleman or heard about him . Amazing, that he is an ex BJ P walla but a true blue blooded politician. He has most definitely humanity and class.Respect to him.
Admire your approach and truthfulness.
What a pronunciation and accent along with such splendid presentation of facts in a cogent manner. IAS of the yester years were indeed the blue chip of the Nation.
Thoroughly enjoyed this interview especially for the candid responses!
I dont believe that the negative trends he has been trying to highlight is as grave as it is pictured. But as a senior and very respected pro he definitely deserved better heed by politicians as well as people. May there be more of his tribes of various denominations guide our land to a more fruitful democracy. If we outright reject the views of such visionaries it might only be at our own peril! Long live the country! Vande matharam!
Your comment gives me hope for our country. Wish there are more people like you who can be civil and respectful of opposing views.
As a person of a minority community from a small state with very little progress and attention from the central government, I disagree.
What wisdom and it applies to every govt. all over the globe.The hype of mediocrity is amazing and even more surprising is how everyone falls for it.Good analysis.
A man who fears arguing is a man who fears his fundamentals
Interviewer did a very good job. As for Sinha, his is a case of sour grapes. That's it.
Muck Fodi. Bjpee supporters r&ve hai.
Yanchinambe shettre mudi na bulli jumbvana 😅
Yashwant Sinha speaks correctly. We must hear him where our country is going. Really worried.
Every point is so true
Betrayed bitterness of a loser, who had no qualms to fall on Sonia's feet for a seat .....
The interviewer has done a fabulous job...
I m watching you with interests !!
May God bless you 😇
Popularity Does not come with Eloquence but with commitment to public life. Modi served 3 terms as CM and One term as PM.
How Dusta Chatustayam in Maha Bharat played Roles to Harm Pandavas given the Boomerang effect to their self Grave is now again repeated to such Crooks
Hey, just curious to know the details of "Dusta Chatustayam". Who are the four people that refers to ?
A lot of ppl resign IAS and join politics today also, doesn't mean,that they r all good
Not given post this dog is shouting This shows Modi is right by keeping him arms length
My sympathies are with you sir!
Mr Sinha is what we can say typical Indian politicians who can adjust his convictions according to the situation.Modi on the other hand is something much different who believes in his convictions and attempts to change the situation to his convictions.This is what which makes him to see Modi as some one alien.But most of the Indians want a politician like Modi and not Sinha Digvijay singh Gandhi Mulayam or Lalu.
Hahaha now he is afraid of euphoria.. Public sab janti hai.. U had ur chance, Your time is gone.. Make peace with that fact.
Never drop this attitude man....
Any news in quint about modi , I just read the headline , no need to read the rest as it will be a criticism. Great , it saves time.
I salute you sir for your courage and conviction
I am quite excited and happy to see Yashwant Sir, perhaps for the first time since the elction resukts were out. I actually wanted to see his reaction to the election result, the mandate thar PM Modi jiand BGJ have got. I was desperate to see Yashwant ji's cry as he used to do before and during the election process. Well, I didnt see his cry of election result but anyhow, its good to see it finally! This man is dejected, defeated, paranoid, and acts like like a drowning person trying clutxh on a straw. Stull lying and trying propagate and mislead people. Thats pity. Jai Bharat! Jai Shri Ram! Jai Hind! Bharat Mata Ki Jai !
One upright man with spine to say truth like it is.
Sir I agree with you
Hats off to you
Quite thoughtful, Mr. Sinha. It's a valid criticism that euphoria is not good. But the opposition has to offer a credible and valid vision for India. It's not enough just to criticize Mr. Modi.