Tata Punch vs Rivals | Episode 3 | Punch vs Kia Sonet | Comparison Review | PowerDrift
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- In episode 3 of Tata Punch vs rivals, we pit it against the Kia Sonet - a car that's Rs 6 lakh more expensive. But hey, we wanted to see if the Punch can punch above its weight! So Cyrus Dhabhar and Ameya Dandekar took out both the cars to figure out what's what.
#PowerDrift
Join the 2 Million strong #PDArmy : bit.ly/PDARMY
Stay updated with News, Behind the Scenes here : / powerdrift
Find us on Facebook: / powerdriftofficial
Follow us on Twitter for Launch updates & more : / powerdrift
Hey #PDArmy, what's your pick between the two? Tell us in the comments and give the video a thumbs up if you want us to make more videos like this!
Guys..... seriously?😑 Is the ride quality and the plain looking interior so impressive for 10L that it had to be compared with something like a top variant sonet of 16L? And are you guys seriously suggesting the punch is the best value for money sub 4m suv in the persence of literally 15-16 sub 4m suvs (mid variant nexon included)which cost less? Otherwise this is a waste of 12mins
I WILL PICK SONET
For ride quality and safety Punch is still holding up.
A
Lo
Editor please dude check the background music levels, when they speak the sound is less so i increase the volume and then immediately when they stop music at full blast i have to lower volume again.. please lower the music volume next time it happens in almost every video.
Crct
True!
True that
Typical PD video, I've noticed this for a year now! 😅 It's irritating
they just keep doing it
Alternate title - "Amey justifying his sonet purchase"! 🤣
😂😂😂
Sahi bola
Thanks a ton for making this series as I have landed on Tata Punch as my first car.
Hi! Can you please tone down music in videos tad bit as if it were playing in the background as it makes it difficult to hear.
7:25 OCD triggered hard bro.... That window seal 💀💀💀
I just noticed. It's hideous
Punch❤️
answer for kia guy is xuv 300
I would buy a Punch EV in a heartbeat 💓
Tata.. please make one soon. The second I saw this car.. I wanted an EV.
Next punch vs seltos
I would never give more than 8-9lakh for a micro suv.clearly sonet makes sense at 11-13 lakh budget and above 14L-15+ creta or seltos or kushaq are winner
I am half way through the video and sorry to say but I have to switch to some other videos because of your loud music!
Really and eagerly waiting for Punch EV to lauch ASAP
Seiko 5 spotted. Cyrus planning a watch review channel with the same zest?
Dude, lose that background track pls
Kia offers
MT
iMT
DCT
Diesal+torque converter
1.2
1l turbo
Diesal
"I'm a widebody" had me rolling🤣
At First time I heard "wide ball" 🙃😃😃😃😃
Bring magnite in to this series
3 mintues in video and you guys talked more non sense then any sensible information, which is :| since it should be a direct comparison btw base or medium variants of punch with base of seltos, both under 8.5L onroad
Good review V sauce 🤣🤣
Punch if gives a punch to Kia , Kia will be best suit for scraping
Also do venue vs punch
Nexon XMS/XM vs Top variant of Punch????...
We all know XMS will beat punch in value!
Please 🙏 CARDEKHO team...make a unbiased review!!
I was considering SONET & NEXON before PUNCH launched. I get around ₹1 Lakh off on SONET in my area but still went for PUNCH. Here's why,
1. Automatic was compulsory for me (for family members, & automatic just makes life a lot easier) - SONET's options are way pricier than PUNCH's.
2. I liked both the exterior designs & was fine with either. Interior was also good in both & PUNCH actually felt a little better.
3. Safety was an important consideration. People drove cars without airbags too, but times are changing.
4. SONET has lesser engine noise. PUNCH has better ride quality and bearable engine noise.
[5]. SONET definitely has the better ENGINE. I'm an enthusiastic driver and definitely not a light footed one, and clearly felt the difference.
But, the roads, traffic, speed limits, ridiculous fines, senseless drivers on roads, rocketing petrol rates ( + mileage concerns) and all other stuff has got me pretty PISSED OFF lately. After my test drive, I realized that I would hardly feel the PUNCH's performance lacking in most scenarios.
Speed limits are ridiculously low, at 40 Kmph, in city. I see 60 Kmph limits throughout locations on NATIONAL HIGHWAYS and they start fining at 80 Kmph sometimes. All kinds of stupid rules are in place to CHOKE anyone who questions. How the hell am I supposed to enjoy my car? A couple of thousands of FINE a few times would kill a common man's spirit.
@@nobodyt9959 for 40-50kmhr speed limit, safety isn't an issue, so in every sense Sonet would have been a better buy plus its IMT is much better option compared to AMT.
I was considering to buy fortuner. As punch seems to be VFM went for it leaving pricey fortuner. 😂😂😂
Will there be a Kia Sonet ev?
How about comparing this car with MG Astor ?
Sonet's seat doesn't seem to accommodate Cyrus like Punch. What Punch needs is the turbocharged version of the same engine and that too under 10L and then for its size, it becomes the perfect car. It's a rip off right now in its current version. I am sure it has fat margins.
Calling Sonet value for money because it's cheaper than the Seltos is the dumbest thing I've heard.
BGM is just too much.
A segment like which car the hosts at PD own would be great to watch 😍
Honda WRV is I think super in 10 lakh range
Which wrv gives at 10L on road ,pls tell
punch in VFM proposition hands down .
Bullshit. Comparing a B2 segment, desel top end car Price to a small raised Hatch back and calling the former over priced. Alag hi chutiyapa.
Do you know, with all those crappy tech, shit touchscreen and unreliable electronics, Nexon top end cost over 16 Lakh as well.
That means, Nexon also don't make sense right, everyone should get Punch.
Slow claps ... Good Job in earning money through misleading common people.
Soon they will be comparing the punch to the GLS and still have the face to say the punch has the upper hand... Powerdrift has let us all down
You forgot the magnite. Best sub -10 lakh CSUV
Punch is absolutely no comparison to the Magnite, that's why. It has better engines, a better automatic transmission, it's priced similarly and has more or less the same features. You can't say stuff like, "The punch is worse, but it's cheaper". Even compared to the Ignis, the punch falls short. It's not as good a car as the media is making it seem.
Magnite is gonna breakdown after 10km on the road. And the only thing going on for the ignis is better engine. But the ignis is a smaller car
@@DeadPool-qp7te makes sense
@@spamansh1710 Are you really bringing up reliability of Tata cars? And are you saying that the engine doesn't matter for a car? The punch has the most painfully slow drivetrain in its class. It is not even as much of a good value as people are making it out to be. You don't get any of the nice features in the punch if you don't get the top end varients, which takes the price higher than the altroz. Even a tiago makes more sense than a punch. Get the NA petrol altroz, even that is much better value than the punch. The punch hype is a media created thing, and people shouldn't fall for it.
@@DeadPool-qp7te Your views are as dead as your username
Next episode: Tata punch vs Toyota Fortuner
Verdict: Tata Punch wins.
Sonet is much more premium looking than punch.......punch rear look is like Kwid 🤣
Lol. Sonet is a joke. It sells because of the better AT.
Next up ? Punch Vs Fortuner. Come on powerdrift, you are better than this.
And then people in the comments will say , Punch is better.😂
If your budget is 10 lakhs, mid variants of upper segment cars may be better value than top variant of punch.
nexon XM is most VFM car under 10 lakh for me
@@shubham_goyal engine is dump
@@jiffinjose7541 yeah better than punch
@@jiffinjose7541 Seems like you haven't driven the Nexon Petrol. It's not too bad. It makes good power, has a good midrange and can give good FE in the highways.
But the city economy will be low and it's pretty lackluster really down like under 1700 rpms.
@@nnlniclb my family has 2 nexon petrol automatics. They have brought it fo the safety it offer's. But now both of them are trying to sell the car and move to another brand. The service is pathetic. Gear box got plenty of complaints, complaints are coming like one by one.
TATA has made many wrong decisions with Punch especially when paying 10 lakhs plus for a car, I would definitely expect a driver armrest and rear ac vents and the worst part is door locking system of TATA. They should provide the two step door unlocking system instead of that single door lever which is very risky when children are in the car.
For that you have to buy altroz
You can have a 3rd party arm rest installed. That is not a big deal. Rear vent ac for two rows you never need as punch air conditioning even at 1 chills down the cabinet. Else look for altroz
Punch vs S Class next. Merc S Class is very good but very expensive. You can buy 30 Punches for 1 S Class. So, Punch is much better and value for money 😅
🤣🤣🤣
Oh fish, wat? Crazy comparo @dayanandlisam
More than 95 % of Indians if that have money they will but only foreign cars. Even if they see some good Indian cars in lesser price also they will not buy because Indian think foreign cars are more value.
PowerDrift editing team, music is unnecessary, and distracts from the conversation.
Nexon should be compared with Sonet, better crash safety than this. PD keeps disappointing with not so sensible videos.
What a waste !!
Only to promote Punch
What put a S presso even more value for money
U r spoiling ur own image
Guys every 1 knows the difference
Next time try Dzire to City 🤮
Tata is best rough tough car
Its a pricey wierd car.... don't justify any segment.....price is on lower side of compact suvs but looks like a boxy hatchback
At 10 lakhs price, altroz xz plus iturbo is a sensible choice...no car can match this bad boy in a combine safety+performance+design.
I own it😘
"Kia has more engine options for this price" - Are you serious Ameya??? 😂For this price we have many and more Compact SUVs to consider in the market
Other than venue who offers this much variety
Can you name 3 of them?
Yes, Kia has most engine options, I don't see anyone offering a proper diesel auto in this segment
Can you name those cars?
Comparing apple with oranges ..Kia sonet can be compared to Nexon but not tata punch ..Punch is good but not in sonet category ..Upper variants of sonet offers luxury of high end cars ..Punch is good for people who dont have budget for SUV/cross but still get some feeling
would be nice to know what cars Rohan or the other people at PD own and their "justification". will make for a nice video
He drives the Evo
@@AayKay47 l
Cyrus has a Padmini and a Thar I think 🤔
Lower down the music , when they are discussing things. God. Cant even hear properly, mainly because of the music.
At the end of the day Tata Punch rocks. 6.5 L ex showroom and GNCAP 5 star at that price. So total value for money for Indians
No doubt in that👍 Punch is the best
Punch sucks swift way better performance and grand i10 too.
@@varuntomer1725 depends if u like tin box over hard steel
Background music tad bit high.
Sonet - reaches 100, where's punch?
punch - ooh paaji I give up
😂😂😂😂
What about safety???? Punch wins!!!
Is it even a fair comparison between compact suv(sonet) vs micro suv(punch), Matlab content k liye kuch v karega. Seriously?
Background music quite distracting....
I was expecting Nissan Magnite
Sonet bcoz of at transmission
Mg Astor manual could be a contender, right?
Credits to talking cars, if you saw the video.
This was the exact video i needed... thanks Powerdrift to make this car buying confusion a lot easier.
Both the cars ...Tata Punch and Kia sonet are benchmarks in their own segments and choosing anyone of them was big dilemma altogether..... Honestly this has helped.
Which one did you buy finally?
⚠️⚠️ VERY HIGH BACKGROUND MUSIC VOLUME LEVEL. 🔕 👎
Punch's engine is below par and mediocre.. I own tiago... 3-cylinder petrol engine natural aspirated on tiago, tigor, punch and altroz is below par
Tata punch......👊👊👊
sonet for the win
I had actually considered both of these cars as my first car back in Dec, 2021 as I had a budget of around 12 lacs. I test drove both of them.
Back seat space, ride quality and the crash test rating of tata punch were the main driving factor for favouring tata punch amt over Kia sonet turbo petrol IMT. I proudly own Tata Punch now and even I drive over speed breakers at higher than normal speeds to impress the nay sayers about the punch's suspension setup and ride quality.
Yes, the 1.2 lt NA petrol engine of tata punch won't make you grin with joy, but for day to day driving it won't bother you either.
Good to see my reasons being conformed by reviewers as well.
So you saying its not underpower right ?
@@ravicholachagudda5912 if you race on streets then you will feel it, if not then you won't.
@@ravicholachagudda5912 yep i have the punch as well, it aint that peppy but good for nice drive through the city or the highway. And the suspension is amazing at the pricepoint!
@@viswanath4473 thanks brother
@@5_FACTS_QUCK thanks for your responds
The Nexon is costly for a sub compact SUV and the Punch is too, being a segment below.. For 10L rupees, the Magnite Turbo CVT gives excellent vfm..
The build quality of magnite and suspension are inferior to Punch. Yes punch is underpowered but it's better suited for indian roads.. Punch feels like it will take some beatings.
Punch is a better city car.
Punch is more value for money,
Punch has scored most in Global NCAP, almost equal to XUV700
Punch has the best suspension
@@rahulgandigudi build quality tiago is average rattling of dashboard panels and near glove box.. Rusting on front disc brake
No comparo btwn sonet and punch
Tata punch 👊
I am the proud owner of punch.
There is no comparison at all. Punch is a class lower category class.
Tata punch is the Winner.....Tata always Top....💥💥💥
Punch anyday...
Tata Punch punches above it's weight,
Ride quality is superb ,I had driven my friends new Punch two months back.
Now see the monthly sales,it reached 10,000 units.
Sales would touch 15000 units if Tata launches iturbo and iCNG versions.
In video it's not clear need to clear that sonet is way bigger on paper 📜📜📜 in comparo with the punche
We want Tata Punch vs Siblings
Altroz, Nexon, Tiago NRG
The most lovely car is Punch. If Tata installs turbo engine and 4 cylinders then it will cost more than Sonet. Then again these people will compare it and says Punch is costly.
So you know the cost of a good engine. 🤷🏻♂️ This is why Punch seems vfm as it has an engine of 5lkh car
Punch - A perfect car for first time buyer who are tight on budget.
Sonet - People who need a upgraded premium car with no issue in budget of sonet
Aa ganje ka 200 rupay kaat overacting ka
Wagon r ke saath compare karo 😂
Background music is higher than your voice Unable to watch fully
punch
Please do a comparison with either the non turbo magnite or the kiger.
Turbo magnite I worked there u can go for it
Sonet❤htk +
Powerdrift now seems like TaMo's B-Team for the Punch's publicity. Come on guys, you are better than this.
Lets goooo 🔥🔥
Tata Punch 💖
Tata over kia any day
We can't fit 3 of you .... even in a Rolls Royce 😁🤣😂
After Swift, WagonR, i20, Ignis, Magnite and Kiger it ready to fight with Sonet.
Really PUNCH is great. With this price it is really best.
Final fight will be punch vs fortuner and punch wins... 😂😂😂 Fan boys are going crazy with punch.
Please do provide proper measurements like shoulder room, leg room knee room seat width & base length. Don't put it in words put it in proper numerical figures.
Doesn't it vary person to person??
@@BlameHari13 Somehow my comment got deleted, so replying you again, I requested for Car interior measurement or dimensions such as seat base width & length, leg room from h-point, seat base height from floor as well as ground to determine ingress. So on.
Comparing a B1 segment (3.8 m length) car with shit engine and shit transmission with a B2 segment (4 m) car with best in class engines and transmissions. Nice.
It doesn't make sense.. but the whole concept of this series was to compare with cars of other segments.. The previous ones were a hatchback, a c-sedan.. so don't blame them
B2 with shit safety!
Respect & support indian brand cars
@@BlackHawkTejas magnite is safer too
@@vkp08 Yup! Nissan & Renault both. But thier less showroom & service center hold back thier success. I'm honestly very disappointed with Hyundai & Kia; only looking for profit & gimmicks with safety at last priority. Plus Indian journalist ain't doing much also, just like in Consumer Electronics, journalist have a bias. That said Tata did very bad with Punch, that Powertrain is a joke.
Too loud music
Tata Punch EV will be great idea
turbo engine in punch is the need of hour with DCA
What has SUV segment come to! Compact, subcompact, micro! Might as well call all the hatchbacks as SUV! 😀
@Niranjan KV. Well you have predicted the future correct 😂 check out Citroen C3 an Hatchback SUV
Value for money on longer run is sonet as it's diesel engine and punch petrol engine ain't giving you mileage and will make you pay more, example sonet milege is average 24 and can go higher cos my brother has it. Punch is 17 on an average for 1 lakh km you spend as per today's diesel price in Bangalore 360000 , for punch you spend almost 591000 as per today's petrol price and you save 3 lakh every 1 lakh km with additional features. Services and spares are also cheap for this car.
If you buy a feature loaded car with super cool engine and DCT transmission, but a bit lower in ride quality in typical Indian roads, I say, your money is wasted !!!
On the other hand, if you have a car with avg engine, avg transmission, avg features, but superior ride quality and comfort in Indian bad roads, you are happy and you got the true investment !!!
Here I am taking Nexon for Sonnet.....
Punch is for Swift, Baleno and others price segment
MG Astor Style..... Anyone???
Are Nexon se compare kro punch se kyo
3 year old pd comparison videos are better than this, the change should be better but it's going downhill 😬