Tata Punch vs Renault Kiger Comparison Review - Which Small SUV To Buy? | MotorBeam
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 มิ.ย. 2024
- In this video, we pitch two compact SUVs against each other. The Tata Punch is becoming a hot favourite with customers and is selling in pretty decent numbers while the Renault Kiger is a very sorted product too. Both these vehicles offer a large number of USPs but both of them have some compromises too. Which one should you buy, let's find out.
Join The FK-R tribe - www.fk-r.com
Become a #MotorBeamer: bit.ly/MotorBeamer and join the #MBSquad
Meet us - www.motorbeam.com/join-us/
Visit our website: www.motorbeam.com
Follow us on Instagram: / motorbeam
Like us on Facebook: / motorbeam
Follow us on Twitter: / motorbeam
0:00 Introduction
0:33 Exteriors
1:15 Boot Capacity
1:49 Safety Features
2:14 Kiger Bottle-Holder Test
3:02 Punch Bottle-Holder Test
3:51 Punch Audio System
4:37 Kiger Audio System
5:25 Kiger Rear Seat
7:09 Punch Rear Seat
8:59 Punch Driving
11:20 Kiger Driving
13:53 Slalom Test
14:44 Braking Test
15:12 Verdict - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
Hello #MotorBeamers! Which car will you pick out of these two? Or is there some other car you’d pick instead of these?
Tata Punch all day!
Magnite❤️ instead of this both 😂
I have visited both the cars in person. Punch build quality is good but way below altroz/Nexon. On the other hand the kiger looks really premium and build quality didn't look bad at all. Punch would be the pick if not for its overpricing. The turbo engine of the kiger could be the deal breaker here
Kiger
Punch
Kiger looks more SUVish and stylish than a Punch and being bigger, it has a better road presence.. I’d pick Kiger between the two..
i have also kiger ..best car .. feeling big suv. .nice look and I am happy and satisfied with kiger ❤
What is the mileage bro? In City and highways
I recently bought kiger rxt non turbo and very happy with my decision 👍
I am also happy with the same model.. 😌
I'm planning to purchase same but I hear there is problem with reverse gear is it true. Could you please provide your feedback
I also bought d same model..its really value for money..no issues with reverse gear..little leggy but can be considered as all cars have their own pros n cons
Non turbo is it good for hills and bad roads, ?
Shall I go for Kiger RxL?
I recently bought Kiger RXZ Turbo CVT and i am really happy.
Before buying I did a lot of research and took a thorough test drive of many cars like Breeza, XL6 and cars like Punch and Magnite too and the reason why i rejected them is because Punch is very disappointed for highway driving, overtaking is a real pain, NVH level is horrible (lot of outside vehicle noise filtering into the cabin), misses lot of essential features like arm rest, boot space and driving modes (though it has ECO and city), therefore Punch is good as a city car if you have any other good car for long drives.
Magnite, however is good, but again misses important features like driving modes, suspension is quite stiff and to me it looks more like a hatchback than a compact sedan and Nissan service center is really a pain (while Renault is slightly better)
While Kiger gives all practical and usable features, such as drive modes (sports mode in my turbo car is unbelievable specially for overtaking, really spot on), large arm rest, lots of usable space, large boot and a look of a compact SUV (Punch also looks epic and lovable i agree). cruise control is not very usable and safe in India as i feel and i donot miss it in my Kiger, as i know i wouldnt use it, evenif i had it. but people who love cruise control, may miss it absence in Kiger. As far as hill hold function is concerned, which is missing in Kiger but is available in Magnite, let me tell you that the L mode in the turbo CVT can take care of any steepest incline. I went to really bad hills and i was surprised to see how amazing the L mode is for the deadly inclines/slopes.
Now coming to mileage, my car is 35 days old, 800 Kms driven as of now and mileage is 14 in city (Hyderabad) and 18 on highways and i am sure after i cross 5000km milestone...mileage should increase by 2 kms in city and 3 to 4 kms in highways (if driven not more than 110Km/h), also verified current mileage using tank to tank.
Apart from Renault's service (which i am little worried about), I am super happy with my Kiger, specially the way it drives. This is being my only car, i know i will never be disappointed in the CITY and in the highways also.
So from an ownership standpoint, I can say that those who do not much care about cruise control, can really go for Kiger Turbo CVT. Kiger CVT is anytime better than its manual version. I found the response and behaviour of the CVT of Kiger is slightly better than even Honda City CVT.
You wont find a car with turbo engine and extremely lovable CVT gearbox with its Top trim/model within ex - showroom price of 10 Lakhs, while the on road price that i paid excluding accessories is 11.5 lakhs (Note - on road price varies from state to state).
yes there are cons also for this car as the case with any product. But I can say I can live with those few cons of the car (though Renault's service is one of my only and biggest concern. Will wait to see how the 1st and 2nd service go)
So I can say, I love its drivability, looks, interior, road presence, cabin space, ergonomics, boot, suspension and the TORQUE (in sports mode, it is any day better than Nexon's sports mode (petrol & diesel both), and I have driven both)
Sir u didn't comment on XL6 and Brezza....they r 4cylinder engine pick up and engine performance is really good better service network...peace of mind....only thing I and all can say that built quality is not good...but overall better than Renault kiger.....you will feel after long term usage that Renault can disappoint you any time.....But everyone has it own taste...
You should've made your own video
We also
Very nice review
..
Sir what is the service related issue for renault. Also since I do not require way too much powerful engine .. I have opted for the Kiger RXT[O] AMT version
I recently bought kiger i am very happy kiger features and car model is superb.
Kiger is a good compact SUV under budget if u don't care about much power as the Indian roads doesn't have very good average Speed.Punch is a good micro SUV with less space for 3 in rear ,legroom and boot
The Design of Kiger is very Sporty and balanced. The build Quality is Decent. Ride quality is average. However, if they would have worked more on it's interior this car could have be in hot selling segment.
interior is cheap like an RTV bus or Taxi
Kiger is superb performance 👌👌👌👌
Kiger looks so much better
But not reliable in various terms as punch
@@jaykolhe6150 Renault is more reliable than tata
@@Alan-jn2qp just like Ford, Reault may vanish from Indian markets,
Tata has more service centers in India,
The new Tata cars are more reliable than another foreign brand, Tata car kees your family safe with 5 star global NCAP safety ratings
@@bhartiyavyakti6542 renault is also safe triber got 4 stars in gncap. Andhbakth tata fans chup karo
@@Alan-jn2qp Punch got 5 stars, ab 4 Zada hota Hai ya 5 ?
Kiger without a doubt ❤️
In fact, no other sub4metre car can beat triber's 600L + bootspace for years to come..
It's mpv?
Goru
Renault Kiger 🥰🔥
Miss those dyno test episodes.. do one for cb350..
Tbh punch is killing it !!!
This video is very well made 👍
I spent two months to decide to buy my new car. First I tried Tata Punch , because I wanted to buy smallest SUV. It is really a compact SUV with enough space inside. But driving experience was not good. Basic first two models are not good enough, and top models are very costly and not worth for mony.
Then I tried Tata Nexon, Kia Sonet, Nissan Magnite and finally Renault Kiger turbo engine CVT.
Oh my God, I was extremely happy and delighted with this superb car. It is a reality a value for money car. It is far better than top model of punch. It is almost the same price of Tata Punch. Kiger is 100 percent automatic car like I was driving in USA It's driving is very smooth and comfortable. It has tons of features. It is the best SUV under 12 lacs. It most beautiful SUV in India. If you want Bold nd Beautiful, go for
Renault Kiger.
You are right Prashant. I recently bought Kiger RXZ Turbo CVT and more than 100% satisfied. This is really an amazing car. Those who can evaluate a car without being biased, would know what this car is capable of in terms of feature and drivability. Else usually people have positive biasness towards TATA or a negative biasness towards Renault/Nissan.
This car is a TRUE value for money. Specially the CVT one....
Please read my ownership review above.
12 lakhs for kiger is not good.Its class competitions are magnite ,punch etc.Nexon or sonet are better cars on any day.But yes kiger has good looks .
@@purplelusture Waste car.. No road presence, small car. No traction and hill control n features only in top model 😂😂
City mileage?
@@player1554 Nexon amt is pathetic. How are you even comparing amt and cvt
I purchase kiger rxe model.. Average in city is near 15 and at highway its gone to 23.5.. I fell king in kiger.. Best car in market to purchase
Punch is 1200 cc? I drove kiger and punch I felt kiger was a bit tough to drive not sure if I'm not sure to full clutch. But punch was so easy with half clutch concept.
We can prefer any car provided if its has most powerful engine, like quick pickup, noise less sounds, comfortable driving, etc.
Interior of kiger have international quality and so sporty
Please try to compare the car like how the user of this segment use. This is not a chaffeur driven car. Practically is the important thing for this segment.
Renault Kiger - THE TIGER 🐯.....
Owners Hit like here 👍
मैं दो महीने सब गाड़ी का test drive लेने के बाद finally Renault Kiger Turbo engine CVT पसंद किया,
I am extremely very happy. It is the best SUV in India, It gives a lot of features and comfortable drive experience. It is worth for money spend. It is Bold and Beautiful SUV.
superb review.. thank you
Kiger one of the most underrated car in India
I bought Renault kiger rxt, really value for money. 4 air bags, 4 cap safety rating.
All things are good 👍
What amount paid on road?
@@ankitpatel2175 8.5 lakh in maharashtra
@@realindia9718 Does it have alloy wheel ?
@@ankitpatel2175 not in rxt
@@realindia9718 Thanks
I took a test ride of kiger yesterday... i noticed a little sound in the engine and also the gear lever was showing some vibration or can say was moving while riding.. so is it the issue in this car ??
Every TH-cam channel complaints about infotainment system of tata, every TH-cam channel. But Tata! They don't care.....
Does 83 PS makes more difference or can we go with kiger if it's almost similar.pls confirm.thanks
Bring in the Turbo engine with CVT, spruce up with features and throw in a few gizmos, fit in captain seats on the middle row, add more styling bits, call it a facelift or an altogether new car a.k.a XL6.
Renault will have a winner with Triber !
Hope they are listening !!
They should perhaps could do a top end version
Hey man what will have to pick in both of these cars...
Punch is the size of a Swift. But Tata is using a great strategy of marketing by putting comparisons of Punch with Sub-compact SUVs
It's not about size it's about the body type......
Kiger is no doubt the ultimate winner in the sub-4 meter Segment, I've been using her for almost a month now.
Tata punch owner and proud of it
Very practical bro
Bought Triber recently, Feels really good to drive with own family. And some relatives too
I have just purchased punch it is ,1and half months old . Believe me it is best car with power and has good pickup too for city like Indore and overtakes easily but it has low mileage in city about 8 or 9 but in highway mileage is above 18 . Cabin is very silent and it's looks is killer I am having creative manual white. I too drove kiger na but it's pickup is less than punch 👊. And too service centre is issue with kiger. Indore tata has good service center as showroom from which i bought has Honda cars showroom too very much satisfied with punch build quality is awesome 😎👍🙏. Highway response is awesome as I engage it in 4 gear it gives the punch like maruti car it has good pickup in 1 and 2 gear and 3 is not that great 4 and 5 gear is awesome sound of car changes as changeed gear to 4 stability is excellent 🙏
Tata Punch 🔥🔥❤️❤️❤️
I have a Kiger RXZ, Kiger door can actually fit 2 one litre bottle each ie. 8 ltr only in door's
I will go for kiger in terms of performance 😂😂😂😂
Kigner NA - 72 BHP one ? 😂😂
Performance means ,,picking in traffick with ease in 2nd gear after breaker yaar .not picking with cut cut voice .. u didn't drive punch I think...onse drive it and see
@@sharathmsg443615yr old me ~~~should drive a car 😂?
Go for puunch really good car
Punch takes 5-6 business days to touch 100
There is no comparison between kiger & small toy punch.... Kiger is sub4meter compact suv its competitors are nexon, breeza, xuv300, ecosport, etc kiger have best in segment boot space, best in segment ground clearance, very decent space, 4 airbags, awesome turbo engine have more then sufficient power comparison to nexon , breeza etc & looks really amazing ✨
Why punch length is smaller than others? Damn sure it would be so awesome if they make 3995mm length and ground clearance 205mm
Nexon is there for that
I have a punch AMT which was delivered to me on 28th Oct.
I have driven it for over 6400km in two months.
It had the following problems.
1. Heating when a/c is in low cool casuing huge drop in milage(10-11km) or a/c is in low cool. At full cool the milage is good(14-15 in city)
2. Fuel indicator not indicating full when fuel is fully topped up.
3. Can't mute central locking.
4. Boot not unlocking with remote.
5. Rattling noise from dash board.
Till now Tata are not ready to open a job card for the a/c problem 😭😭.
Visit showroom man.. not every car will be perfect.. some minor niggles like this can be easily sorted out
@@jonjones18 i did visit the service center not much of help
After sales service is Tata's biggest drawback
That turbo, wireless charging, looks, and that European car feel, and forget everything when you are gonna do 0 to 100 under 11 secs against 17 secs of punch, even 0.8 litre kwid is faster than that punch
Sahi kya bhai
Comparing turbo and non turbo car only makes no sense
Kiger ✨ is really a tiger✨ no doubt the turbo engine of kiger perform more then sufficient power👍 have best in segment boot space even more then ecosports, nexon, breeza etc best in segment ground clearance 205 mm , have very decent cabin space even more then its competitors like nexon, venue, breeza, xuv300 etc & if i talk about the looks of kiger🫡 hats of to reno.... Its amazing & kiger provide maximum features like keyless entry, 8 inches touch screen, tyre pressure monitoring, cooled glove box, rear ac winds & rear hand rest which is countable in luxurious accessories 🫡 & if we talk about safety provide by reno which is also very impressive because kiger get 4⭐ rating in global ncap crash test ✨ so... We can say its a safe car also.... & Reno provide 4 airbags in kiger so... We can say kiger is really value for money & very decent product of Renault ✨ so... Everyone should go for this beast also.... In this segment this is the only compact suv which provide alot of things according to its price segment 🫡 definitely everyone should consider this beautiful beast✨
What about resale value and maintenance issues after 20000 KM of running ? Can somebody share your experience ?
I'm using kiger since 1year and the experience is really great
I have heard that the AC in weak... Is it true ?
How much mileage you are getting bayya..
Kiger Looks DasHinG😍👌👌
Little confused if i have to buy baae model or base se ek upar what to choose kiger or punch ?? I need average also and safety as well. I am a travel vlogger
Can anyone suggest what yo buy if I have to go to hill station
Kiger dimensionsal actually competing with NEXON at PUNCH's price
I have visited both the cars in person. Punch build quality is good but way below altroz/Nexon. On the other hand the kiger looks really premium and build quality didn't look bad at all. Punch would be the pick if not for its overpricing. The turbo engine of the kiger could be the deal breaker here
Tata wants to make u feel that you are buying a budget car but it's not the same in case of kiger they have given the best features
@@Salam-qx1qv best features? What? Radio,
But kiger is the best car then punch 👍
@@swapniljejurkar1708 tatti engine 🤣
@@nou7401 तो तू ही बना दे इंजन 😆😆😆इतना खराब लग रहा है तो
Reasons to buy Kiger over Punch:
1. Better looking front, rear, interior and instrument cluster than of punch
2. More Premium detailing than Punch
3. Better value for money even at the top models
4. More space than Tata punch and don't forget about the biggest boot space in the segment
5. More mileage but compromising the power but not much issues
6. Renault's service and customer support is better than Tata's service
7. Better road presence than Punch, that coupe like design, integrated rear camera with the logo, looks more like a European styled SUV's
8. Not better than Punch but have a good safety upon the price is given
9. Have more options than Punch, like it have CVT and turbo.
Better looking is better in punch I think bro
Kiger and Magnite are build with same platform. Magnite have 4 star safety rating in GNCAP. I thing kiger may have same safety rating.
@@harshsingh00001 its has better road presence than Punch in looks, more premium looking
It's just a new launch car 😂wait karo bhai turbo be ajayega
@@rrichard8719 I am telling to those people who are planning to buy the car now
Tata punch my favourite
What the shit was that "Bottle holder test" ???
😂😂😂😂
Looks:- Renault Kiger.
Safety:- Tata Punch.
Features+Looks+Safety:- Nissan Magnite.
Clear winner is Nissan Magnite but its booking cross 75k+ with 10 months waiting period.
Last year in lock down there was no showroom of Nissan in pune just because dealers cancelled the contract with the Nissan. I am having nissan micra and i can truely say the car is very nice but the company is totally unreliable in india... You never know when they will close all the deal and wind up they are just here because of this car magnite and this is a risk taking for the magnite owners coz if nissan does not show with any new car and magnite gets old then again nissan will plan to wind up everything from india..... And that's the reason why i went for Renault kiger!!! As my new car
@@hemangkhanna5616
Nissan export 1 lakh + cars from India in other countries.
And if they stop production in India then already renault is here which is group of Nissan.
Also don't think that after a success of Magnite they didn't launch new products.
Renault refused to touch my micra saying this is a nissan and now i was left with only one a option which is to go with a local car mechanic.
And then the resale value is a different perk which u need bear with nissan any time
After taking that experience i would have look like a fool in front of my eyes if i would considered the magnite
Kiger should be compared with SUVs like venue, sonet and Nexon while punch with ignis, S-presso and the upcoming Hyundai casper
Why
Because punch is a mini suv and kiger is a compact suv
Yea but both are same price
@@Salam-qx1qv that’s why I am saying punch is overpriced… instead of punch higher end models you can go for nexon mid models
Tata Punch is a good package as its offer road presense nd features but its engine and Price disappoint.Kiger is good package if its interior quality is good and after sales services.
i bought TATA PUNCH a year ago, and i drove almost 11000 kms, everyone who travelled in my car, felt very comfortable, especially during long drive with great suspension and the real drive feel, it doesnt have few features comparing to kiger but i did not regret buying punch, i bought Accomplish dazzla amt, took me 10L with seat covers - on road, still i did not regret, PUNCH gives you confident while cornoring on 90s... and i feel confident driving it
How is your car now? Im in confusion either punch accomplished amt or kiger rxt(o)?
For 6'1 guy is tata punch good?
Suzuki punch kiger rival is missed in the market. Tata and Renault has a breath.
Kiger ✌✌
Automatic gear.
Kiger
Punch
Nissan magnite
Which car best plz any one reply plz
🙏🏻
KIGER IS BEST IN THIS BUDGET IN ENQUIRED IN DEHRADUN UTTARAKHAND IT IS BASE MODEL PETROL IN 6.95 LAC
Kiger turbo any day ..
Bhai konsa desh ka ha tu
TataBeam
Global NCAP ratings document shows crash test weight as 1318 kgs. And car curb weight is 1000-1035kgs. What is the reason for difference in 300kg(30% extra weight)??
For other cars ncap crash test weight is 10-15% extra only.
It's because of the weight of the crash test dummies. There's a huge difference in many cars
@@glubglubglub732 The weight difference for Tata cars is way more than other cars. You can check Altroz VS i20 crash test weight changes. Hence I thought if I'm missing something or Tata playing some game!
@@kishorekurapati9172 i20 hasn't been crash tested im pretty sure
He really wants punch to win in almost every aspect😢
This is like creta vs brezza. No comparison
You could have used seat back pocket to increase bottle count for punch.. this review was clearly punch biased
Definitely Kiger. Killer looks and performance
Performance? Gaanja phooka h
Bakwaas h kiger only 1 lt engine itni badi gaadi me
@@nou7401 Kaafi hai...And turbo me faad deta hai
Kiger is tiger ✨ there is no comparison of kiger with this tata toy... Kiger have more space & punch comparison to duplicate punch....✨👍
Tata punch 👊 is best but expensive...
punch is the best
I have driven both the cars, but honestly tata punch engine performance is much much better than kiger.
Please help me out....
I'm new driver, monthly drive not more than 200 km, long drive 1000 km three times in year, occasional need hill driving
Should I go with kiger AMT
Same for me as well.
Tata Punch is 1200cc and Kiger is just 1000cc. How will this impact? Can anybody explain/help!
This is the main issue. Kiger's 1000CC is less for its size.
Why doesn't people compare Kiger Turbo vs punch.
Variant to variant kiger offers better value for money even in turbo variant
Punch is punch over others.
Kiger looks more premium and huge from outside but from inside it's very congested.
Tata Punch takes the cake over here coz it has that harrier look, pratical and after market there are many options to upgrade it simultaneously.
Though the punch does not have power but makes it up in terms handling ingress as well as safety.
U r rat bro, I owe KIGER RXT OPT
Tata punch is a cross over hatchback not suv 🚙 lol but it has suv dna 🧬 but people like me will will go forward Tata punch bcoz it has good build quality and it’s mere India 🇮🇳 make 😇
Renault-Nissan has a manufacturing unit in orakadam. It is also an India Make
Don't call them SUV, they are just scaled down crossover based on compact car platform
Punch is 🔥
Definitely PUNCH
Sedans are any day more Comfortable, more stable, have better Fuel economy, better, aerodynamics than SUV.
Only one negative is ground clearance otherwise you are right👍
Yeah that's why I opted for TATA tigor instead of Kiger. Mileage is really good and has about 16 kmpl in city. Build quality is the same of both the cars. Only drawback is a lower ground clearance. Other than that, Sedans are great value for money in all aspects.
@@noice8674 now tigor is launched with factory fitted iCNG
@@carwa9651 Yeah. It also comes with additional features like Rain sensing vipers, Automatic Headlamps, Beize interiors for 8.3 lakhs. Great value for money. But I wanted an automatic car. Unfortunately CNG cars don't offer automatic transmission.
@@noice8674 wow yaar...same thing i also want
Cng cars with automatic
Dont knw Y car makers doesn't offer that
Punch is actually a premium hatchback
No it's actually a compact SUV
@@Charlie78376 No it is compact suv and premium hatchback
I think tata punch is the best.
What about suspensions & at speed of 120 to 140 is kiger stable
Nope
Handling problem
I have taken test drive of kiger I don't know why people comparing punch with kiger I feel power and driving comfort of kiger is better than Nexon also.
No compact suv can beat nexon in power..It has turbo and 1.2L which can beat even segment above cars
Haha ending was suppperb. 😂
Kiger 👍👍👍
I love Punch
Kiger is Punch ka bada bhai.
And renault is bhikari
@@nou7401 Kyu Tere Papa Renault M Kaam Krte H Kya?? 😀😀
Kiger is weak AF
Renault Kiger is value for money car 🥰❤️❤️☺️🔥🔥
Poo da Tata punch is nice
yes kiger is also giving us a very premium look, but punch exterior is like a box
look for safety not money / performance /looks .
@@saiprasad1 😂😂😂 nice joke uneducated rascal chaiwala company member first you research Renault Kiger is a safe car because the platform used in kiger is same as Renault Triber and Nissan Magnite and both got global ncap 4 Star rating so Renault Kiger will also get Global NCAP 4 Star or 5 star
@@JAVED_295 is global ncap result out for this car officially?
Why Anurag is here. What is he doing in MB show where is fazlu....
Kiger best suv😍😍
16:10 🔥🔥
Clearly the words are saying, TAYA has payment were more strong then Renault
Under 8 lakhs punch is the best in the segment close your eyes and get it. Adventure rhythm seems more vfm than higher variants. From accomplished onwards they should have provided 1.0 turbo atleast.
Kiger is much better even then Nexon. Tata is having poor service and low average
Bro u really comparing with nexon😆😆😆
@@mantubarman9735 yes friend- check out all specifications and price too.
Nexon is good in providing few additional safety benefits and more power but overall value for money , features (even safety) after sale service, average- kiger is better
No matter how good the Kiger is.. here most of them will comment Tata Punch is the best suv in the whole world 😂🔥
👍
As per now, kiger is leading
Paid marketing by tata
@@Salam-qx1qv are you sure? Will automobiles influence such channels for promotion? I thot these channels are unbiased in everything they review.
@@melvingunners yea they are taking advantage of gullible people like you. I have audited many companies they spend huge amounts in social media advertising