आपका बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद। हमारे पास एक पुस्तक है चंद्रशेखर आज़ाद पर। उसकी लेखिका भी राजवंती मान है। कृपया हमारी उत्सुकता सुलझाएं और बताएं की आप ही वो लेखिका है।
Gaha Sattasai (Prakrit) / Gatha Saptashati (Sanskrit) was written by King Hala. Hence it was known as Hala's Gatha Saptashati. There is an interesting story about him (& his queen). His queen was a princess from Sri Lanka & can speak Samskrt fluently. Once while they were playing "jala kreeda" in the palace pond (swimming pool), he began splashing water on her. She held her palms against the splash & said "Rajan ! Ma`odakam taadayat", which means "King ! don't splash water that beats me". King Hala who doesn't know Samskrtam, thought she is asking for Modakam (Modak, that is offered to Ganesha) as she was pregnant. He got modak s made, took to her & asked her to eat. She laughed at the King Hala's ignorance of Samskrt & explained it (ma udakam = not with water). Hala was embarrassed and began learning Samskrt. Gatha Saptashati's translations in Telugu are available.
Prakrit is only for Marathi 😂😂😂 😅 there are many areas where it is spoken don't forget . It's ancient India there was no Marathi at that time and prakrit was spoken equally in Andhra Pradesh too later Telugu evolved from Dravidian and prakrit and sanskrit . Other wise u don't find every dam word of Sanskrit and prakrit in Telugu. Marathi evolved post 12 century.
@@thesupremesupreme Thanks for the information. I am deeply grateful. All the same, don't comment on things you don't know (like Telugu language), based on your visceral feelings. It is a typical Indian trait that needs to be checked & overcome, before the country gets split into various language based countries. Responsibility for it, rests with us & us only. Have respect for all native Indian languages . I have a great regard & respect for Marathi (my third sister is married in the Maratha household - Bhongade) though I don't know enough.
@@MrPoornakumar I don't have any opposition to any language infact I speak both marati and Telugu . Telugu being my mother tongue. And I speak tamizh as well. I'm only against to the fact that modern states are different from old ones and borders keeps on changing. And we can't say only Marathi originated from prakrit so prakrit speakers are ancient Marathi this is unacceptable.as prakrit was spoken from north to south in ancient India. And prakrit and sanskrit has greatly impacted other regional languages of India. I'm against to the idea of claiming kings on regional basis and state wide basis as nationalism and state were new concepts and in previous times empire consists of different people in one empire.
आपकी पुरानी वीडियोस देखने के बाद लगातार देखते रहने और ऐतिहासिक कहानियां सुनते रहने का दिल करता है । स्वस्थ रहिए और लागतार वीडियो बनाते रहिए। बहुत शुभकामनाएं 🎉🙏
वाह साहब गज़ब विषयों का चयन करते हैं आप! हर विषय में आनन्द आ रहा है। इन विषयों के लिए आपका आभार और धन्यवाद और शुभकामनाएं प्रेषित कर कृत्य पूरा नहीं हो पाएगा। एक आत्मीय निवेदन है। आप निष्पक्ष होकर ही , विषयों का चयन करते हैं। इस ही आरूढ़ रहें।
मै बहुत साल साल से गाथा सप्तशती के बारे मे सुना था . आज संक्षिप्त मे सही, मगर जानकारी मिली. उस समय के समाज व्यवस्था के बारे मे मुझे जानकारी चाहीये थी, थोडिसी सही, लेकीन nut shell मे समझ पाया. धन्यवाद !
I accidentally discovered your channel and really enjoyed your content. Please make more videos on such interesting but lesser known topics of ancient India.
I feel blessed to increase my knowledge through people like you who in the business of spreading knowledge provide us with an opportunity to increase our awareness of our civilization. Thank you and god bless.
पता नहीं क्यों आर्टिफिशियल इंटेलिजेंसी ने पता नहीं क्यों मेरी पंसन्दो को पढ़ा। मेरी मुख्य पसंद पुरातन इतिहास और पुरातत्व है। आपके यह शिक्षाप्रद विडियो देरी से देखने पर अभागा सा महसूस करता हूं। इतने शानदार विडियो बहुत ही कम होते हैं। भारत का एक पुरातन व्यापार चमड़े का होता था और जिन जहाजों में लादा जाता था , वे जहाज़ बहु मंजिल होते थे ।और यह व्यापार पश्चिम तक होता था। कृपया इस विषय पर भी प्रकाश डालने की कृपा किजीए।
Gaha Sattasai is actually a composition of poems in Maharashtri(one of the many Prakrits spoken in ancient India). Considering that Marathi was declared classical due to its continuity with Maharashtri, the first collection of ancient poems of Marathi is actually the Gaha Sattasai.
I have watched all your episodes. Your videos takes me on a historical journey and connects me to my ancestors. Please keep making more videos. Thank you very very much .
नमस्ते सर, आप कहां चले गए हो सर? अब आप विडियोज क्यों नही बना रहे हो? आपकी इतिहास की इतनी समझ और उसे बताने का आपका इतना बेहतरीन तरीका, ये बहुत ही कम है TH-cam पर। Plz सर वापस आ जाइए We all miss you sir a lot
आपने वीडियो बनाना बंद कर दिया। मुझे इसकी सटीक वजह तो नहीं पता। लेकिन आपको continue करना चाहिए। यदि आप स्वयं प्रसन्न हैं, तो जिन्दगी उत्तम है ! परंतु, यदि आपकी वजह से लोग प्रसन्न हैं, तो यह सर्वोत्तम है!!
There are so many love odyssey books like silapaddakam, manimekalai, ramsetuvandana, mudrarakshasa, all are so aesthetically written depicts the broad liberal intellectual minds
What a fascinating style of narration you have Sir. I have one question, Sir. Gaha Sattasai was written by 17th Satvahana King Hala almost around 1st Century AD whereas Vatsyayana belonged to 3rd-4th Century CE hence Kamasutra was written later than Gaha Sattasai. How come Gaha Sattasai make a criticism of Kamasutra when it was written earlier also would it be fair to make a comparison of both when these two were written in a completely different time and space. I'll patiently wait for your response Sir. Thank you.
Thank you for watching the video, thinking it through and asking a very interesting question. Gaha Sattasai has been compiled over time and it spread from one region to another, over time, moment/culture specific situations were addressed in form of short poems and were added to the compilation. Thatswhy a time frame of its compilation has been allotted to it as mentioned in the video. This gives rise to a commentary on relevance of Kamasutra which finds its place in the early poems of Gaha Sattasai. The fluidity of its movement through time and consequent evolution allows space for speculation. In its own way, Kama Sutra, is supposed to have undergone consistent effort over centuries before reaching its datable form. Also, your observation is brilliant, because, Charles Wilkins while translating Bhagvat Gita with the help of Kashinath Bhattacharya, had observed that it was composed before Atharva Veda, since it mentions all other Vedas except Atharva Veda. Thank you again.
@@trystwithhistory8480 Thank you so much for your response Sir. It indeed was very helpful. I'll continue to ask my queries in the comment section and wait for your response in other videos.
@@trystwithhistory8480 I'm going through that right now.. And I have found a beautiful collection of English poem too. th-cam.com/video/jD7P1bBeeeU/w-d-xo.html Thank you to sir.. Why he isn't making new videos.
Sir hindi me gatha satsai kitaab kaise uplabdh hogi? Video me jo aap padh rahe hain wo kis kitaab se hai? Description me sbhi kitaabein english me hain..
Wow sir … if u can guide pls help me get English or Hindi translation of this book and as many ancient Indian texts that you know are available … I would be so much obliged
The castes division of people finds a mention in the Bhagavad-Gita. And the Gita was written by Ved Vyas in about 7000 BCE. You'll find mention in Adhyay 4 Sloka 13.
Sir, this work relates to Deccan where sanskritisation happened much later in time. Reference is made to how wives of Satvahan Kings brought the influence of Sanskrit and north on the language and culture of Deccan.
Srikrishna talks of varnashram dharm ie based on profession chosen on merit and inclination.. not caste... Ved Vyas himself was born of a fisherwoman and highly revered in his own lifetime.
Sir, who talks about caste even in current day Indian love songs.? To make special mention of caste being absent and justifying that it's from Deccan and no Sanskrit influence is imagination going drunk
I have been listening to your videos with interest. Great work! Please continue your great work. However, I want to register a criticism on this one. You may want to check your analysis and facts: 1:00 to 1:40 ब्राह्मण, शुद्र, क्षत्रिय का जिक्र नहीं है, so you conclude this was composed before जातीसंस्था came (but examples used are वर्ण). This can’t be. Because Yajurveda and Rigveda mention वर्णसंस्था, etc. just because this one book doesn’t mention them doesn’t mean they were non existent when this poetry composition was written. Further the epigraphy in नाणेघाट proves that even kings in that area were performing Vedic rituals. So you can’t say the Vedic religion had not reached Deccan (and was limited to “भारत” which you talk about as a potentially limited area in early first millennium) 2:55 to 3:30 claims प्राकृत doesn’t have structure or grammar. - not true. प्राकृत sentences are more structured than Sanskrit (like many later languages) and has विभक्ती, verb conjugations etc very similar to Sanskrit and modern Indian languages.
Thank you for your erudite comment. This video is based on material mentioned in the description of the video. Please share some reference reading material on which we can rely. It will be our pleasure to present the contrary view point to our viewers.
कुछ दिन पहले आपकी वीडियो देखी और अब लगातार देखने की इच्छा है ।आपकी शोध और शोध के विषय बहुत ज्ञान वर्धक हैं ।आप सलामत रहें ।नमस्कार आपको।
आपका बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद। हमारे पास एक पुस्तक है चंद्रशेखर आज़ाद पर। उसकी लेखिका भी राजवंती मान है। कृपया हमारी उत्सुकता सुलझाएं और बताएं की आप ही वो लेखिका है।
@@trystwithhistory8480 जी मैं ही हूँ ।
आदरणीया, आपकी सराहना हमारी खुशकिस्मती है। बहुत-बहुत आभार।
You are gem of our culture , shriman.
Gaha Sattasai (Prakrit) / Gatha Saptashati (Sanskrit) was written by King Hala. Hence it was known as Hala's Gatha Saptashati. There is an interesting story about him (& his queen). His queen was a princess from Sri Lanka & can speak Samskrt fluently. Once while they were playing "jala kreeda" in the palace pond (swimming pool), he began splashing water on her. She held her palms against the splash & said "Rajan ! Ma`odakam taadayat", which means "King ! don't splash water that beats me". King Hala who doesn't know Samskrtam, thought she is asking for Modakam (Modak, that is offered to Ganesha) as she was pregnant. He got modak s made, took to her & asked her to eat. She laughed at the King Hala's ignorance of Samskrt & explained it (ma udakam = not with water). Hala was embarrassed and began learning Samskrt. Gatha Saptashati's translations in Telugu are available.
It's written in prakrut Marathi 👈
Prakrit is only for Marathi 😂😂😂 😅 there are many areas where it is spoken don't forget . It's ancient India there was no Marathi at that time and prakrit was spoken equally in Andhra Pradesh too later Telugu evolved from Dravidian and prakrit and sanskrit . Other wise u don't find every dam word of Sanskrit and prakrit in Telugu. Marathi evolved post 12 century.
@@thesupremesupreme
Thanks for the information. I am deeply grateful.
All the same, don't comment on things you don't know (like Telugu language), based on your visceral feelings. It is a typical Indian trait that needs to be checked & overcome, before the country gets split into various language based countries. Responsibility for it, rests with us & us only.
Have respect for all native Indian languages . I have a great regard & respect for Marathi (my third sister is married in the Maratha household - Bhongade) though I don't know enough.
@@MrPoornakumar I don't have any opposition to any language infact I speak both marati and Telugu . Telugu being my mother tongue. And I speak tamizh as well. I'm only against to the fact that modern states are different from old ones and borders keeps on changing. And we can't say only Marathi originated from prakrit so prakrit speakers are ancient Marathi this is unacceptable.as prakrit was spoken from north to south in ancient India. And prakrit and sanskrit has greatly impacted other regional languages of India. I'm against to the idea of claiming kings on regional basis and state wide basis as nationalism and state were new concepts and in previous times empire consists of different people in one empire.
@@thesupremesupreme All of what you said is fine. But why are telling me? Why do you target me?
Seems like you have a grouse & you are venting on me.
💐 अमूल्य ज्ञान बांटने के लिए आप का आभार🙏🙏
आपकी पुरानी वीडियोस देखने के बाद लगातार देखते रहने और ऐतिहासिक कहानियां सुनते रहने का दिल करता है । स्वस्थ रहिए और लागतार वीडियो बनाते रहिए। बहुत शुभकामनाएं 🎉🙏
भूत को समझ भविष्य को सुधारने हेतु जन जागृति का ये अदना प्रयास है। आपकी कामनाओं के लिए और सराहने के लिए बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद।
Narration makes it even more pleasing and beautiful!
Thank you for such a wonderful video.
I have ordered the Penguin India version. I am so eager to read it. Thankyou for such profound introductions into our own history and our being!
Plzzzz 🙏 vidios bnate rhe bhot sandar prastuti h apki
Dhannavayo!! Just embarked on the journey to learn Prakrit and came across you TH-cam Channel as I was searching for an Indian version of the book.
वाह साहब गज़ब विषयों का चयन करते हैं आप!
हर विषय में आनन्द आ रहा है।
इन विषयों के लिए आपका आभार और धन्यवाद और शुभकामनाएं प्रेषित कर कृत्य पूरा नहीं हो पाएगा।
एक आत्मीय निवेदन है। आप निष्पक्ष होकर ही , विषयों का चयन करते हैं। इस ही आरूढ़ रहें।
आपके प्रयास सराहनीय है
भाषा का गौरव होता है
आपका presentation संक्षिप्त पर clear है 🌻🌻🌻🌻🌻🌻🌻🌻🌻🌻
Bahut badhiya Sir Ji ummid he or Bhi esi knowledgeable video aeti rehegi
मै बहुत साल साल से गाथा सप्तशती के बारे मे सुना था . आज संक्षिप्त मे सही, मगर जानकारी मिली. उस समय के समाज व्यवस्था के बारे मे मुझे जानकारी चाहीये थी, थोडिसी सही, लेकीन nut shell मे समझ पाया. धन्यवाद !
Thank you so much, sir. Wonderful description and very useful! - A Sri Lankan monk from USA
I love shree lanka
@@debashissarkar5158
It is always "Sri Lanka"like "Sri nagar".
The transliteration, "Shree" is an alien (un-Indian) abomination.
बहुत सुंदर जानकारी दी है आपने 👃👃👃
I accidentally discovered your channel and really enjoyed your content. Please make more videos on such interesting but lesser known topics of ancient India.
You open a new world for me, the sance of humor of our ancestors was better then present day, thanks sir
I feel blessed to increase my knowledge through people like you who in the business of spreading knowledge provide us with an opportunity to increase our awareness of our civilization. Thank you and god bless.
पता नहीं क्यों आर्टिफिशियल इंटेलिजेंसी ने पता नहीं क्यों मेरी पंसन्दो को पढ़ा। मेरी मुख्य पसंद पुरातन इतिहास और पुरातत्व है।
आपके यह शिक्षाप्रद विडियो देरी से देखने पर अभागा सा महसूस करता हूं।
इतने शानदार विडियो बहुत ही कम होते हैं।
भारत का एक पुरातन व्यापार चमड़े का होता था और जिन जहाजों में लादा जाता था , वे जहाज़ बहु मंजिल होते थे ।और यह व्यापार पश्चिम तक होता था।
कृपया इस विषय पर भी प्रकाश डालने की कृपा किजीए।
Very nice information sir.. Thank you
Thank-you so much for this one also sir, made my day❤
Gaha Sattasai is actually a composition of poems in Maharashtri(one of the many Prakrits spoken in ancient India). Considering that Marathi was declared classical due to its continuity with Maharashtri, the first collection of ancient poems of Marathi is actually the Gaha Sattasai.
Sir please come back..hope you are doing well.. shubhkamnaye ❤️🩹
आपकी नई वीडियो का हमेशा इंतज़ार रहता है।
I have watched all your episodes. Your videos takes me on a historical journey and connects me to my ancestors. Please keep making more videos. Thank you very very much .
Nice comparison
Thank you for the valuable information of our past. Like your narration as always.
नमस्ते सर,
आप कहां चले गए हो सर?
अब आप विडियोज क्यों नही बना रहे हो?
आपकी इतिहास की इतनी समझ और उसे बताने का आपका इतना बेहतरीन तरीका, ये बहुत ही कम है TH-cam पर।
Plz सर वापस आ जाइए
We all miss you sir a lot
Wonderful! True essence of love is reflected nicely in your narration.
हमारी सारी प्राचीन धरोहर हमे दिखलाई पाश्चिमात्य जर्मन, इंग्लिश, अभ्यासकोने!
धन्यवाद उनका!
दु:ख है,की हम क्यूं कैसे भूले हम अपने स्वयंको...
आपने वीडियो बनाना बंद कर दिया। मुझे इसकी सटीक वजह तो नहीं पता। लेकिन आपको continue करना चाहिए।
यदि आप स्वयं प्रसन्न हैं,
तो जिन्दगी उत्तम है !
परंतु,
यदि आपकी वजह से लोग प्रसन्न हैं,
तो यह सर्वोत्तम है!!
सराहना के लिए धन्यवाद सर। उत्तम से सर्वोत्तम का सफर जल्द ही शुरू होगा। 🙂
सर का नाम बताने की कृपा करें।अहसान होगा
Interesting !!! Very lovingly and passionately narrated... Well researched,as always
Thank you Sir
@@trystwithhistory8480sir one mistake u did speaking word aurat it's very disgraceful word. Please use stree or mahila
Great sir please make more videos .
Beautiful Presentation sir..🙏🙏
As usual well researched and narration is superb.
Tarun Agarwala
Thank you Sir.
Superb Thank you so much . ❤
Excellent research, wonderful narration : an experience akin to listening to Carl Sagan in “Cosmos”👍👍🌹🌹🌹
Very well researched, Sir!
Brings out the rich mobilization of the senses, beauty, and the intelligence.
Mind blowing sir...keep it up
Sir please make more videos , all the videos are old. Why have you stopped making new ones? Please resume it. It enlightens me.
आपको सुन कर इतिहास में रुचि हो गई।
So beautifully explained thanks you so much.. more power to you
Hats off sir dil se,for educating India of what we actually are,and this episode needs real courage 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
acharya dev vrat ne bataya ap ke baare mai
Prakrit ke bareme batane ke liye bhut dhanyavad.
Thank you sir 👍
Thanks TH-cam for recommending me this channel.
Sir I have no words to appreciate your efforts
Beautiful Work...💐💐
Guru ji,.
Thanks
Amazing
Sir, Ellora Kailasnath temple pe video banaye🙏 please.
Pls sr keep it up 👍 excilent work
Interesting information. God bless you👌
True history , wonderful !
KK sir unbelievable research and wonderful narration ..better than the best 👍 keep rocking bhai🙏
Thank you bhai
Wonderful Sir 🙏
Thank you ...well researched and informative.Wish we were made aware earlier ☺️
wonderful
Itni gahri feelings or kuhle bichar me apna monki bate bolsakte the hamare purbaj ,lekin ajj hamare pass itna sochhi nehi hay.
Great knowing
Sir, your channel is fascinating and gives so much knowledge and makes me proud of 🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏
Amazing Sir 👏
VERY INFORMATIVE
Outstading research Kusumakar...🙏
Thank you brother.
Wah it's really revisting bygone era
Thank you Sir
it was utterly beautiful
Wonderful.. I wish I get this book in Bengali version...
Incredible 🙏🙏
There are so many love odyssey books like silapaddakam, manimekalai, ramsetuvandana, mudrarakshasa, all are so aesthetically written depicts the broad liberal intellectual minds
❤ *Thanx for teaching beautifully* ♥
Sir g aap ka tarika bilkul ek dam Dada g jaise h love you sir g
Thank you very much
Please make video on relating indian history and glass.
What a fascinating style of narration you have Sir.
I have one question, Sir. Gaha Sattasai was written by 17th Satvahana King Hala almost around 1st Century AD whereas Vatsyayana belonged to 3rd-4th Century CE hence Kamasutra was written later than Gaha Sattasai. How come Gaha Sattasai make a criticism of Kamasutra when it was written earlier also would it be fair to make a comparison of both when these two were written in a completely different time and space. I'll patiently wait for your response Sir. Thank you.
Thank you for watching the video, thinking it through and asking a very interesting question.
Gaha Sattasai has been compiled over time and it spread from one region to another, over time, moment/culture specific situations were addressed in form of short poems and were added to the compilation. Thatswhy a time frame of its compilation has been allotted to it as mentioned in the video. This gives rise to a commentary on relevance of Kamasutra which finds its place in the early poems of Gaha Sattasai. The fluidity of its movement through time and consequent evolution allows space for speculation. In its own way, Kama Sutra, is supposed to have undergone consistent effort over centuries before reaching its datable form.
Also, your observation is brilliant, because, Charles Wilkins while translating Bhagvat Gita with the help of Kashinath Bhattacharya, had observed that it was composed before Atharva Veda, since it mentions all other Vedas except Atharva Veda.
Thank you again.
@@trystwithhistory8480 Thank you so much for your response Sir. It indeed was very helpful. I'll continue to ask my queries in the comment section and wait for your response in other videos.
You are very welcome to ask questions. In the process, we will also learn.
Sir I wish aap humari santali tribe k bare mai research kare jo ki humari history indus vally civilization se juri hai 👏
I couldn't find the mention of name hala in the whole text. Why the text is attributed to king hala?
7:26 Oh sir ❤️
Can anyone give any source where we can read those poems..
Please 🥺🙏
Thank you for watching the video. Please see the references of suggested readings in the description of the video.
@@trystwithhistory8480 I'm going through that right now..
And I have found a beautiful collection of English poem too. th-cam.com/video/jD7P1bBeeeU/w-d-xo.html
Thank you to sir..
Why he isn't making new videos.
We are sure you will enjoy Peter Khoroche's translation as well.
Sir please explain... A L Bhasam' Wonder that was India
Keep it up one day your channel came in million subscribers
Why are these poems not part of our school curriculum but we read centuries old British and American poems? Has no one translated Gatha Saptashati ?
The book is directly connected with history of ancient Maharashtra 👈
It was written In Andhra Pradesh.
Nice sir 👍
Sir need more videos
Nice works Sir...
Sir hindi me gatha satsai kitaab kaise uplabdh hogi? Video me jo aap padh rahe hain wo kis kitaab se hai? Description me sbhi kitaabein english me hain..
Thañk you Sir ..............so interesting .
Thank you for watching the video.
Wow sir … if u can guide pls help me get English or Hindi translation of this book and as many ancient Indian texts that you know are available … I would be so much obliged
Thank you for watching the video. Reference to reading material is given in the description of the video.
Sir, make a video on Origen of Sanskrit.
माननीय
क्या यह गाथा उपलब्ध है। और क्या प्राकृत और और उसके टीका में। और किस नाम से । कृपया लिंक मेजें।या विषय के आलेख में जोड़ने का कष्ट करें।
वीडियो के विवरण में पुस्तकों का उल्लेख है।
Sir please Make One videos History of (Ghazal )🙏🙏🙏
Thanx
In prakrit does meaning os Hal is same as in hindi ?
It is one of the early referances of Marathi language,where some marathi words are used...
Can you please make a video about Kamasutra and Khajuraho temples. I mean what events lead to their creation
We would love to do a sociological study of the era. It may be a bit longish and boring for many. 🙂
Sir, any reference for Hindi version of our ancient love poetry? Need to gift it to my father.
Why law books at the background?
Sir, enlighten.
The castes division of people finds a mention in the Bhagavad-Gita. And the Gita was written by Ved Vyas in about 7000 BCE. You'll find mention in Adhyay 4 Sloka 13.
Sir, this work relates to Deccan where sanskritisation happened much later in time. Reference is made to how wives of Satvahan Kings brought the influence of Sanskrit and north on the language and culture of Deccan.
I am from 'Koti Lingala' the first capital city of Satavahanas.King 'Simuka' is the founder of dynasty.
Srikrishna talks of varnashram dharm ie based on profession chosen on merit and inclination.. not caste... Ved Vyas himself was born of a fisherwoman and highly revered in his own lifetime.
Sir, who talks about caste even in current day Indian love songs.? To make special mention of caste being absent and justifying that it's from Deccan and no Sanskrit influence is imagination going drunk
Ap log abhe bhe nahe samjai kon se cast system......
Wow
I have been listening to your videos with interest. Great work! Please continue your great work.
However, I want to register a criticism on this one. You may want to check your analysis and facts:
1:00 to 1:40 ब्राह्मण, शुद्र, क्षत्रिय का जिक्र नहीं है, so you conclude this was composed before जातीसंस्था came (but examples used are वर्ण). This can’t be. Because Yajurveda and Rigveda mention वर्णसंस्था, etc. just because this one book doesn’t mention them doesn’t mean they were non existent when this poetry composition was written. Further the epigraphy in नाणेघाट proves that even kings in that area were performing Vedic rituals. So you can’t say the Vedic religion had not reached Deccan (and was limited to “भारत” which you talk about as a potentially limited area in early first millennium)
2:55 to 3:30 claims प्राकृत doesn’t have structure or grammar. - not true. प्राकृत sentences are more structured than Sanskrit (like many later languages) and has विभक्ती, verb conjugations etc very similar to Sanskrit and modern Indian languages.
Thank you for your erudite comment. This video is based on material mentioned in the description of the video. Please share some reference reading material on which we can rely. It will be our pleasure to present the contrary view point to our viewers.
sir apka name kya h 🌸🌸🌸⚘🌷🌷🌷🌷
Poem mast hai.