Discovery of India Ep. 7 | Bharat | Aryavart | Jambudwip | Bharat Mata
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ต.ค. 2024
- "Bharat" has come a long way, from a concept and a small Janpad in Panini's Ashtadhyayi (500 B.C.) to a Sovereign Country with definite geographical boundaries in 1947. Here we trace the wondrous journey of "Bharat" through time and we graciously acknowledge the contribuntions of the players in the ever evolving life of "Bharat".
Please share your thoughts on - trystwithhistory@gmail.com
For more wonderful content, please Like, Share and Subscribe to our channel and Follow us on our social media handles :
Twitter - / tryst_w_history
Instagram - / trystwithhi. .
This not-for-profit educational video is based on the information material sourced from the following suggested readings for the viewers;
1. Looking for a Hindu Identity by D. N. Jha
2. Photo Credits - Wikimedia Commons
Well shankaracharya ji visited all india at almost more than 1200 years ago, and built four math in four different directions of India, there is a temple of shankaracharya in kashmir and four math in badrinath, kedarnath, kanchi, Dwarika, puri etc, and was born in kerala
you forgot to mention Shrungeri math... jyotirmath or joshimath as they call it today ...in north, Dwarika at West , Puri in the East and Shrungeri in the South... Four mathas founded by Adi Shankaracharya..
@@sunilkhadilkar7161 yes bro, this uncle has very one sided view towards indian history, perhaps he is puppet of Britishers who destroyed/looted our history and country
@@HimanshuSingh-nb4sz correct
Kanchi is upa mutt it's not pradhaan mutt
Shankaracharya is not an ancient personality, more Medieval 🙂
भारतवर्ष के नौ भेद ‘मत्स्य पुराण’ में इस प्रकार से बताये गये हैं - इन्द्रद्वीप, कसेरू, ताम्रपर्णी, गभस्तिमान्, नागद्वीप, सौम्य, गन्धर्व, वारूण और सागर।
इसे विस्तृत रूप से समझाएं की मत्स्य पुराण ऐतिहासिक है और अगर है तो इसे लिखने का कालखंड भी बताएं यह किस भारत को बता रहा है और यह 9 भाग कौन से हैं
आपकी वीडियो अच्छी लगी थी देख भी रहा था पर आजकी वीडियो आपको भी एजेंडा ग्रस्त सिद्ध करती है
Sir, info in this documentary is not complete. You seem to ignore Ramayana, Mahabharata and Kalidas's Raghuvamsha. Also Vishnupuran which is considered very old [4th century BC??]. Please re-do a documentary. Also refer to Gauda Desha and Dravida Desha references and more.
Also mentioned how Buddhism down
These are not very old books, these are compiled after 7/8th century.
@@tourismhumanity why do you exhibit ignorance and hate. Few things may be added or removed, but are all cleaned up on critical texts. Please read. If possible read books by BBLal and similar
It's reality. You just read History of Sanskrit literature by Baldev Upadhyay.
Can you also tell something about shaktipeeths of devi, total 52 in number, hinglaz mata in present Balochistan, sharda peeth in Neelam valley kashmir, one shaktipeeth in tibbet along mansarovar lake, one in Nepal, few in Bangladesh, few in Nepal, and shankari devi shaktipeeth in sri lanka.
रामायण padhi. hi nahi होगी
uttaraṃ yatsamudrasya himādreścaiva dakṣiṇam
varṣaṃ tadbhārataṃ nāma bhāratī yatra santatiḥ
उत्तरं यत्समुद्रस्य हिमाद्रेश्चैव दक्षिणम् ।
वर्षं तद् भारतं नाम भारती यत्र संततिः ।।
"The country(varṣam) that lies north of the ocean and south of the snowy mountains is called Bhāratam; there dwell the descendants of Bharata."
- Vishnu Purana
शंकराचार्य ने क्या किया और कहा था। इतने बुजुर्ग होकर भी आप एक भारतीय नहीं हो पाये
I disagree with the presentation. In itihaasa Mahabharat - Arjun fought with tribes from
South India and Ramayan has from N to S. Kalidasa 'Meghaduta' refers to Ujjain. Ashoka spent a fortune to conquer Deccan & Orissa. Shankracharya established the Muth in 4 directions of Bharat. The same Vedic culture is prevalent in Northern and Southern areas. Sanskrit is written in all Indian scripts including Devanagari. All Muslims and Christian can trace their grandmothers were Hindu (or following some form of vedic culture). I can rest my case. BTW - you speak good Urdu which is also gift of Bharat😀
His point is geographical concept of bharat , word bharat and its geographical area. From your point of ramayana and mahabharat , how will you establish this link : bharat and its geographical area . Similarly your all point are lack context. And Urdu is not bharatiya , its origin is in persian
Fathers also are Hindu only
बिना मतलब अपनी पीपुड़ी बजाना है। ना रामायण की चर्चा न ही महाभारत की चर्चा। रामायण का श्री लंका और किसकिन्धा, रामेश्वरम दक्षिण भारत में नही तो क्या हिमालय us paar चीन में था। बकैत कहीं के। विशुद्ध भारतीय ग्रंथों को पढ़ो। मेगास्थनीज की इंडिका के हिस्सों को पढ़ो। सब मिलेगा। मनमौजी रूप से अपनी गलत बात को सिद्ध करने के लिए तथ्य वन साइडेड रूप से उठा लिए गए हैं। आपका निष्कर्ष पूर्ण रूप से गलत है।
संस्कृत ,प्राचीन भारत के उत्खनन में कहाँ कहाँ मिला है बताने का कष्ट करेंगे
@@mrjj6887 इन्होंने क्रमवार प्राप्त लिखित श्रोतो को reference मानते हुआ कहा भाई ना की तुम्हारे पुराण रामायण महाभारत क्या कहते है इसके आधार पर कहा
Sir, Bali belong to south India in Ramayana. Lanka was also mentioned in Ramayana. Sugriv was known for direction and Maps. Check Balmiki Ramayan
And sir, this historian is totally fake and talwa chaatu, who believes in fake history written by British missionaries to prove their fake god as true and destroy the real history of mankind. Always remember history written by Europeans are false and total mythology i.e., myth fake.
It's just a mythological tale written by a writer named Valmiki or Balmiki.
@@part-timebrock1126 all thos stories of genesis, devils and angels in bible are mythology, not Ramayana. And christ is the biggest enemy of human history.
@@shushantodas7746 look at this buthurt guy 😂. Both ramayan and Mahabharat are myths. No arrows, no gods, no flying chariots, no elephant faced person. Harappan people created toys and Vedas made them "Gods". As far as Christ goes, everything started from his birth that means he was atleast a real human being. Keep crying anyway....
@@shushantodas7746 also devils and angels are also myths and everyone knows it.
आपका कहना है कि भारत की कल्पना ब्रिटिशों की देन है। आपसे निवेदन है अपना शोध और गंभीर करें।
We can't deny the fact 😅
उत्तरं यत्समुद्रस्य हिमाद्रेश्चैव दक्षिणम् ।
वर्षं तद् भारतं नाम भारती यत्र संततिः ।।
"The country (varṣam) that lies north of the ocean and south of the snowy mountains is called Bhāratam; there dwell the descendants of Bharata."
-Vishnu Purana
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤪🤪🤪🤪🤪🤪🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀
आधा ज्ञान हमेशा नुकसान पहुंचाता है ।।
Sir, very nice video, thanks for providing information about Bharat name history.
I have a question, as in the video you have mentioned that King Asoka inscription on the rock mentions India name as Jamboo dweepa was it excluding only extreme south India ? As King Asoka ruled from Kashmir to few parts Tamil nadu and afghanistan to Burma, then is it right to say our country first name is Jamboo Dweepa.
वीडियो में कथानक ठीक है किंतु कथन अपूर्ण प्रतीत होते हैं रामयण में कहीं भी वर्तमान भारत जिसमें पाकिस्तान ,अफगानिस्तान और बांग्लादेश शामिल है अलग नहीँ दिखाया गया है। भारत मे प्राचीन काल से ही अलग अलग स्थानों पर अलग अलग राज्य रहे किंतु सभी की संस्कृति एक रही और धार्मिक क्रिया कलाप पूरे देश में समान रहे ।अफगानिस्तान से वर्मा की सीमा तक और बलोचिस्तान से कुमारी अंतरीप तक कि सांस्कृतिक सीमा ही भारत के अवधारणा है । यही कारण है कि इस्लाम अपनाने के बाद भी इस सीमा में बसने वालों के रीत रिवाज आज भी लगभग हर क्षेत्र में एक से हैं । प्रस्तुत कर्ता को अधिक शोध की आवश्यकता है ।
अगर पुराणों की प्रामाणिकता आप मानते हैं तो मत्स्य पुराण में भारत की भौगोलिक स्थिति का वर्णन किया गया है, वंशों के वर्णन में भी दक्षिण का वर्णन है,
वीडियो के शुरू में ही कह दिया है सँविधान बनने के बाद भारत बना है
@@सत्यनारायणगोदारा-भ5ङ दरअसल पैराणिक मान्यताओं के बारे में ज़िक्र किया सर ने, इसलिए ये ज़रूरी है कि अनुसंधान प्रामाणिक रहे, इसलिए नहीं कि लोग गलत समझेंगे, बस इसलिये कि बिना पूरा पढ़े चीजों को न कहा जाए, मेरी भी समझ सीमित है परंतु पुराण पढ़ने के बाद इतना तो समझ मे आता है कि भारत की परिकल्पना पुराणों के अनुसार भी हिमालय और कन्याकुमारी के बीच के क्षेत्र को कहा गया है, द्वीपों की बात ठीक है पर भारत का अस्तित्व सीमित नही था...
@@dileep810 bharat never considered south as part of it.. South India is Dravidian land.. Different culture
@@ahareensaha5328 भारत की यही परंपरा रही है, कई संस्कृतियों का मिश्रण....
According to the Vishnu Purana, written anywhere between 400 BC to 900 CE, says, "The country that lies north of the ocean and the south of the snowy mountains is called Bharat for there dwell the descendants of the Bharat."
Uttaram yastsamundrasya,
Himadres Haiva dakshinain
Vaisham tad Bharatam nama
Bharatiyatia santatih.
In other words, it is stated that the subcontinent of India stretches from the Himalayas to the sea. It is known as Bharatvarsha or the land of Bharat where the descendants of Bharata live.
I strongly urge you to consider a remake of the video with Vinshu Puran, Valmiki Ramayana, Mahabharata (reference of the King of Udupi), Arthashahtra and Magasthenes' Indica taken into consideration.
Also, please try to delve deeper into the meaning of 'Desh'. You may be able to differentiate between Rajya (political entity) and Desh/ Rastra/ Varsha (landmass with similar people).
I'm sure, you shall not find the need to twist 'Bharat naam purana hai, par desh naya hai'.
Thank you!
वामपन्थी सुअर ह ये इसे ही तोड़मरोड़ कर इतिहास प्रस्तुत करते आए ह ये अब तक
Superb
उत्तरं यत्समुद्रस्य हिमाद्रेश्चैव दक्षिणम् ।
वर्षं तद् भारतं नाम भारती यत्र संततिः ।।
अशोक का सम्राज्य अफगानिस्तान तक फैला हुआ था
यह राष्ट्र बहुत पुराना है
इस पर आपका शोध अधुरा है
Aapka pura ho gya is pr shodh.....aur aapne ye shodh pura kaha se kiya jara batana
Mi apke is discovery ko ak adhoora vichar manta hu,,,,kioki ajka bharat loktntr ka h ,,,,kashmir se kniakumari, Bangladesh se le k afganistan Tak hum aghand bharat mante h or isme hi saab ka bhla h...Akhand Bharat Mata ki Jai....A bharat mata teraa bhebhav amar rahega 🙏 Jai Ho 🙏
Sir, with all due respect I want to covey that it is not the Britishers who had created the first ever AKHAND BHARAT but it was the mighty Mauryan Dynasty who had created that.
Moreover princely states are not directly ruled as British Indian territory, they are under their suzerainity. In addition to that Portuguese & French too had their own territory in Indian subcontinent.
what about Vikramaditya bharat just see the map at that time period
Not really, the Britishers gave us the modern map of India including Southern states like TN.
The Mauryans were East Indians who conquered the rest of India, Pakistan and parts of Afghanistan and Iran, although not TN and some other North eastern states. 🙂
You may have to read more about Vyasa Mahabharat! God bless
परन्तु, परन्तु! बिना जड़ के आधार की रचना कैसे हो सकती है ? कृपया बताएं !!!
महाशय, आपका यह शोध पूर्वाग्रह से ग्रसित जान पड़ता है।
Sir you forgot meghasthene's indica where he clearly defines the geographical area of india from sindhu to south.
Sir ye sab granth ya kuch bhi ved ik n sab ki original books kaha mil payengi muze bohot ruchi hai apen sanskriti aur etihas me
According to this storyteller there was no concept of "Bharat" and "Bharatmata" before the British era. But thousands year ago Vedabyasa wrote "Mahabharata".
Historian D.N.Jha was a communist.
I don't know this man, but for sure, he has agenda to divide Bharat and praise Abrahamic majhab. Probably funded by Rome or Saudi. I am unsubscribing from his channel
I also askd my mom what is jambhudeep how v cn c it... Coz earth is round
Sir, what name is given to the territory of Maurya and Gupta Empire?
राम राम श्रीमान आपका शुभ नाम क्या है?
Sir,there is reference of Chola and Pandya in Mahabharat
See the interconnections of north and south ,jambudweep since 11200BC when rishi Kashyap crossed Vindhyachal and did a lot for region.
आओ चले असत्य से सत्य की ओर , अंधकार से प्रकाश की ओर , मृत्यु से अमृत्व की ओर , आओ चले प्रकृति की ओर , आओ चले " सनातन " की ओर | धर्म की जय हो, अधर्म का नाश हो |
Mahabharat was written in 400AD. The references for the information and related maps are given as.....
"This not-for-profit educational video is based on the information material sourced from the following suggested readings for the viewers;
1. Looking for a Hindu Identity by D. N. Jha
2. Photo Credits - Wikimedia Commons"
Pandya kingdom in mahabharata war,
Some references from wiki pages, link below,
Please
What about references of southern places in Ramayan going upto srilanka
भारत की आत्मा उसके मंदिरों में बसती है,जो न केवल आस्था,बल्कि (विज्ञान,कला,अर्थशास्त्र,वारियर स्थान,astronomy) के विकास का भी केंद्र है।
अफ़ग़ानिस्तान से मंदिर,समाप्त हो गए,वहाँ के हिन्दू पखता का link धीरे धीरे भारतीय लोग संस्कृति से टूट गया।
Sir do you have treaty of sugouli story for Gurkha people
Sir. Thank u for giving such valueable info. Perhaps there is no information about Gondavana land. So plz give us some info.
अद्भुत शोध, अद्भुत प्रस्तुति। बधाई हो।
Gyan se paripurna video, maja aa gya,
Just one question - didn't mauryan literature and inscriptions talk about Bharat?
Ok, how do you explain as stated ramayana composed in Gupta dynesty era between 200 Ad to 300 Ad, so how can places like Panchwati, Kishkindha, Rameshwar, Takedh, Tadkavan, exist as stated reference to South Indian places came after 10th century Ad, also how come Satvahana, Chera, Chalukya managed to expand partly to madhya pradesh, and Gujrath as to influence great truck road also how come Roman Empire have thought of single indenty as bharat Or Indus way back in 2nd Century BC
Sir Chandra Gupta Maurya Ka akhand Bharat Kya hai eska bare mai nhi bataya Kya hai
3:13 bhaiji तारपिदा नहीं, तारापीड . सारा शोध रोमन में किया था?
सर,
पाणिनि ने अष्टाध्यायी 500 bc में लिखा इस की पुष्टि कैसे होती है इसपर शोध करें और publish करें
Can u add the story of Bharata here?
रामायण में भारत के दक्षिण का भी विवरण है।
Plz add vishnupurana reference in this report . What is it significance in conceptualizing bharata before british?
Sir tell me india is called golden birds how
It is Jain cosmology
Great Jain King kharvela 🤩
Jambudweep is middle part is sumeru parvat where tirthankar bhagwan Abhisheka performed by Indra 😍
Sir I wanted to study about India encient history and vedas
There is a reference of sahdev invading south as part of rajasuya... Subjugating pandyas...
Where was Vidharba..A dry arid place where Dharba grass doesn't grow ?
What about ramayana ? Where was dandakaranya ..Prabhu sriram went to meet rushi munis ?
Sir please tell about South America is patal lok
Who is this person
I accidentally came to this Video
What's his name??
14 August Akhand Bharat Sankalp Divas.
Sir, between 6:35 to 6:45 there was glitch when you define jambu dweep according to purana, why??
Rama visited srilanka how come there is no mention of southern India in our literature?
Aap ke hisab se jo geographical description aap nei jante
Woh hai hi nahi
May I know the name of the anchor please 🙏
It is written in Pali , How you interpret it ?
Sir what is your full name
Please research your topic. Below is from Vishnu Purana. Bharat i.e. India is so well defined here.
उत्तरम् यत् समुद्रस्य हिमाद्रेश्चैव दाक्षेणम् |
वर्षम् तद भारतम् नाम भारती यत्र सन्ततिः ||
The country that lies north of the ocean and south of the snowy mountains is called Bhāratam there dwells the descendants of Bharata.
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
apne vishnu puran or chanakya arthasatra ki bat nhi ki isme bharat k pura varnan kiya h
Who is the this scholar?
Sir, during Chanakya, this period was Before Christ, he himself mentions that Bharat is from Himalayas to Indian Ocean.
From where the name came Bharat
In “Shrimad Bhagwatam" there is a complete description of jambudwip.
Not sure which canto from Bhagwatam.
Who are you sir ❓ Please describe yourself please ❓
Sir ramayan me to south ka zikar hai karnatka tamil nadu srilanka even kashmir ka bhi may be vo kaikayi ka mayika ... Please talk about that also...
Wah! Bharat, an ancient concept but a new nation.
I am still not updated on Jambu Dwip. Kindly elaborate. In our Hindu rituals , Havana and Mantras chanted by Pandit, word Jambu Dwip is still reflected. Was Indo- Gangetic plane surrounded by big rivers was Jambu Dwip. Please clarify.
No for the matter look into Jain and Buddhist literature. Jambo deep is not something on earth, it is a cosmic space where the our earth reside. It is very complicated to explain. But, don't try to allocate Jambu dweep with the geography of this earth. about this thing, it is mention is in Jain Agamas.
th-cam.com/video/t71xk3DvsmE/w-d-xo.html
take it as cosmic distinction of universe. in the video, our earth reside in the sourthern most - Bharat kshetra.
Sir audio problem
Are you an Advocate Sir.
Sir onwhat basis do you say that Mahabharat was written around 2-3 century AD?. The antiquity of Mahabharata has become a matter of opinion for some scholars. Are you following the same approach?
yes at 2.03 min he speaks about Mahabharata being created between 200 to 300 AD . I thought i heard it wrongly so went back 2 to 3 times, but he said the same thing. @tryst with history can you please explain what is the basis of your reference. whereas we know that it was created long back.
The Mahabharata, Volume 1: Book 1: The Book of the Beginning translated and edited by J.A.B. Van Buitenen. Mahabharat as a work is said to have been finally compiled during Gupta period, the outer limit of 400 A. D. has been noted to it. Please see our episodes on Gita for ancillary reference.
@@trystwithhistory8480
Sir, may be it's compiled during Gupta period but mahabharat actually done much before
@@khushi0033 True. We had oral tradition of transferring stories and knowledge. That introduces possibility of alteration with each generation of transfer. Written record is precise. In Study of History, we deal with cogent proof, analysis and research to bring precision to the theory. Belief is more abstract and has to be supported with proof and research. In India our beliefs have to be supported with much more scholarly research. We fervently hope it will happen in the near future.
Sir , panini ki asthadhyayi kis script Mai hai
बस इतना ही कह सकता हूँ कि मेरा आपके श्री चरणों में बार बार प्रणाम है 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Adura Gyan pasand hai kya tumko.
😂😂🤣🤣 inko kehte hai bin pende ke lotee
Sir aapki puri research communist Marxist historian par based hai, bharat varsh hamesha se hai aapka knowledge Indian ancient scripture par full nhi hai aryavart Afghanistan se lekar South tak tha
Is Sir ke baaki sabhi videos bharat ko great dikhaate hai lekin ye video nahi aur dusra matter yeh hai ki yeh saab shakal se toh communist ya leftists nahi lagte lekin is video me to unka hi support waala video banaaya inhone
@@dilip83kumar tumlog gawar ho.. Bharat mein south India kabhi nhi tha.. Tumlog ke dimag mein nhi ghusega yebaat
@@ahareensaha5328 Haa tum hoshiar jo thehre
The timelines do not seem to match with the findings of Nilesh oak and in general most modern historians
South ka bhut refrence hai , रामायण में पढ़े ।। Ved व्यास वाली
उत्तरं यत्समुद्रस्य हिमाद्रेश्चैव दक्षिणम् ।
वर्षं तद् भारतं नाम भारती यत्र संततिः ।।
Uttaraṃ yatsamudrasya himādreścaiva dakṣiṇam
varṣaṃ tadbhārataṃ nāma bhāratī yatra santatiḥ
(VISHNU PURAN)
Source- विष्णु पुराण २.३.१
This shloka means: “The country (Varsam) that lies north of the ocean and south of the snowy mountains is called Bharatam; there dwell the descendants of Bharata.
Therefore, it is also said that the name Bharata is derived from the ancient Indian texts, the Puranas which refers to the land that comprises India as Bharata Varsam. They used this term to distinguish it from other varsas or continents.
Amazing is that this Bharat Empire i.e. Bharatvarsha or India includes the present day of Pakistan, Afghanistan, China, Iran, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, Russia, Turkmenistan, North-West Tibet, Nepal and Bangladesh.
What basis do you have for claiming Mahabharata in 200ad?
How does one connect with you?
Very badly researched if he has read the real ved vyas mahabharat it mentioned many ancient kingdom being part of the battle, kalpanic ho nahi sakta because of enormous visual appeal. From Himalayas to palavas, Many were involved in the war. Centre was Hastinapur. Son of Dushyant bharat conquered india from all angles, you can easily that kind temple architecture still present in tamil nadu. After Hastinapur lost power due to internal struggle. Fellow states prospered with different kings same ideology. India is so enormous that to become sovereign is extremely difficult. Very few kingdoms did it. Otherwise it was distorted but with tremedous cooperation due to similar beliefs
Rama did not cross dandakaranya and reached rameshwaram...then sri Lanka to defeat Ravana?
हमेशा की तरह वीडियो बहुत ही रोचक और ज्ञानवर्धक है। आपके समझाने का तरीका बहुत ही अच्छा है। मैने इस चैनल की सारी वीडियो देख डाली।
brahman vishnu and mahesh is the tridev as per sanatan dharm... we worship idols... and wherever this sanatan culture is followed is the part of Hindustan.. Bharat is the name derived from the king bharat as you know and India means the land beyond Indus river...but the sanatan exists wherever om namah shivay is chanted... you know what I mean...
in the ramayan period there was naimisharanya and dandakaranya all located south of Vindhyas...the panchkutir where Ravan abducted Sita was located in today's Nashik - maharashtra.. the Kishkindha is today's Hampi - karnataka and rameshwar and so on ...even in the countries like Azharbaijan we found hindu temples... Lalitadity king of kashmir expanded his kingdom till Caspian Sea... The Cholas (if I am not wrong) expanded their kingdom to Cambodia, Indonesia etc... world's largest biggest temple exists not in India but in Cambodia Angkor Vat... so we call all those region as ours... and British helped us found this common thread is a silly argument... I am sorry...
Sir plz make more video....
बहुत ही अद्भुत क्षमता है आपकी 🙏
बहोत अच्छा सर। यही अपने लोग आज समज कसे तो बहोत है।
South ka reference isiliye nae hai..coz it did not fought Mahabharata,they were engaged in giving food to..all the army soldiers, uddupii king headed this..
Still uduppi has largest kitchen where food is served free..and it started from DAT day nd continuing till today..
I can only say Thank you
यद्यपि बहुत लम्बे सुंदर इतिहास का विभिन्न आयामों से दर्शन कराने हेतु धन्यवाद,
१९४७से पहले के आपके पूर्वजों को दी आदरांजलि से आपके ज्ञान व सुंदर शैली के साथ ही ऐसा लगता है कि शायद विभागीय अधिकारी या प्रवक्ता हों।
Ye fake history hai, British missionaries ki likhi hue, keval jhoothe J€$us ko true batane ke liye.
FAKE FAKE FAKE
Purana concept Bharat ka,ki geographical description angrezon ki gift thi to sirji Shankaracharya ka 4 math geographical boundaries kya tha. Sir I can't dare to challenge you, I just want a separate video on this perspective. Because I became very very delighted when I listened you.
How come the background books are of law
Because he is a lawyer.
going by this definition all area south of Himalaya till the ocean is India :-)
Sirji here is a Sloka from Vishnu Purana geographical definition of Bharat: उत्तरं यत् समुद्रस्य हिमाद्रेश्चैव दक्षिणम् |
वर्षं तद् भारतं नाम भारती यत्र सन्ततिः ||
Sorry I am not convinced. In Mahabharata Andhra fought in the kirukshetra along with kuvravas against pandavas.
Enjoyed your other episodes before this, but sorry to say, research on this one seems to be a bit inadequate or incomplete. Earlier depictions or description of Bharat are quite common in popular texts like Ramayan which is the text that predates Mahabharat. Sugrivas description of earth goes much beyond bharat and covers large areas of the Earth, no other text does it to such an extent. You can watch Nilesh Oaks talks on Sugrivas Atlas, he has done a great job in presenting it. When Adi Shankaracharya established his maths in the 4 different directions in 4 different corners of Bharat, Badrinath, Shringeri (or was it Rameshwaram one if the two) , Puri and Dwarka....he made it very clear to everyone the idea of Bharat at that time and this was in the 8th century itself, a thousand years before the British could define anything.
are main batata hun . Jinhone nahi pada unko sab theek lagega . I am a student of Ashtadhyayi . Ashtadhyayi is a ultra compact work of Panini summing the rules of sanskrit grammar , it is not a history book .
Even a begginer in ashtadhayi could tell you this , even without going through it .
Ofcourse it DOSENT contain any hint towards the geographical location of Bharat .
I would give a detailed reply to this old trash in some time .
@@namanpal123 he is correct.. Bharat came into existence in 1947
Your informations are incomplete! You need to search more for this topic.
Kindly add other episodes of the series also in this playlist.
Kis puran me bharat mata ka concept paisa hota hai , shriman ji
sare duniya ko chand ko lekar koi confusion nhi hai aap chand pe jakar rahiye 😊