Wow, I didn't knew they made it together, just followed them separately. This is a life gathering for the spirit of sound experience. This performance has a more chill ambient mood, with some hypnotic sequences together. I liked this, just a feeling. Thank you 🙏
Amazing!! I've been a massive fan of both Steve Roach and Tangerine Dream for at least 30 years now. Such a treat to see them perform together!! Thank you for putting this out there!!!
I just wasted 15 seconds of my life reading one of the comments here, hoping that there would have been respect for Edgar's vision of the Quantum years which is sadly not acknowledged by some fans, considering the band has always evolved and current band leader even outlasted Chris Franke. Just my humble opinion as everyone has one...!
Regardless of who they were back then and who they are new, nothing stays the same, that was then, this is now and kudos for TD for keeping the vision and the dream alive for so long.... When I first herd these guys, with the soundtrack from the movie Miracle Mile, I was already listening to Kraftwerk and many others....
Agree, the new TD lead by Thorsten is vastly underrated, especially live in these Sessions, but also the last few albums. Fans that gave up on them during the Jerome years, or the last few albums before Edgar's passing (admittedly a bit too much sameness), need to come back and check this out.
TDs music regardless who actually is currently part of this project always helped me to get along with the madness of this world. So thanks for sharing this!
So I’m about 1/3 through this, and it’s awesome. I do not wish to contribute to any argument, add to any debate. But I sure wish I had been there on this night! They say you can’t find heroes any longer. Here are some of my heroes. ❤
Thanks so much Beth! This both looks and sounds better than what Steve put up on his official channel! Must have been amazing to be there. A once in a lifetime experience.
Lovely performance, the interlocking grooves and tonal colouring here are reminiscent of the years around 1980, especially the superb Tangram and Phaedra albums. This joint ensemble should try to do a reworked version of Tangram 2, with its dramatic reversals and funky, brooding sense of destiny.
I can say even though I absolutely love Krafterk, and will forever be a fan, I was disappointed when I hardly heard any new material from them or new exciting variations on their classic songs when they played here in Vancouver.. I hope Jarre and Olkenfold come here
This evening at the Magnolia turned out better than I anticipated! Especially this encore presentation with Steve Roach! I also recorded the evening from a different angle. I am happy that I did. It wasn't easy trying to stabilize by iPhone for 57 consecutive minutes for one performance! Boy was my hand tired! I bet TD was ready for a break also!
Tangerine Dream was an idea created back in the late 1960’s by Edgar Froese and others in Berlin. The only constant since then up to his death was Edgar but EVERYONE who was involved put something into the bad during their time there. Edgar is no longer there but the “dream” continues and evolves. Music didn’t end when MOZART died and people still play/listen to his music and similar created after his death.
@@stefanocorbellini4480 Except Thorsten Quaeschning is in the band for 15+ years and has composed alongside Edgar and was appointed by him personally to take over the project.
I missed these guys tonight,they're playing one night here in Vancouver,BC... I really hope I get to see them in the future..I hope they did a tribute to Vangellis.. If I still had my Korg Wave Station and my software, Reason, Rebirth,Nunendo etc.. I would put something together...
Love Steve Roach always... I always hadta sift through Tangerine Dreams various incarnations of that band to find songs I liked. Atem, Phaedra and Zeit are more to my liking. I have no idea why these guys still call themselves Tangerine Dream. I love electronic space and ambient music along with other kinds of music. My collection covers a lot of early electronic music. I stopped buying it like I used to cuz it seemed to morph into a sound that became so alike that it started to get indistinguishable but I still search it out. There's still good music out there but quality over quantity is my motto.❤
@@bethchella They actually do publish these improvisations on CDs. They're called Sessions and now there's like eight of them. But the newest has content from Polish concerts from last year, so for this to appear, you"d probably have to wait another one.
wonderful stuff. TD are one of the few acts I've heard who are capable of doing a one song encore which goes on for close to a hour but this is excellent (:
"The enormity of their flat brain; the enormity of their stupidity is just overwhelming. You have to do yourself a favor, when you're out in the country: try to look a chicken in they eye, with great intensity and the intensity of stupidity that is looking back at you is just amazing” Werner Herzog. You can’t miss his particular German accented English. He is talking about chickens. 😂 WTF TD 😂
This is nice but when the original members of TD are no longer the group, they should change the name (brand). Even Jerome Froese is not there with this version of the group.
Awful electronic meditation. No direction and no meaning. Totally empty practicing sequencing of a non professional musician that follows no direction. Sorry for Edgar’s melodies. This is not tangerine dream. If they want to waste our time with more noises like these then forgets their concerts.
Let me just say, comparing someone's style, creativity,skillset, imagination, innovation to someone elses in the same music genre is like comparing two architects with with the same everything and both build two completely different buildings, how stupid and asinine and pointless is that?
I have just wasted 55 minutes of my life, watching this and hoping something musical would emerge, it didn't. As a veteran electronic musician myself, all I have to say is, absolutely boring as always with his "performances". TD will never be the same since Edgar passed away and no original members remain, adding Steve to their show did not help. Just my humble opinion as everybody has one..
Could it be really bad sound quality of the recording? Did you asked yourself if what you heard is really what was played there? To me it is pretty obvious that 90% of the sounds are missing. This kind of music tends to be butchered when recorded and played at low quality. A "veteran electronic musician" like yourself should know that, right?
@@andrew4982 That's what is. I was there at the show. It sounded a lot better in person than it does in the recording. I tried a a couple recordings of the performance too and my audio quality turned out the same too. A phone mic recording doesn't do something so grand like this justice. I thought it was a great experience
This is a dream come true. I love Steve Roach also and these 2 together is so cool
Wow, I didn't knew they made it together, just followed them separately. This is a life gathering for the spirit of sound experience. This performance has a more chill ambient mood, with some hypnotic sequences together. I liked this, just a feeling. Thank you 🙏
Amazing!! I've been a massive fan of both Steve Roach and Tangerine Dream for at least 30 years now. Such a treat to see them perform together!! Thank you for putting this out there!!!
I just wasted 15 seconds of my life reading one of the comments here, hoping that there would have been respect for Edgar's vision of the Quantum years which is sadly not acknowledged by some fans, considering the band has always evolved and current band leader even outlasted Chris Franke. Just my humble opinion as everyone has one...!
Waisted more time responding lol .. was a great show, if you didn't enjoy it, you weren't there.
Great job, I love TD and Steve Roach's music. They have had a strong influence on my music and have always been a role model for me.
I caught TD in DC late last year . . . . . . amazing show. I would've flipped for sure if Steve Roach had walked out for the encore session!
Regardless of who they were back then and who they are new, nothing stays the same, that was then, this is now and kudos for TD for keeping the vision and the dream alive for so long.... When I first herd these guys, with the soundtrack from the movie Miracle Mile, I was already listening to Kraftwerk and many others....
But, but I thought “The Dream is Always the Same” ;-)
Amazing to see Steve with another all-time fave.......totally awesome!!!
Great stuff....absolutely loving the Quantum era music...right up there with the Virgin year stuff in my eyes! Thank you for all your AWESOMENESS!!
Agree, the new TD lead by Thorsten is vastly underrated, especially live in these Sessions, but also the last few albums. Fans that gave up on them during the Jerome years, or the last few albums before Edgar's passing (admittedly a bit too much sameness), need to come back and check this out.
Totally agree
J'adore!
Excellent mate 😊😊😊
This is great, thanks for capturing it. It was my first Tangerine Dream show since the 90s, I think, and Steve roach was a great bonus!
TDs music regardless who actually is currently part of this project always helped me to get along with the madness of this world. So thanks for sharing this!
So I’m about 1/3 through this, and it’s awesome. I do not wish to contribute to any argument, add to any debate.
But I sure wish I had been there on this night!
They say you can’t find heroes any longer.
Here are some of my heroes. ❤
Awesome! I hope this gets an official release. What a brilliant session👌🙂👍
Fabulous...great music...respect!
Thanks for the post. Such an intense and personal piece here. I look forward to collabs between them. The future of TD is in good hands.
Thanks so much Beth! This both looks and sounds better than what Steve put up on his official channel! Must have been amazing to be there. A once in a lifetime experience.
Lovely performance, the interlocking grooves and tonal colouring here are reminiscent of the years around 1980, especially the superb Tangram and Phaedra albums. This joint ensemble should try to do a reworked version of Tangram 2, with its dramatic reversals and funky, brooding sense of destiny.
Precioso momento🪐
Merci 👽
Caught the tour in Portland, front row, nothing short of amazing. I wish I had a recording of it...
I can say even though I absolutely love Krafterk, and will forever be a fan, I was disappointed when I hardly heard any new material from them or new exciting variations on their classic songs when they played here in Vancouver.. I hope Jarre and Olkenfold come here
thank you for uploading. I put up two songs from the same performance for anyone interested. regards
Om 🎹🎶🎉 grande 🎉
This evening at the Magnolia turned out better than I anticipated! Especially this encore presentation with Steve Roach! I also recorded the evening from a different angle. I am happy that I did. It wasn't easy trying to stabilize by iPhone for 57 consecutive minutes for one performance! Boy was my hand tired! I bet TD was ready for a break also!
The struggle was real!
Return to elektronic music ,Tangerine Dream. ...
I know when I'm enjoying a peice from TD because as the intensitiy increases, so does the volume on my listening device!
Tangerine Dream was an idea created back in the late 1960’s by Edgar Froese and others in Berlin. The only constant since then up to his death was Edgar but EVERYONE who was involved put something into the bad during their time there. Edgar is no longer there but the “dream” continues and evolves. Music didn’t end when MOZART died and people still play/listen to his music and similar created after his death.
yes but the people making music after Mozarts passing did not call themselves “Mozart”..
@@stefanocorbellini4480 Except Thorsten Quaeschning is in the band for 15+ years and has composed alongside Edgar and was appointed by him personally to take over the project.
Fake band.
This was the previous show in San Diego, not from September 2023, funny it was posted last month 🤔
It was the September 18 2023 show.
I missed these guys tonight,they're playing one night here in Vancouver,BC... I really hope I get to see them in the future..I hope they did a tribute to Vangellis.. If I still had my Korg Wave Station and my software, Reason, Rebirth,Nunendo etc.. I would put something together...
Love Steve Roach always...
I always hadta sift through Tangerine Dreams various incarnations of that band to find songs I liked. Atem, Phaedra and Zeit are more to my liking. I have no idea why these guys still call themselves Tangerine Dream.
I love electronic space and ambient music along with other kinds of music. My collection covers a lot of early electronic music. I stopped buying it like I used to cuz it seemed to morph into a sound that became so alike that it started to get indistinguishable but I still search it out. There's still good music out there but quality over quantity is my motto.❤
Is there a proper audio recording of this anywhere, rather than one taken from the audience?
It was all improvised so it's unlikely.
@@bethchella They actually do publish these improvisations on CDs. They're called Sessions and now there's like eight of them. But the newest has content from Polish concerts from last year, so for this to appear, you"d probably have to wait another one.
@@krzysztofkietzman3332 oh, that's great!
It was recorded
wonderful stuff. TD are one of the few acts I've heard who are capable of doing a one song encore which goes on for close to a hour but this is excellent (:
Miss Chris franke a lot.
Is the Magnolia in SanDiego? I think Steve joined them in Tucson (or somewhere in AZ) and in San Diego - just curious.
Yes, it's in El Cajon just outside of San Diego. It's actually Steve's home town, too. He played in his current city in Tucson the night before.
Thank you, just wanted to be clear... @@bethchella
I wanted to see the applaud at the end :/
"The enormity of their flat brain; the enormity of their stupidity is just overwhelming. You have to do yourself a favor, when you're out in the country: try to look a chicken in they eye, with great intensity and the intensity of stupidity that is looking back at you is just amazing” Werner Herzog. You can’t miss his particular German accented English. He is talking about chickens. 😂 WTF TD 😂
Paulo, relève le son de la violoniste !!!!!!!!!!!
Ma....dove sono Frank Froese e Baumann...i veri Tangerine Dream ?
This is nice but when the original members of TD are no longer the group, they should change the name (brand). Even Jerome Froese is not there with this version of the group.
Too bad,😿
it's hard to summon up at least at little bit of enthusiasm here...
Well I guess it sucks to be you doesn't it?
@@theeverythingelectronicsst3897 thanks for your kind words. I consider myself lucky for not being you, which is a blessing I am very thankful for
Ionno. I’m fairly chuffed! Really enjoyed the recent TD Sessions sets, adore Steve and Rubycon made an electronica fan out of me way back in 1975.
@@frankhoulihanfh4972 I adore Rubycon, and I feel nothing but respect for Steve... but this is a bit pathetic, no?
Awful electronic meditation. No direction and no meaning. Totally empty practicing sequencing of a non professional musician that follows no direction. Sorry for Edgar’s melodies. This is not tangerine dream. If they want to waste our time with more noises like these then forgets their concerts.
Let me just say, comparing someone's style, creativity,skillset, imagination, innovation to someone elses in the same music genre is like comparing two architects with with the same everything and both build two completely different buildings, how stupid and asinine and pointless is that?
I have just wasted 55 minutes of my life, watching this and hoping something musical would emerge, it didn't. As a veteran electronic musician myself, all I have to say is, absolutely boring as always with his "performances". TD will never be the same since Edgar passed away and no original members remain, adding Steve to their show did not help. Just my humble opinion as everybody has one..
Could it be really bad sound quality of the recording? Did you asked yourself if what you heard is really what was played there? To me it is pretty obvious that 90% of the sounds are missing. This kind of music tends to be butchered when recorded and played at low quality. A "veteran electronic musician" like yourself should know that, right?
Well, I guess you must be the God of Electronic Music than said no one ever lol
Agree, wheres the heavy sequencing and soloing.
@@andrew4982 That's what is. I was there at the show. It sounded a lot better in person than it does in the recording. I tried a a couple recordings of the performance too and my audio quality turned out the same too.
A phone mic recording doesn't do something so grand like this justice. I thought it was a great experience
@@paulcollins5586 It's on all the other Sessions improvisations BUT this one with Steve Roach, an AMBIENT composer. This one is the outlier.
people who record td on phones are crap