Rares do not cost less to upgrade at the Smith. Upgrade cost is based on the number of upgrades already on the item and upgrading an item via imprinting an aspect allows for a 4th upgrade at smith where rares can only have 3 upgrades. As a rare or legendary, upgrades 1 to 3 cost the same, progressively more each time and a 4th upgrade costs quite a bit, typically in the 100k+ range You are correct about 'enchanting' an item to reroll a mod at the occultist though, it takes a 'fiend rose' or some other item that we cant get in the beta (found in helltide events iirc)
Thank you, now I understand how to do it. I tried to view another TH-camr's vid but he was all over the place and rushing through it. You were very informative and did a great job explaining things.
Unfortunately, I missed most of the days, I was only able to play it for two days... I'm biting my fingers for this, since I've seen this game born, I've never been able to say anything at the beginning, about the game, of what I thought. Now I can say that, from the very beginning I had noticed a fighting style, although initially very rudimentary but it already showed how it would be in the future. Now that I've seen it "assembled" with a story, music, graphics "and all the textures..." as well as an excellent series of complete translations into various languages, I can say that I love it. Knowing Blizzard there will be many changes, dictated by the high number of feedb. and this will lead this game to become, I'm sure, GREAT.
The weapon in your video didn't double-roll vulnerable damage; each weapon type has an inherent buff up top just under the DPS--for crossbow it is vulnerable damage. Gloves don't have a decreased value to aspects, they just don't have an increased value to the aspect.
Great video. It explained a lot of questions that I had about the Codex of Power and how to go about upgrading your weapon with an aspect. Very nicely done.
Moxsy...I'm so glad you got into Diablo 4 bro. I've watched you thru Borderlands 3 and always looked forward to seeing the next crazy build there and now, we get to see you here in this game. Hells to the yeah bro, keep the bangers coming.
Really good guide, I found out after that you can only have one aspect of the same equipped, it greys out the others. Don't think you mentioned this. Interface could do with a warning :(
I have a problem... i upgraded a rare weapon 2 times and an imprint after that. Now, every time i want to imprint a god damn rare weapon (non upgraded), it ask for Baleful Fragments!!!... wich are very difficult to get... Maybe it's not a good ideia to upgrade a rare before imprinting it... or my game just bugged out. Anyone? Please help
I put a codex of power on a good weapon and now I cant put it on my new weapon because I need baleful fragments, so be careful what you’re putting them on even if it can be taken off.
I just wished that when you upgraded an item at the blacksmith that it would upgrade the item power higher. Right now upgrading 1 time increases the item power by 5. The issue is that you can find that easily at your same level. It would be better if it upgraded it maybe by 20 points so the weapon lasts longer until you find another.
That would be awful… you’d be able to take the first drop and upgrade it and never find a drop better until the next tier. You’d never need to have drops. It’s a small increment because it’s for min-max at the end game, not for leveling.
@@SuspenseGames thats a little exagerated dont you think, next tier. 5 item power each upgrade is super low, why even upgrade it? 3 minutes later you can find a weapon that will be the same amount as your newly upgraded weapon. I found weapons with an item power level difference 20 to 30 points in my same character level.
Question, let's say I'm looking for ranks of a specific ability or skill like more ranks in chain lightning. Are all the skill available to add to our gear or just some?
Great video! Thanks for explaining how to do this. I thought I lost my aspect when I took it off. Didn't realize there was an aspect tab in the inventory.
This is pretty cool. It looks like imprinted rares that become legendaries can still only have 3 passives so a natural rolled legendary or a legendary that's been imprinted will be better if it has better stats but this works until you get that. I was curious how this system worked and couldn't get the materials in time to try it.
The system is almost like what they have in Diablo Immortal. What I don't currently see implemented here is upgrading your weapon to a higher power level by sacrificing a higher level item.
I would have never put the thought into doing this type of stuff before. I'm usually just see green or red and equip. Seems pretty simple now that it is explained. Should make the game more enjoyable now that I can put a little more thought into things and keep an eye out for stats -- THANKS!
It seems to me that for weapons and armor, you should continue using whatever is green until you reach endgame. If you spend a bunch of gold enhancing weapons and armor before then, no matter how awesome the stats you craft, it will become obsolete within a few levels when you just need more raw dps or armor. That's my humble understanding. I hope someone can correct me with a clear explanation.
The downside with this is you will lose 1 affix from a legendary item. Converted legendaties will only have 3 affixes compared to 4 affixes from an original legendary. Although, you won't extract an aspect in the first place if that legendaries have good stats. This is a good strategy to get good items but not that most optimum. There is a way to change stats on original legendaries but not available in the beta yet. Change the aspect and affix that you don't like boom much better. retained the 4th affix.
So i got a legendary necklace drop at level 32 that increases basic attack by 33%. Will there be a way to always use the necklace as I progress through the game and it scale well or will I need something with more item power later on?
nice video, just one thing i was wondering, after you upgrade it i see its still on low lvl, lvl 4, is'nt that bad ? i mean will it not be better with a higher lvl gear?
The REAL question here is, is it worth it to do stuff like this while we are leveling during the actual release? Is it better to keep resources for later? Maybe just making normal gear with good rolls legendaries from the codex is just.. good enough while leveling, and keep the actual legendaries for later? Those are questions worth answering.
Great video man! Explained it well. Haven’t played Diablo since Diablo 2 old days. And I’m gonna return for Diablo 4. U seem like a good dude to follow for some help when the game launches. Can’t wait. Subbed ✅
does the rare give the same increase in stats as the legendary only cheaper or does the legendary give more stats at blacksmith if you make it legendary first?
I'm wondering exactly the same thing and no one seems to talk about it. Is it worth to transfer legendary aspect into rare gear before max level ?? (maybe they are doing it cause its the beta and max is 25??). I saw that you can upgrade gear up to 3 or 4 times in the blacksmith (like in the vid, he did it once) and it can give 20 level max or something, so i guess its not worth at lower level if thats the only way to level up gear, right?
@Théo SH yeah, I made the mistake of throwing a lege affix on a rare item, but regretted it when I know better gear would drop soon. Wish I could take imprints off again, maybe for an increased cost each time. I hate my luck, especially with so much rng for drops.
Keep up the good work.A lot of things explained... i would love to find 2 same items and to upgrade 1 rare and than extrack legendary and other extract legendary and than upgrade to see if there is diffrence. Also i saw somewhere that some legendary powers increase or decrease item level , so if you got high level legendary aspec it might cause your item to higher level which can be higher than your level and you cant wear it.
Hi Moxsy Have You Ever Heard of Last Epoch and Could You Play It Sometimes. The Game is on Steam and It's Like Diablo II & III or Path of Exile Thank You.
I am your 1000th thumbs up so now you owe me a psvr 2 set. ;) By the way, did you know that on level 16 stats on gear gets better and sometimes doubled? I saw a TH-camr talking about it. For example: if a gear item between level 1-15, gives you 1 rank on a ability, on level 16 this same item has the possibility of having an extra rank, making it two points. This means the level on gear does matter and it seems like there are hidden level caps when it comes down to gear. With this in mind, I wonder how level 70-100 gear will be.
The only draw back with this game system. You can not extract that legendary power after it has been imprinted onto a rare. So you can't keep cycling that power to your next best rare. You will have to wait for another lego to drop to extract it and it may not be as good. It could be a lot worse though.
I also notice you can’t put any legendary you extract to just any item type. How can you know before hand what item type the legendary can be applied to before deciding to extract? I hope there’s a way to figure this out beforehand. I extracted a ring legendary to put on my waist but found out it can only be applied to weapons and rings but not my waist.
@@jilau7478 You could of been an adult and actually had a conversation instead of proving how much of a child you are. But here you go. Correction. The system only states that you can extract the powers from a legendary item. When you imprint it, it becomes a legendary item. The problem is in the explanation with in the game and the item being named a legendary still. They shouldn't continue to be called a legendary item and have the same item coloration as a legendary. Now go to the corner and shut up if you can't behave.
Question: Yes we can extract the aspect, but i find it hard to let go of my level 22 Armor with +8 on all stats compared to another higher level armor without it, should i always focus on the number being green when i replace the armor? so regardless if the higher level armor doesnt have +8 on all stats, it is still the better one? Because if thats the case, i will end up with a build filled with high level yellows instead of full low level legendaries. Thanks
I have a question please, for you or anyone out there. After putting an imprint at the lowest roll, is it possible to improve the roll somehow? Eg, If you imprint an aspect and its range is 1-4 and it defaults to 1 on the imprinted item, is there a way to get the number higher at all to say a 3 or 4 for example? Thank you in advance!! Useful vid BTW!!!!
No. At least it wasn't in the beta at all. I think they want you to farm Legendries for the higher rolls just to keep them viable. Just keep in mind, affixes you get from Legendries can only be applied once and can not be removed again.
OmG ... I didn't expect to buy/play this game so I didn't watch 20 - 50 video's about it >< I wish there was an in game tutorial >< Sigh ... just learning about these things, but thanks for the info :)
Nice video, nice guide, i am gonna tell you something too, rare stuff have not " +1 level on skill " i think this Is huge buff even if legendary Power is not a goodroll, suppose i need to do some test in to It, but last beta i had Hydra on sorcer at grade 7 and deal massive dps so this beta i'll try the same with necromancer. Thanks for share! 💪
Got a ring legendary with the effect being if a storm skill crits it adds a buff aura on me that spams strong lightning strikes on enemies near me and now I just walk around throw an earth basic out to get a crit chance buff from another Lego and then hit tornado or hurricane or w.e and I just start raining strong lightning spamming lol. Super good w the ultimate lucky hit too
Do the same legendary effects stack? for example, the same legendary aspect has been extracted and now I put one on my 2 handed weapon and another one on an amulet. Will I get the same benefit twice? or is it unique and only applies once
Watching people that have UI and be able to do all this is nuts. I had no UI, no mini map, No nothing, Had to guess and use photos off the internet in order to use skill points. Hope that gets fixed.
Helpful video but i cannot for the life of me find any other videos from you on diablo your page does not have diablo playlists and the search for diablo brings up nothing >>>> did you make more ?
Rares do not cost less to upgrade at the Smith. Upgrade cost is based on the number of upgrades already on the item and upgrading an item via imprinting an aspect allows for a 4th upgrade at smith where rares can only have 3 upgrades. As a rare or legendary, upgrades 1 to 3 cost the same, progressively more each time and a 4th upgrade costs quite a bit, typically in the 100k+ range
You are correct about 'enchanting' an item to reroll a mod at the occultist though, it takes a 'fiend rose' or some other item that we cant get in the beta (found in helltide events iirc)
Thank you, now I understand how to do it. I tried to view another TH-camr's vid but he was all over the place and rushing through it. You were very informative and did a great job explaining things.
you should say that once aspects can only be imprinted once if it comes from a legendary item
Unfortunately, I missed most of the days, I was only able to play it for two days... I'm biting my fingers for this, since I've seen this game born, I've never been able to say anything at the beginning, about the game, of what I thought. Now I can say that, from the very beginning I had noticed a fighting style, although initially very rudimentary but it already showed how it would be in the future. Now that I've seen it "assembled" with a story, music, graphics "and all the textures..." as well as an excellent series of complete translations into various languages, I can say that I love it. Knowing Blizzard there will be many changes, dictated by the high number of feedb. and this will lead this game to become, I'm sure, GREAT.
Super happy they put this in the game, seems like it will add a lot of fun and help with a little less grinding
I wouldn't be so sure about that.
what are you talking about. There are like a million different stats, there are stats I haven't even seen roll yet, there's even more RNG than in D3
How do you get your sword glowing ? :)
The weapon in your video didn't double-roll vulnerable damage; each weapon type has an inherent buff up top just under the DPS--for crossbow it is vulnerable damage.
Gloves don't have a decreased value to aspects, they just don't have an increased value to the aspect.
Great video. It explained a lot of questions that I had about the Codex of Power and how to go about upgrading your weapon with an aspect. Very nicely done.
Moxsy...I'm so glad you got into Diablo 4 bro. I've watched you thru Borderlands 3 and always looked forward to seeing the next crazy build there and now, we get to see you here in this game. Hells to the yeah bro, keep the bangers coming.
Really good guide, I found out after that you can only have one aspect of the same equipped, it greys out the others. Don't think you mentioned this. Interface could do with a warning :(
June can’t come fast enough!
Saved me a lot of confusion. Quick question;
What is the weapon level cap? Should we wait until that cap before spending recourses upgrading it
This is exactly what I was looking for. Can you make an in depth guide? Super confusing for me. Never really played Diablo
Great videos moxsy I used your poisonslide build all the way from 50 to 100 and love it. Tried other builds but nothing feels as good and fun to play.
I have a problem... i upgraded a rare weapon 2 times and an imprint after that. Now, every time i want to imprint a god damn rare weapon (non upgraded), it ask for Baleful Fragments!!!... wich are very difficult to get... Maybe it's not a good ideia to upgrade a rare before imprinting it... or my game just bugged out. Anyone? Please help
Thank you for that, the whole process confused me on beta. Now I understand! ❤
I put a codex of power on a good weapon and now I cant put it on my new weapon because I need baleful fragments, so be careful what you’re putting them on even if it can be taken off.
Perfectly explained and demonstrated. Good sir, can you please make a video explaining the codex of power? Thank you
You earned yourself a sub... well done video.
I just wished that when you upgraded an item at the blacksmith that it would upgrade the item power higher. Right now upgrading 1 time increases the item power by 5. The issue is that you can find that easily at your same level. It would be better if it upgraded it maybe by 20 points so the weapon lasts longer until you find another.
That would be awful… you’d be able to take the first drop and upgrade it and never find a drop better until the next tier. You’d never need to have drops. It’s a small increment because it’s for min-max at the end game, not for leveling.
@@SuspenseGames thats a little exagerated dont you think, next tier. 5 item power each upgrade is super low, why even upgrade it? 3 minutes later you can find a weapon that will be the same amount as your newly upgraded weapon. I found weapons with an item power level difference 20 to 30 points in my same character level.
Bummer, I never looked for the Advanced stats option. Where was that?
You have to turn it on in the Options Screen under gameplay
Super helpful guide! Would've taken me some unfun troubleshooting to sort out the proper setup on my own, so thank you!
Oh shoot. Mox is doing Diablo content. Whoop!
should you fully upgrade it before imprinting?
Glad to see you dip into Diablo series as well, hope you will craft some broken builds for us like in Borderlands :) Do you plan to pick it up ?
I’ve been playing it a bunch. Might post my beta build just to show but will have full coverage on launch
Holy moly - after this bit of info the demons of Diablo 4 stand no chance at all
Question, let's say I'm looking for ranks of a specific ability or skill like more ranks in chain lightning. Are all the skill available to add to our gear or just some?
Well done vid. You broke it down perfectly!
Great video! Thanks for explaining how to do this. I thought I lost my aspect when I took it off. Didn't realize there was an aspect tab in the inventory.
I Watched all ur borderlands 3 Videos,
So Happy that u play diablo 4
Looking forward for some op builds.
fantastic guide, ty! This was quite complex to figure out within the beta
Nice video hadn’t fully examined this and was amazing to figure out. Thanks!!
This is pretty cool. It looks like imprinted rares that become legendaries can still only have 3 passives so a natural rolled legendary or a legendary that's been imprinted will be better if it has better stats but this works until you get that. I was curious how this system worked and couldn't get the materials in time to try it.
The system is almost like what they have in Diablo Immortal. What I don't currently see implemented here is upgrading your weapon to a higher power level by sacrificing a higher level item.
I would have never put the thought into doing this type of stuff before. I'm usually just see green or red and equip. Seems pretty simple now that it is explained. Should make the game more enjoyable now that I can put a little more thought into things and keep an eye out for stats -- THANKS!
It seems to me that for weapons and armor, you should continue using whatever is green until you reach endgame. If you spend a bunch of gold enhancing weapons and armor before then, no matter how awesome the stats you craft, it will become obsolete within a few levels when you just need more raw dps or armor. That's my humble understanding. I hope someone can correct me with a clear explanation.
The downside with this is you will lose 1 affix from a legendary item. Converted legendaties will only have 3 affixes compared to 4 affixes from an original legendary. Although, you won't extract an aspect in the first place if that legendaries have good stats. This is a good strategy to get good items but not that most optimum. There is a way to change stats on original legendaries but not available in the beta yet. Change the aspect and affix that you don't like boom much better. retained the 4th affix.
Great video. Solved everything i needed to know in 1 video
I learned a lot, good looking out!
I'm confused when I pre-ordered ultimate edition, it says I'll get a code but didn't get it
For xbox
very informative in a short video! keep it up man!
Awesome video! No idea all this existed. Thanks from all us newbs. Lol
is that just a tooltip glitch in the roll possibility after you imprinted?
Wonder if it's better to farm that one area that drops level 30 gear and upgrade those to legendaries
So i got a legendary necklace drop at level 32 that increases basic attack by 33%. Will there be a way to always use the necklace as I progress through the game and it scale well or will I need something with more item power later on?
THANK YOU so much for this thorough tutorial. It is VERY well done, and greatly appreciated. I learned so much from this!
is there a reason why i can’t add socket to a piece of armor? gauntlet.
nice video, just one thing i was wondering, after you upgrade it i see its still on low lvl, lvl 4, is'nt that bad ? i mean will it not be better with a higher lvl gear?
The REAL question here is, is it worth it to do stuff like this while we are leveling during the actual release?
Is it better to keep resources for later?
Maybe just making normal gear with good rolls legendaries from the codex is just.. good enough while leveling, and keep the actual legendaries for later?
Those are questions worth answering.
Great video man! Explained it well. Haven’t played Diablo since Diablo 2 old days. And I’m gonna return for Diablo 4. U seem like a good dude to follow for some help when the game launches. Can’t wait. Subbed ✅
does the rare give the same increase in stats as the legendary only cheaper or does the legendary give more stats at blacksmith if you make it legendary first?
I do love being able to put lege affixed on rare gear. Wish there was a way to increase the level of gear, but maybe I missed if that is a thing.
I'm wondering exactly the same thing and no one seems to talk about it.
Is it worth to transfer legendary aspect into rare gear before max level ?? (maybe they are doing it cause its the beta and max is 25??). I saw that you can upgrade gear up to 3 or 4 times in the blacksmith (like in the vid, he did it once) and it can give 20 level max or something, so i guess its not worth at lower level if thats the only way to level up gear, right?
@Théo SH yeah, I made the mistake of throwing a lege affix on a rare item, but regretted it when I know better gear would drop soon. Wish I could take imprints off again, maybe for an increased cost each time. I hate my luck, especially with so much rng for drops.
Keep up the good work.A lot of things explained... i would love to find 2 same items and to upgrade 1 rare and than extrack legendary and other extract legendary and than upgrade to see if there is diffrence. Also i saw somewhere that some legendary powers increase or decrease item level , so if you got high level legendary aspec it might cause your item to higher level which can be higher than your level and you cant wear it.
Thx for the video man finally someone who makes sense.. I was a little bit lost 😅
Really a good thing to put in game..thanks dude
Why is attack power at 0 even though you have 2 daggers equipped?
What is the “control” button for ps5?
Which mob drops that sword with fire? looks like a specific boss.
Seriously so damn helpful! Thank you
Hey man, that was super helpful. Thanks!
Good explanation of the process 🎉
Hi Moxsy Have You Ever Heard of Last Epoch and Could You Play It Sometimes. The Game is on Steam and It's Like Diablo II & III or Path of Exile Thank You.
Beautiful way to min max
Thanks a lot, man! At least for me, the crafting was a little confused, so.. cheers 😊
Omg thank you so much for the video 😱
nice info, thanks man.. appreciate it
I am your 1000th thumbs up so now you owe me a psvr 2 set. ;) By the way, did you know that on level 16 stats on gear gets better and sometimes doubled? I saw a TH-camr talking about it. For example: if a gear item between level 1-15, gives you 1 rank on a ability, on level 16 this same item has the possibility of having an extra rank, making it two points. This means the level on gear does matter and it seems like there are hidden level caps when it comes down to gear. With this in mind, I wonder how level 70-100 gear will be.
The only draw back with this game system. You can not extract that legendary power after it has been imprinted onto a rare. So you can't keep cycling that power to your next best rare. You will have to wait for another lego to drop to extract it and it may not be as good. It could be a lot worse though.
I also notice you can’t put any legendary you extract to just any item type. How can you know before hand what item type the legendary can be applied to before deciding to extract? I hope there’s a way to figure this out beforehand. I extracted a ring legendary to put on my waist but found out it can only be applied to weapons and rings but not my waist.
@@blackstrings Go to 6:09 in the video. The item types are listed as "Allowed Item Types".
Yeah so you don't get a gg item off the Bat and never have to farm for it again. Durrr herrr what a dumb comment
@@jilau7478 You could of been an adult and actually had a conversation instead of proving how much of a child you are. But here you go.
Correction. The system only states that you can extract the powers from a legendary item. When you imprint it, it becomes a legendary item. The problem is in the explanation with in the game and the item being named a legendary still.
They shouldn't continue to be called a legendary item and have the same item coloration as a legendary.
Now go to the corner and shut up if you can't behave.
Question: Yes we can extract the aspect, but i find it hard to let go of my level 22 Armor with +8 on all stats compared to another higher level armor without it, should i always focus on the number being green when i replace the armor? so regardless if the higher level armor doesnt have +8 on all stats, it is still the better one? Because if thats the case, i will end up with a build filled with high level yellows instead of full low level legendaries. Thanks
I have a question please, for you or anyone out there. After putting an imprint at the lowest roll, is it possible to improve the roll somehow? Eg, If you imprint an aspect and its range is 1-4 and it defaults to 1 on the imprinted item, is there a way to get the number higher at all to say a 3 or 4 for example? Thank you in advance!! Useful vid BTW!!!!
No. At least it wasn't in the beta at all. I think they want you to farm Legendries for the higher rolls just to keep them viable. Just keep in mind, affixes you get from Legendries can only be applied once and can not be removed again.
I wasted so many good items, I thought waiting for T3 to worry about this was okay, I need to start double checking my yellows I guess.
So i can only change ONE affix not all of them?
So the 3 times upgraded rare became a 2 times upgraded legendary and all the upgrade costs are back on the same level as upgrading a legendary ^^.
OmG ... I didn't expect to buy/play this game so I didn't watch 20 - 50 video's about it >< I wish there was an in game tutorial >< Sigh ... just learning about these things, but thanks for the info :)
Nice video, nice guide, i am gonna tell you something too, rare stuff have not " +1 level on skill " i think this Is huge buff even if legendary Power is not a goodroll, suppose i need to do some test in to It, but last beta i had Hydra on sorcer at grade 7 and deal massive dps so this beta i'll try the same with necromancer.
Thanks for share! 💪
thanks alot ! great guide :)
As always, thank you for doing incredible work Mox.✨️
Crafting like a boss hehehehhe
Great video.
Yeah, we're gonna need a series of build videos because I'm having a blast with the Druid right now
Got a ring legendary with the effect being if a storm skill crits it adds a buff aura on me that spams strong lightning strikes on enemies near me and now I just walk around throw an earth basic out to get a crit chance buff from another Lego and then hit tornado or hurricane or w.e and I just start raining strong lightning spamming lol. Super good w the ultimate lucky hit too
how many affix can you re roll?
Do the same legendary effects stack? for example, the same legendary aspect has been extracted and now I put one on my 2 handed weapon and another one on an amulet. Will I get the same benefit twice? or is it unique and only applies once
They don’t stack
Amazing video makes sense now :)
Great video, very good information
But can you do this to a legendary? Dumb question I'm sure.
Watching people that have UI and be able to do all this is nuts. I had no UI, no mini map, No nothing, Had to guess and use photos off the internet in order to use skill points. Hope that gets fixed.
Thank you for the informative and easy to understand video :)
When the game releases, I think I might have to hold onto some of the stronger legendaries until I am max level.
Thanx for the great Tutorial
That bow was requested level 4 lmao does power leveling new champs going to be that op
It was always refreshing to see you greet us in your Borderlands 3 videos. Now, you are more subdued in your D4 videos? What happened?
Why I just came across this video just now after I salvage so many good aspect items😢
Helpful video but i cannot for the life of me find any other videos from you on diablo your page does not have diablo playlists and the search for diablo brings up nothing >>>> did you make more ?
This was great, however every time you don't open with "...another Borderlands (whatever) video." It feels off. It's really odd lol.
Honestly the beta didnt do a great job of explaining all this. This video was super helpful and il be bookmarking it for when the game comes out
I just want to try out necro
Thank you!
I don't think i'm going to even attempt to log in at midnight tonight...
lol I found that exact same crossbow and got the exact same dex roll when I replaced :P
So it has to be the ultimate edition to get the beta right?
Any preorder for early and free this upcoming weekend to every one
the unique items levels 30-50 when the game is finalized will be really good looking forward to the actual release of this game!
Thanks!!
Mid maxing lvl 25 is funny, why not mention uniques?
Good job