I encountered this request after doing the Valentine bank robbery with Bill, Lenny, and Karen. I remember it so vividly because I remember thinking about how truly alive this game felt. Lenny, Swanson, Javier, Uncle, Pearson, and Myself sat in the circle and listened to the story. After Lenny finished there was a couple minutes silence, Javier pulled out a guitar and started playing a song about a love so strong you couldn't comprehend. I remember listening to that whole song, turning the game off, and just laying in bed in silence for a while just feeling at peace. God this game is such a masterpiece.
@51 50 ah, yes, because a single significant moment of immersion in a game known for causing that feeling CLEARLY means I have no social life, lol. Terminally online thought process.
I remember I came back from hunting deer in was in the middle of the night both in real time and in game where Charles sat down and started talking about how he didn't really understand life and how he was born to suffer next thing i know it begins to rain and javier began to play on his guitar with the critters in the back eventually having the sun slowly rise and having a song play in the background and I just remember thinking "This Is probably the most immersive game I ever played" Still holds up and I end up getting lost for hours
That cabin is the only place to get the pipe requested by Dutch! I've donated SO MANY silver pocket watches to the camp fund, I could've sent us all to Tahiti on the money they would've brought. btw, If Dutch REALLY wanted to escape to Tahiti, there was more than enough money in camp to do that, he was just greedy and wanted MORE!
OK, I think I FINALLY found the best way to trigger this. I was in chapter 4 reloading 8 PM fire chats and midnight fire chats OVER AND OVER AND OVER and I was about to give up. What FINALLY worked was I was in camp and SAVED around 8 PM. Heard chat by the fire that wasn't Lenny and went to sleep till midnight. Got up and went over to the fire and FINALLY got the story about Lenny's father and the watch. I suggest you use this format if you want to trigger this. It gives you two different conversations in one evening to load as opposed to the crap shoot doing just one. Save at 8 PM, sleep till midnight, listen to fire chat, repeat till you get Lenny's story. Hope this helps those who were as frustrated as I was.
How far in chapter 4 were you? I have the mission a gilded cage available and i've tried this but i can't seem to trigger it I've been trying in every single previous camp but i can't get this one to trigger
@@PringlesCan1968 I was fairly close to the end of chapter 4 IIRC. It's been six months so it's not as fresh in my memory. It took me so many times and it drove me nuts when i was previous camp. Like I said. Save at 8 PM and sleep till midnight for two chances at it instead of one.
Came here to watch the cutscene because I was so moved by his story, and since I already love Lenny, I gave him the pocket watch that I already had on me the second I could and the only reply I got from Lenny was: “good”. Maybe it was because I was sitting at the campfire at the same time as him and it glitched so it didn’t trigger any cutscenes. Anyway, I was like “Ain’t no way it’s just that !, just a simple word from Lenny? No way”. Glad to know I wasn’t mistaken. Had to watch the full thing here and you can have my like lmao
In case it doesnt spawn for anyone, just go rob a train or loot enemies. Any watch will do except for the ones you buy at the store or the ones in train safes.
Damn same here, also where am I supposed to go to collect the reward?? I’m worried it didn’t trigger the reward for me because he just walked off as soon as I gave him the thing
@@oliviawilson441same, I gave him the watch and the mission says “return to your tent for a reward” but there’s no reward? 🤷🏼♂️ As fun as it is, this game is a little frustrating at times.
I wanted to watch what he said because lenny accidently stepped into the fire when I gave it to him lmao. Like literally I give it to him I hear screaming and poor Lenny is on fire and it interrupted the dialogue. I was like oh man I feel like I'm missing out on something.
@@null00003 they way he did it the skin was in poor condition, from the back, you get a clean shot and a pristine skin, however going in the front the way he did was a good way to contribute to the achievement: Grin and Bear it!
i think mine glithed, i just happened to have random platinum pocket watch from looting a body or something, and gave it to him. he said nothing in return so i think it was bugged. i never visited that hut with the bear tho.
you couldn't have given him the platinum watch, it would not register that you have an item to give! you must've had a silver one in inventory from looting that you didn't realize you had! sometimes they won't say anything, but if you check your log (D-pad or L on PC), you will see that you gave it and check your tent for a reward!
usually the pearson rabbit request and Dutch's pipe request give me the most trouble, but latest playthrough I got them to happen right away soon after arriving in Horseshoe Overlook. but Lenny and Bill are being stubborn. I heard Lenny tell a story about his Grandmother birthing his mother who was the object of the Overseers innapropriate affections, but never the story about his Fathers watch! True I'm still in Ch. 2, and you can get this request up til ch 4. so , I'm not TOO upset about it! I expect in chapter 3, I'll get Tilly's neclace request, Lenny's pocket watch request, and Bill's Pomade request! I guess the game doesn't want me to get them all done in chapter 2!
@@coyotegaming4027 Yeah seems different every playthrough. I'm in Ch4 right now with only Lenny's pocketwatch request to unlock just afking in camp at night near the fire lol.
@@STRAIXSTER how? Everytime I go to the campfire it's reverand, Micah, Javier or uncle opening their gob...never Lenny...do you know that trigger state? I am with 3-4 or quests left in chapter 3. Can't trigger Pearson as well...
Can this story trigger a 2nd time? In chapter 2, he started telling his story right as I hit the sleep button, so I didn't get to hear the part about the watch and it didn't log in his item request. I'm in chapter 3 now and am trying to get him to tell this story, but no luck so far. Am I just wasting my time now?
Yeah man, I gave it to him by the fire as soon as he finished his story. Hoping for some touching cut scene but nope, he just took it and left. I was trying so hard to grabbed my shotgun😂
It seems that i cannot give lenny his pockedwatch. Heard the story, the give item is on lenny, still only possible to talk ore difuse.... Not give request ore item to lenny.... What is wrong here?
Is there a certain misson timline within a chapter you have to do it in obviously you can't do it in a mission that contains lenny or before dies and do other certain people have to be at the camp also?
This is one of the reasons I turn autosave off and save regularly like when I am about to give a request I quickly save and if the cut scene doesn't play I just reload the game
actually no, that would be a generous gesture, but he only accepts the Silver Pocket Watch! Funny how the guy you "won" it from says that watch is worth more than an oil tycoon, but you can only sell it for $150
Ok so I have 2 pocket watches I blew up a safe after a train robbery and I found a pocket watch in there but the problem is I already have a pocket watch so what do I do? Nvm I looted a corpse and found it
I gave it to him as soon as he asked. Didnt get the cutscene so I came here to watch it lol
Same
Yea I didn’t get cutscene to and I did it as soon as he finished his story 😂
I was greeting bill about the valentine bank
Same
Same
I gave it to him while i was sitting so no cutscene for me i guess... thank you Rockstar, really cool👍
Lol same thing. Decided to TH-cam it immediately after.
Same. With Dutch's pipe, too (didn't miss much with that one, though, after looking it up).
@@thegageinator805 here for this exact reason
@@mattshannon8898 you best get back to it, pardner. Them Grey Boys ain't gonna fight themselves.
same
I encountered this request after doing the Valentine bank robbery with Bill, Lenny, and Karen. I remember it so vividly because I remember thinking about how truly alive this game felt. Lenny, Swanson, Javier, Uncle, Pearson, and Myself sat in the circle and listened to the story. After Lenny finished there was a couple minutes silence, Javier pulled out a guitar and started playing a song about a love so strong you couldn't comprehend. I remember listening to that whole song, turning the game off, and just laying in bed in silence for a while just feeling at peace.
God this game is such a masterpiece.
You need some real life interactions my guy
@51 50 ah, yes, because a single significant moment of immersion in a game known for causing that feeling CLEARLY means I have no social life, lol. Terminally online thought process.
I remember I came back from hunting deer in was in the middle of the night both in real time and in game where Charles sat down and started talking about how he didn't really understand life and how he was born to suffer next thing i know it begins to rain and javier began to play on his guitar with the critters in the back eventually having the sun slowly rise and having a song play in the background and I just remember thinking "This Is probably the most immersive game I ever played"
Still holds up and I end up getting lost for hours
@@Trblsum96 Ironic, maybe you should get off the internet yourself.
@@choipichiim 💭
🦸♂️
Never went there, he just took one of the many I had from looting bodies.
That cabin is the only place to get the pipe requested by Dutch! I've donated SO MANY silver pocket watches to the camp fund, I could've sent us all to Tahiti on the money they would've brought. btw, If Dutch REALLY wanted to escape to Tahiti, there was more than enough money in camp to do that, he was just greedy and wanted MORE!
OK, I think I FINALLY found the best way to trigger this. I was in chapter 4 reloading 8 PM fire chats and midnight fire chats OVER AND OVER AND OVER and I was about to give up. What FINALLY worked was I was in camp and SAVED around 8 PM. Heard chat by the fire that wasn't Lenny and went to sleep till midnight. Got up and went over to the fire and FINALLY got the story about Lenny's father and the watch. I suggest you use this format if you want to trigger this. It gives you two different conversations in one evening to load as opposed to the crap shoot doing just one. Save at 8 PM, sleep till midnight, listen to fire chat, repeat till you get Lenny's story. Hope this helps those who were as frustrated as I was.
Chapter 4 is when they lived in big house near swamp right?
@@anakmilan Correct
Idk how you got this to work bro I’ve tried like 20 times and still nothing
How far in chapter 4 were you? I have the mission a gilded cage available and i've tried this but i can't seem to trigger it I've been trying in every single previous camp but i can't get this one to trigger
@@PringlesCan1968 I was fairly close to the end of chapter 4 IIRC. It's been six months so it's not as fresh in my memory. It took me so many times and it drove me nuts when i was previous camp. Like I said. Save at 8 PM and sleep till midnight for two chances at it instead of one.
As good as this game is. The sheer luck involved in getting Bill's, Lennys and Seans requests to activate is beyond a joke.
Came here to watch the cutscene because I was so moved by his story, and since I already love Lenny, I gave him the pocket watch that I already had on me the second I could and the only reply I got from Lenny was: “good”. Maybe it was because I was sitting at the campfire at the same time as him and it glitched so it didn’t trigger any cutscenes. Anyway, I was like “Ain’t no way it’s just that !, just a simple word from Lenny? No way”. Glad to know I wasn’t mistaken. Had to watch the full thing here and you can have my like lmao
In case it doesnt spawn for anyone, just go rob a train or loot enemies. Any watch will do except for the ones you buy at the store or the ones in train safes.
Any watch will do as long as it is a "Silver Pocket Watch"! Platinum and Gold will not work!
@@coyotegaming4027 platinum worked for me
if you check the ledger it says lenny donated it to camp
Damn those little details are crazy, Lenny so sweet❤️
the reason I’m here is because I overheard the story in camp and gave him the watch as soon as he was done talking and he just walked off 😂
Damn same here, also where am I supposed to go to collect the reward?? I’m worried it didn’t trigger the reward for me because he just walked off as soon as I gave him the thing
@@oliviawilson441my bad i didn’t see this, hopefully you got it but to be honest i forgot 😂
@@oliviawilson441same, I gave him the watch and the mission says “return to your tent for a reward” but there’s no reward? 🤷🏼♂️
As fun as it is, this game is a little frustrating at times.
I wanted to watch what he said because lenny accidently stepped into the fire when I gave it to him lmao.
Like literally I give it to him I hear screaming and poor Lenny is on fire and it interrupted the dialogue. I was like oh man I feel like I'm missing out on something.
He just went straight to bed after I gave it to him
You can also find it at one of the o driscolls at hanging dog ranch
The ranch is located west of Wallace station, north of little creek river
Just go around the back of the shack and the bear will walk out for a clean shot.😉
i walk in the front cuz I wanted the bear skin
@@null00003 they way he did it the skin was in poor condition, from the back, you get a clean shot and a pristine skin, however going in the front the way he did was a good way to contribute to the achievement: Grin and Bear it!
I wonder if they had Lenny give dynamite as reward for a JJ reference DYNO-MITE 🧨💥 Goooood Times!
Dutchs pipe is also there
@@scallywag5236 it's a random camp encounter
@@scallywag5236 what chapter you in
It happens then 8,-10 at night
@@scallywag5236 if Dutch is smoking his cigar in chapter 2/3/4 just greet him and he will talk about his pipe he lost in Blackwater
i think mine glithed, i just happened to have random platinum pocket watch from looting a body or something, and gave it to him. he said nothing in return so i think it was bugged. i never visited that hut with the bear tho.
you couldn't have given him the platinum watch, it would not register that you have an item to give! you must've had a silver one in inventory from looting that you didn't realize you had! sometimes they won't say anything, but if you check your log (D-pad or L on PC), you will see that you gave it and check your tent for a reward!
Nah mate I have gold and platinum rn and I can give it to him
I’m trying to trigger this too. I got the Errand Boy trophy but I still like getting requests. Havent got the Pearson one either.
usually the pearson rabbit request and Dutch's pipe request give me the most trouble, but latest playthrough I got them to happen right away soon after arriving in Horseshoe Overlook. but Lenny and Bill are being stubborn. I heard Lenny tell a story about his Grandmother birthing his mother who was the object of the Overseers innapropriate affections, but never the story about his Fathers watch! True I'm still in Ch. 2, and you can get this request up til ch 4. so , I'm not TOO upset about it! I expect in chapter 3, I'll get Tilly's neclace request, Lenny's pocket watch request, and Bill's Pomade request! I guess the game doesn't want me to get them all done in chapter 2!
@@coyotegaming4027
Yeah seems different every playthrough. I'm in Ch4 right now with only Lenny's pocketwatch request to unlock just afking in camp at night near the fire lol.
@@leonvanderliner did it work
Its so hard to trigger it.
Ik I triggered it once. And I'm trying to trigger it again and it's so hard
@@travisghilonijr475good luck , I managed to trigger it finnaly.
@@STRAIXSTER how? Everytime I go to the campfire it's reverand, Micah, Javier or uncle opening their gob...never Lenny...do you know that trigger state? I am with 3-4 or quests left in chapter 3. Can't trigger Pearson as well...
@@kartik1396 just go to the campfire and wait from 8pm to 3 am if it doesn't spawn sleep until night and repeat the procces
@@kartik1396 I'm very late but unfortunately these requests are all random so some people have no problem, some have to try for a very long time
Can this story trigger a 2nd time?
In chapter 2, he started telling his story right as I hit the sleep button, so I didn't get to hear the part about the watch and it didn't log in his item request. I'm in chapter 3 now and am trying to get him to tell this story, but no luck so far. Am I just wasting my time now?
I think this may have happened to me as well, because I'm ready to advance to chapter 3, and no luck getting him to tell that story,
Any luck?
doing the same thing lol@@TheAMVLOST
@@babashawn2039 Is possible to trigger it more than once?
I see I'm not the only one who came here because I gave Lenny the watch just after he finished his story and missed the cutscene 😆
The end the background music is what what I hear when I'm riding in the snow ❄ or near the mountains🏔 I like to go trail riding in the snow
Yeah man, I gave it to him by the fire as soon as he finished his story. Hoping for some touching cut scene but nope, he just took it and left. I was trying so hard to grabbed my shotgun😂
I get the pipe in that location though and also by the first camp I already have one on hand from killing gang members
What a bs, it's always
- they're having dinner
- others telling stories
- and completely silence
Even Strauss who sleeps far from camp told his story wtf
This mf finally speaks, but he told another story 😭😭😭
It seems that i cannot give lenny his pockedwatch. Heard the story, the give item is on lenny, still only possible to talk ore difuse.... Not give request ore item to lenny.... What is wrong here?
Can't seem to trigger it. Already at Chapter 3 and about to do Blessed are Peacemaker
Lenny asked me for a pocket watch so I bought it in town lol but it didn’t work so I have to find it
I got back to my tent and the reward isn’t anywhere to be seen 🤷🏼♂️
Is there a certain misson timline within a chapter you have to do it in obviously you can't do it in a mission that contains lenny or before dies and do other certain people have to be at the camp also?
So just any watch? Nothing unique?
um couldn't find the watch but found the pipe for dutch
I got him it and the next thing he does he puts it in the Damm box
What is the song name used for this video?
This is one of the reasons I turn autosave off and save regularly like when I am about to give a request I quickly save and if the cut scene doesn't play I just reload the game
I'm trying to get this request but it won't appear, do you guys have any advice on how to trigger it?? Please😂 I'm losing my mind.
Stay near camp fire at night. Or when you see people talking near camp just sit on the chair.
Can you give him the reutlinger?
I was wondering the same thing
actually no, that would be a generous gesture, but he only accepts the Silver Pocket Watch! Funny how the guy you "won" it from says that watch is worth more than an oil tycoon, but you can only sell it for $150
Ok so I have 2 pocket watches I blew up a safe after a train robbery and I found a pocket watch in there but the problem is I already have a pocket watch so what do I do? Nvm I looted a corpse and found it
Bro the game for some reason gave lenny my paltinum pocket watch instead of the silver one i had before😢😢
❤❤❤😊😊😊
Hi friend
joel what are you doing here
Lenny is so woke.
This game is trash I didn’t get the cutscene just because I gave it to Lenny right after he mentions it.