She is the one who asked Dr. S Jaishankar a question at SCO Summitt in Goa that " Comming to Goa Summitt by Bilawal Bhutto zardari is considered as bold move in Pakistan and also considered as normalization of bilateral ties between India and Pakistan and as a breakthrough. What India thiks about his visit?" Dr. Jaishankar replied " He came as foreign minister of SCO member state, I dont see it as more than that, dont considere as more than that and what he said deserve more than that"🔥🔥🔥
Breathtaking example of measuring oneself with one yardstick, then turning around and measuring the neighboring country's free and vibrant media with a completely different yardstick, because that's what suits your preexisting worldview. I expect this sort of mental gymnastics from this channel's host but not from the journo who seemed level-headed.
I think journalists must critique three areas (1) Military Civil Relations (2) Corruption and (3) Terrorism and involvement of the State. Even frontline journalists evade these issues.
It's very telling that Pakistanis confuse their preferences on Indian politics as somehow being the reality with all other contradictory opinions dismissed as being godi media etc..... A reference was made to Barkha Dutt & somehow connecting her not being on a mainstream channel as being the doing of Modi. Lots of other critics of Modi are alive, kicking, and some make a lot of money opposing him but somehow Barkha is a special target. A few facts, not that you guys are interested but here anyways - Barkha Dutt's credibility was damaged tremendously with the Nira Radia tapes where she was seen as hobnobbing with the Congress party and working as a fixer/dalal. All available on record as was the public reaction towards her during the anti corruption demonstrations with Anna Hazare and Kejriwal where she was jeered and booed and forced to leave the place with people calling her a dalal. NDTV came under pressure to fire her but they kept her on. She eventually left NDTV having complaints against the Roys who founded it. All long before Adani was in the picture . She then joined hands with Congress leader Kapil Sibal (very neutral of her) to create a channel just before the 2019 general elections. Modi won and Sibal had no use for Barkha after that and the channel closed down with extremely unpleasant commentary against the Sibals by Barkha Dutt. Again, all part of available record. She tried something with Shekhar Gupta of The Print, and that too fell through the The Print itself is doing ok. I'm sure that's all Modi's fault....somehow. she has an You Tube channel and while it hasnt set the world on fire, it is prodding along. The market decides who it wants. Some Modi critics do really well, others dont. Getting certificates of how great you are or were doesn't cut it anymore. The so called "godi" media has better viewership because the viewers, not critics decide. Television media is a business the world over, India is no different. Value has to be perceived before money changes hands. If Barkha Dutt or any other can bring viewers, they will get jobs. Not otherwise.
Kuch bhi she said politicans are necessary for development she cited eg of Afghanistan n manamar but could not sitr eg of china where ther is no democracy but still there is development.so democracy n journalists are overayed stuff
Pakistani journalists must cease their unwarranted commentary on India. This isn't merely due to their lack of understanding about India; it's primarily because of their deep-rooted dishonesty. They conveniently overlook their own nation's failings and refuse to confront their actions, let alone acknowledge the egregious animosity their people and government harbor towards India, particularly Hindus. Moreover, the fact that the daughter of their revered "Qaid" chose to make India her home should unequivocally settle the matter.
Asma was a unique individual and most respected lady avtivist of pakistan. As an Indian I respect her as champion of human rights. Hats of to your mom ❤️India
coined by the group of journalists jisne accept kar lia his company was receiving funds from china to promote anti india agenda and has now turned into approver. Lets me make it easy for you, its newsclick on which the original user of "godi media" whose godi ravish sat in. @@user-rh5jp2sh4s
Sir…I’m from Lahore, Pakistan 🇵🇰 I left Islam after reading Quran and listening Adam Seeker, Sahil Bhai, Zafar Heretics and Harris Sultan. I’m Ex-Muslim Now. I need your help…
Alhamdulilah brother, hopefully more people leave Islam. Only power they have is of bullying and threats, they will block Ex Muslim channel on TH-cam because they are very scared. What a coward qaum
Well, even a politician from RSS/BJP, L.K Advani, said that of the Indian media, when they were asked to bend, they crept. Ofcourse also in Pakistani media there are sellouts, but many also have resisted and have paid a price... some even paid the ultimate price... But probably L.K. Advani isn't right wing enough, or maybe he is even a Pakistani agent 🤔....
To all Indians, don't get addicted to never ending podcasts. Instead plase spend 1or2 hrs everyday learning new skill, personal & financial development, side hussle etc.
There was a blast in Narendra Modi's rally in 2013. Fast forward now, and you must know how many rallies he takes already. I'm just setting the record straight.
She is absolutely right in saying that the youngsters in India look at Pakistan as a terror exporting country...they have grown up hearing stories and have themselves witnessed Pakistani terror attacks, they have heard and read comments made by terror organisations in Pakistan taking credit for these attacks, celebrating and promising to carry out more of the same in future. It will take a very long time, if at all, to remove this mistrust with which Indian youth look at Pakistan and Pakistani's! It's unfortunate, but that's the current reality wherever you go in our country. I share the same view! 🇮🇳
Sure, in the same manner as many Pakistani, only seeing India as being deeply in trenched in Hindutva with a fascist PM leading it. This is unfortunate as there are also many normal common people in India.
In the aftermath of the 2008 Mumbai Terrorist Attack, India's accelerated economic growth stands strong, fueled by a public sentiment prioritizing national security, leading to a reluctance for any relationship with Pakistan.
@2107Slash Well actually the Hindutva started to gain traction in late 80s..90s the entire movement for the demolition of the Babri mosque...interesting how, just now in the coming days Modi will be "celebrating" that mosque site to be turned into a temple. So 2014 wasn't the date where Hindutva gained traction but gained its height. You can tell stories to Westerners, but people in neighbouring countries of India (not just Pakistan) understand very well the realities in India. Particularly also because the very same ills exist in their countries As to the use of militant organisations, proxies. Well, both countries have done it against each other. Like what is happening in Balochistan or previously the nefarious activities from Indian Embassies in Afghanistan. Indians always mention the Mumbai attacks, True the loss of life is terrible. But forget what happened in the Samjuta Express. Just shows that it's not about sadness over loss of life but political point scoring.
Recently , Aamir Khan's daughter got married to Nupur Shikhare . There is a Special Marriage Act for inter faith marriage in India . Does pakistan have similar provisions for inter faith marriage ? Also can Shia Sunni Ahmediya inter marry?
@shatnermohanty6678 Yes, legally allowed between shias and sunnis. But not interfaith, with some exceptions. Like a Muslim man can marry a Christian or Jewish woman. Ahmediya are not considered muslims according to Pakistani law, so they can't marry shia or sunni.
I don't know why people of Pakistan want good relations with india at this time Pakistan is nothing infront of India so it's good to not comment on india relations but to focus on it's own
She compare false equality with India . It upto politicians who decide the fate of the country. Naxals affected area , Kashmir, some places in North East are in the hostile for decades but a political process never stop. When the political process stops in India during emergency then most furious resistance start from Bihar ( backward state of India) .
Nice podcast as always. There are lot of journalists or historians like Ramchandra guha who spell venom on BJP and Prime minister Modi. He has even called Hinduism disaggregated (to break up or apart) faith. But he is still very much alive and freely expressing his opinions. Alt least he is not missing or killed or tortured (Like Arshad or Imran Niazi or shot at like Hamid Mir). I hope pakistani's realize the inclusiveness of India's society. MY local senator in Hyderabad (India) has given a call to Muslims that he can wipe out Hindus in 15 minutes if police are removed. Now sample this he was given intereim speaker ship when the govt has changed recently in my state of telangana. Can these type of statements be made by any minorotiy community in pakistan ?.
This made my day. I am glad that people like barkha dutt don't have anyone offering them cushy jobs with unlimited funding. I don't support silencing them. They can have their own platform and speak their truth but boy am I glad that the appeasement has stopped.
@@trilokyamohanchakra6351 she is talking about the initial days of NDTV. When they were relatively unbiased. The Overton window shift in India is recent before far left were centrist. You can clearly see this. When leftist historian were called in courts and Lied through their teeth and no one questioned them. All were proved false obviously and here we are.
1:01:02 my guy the attack happened in 2008 aur aaj tak uss attack ke masterminds aur planers ko state protection de rakhi hai apki country ne. All of this and those visuals of that barbaric attack on innocent civilians is in the living experienced memory of our Nation across states, across languages and across political ideologies. Kaise hoga "behtar"?
Countries in the rest of the world/history have been at war with each other to the most horrifying degree, but have been able to come to positive relationships soon after. The only way to guarantee positive development never happens, is to preemptively deny any hope that progress is even theoretically possible.
@@howmanybeansmakefive that's worse lol. You're ready to make amends with same people who've murdered your civilians for fun and have ZERO empathy for you and WILL do it again the moment they get the opportunity. Either you're delusional or Stockholm Syndrome at its best lol.
do you realize that it is not just one event of 26/11, we have had the parliament attacked, constant kashmir conflict, proxy war of khalistan, air dropping of drugs to punjab? and this is just the surface of the mountain of terrorism issues we have with pakistan. Entire north east insurgency is funded and supported by pakistan. The moment Pak's economy went down, so did the insurgency @@howmanybeansmakefive
59:10 Barkha Dutt was responsible for 2 major misadventures in journalism of her reporting sensitive information from Kargil War and 26/11. she was acting more of an OGW😂. Available on youtube leave her aside.
Why should fair-skinned Aryan martial-race Punjabi Mussalman bother about what dark-skinned Dravidian ex-slave Hindus think about them? Whole of the Pak-Ind subcontinent is a personal property of the Punjabi Mussalman and he/she can do whatever he wants to do in Dehli or Bambay.
Tons of respect for Muni-zae, the respect also comes out because of her mother. Asma jahangir was not only a brilliant mind but also a very brave lady. ( i some how believe she was killed). Muni's analysis of current situation in india is right on the money.MODI'S INDIA IS NOT VERY CIVILIZED INDIA.We feel very embarrassed too. But i also believe that pakistan has big contribution in bringing MODI in india. There were so many attacks that were initiated from pakistan, Bombay was exceptionally BRUTAL and was extremely difficult to swallow.I will suggest, please continue your good work, there is lot of support for you in india. Thanks for everything.
oh Miss Barkha Dutt, She was one of the journalists who was covering the "live war' for NDTV. She gained prominence for irresponsibly doing a live commentary during the "secret" Tiger Hill operation. While covering the operation, Barkha Dutt gave away the military location by concluding her live commentary by saying "Barkha Dutt reporting from 56 Brigade HQ" at the end. She didn’t even blink or hesitate for a second before giving such a crucial bit of information on national television that too, live. It seemed that she was not reporting to inform the citizens but was acting like 'Vibhishan' by helping Pakistan by providing crucial information about the operations and live army movements. Despite knowing that even army officers do not use satellite phones in conflict zones, as it allows enemies to track their movements, she carried one while doing live coverage of the war zone. Since that blunder, everyone felt that Kargil's experience would have made the so-called journalist mature about these aspects, however, she again dug her own grave by repeating the same mistake during the Mumbai 26/11 terror attack. While reporting the attack, in one report, she unethically reported that "her sources are on the 19th floor, where the terrorists are currently in their murderous frenzy". Such blunders by the journalist need to be punished so that the aspiring journalist do not repeat such grave mistakes, " Nahi ta log bolenga ki unko kam nahi milta"
Good podcast. In the aftermath of the 2008 Mumbai Terrorist Attack, India's accelerated economic growth stands strong, fueled by a public sentiment prioritizing national security, leading to a reluctance for any relationship with Pakistan.
Hamare India ke Godi Media ki Anjana Om Modi , Navika se lekar Rubika Liyuqat Kumari Sharma ke beech Muqabila chal raha hai ke Modi darbar ki Anaarkali kaun banegi ... abb iss me bahut se Pakistani naam bhi shaamil ho gaye hai ,,,, Arzoo , Aaliya , Sana ... and.. and.. and 😜😜
This are english speaking class of pakistani's but when i see public reaction videos of pakistan some one from street its always about GAZWA E HIND , i have seen even lawyers spewing venom against our country rather about our faith and beliefs , and which is majority of pakistan . and well about Barkha Dutt "journalism" we have seen her "journalism" during 26/11 attacks and even during kargil war and who got benefited by her "journalism" and NDTV they were always a media wing of congress NDTV use to do their celebrations in "Rashtrapati Bhavan" and who says their are no media houses who oppose government narrative , their is The Print , The Wire , The Quint , News laundry and many more and they are part of main stream media their access to a lay man is on Phone , but honest journalism i have not seen on both sides because every has their own personal bias and every one has their own opinion , no one dose reports as it is with facts , no one is holier than thou , NANGAY EK HAMMAM MEIN SAB HAIN
Indian People are buying Governments narrative 😂😂. Well I just remembered when the Mumbai Terror attacks happened we were watching the news for 72 hours without a break it broke our hearts and the people who did it are freely roaming in Pakistan aren't they? We have seen those people on television and Pakistani Army provides security to them. Chalo maan liya ke Modi fascist hai 😂 but aap kaunse progressive ho? Modi toh protocol tod ke aya tha Nawaz Sharif ke ghar aapne pulwama kar diya, Atal Bihari Vajpayee ji aaye the aapne Kargil kar diya. Iske aage bhi dekhte hai chalo Modi ji hai fascist hai but what about other Indian Prime minister's 😂😂 ? Kya Nehru, Shastri, Indira-Rajeev, Atal Bihari Vajpayee yeh bhi fascist the? In last 75 years we are unable to solve the Kashmir issue why? I know from where she's coming😂 from NDTV😂 btw NDTV is a very biased news channel. Just look at their coverage of 2019 election results coverage. Jo hay tauba kiya jo left liberal elites ka meltdown tha bhaisahab dekhne layak tha.They primarily hate PM Modi but they are unable to digest the fact that the PM Modi is India's most successful PM till date. Jitna bhala Modiji ne kiya hai wo aaj tak kisi PM ko possible nahi hua. Indian economy has doubled in the last decade so that explains everything and Congress toh bilkul bhi nahi aa rahi hai😂😂 so tough luck😂😂.Barkha Dutt has said I make and break Governments😂😂. Toh aise logon ko kya zarurat hai job ki?😂😂.
She was a classic old school host, patted her back for things that she then condradicted later on. Kudos to kudos to the podcast host for asking right questions
Good chat, but I'm afraid I have to disagree with mainstream media's credibility over social media, especially in a country like Pakistan. People are waking up in the social media age this day. warna, we used to think our neighbors were big bad wolves and we are angels thanks to the "controlled" mainstream media for decades.
I grew up hating Asma Jehangir, starting from our university days in early 2000s. It took more than a decade of gradual learning and 'unlearning' that I have her at a place of great respect in my heart. A brave soul. A fighter. May Allah bless her soul. She would have been an amazing guest in this podcast.
Not sure who rules the Pakistan, ISI, Army or selected PM. Most of the people hate Hindus, that's why Hindu / non-muslim population has reduced to 1% from 23% in last 76 years. Still People of Pakistan claim to be human right champions. The lady talked about Barkha Dutt & NDTV, India is a competitive market, to survive the organization has to be economically feasible, if people do not watch it .. its is bound to shut. She Did not talk about Fiza khan of pakistan...
About Barkha and Some Other NDTV reporter who are now Jobless because Like Before ,now Government not giving any favour to them as Journalists. And The Hostile Takeover Madam talking about the owner himself sold that TV Company share , He did it for money . Some of the Indian Journalists are very left leaning Ideology and they're still doing their Job on TH-cam . India gayab ni. Karta reporting k liye.. If I may try to bring light on some matters. Those Journalists lost their credibility when they tried to Ignore some great work Done by the current govt and Blindly criticised everything. They weren't that neutral while reporting the issue as in actual. People saw their Dalla Panti when they Rant 24Hrs how Congress Govt was very good In Center. Now the tastes changed, As madam said at the end of the day they're doing business and had to Bring Money home.. So the reporting styles did changed a lot. Now story based Reporting work as in Documentary and Primetimes are now Mindless Debate Show 😌
Why has Pakistani police arrested Shoiab chaudhury of Real Entertainment just casue he called PM modi a brand and makes indian content . Why Pak TH-camrs like Sana Amjad , Ribaha Imran , Muzzamil sheikh , Mehwish Naz ,Anam Sheikh , Naila khan live in Fear of Arrest ? Should pakistan not help its citizens to live in freedom of press and democracy
Munizee has a naive and tinted view of her own country...she needs to be more critical. She is approaching things in an emotional way! Other than that, she has a tunnel vision for india... without much basis and little analysis or details. On the other hand, the host has a better grip on both Pakistan and India both! Though none of you have any idea about tye complex interplay of forces and the highly changing situation of India! Even Indians are getting surprised every year in india.. So don't try or approach very carefully 😂
Journalism is Same everywhere now. In INDIA you try to write against BJP, even America or many countries of Europe you can not write what you think is right unless you want to lose your job or death threats.
One can understand how liberal and reslient Pakistant media is from the fact that podacst person has to delete and cut words from her when she was talking about now younger generation of Indians think Pakistan as terror exporter.😂😂😂😂😂 Inke jhoot ki pole toh isi program mein khul gayi
Hi from India, After sometime had a time to watch your show. Since I like you, I respond, not sure if this is taken in right sense. Few points to add. 1. Media restriction was an issue sometime back, but now with TH-cam it is not, in fact with popularity of TH-cam MSM has started loosing relevence, So Media now should stop being a cry baby. 2. On Godi Media, in fact this was also the case earlier during Non BJP Government, and almost all of the non bjp state government, they are called Durbari Media, their loyalty to Congress is far more than that of so called Godi Media to BJP. Barkha Dutt is considered one of them, not so much liked by some Indian masses. In fact there were reports, she would involve herself with Congress Govt to lobby for Ministrial berth for people. Maybe your host, since not from India is not well informed and that was the reason why NDTV kept loosing viewership.
I don't know why but on TH-cam everyone from Pakistan podcast i feel they are sold to there army and they always be nice to get views only. Inside they are hating india i don't know but it's my personal feelings seems like these pakistani youtubers are part of any agenda.
She is a daughter of brave lady who always remained critical of the establishment, but somehow, she is lacking her traits and having soft corners for them.
Shehzad sb, kindly do a podcast series on war on terror years in Pakistan. Invite people from Peshawar, Lahore and Quetta and the tribal parts. Take testimonies of the horror we as people have faced. It is imperative that the world must know the history from the people who were pushed into this war. Mainstream media, the state has no concern with the suffering inflicted upon us. - writing from Lahore.
as usual good one. she also tried to save the face of dirty journalism at some point came with different answer why this law why that law. and you always very brave to ask questions which should be asked. ❤
India Pakistan romance n India ko kuch n diya to break up ho gya , india move on kr gya aur Pakistan ko y dikkat h ki india ab hmari yaad m aansu kyu nhi bahata
Well i dnt think there is struggle for journalists in pakistan i think we have more news channel then any other country its is business manipulation and and problems starts when they chose sides instead of fair and neutral journalits. The idea of journalism is give news not to manipulte impose and force their ideas upon ppl.
Name to lo na army kay journal(s) ka batao Amjad shoiab(R) ki baat ho rahi hai. jo pehlay army ki uthao giri karta tha aur ab army nay hi utha liya us ko.
But this podcaster defended 7Oct Terrerist attack on unarmed civilians,hypernationalistic indians opposed this Terrerist attack Hypernationalism means standing up with humanity.
@@bhalkitoday8267I don’t think he was defending it, but trying to understand it. How can hypernationalism stand up for the whole world/humanity? What about those outside of that nation, or outside of all/any nations? Surely there is an element of contradiction with hypernationalism
@@howmanybeansmakefive share the video where he said 7 Oct was a terrorist attack. He vehemently defended acts of terrorism by Hamas terrorists on a peaceful gathering.
@@Takecare55 yes in pakisthan you can't find a single person who supports Israel but in india you found crores of muslims supporting Hamas even though india supporting Israel This shows freedom of expression and freedom of speech in india.
Valiant defense of Pakistani journalism. While I appreciate her view about Pakistani journalists having to work in very adverse conditions, she comes across as an indulgent mother who can see the travails of her son but can’t see his/her shortcomings. But, if you ask her about the neighbours, she becomes objective and all knowing. But it’s good that Shehzad did his job and tried to make her see the light multiple times.
True, you are right. But it's also easier for Shahzad to say that as he is only a TH-camr, and it is easier for him to express his opinion. But journalism isn't only about opinion but primarily about news collection and reporting. There is an entire organisation and network involved. In short, the stakes are much much higher.
@@user-rh5jp2sh4sShahzad khud green TV k lie kaam KR chka ha k Jo khud Kisi retd fouji K under ata ha. Jahan apna pait laga ho wo thk ha baqi SB ghalat
@@RohiteshSharma Asma Jahangir was an exceptional person... very brave indeed but also skillfull. So comparisons shouldn't be done. But her daughter's basic thinking (protection of fundamental rights and rule of law) is the same
Well one cannot forget the 3 days of horror we have faced.. and also the way it was celebrated across the border.. Almost every Maharashtrian has someone who was personally affected by the Mumbai attack be it 2008 1991 2011 etc and pune attack. I know my father was .. we cannot forget about it and forgive Pakistani establishment for support to them
I remember those terrible horrifying days , watching on TV In islamabad, pakistan And cried.. felt such sadness... So no , not everyone celebrated... Am sorry, u all had to go through that... May no one face such cruelty n madness n terrorism again ever... Sending u love n lots of prayers
@@murtaza636 yes not everyone.. but a few did.. and that's the problem.. and even today the handler of the terrorist group run scot free in Pakistan.. in India when there was that attack on army public school in Pakistan.. not a single person celebrated every school assembly had a day of mourning.. including the government. We don't have any issues with the public.. but the government we cannot trust.. My point is simple will you be ok if the mastermind of any terrorist attack in Pakistan would be roaming freely in India..
She is very wise and an open minded person who can look at the bigger picture. Not at all bitter or revengeful. Amazing courage, but then again she is Asma Jahangir’s daughter!
very well articulated podcast. everything bogs down to humman index development and that comes from education. more the pakistanis will swing towards education easier it will be for them to drift away from radicalisation. best wishes from india 🇮🇳 !
Khabardar hamre piche kyu rehte hohame Pakistan's se koi matlab nahi hai na hum rakhna chahte hai chahe modi govt rahe yana rahe aur jahatak ye baat hai hum to develop kargaye hai utna nahi jitna west lekin aapse zyada it s you hame aapki koi zarurat nahi hai (pakistan)
They can't digest that people or certain journalists support the current government. Or the fact that the government is really making india progress ...they can't digest.
Saying that no matter the corruption, at least we have these politicians. If we keep on accepting these criminal politicians nothing is going to change.
Yo bro... thanks for this one... i didnt even know Asma had a daughter ... an accomplished one too it seems ... miss Asma ...wish there were more like her... on both sides of the border.
ended too soon :( .... it was such a pleasure listening to her nuanced take on things :) wish you won't pack so many guests back to back & give ppl (esp. like her) more time.... they have so much more to tell/say/share... but thank you once again 👍
after watching this podcast 3 conclusions drawn from this interview NDTV ---The original Founder of GODI MEDIA courtesy Prannoy Roy😆😆😆 Barkha Dutt's name featured in Neera Radia Tapes and Munizae still appreciates her .....shocking? Pakistan today is very irrelevant in Indian Peoples narrative so nobody in India cares about Pakistan anymore unlike the past &the reason for that is only Pakistan has to be blamed for this dip in relationship..It can't even maintain good relations with muslim dominated Afghanistan & Iran Thats why htey say.."people who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones"
She is the one who asked Dr. S Jaishankar a question at SCO Summitt in Goa that " Comming to Goa Summitt by Bilawal Bhutto zardari is considered as bold move in Pakistan and also considered as normalization of bilateral ties between India and Pakistan and as a breakthrough. What India thiks about his visit?"
Dr. Jaishankar replied " He came as foreign minister of SCO member state,
I dont see it as more than that, dont considere as more than that and what he said deserve more than that"🔥🔥🔥
I am a fan of the fearless Asma Jahangir and my best wishes are always there for her deserving daughter.
What a beautiful young soul she is, time just flew by listening to her experiences and stories.
Very impressive podcast.
🙌
Great podcast. Munize, and her legendary mother Asma Jehangir, two of the most respected and appreciated persons in India.
🙌
We all should apologise to late Asma Jahangir, she was so right about these duffers and we used to insult her for her absolutely true views
Breathtaking example of measuring oneself with one yardstick, then turning around and measuring the neighboring country's free and vibrant media with a completely different yardstick, because that's what suits your preexisting worldview. I expect this sort of mental gymnastics from this channel's host but not from the journo who seemed level-headed.
Her mom also did that 😊
❤good to hear you mam you are my hero ❣️ I love you mam I am big muridh of you❤
youtube.com/@samay3258?si=w4AXVeeezyncsyLl
My only criticism is, I wish you hadn't scheduled back to back shows with such a brilliant guest and kept the conversation going 😊
sir ❤️
Today Pak awam is searching for another Asma Jahangir. May be they find one. May be they don't.
26/11 changed public perceptive towards pak, she is right.
I think journalists must critique three areas (1) Military Civil Relations (2) Corruption and (3) Terrorism and involvement of the State. Even frontline journalists evade these issues.
Thanks for telling Pakistanis that great asma jehangir legacy still persist . Today in jan 2024 I came to know she is her daughter.
It's very telling that Pakistanis confuse their preferences on Indian politics as somehow being the reality with all other contradictory opinions dismissed as being godi media etc..... A reference was made to Barkha Dutt & somehow connecting her not being on a mainstream channel as being the doing of Modi. Lots of other critics of Modi are alive, kicking, and some make a lot of money opposing him but somehow Barkha is a special target. A few facts, not that you guys are interested but here anyways - Barkha Dutt's credibility was damaged tremendously with the Nira Radia tapes where she was seen as hobnobbing with the Congress party and working as a fixer/dalal. All available on record as was the public reaction towards her during the anti corruption demonstrations with Anna Hazare and Kejriwal where she was jeered and booed and forced to leave the place with people calling her a dalal. NDTV came under pressure to fire her but they kept her on. She eventually left NDTV having complaints against the Roys who founded it. All long before Adani was in the picture . She then joined hands with Congress leader Kapil Sibal (very neutral of her) to create a channel just before the 2019 general elections. Modi won and Sibal had no use for Barkha after that and the channel closed down with extremely unpleasant commentary against the Sibals by Barkha Dutt. Again, all part of available record. She tried something with Shekhar Gupta of The Print, and that too fell through the The Print itself is doing ok. I'm sure that's all Modi's fault....somehow. she has an You Tube channel and while it hasnt set the world on fire, it is prodding along.
The market decides who it wants. Some Modi critics do really well, others dont. Getting certificates of how great you are or were doesn't cut it anymore. The so called "godi" media has better viewership because the viewers, not critics decide. Television media is a business the world over, India is no different. Value has to be perceived before money changes hands. If Barkha Dutt or any other can bring viewers, they will get jobs. Not otherwise.
Plz invite Afrasiab khattak and Dr Qaisar Banagli plz.
Asma Jahangir was great lady.
Kuch bhi she said politicans are necessary for development she cited eg of Afghanistan n manamar but could not sitr eg of china where ther is no democracy but still there is development.so democracy n journalists are overayed stuff
Pakistani journalists must cease their unwarranted commentary on India. This isn't merely due to their lack of understanding about India; it's primarily because of their deep-rooted dishonesty. They conveniently overlook their own nation's failings and refuse to confront their actions, let alone acknowledge the egregious animosity their people and government harbor towards India, particularly Hindus. Moreover, the fact that the daughter of their revered "Qaid" chose to make India her home should unequivocally settle the matter.
❤
🙌
Asma was a unique individual and most respected lady avtivist of pakistan. As an Indian I respect her as champion of human rights. Hats of to your mom ❤️India
" Pakistani media doesn't blindly follow narrative " 😂😂😂😂😂
Well, the term Godi media comes from somewhere...
coined by the group of journalists jisne accept kar lia his company was receiving funds from china to promote anti india agenda and has now turned into approver. Lets me make it easy for you, its newsclick on which the original user of "godi media" whose godi ravish sat in. @@user-rh5jp2sh4s
@@user-rh5jp2sh4s GODI-Government direction nd instructions 👍👍But in Pakistan
Whole Media Run by Army..sorry Merchant Army 😂😂
It’s still much better than our media
@@user-rh5jp2sh4s😂 true
Sir…I’m from Lahore, Pakistan 🇵🇰 I left Islam after reading Quran and listening Adam Seeker, Sahil Bhai, Zafar Heretics and Harris Sultan. I’m Ex-Muslim Now. I need your help…
Then say Ram Randikapilla Hai.
Only One time to Prove your Ex-Muslim Identity
Alhamdulilah brother, hopefully more people leave Islam.
Only power they have is of bullying and threats, they will block Ex Muslim channel on TH-cam because they are very scared.
What a coward qaum
@@ertugalghazi9323allah bhut bda Dalla hai 😂😂😂
Bhai dehsadgardh peida hua
Recently insaan bana hai😮😮
*Thoda waqt lagega adjust hone mein,hosla rakh beh thoda*
@@ertugalghazi9323 gali dene ka itna shonk he to shuruat apne wale se kr bta kon pedophile he Jo male ganimat ke naam pe logo ko Lut ta he
By calling Pakistani media more progressive and resilient she just won the war of ironies😂😂
It's so hilarious to hear her delusions.
Well, even a politician from RSS/BJP, L.K Advani, said that of the Indian media, when they were asked to bend, they crept. Ofcourse also in Pakistani media there are sellouts, but many also have resisted and have paid a price... some even paid the ultimate price...
But probably L.K. Advani isn't right wing enough, or maybe he is even a Pakistani agent 🤔....
You must be literally blind if you still believe that Indian media is independent and progressive nowadays
To all Indians, don't get addicted to never ending podcasts. Instead plase spend 1or2 hrs everyday learning new skill, personal & financial development, side hussle etc.
Especially when the Aman ki asha type program never finishes onside and full hipocrate on the other side.
Right said !!
Well why are you watching a Pakistani podcast then?
@@f0815Hi-cd1toto have fun watching their mazboori 😂😂😂 for couple of minutes not whole podcast 😂😂😂
Sensible comment, aman ki asha ka churan no more. Pakistani youtube beggars don't have content.
There was a blast in Narendra Modi's rally in 2013. Fast forward now, and you must know how many rallies he takes already.
I'm just setting the record straight.
However intelligent Pakistani is, no one fully understood indian politics because no one seriously follows indian politics.
She is absolutely right in saying that the youngsters in India look at Pakistan as a terror exporting country...they have grown up hearing stories and have themselves witnessed Pakistani terror attacks, they have heard and read comments made by terror organisations in Pakistan taking credit for these attacks, celebrating and promising to carry out more of the same in future. It will take a very long time, if at all, to remove this mistrust with which Indian youth look at Pakistan and Pakistani's!
It's unfortunate, but that's the current reality wherever you go in our country.
I share the same view! 🇮🇳
Sure, in the same manner as many Pakistani, only seeing India as being deeply in trenched in Hindutva with a fascist PM leading it. This is unfortunate as there are also many normal common people in India.
In the aftermath of the 2008 Mumbai Terrorist Attack, India's accelerated economic growth stands strong, fueled by a public sentiment prioritizing national security, leading to a reluctance for any relationship with Pakistan.
@@user-rh5jp2sh4s world knows who spread Te rro rism
No peace, trade and friendship with Pakistan. Period.
@2107Slash
Well actually the Hindutva started to gain traction in late 80s..90s the entire movement for the demolition of the Babri mosque...interesting how, just now in the coming days Modi will be "celebrating" that mosque site to be turned into a temple. So 2014 wasn't the date where Hindutva gained traction but gained its height. You can tell stories to Westerners, but people in neighbouring countries of India (not just Pakistan) understand very well the realities in India. Particularly also because the very same ills exist in their countries
As to the use of militant organisations, proxies. Well, both countries have done it against each other. Like what is happening in Balochistan or previously the nefarious activities from Indian Embassies in Afghanistan. Indians always mention the Mumbai attacks, True the loss of life is terrible. But forget what happened in the Samjuta Express. Just shows that it's not about sadness over loss of life but political point scoring.
Recently , Aamir Khan's daughter got married to Nupur Shikhare .
There is a Special Marriage Act for inter faith marriage in India .
Does pakistan have similar provisions for inter faith marriage ?
Also can Shia Sunni Ahmediya inter marry?
Kyu gyan de raha hai, ghanta farak padta hai inko...Free me Kalma padhate hai ye sabko
Shia sunni can, yes!
@@saltpepper7525 is it legally allowed ?
And what about other religions?
Whenever a Hindu girl marries ta a muslim guy you ppl start shouting Love jihad come on bro we have seen ur double standard
@shatnermohanty6678 Yes, legally allowed between shias and sunnis. But not interfaith, with some exceptions. Like a Muslim man can marry a Christian or Jewish woman. Ahmediya are not considered muslims according to Pakistani law, so they can't marry shia or sunni.
Thanks for bringing such distinguished guests to your podcasts .
Enjoyed your show as always ❤
❤️
@@ThePakistanExperienceestablishment ka support hain na aapko?
@@ThePakistanExperience this guys shut up by s Jaishankar 😅😅😅😊
Please invite Zaid Hamid in your podcast@@ThePakistanExperience
We don't want this Aman ka tamasha with pakistan anymore
Aaj Kal parsoon. After there is a lot of bloodshed, we will have to eventually sit down and talk
@@71espn but the onus is on those who are perpreting the bloodshed
I don't know why people of Pakistan want good relations with india at this time Pakistan is nothing infront of India so it's good to not comment on india relations but to focus on it's own
Bhai Tu galatfami mai kyun hai ??? India Punjab punjabi nahi hai … jo Lahore ko jannat samjhta ho …
Kuch jaanta nahi tu India ke baare mai …
She compare false equality with India . It upto politicians who decide the fate of the country.
Naxals affected area , Kashmir, some places in North East are in the hostile for decades but a political process never stop.
When the political process stops in India during emergency then most furious resistance start from Bihar ( backward state of India) .
Nice podcast as always. There are lot of journalists or historians like Ramchandra guha who spell venom on BJP and Prime minister Modi. He has even called Hinduism disaggregated (to break up or apart) faith. But he is still very much alive and freely expressing his opinions. Alt least he is not missing or killed or tortured (Like Arshad or Imran Niazi or shot at like Hamid Mir). I hope pakistani's realize the inclusiveness of India's society. MY local senator in Hyderabad (India) has given a call to Muslims that he can wipe out Hindus in 15 minutes if police are removed. Now sample this he was given intereim speaker ship when the govt has changed recently in my state of telangana. Can these type of statements be made by any minorotiy community in pakistan ?.
OK andhbhakt 😂😂
well said nalini.
@@mohakroy821 Everyone prefer an Andhbhakt over a Commie....Even Augusto Pinochet throwed you lot from Helicopter...
This made my day. I am glad that people like barkha dutt don't have anyone offering them cushy jobs with unlimited funding. I don't support silencing them. They can have their own platform and speak their truth but boy am I glad that the appeasement has stopped.
This women was saying, "Nadtv works for women, ......" like they opposed triple talaq bill, They support Halala etc
Rats like BHAKTS are everywhere
@@ajitpalsinghatwal7931Dalal Spotted
@@trilokyamohanchakra6351 she is talking about the initial days of NDTV. When they were relatively unbiased. The Overton window shift in India is recent before far left were centrist. You can clearly see this. When leftist historian were called in courts and Lied through their teeth and no one questioned them. All were proved false obviously and here we are.
@shrawins lol, they were congress lap dog for decades
1:01:02 my guy the attack happened in 2008 aur aaj tak uss attack ke masterminds aur planers ko state protection de rakhi hai apki country ne. All of this and those visuals of that barbaric attack on innocent civilians is in the living experienced memory of our Nation across states, across languages and across political ideologies. Kaise hoga "behtar"?
Countries in the rest of the world/history have been at war with each other to the most horrifying degree, but have been able to come to positive relationships soon after. The only way to guarantee positive development never happens, is to preemptively deny any hope that progress is even theoretically possible.
@@howmanybeansmakefive pretty convenient to say when your family wasn't the one at the receiving end. Mighty convenient.
@@sahasss7100 how do you know that? My family has been. I’m not Pakistani
@@howmanybeansmakefive that's worse lol. You're ready to make amends with same people who've murdered your civilians for fun and have ZERO empathy for you and WILL do it again the moment they get the opportunity. Either you're delusional or Stockholm Syndrome at its best lol.
do you realize that it is not just one event of 26/11, we have had the parliament attacked, constant kashmir conflict, proxy war of khalistan, air dropping of drugs to punjab? and this is just the surface of the mountain of terrorism issues we have with pakistan. Entire north east insurgency is funded and supported by pakistan. The moment Pak's economy went down, so did the insurgency @@howmanybeansmakefive
59:10 Barkha Dutt was responsible for 2 major misadventures in journalism of her reporting sensitive information from Kargil War and 26/11. she was acting more of an OGW😂. Available on youtube leave her aside.
Why should fair-skinned Aryan martial-race Punjabi Mussalman bother about what dark-skinned Dravidian ex-slave Hindus think about them? Whole of the Pak-Ind subcontinent is a personal property of the Punjabi Mussalman and he/she can do whatever he wants to do in Dehli or Bambay.
Tons of respect for Muni-zae, the respect also comes out because of her mother. Asma jahangir was not only a brilliant mind but also a very brave lady. ( i some how believe she was killed). Muni's analysis of current situation in india is right on the money.MODI'S INDIA IS NOT VERY CIVILIZED INDIA.We feel very embarrassed too. But i also believe that pakistan has big contribution in bringing MODI in india. There were so many attacks that were initiated from pakistan, Bombay was exceptionally BRUTAL and was extremely difficult to swallow.I will suggest, please continue your good work, there is lot of support for you in india. Thanks for everything.
I don't feel embarrass dude... Who the hell are you. Don't use (We) . I saw. Manmohan Singh era In my Collage days that's what Embarrassing was.
oh Miss Barkha Dutt, She was one of the journalists who was covering the "live war' for NDTV. She gained prominence for irresponsibly doing a live commentary during the "secret" Tiger Hill operation. While covering the operation, Barkha Dutt gave away the military location by concluding her live commentary by saying "Barkha Dutt reporting from 56 Brigade HQ" at the end.
She didn’t even blink or hesitate for a second before giving such a crucial bit of information on national television that too, live. It seemed that she was not reporting to inform the citizens but was acting like 'Vibhishan' by helping Pakistan by providing crucial information about the operations and live army movements.
Despite knowing that even army officers do not use satellite phones in conflict zones, as it allows enemies to track their movements, she carried one while doing live coverage of the war zone.
Since that blunder, everyone felt that Kargil's experience would have made the so-called journalist mature about these aspects, however, she again dug her own grave by repeating the same mistake during the Mumbai 26/11 terror attack. While reporting the attack, in one report, she unethically reported that "her sources are on the 19th floor, where the terrorists are currently in their murderous frenzy".
Such blunders by the journalist need to be punished so that the aspiring journalist do not repeat such grave mistakes, " Nahi ta log bolenga ki unko kam nahi milta"
Your mom is a legend. Respect from India
🙌
Yes a very brave lady
Opening statement of video shows that this channel is probably more targetted to indian audience
Good podcast. In the aftermath of the 2008 Mumbai Terrorist Attack, India's accelerated economic growth stands strong, fueled by a public sentiment prioritizing national security, leading to a reluctance for any relationship with Pakistan.
Hamare India ke Godi Media ki Anjana Om Modi , Navika se lekar Rubika Liyuqat Kumari Sharma ke beech Muqabila chal raha hai ke Modi darbar ki Anaarkali kaun banegi ... abb iss me bahut se Pakistani naam bhi shaamil ho gaye hai ,,,, Arzoo , Aaliya , Sana ... and.. and.. and 😜😜
Your name is not Ravinder, you are from North Punjab of Pakistan:)
This are english speaking class of pakistani's but when i see public reaction videos of pakistan some one from street its always about GAZWA E HIND , i have seen even lawyers spewing venom against our country rather about our faith and beliefs , and which is majority of pakistan . and well about Barkha Dutt "journalism" we have seen her "journalism" during 26/11 attacks and even during kargil war and who got benefited by her "journalism" and NDTV they were always a media wing of congress NDTV use to do their celebrations in "Rashtrapati Bhavan" and who says their are no media houses who oppose government narrative , their is The Print , The Wire , The Quint , News laundry and many more and they are part of main stream media their access to a lay man is on Phone , but honest journalism i have not seen on both sides because every has their own personal bias and every one has their own opinion , no one dose reports as it is with facts , no one is holier than thou , NANGAY EK HAMMAM MEIN SAB HAIN
lots of love and respect for her late mother ''Asma Jehangir'' from student of Eng Ali Mirza.
❤️
Indian People are buying Governments narrative 😂😂. Well I just remembered when the Mumbai Terror attacks happened we were watching the news for 72 hours without a break it broke our hearts and the people who did it are freely roaming in Pakistan aren't they? We have seen those people on television and Pakistani Army provides security to them. Chalo maan liya ke Modi fascist hai 😂 but aap kaunse progressive ho? Modi toh protocol tod ke aya tha Nawaz Sharif ke ghar aapne pulwama kar diya, Atal Bihari Vajpayee ji aaye the aapne Kargil kar diya. Iske aage bhi dekhte hai chalo Modi ji hai fascist hai but what about other Indian Prime minister's 😂😂 ? Kya Nehru, Shastri, Indira-Rajeev, Atal Bihari Vajpayee yeh bhi fascist the? In last 75 years we are unable to solve the Kashmir issue why? I know from where she's coming😂 from NDTV😂 btw NDTV is a very biased news channel. Just look at their coverage of 2019 election results coverage. Jo hay tauba kiya jo left liberal elites ka meltdown tha bhaisahab dekhne layak tha.They primarily hate PM Modi but they are unable to digest the fact that the PM Modi is India's most successful PM till date. Jitna bhala Modiji ne kiya hai wo aaj tak kisi PM ko possible nahi hua. Indian economy has doubled in the last decade so that explains everything and Congress toh bilkul bhi nahi aa rahi hai😂😂 so tough luck😂😂.Barkha Dutt has said I make and break Governments😂😂. Toh aise logon ko kya zarurat hai job ki?😂😂.
Madam you spoke the truth of Pakistan about terrorism.
As a Pakistani, do you deserve respect from Indians?
I absolutely loved Asma Jhangeer ji and Marvi Sirmed ji. They spoke for people who have no voice otherwise
She was a classic old school host, patted her back for things that she then condradicted later on. Kudos to kudos to the podcast host for asking right questions
Good chat, but I'm afraid I have to disagree with mainstream media's credibility over social media, especially in a country like Pakistan. People are waking up in the social media age this day. warna, we used to think our neighbors were big bad wolves and we are angels thanks to the "controlled" mainstream media for decades.
I grew up hating Asma Jehangir, starting from our university days in early 2000s. It took more than a decade of gradual learning and 'unlearning' that I have her at a place of great respect in my heart. A brave soul. A fighter. May Allah bless her soul.
She would have been an amazing guest in this podcast.
🙌
🙌
Give hard proof of al lah's existence
Not sure who rules the Pakistan, ISI, Army or selected PM. Most of the people hate Hindus, that's why Hindu / non-muslim population has reduced to 1% from 23% in last 76 years. Still People of Pakistan claim to be human right champions. The lady talked about Barkha Dutt & NDTV, India is a competitive market, to survive the organization has to be economically feasible, if people do not watch it .. its is bound to shut. She Did not talk about Fiza khan of pakistan...
About Barkha and Some Other NDTV reporter who are now Jobless because Like Before ,now Government not giving any favour to them as Journalists. And The Hostile Takeover Madam talking about the owner himself sold that TV Company share , He did it for money . Some of the Indian Journalists are very left leaning Ideology and they're still doing their Job on TH-cam . India gayab ni. Karta reporting k liye.. If I may try to bring light on some matters. Those Journalists lost their credibility when they tried to Ignore some great work Done by the current govt and Blindly criticised everything. They weren't that neutral while reporting the issue as in actual. People saw their Dalla Panti when they Rant 24Hrs how Congress Govt was very good In Center.
Now the tastes changed, As madam said at the end of the day they're doing business and had to Bring Money home.. So the reporting styles did changed a lot. Now story based Reporting work as in Documentary and Primetimes are now Mindless Debate Show 😌
Why has Pakistani police arrested Shoiab chaudhury of Real Entertainment just casue he called PM modi a brand and makes indian content .
Why Pak TH-camrs like Sana Amjad , Ribaha Imran , Muzzamil sheikh , Mehwish Naz ,Anam Sheikh , Naila khan live in Fear of Arrest ?
Should pakistan not help its citizens to live in freedom of press and democracy
Neutral Toh Jaanwar Hota Hai 😡
Munizee has a naive and tinted view of her own country...she needs to be more critical. She is approaching things in an emotional way! Other than that, she has a tunnel vision for india... without much basis and little analysis or details. On the other hand, the host has a better grip on both Pakistan and India both! Though none of you have any idea about tye complex interplay of forces and the highly changing situation of India! Even Indians are getting surprised every year in india..
So don't try or approach very carefully 😂
Uncanny resemblance to her mom....style of speaking, voice, passion, clarity.
Nice interview!
🙌
Journalism is Same everywhere now. In INDIA you try to write against BJP, even America or many countries of Europe you can not write what you think is right unless you want to lose your job or death threats.
modi ke family dekhi sada wargi ah middle class aap ka lya villain hai sada lya hero
One can understand how liberal and reslient Pakistant media is from the fact that podacst person has to delete and cut words from her when she was talking about now younger generation of Indians think Pakistan as terror exporter.😂😂😂😂😂 Inke jhoot ki pole toh isi program mein khul gayi
Hi from India,
After sometime had a time to watch your show.
Since I like you, I respond, not sure if this is taken in right sense. Few points to add.
1. Media restriction was an issue sometime back, but now with TH-cam it is not, in fact with popularity of TH-cam MSM has started loosing relevence, So Media now should stop being a cry baby.
2. On Godi Media, in fact this was also the case earlier during Non BJP Government, and almost all of the non bjp state government, they are called Durbari Media, their loyalty to Congress is far more than that of so called Godi Media to BJP. Barkha Dutt is considered one of them, not so much liked by some Indian masses. In fact there were reports, she would involve herself with Congress Govt to lobby for Ministrial berth for people. Maybe your host, since not from India is not well informed and that was the reason why NDTV kept loosing viewership.
If you say so..🙃
Miss the Iron Lady Asma Jahanghir. Hope her daughter make her mother's name shines more.
I don't know why but on TH-cam everyone from Pakistan podcast i feel they are sold to there army and they always be nice to get views only. Inside they are hating india i don't know but it's my personal feelings seems like these pakistani youtubers are part of any agenda.
She is a daughter of brave lady who always remained critical of the establishment, but somehow, she is lacking her traits and having soft corners for them.
Shehzad sb, kindly do a podcast series on war on terror years in Pakistan. Invite people from Peshawar, Lahore and Quetta and the tribal parts. Take testimonies of the horror we as people have faced. It is imperative that the world must know the history from the people who were pushed into this war. Mainstream media, the state has no concern with the suffering inflicted upon us. - writing from Lahore.
as usual good one. she also tried to save the face of dirty journalism at some point came with different answer why this law why that law. and you always very brave to ask questions which should be asked. ❤
Wonderful human being and worthy daughter of an illustrious Humanist mother. My best wishes and blessings.
Why you losing sleep over Indian Visa. I wouldn't go to the extremists country if offered free travel to India.
Extremely Happy To Watch This Podcast.. Love You..Asma Was My Favourite..🙏🙏🌺🙏🙏
🙌
شیرنی ماں کی شیرنی بیٹی تاریخ رقم ہوتی رھے گی ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️👍💕🐎🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🐎🐎🐎🐎💕💕💕💕
India Pakistan romance n India ko kuch n diya to break up ho gya , india move on kr gya aur Pakistan ko y dikkat h ki india ab hmari yaad m aansu kyu nhi bahata
I wonder where are these intellectual Pakistani’s in real life???? These guys are just doing it to get Indian viewership
Wow.a Pakistani in Indian media 😊!!!!. Now we can know how credible the NDTV was...
Well i dnt think there is struggle for journalists in pakistan i think we have more news channel then any other country its is business manipulation and and problems starts when they chose sides instead of fair and neutral journalits. The idea of journalism is give news not to manipulte impose and force their ideas upon ppl.
For the first time, I watched hour hour-long podcast. very first time.
it is really engaging. I was of no mind to give it a full shot but it took.
I am not supporting you due to Mian Murzai.You promoted Qadiani.Shame
I have total respect for you and your Journalism. Can I contact you to get news.
Name to lo na army kay journal(s) ka batao Amjad shoiab(R) ki baat ho rahi hai. jo pehlay army ki uthao giri karta tha aur ab army nay hi utha liya us ko.
पाकिस्तान में असली इस्लाम अल्ला मोहमद कुरान हदीस अभी तक बचा हुआ है क्या ????
Your PM said 300 time war on india. People of pakistan want good relegation with us how it is possiable
As an Indian I love this podcast because of no hypernationalism talk on facts and real conversation. IT is better than many indian podcast.
🙌
But this podcaster defended 7Oct Terrerist attack on unarmed civilians,hypernationalistic indians opposed this Terrerist attack
Hypernationalism means standing up with humanity.
@@bhalkitoday8267I don’t think he was defending it, but trying to understand it. How can hypernationalism stand up for the whole world/humanity? What about those outside of that nation, or outside of all/any nations? Surely there is an element of contradiction with hypernationalism
@@howmanybeansmakefive share the video where he said 7 Oct was a terrorist attack. He vehemently defended acts of terrorism by Hamas terrorists on a peaceful gathering.
@@Takecare55 yes in pakisthan you can't find a single person who supports Israel but in india you found crores of muslims supporting Hamas even though india supporting Israel
This shows freedom of expression and freedom of speech in india.
Valiant defense of Pakistani journalism. While I appreciate her view about Pakistani journalists having to work in very adverse conditions, she comes across as an indulgent mother who can see the travails of her son but can’t see his/her shortcomings. But, if you ask her about the neighbours, she becomes objective and all knowing. But it’s good that Shehzad did his job and tried to make her see the light multiple times.
True, you are right. But it's also easier for Shahzad to say that as he is only a TH-camr, and it is easier for him to express his opinion. But journalism isn't only about opinion but primarily about news collection and reporting. There is an entire organisation and network involved. In short, the stakes are much much higher.
@@user-rh5jp2sh4sShahzad khud green TV k lie kaam KR chka ha k Jo khud Kisi retd fouji K under ata ha.
Jahan apna pait laga ho wo thk ha baqi SB ghalat
@@user-rh5jp2sh4s I agree. Why have the podcast then? To me, she appeared to be more like Maleeha Lodhi’s child than Asma Jahangir’s.
@@RohiteshSharma
Asma Jahangir was an exceptional person... very brave indeed but also skillfull. So comparisons shouldn't be done. But her daughter's basic thinking (protection of fundamental rights and rule of law) is the same
@@user-rh5jp2sh4s agree
Well one cannot forget the 3 days of horror we have faced.. and also the way it was celebrated across the border..
Almost every Maharashtrian has someone who was personally affected by the Mumbai attack be it 2008 1991 2011 etc and pune attack. I know my father was .. we cannot forget about it and forgive Pakistani establishment for support to them
I remember those terrible horrifying days , watching on TV
In islamabad, pakistan
And cried.. felt such sadness...
So no , not everyone celebrated...
Am sorry, u all had to go through that...
May no one face such cruelty n madness n terrorism again ever...
Sending u love n lots of prayers
@@murtaza636 yes not everyone.. but a few did.. and that's the problem.. and even today the handler of the terrorist group run scot free in Pakistan..
in India when there was that attack on army public school in Pakistan.. not a single person celebrated every school assembly had a day of mourning.. including the government.
We don't have any issues with the public.. but the government we cannot trust..
My point is simple will you be ok if the mastermind of any terrorist attack in Pakistan would be roaming freely in India..
She is very wise and an open minded person who can look at the bigger picture. Not at all bitter or revengeful. Amazing courage, but then again she is Asma Jahangir’s daughter!
🙌
Are to advwrtising money products aur services ne lao
India me govt funding for ads is miniscule
Very Difficult to find Asma Jahangir, she was only one.
very well articulated podcast. everything bogs down to humman index development and that comes from education. more the pakistanis will swing towards education easier it will be for them to drift away from radicalisation. best wishes from india 🇮🇳 !
🙌
I beg to differ -
From Laden to keralites who joins ISIS were all educated.
Khabardar hamre piche kyu rehte hohame Pakistan's se koi matlab nahi hai na hum rakhna chahte hai chahe modi govt rahe yana rahe aur jahatak ye baat hai hum to develop kargaye hai utna nahi jitna west lekin aapse zyada it s you hame aapki koi zarurat nahi hai (pakistan)
Mhatlab confirmed hogia hai Balochistan mein phele se gayab karraha hai bandah ko😢
They can't digest that people or certain journalists support the current government. Or the fact that the government is really making india progress ...they can't digest.
You are too dumb to understand that it is not a journalist's job to support the current Government
Saying that no matter the corruption, at least we have these politicians. If we keep on accepting these criminal politicians nothing is going to change.
Madam jahangir seems mesmerized by Bollywood ...
Will anybody from India can pass on this podcast to Rajdeep, Barkha, Rabish &to Abisekh sharma please😂
This was too short. There was so much more to explore. A classic TPE three and half hours would be the only thing appropriate. Ahh! Maybe next time.
❤️
Yo bro... thanks for this one... i didnt even know Asma had a daughter ... an accomplished one too it seems ... miss Asma ...wish there were more like her... on both sides of the border.
🙌
Barkha dutt is journalist is saying like Pakistan is a secular state 😅😅
She is exceptionally talent and ahead of her time.. Great session Shehzad, keep it up 🙌🏼
🙌
ended too soon :( .... it was such a pleasure listening to her nuanced take on things :)
wish you won't pack so many guests back to back & give ppl (esp. like her) more time.... they have so much more to tell/say/share...
but thank you once again 👍
🙌
She is the only Pakistani journalist I know by name. She was NDTV's Pakistan correspondent for a longest time. Looking forward to the podcast!
🙌
after watching this podcast 3 conclusions drawn from this interview
NDTV ---The original Founder of GODI MEDIA courtesy Prannoy Roy😆😆😆
Barkha Dutt's name featured in Neera Radia Tapes and Munizae still appreciates her .....shocking?
Pakistan today is very irrelevant in Indian Peoples narrative so nobody in India cares about Pakistan anymore unlike the past &the reason for that is only Pakistan has to be blamed for this dip in relationship..It can't even maintain good relations with muslim dominated Afghanistan & Iran
Thats why htey say.."people who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones"
Syed muzzamil is another one to watch
@@pranaypratik8634ok