My Springfield(s) 1911`s are impeccably reliable, reasonably concealable, and exceptionally "shootable" ...yep, I carry a 1911 to the grocery store, and the gas station, and the mall, and on a Sunday drive.
I started/learning shooting strikers first...shot my first 1911, INSTANTLY made it my carry. 😅😅. I love it and it's easy to shoot accurately. 9 or .45. Piece of cake.
I agree with almost everything you said except that i carry the lightweight commander in .45 with the 8 round Wilson Combat magazine. I have carried this weapon "on the job" for 30 plus years. Never had an issue. I shoot every weekend. I do not consider myself an expert but i am very comfortable with this weapon. I do love my lightweight commander.
I actually made it thru 3.5 minutes without wanting to say something. I've been carrying a 1911 more than anything else in the 35+ years that I've been carrying a pistol. My current carry gun is a Colt 1911 Officer model Series 80 in SS with a Barsto barrel & bushing. At most, I might have paid in the $600-$700 range. After more than 10,000 rounds, I've had ONE failure and that was a weak magazine spring. I agree that the 9mm is a perfectly fine round but there's nothing wrong with the 38 Super. Less recoil, good ballistics & very accurate in a steel pistol. I like the 5" or even a full size with some kind of jacket but warm weather fits a 3.5" perfectly and I don't need to hit a steel plate at 35 yards (a 3" group at 25 yards with my Colt is fine) since most defensive shooting is going to be at less than 10 yards without even using sights. The main things that I can agree on are....practice, invest in quality mags & ammo! Shoot as much as financially possible!
I must admit that I am 76 years old and I mention this because my experience with hand guns was first with a S&W Revolver and it was my Duty Weapon for many years before I was able to Carry a G19 as my duty weapon. Having said this, back in the day, my first EDC Carry Gun was the Colt 1911 A1 all steel Gun! Yes, very heavy and I soon changed to the Colt Light Weight Officer Model for everyday carry. I just loved my single stack 1911's and at this time they were very popular Guns to carry! Things Change and I tried the Glock Platform and then I discovered I found them to be the perfect Gun for my EDC needs and the rest is History! My EDC is my G43 and I just purchased a G48 which has been a Great shooter!
I carried the Colt Officers for years. Shot a fellow Recon Marines Kimber Ultra Carry at the range about 10 years ago. Had to have it. I have been carrying one ever since. I hear all the time that they are not reliable. But, every single malfunction I have seen has been from a limp wrist. There are heavy springs in that short slide, and they need a tight wrist to push against to get full slide action.
Great advice. Thank you.Last year I bought my wife, a 1911 fan, a Springfield EMP 1911 .9mm. She just signed up for her CCW, and intends to carry her gun. What do you think? Thanks, from a new fan.
Thanks for sharing your opinions. I enjoy your perspective. I started carrying a 1911 thirty plus years ago. I carried the Colt Delta Elite 10MM, mostly open carry or in a shoulder holster. This is a great gun. I now carry the Springfield EMP4 9MM and the Springfield EMP3 9MM. They are both extremely reliable whether I shoot range loads or self defense rounds.
Thanks Lisa for all the support of carrying an Kimber ultra carryII 45acp. I love it and will continue carrying it when I go to certain places. I also carry my M&P Shield on lite days. I am not by no means a weapon expert, but I have a good amount of guns and long rifles, ar,ak, and my newest 30/30 lever action. I have a private range that I shoot at ever weekend. I reload a lot of my own ammo but maybe shoot 700-900 rounds a week. I am also retired USAR, 24yrs. Maybe that's why I love firearms.
I’ve owned 1911’s for over 35 years, having transitioned from Colt and S&W revolvers. I’ve had inexpensive 1911’s and higher end. I’ve been carrying a Colt Defender since 1996, when I purchased it new. I couldn’t tell you how many rounds I’ve put through it. Shortly after I got it, the gun shop owner I bought it from asked me if I had any jam ups, I hadn’t. I said if I had a few minutes he would polish the feed ramp which he did. He said he had gotten a flyer about feeding troubles. To this day, knock on wood, it’s been trouble free. I sold my Kimber Custom Shop, a Springfield long slide, Dan Wesson, and ParaOrdinace P12 LDA, because they either jammed or had a something I didn’t like. I have a Colt Commander that’s also been good to me. But daily I will continue to rely on my Defender.
Carried a 1911 .45 acp concealed for years. Always felt safe and confident. To me, the simplest, most basic, least fancified pistol is the best. I favor the original GI model, perhaps with a throating for reliability. Now I carry the Springfield Armory Mil Spec, and that thing is spectacular. It has a few minor improvements- throating, beveled mag well, relieved ejection port, hi-viz sights, but those are not superfluous. That thing shoots, has never malfunctioned, and is extremely tight and precise. Very very accurate. Thanks.
I have carried a Kimber Ultra Carry II in 45acp 3.5" barrel for yrs. I have attended Front Sight Firearms Training Institute with it. I have had no issues or failures with said firearm. It is my constant companion (The Comforter) I also own a Springfield TRP, and 2 Colts, love them all. I will never leave home without my 45acp 1911.
I enjoyed your video. After about 45 years of screwing around with 1911s (the good, the bad, and the ugly) I agree with most of what you said. I particularly think you have set a reasonable reliability standard for testing (200 rounds training ammo, 50 rounds carry ammo) that anyone considering the 1911 for carry should be able to afford. My LW Commander I use now is one of the new 2016 Colts, and I find it to be a fine pistol. The new dual recoil spring really works and when I shoot it side by side with my all-steel Commander it feels the same. I got mine in .45 ACP because I'm an old fart who lived back in the day when the 9mm didn't work, so psychologically I just feel better with those big old fat slugs. I know it's probably silly, but that's just me. I also had a ton of Wilson magazines in .45 and none in 9mm, lol. But now that I'm getting old and turning into a bigger wuss with each passing day, my next 1911 will probably be a 9mm. I'm thinking of a Springfield Range Officer Champion to experiment with. In short, I can't really disagree with anything you said, except that I've seen more than my share of problems with SIG 1911s, but that was right after they started making them, so that might be unfair. I'm going to have to look into Dan Wessons. Thanks for a good video. P.S. I still back up my 1911 with a J-frame revolver, which fortunately I shoot very well. That ability with a snub is no doubt the product of a misspent youth :)
Agree totally. I would be carrying a LW 9mm Commander if Colt had been making them three years ago...so I'm carrying a LW Commander in 38 Super. It's had about 2000 rounds through it and I don't recall any failures at all, but I don't keep written records like Tam does. Hits all three objectives easily for me and 124 gr HPs hit an honest 1340 fps. Handy for the odd coyote when bird hunting.
Great video. I have been recently testing the Kimber Micro 9mm. I needed a small pocket easy carry gun. I live in Arizona and pretty much all year long wear shorts and a t shirt. I have found the Micro 9 to be very accurate for a small gun and super reliable at this time. I have 300 rounds through it and no malfunctions. Time will tell how it goes, but so far so good. Thanks.
I always like your videos. They show that you have actually thought about what your are talking about. You present your arguments in a concise, cogent way (with added humor) and you make sense. That's not the most common trait in TH-cam gun videos. You are also confident enough to go against the prevailing winds on the caliber wars without getting bogged down in them. Nice work. It's nice to listen to a grown up talking about something he knows well. Keep it up.
Gun Nuts Media how about doing a review on a Beretta Px4 Storm Full-Size in 9mm & I been carrying this firearm for the past 3 yrs already & love it on it by having 17+ 1 rounds & never had any malfunctions through all the yrs I've been carrying it but just wanted to let you know on what I carry & I carry it in the Alien Gear Cloak Tuck 3.0. Obtw that I almost forgot to mention is that could you also do a Citadel Full-Size 1911 Model as well & haven't had any problems, too. I had that firearm as long as the Px4 Storm
the 45 will always have more kinetic energy then the 9mm everyone compares the 9mm hollow point to a 45 ball. shoot the same bullet out of both and the 45 will cause more damage.
+Mark Hallett no it won't, but that's okay I understand that most people are really ignorant about handgun wounding mechanisms. If you'd like to educate yourself I can suggest some really great technical papers.
@@MrRevolver depends on the powder then because 45 should have more kinetic energy transferred but not at a smaller point i am assuming the 45 has more powder because of a bigger shell. I would love the technical papers
Caliber arguments are becoming silly and obsolete with the advancements in bullet design and ballistics; frankly it just narrows down to the quality of the ammunition used. That being said, the old thought of 9mm being lesser then 45 was true FOR THE TIME when 9mm (as for most bullets) were not further developed, it was left upon which had more powder loaded in them so logically the 45acp held that advantage. But now thanks to science and engineering, the 9mm can hold it's own, yes the 45 is a bigger slug of a round but 9mm isn't a lightweight either. Also consider human beings are pretty resilient, especially when hopped up on drugs or adrenaline, I've heard stories from guys taking shotgun blasts and still moving. Now they of course died but not without some fight still left in them. Case and point, being over reliant and putting your gamble on the bullet is a trivial and somewhat dangerous game to play.
I ordered a new Valkyrie 9mm commander from Dan Wesson this week. CZ has a nice program for first responders and military. Also ordered Wilson Combat mags. I hope you become a rep for Dan Wesson cause you sold me on it Caleb.
I like your choice of the lightweight commander in 9mm. What is your opinion of the new Springfield Armory EMP4 in 9 mm? Is it comparable to your choice?
Agree with pretty much everything here. I’ve been carrying a Springfield Range Officer Elite compact in 45 for a little while now and it’s great. 4in barrel, aluminum frame, ramped bull barrel, and an awesome trigger. Only thing I changed from the point of getting the gun out of the box was switching to some Wilson Combat mags. Seems like every 1911 I’ve ever owned has only had issues while firing from the magazines that came with the gun, never had any feeding issues after swapping to the Wilsons. I’ll never understand how 20+ manufactures manage to make magazines that have issues when there’s obviously a design that just works *shrug*
Now in all of your videos I've never heard you once mention Remington, for being either good nor bad. I purchased my first gun 6 months ago and it was the Remington R1 1911(200th anniversary edition), yet I don't ever see anyone talking about Remington 1911's in their videos. I think I've put 1000 rounds into it so far and only problems I've had were when I first got it and the stock magazine were utter shit until I started using them. Since then I've gone like 900 rounds without failure. Great gun. I love your videos by the way. Going to go buy a good belt today and start carrying as soon as possible.
I carry an old llama 1911 .45 . Commander. I maintain the gun and it shoots flawlessly . It's had thousands of rounds shot through it and it still works great. I replace parts when they wear and it has that "old friend" feel.
My tisas 1911 comander is over 1000x rounds no issues. Wilson combat mags make the difference. 45acp in ballistics next to 9mm are Night and day 45.is the superior round
Only issue I see is that you are comparing a $1,600? CZ against $8-900 guns ( Colt, Springfield etc )as to which one is best and there is a huge difference in quality with that big a price jump. You are almost into custom gun prices with the CZ.
I currently carry a PPQ M2 SC 9mm, thinking about getting a 45 next. Ive always liked 1911s but comparing it to the PPQ chambered in 45. I'm really on the fence. Browsing around a few months back I saw a Dan Wesson that I liked but at twice the price (around $1300). The capacity difference is crazy
Love my lightweight Commander! Easy to shoot and accurate as all heck. I use a leather chest side old military style holster. The gun absolutely disappears.
Hi Calib, thanks for the great videos you share with us. I have a smith & wesson performance center commander size 1911 bobtail in 45acp, great carry gun and range gun. 1000 rounds with zero issues, thanks again for all your input, God bless you, al
"I wouldn't recommend a 1911 for conceal carry" My 10mm 1911 A2 fits just fine under the coat with a low profile shoulder holster. There are IWB holsters that can make a full size completely disappear. However, if you want the most versatile CCW 1911, I would go with a cbob and possibly a scandium or 7075 aluminum frame. If your 1911 doesn't function properly it's because you bought a cheap one that needs an hour of polishing and/or a slight adjustment to the extractor. These days they cost anywhere from 500 to 3000 depending on which one you want. Guaranteed a properly tuned 1911 made entirely from 4140 steel is going to be more accurate, reliable, and will last longer than any polymer sidearm you get your hands on.
To @ Kaiser : His reply to you is ' sigh ' ? What is his experience ? Ex airforce military police ? Glorified babysitter or tantamount to a security guard ? No real strenuous training like the Marines or Army . Taught only the basics, promoted grunt mentality to take orders and not to think by drill sgt/military, and no combat experience or medals reflecting same ? What has he done to take him beyond the basics the military has taught him ? I seriously doubt he has the experience or expertise to be worthy to shine Travis Tomasi 's shoes or other true experts and champions . People should stop allowing themselves to be manipulated into believing military and paramilitary service alone qualifies individuals as experts . A task impossible to accomplish if they ( viewers ) are weak minded or lack common sense . You ever notice that bullies ( a.k.a. cowards ) try to intimidate using methods such as loud talking you ( yelling ), talking over you, posturing, etc ? Navy Seals, and Green Berets possess the 3 C 's ( cool, calm and collective ) . According to a reliable associate this guy is false bravado and exhibit traits associated with the opposite of people like Paul Harrell, etc . Go talk to some Navy Seals and examine the difference between this guy .
Excellent video. Thank you for posting it. I love the m1911a1 in as close to the GI issue as possible. Mine is a Springfield Armory GI, which is a replica of what we were issued in the Service, right down to the lanyard ring. To me, THAT'S a 1911. I even replaced the good-looking wooden stocks with plastic grips, to make it more historically accurate. And, I CAN carry it. It meets all the criteria you cited. Right now, I'm wearing it, appendix position, with my shirt tucked in, but not tucked into the holster, bloused over the grip (my usual carry method), which I find makes for a quicker draw, and the gun is invisible. I had bought a Smith and Wesson M&P 45 compact for carry, and while I can't really fault the gun, I just don't love it. It's kind of like marrying for money instead of for love. The M&P Shield 9mm is much better, in my opinion. But what I REALLY love for carry IS my J Frame, Smith and Wesson 442 airweight snubnose revolver. There's something about the snubbie and the 1911 that is almost magical. Mystical? I don't really know how to describe it. The snubnose IS harder to shoot accurately, but that gives me an excuse to go to the range. Two speed strips in my pocket, plus 5 in the cylinder, and I'm carrying 15 rounds more than most people are carrying.
Caleb, thank you so much for making this video. Loved watching you compete on “Top Shot” back in the day too btw. What do you think about the Kimber brand?
I have had three Kimber 1911s. One of them was amazing, search for Kimber Team Match II on my channel. One of them was okay, and one of them was pretty awful. I think with Kimber if you get a good one it will be awesome, but if you get a bad one it's going to be really bad.
My personal favourite carry pistol was the lightweight commander in 45acp, with Wilson 8 round magazines. In competitive shooting however I scored much better with a full size steel framed Government model, the extra weight improved recovery time from recoil, and the longer sight radius was certainly an advantage on targets at longer distances. Also I had more faith in the 45acp cartridge than 9mm loads at that time, for both effectiveness and reliability. I find your current reasoning well thought out, and correct in conclusion. Because of improvements in today's 9mm loads, the better choices of pistols available in that calibre, and the extra round capacity. When carrying every day the saving in weight of the lightweight commander over the Government model is appreciably more comforting.
Nice gun, but I don't see it replacing my Kahr TP9, which is lighter weight, just as thin, has a smooth and high stress friendly, double action trigger; and has no safeties to deal with in a defensive encounter.
Pretty well reasoned presentation even if it took a while to get to your "aha" moment. I'm glad I stuck around for that moment because it turns out I'm in total agreement. I have J frames and a Glock 43 and a Walther 9 and a little Kimber .380 but the gun I absolutely shoot the best is my 9mm Ruger 1911 commander-size that was introduced just this year. Alloy frame, stainless slide, Series 70 so no silly firing pin block to mess with the trigger pull. It is no more difficult to conceal than the Glock or the Walther, and when I draw it and put it into my hand I know I can hit whatever I need to hit. 11 rounds with another 10 in my spare mag (thanks Chip McCormick) should be enough to get it done. Look, the FBI went down from .40 to 9mm, so with the right ammo I definitely know I'm as good to go as I can be. Plus the 1911 is just too cool.
My father left me lots of firearms when he passed in 1998! Is my Colt 1911 Ambassador .45 acp a good idea for a concealed weapon? Shoots awesome, never hangs up, but it’s a little heavy! What holster and type would u recommend!(new to concealed carry) hunted and shot firearms my whole life! Figured it’s time to legally carry! God Bless !🇺🇸❤️🙏
I own the Springfield Range Officer Compact in 45ACP. You made very good points in the video and I have to agree with them. However, I like this little Springfield even though it goes against the grain of some of your comments in that it is not a traditional 1911 design. So far it has been reliable with about 200 rounds of mostly ball and some hollow points so I am happy with it regarding reliability. I have smaller hands so the office size grip presents me with no problems in getting and maintaining a good two hand grip plus it makes the firearm easier to conceal. I have been interested in your latest test with the 357 sig 1911 because I love the cartridge matched up the 1911 style pistol. Thank you for the videos as they are always enjoyable and educational.
I've been carrying my sig, fastback, commander,45acp, for years. never had a problem. I run golden sabers in a Tripp cobra mag,and sx big dot sights. 1911s are a little more hi maintenance and complex,than my other carry weapons though.
I have a Colt Combat Commander 45ACP. My main EDC. Very easy to conceal with my Milt Sparks Summer Special IWB leather holster. Now I will be looking for a light weight Commander or Wiley Clapp Commander in 9mm. Never knew the Commander was originally designed for 9mm. Thought it was 38 Super. But 9mm makes sense for a light weight Commander. Thanks for sharing.
NICE job!!! I love 1911 for CC...... Just a great feel, and accurate. I have the Ruger LW Commander and the Springfield LW RO..... both in 9mm..... and HST ammo.
I bought a para ordnance tac-4 20 years ago. I carried it every day for at least 10 years. I still prefer that to any other gun even now. That’s a .45 ACP with a double stack magazine. It’s a 4 1/4 inch barrel and a 13 round magazine. I know para doesn’t make that gun anymore but they do make s similar version the p-13 LDA. I really do love that gun. Just bought a new alien gear cloak tuck holster. The new holster makes it even better.
I got lucky bought a $450 rock island 1911 and the only issue I’ve had is for the fact that if you use a low end 7 round magazine the slide doesn’t lock back when out of ammo
Great video! You forgot Kimber, in my opinion, another good reasonably priced option. I carry a Nighthawk Custom 5 inch GRP in .45 ACP. I just prefer that caliber, but, have owned 9mm in the past.
Nothing at all wrong with Dan Wesson or Sig Sauer but also nothing wrong with a Ruger SR 1911 or Springfield Armory A1 Mil Spec or the Ronin!! Great video very informative!!!
During my advanced CCW course, I felt sorry for the lady who brought a snubnose .38 to shoot. She had a terrible time getting one on the target which just verified what you said. It also really wore her out because of the recoil. I told her and her husband that they were really tough to get good at and they had to agree.
Very interesting! Now you've gone and made me want to get a Lightweight Commander. I've been carrying a double-stack 9 mm for some time and have been looking for something slimmer, yet with decent bang for the buck. And I agree that 9 mm is just fine for firepower.
I carry a Springer RO Elite 9mm commander. Over 1k rounds, two malfunctions, both not issues from the gun. Confident to protect life with it, its a gem to shoot. Know the platform, learn it well and the 1911 is a fine gun for carry protection, once you get the relaibily out of the way, the ergonomics, and quality of the trigger makes it a even more formidable weapon for daily carry.
I would argue you’re gonna need more than 1000 rounds worth of training to be proficient. I will look at it as an ongoing endeavor that deserves consistent maintenance.
I carry a colt combat commander. 70 series 45 apc corbon hp jacked I put it in the galco sob holster it shoots every time l won't ever get rid of it. OK thanks for the help good vedeo. Keith
Terminal ballistics and wound cavities in gel blocks may not look very different between different handgun cartridges however the “stopping power” conundrum does have some truth to it. The foot pounds of energy generated with good carry ammo that doesn’t over penetrate in .45 caliber is far more impactful then 9mm. When looking at the numbers you will see that .45 produces nearly three times the foot pounds of energy then a 9mm. You simply can not say 9mm and .45 are equal.
All you vids are pretty good but this one is one of your best. Really good "cut and dry" information. I really learned a lot and feel a little more comfortable shopping for my first 1911. I am familiar with your work on other channels as well as your own and know you have extensive experience with this platform. thanks again, keep the vids coming. How the f@#k do you only have 9000+ followers!?
I have never agreed with anyone so much ever. I carry the new 2016 Colt lightweight commander in 9mm. I worked plain clothes law enforcement my last 14 years and bumped into too many door jams with my double stack guns and wanted the lightweight commander. Ruger has just released their version of the SR1911 with commander size in 9mm.
How do you feel about the Ruger sr1911, I've herd good things but I'd like to see one really put to the test. They still are the "new kid on the block" in a way.
Ruger SR1911 Lightweight Commander. It's large, but it's very slim and light. Lot of gunsmith type features from the factory. Rosewood grips, Titanium feed ramp. Titanium firing pin. Skeletonized trigger. Adjustable trigger (I leave it at the factory setting). Put well over 2,000 rounds through it in the last 2 years I've owed it. ZERO malfunctions. Cost me $600 plus tax at a gun shop.
I like your videos.Most gun nuts disagree with your opinion.But i agree with 100%.I carry S.A. Champion Operator LW 45acp.But now thinking about S.A. EMP 9mm in 3" or 4" what do you think?Thanks,Rob----Be well stay safe!
@@VMEMotor5 I carry a Springfield Armory A1 Mil Spec 1911 .45 loaded with Federal HST 230 grain JHP!! I’m very comfortable in my ability to stop any threat that comes my way!!!
What is your opinion on the colt 1911 combat commander, in blued steel, chambered in 38 super? Biggest reason I ask is there is already one in the family. Why pay for something if you can get it for free, as long as it is good right?
Couldn't agree with you more. I see no problem at all with the 9mm , it has a light felt recoil and it is a lot easier to get off a follow up shot if needed. As a former military man, I have to say the Commander size is really an ideal size for carry if you insist on a 1911. I agree that the manufacturers you named are very reputable and a good selection , but there re several others that will fit into the list as well.
I just picked up my first 1911. It’s a Springfield RO elite operator in 10mm. Not sure about making my CCW yet since I’ve only got 100 rounds through it so far but it’s a blast to shoot. It’s doesn’t particularly care for cheap ammo though.
You are wrong about terminal ballistics the 45 has the edge over the 9MM as for the LW commander being the best carry gun in 1911 I completely agree there keep up the good work
Thanks so much for the video. Any thoughts on the Browning Right 380? Love the 1911 frame just not sure about the caliber. I have owned 45's but none that I can conceal carry. Thank you.
Actually I think your choice is good but I would recommend the Dan Wesson ECO in 9mm over the light weight commander. It shoots as well and is even more concealable.
What is your opinion on the 38 Super? I have a Colt Government model 1911 chambered in 38 Super and a RIA chambered in 38 Super. I love the 38 Super! Great channel by the way. Thanks for the great vids and information.
A thing I’d like people to say about 1911s though is that they are just mechanical pieces. They can be tuned very easily with simple tools. Yes if you’ve got the money get a pro to do it if there is an issue. But you can also do it yourself. It’s not hard. People do it all the time. It is just care, time, and making sure you understand what you are doing. A rock island 1911 can become an excellent weapon with some polishing and a complete spring kit from Wilson combat. That’s a 550 dollar total give or take some. You can buy any part for a 1911 in any material oversized so that you can file and polish it down to the custom fit that you get with a les Baer or whatever. If something is messed up with the frame rails or slide rails or feed ramp in a negative manner as in not enough material (so you can’t just smooth it into reliability) then send it the heck back to the maker. And guess what you’re doing the whole time: learning, training, and having fun with YOUR gun that you defend your life and the life of others with.
I’ve carried my 70 Series Commander for 25 years. It was gone through originally by an old friend/armorer stationed at Camp Pendleton. Since then I’ve learned enough to maintain it. In 25 years I have a $1500 into it in that time: Novak sights, lightly smoothed edges, Bar-Stow barrel and Cerakote in matte dark grey. As to ballistics you are incorrect. I was privy to the ballistics test SOCOM did in the early 90s that lead to the development of the USP .45. Get the knock down power debate out of the discussion. If that’s your argument you are 100% correct. Stopping power is actually based on the ability to rapidly cause shock inducing trauma. Shock is what stops an assailant, not simple impact. Even on HP vs HP .45 vs 9mm always cause very different wounds. 9mm HP are alway deeper and narrower. .45 HP aren’t as deep but are wider, affecting more organs. The physics of the shock wave are the reason. Add to that the ability of a quality 230 gr HP to punch through walls and similar barriers and still be more affective, it’s the hands down choice to me. Where it gets muddy is the calibers in between. I prefer to stay out of THAT mud and use the tried and true.
I like a single stack so as long as your belt and holster are up to the job any 1911 that conceals well is good enough to me. Weight isn't that big of an issue depending on what your current activity is. I was doing electrical work with a glock19 IWB and a tool pouch over it, no problems.
Wow... great video - very informative - I too love the 1911 foundation and have a couple of nice Browning 1911-380's - enjoy them both - great shootability - now am in the market to pick up another 1911 in 9mm. Your information about the commander was great - thank You !!!!
Thinking about a Ruger SR1911. The newer model with the titanium feed ramp. What I want out of a handgun is a good look, comfortable grip, the possibility based on general prestige to be an inheritance piece, and the ability to both be conceal carried and used for woods defense from animals. I also don't want it to be TOO awfully expensive to shoot, as I have that problem with my current only gun right now, a 12ga Mossberg 500. ((And that's just ammo since the range makes you shoot buck or slugs, and that shits $25 a box for the cheap stuff. The defense ammo I bought was $19 for a box of 10. Also, since range fees are costly, I don't get to shoot often, but I digress.))
The best 1911 for CC is a Pro Series Sub-Compact Smith & Wesson in a 45 cal. Small enough at 3" that you don't mind wearing it. Perfect, If six shots are enough (It is in rural MO). If the SHTF, I will upsize for additional range and rounds.
opening statement "99% of the public should not carry a 1911" Wow, kinda hard to believe. Everybody I know including people I come across at chance with people they know all have 1911s and carry them. I'd have to say 95% of the people I meet if at a gun range or a car show have and carry a 1911. Seems that comment is a little off since you just don't seem to like a 1911. Hell man I don't like Mustangs so you're not going to catch me making a video on the best one to drive. Now do I have a Glock??,,,Yes Glock 19. I also carry Berettas, S&W 686 Plus 3"barrel and one of 5 different 1911 choices. Very seldom carry the Glock and almost always carry a 1911. I have them in 9mm and 45 but I find that most of the Mellinnials today don't carry a 1911 because they are just afraid of it. To be honest it's one of the safest guns to carry. Like anything else you have to train with it and the comfort level just appears. It is the most pointable and easiest platform to shoot. I agree the Plastic Generation has taken over but when it comes down to the bones of it I'm gonna carry good ole metal on my hip and you're gonna get hit with a round the size of my thumb!!!! Have a nice Day
John Delvisco agree 100%. The only argument for a polymer gun is weight and perhaps cost. Weight makes no difference to a guy built like me but may on a smaller person maybe? Of capacity is really something you want there are very good double stack 1911s. I put 300 rds through a Remington R1 double last month and own an original Para conversion. But realistically I’m not John Wick and I’ve been out of combat and protection duty for 20 years. If 8+1 and two spares isn’t enough for me I’m in over my head to begin with. For concealed carry. I’m not an operator and the chances of my needing my AR or 45+ rounds is remote.
In 2017 there were about 2.9M pistols made in the US in 9mm and lower. In .40 and above 600k. Most were probably polymer. Facts don’t have opinions. 1911 is fading fast into history. He likes 1911, he showed you his carry 1911. Why say he doesn’t like them. He thinks they’re not right for most. Source: www.atf.gov/file/130851/download
I've been carrying a kimber pro carry and an ED Brown Cobra carry ,both of which have considerably more than just a 1,000 rounds through them. Both in 45acp and with proper spring replacement at around 3.000 rounds or so each has been 100%reliable. It should be mentioned I also use these pistols for club level steel challenge competitions. People often as if the cobra carry is worth 3x the kimber price. That is for each person to decide for themselves. My kimber has never failed but that said I believe the cobra carry is definetly worth the price of entry.
Hey Caleb...great vid's! I bought a SA RO compact 9mm a few months ago. Installed a WC extended slide release and tactical thumb safety. I also replaced the factory trigger with a WC anodized black one. I also sent the barrel to H&M metal processing in Akron OH. and had coat it with black nitride. I just like the all black look. Also installed a shock buffer. Now that you know what's been done to it, here is the issue I'm having. Took it to the range today for the first time with 100 rounds of Aguila FMJ 124 gr. and 200 rounds of reloads. loaded the factory mags racked the slide and it wouldn't load into the chamber, it just hit the ramp and jammed. Same with the reloads. I also brought my G 32 with a full 9mm conversion and it ate all the ammo up. What are your thought as to what the problem could be?
You have made the classic mistake by trying to turn your stock 1911 into a race gun. The platform is designed to function best as a stock gun. Instead of mkdifying a mid price gun spend the money on a high end gun.
If you go to local cabelas,bass pro, etc.. I find the 45 ammo or target ammo is always gone off the shelves... foremost have to order it... I personally carry a colt mustang pocket lite .With 2 8rd mags.. it's small but very accurate and reliable...
I agree that you have a goo choice for 1911 carry in 9mm for you. If I am going to carry 9mm I will go with my H&K p7m8, extremely safe, reliable, accurate and concealable, maybe a little low in round count though that's its only downfall. Just carry extra mags.
Sig Sauer 1911 C3. . 45 reliable, accurate, fits my hand perfectly. Always on target when pointed (sights always aligned perfectly). Carried in a leather versacarry IWB holster, literally disappears.
I bought a Taurus pt1911 used for $500 and I'm actually surprised with it, 900 or so rounds so far with no malfunctions.. it's full sized though so I cant exactly carry it with my build but it's a fun range toy for sure
I know that grip width is always a concern when it comes to concealed carry pistols, but have you considered the possibility of a double stack 1911 in 9mm like those offered by Para Ordnance or Rock Island Armory?
Very very informative. I have been carrying a government springfield Armory in 9 mm, and it has done well by me. But I think a may pull out my still unfired Wilson Combat government 45 acp. I wanna test it out and go with it.
Thank you bud I don't think your wrong lol, and your info was helpful to me on my rock island 5.5 in 1911, 5.5 because of a muzzle breake. It will be harder to conceal i agree but my 45 is smooth as butter. Again thank you
That's funny your Sig doesn't feed Winchester White Box well b/c my Sig Emperor Scorpion eats its just fine. Secondly I notice you didn't mention Kimber and I love their Eclipse model. I am considering buying one. What are your thoughts on Kimbers?
After testing the 9mm Rock Island Armory 1911 would you change your opinion of expand upon it? Or would you stick to this decision now. (Not sure if you tested the ria before or after this video does not give me posted date for some reason)
Since 1979 I've carried just about every handgun you can name, as an LEO or civilian. I ALWAYS end up coming back to a 1911.
Try a CZ.
I would too. Its simplicity and reliability is great
I carry a PPQ, ive always liked 1911s though and I may get one in the next few months. Trying to decide between an AR15/10 or a 1911.
My Springfield(s) 1911`s are impeccably reliable, reasonably concealable, and exceptionally "shootable" ...yep, I carry a 1911 to the grocery store, and the gas station, and the mall, and on a Sunday drive.
I should be able to thumbs up this comment as many times as I want. 🍻
Do you actually know how to shoot? Can you recognize a real threat from a false one? I would doubt that very much.
@@davelawson8568 WOW...upon what do you based your comment ? How many gun fights on the streets of America have your been involved ? Law enforcement ?
I started/learning shooting strikers first...shot my first 1911, INSTANTLY made it my carry. 😅😅. I love it and it's easy to shoot accurately. 9 or .45. Piece of cake.
For carrying, I prefer a phased plasma rifle in the 40-watt range.
WRONG
*pfft 40-watt is fine if you are looking for something for your purse
The 40 is dead. You missed the James Yeager video. James is THE FINAL WORD in plasma. Just ask him.
I prefer the uzi 9mm
hahahahahahahahahaha
I watched that yesterday
I agree with almost everything you said except that i carry the lightweight commander in .45 with the 8 round Wilson Combat magazine. I have carried this weapon "on the job" for 30 plus years. Never had an issue. I shoot every weekend. I do not consider myself an expert but i am very comfortable with this weapon. I do love my lightweight commander.
I actually made it thru 3.5 minutes without wanting to say something.
I've been carrying a 1911 more than anything else in the 35+ years that I've been carrying a pistol. My current carry gun is a Colt 1911 Officer model Series 80 in SS with a Barsto barrel & bushing. At most, I might have paid in the $600-$700 range. After more than 10,000 rounds, I've had ONE failure and that was a weak magazine spring.
I agree that the 9mm is a perfectly fine round but there's nothing wrong with the 38 Super. Less recoil, good ballistics & very accurate in a steel pistol.
I like the 5" or even a full size with some kind of jacket but warm weather fits a 3.5" perfectly and I don't need to hit a steel plate at 35 yards (a 3" group at 25 yards with my Colt is fine) since most defensive shooting is going to be at less than 10 yards without even using sights.
The main things that I can agree on are....practice, invest in quality mags & ammo! Shoot as much as financially possible!
Why do you carry a series 80? You just like those 4 extra parts that don’t belong there so they can get gummed up and cause a failure?
Golden Banjo he just said he’s went through 10,000 rounds only one failure which wasn’t even the gun’s fault
I must admit that I am 76 years old and I mention this because my experience with hand guns was first with a S&W Revolver and it was my Duty Weapon for many years before I was able to Carry a G19 as my duty weapon. Having said this, back in the day, my first EDC Carry Gun was the Colt 1911 A1 all steel Gun! Yes, very heavy and I soon changed to the Colt Light Weight Officer Model for everyday carry. I just loved my single stack 1911's and at this time they were very popular Guns to carry! Things Change and I tried the Glock Platform and then I discovered I found them to be the perfect Gun for my EDC needs and the rest is History! My EDC is my G43 and I just purchased a G48 which has been a Great shooter!
I bought my Kimber ultra carry used, and I have had no issues with it yet. I have put 1000 rounds through it myself and no malfunctions.
I carried the Colt Officers for years. Shot a fellow Recon Marines Kimber Ultra Carry at the range about 10 years ago. Had to have it. I have been carrying one ever since. I hear all the time that they are not reliable. But, every single malfunction I have seen has been from a limp wrist. There are heavy springs in that short slide, and they need a tight wrist to push against to get full slide action.
Great advice. Thank you.Last year I bought my wife, a 1911 fan, a Springfield EMP 1911 .9mm. She just signed up for her CCW, and intends to carry her gun. What do you think? Thanks, from a new fan.
Thanks for sharing your opinions. I enjoy your perspective. I started carrying a 1911 thirty plus years ago. I carried the Colt Delta Elite 10MM, mostly open carry or in a shoulder holster. This is a great gun. I now carry the Springfield EMP4 9MM and the Springfield EMP3 9MM. They are both extremely reliable whether I shoot range loads or self defense rounds.
Kimber Pro Raptor 2. Carried as my "off duty" weapon for over 10 years. One of the best guns I've ever owned.
1911s rule for CCW!
Thanks Lisa for all the support of carrying an Kimber ultra carryII 45acp. I love it and will continue carrying it when I go to certain places. I also carry my M&P Shield on lite days. I am not by no means a weapon expert, but I have a good amount of guns and long rifles, ar,ak, and my newest 30/30 lever action. I have a private range that I shoot at ever weekend. I reload a lot of my own ammo but maybe shoot 700-900 rounds a week. I am also retired USAR, 24yrs. Maybe that's why I love firearms.
I’ve owned 1911’s for over 35 years, having transitioned from Colt and S&W revolvers. I’ve had inexpensive 1911’s and higher end. I’ve been carrying a Colt Defender since 1996, when I purchased it new. I couldn’t tell you how many rounds I’ve put through it. Shortly after I got it, the gun shop owner I bought it from asked me if I had any jam ups, I hadn’t. I said if I had a few minutes he would polish the feed ramp which he did. He said he had gotten a flyer about feeding troubles. To this day, knock on wood, it’s been trouble free. I sold my Kimber Custom Shop, a Springfield long slide, Dan Wesson, and ParaOrdinace P12 LDA, because they either jammed or had a something I didn’t like. I have a Colt Commander that’s also been good to me. But daily I will continue to rely on my Defender.
Carried a 1911 .45 acp concealed for years. Always felt safe and confident. To me, the simplest, most basic, least fancified pistol is the best. I favor the original GI model, perhaps with a throating for reliability. Now I carry the Springfield Armory Mil Spec, and that thing is spectacular. It has a few minor improvements- throating, beveled mag well, relieved ejection port, hi-viz sights, but those are not superfluous. That thing shoots, has never malfunctioned, and is extremely tight and precise. Very very accurate. Thanks.
I have carried a Kimber Ultra Carry II in 45acp 3.5" barrel for yrs. I have attended Front Sight Firearms Training Institute with it. I have had no issues or failures with said firearm. It is my constant companion (The Comforter) I also own a Springfield TRP, and 2 Colts, love them all. I will never leave home without my 45acp 1911.
I enjoyed your video. After about 45 years of screwing around with 1911s (the good, the bad, and the ugly) I agree with most of what you said. I particularly think you have set a reasonable reliability standard for testing (200 rounds training ammo, 50 rounds carry ammo) that anyone considering the 1911 for carry should be able to afford.
My LW Commander I use now is one of the new 2016 Colts, and I find it to be a fine pistol. The new dual recoil spring really works and when I shoot it side by side with my all-steel Commander it feels the same.
I got mine in .45 ACP because I'm an old fart who lived back in the day when the 9mm didn't work, so psychologically I just feel better with those big old fat slugs. I know it's probably silly, but that's just me. I also had a ton of Wilson magazines in .45 and none in 9mm, lol. But now that I'm getting old and turning into a bigger wuss with each passing day, my next 1911 will probably be a 9mm. I'm thinking of a Springfield Range Officer Champion to experiment with.
In short, I can't really disagree with anything you said, except that I've seen more than my share of problems with SIG 1911s, but that was right after they started making them, so that might be unfair. I'm going to have to look into Dan Wessons.
Thanks for a good video.
P.S. I still back up my 1911 with a J-frame revolver, which fortunately I shoot very well. That ability with a snub is no doubt the product of a misspent youth :)
Tom Crawford got a range officer elite (the full size one) in .45 acp awesome gun u will like the smaller champion.
Agree totally. I would be carrying a LW 9mm Commander if Colt had been making them three years ago...so I'm carrying a LW Commander in 38 Super. It's had about 2000 rounds through it and I don't recall any failures at all, but I don't keep written records like Tam does. Hits all three objectives easily for me and 124 gr HPs hit an honest 1340 fps. Handy for the odd coyote when bird hunting.
Great video. I have been recently testing the Kimber Micro 9mm. I needed a small pocket easy carry gun. I live in Arizona and pretty much all year long wear shorts and a t shirt. I have found the Micro 9 to be very accurate for a small gun and super reliable at this time. I have 300 rounds through it and no malfunctions. Time will tell how it goes, but so far so good. Thanks.
I always like your videos. They show that you have actually thought about what your are talking about. You present your arguments in a concise, cogent way (with added humor) and you make sense. That's not the most common trait in TH-cam gun videos. You are also confident enough to go against the prevailing winds on the caliber wars without getting bogged down in them. Nice work. It's nice to listen to a grown up talking about something he knows well. Keep it up.
Thanks!
fh5786 t
Gun Nuts Media how about doing a review on a Beretta Px4 Storm Full-Size in 9mm & I been carrying this firearm for the past 3 yrs already & love it on it by having 17+ 1 rounds & never had any malfunctions through all the yrs I've been carrying it but just wanted to let you know on what I carry & I carry it in the Alien Gear Cloak Tuck 3.0. Obtw that I almost forgot to mention is that could you also do a Citadel Full-Size 1911 Model as well & haven't had any problems, too. I had that firearm as long as the Px4 Storm
Seriously!? You take the time to comment rather than googling?
bfy.tw/7SYt
EXACTLY!
the 45 will always have more kinetic energy then the 9mm everyone compares the 9mm hollow point to a 45 ball. shoot the same bullet out of both and the 45 will cause more damage.
+Mark Hallett no it won't, but that's okay I understand that most people are really ignorant about handgun wounding mechanisms. If you'd like to educate yourself I can suggest some really great technical papers.
@@MrRevolver depends on the powder then because 45 should have more kinetic energy transferred but not at a smaller point i am assuming the 45 has more powder because of a bigger shell. I would love the technical papers
It has been proven time and time again that shot placement determines the outcome of shootings..
Caliber arguments are becoming silly and obsolete with the advancements in bullet design and ballistics; frankly it just narrows down to the quality of the ammunition used.
That being said, the old thought of 9mm being lesser then 45 was true FOR THE TIME when 9mm (as for most bullets) were not further developed, it was left upon which had more powder loaded in them so logically the 45acp held that advantage. But now thanks to science and engineering, the 9mm can hold it's own, yes the 45 is a bigger slug of a round but 9mm isn't a lightweight either.
Also consider human beings are pretty resilient, especially when hopped up on drugs or adrenaline, I've heard stories from guys taking shotgun blasts and still moving. Now they of course died but not without some fight still left in them.
Case and point, being over reliant and putting your gamble on the bullet is a trivial and somewhat dangerous game to play.
@@TheTAEclub What are the really great technical papers suggested?
I ordered a new Valkyrie 9mm commander from Dan Wesson this week. CZ has a nice program for first responders and military. Also ordered Wilson Combat mags. I hope you become a rep for Dan Wesson cause you sold me on it Caleb.
I like your choice of the lightweight commander in 9mm. What is your opinion of the new Springfield Armory EMP4 in 9 mm? Is it comparable to your choice?
Agree with pretty much everything here. I’ve been carrying a Springfield Range Officer Elite compact in 45 for a little while now and it’s great. 4in barrel, aluminum frame, ramped bull barrel, and an awesome trigger. Only thing I changed from the point of getting the gun out of the box was switching to some Wilson Combat mags.
Seems like every 1911 I’ve ever owned has only had issues while firing from the magazines that came with the gun, never had any feeding issues after swapping to the Wilsons.
I’ll never understand how 20+ manufactures manage to make magazines that have issues when there’s obviously a design that just works *shrug*
Great video buddy!! I own a Springfield emp4 in 9mm that is a dream to shoot. Great points made. Keep up the good work 👍
I love my emp4
Just picked one up lnib for $700! Feel like I got a steal!
I am seriously contemplating this as I live in California and I'm faced with a 10 round magazine capacity limit
Now in all of your videos I've never heard you once mention Remington, for being either good nor bad. I purchased my first gun 6 months ago and it was the Remington R1 1911(200th anniversary edition), yet I don't ever see anyone talking about Remington 1911's in their videos. I think I've put 1000 rounds into it so far and only problems I've had were when I first got it and the stock magazine were utter shit until I started using them. Since then I've gone like 900 rounds without failure. Great gun. I love your videos by the way. Going to go buy a good belt today and start carrying as soon as possible.
I carry an old llama 1911 .45 . Commander. I maintain the gun and it shoots flawlessly . It's had thousands of rounds shot through it and it still works great. I replace parts when they wear and it has that "old friend" feel.
My tisas 1911 comander is over 1000x rounds no issues. Wilson combat mags make the difference. 45acp in ballistics next to 9mm are Night and day 45.is the superior round
Only issue I see is that you are comparing a $1,600? CZ against $8-900 guns ( Colt, Springfield etc )as to which one is best and there is a huge difference in quality with that big a price jump. You are almost into custom gun prices with the CZ.
I currently carry a PPQ M2 SC 9mm, thinking about getting a 45 next. Ive always liked 1911s but comparing it to the PPQ chambered in 45. I'm really on the fence. Browsing around a few months back I saw a Dan Wesson that I liked but at twice the price (around $1300). The capacity difference is crazy
Love my lightweight Commander! Easy to shoot and accurate as all heck. I use a leather chest side old military style holster. The gun absolutely disappears.
Hi Calib, thanks for the great videos you share with us. I have a smith & wesson performance center commander size 1911 bobtail in 45acp, great carry gun and range gun. 1000 rounds with zero issues, thanks again for all your input, God bless you, al
"I wouldn't recommend a 1911 for conceal carry"
My 10mm 1911 A2 fits just fine under the coat with a low profile shoulder holster.
There are IWB holsters that can make a full size completely disappear. However, if you want the most versatile CCW 1911, I would go with a cbob and possibly a scandium or 7075 aluminum frame.
If your 1911 doesn't function properly it's because you bought a cheap one that needs an hour of polishing and/or a slight adjustment to the extractor.
These days they cost anywhere from 500 to 3000 depending on which one you want.
Guaranteed a properly tuned 1911 made entirely from 4140 steel is going to be more accurate, reliable, and will last longer than any polymer sidearm you get your hands on.
Sigh
To @ Kaiser : His reply to you is ' sigh ' ? What is his experience ? Ex airforce military police ? Glorified babysitter or tantamount to a security guard ? No real strenuous training like the Marines or Army . Taught only the basics, promoted grunt mentality to take orders and not to think by drill sgt/military, and no combat experience or medals reflecting same ? What has he done to take him beyond the basics the military has taught him ? I seriously doubt he has the experience or expertise to be worthy to shine Travis Tomasi 's shoes or other true experts and champions . People should stop allowing themselves to be manipulated into believing military and paramilitary service alone qualifies individuals as experts . A task impossible to accomplish if they ( viewers ) are weak minded or lack common sense . You ever notice that bullies ( a.k.a. cowards ) try to intimidate using methods such as loud talking you ( yelling ), talking over you, posturing, etc ? Navy Seals, and Green
Berets possess the 3 C 's ( cool, calm and collective ) . According to a reliable associate this guy is false bravado and exhibit traits associated with the opposite of people like Paul Harrell, etc . Go talk to some Navy Seals and examine the difference between this guy .
always loved my 45, was carrying them before glock was the have all to beat all. Still do, just my preference, commander or 5"
I bought a Commander before a full size 1911 to carry, and then I realized my 6'3" ass can comfortably carry a 5" ALL day long with no problems!
Excellent video. Thank you for posting it. I love the m1911a1 in as close to the GI issue as possible. Mine is a Springfield Armory GI, which is a replica of what we were issued in the Service, right down to the lanyard ring. To me, THAT'S a 1911. I even replaced the good-looking wooden stocks with plastic grips, to make it more historically accurate. And, I CAN carry it. It meets all the criteria you cited. Right now, I'm wearing it, appendix position, with my shirt tucked in, but not tucked into the holster, bloused over the grip (my usual carry method), which I find makes for a quicker draw, and the gun is invisible. I had bought a Smith and Wesson M&P 45 compact for carry, and while I can't really fault the gun, I just don't love it. It's kind of like marrying for money instead of for love. The M&P Shield 9mm is much better, in my opinion. But what I REALLY love for carry IS my J Frame, Smith and Wesson 442 airweight snubnose revolver. There's something about the snubbie and the 1911 that is almost magical. Mystical? I don't really know how to describe it.
The snubnose IS harder to shoot accurately, but that gives me an excuse to go to the range. Two speed strips in my pocket, plus 5 in the cylinder, and I'm carrying 15 rounds more than most people are carrying.
Caleb, thank you so much for making this video. Loved watching you compete on “Top Shot” back in the day too btw. What do you think about the Kimber brand?
I have had three Kimber 1911s. One of them was amazing, search for Kimber Team Match II on my channel. One of them was okay, and one of them was pretty awful.
I think with Kimber if you get a good one it will be awesome, but if you get a bad one it's going to be really bad.
My personal favourite carry pistol was the lightweight commander in 45acp, with Wilson 8 round magazines. In competitive shooting however I scored much better with a full size steel framed Government model, the extra weight improved recovery time from recoil, and the longer sight radius was certainly an advantage on targets at longer distances. Also I had more faith in the 45acp cartridge than 9mm loads at that time, for both effectiveness and reliability. I find your current reasoning well thought out, and correct in conclusion. Because of improvements in today's 9mm loads, the better choices of pistols available in that calibre, and the extra round capacity. When carrying every day the saving in weight of the lightweight commander over the Government model is appreciably more comforting.
I love Wilson Combat magazines. I have a few 8 rounders.
Nice gun, but I don't see it replacing my Kahr TP9, which is lighter weight, just as thin, has a smooth and high stress friendly, double action trigger; and has no safeties to deal with in a defensive encounter.
Pretty well reasoned presentation even if it took a while to get to your "aha" moment. I'm glad I stuck around for that moment because it turns out I'm in total agreement. I have J frames and a Glock 43 and a Walther 9 and a little Kimber .380 but the gun I absolutely shoot the best is my 9mm Ruger 1911 commander-size that was introduced just this year. Alloy frame, stainless slide, Series 70 so no silly firing pin block to mess with the trigger pull. It is no more difficult to conceal than the Glock or the Walther, and when I draw it and put it into my hand I know I can hit whatever I need to hit. 11 rounds with another 10 in my spare mag (thanks Chip McCormick) should be enough to get it done. Look, the FBI went down from .40 to 9mm, so with the right ammo I definitely know I'm as good to go as I can be. Plus the 1911 is just too cool.
My father left me lots of firearms when he passed in 1998! Is my Colt 1911 Ambassador .45 acp a good idea for a concealed weapon? Shoots awesome, never hangs up, but it’s a little heavy! What holster and type would u recommend!(new to concealed carry) hunted and shot firearms my whole life! Figured it’s time to legally carry! God Bless !🇺🇸❤️🙏
Taurus PT 1911 is a great gun for around $500. So it's affordable and reliable. I have one and carry it with no issues.
04Interc3ptorP71 its sad that we Brazilians have to pay almost 2.000 dollars on it
Really? It is Brazilian made. Fine quality weapon. You guys know how to build them.
Those guns sold to us is a piece of shit, not to mention they're overpriced. Taurus only sells good guns internationally.
I own the Springfield Range Officer Compact in 45ACP. You made very good points in the video and I have to agree with them. However, I like this little Springfield even though it goes against the grain of some of your comments in that it is not a traditional 1911 design. So far it has been reliable with about 200 rounds of mostly ball and some hollow points so I am happy with it regarding reliability. I have smaller hands so the office size grip presents me with no problems in getting and maintaining a good two hand grip plus it makes the firearm easier to conceal. I have been interested in your latest test with the 357 sig 1911 because I love the cartridge matched up the 1911 style pistol. Thank you for the videos as they are always enjoyable and educational.
I've been carrying my sig, fastback, commander,45acp, for years. never had a problem. I run golden sabers in a Tripp cobra mag,and sx big dot sights. 1911s are a little more hi maintenance and complex,than my other carry weapons though.
I have a Colt Combat Commander 45ACP. My main EDC. Very easy to conceal with my Milt Sparks Summer Special IWB leather holster. Now I will be looking for a light weight Commander or Wiley Clapp Commander in 9mm. Never knew the Commander was originally designed for 9mm. Thought it was 38 Super. But 9mm makes sense for a light weight Commander. Thanks for sharing.
NICE job!!! I love 1911 for CC...... Just a great feel, and accurate. I have the Ruger LW Commander and the Springfield LW RO..... both in 9mm..... and HST ammo.
I bought a para ordnance tac-4 20 years ago. I carried it every day for at least 10 years. I still prefer that to any other gun even now. That’s a .45 ACP with a double stack magazine. It’s a 4 1/4 inch barrel and a 13 round magazine. I know para doesn’t make that gun anymore but they do make s similar version the p-13 LDA. I really do love that gun. Just bought a new alien gear cloak tuck holster. The new holster makes it even better.
I got lucky bought a $450 rock island 1911 and the only issue I’ve had is for the fact that if you use a low end 7 round magazine the slide doesn’t lock back when out of ammo
Great video! You forgot Kimber, in my opinion, another good reasonably priced option. I carry a Nighthawk Custom 5 inch GRP in .45 ACP. I just prefer that caliber, but, have owned 9mm in the past.
Nothing at all wrong with Dan Wesson or Sig Sauer but also nothing wrong with a Ruger SR 1911 or Springfield Armory A1 Mil Spec or the Ronin!! Great video very informative!!!
During my advanced CCW course, I felt sorry for the lady who brought a snubnose .38 to shoot. She had a terrible time getting one on the target which just verified what you said. It also really wore her out because of the recoil. I told her and her husband that they were really tough to get good at and they had to agree.
Beretta 92FS is in the equation for carry although it is a little on the big side for CC. It is light enough and can be concealed in cooler climates.
A 9mm may expand but a 45ACP will never shrink.... just kidding great video you got me thinking ... well done
Very interesting! Now you've gone and made me want to get a Lightweight Commander. I've been carrying a double-stack 9 mm for some time and have been looking for something slimmer, yet with decent bang for the buck. And I agree that 9 mm is just fine for firepower.
I carry a Springer RO Elite 9mm commander. Over 1k rounds, two malfunctions, both not issues from the gun. Confident to protect life with it, its a gem to shoot. Know the platform, learn it well and the 1911 is a fine gun for carry protection, once you get the relaibily out of the way, the ergonomics, and quality of the trigger makes it a even more formidable weapon for daily carry.
I would argue you’re gonna need more than 1000 rounds worth of training to be proficient. I will look at it as an ongoing endeavor that deserves consistent maintenance.
I carry a colt combat commander. 70 series 45 apc corbon hp jacked I put it in the galco sob holster it shoots every time l won't ever get rid of it. OK thanks for the help good vedeo. Keith
Nice video, what is the brand of holster you used in the video? I want one for my Kimber Super Carry Ultra and my Springfield Armory Loaded.
Terminal ballistics and wound cavities in gel blocks may not look very different between different handgun cartridges however the “stopping power” conundrum does have some truth to it. The foot pounds of energy generated with good carry ammo that doesn’t over penetrate in .45 caliber is far more impactful then 9mm. When looking at the numbers you will see that .45 produces nearly three times the foot pounds of energy then a 9mm. You simply can not say 9mm and .45 are equal.
All you vids are pretty good but this one is one of your best. Really good "cut and dry" information. I really learned a lot and feel a little more comfortable shopping for my first 1911. I am familiar with your work on other channels as well as your own and know you have extensive experience with this platform. thanks again, keep the vids coming. How the f@#k do you only have 9000+ followers!?
Probably don't show enough boobies. ;-)
Very nice video! Like you, I love a LWT Commander 1911 for EDC and carry AIWB. What holster did you use in this video?
I have never agreed with anyone so much ever. I carry the new 2016 Colt lightweight commander in 9mm. I worked plain clothes law enforcement my last 14 years and bumped into too many door jams with my double stack guns and wanted the lightweight commander. Ruger has just released their version of the SR1911 with commander size in 9mm.
How do you feel about the Ruger sr1911, I've herd good things but I'd like to see one really put to the test. They still are the "new kid on the block" in a way.
Ruger SR1911 Lightweight Commander. It's large, but it's very slim and light. Lot of gunsmith type features from the factory. Rosewood grips, Titanium feed ramp. Titanium firing pin. Skeletonized trigger. Adjustable trigger (I leave it at the factory setting). Put well over 2,000 rounds through it in the last 2 years I've owed it. ZERO malfunctions. Cost me $600 plus tax at a gun shop.
I like your videos.Most gun nuts disagree with your opinion.But i agree with 100%.I carry S.A. Champion Operator LW 45acp.But now thinking about S.A. EMP 9mm in 3" or 4" what do you think?Thanks,Rob----Be well stay safe!
Springfield milspec. 600-700 bucks. Loaded with 200 gr Gold Dot.
I have trekked a lot of miles with a Springer Mil-Spec loaded with various 230gr JHPs. Great pistol.
@@VMEMotor5 I carry a Springfield Armory A1 Mil Spec 1911 .45 loaded with Federal HST 230 grain JHP!! I’m very comfortable in my ability to stop any threat that comes my way!!!
Because of your videos, I scored a brand new Valkyrie for $1299...fml.
That's right I just got the same gun today 999.$ and it's dream to shoot. I love it. Thanks for the video
What is your opinion on the colt 1911 combat commander, in blued steel, chambered in 38 super? Biggest reason I ask is there is already one in the family. Why pay for something if you can get it for free, as long as it is good right?
Take it use it & buy a 45.
Great video brother and very informational. What IWB holster were you using during this video? It looks like kydex, if so please provide information.
Genesis Concealment Custom Carry Concepts Shaggy
Couldn't agree with you more. I see no problem at all with the 9mm , it has a light felt recoil and it is a lot easier to get off a follow up shot if needed. As a former military man, I have to say the Commander size is really an ideal size for carry if you insist on a 1911. I agree that the manufacturers you named are very reputable and a good selection , but there re several others that will fit into the list as well.
I just picked up my first 1911. It’s a Springfield RO elite operator in 10mm. Not sure about making my CCW yet since I’ve only got 100 rounds through it so far but it’s a blast to shoot. It’s doesn’t particularly care for cheap ammo though.
NERVER had any issues with my NIGHTMARE 45 including white box good video and reviews
You are wrong about terminal ballistics the 45 has the edge over the 9MM as for the LW commander being the best carry gun in 1911 I completely agree there keep up the good work
Thanks so much for the video. Any thoughts on the Browning Right 380? Love the 1911 frame just not sure about the caliber. I have owned 45's but none that I can conceal carry. Thank you.
Actually I think your choice is good but I would recommend the Dan Wesson ECO in 9mm over the light weight commander. It shoots as well and is even more concealable.
What is your opinion on the 38 Super? I have a Colt Government model 1911 chambered in 38 Super and a RIA chambered in 38 Super. I love the 38 Super! Great channel by the way. Thanks for the great vids and information.
I am leaning towards the 1911 for carry. I like what I see in the RIA 4 inch 45. Cheap and reliable.
Sportsman's Warehouse has the RIA 1911 9mm in sale for $349. Great gun for the price!
Commander size 1911's in 9mm
I can't say enough about them I own 3, Colts new lightweight, Ruger SR 1911 and a old Para Ordnance LTC
you are absolutely right on with D Wesson and other brands you spoke of they all make good candidates for CC in 1911 type pistols
A thing I’d like people to say about 1911s though is that they are just mechanical pieces. They can be tuned very easily with simple tools. Yes if you’ve got the money get a pro to do it if there is an issue. But you can also do it yourself. It’s not hard. People do it all the time. It is just care, time, and making sure you understand what you are doing. A rock island 1911 can become an excellent weapon with some polishing and a complete spring kit from Wilson combat. That’s a 550 dollar total give or take some.
You can buy any part for a 1911 in any material oversized so that you can file and polish it down to the custom fit that you get with a les Baer or whatever. If something is messed up with the frame rails or slide rails or feed ramp in a negative manner as in not enough material (so you can’t just smooth it into reliability) then send it the heck back to the maker.
And guess what you’re doing the whole time: learning, training, and having fun with YOUR gun that you defend your life and the life of others with.
I’ve carried my 70 Series Commander for 25 years. It was gone through originally by an old friend/armorer stationed at Camp Pendleton. Since then I’ve learned enough to maintain it. In 25 years I have a $1500 into it in that time: Novak sights, lightly smoothed edges, Bar-Stow barrel and Cerakote in matte dark grey.
As to ballistics you are incorrect. I was privy to the ballistics test SOCOM did in the early 90s that lead to the development of the USP .45. Get the knock down power debate out of the discussion. If that’s your argument you are 100% correct. Stopping power is actually based on the ability to rapidly cause shock inducing trauma. Shock is what stops an assailant, not simple impact. Even on HP vs HP .45 vs 9mm always cause very different wounds. 9mm HP are alway deeper and narrower. .45 HP aren’t as deep but are wider, affecting more organs. The physics of the shock wave are the reason. Add to that the ability of a quality 230 gr HP to punch through walls and similar barriers and still be more affective, it’s the hands down choice to me. Where it gets muddy is the calibers in between. I prefer to stay out of THAT mud and use the tried and true.
I like a single stack so as long as your belt and holster are up to the job any 1911 that conceals well is good enough to me. Weight isn't that big of an issue depending on what your current activity is. I was doing electrical work with a glock19 IWB and a tool pouch over it, no problems.
Wow... great video - very informative - I too love the 1911 foundation and have a couple of nice Browning 1911-380's - enjoy them both - great shootability - now am in the market to pick up another 1911 in 9mm. Your information about the commander was great - thank You !!!!
Thinking about a Ruger SR1911. The newer model with the titanium feed ramp. What I want out of a handgun is a good look, comfortable grip, the possibility based on general prestige to be an inheritance piece, and the ability to both be conceal carried and used for woods defense from animals. I also don't want it to be TOO awfully expensive to shoot, as I have that problem with my current only gun right now, a 12ga Mossberg 500. ((And that's just ammo since the range makes you shoot buck or slugs, and that shits $25 a box for the cheap stuff. The defense ammo I bought was $19 for a box of 10. Also, since range fees are costly, I don't get to shoot often, but I digress.))
How about rock island armory compact size 1911 do you recommend?
The best 1911 for CC is a Pro Series Sub-Compact Smith & Wesson in a 45 cal. Small enough at 3" that you don't mind wearing it. Perfect, If six shots are enough (It is in rural MO). If the SHTF, I will upsize for additional range and rounds.
I think it's interesting that Caleb didn't mention Kimber once. Not surprising but interesting...
Kimbers became lipstick on a pig so no surprise there, the carry 1911's they make are shitty malfunction jammomatics.
opening statement "99% of the public should not carry a 1911" Wow, kinda hard to believe. Everybody I know including people I come across at chance with people they know all have 1911s and carry them. I'd have to say 95% of the people I meet if at a gun range or a car show have and carry a 1911. Seems that comment is a little off since you just don't seem to like a 1911. Hell man I don't like Mustangs so you're not going to catch me making a video on the best one to drive. Now do I have a Glock??,,,Yes Glock 19. I also carry Berettas, S&W 686 Plus 3"barrel and one of 5 different 1911 choices. Very seldom carry the Glock and almost always carry a 1911. I have them in 9mm and 45 but I find that most of the Mellinnials today don't carry a 1911 because they are just afraid of it. To be honest it's one of the safest guns to carry. Like anything else you have to train with it and the comfort level just appears. It is the most pointable and easiest platform to shoot. I agree the Plastic Generation has taken over but when it comes down to the bones of it I'm gonna carry good ole metal on my hip and you're gonna get hit with a round the size of my thumb!!!! Have a nice Day
John Delvisco agree 100%. The only argument for a polymer gun is weight and perhaps cost. Weight makes no difference to a guy built like me but may on a smaller person maybe? Of capacity is really something you want there are very good double stack 1911s. I put 300 rds through a Remington R1 double last month and own an original Para conversion.
But realistically I’m not John Wick and I’ve been out of combat and protection duty for 20 years. If 8+1 and two spares isn’t enough for me I’m in over my head to begin with. For concealed carry. I’m not an operator and the chances of my needing my AR or 45+ rounds is remote.
In 2017 there were about 2.9M pistols made in the US in 9mm and lower. In .40 and above 600k. Most were probably polymer. Facts don’t have opinions. 1911 is fading fast into history. He likes 1911, he showed you his carry 1911. Why say he doesn’t like them. He thinks they’re not right for most. Source: www.atf.gov/file/130851/download
so back to 9mm in the end, sigh.....
I thought the same thing, sigh........
Hi Calib, I have a Dan Wesson 45acp commander that is super reliable and acurate thaks for the great advice
I've been carrying a kimber pro carry and an ED Brown Cobra carry ,both of which have considerably more than just a 1,000 rounds through them. Both in 45acp and with proper spring replacement at around 3.000 rounds or so each has been 100%reliable. It should be mentioned I also use these pistols for club level steel challenge competitions. People often as if the cobra carry is worth 3x the kimber price. That is for each person to decide for themselves. My kimber has never failed but that said I believe the cobra carry is definetly worth the price of entry.
Hey Caleb...great vid's! I bought a SA RO compact 9mm a few months ago. Installed a WC extended slide release and tactical thumb safety. I also replaced the factory trigger with a WC anodized black one. I also sent the barrel to H&M metal processing in Akron OH. and had coat it with black nitride. I just like the all black look. Also installed a shock buffer. Now that you know what's been done to it, here is the issue I'm having. Took it to the range today for the first time with 100 rounds of Aguila FMJ 124 gr. and 200 rounds of reloads. loaded the factory mags racked the slide and it wouldn't load into the chamber, it just hit the ramp and jammed. Same with the reloads. I also brought my G 32 with a full 9mm conversion and it ate all the ammo up. What are your thought as to what the problem could be?
You have made the classic mistake by trying to turn your stock 1911 into a race gun. The platform is designed to function best as a stock gun. Instead of mkdifying a mid price gun spend the money on a high end gun.
If you go to local cabelas,bass pro, etc.. I find the 45 ammo or target ammo is always gone off the shelves... foremost have to order it... I personally carry a colt mustang pocket lite .With 2 8rd mags.. it's small but very accurate and reliable...
I agree that you have a goo choice for 1911 carry in 9mm for you. If I am going to carry 9mm I will go with my H&K p7m8, extremely safe, reliable, accurate and concealable, maybe a little low in round count though that's its only downfall. Just carry extra mags.
I have a philpino made 1911 within the 500 dollar range.Ctidel is the name I think RIA makes them.5" full size no problems
Philippine made 1911s are reliable like the Metroarms , Rock Island , Shooters Arms MFG.
Sig Sauer 1911 C3. . 45 reliable, accurate, fits my hand perfectly. Always on target when pointed (sights always aligned perfectly). Carried in a leather versacarry IWB holster, literally disappears.
I bought a Taurus pt1911 used for $500 and I'm actually surprised with it, 900 or so rounds so far with no malfunctions.. it's full sized though so I cant exactly carry it with my build but it's a fun range toy for sure
I know that grip width is always a concern when it comes to concealed carry pistols, but have you considered the possibility of a double stack 1911 in 9mm like those offered by Para Ordnance or Rock Island Armory?
Very very informative. I have been carrying a government springfield Armory in 9 mm, and it has done well by me. But I think a may pull out my still unfired Wilson Combat government 45 acp. I wanna test it out and go with it.
Thank you bud I don't think your wrong lol, and your info was helpful to me on my rock island 5.5 in 1911, 5.5 because of a muzzle breake. It will be harder to conceal i agree but my 45 is smooth as butter. Again thank you
That's funny your Sig doesn't feed Winchester White Box well b/c my Sig Emperor Scorpion eats its just fine. Secondly I notice you didn't mention Kimber and I love their Eclipse model. I am considering buying one. What are your thoughts on Kimbers?
After testing the 9mm Rock Island Armory 1911 would you change your opinion of expand upon it? Or would you stick to this decision now. (Not sure if you tested the ria before or after this video does not give me posted date for some reason)