crazy you made my decision better i have been looking for a comparison between these three. Thanks a lot and here is a perfect thumbs up from both hands 👍👍
Great review! I have the Stanmore in my living room and the Tufton and Stockwell for all other purposes. I absolutely love the powerful sound of Marshall speakers!
I have the Kilburn 2 and it's been a super great speaker in my opinion. Audio clarity is really good but the bass is more of a thumpy quality than a boomy one so for people who love EDM music, it wouldn't sound as satisfying on this speaker compared to something like a JBL
I got middleton and I love it. The mid volume gave me nice bass already plus it's really a modern design without the knob. But I'm planning to get the killburn 2 since it's smaller than tufton and for me it's very handy and portable 😉
I've had the Middleton for around 1.5 years now and fuckin love it. I'm pissed though because now I wanna get all these speakers from marshall. Middleton sooo good
Leaning towards the Kilburn 2 since it's still portable and under $200. I like my speakers with a good amount of bass to it w/ thump since I enjoy listening to 90's rap and some Gareth Emery. Haven't checked out other brands like JBL, Bose, or any other brands but thank you for helping me make my decision.
I have the old tufton with the red velvet strap and it still BANGS. Nothing beats the sound of that speaker. I have a $450 song party speaker about 7 times the size and it doesn’t do as good at all. I’ve had it for years and it’s still in perfect condition and works amazing. You just can’t connect it to the Marshall app. I have have the emberton and Willen and they are phenomenal for how small they are
Thanks, I will get the Kilburn 2 after seeing this vid, for size. The Tufton is a bit too big for what I need at the moment and I won't feel like I have a small speaker with the Kilburn on my toolbox. It sounds good at Best Buy but the demo is way too low and no volume controls so I am rolling the dice...
Love my tufton but there is this one thing that drives me crazy ... It irregularly plays some kind of sound effect for which it stops the music. It's the dumbest feature I have experienced in such a product and I have not yet found a way to disable it. I have not even found out what it indicates. Best guess is battery state, like for every battery-bar it loses during use, it plays the sound. Especially when used for a party this "feature" makes the speaker near to unusable.
Yes, I agree 100%. But for my purpose like travelling with plane and train the Middleton is perfect. And I bought it for 202,00 €. For this price its absolutely okay.
Haha, Marshall never hints very far in the future for new models. I think their Middleton is the new guy on the block. I don't predict anything soon but I could be wrong.
Hi Danny, thanks for the video! In your review of all marshall speakers from a year ago you said you would not recommend the Kilburn as it sounds boxy - are you recommending it now more because of the price or do you think its really not that bad?
I think the first one i checked out sounded kind of boxy. I think for 200 it's a good value compared to the Middleton. My perception kind of changed as I listened to it more and more so now I recommend it.
@steroberry Embertons etc current Marshall lineup have stereo- L & R channel sound - Left channel front/Right channel back. When using stack mode I turn one Emberton 2 around providing Right channel sound = directional stereo sound. My side by side speaker separation is around 1 foot , outstanding results full stereo sound front & back direction , I use such setup @ small outdoor get togethers. If setup is used against back stop such as interior wall. I find 6-8 inch from wall to be sweet spot in my environment. Room filling stereo sound base increase can be felt. Single Emberton 2 gets same result , adding 2nd In stack mode = amazing. Anyway, I found Middelton to be greatly lacking in comparison. Amazon black friday deals was my bt speaker upgrade time , did a lot of buying & returning many brands before finally finding great sound. Emberton 2 were selling for 119.00 , I jumped on it. Yes pricey but worth it to me. Outstanding sound , Stackmode speaker flexibility , Bluetooth 5.1 / 30 hour battery life & built strong looks 😎
Surely the tufton or kilburn gets a much needed update! Need better water resistance, usb c charging and Bluetooth 5.3. been looking for a new portable speaker and I'm torn between kilburn 2, acton or jbl a 300. Thinking I'm just going to wait and hope for an update on these speakers. I swear by my marshall motif 2s and makes me itch for a marshall speaker
Hi Danny, thank you for the video. I wanna ask about the lack of midrange in Tufton. Many comments I read about this issue. Do you think that is true? what's your impression about the midrange or vocal in Tufton? In my region right now, the price of tufton and kilburn 2 is about the same. Thankyou
Nice review! Do you think that when bass on the Middletown is turned down to the minimum - it will be suitable for listening to podcasts / human voice only? Or the voice will still sound bassy?
Watts only describe the power consumption of a speaker... the wider and bigger the chassis (speaker membran) is the less power consumption does it need for playing loud. Because loudness needs air and space! To comprehend this problem you can build a speaker with either more chassis or the single chassis is able to move itself stronger which ends in higher power consumption... thats why bigger speaker needs less power than smaller ones for the same loudness :)
What about the stockwell 2? How does it compare to the middleton or killburn 2? Im in the market and im finding good deals on the stockwell and i really like the for factor
Sonos one is ok.. portable home speaker by bose has several issues if you have a Sonos Soundbar it has amazing wifi sound Somehow I prefer bluetooth speakers as the delay in transferring audio and sync is a little more reliable
Hey Danny, do you have any interest at all in "party speakers"? (i.e. JBL Partybox or Klipsch XL/XXL). Would be quite curious to see how they stack up against Marshall or the JBL Authentics line.
I hate the look of party speakers so I've stayed away. I'm sure they are good but they are party speakers because they are made to sound good and have features catered to parties.
Hi Danny! I love your videos, Bass Wise and Listening to Hi Res/Lossless Music which speaker would you recommend Woburn 3 or JBL Authentic 500 or any other brand in the same size?
I havent listened to either in a totally lossless format. They are great speakers the both of them, so I'd say go with the one that has the features and looks you like more.
I have a stockwell 2 and a tufton cause... well... you cant really put the tufton in your pocket or backpack lmao. It is portable alright. If you want to do a workout at the same time. 5-6kg's of deadweight for that puppy
I'm really disappointed with my kilburn 2 - it doesn't feel like it has the same sound profile as the stanmore or larger speakers. Bass is too heavy and the highs just ain't good. Gonna be returning it
I got the middleton and i love it. But my confused about killburn at tufton,why it seems that the killburn sounds greater than tufton. And i think you have a hearing impairment when you said the killburn is still quiete for you. Dude clean your ears regularly. Cotton buds are cheaper in any dollar tree store 🤣🤣🤣
crazy you made my decision better i have been looking for a comparison between these three. Thanks a lot and here is a perfect thumbs up from both hands 👍👍
👍Nice review. Wasn't expecting such a dramatic difference, but the Tufton is the clear winner here.
I have been using a Kilburn 1 since 2018. It's been a great portable speaker. My go to for tailgating and camp.
I have Tufton... 🔥 Great speaker I switched from Sony to Marshal Huge difference
Great review! I have the Stanmore in my living room and the Tufton and Stockwell for all other purposes. I absolutely love the powerful sound of Marshall speakers!
How do like the Tufton over the Stockwell, in terms of vocals, and midrange.
I have the Kilburn 2 and it's been a super great speaker in my opinion. Audio clarity is really good but the bass is more of a thumpy quality than a boomy one so for people who love EDM music, it wouldn't sound as satisfying on this speaker compared to something like a JBL
Perfect, thanks for the tip. I have a Stockwell 2. It serves me well for the size of it in my room but looking forward to one of these.
How about for soul or jazz music its better than the JBL?
@@TheJojoso in my opinion Kilburn wins for this one
JBL sounds muddy for this genre of music so Marshall’s clarity really wins
Agree with you
Thanks for your great video information
Another good comparison video and summary at the end. 👍🏻
I got middleton and I love it. The mid volume gave me nice bass already plus it's really a modern design without the knob. But I'm planning to get the killburn 2 since it's smaller than tufton and for me it's very handy and portable 😉
I've had the Middleton for around 1.5 years now and fuckin love it. I'm pissed though because now I wanna get all these speakers from marshall. Middleton sooo good
Thank you for this Review. Really helped me make the choice. Went for Kilburn 2 as it’s portable than tufton. Sounds great and serves the purpose 👍
Leaning towards the Kilburn 2 since it's still portable and under $200. I like my speakers with a good amount of bass to it w/ thump since I enjoy listening to 90's rap and some Gareth Emery. Haven't checked out other brands like JBL, Bose, or any other brands but thank you for helping me make my decision.
what is your choice?
I have the old tufton with the red velvet strap and it still BANGS. Nothing beats the sound of that speaker. I have a $450 song party speaker about 7 times the size and it doesn’t do as good at all. I’ve had it for years and it’s still in perfect condition and works amazing. You just can’t connect it to the Marshall app. I have have the emberton and Willen and they are phenomenal for how small they are
Thanks, I will get the Kilburn 2 after seeing this vid, for size. The Tufton is a bit too big for what I need at the moment and I won't feel like I have a small speaker with the Kilburn on my toolbox. It sounds good at Best Buy but the demo is way too low and no volume controls so I am rolling the dice...
Love my tufton but there is this one thing that drives me crazy ...
It irregularly plays some kind of sound effect for which it stops the music. It's the dumbest feature I have experienced in such a product and I have not yet found a way to disable it.
I have not even found out what it indicates. Best guess is battery state, like for every battery-bar it loses during use, it plays the sound.
Especially when used for a party this "feature" makes the speaker near to unusable.
Just ordered a tufton at 229 from Marshall’s online directly. Seems a good buy at that price
Is kilburn 2 open box for 160$ in 2024 worth it?(it’s been 5 years from initial launch ) Or do you recommend going with midleton open box for 200$
Kilburn 2 будет лучше, басс на всей громкости без перегрузки. Вообще это две разные системы звука из-за этого разный басс
Middleton играет гораздо лучше
Thanks for your suggestions
Yes, I agree 100%. But for my purpose like travelling with plane and train the Middleton is perfect. And I bought it for 202,00 €. For this price its absolutely okay.
"daba daba daba daba" the words of a true chad
Btw enjoyed ur videos everytime..
I am confused between marshall acton 3 and harman's aura studio 3. Please help brother. Your videos helped me a lot earlier also.
The Kilburn 2 has been out a long time now and I see it go on sale often. Does this mean newer models are on the way?
Haha, Marshall never hints very far in the future for new models. I think their Middleton is the new guy on the block. I don't predict anything soon but I could be wrong.
Think the Kilburn would work well with Rode Mics/Transmitter for small meetings of 20-50 ppl in an indoor a 2,000 square foot area?
I don't think it's well suited for that since it's not built to be a PA system. I think it'd be a little too quiet possibly as well for 50 ppl.
Hi Danny, thanks for the video! In your review of all marshall speakers from a year ago you said you would not recommend the Kilburn as it sounds boxy - are you recommending it now more because of the price or do you think its really not that bad?
I think the first one i checked out sounded kind of boxy. I think for 200 it's a good value compared to the Middleton. My perception kind of changed as I listened to it more and more so now I recommend it.
Whats up with the gold vs. the white emblem. Straps are different. Are there other differences?
👍🏻
Which one is better among Kilburn and Middleton
Can someone help me know if there are Chinese copies of this speaker or how would I know if it is original or not?
Hi! I'm planning to gift my bf either stockwell 2 or killburn 2. Which would be a better choice?
But whats about directivity? Im thinking of purchase the acton 3 or tufton. Im not sitting in front of the speaker. So wich is best for directivity?
Emberton 2 & Killburn are way to go.
Stack mode of two Embertons provides much better sound @ higher volume then Middelton.
But mono
@steroberry
Embertons etc current Marshall lineup have stereo- L & R channel sound - Left channel front/Right channel back.
When using stack mode I turn one Emberton 2 around providing Right channel sound = directional stereo sound.
My side by side speaker separation is around 1 foot , outstanding results full stereo sound front & back direction , I use such setup @ small outdoor get togethers.
If setup is used against back stop such as interior wall.
I find 6-8 inch from wall to be sweet spot in my environment.
Room filling stereo sound base increase can be felt.
Single Emberton 2 gets same result , adding 2nd In stack mode = amazing.
Anyway, I found Middelton to be greatly lacking in comparison.
Amazon black friday deals was my bt speaker upgrade time , did a lot of buying & returning many brands before finally finding great sound.
Emberton 2 were selling for 119.00 , I jumped on it.
Yes pricey but worth it to me.
Outstanding sound , Stackmode speaker flexibility ,
Bluetooth 5.1 / 30 hour battery life & built strong looks 😎
@@pjc4425 would you recommend a middleton if I get it under $200?
I did the same and it’s a awesome sound 360 degrees.
Surely the tufton or kilburn gets a much needed update! Need better water resistance, usb c charging and Bluetooth 5.3. been looking for a new portable speaker and I'm torn between kilburn 2, acton or jbl a 300. Thinking I'm just going to wait and hope for an update on these speakers. I swear by my marshall motif 2s and makes me itch for a marshall speaker
Hi Danny, thank you for the video. I wanna ask about the lack of midrange in Tufton. Many comments I read about this issue. Do you think that is true? what's your impression about the midrange or vocal in Tufton? In my region right now, the price of tufton and kilburn 2 is about the same. Thankyou
Nice review! Do you think that when bass on the Middletown is turned down to the minimum - it will be suitable for listening to podcasts / human voice only? Or the voice will still sound bassy?
Does somehow the Middleton has more subbass?
Marshall represented the sounds of the seventies, so you really should be testing them with seventies music!
Tufton is hands down a bare bones beast.
It has no tech. Pure sound physics that no form of artificial software tuning can deliver
Was looking at both on marhsalls website, how come the middleton has more Watts yet isnt as loud or good sound quality wize as the kilburn?
Watts only describe the power consumption of a speaker... the wider and bigger the chassis (speaker membran) is the less power consumption does it need for playing loud. Because loudness needs air and space! To comprehend this problem you can build a speaker with either more chassis or the single chassis is able to move itself stronger which ends in higher power consumption... thats why bigger speaker needs less power than smaller ones for the same loudness :)
What about the stockwell 2? How does it compare to the middleton or killburn 2? Im in the market and im finding good deals on the stockwell and i really like the for factor
the Stockwell is WHISPER quiet compared to these guys, its on the emberton level of loudness.
Hi Danny, any recommendations for portable speakers with built in wifi...
Sonos one is ok..
portable home speaker by bose has several issues
if you have a Sonos Soundbar it has amazing wifi sound
Somehow I prefer bluetooth speakers as the delay in transferring audio and sync is a little more reliable
fhey should do let it connect all! pair all marshall speakers !
Can u make a video of woburn 2 vs3 please
th-cam.com/video/ypwOXcoMqdo/w-d-xo.htmlsi=ImVo3kul4nvPNaFQ&t=427 there is a sound comparison for you :)
👍🏼I just ordered the kilborn 2 tonight 😂
Have you determined that there’s any difference between the one with the white emblem and red strap versus the gold emblem and camo strap?
@ 🤷🏻♂️
Thanks go sharing 😊
Hey danny can you make Tufton vs woburn 3 video?
Good video, which one has the best bass?
Please do comparison with bogasing M5
How do you think they compare to Beolit 20?
Hey Danny, do you have any interest at all in "party speakers"? (i.e. JBL Partybox or Klipsch XL/XXL). Would be quite curious to see how they stack up against Marshall or the JBL Authentics line.
I hate the look of party speakers so I've stayed away. I'm sure they are good but they are party speakers because they are made to sound good and have features catered to parties.
@@DannyPops True!
Acton 3 killer speaker 🔥
Have Tufton and Midleton, love them !!!!!
Hi Danny! I love your videos, Bass Wise and Listening to Hi Res/Lossless Music which speaker would you recommend Woburn 3 or JBL Authentic 500 or any other brand in the same size?
I havent listened to either in a totally lossless format. They are great speakers the both of them, so I'd say go with the one that has the features and looks you like more.
@@DannyPops Thank you
Helpful thanks.
Can you use these speakers while the battery is charging? Can you just keep them plugged in all the time?
Yes
Kill burn 2 or acton 3, which one is better ?
Suggest one
@@Amanpreet2654 Acton is not wireless
nice review
Does they have good bass
very very good video
I have a stockwell 2 and a tufton cause... well... you cant really put the tufton in your pocket or backpack lmao. It is portable alright. If you want to do a workout at the same time. 5-6kg's of deadweight for that puppy
Tufton also got aptx
With a name like Marshall you should be playing rock and roll
I'm really disappointed with my kilburn 2 - it doesn't feel like it has the same sound profile as the stanmore or larger speakers. Bass is too heavy and the highs just ain't good. Gonna be returning it
Please compare them to a Fender Riff!
thx
👍👍👍
the expensive speaker in the Philippines that i cant afford 😂😂😂
when new kilburn 3 is coming finally, k2 is such old tech ... :-/
I'm getting tufton just 45$ expensive than Middleton
👍
👍🏻
you can get Harman Kardon Aura Studio 3 or else Harman Kardon Soundsticks 4 much much better than Marshalls products.
I got the middleton and i love it. But my confused about killburn at tufton,why it seems that the killburn sounds greater than tufton. And i think you have a hearing impairment when you said the killburn is still quiete for you. Dude clean your ears regularly. Cotton buds are cheaper in any dollar tree store 🤣🤣🤣
lol sheesh.
Why build a portable speaker that can’t be charged from a 12v source- ie your car?!!! Useless
Pick a better song next time. Terrible song for a review.
Way over priced trading on marshall name and legacy. China under another name
I don’t know a damn thing about speakers, Bluetooth, or any of that other crap you said. But thanks for the vid it did help me.
👍🏼
👍
👍🏼
👍
👍
👍