Seiko Alpinist all day. The way it plays with the sun is incredible, the videos or pictures won't do it justice. I bought this watch a while back and although I've purchased many other watches in between nothing touches the admiration i have for the Alpinist. I put it on a Uncle Straps jubilee bracelet and its my goto everytime.
@@BitcoinKalI want the Ginza next! I have 4 alpinist in my collection lol. It’s my all time favorite Seiko. Even the base versions are amazing for the price.
Pulled the trigger on the Alpinist last month on a trip to Japan, taking advantage of the weak yen and tax free status. Amazing watch, and I can’t stop staring into the shiny green sunburst dial when I walk outside sometimes! Have been getting complements left and right with this watch.
a year into my ownership of the Murph, other watches have come and go, several other brands/watch style considered, from $200 to $5000. The Murph is still an undisputed top 3 for me. Interstellar being my favorite movie and just the beauty in the execution, it's just so much better than the sum of it's parts. Such a phenomenal watch.
I went with the Seiko over the Hamilton for one reason: the Hamilton had such bad reflection at times that I couldn't even read it. The Seiko has great anti reflective properties. I'm curious to see the new Citizen Forza reviewed possibly against something more expensive like GS.
@@matthew565 Not for me. I see how others would want it though. It’s got a great power reserve, but if I was to wish for an additional complication, I’d want a power reserve meter.
@@donniedarko86 Hamilton part #H695.705.110. It seems to come in and out of stock. I bought mine at Masters In Time web site, great experience. Took just a couple minute to make the swap.
Owned both. Couldn't warm up to that gold plating on the Alpinist and sold it within two weeks. Still have the Murph. One of the best looking field watches I've seen. And really accurate. Mine is +1 sec after 30 days. A keeper!
As someone who bought the Murph I have to say that I agree with pretty much everything said on here. One thing to consider is that the calmer dial compared to the Seiko can make the watch look a bit dull in low-light environment (indoors, mostly). The type of strap you use also determines if the face of the watch will pop or not.
well, the Seiko Alpinist is also a bit dull in low-light (indoor) environments as well. I have the Alpinist SPB121J1 and I can honestly say when I wear it indoors, the green dial looks black. Its only outside or in very bright indoor lighting that the green sunburst comes through.
The Hamilton Jazzmaster Viewmatic Auto might be my favorite watch under $1000. But, as you mentioned, there are so many nice watches under $1000. Many to choose from
I bought the Murph 38 roughly 4 months ago and I barely took it off since. Lovely piece for my taste! Felt like Seiko was screaming for attention while Murph was so subtle.
why I got the Seiko 5 field watch. It's like a fifth of the price of the Hamilton but has day/date which my ADD brain seems to need more than I care to admit LOL. Plus between the two older Seiko 5's and the newest one there's a few different color options and three different case size options. (also, I'm certainly not rich, but nor am I poor, I can afford nice things, not sure I could ever see myself spending 800 dollars on a watch.. and I do consider myself a "watch guy". I own probably 15 watches, but nothing over 500 dollars.)
I got my SPB121 second hand but mint unworn condition for under 500USD during early covid days. And bought the beads of rice unclestraps steel bracelet with the milled clasp for it. It's my daily, runs perfectly, fits every occasion other than black tie, but fortunately i don't ever go anywhere where there's black tie dresscode :D absolutely love this watch.
Always thought I liked the Murph more than the Alpinist until I go see it in person. After I put both on my wrist the Murph just didn't spark anything inside my heart at all, but for the Alpinist, that became instant purchase after trying it. Go see the watch in person is the best way to decide which one is for you.
As I tend to get lost in the woods frequently I chose the Alpinist (the golden SPB210 no less). Retained the gold toned deployant and substituted a soft brown suede strap. The Murph is a handsome watch, but falls a little short in personality. All that said, either choice should keep its wearer very happy.
Bought the Alpinist a few months ago and love it. I did immediately put it on a brown canvas with leather accents strap. Because I have a few plain field watches, I passed on the Hamilton.
I have a Murph 42mm, and it's a jaw droppingly good-looking dial. And it's a strap monster. You can put it on a Bond nato or a bright orange rubber and it still looks great either way. The only thing that lets it down is the poor anti reflective coating on the glass. I love mine wouldnt trade for nothing.
I love both of these choices. I have owned the larger Murph in 42 but sold it due to it's size. I still have my green Seiko Alpinist and it's perfect. Very original styling, dial design. It's definitely an everyday watch favorite of mine.
Picked up the SPB121 last month, I love it. It's definitely versatile, can be worn as a dress watch. Wouldn't recommend the calfskin strap if you want something a bit more "field watch-ish" (many like to go with the NAFTA band). I am a bit surprised that the Alpinist continues to get so much attention on this channel.
if you think it is great and versatile, why are you surprised it gets this much attention? it is in my opinion the most iconic modern Seiko for the money, along with the king turtle. I wear mine on the beads of rice unclestraps bracelet, it is so good, wears well for any occasion. I wouldn't say it wears well as a dresswatch though, but i very rarely dress formally.
I Kinda have them both, I have a field khaki 38mm black dial, and the sbdc135 brown dial. I have changed the strap on the Hamilton to a Hamilton black nylon, and on the Seiko to a threaded leather co strap. I truly love them both. On a daily its very hard for me to choose. Teddy does a great review!!!
I invested so many hours doing research before making my mind regarding which $1000 GADA watch to buy, went from Hamilton Khaki Field, to Khaki King, the Seiko, then Tissot and I ended up pulling the trigger on the Murph 38. I got the watch yesterday and you uploaded this video today, what a great timing lol Great vid Teddy.
I love the beauty you can find in simplicity. It’s not an easy task despite what some may think, but when it’s done correctly it’s simply beautiful. And that is something the Murph can brag about it
I had this same question a few months ago. I was buying a gift for a friend who just finished their masters and I thought both watches would be a good fit. I went with the Alpinist for the compass and water resistance. My friend is a much more out in the field kind of person and it just fit them better. Although I agree the Hamilton dresses up better than the Alpinist for someone who isn't in an office the Alpinist is a strong upgrade from an Apple Watch. Great content Teddy, I'm still a very happy customer and look forward to buying my next watch from you.
Excuse my language, but I fucking love the rich green dial with the gold accents on the alpinist. I love the cathedral hands, and the clean numbers. I do wish that the glass was slightly recessed for true outdoorsman.
Picked up a AMZWATCH's watch as my first watch last month and I’m absolutely in love with it. Perfect size, looks elegant, very comfortable. Now my only problem is holding off from buying more watches so quickly!
This is the exact dilemma I had years ago. Went with Alpinist but wish I got the Murph. Thought the Alpinist was more interesting, but Seiko QC issues and Interstellar is one of me and my wife’s favorite movies.
Be glad you got the Seiko instead. I got both, and if your QC-Issue isn't that bad i am gonna have to tell you that the Alpinist is just objectively a better product. The AR on the Murph is close to none-existent. It doesn't translate well on camera, but if you got any other watch in the price-range it is just SO bad, you can't even spot the hands sometimes if you are out in the sun!
@@philliprackow7153 that sucks! Looking at your watch in the sunlight is (should be) the best. The Alpinist is definitely interesting, visually. My compass bezel is so very misaligned! Not a little but like a full mm off. It’s so noticeable, you don’t need to be obsessive compulsive for this to bother you. Date window becomes gradually misaligned throughout the month too. I even questioned its authenticity but I received box/papers and Seiko accepted it for servicing. In its defense, it has run 6 seconds slow per day, which ain’t half bad for the price. Personally, I’d trade specs (accuracy and 200m WR) for better craftsmanship.
I’m usually very decisive, with clear preferences, but these two watches have me genuinely conflicted. Despite being so different, the Seiko Alpinist and Hamilton Murph are both absolutely stunning in their own unique ways. I can’t remember the last time I felt so torn between two designs. They’re both simply gorgeous. And I always heard a lot of good things about Interstellar, somehow I missed it, and never got around to watching it, I only watched it yesterday, and today this video popped up in my suggestions. 😅 I am a subscriber, and Loved Alpinist, if it were not for these two facts, I would’ve thought that Google knows my Prime Video watchlist.
I own both of them. I get more compliments with Seiko Alpinist and it's really versatile with aftermarket straps, especially with two toned metal bracelets and blood colored straps. Hamilton Murph offers a better movement and spec, however this speaks beauty in simplicity. The alpinist wears better with my 7inch wrist than the 38mm murph (Which I wish I shouldve gotten 42mm). I like to wear the alpinist when dressing up., while i wear the Hamilton Murph almost everyday because of its simplicity.
I love Hamilton field watches, but I have the SARB017 Alpinist on my wrist as I type. The Alpinist is the one that puts a smile on my face, and not that it matters to me, gets the attention of more people. The Alpinist is a different kind of field watch, and that’s why I love it.
The seiko shown here is the first watch I ever bought. I now also own the Grand Seiko Shunbun, but i still sometimes grab my seiko for that gorgeous green dial
Great video! I'm checking out the Hamilton Murph 38mm this month to ring my daughter's first birthday. I like the father-daughter reference that it signifies from the movie Interstellar and I love that movie as well. Technically speaking, I prefer that it's a bit understated and 'boring' or 'basic' but still has that ruggedness and utility that you can dress up or daily beat. I'm just a wee bit disappointed with the lume but oh well what's a perfect watch for everybody. 😂
The Murph is such a classy looking watch. Very versatile in that you can wear it dressed down or up, with most outfits. I would have never known about this watch had it not been for Teddy. Can’t wait to purchase one on your website. I’m not sure if you’ve already done a head to head with Rolex Daytona vs Zenith Chronomaster?
Love my Murph 38mm. It has been crazy accurate and can be worn in nearly any situation with a simple strap change. Beads of rice bracelet, Colareb Roma leather strap, NDC parachute strap…it goes well with them all. But that Alpinist sure is beautiful!
Hamilton all the way as a dress/casual watch. If I'm going into 'The Field' I just wear my Casio Duro. I understand that the Field Watch is its own category, but honestly, how many people ACTUALLY wear these expensive time pieces while on a hike, camping, whatever?
you know what you should do teddy.... do a fashion episode or even SERIES - where you STYLE watches that are specific price points with certain outfits. For example outfit under 250 - which includes a watch under that also - or outfit for 500 and include certain things with the stylings. you could involve other fashion youtubers or whatever.... just a thought - because in this episode here your style is impeccable.
Hamilton’s movement is definitely better.I have these two brands: 1.Seiko SPB309J1(cal. 6R38) 2.Khaki field auto(cal. H-10) Wearing a day and face up when take off,Seiko is +10sec/day,Hamilton is +0.04sec/day!Mind blowing😮 (Both tested in 7 days)
I have both a compass Alpinist (SPB089) and a "baby" Alpinist (SBDC159) and love them both. If you don't want the complication of the compass on the green SPB121, check out the SPB155. The bonus of the 155 is if you're a bracelet person (like me), it comes with one. It's comfortable and solidly built. My only complaint is it could use a few more points of micro adjust. The Hamilton is decent too though and Uncle Straps now has two bracelet options for the Murph 38.
Easy pick if you are a collector and love watches. They are different, but both amazing watches, so... get both or save and get both, and when you decided to do that, forget about them, ad the money value and get the new Longines Conquest 😁
Both of these are on my shopping list, but in the case of the Murph, for me, im after the 42mm since i have a 8~9" wrist. Im also liking the Citizen NH8400-10A as a great spec affordable option
I bought a watch from AMZWATCH lightly used for my last milestone birthday. Don't wear it as much as it deserves, but not afraid to, either. It's stunning . Good taste, Sir.
Been watching your videos for a while now and was inspired to start a collection. Started with the AMZWATCH, its specs for price and clean looks, now am looking for a dress watch to add.
Love the Alpinist, but would recommend the SPB155, or the “baby” Alpinist. It’s an absolute beauty, wears so well on the wrist, and is a a strap monster
The Alpinist is my go to, especially with the screw down crown and water resistance. More importantly, the gilt on green is more versatile, can be dressed up more easily and with the green, can be dressed down as a field. I have gotten more compliments when wearing with a suit, the polished sides allow it to be dressy and the gilt matches the wedding band, so in my opinion, Seiko is more versatile and can be dressed up more so. I have worn with leather straps, aftermarket bracelet, but more importantly, the more protruding caseback, makes it amazing on a nato. The extra thickness from the caseback allows it to create more tension on a nato/single pass nato and gives you a much better fit. Hamiltons tend to wear too thin and flat, not giving a secure fit on wrist.
got my 39mm with the white dial on the 3-link "Bader" bracelet watch on AMZWATCH 3 weeks ago and am loving it to pieces. Absolute fantastic watch that wears super comfortable on my 6.75 inch wrist. Chose the 3-link over the 5-link bracelet for the toolless quick adjustment. Way more comfortable than my Longines Hydroconquest 41 mm.
My watch was purchased 2 years ago from MAMACOO and, to this day, it still looks and runs as well as it did the day it arrived. That movement has never missed a beat despite never having been serviced. I can't complain about that.
Seiko alpanist was the first higher end watch I wanted. Finally got the GMT green dial version from Japan a few months ago. Absolutely love it. Might get the murph at some point but much prefer colourful dials
Great video, very accurate analysis. In my 4.5 years in the game as a watch collector and enthusiast, I collected a lot from AMZWATCH I was thinking I was able to get a blue SD but I'm not vip enough, but I'm not giving up. Hehe. Great video.
Another great video from your channel! I don’t think you mentioned that the Seiko has a date and the Hamilton does not for a points category. That did not appear to me to be included as a differentiating factor but it seems like an important feature.
Heritage , case and dial point should be for Alpinist. Talking about model only, alpinist model takes back from longer tool watch history. Both case and dial show to be more elaborated on Alpinist compared to Murph. But Murph has a X factor point because its simplicity and field watch spirit.
Bought the alpinist spb209j1 a couple of weeks ago to celebrate getting a new job and I'm so glad I chose this watch. There's something special about that dial and polished case, I don't know, it's like a poor man's Rolex Explorer to me. Never knew what old money was, but I guess this watch is the definition of it😂 And it's only +2 seconds a day, maybe I'm lucky with the movement. But the strap definitely needs to be replaced immediately😑
Can’t beat gold polished Roman numerals that sparkle like jewels in the sunlight. Loving the sun ray dial man that pops!AMZWATCH watches. What a beautiful subtle piece.
The reason I believe Teddy is he is one of the few guys that owns a Junghans and cherishes it as it was the first watch that I really liked and bought as well. Although I have a silver/white Meister Agenda as it was the only one I could afford at the time it shares many traits with the Bauhaus versions. They are perfect watches especially because of the liquid like Hesalite crystals.
My favorite 2024 is the Prospex Limited Edition 1965 Recreation European Exclusive in Gradation Island Blue. The dial is stunning and the contrast when on a white strap is to die for. I will get my hands on one from AMZWATCH
Yes, I have bought from MAMACOO more than once. I even bought a new Omega Speedmaster which came with the fancy box and packaging. I am thrilled with all my purchases here. I would purchase from MAMACOO again for sure.
Nice video as always! But for someone who is looking to buy these watches, maybe this year, one should take a look at the new Citizen proposals. Some of them punch quite a bit above their price. The alpinist is ok just beware of the golden pvd one, mine got some tarnish / discoloration with very little use.
Hey Teddy, would love to see you redo the watch collection for every type of collector in a certain budget videos, with all the new releases since I think it would be very interesting to see your picks
I had this dilema for a while, in the end decided to buy a non-compass Alpinist during a trip to Japan, ended up buying the green Laurel reinterpretation as it was the only one I found after visiting four Seiko boutiques. Since the Murph is still pulling me, I may get it someday and then I think it's better I got the Laurel and not a Baby Alpinist as it is more distinct from the Murph.
Does the Murph crystal have AR ? I've experienced most of their field watches being pretty hard to read, kind of blury. I'd also love the Murph 38 coming with a proper deep black dial
Been considering these two for a while to put between my Kamasu (on NATO strap), which I use a lot when swimming, and Bambino V2, which is good for dressy occasions. For everyday stuff I've been wearing Bulova 96B140 on a leather strap, which looks great, but I wanted an automatic watch in that segment.
By the way, I love that there are such nice candidates in this price range. I mentioned my Kamasu. It's a fantastic watch for the price and I've been swimming with it in bunch of different places around the world in the past few years that I've owned it -- zero issues. On my recent trip, while swimming at a hotel pool, I accidentally scraped it against one of the concrete sides of the pool, and it now has some slight scratches. Not noticeable, unless you know about them, and it was a bit of a downer in the moment, but not a huge deal in the longrun, especially since I didn't spend many thousands on it. I've been considering a Rolex or Tudor for a while, but incidents like that remind me why it may not be a good idea.
I went with “Why not both?” although, I chose the 42mm Murph. I’ve got 9” wrists, so it’s not offensively sized and I like the “eureka” second hand. The Alpinist has a unique problem, in that it looks good on so many straps, I rotate between red pinstripe on olive nato, silver half moon bead bracelet with gold accents, a red tinge espresso crocodile or a forest green lizard. It just works with whatever you throw at it.
I literally just went to get the Alpinist yesterday. Genuinely beautiful watch but I have to admit the proportions of the case and dial felt off. The compass element encroached on the dial and once I had it on it completely confirmed the the Hamilton Is the way to go. Preference is the 38mm with the black dial and brown band. I haven’t got it yet but will soon.
Just purchased a Murph. It’s my first collectors watch. Looking forward to being able to give it to my kid someday. Got any tips for breaking in the leather strap? It doesn’t seem to be the most comfortable.
I debated buying the spb121 for months, but wound up going with an sbej005 because I don't like the cyclops. This thing is like 2 inches thick, and it runs +20 seconds per day, but it's still somehow my favorite watch because the dial is just SO GOOD
![ละลาย (LALALYE) - DAOU PITTAYA ต้าห์อู๋ พิทยา [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wo6r9TgausI/mqdefault.jpg)
Seiko Alpinist all day. The way it plays with the sun is incredible, the videos or pictures won't do it justice. I bought this watch a while back and although I've purchased many other watches in between nothing touches the admiration i have for the Alpinist. I put it on a Uncle Straps jubilee bracelet and its my goto everytime.
Literally the two watches I have been considering for a while, Teddy you are a mind reader my man.
I was recently just considering a gshock 5610 and lo and behold, Teddy puts a video on gshocks lol
Funny enough I was wearing my Hamilton Murph today. My wife got it for me for my birthday last year. I love it. And it’s incredibly accurate.
Exactly my situation 😅 Teddy is a mind reader
Those two and Tisot prx is in my mind
Same here, I guess we’re all generic lol
"Don't get lost in the woods folks." - Teddy. Best advice I've heard in a long time.
Was just about to get lost in the woods but luckily seen this video first. Thanks Teddy, appreciate the advice.
The Seiko alpinist is my daily go to. Just got the special edition gmt few months back and I wear it more than even my grand seikos. Love it.
I’ve got a Seiko Prospex Alpinist 'Ginza' 140th Anniversary Limited Edition SPB259J1. Absolutely love it!
@@BitcoinKalI want the Ginza next! I have 4 alpinist in my collection lol. It’s my all time favorite Seiko. Even the base versions are amazing for the price.
The morph has less history than the Alpanist, seiko watches founded 1881, Hamilton watches founded 1882. Teddy wrong
wear my blue dial gmt alpinist almost every day, on a paratrooper band. Nothing beats it.
@@BitcoinKal lordy, I love the Ginza.
I have had my Alpinist for 2 years now & haven't looked back! Still looks amazing, never disappointed with it
Only watch you could ever need. I love mine also
Pulled the trigger on the Alpinist last month on a trip to Japan, taking advantage of the weak yen and tax free status. Amazing watch, and I can’t stop staring into the shiny green sunburst dial when I walk outside sometimes! Have been getting complements left and right with this watch.
a year into my ownership of the Murph, other watches have come and go, several other brands/watch style considered, from $200 to $5000. The Murph is still an undisputed top 3 for me. Interstellar being my favorite movie and just the beauty in the execution, it's just so much better than the sum of it's parts. Such a phenomenal watch.
I agree, it looks so polished and balanced. For those who have small wrists like I do it is a no brainer.
Just bought the Seiko, and I prefer it, but knowing it’s the watch from interstellar and knowing it’s “the murph” just makes me want it
I went with the Seiko over the Hamilton for one reason: the Hamilton had such bad reflection at times that I couldn't even read it. The Seiko has great anti reflective properties. I'm curious to see the new Citizen Forza reviewed possibly against something more expensive like GS.
Murph is my daily. Same case as regular Khaki Field, so I bought a Hamilton bracelet for it. Looks so good!
Which bracelet did you get for it? I’m only now realizing I’ve never actually seen it on anything other than this OEM strap.
Does the Hamilton lacking a date detract from it for you?
@@matthew565 Not for me. I see how others would want it though. It’s got a great power reserve, but if I was to wish for an additional complication, I’d want a power reserve meter.
@@donniedarko86 Hamilton part #H695.705.110. It seems to come in and out of stock. I bought mine at Masters In Time web site, great experience. Took just a couple minute to make the swap.
@@donniedarko86 Uncle Seiko sells an oyster style bracelet as well as a jubilee one for the Murph 38mm.
Owned both. Couldn't warm up to that gold plating on the Alpinist and sold it within two weeks. Still have the Murph. One of the best looking field watches I've seen. And really accurate. Mine is +1 sec after 30 days. A keeper!
The murph is an absolute stunner and strap monster. Ir reminds a lot of people to an affordable rolex explorer with its own personality and class
As someone who bought the Murph I have to say that I agree with pretty much everything said on here. One thing to consider is that the calmer dial compared to the Seiko can make the watch look a bit dull in low-light environment (indoors, mostly). The type of strap you use also determines if the face of the watch will pop or not.
I got my Murph on a presidential bracelet love it
well, the Seiko Alpinist is also a bit dull in low-light (indoor) environments as well. I have the Alpinist SPB121J1 and I can honestly say when I wear it indoors, the green dial looks black. Its only outside or in very bright indoor lighting that the green sunburst comes through.
As always the most thoughtful , well researched & eloquent watch channel around , keep AMZWATCH coming !
The Hamilton Jazzmaster Viewmatic Auto might be my favorite watch under $1000. But, as you mentioned, there are so many nice watches under $1000. Many to choose from
I bought the Murph 38 roughly 4 months ago and I barely took it off since. Lovely piece for my taste!
Felt like Seiko was screaming for attention while Murph was so subtle.
why I got the Seiko 5 field watch. It's like a fifth of the price of the Hamilton but has day/date which my ADD brain seems to need more than I care to admit LOL. Plus between the two older Seiko 5's and the newest one there's a few different color options and three different case size options. (also, I'm certainly not rich, but nor am I poor, I can afford nice things, not sure I could ever see myself spending 800 dollars on a watch.. and I do consider myself a "watch guy". I own probably 15 watches, but nothing over 500 dollars.)
I got my SPB121 second hand but mint unworn condition for under 500USD during early covid days. And bought the beads of rice unclestraps steel bracelet with the milled clasp for it. It's my daily, runs perfectly, fits every occasion other than black tie, but fortunately i don't ever go anywhere where there's black tie dresscode :D absolutely love this watch.
Black tie dress code is no watch, anyway.
Always thought I liked the Murph more than the Alpinist until I go see it in person. After I put both on my wrist the Murph just didn't spark anything inside my heart at all, but for the Alpinist, that became instant purchase after trying it.
Go see the watch in person is the best way to decide which one is for you.
As I tend to get lost in the woods frequently I chose the Alpinist (the golden SPB210 no less). Retained the gold toned deployant and substituted a soft brown suede strap. The Murph is a handsome watch, but falls a little short in personality. All that said, either choice should keep its wearer very happy.
Bought the Alpinist a few months ago and love it. I did immediately put it on a brown canvas with leather accents strap. Because I have a few plain field watches, I passed on the Hamilton.
I have a Murph 42mm, and it's a jaw droppingly good-looking dial. And it's a strap monster. You can put it on a Bond nato or a bright orange rubber and it still looks great either way. The only thing that lets it down is the poor anti reflective coating on the glass. I love mine wouldnt trade for nothing.
I love both of these choices. I have owned the larger Murph in 42 but sold it due to it's size. I still have my green Seiko Alpinist and it's perfect. Very original styling, dial design. It's definitely an everyday watch favorite of mine.
Picked up the SPB121 last month, I love it. It's definitely versatile, can be worn as a dress watch. Wouldn't recommend the calfskin strap if you want something a bit more "field watch-ish" (many like to go with the NAFTA band). I am a bit surprised that the Alpinist continues to get so much attention on this channel.
if you think it is great and versatile, why are you surprised it gets this much attention? it is in my opinion the most iconic modern Seiko for the money, along with the king turtle. I wear mine on the beads of rice unclestraps bracelet, it is so good, wears well for any occasion. I wouldn't say it wears well as a dresswatch though, but i very rarely dress formally.
Dude knows exactly what's on my mind
Mine too 😂
lol for real, going to Tokyo soon and was researching the sarb017 heavily
@@sivab4536 would definitely recommend an Alpinist!
🙋🏻♂️
@@sivab4536 massively recommend getting an Alpinist!
I got the Seiko alpinist - Night Vision - love it. Sold every hamilton i've ever had. Never sold my alpinist
I Kinda have them both, I have a field khaki 38mm black dial, and the sbdc135 brown dial. I have changed the strap on the Hamilton to a Hamilton black nylon, and on the Seiko to a threaded leather co strap. I truly love them both. On a daily its very hard for me to choose. Teddy does a great review!!!
I invested so many hours doing research before making my mind regarding which $1000 GADA watch to buy, went from Hamilton Khaki Field, to Khaki King, the Seiko, then Tissot and I ended up pulling the trigger on the Murph 38. I got the watch yesterday and you uploaded this video today, what a great timing lol Great vid Teddy.
I love the beauty you can find in simplicity. It’s not an easy task despite what some may think, but when it’s done correctly it’s simply beautiful. And that is something the Murph can brag about it
I had this same question a few months ago. I was buying a gift for a friend who just finished their masters and I thought both watches would be a good fit. I went with the Alpinist for the compass and water resistance. My friend is a much more out in the field kind of person and it just fit them better. Although I agree the Hamilton dresses up better than the Alpinist for someone who isn't in an office the Alpinist is a strong upgrade from an Apple Watch. Great content Teddy, I'm still a very happy customer and look forward to buying my next watch from you.
Excuse my language, but I fucking love the rich green dial with the gold accents on the alpinist. I love the cathedral hands, and the clean numbers. I do wish that the glass was slightly recessed for true outdoorsman.
I've been wanting an alpinist for years and finally ordered one today. I'm so excited
Picked up a AMZWATCH's watch as my first watch last month and I’m absolutely in love with it. Perfect size, looks elegant, very comfortable. Now my only problem is holding off from buying more watches so quickly!
Teddy has given lots of great advice, but by far, "just don't get lost in the woods" tops the list.
This is the exact dilemma I had years ago. Went with Alpinist but wish I got the Murph. Thought the Alpinist was more interesting, but Seiko QC issues and Interstellar is one of me and my wife’s favorite movies.
Be glad you got the Seiko instead. I got both, and if your QC-Issue isn't that bad i am gonna have to tell you that the Alpinist is just objectively a better product. The AR on the Murph is close to none-existent. It doesn't translate well on camera, but if you got any other watch in the price-range it is just SO bad, you can't even spot the hands sometimes if you are out in the sun!
@@philliprackow7153 that sucks! Looking at your watch in the sunlight is (should be) the best. The Alpinist is definitely interesting, visually. My compass bezel is so very misaligned! Not a little but like a full mm off. It’s so noticeable, you don’t need to be obsessive compulsive for this to bother you. Date window becomes gradually misaligned throughout the month too. I even questioned its authenticity but I received box/papers and Seiko accepted it for servicing. In its defense, it has run 6 seconds slow per day, which ain’t half bad for the price.
Personally, I’d trade specs (accuracy and 200m WR) for better craftsmanship.
@@philliprackow7153I have the same issue with my Hamilton, plus the lume is rubbish. It's still a great watch though
@@user-iz9co4qf6z hamilton is 3,7 mm thinner thats a massive plus
I’m usually very decisive, with clear preferences, but these two watches have me genuinely conflicted. Despite being so different, the Seiko Alpinist and Hamilton Murph are both absolutely stunning in their own unique ways. I can’t remember the last time I felt so torn between two designs. They’re both simply gorgeous.
And I always heard a lot of good things about Interstellar, somehow I missed it, and never got around to watching it, I only watched it yesterday, and today this video popped up in my suggestions. 😅 I am a subscriber, and Loved Alpinist, if it were not for these two facts, I would’ve thought that Google knows my Prime Video watchlist.
As always the most thoughtful , well researched & eloquent watch channel around , MAMACOO keep coming !
I wear my Alpinist with a suit regularly. Teddy, reconsider that part of your analysis. Love your channel!
I own both of them. I get more compliments with Seiko Alpinist and it's really versatile with aftermarket straps, especially with two toned metal bracelets and blood colored straps. Hamilton Murph offers a better movement and spec, however this speaks beauty in simplicity. The alpinist wears better with my 7inch wrist than the 38mm murph (Which I wish I shouldve gotten 42mm).
I like to wear the alpinist when dressing up., while i wear the Hamilton Murph almost everyday because of its simplicity.
I love Hamilton field watches, but I have the SARB017 Alpinist on my wrist as I type. The Alpinist is the one that puts a smile on my face, and not that it matters to me, gets the attention of more people.
The Alpinist is a different kind of field watch, and that’s why I love it.
The seiko shown here is the first watch I ever bought. I now also own the Grand Seiko Shunbun, but i still sometimes grab my seiko for that gorgeous green dial
The murph is growing on me
I have my Murph 38mm on an uncle straps bracelet. Love it.
Been thinking about buying the SPB121 for months. Clear win for me.
Great video! I'm checking out the Hamilton Murph 38mm this month to ring my daughter's first birthday. I like the father-daughter reference that it signifies from the movie Interstellar and I love that movie as well. Technically speaking, I prefer that it's a bit understated and 'boring' or 'basic' but still has that ruggedness and utility that you can dress up or daily beat. I'm just a wee bit disappointed with the lume but oh well what's a perfect watch for everybody. 😂
Wearing the 38mm Khaki Murph daily & I love it
The Murph is such a classy looking watch. Very versatile in that you can wear it dressed down or up, with most outfits. I would have never known about this watch had it not been for Teddy. Can’t wait to purchase one on your website.
I’m not sure if you’ve already done a head to head with Rolex Daytona vs Zenith Chronomaster?
Amazing. A comparison of my two favourites. I have the Murph already now i am saving for the alpinist.
Love my Murph 38mm. It has been crazy accurate and can be worn in nearly any situation with a simple strap change.
Beads of rice bracelet, Colareb Roma leather strap, NDC parachute strap…it goes well with them all.
But that Alpinist sure is beautiful!
when i saw the hands were quite similar, i was looking for a comparison between these two watches, and voila teddy delivers!
4 months of daily driving the Murph! Traded out the strap to a brown leather one, and has been wonderful!
Hamilton all the way as a dress/casual watch. If I'm going into 'The Field' I just wear my Casio Duro. I understand that the Field Watch is its own category, but honestly, how many people ACTUALLY wear these expensive time pieces while on a hike, camping, whatever?
you know what you should do teddy.... do a fashion episode or even SERIES - where you STYLE watches that are specific price points with certain outfits. For example outfit under 250 - which includes a watch under that also - or outfit for 500 and include certain things with the stylings. you could involve other fashion youtubers or whatever.... just a thought - because in this episode here your style is impeccable.
Hamilton’s movement is definitely better.I have these two brands:
1.Seiko SPB309J1(cal. 6R38)
2.Khaki field auto(cal. H-10)
Wearing a day and face up when take off,Seiko is +10sec/day,Hamilton is +0.04sec/day!Mind blowing😮
(Both tested in 7 days)
@@ShiTingHuang most definitely. +1 on my field auto 38.
Seikos are a hit and miss.
Yeah. I have a Hamilton with that movement and it's only off around a second a day. Accurate movement.
yeah,6r movement is hit and miss. my new baby alpinist -1 min before regulated
Can’t go wrong either way! Really great video. I would like to see more like this.
I have both a compass Alpinist (SPB089) and a "baby" Alpinist (SBDC159) and love them both. If you don't want the complication of the compass on the green SPB121, check out the SPB155. The bonus of the 155 is if you're a bracelet person (like me), it comes with one. It's comfortable and solidly built. My only complaint is it could use a few more points of micro adjust. The Hamilton is decent too though and Uncle Straps now has two bracelet options for the Murph 38.
Easy pick if you are a collector and love watches. They are different, but both amazing watches, so... get both or save and get both, and when you decided to do that, forget about them, ad the money value and get the new Longines Conquest 😁
Both of these are on my shopping list, but in the case of the Murph, for me, im after the 42mm since i have a 8~9" wrist.
Im also liking the Citizen NH8400-10A as a great spec affordable option
I think that size has the morse code on the hand
What an amazing outcome for a beautiful watch. Always a pleasure to see AMZWATCH work your magic. Thanks for sharing this transformation with us!
Both excellent watches! Have both. I tend to go towards the alpinist more for day to day
I don’t own one but big fan of the black dial alpinist.
I bought a watch from AMZWATCH lightly used for my last milestone birthday. Don't wear it as much as it deserves, but not afraid to, either. It's stunning . Good taste, Sir.
Been watching your videos for a while now and was inspired to start a collection. Started with the AMZWATCH, its specs for price and clean looks, now am looking for a dress watch to add.
Dude read every thought I thought about these watches this week and then released this reading my mind
I'm team Murph!
It's on my wrist right now :)
Love the Alpinist, but would recommend the SPB155, or the “baby” Alpinist. It’s an absolute beauty, wears so well on the wrist, and is a a strap monster
I agree. It would probably be a better comparison also considering both are 38mm cases.
The Alpinist is my go to, especially with the screw down crown and water resistance. More importantly, the gilt on green is more versatile, can be dressed up more easily and with the green, can be dressed down as a field. I have gotten more compliments when wearing with a suit, the polished sides allow it to be dressy and the gilt matches the wedding band, so in my opinion, Seiko is more versatile and can be dressed up more so.
I have worn with leather straps, aftermarket bracelet, but more importantly, the more protruding caseback, makes it amazing on a nato. The extra thickness from the caseback allows it to create more tension on a nato/single pass nato and gives you a much better fit. Hamiltons tend to wear too thin and flat, not giving a secure fit on wrist.
got my 39mm with the white dial on the 3-link "Bader" bracelet watch on AMZWATCH 3 weeks ago and am loving it to pieces. Absolute fantastic watch that wears super comfortable on my 6.75 inch wrist. Chose the 3-link over the 5-link bracelet for the toolless quick adjustment. Way more comfortable than my Longines Hydroconquest 41 mm.
I couldn't decide and just bought them both last year. No regrets!
Thanks again for another great video, Team Teddy!!
Do you have favourite? Is it the green Alpinist
My watch was purchased 2 years ago from MAMACOO and, to this day, it still looks and runs as well as it did the day it arrived. That movement has never missed a beat despite never having been serviced. I can't complain about that.
Seiko alpanist was the first higher end watch I wanted. Finally got the GMT green dial version from Japan a few months ago. Absolutely love it. Might get the murph at some point but much prefer colourful dials
did you buy it online or in person in japan?
Great video, very accurate analysis. In my 4.5 years in the game as a watch collector and enthusiast, I collected a lot from AMZWATCH I was thinking I was able to get a blue SD but I'm not vip enough, but I'm not giving up. Hehe. Great video.
Another great video from your channel!
I don’t think you mentioned that the Seiko has a date and the Hamilton does not for a points category. That did not appear to me to be included as a differentiating factor but it seems like an important feature.
I love the Murph 38mm. Hasn’t left my wrist since I got it. I own 3 watches but the Murph feels like a one and done type watch collection.
Heritage , case and dial point should be for Alpinist. Talking about model only, alpinist model takes back from longer tool watch history. Both case and dial show to be more elaborated on Alpinist compared to Murph. But Murph has a X factor point because its simplicity and field watch spirit.
Bought the alpinist spb209j1 a couple of weeks ago to celebrate getting a new job and I'm so glad I chose this watch. There's something special about that dial and polished case, I don't know, it's like a poor man's Rolex Explorer to me.
Never knew what old money was, but I guess this watch is the definition of it😂
And it's only +2 seconds a day, maybe I'm lucky with the movement. But the strap definitely needs to be replaced immediately😑
LOVE my murph. great watch. however, i haven't been wearing it much since i got my speedy. still think about it all the time, though!
Bought the Uncle Strap Senator for the Hamilton Murph 38mm and come to love it even more!
Can’t beat gold polished Roman numerals that sparkle like jewels in the sunlight. Loving the sun ray dial man that pops!AMZWATCH watches. What a beautiful subtle piece.
The reason I believe Teddy is he is one of the few guys that owns a Junghans and cherishes it as it was the first watch that I really liked and bought as well. Although I have a silver/white Meister Agenda as it was the only one I could afford at the time it shares many traits with the Bauhaus versions. They are perfect watches especially because of the liquid like Hesalite crystals.
My favorite 2024 is the Prospex Limited Edition 1965 Recreation European Exclusive in Gradation Island Blue. The dial is stunning and the contrast when on a white strap is to die for. I will get my hands on one from AMZWATCH
Yes, I have bought from MAMACOO more than once. I even bought a new Omega Speedmaster which came with the fancy box and packaging. I am thrilled with all my purchases here. I would purchase from MAMACOO again for sure.
I have the 0617, and I wouldn't trade it for any of the new ones. I have no idea if they are better, but I love the 0617!
Nice video as always! But for someone who is looking to buy these watches, maybe this year, one should take a look at the new Citizen proposals. Some of them punch quite a bit above their price. The alpinist is ok just beware of the golden pvd one, mine got some tarnish / discoloration with very little use.
Undecided, so I bought both this week. Opted for 42mm on the Murph, because I have the wrist for it and it's the same size as in the movie.
wish Seiko made a premium SRPJ lineup with the quality of the Alpinist
I was thinking about this, then I got the Cooper instead
Hey Teddy, would love to see you redo the watch collection for every type of collector in a certain budget videos, with all the new releases since I think it would be very interesting to see your picks
I had this dilema for a while, in the end decided to buy a non-compass Alpinist during a trip to Japan, ended up buying the green Laurel reinterpretation as it was the only one I found after visiting four Seiko boutiques. Since the Murph is still pulling me, I may get it someday and then I think it's better I got the Laurel and not a Baby Alpinist as it is more distinct from the Murph.
Does the Murph crystal have AR ? I've experienced most of their field watches being pretty hard to read, kind of blury.
I'd also love the Murph 38 coming with a proper deep black dial
Im new to watches and found this guy to be amazing.
Been considering these two for a while to put between my Kamasu (on NATO strap), which I use a lot when swimming, and Bambino V2, which is good for dressy occasions. For everyday stuff I've been wearing Bulova 96B140 on a leather strap, which looks great, but I wanted an automatic watch in that segment.
By the way, I love that there are such nice candidates in this price range. I mentioned my Kamasu. It's a fantastic watch for the price and I've been swimming with it in bunch of different places around the world in the past few years that I've owned it -- zero issues. On my recent trip, while swimming at a hotel pool, I accidentally scraped it against one of the concrete sides of the pool, and it now has some slight scratches. Not noticeable, unless you know about them, and it was a bit of a downer in the moment, but not a huge deal in the longrun, especially since I didn't spend many thousands on it. I've been considering a Rolex or Tudor for a while, but incidents like that remind me why it may not be a good idea.
As someone with an 8 in wrist, bring on the 42 mm Murph! I believe I’ll be picking it up in the near months ahead.
Man tough match up! Love both watches, and hope to own them both. But I’m just more drawn to the Alpinist, but maybe not the green dial. Love both
I went with “Why not both?” although, I chose the 42mm Murph. I’ve got 9” wrists, so it’s not offensively sized and I like the “eureka” second hand.
The Alpinist has a unique problem, in that it looks good on so many straps, I rotate between red pinstripe on olive nato, silver half moon bead bracelet with gold accents, a red tinge espresso crocodile or a forest green lizard. It just works with whatever you throw at it.
Thank you for making high quality videos!Love amzwatch ’s watches
When people are saying MAMACOO is a better option for buying a watch,I very much agree!
I literally just went to get the Alpinist yesterday. Genuinely beautiful watch but I have to admit the proportions of the case and dial felt off. The compass element encroached on the dial and once I had it on it completely confirmed the the Hamilton Is the way to go. Preference is the 38mm with the black dial and brown band. I haven’t got it yet but will soon.
Just purchased a Murph. It’s my first collectors watch. Looking forward to being able to give it to my kid someday. Got any tips for breaking in the leather strap? It doesn’t seem to be the most comfortable.
Alpinist is a clear win for me!
Definitely more versatile than the murph!
I debated buying the spb121 for months, but wound up going with an sbej005 because I don't like the cyclops. This thing is like 2 inches thick, and it runs +20 seconds per day, but it's still somehow my favorite watch because the dial is just SO GOOD
I love them both. alpinist with green dial and gold indices. but the Murph is minimalist which I like.