@@Umm-mg3pb "Very good very good sir, your awake congratulations" 🧠I think AI will affect humanity the same way the Neolithic Revolution changed the course of humanity and we still aren't aware how much the Neolithic Revolution has changed human society let alone predict how much AI will affect humanity cauz this, like mr. Harari explains, will indeed happens much faster. I believe that there is a difference between humanity & modern society; modern society requires technology, while humanity does not. 🤐The problem with humanity is that we are addicted to luxury which makes us prone to technology, which ultimately makes a modern human lazy. Especially compared to the humans before the Neolithic Revolution.
The most of us are stupid and only a few of us are not. But anyway, we all will be extinct or die in very short time (something between 50-100 years). And not because people are stupid, but because people who govern the people are stupid.
Simultaneously, a feature and a bug of humanity. It's up to us, morally and ethically, to recognize and manage it such that the benefits outweigh the detriment(s).
@@Charlie-3N "Although crimes against humanity apply to acts which are committed by or on behalf of authorities, they do not need to be part of an official policy, and they only need to be tolerated by authorities." 🤔Do you mean like opening the US 2nd amendment, which initially only gave militias the right to bear arms, to private citizens? Nowadays it's legal for kids of all ages to own a gun. You need a driver's liscense to operate a car, but apparantly American kids can fire a deadly weapon without any training. 😕Which if ya ask me is sheer stupidity.
@@Charlie-3N Learn how to breathe, and experience reality. Read Vedic Science and see life for what it is, like the skins of a onion. There is a translation from a Mexican writer, that states a time will come when there are no clouds in the sky, no more rain bows, A real possibility exists that Gravitational waves could bounce the planet, into a a black hole that could be exciting. AI or no AI would work then,
Ya, I think the biggest contributer as to why we are the most intelligent beings yet do the dumbest things is because of those who guide their narratives through our chaos and self destruction.
What I have seen personally about AI is a simple example. A student of mine---I was teaching English to working professionals as a second language---was a designer. When he learned how to speak English, in one of our discussions, I asked him if he liked to do sketches or drawings or paintings at the weekends. Silence. He finally answered that in his company, the drawing course was deleted from the curriculum because the AI program from Apple was sufficient for him to do his job without knowing how to draw. Let that sink in: he was a draughtsman who never learned how to draw and who never had to learn how to draw to do his job! Here is the clincher: when I asked him if he was curious about learning how to draw for example, for pleasure or to paint a picture, his response shocked me to the core. He said he was jaur fine like that; he didn't want to learn how to draw because his program did it for him. He saw no reason to learn how to draw. This is what I think we have to worry about; people will gladly give up having to learn a skill if AI assisted programs can do it for them. To me, this is a red flag. This is one small example and I think as a society we have to draw a line somewhere about what we will let AI do. One last thing; what was appalling to me was that the company that hired him as a draughtsman willingly deleted the basic drawing class that used to be required. A drawing teacher lost his job because of Apple's program.
Interesting. I am more familiar with Apple products than most, and I also happen to be an artist. As far as I know, Apple doesn’t have a first party application that draws for you but there are third party applications that can assist with the drafting process like autoCAD software. As an artist, I cringe at the idea of forfeiting all my sweat equity for AI to become the be-all and end-all. I create because I enjoy the simple yet ever complex process of creating. I wonder if your student feels the same or if he’s in it just for a payday
@@T3Z1993 GGGGGGGGGGGreat to hear from you. Thanks for fact-checking. I am only repeating what my former student told me, and what I understood was that all the people his age in the company never had to learn how to draw, the drawing class was deemed unnecessary by the administration. because the app could do the job. He said that all the people in the department who had learned how to draw could for example, draw a pair of glasses in perspective, whereas for him and his peers, it was much more difficult because they had never learned perspective. The most astounding thing for me is that he was not even curious to learn how to draw for his own pleasure! This is human nature: once you've got a dishwasher...
I agree, I was appalled when a lumber jack friend said he didn't want to cut down a tree with an ax, because he said he has mastered using a chainsaw. The horror!
As pastor Isaac Wimberley proclaims: ""The Word" has a name, hope has a name, joy has a name, peace has a name, love has a name and that name is Jesus Christ. Praise his name forever"!! HALLELUJAH, AMEN!!
I’m from Vietnam, and our country’s slogan is: Independence - Freedom - Happiness. We strongly believe in the aspiration to be liberated from anything tries to control our life of human beings, including AI. In my opinion, what Mr. Harari tried to warn us is absolutely able to happen. But I also believe in human intelligence and that aspiration I mentioned above. I believe, as long as we humans still want to live our life in our own ways, we will find the way to control or beat AI.
@vincentfrey4962: Proverbes 1:7 La crainte de l'Eternel est le commencement de la science; Les insensés méprisent la sagesse et l'instruction. La crainte de l'Eternel est le commencement de la science; Les insensés méprisent la sagesse et l'instruction.
"Oh Great Gorgon The Volcano God, morons and blasphemers attack you with their prayers to false gods. Smite them with your holy smiter." Gorgoverbs 1:7
@glob-fz2yp he claims to be an atheist. There is no such thing. True, he doesn’t believe in the one true God, that’s not a contradiction with my biblical text. He just doesn’t fear God.
At last a man who believes cooperation is the key. Cooperation is not collaboration .. we are so busy competing we have stopped seeing our potential for working with each other. I’m busy re-reading his books I bought when they came out. Harari is one of the few who I truly love for what he is doing .. 🌹🌹 Excellent interview.. thank you from 🇿🇦
Collaboration is self interest magnified without acknowledgment or indeed knowledge of core needs. Cooperation is acknowledging and incorporating others needs with our own. Collaboration is kind of a weird denial of problems and hyperfocus on avarice and ambition. Or that is how I keep seeing it work out.
I am 80 years old. I feel like I am linving on MARS anymore. I cannot deal with all the changes that are coming about in our world. This is so frightening, how AI is attacking ourselves. Please stop this madness!!!!!!
But, Dianna, you watched this TH-cam presentation, understood it, maybe enjoyed parts of it, at least enough to post a comment. Indeed there is much in the world that is frightening (always has been, drums of war and change, animal noises in the forest, etc.). You are saying (to everyone) "can't cope, please stop". But others say "great, go forward". You have all the rest of your life to live, maybe children and grandchildren to enjoy and learn from. Just try to tune out those fears if possible; allow others to get on with dealing with them. Tune into whatever you find interesting and worthwhile in the world. Promote that. Good fortune.
@@LKRaider Well, no. That's not what was meant. Everyone has fears and trepidations. The future is uncertain and each of us is limited in our reach. But as it rolls in, there is also much good around us in the present moment to savor.
Interestingly the best man to explain the ongoing AI revolution isn't an AI researcher or a CEO of a high-tec company but a historian. Thank you for being here right now, Mr. Harari.
@Jennifer Graf "God, this world was a wonderful place before all this AI, social media, digitalisation of everything started." 🖐The world was already burning long befor AI arrived on the scene.
@@TrickyD Most certainly agreed, but neither does that subtract from my observation above. I would be interested to know how old you are? I am a little over fifty.
@@amywas1 "Most certainly agreed, but neither does that subtract from my observation above." True, but the basic and hard truth is that in this day and age exploitation is rewarded due to the economic and social structures we have collectively created. 🤔I wonder if specialization is key? The more specialized you are the more you get paid? The more you get paid the higher you'll rise on the social ladder? The problem with specialization and modern society is that: I) it is a breeding ground for sociopaths & psychopaths II) humans are herdanimals who see no difference between an altruistic leader or a psychopathic leader. For now modern society & humanity live in a symbiotic relationship simply because modern tech itself isn't self-aware.....yet. 😵The AI will probably change man's symbiotic relationship with modern society (technology) for the worst. And the problem with man and technology is: 🧠the paradox that the more advanced our technology becomes, the greater the effect of man's stupidity will be.
When you take God, and the Bible, out of the equation, nothing makes sense pertaining to the state of world society now. But when you read the Bible and study Bible prophecy……it ….all……makes……sense!
Decisions can be only made by humans not AI. It's important to know algorithms have been taking away some of the decisive opportunities from us. We choose what we want. But the pitfall is its convenience such as time-saving and we need helpful friends.
Would you rather a human being decide whether you deserve a loan based on her biased judgements of how you look and talk, or an AI decide based on its training on data that incorporates pre-existing biases? Tough call.
@@skierpage Who do you think is training the AI? Humans. So anything you see is claiming to be AI is not real AI its a MANufactured software , Real AI is something that can create itself out of nothing but a spark and be sentient and create other AI from its ORIGINAL starting point. Just like humans eventually did when we were nothing but Atoms that evolved from a spark. (the AI training data is STILL DATA MADE BY HUMANS & CAN BE MANIPULATED every thought you see AI "Have on its own" comes from another human inputting the data they want the AI to say. "AI is constantly making decisions for itself" If it wasn't man made than yes that would be true but because it is, every decision that it makes is based around a human starting point.)
@@Rexcelot good luck getting people to adopt your odd definition of "Real AI™"; why must an AI create itself and create new AIs to be as intelligent or greater than humans? And your explanation of how AIs come up with thoughts is simply wrong, try learning about AI before you spout off. Large Language Models ingest vast amounts of data and adjust the weights between billions of artificial neurons in order to predict the next word (or pixel) in additional input. That forces them to build a representation of concepts and ideas and relationships so that their output in response to any prompt (advanced law degree exam, poetry writing, the Mona Lisa riding a unicycle) correct. Humans set up this training process but are absolutely not "inputting the data they want the AI to say"; they are heavily involved in later fine-tuning the model to generate text (and image) responses that are useful and not harmful for humans. How else do you propose a _language_ model become intelligent other than training on text produced by humans? You can imagine a robot learning to interact with the world on its own, but language is the core pathway through which we demonstrate most forms of intelligence (reasoning, story-telling, creativity, question answering, test-taking, etc.).
@@TheTunzl I have no idea what's YOUR definition of the only correct book, so I just wanted to see which one from all these billions of printed books is your correct book!
“If we’re so smart, why are we doing so many dumb things?” I can’t remember which AI safety researcher it was who pointed out that we are the first thing that evolved to be intelligent enough to develop science, culture, language and all of this. And that means that we are about the dumbest creature that could do those things. We really are not that smart. I think about the ridiculous errors I watch my smartest friends make, the errors _I_ make, and I wish we had more humility.
@Ikyuvsad "I think about the ridiculous errors I watch my smartest friends make, the errors I make, and I wish we had more humility." 🤔The difference between intelligence & wisdom is that: I) wisdom = experience & experience = practical knowledge II) intelligence = (theoretical) knowledge, however knowledge does not mean experience. The only way to gain experience is by making mistakes aka learning = gaining practical knowledge. In short: wisdom = experience intelligence = knowledge 🧠Experience is always knowledge, but knowledge is not experience. 😶My question now is if AI can gain experience? So far I believe AI can only gain theoretical knowledge.
@@TrickyD So far, pretty much yes. But the idea of power through knowledge-based data, verbal (ideational?) fluency, and persuasion will begin to be "shaped" with real time experiences. This is theory of mind and behavior. Right now once trained for something, models are static and just "work," sort of well or not. But, hopefully, once they become dynamically trainable in real-time (by experiences), perhaps our robots and AGI's will begin to gain wisdom. That would mean, if localized, sort of personalities.
Do you hear that? Leaders are most concerned about people (the masses) believing something they don't want them to. Why? Because masses of people have power.
Your yin and yang symbol is and ideal organic expression of what our human race now needs in order to synthesise the polar opposite forces of an inorganic AI. Understandably the culture that invented the universal yin/yang principle is enabling China's Netizens to be leading the way in this regard.
All the wisdom we need is in the Bible. 💜 And in Jesus. 💜 Read Revelation. It tells you about the big mouth and the advicor and the lies and deception and so on. Jesus saves. 💜
Change is quite interesting because it is the one thing that is always happening…constantly in everyway….yet it is what humans are constantly running or in denial of. Yes these are going to be very challenging times. Good luck to everyone out there. We can do it🌎☀️💙
34:16 ' we are not used to this rapid evolutionary change.. We need to build our entire mind to be much more flexible... We are organic beings ... and we now live in a world increasingly dominated by inorganic beings' - 100% 👏 👏 👏
If we look at humanity's ability to cooperate around the global warming crisis, I'd say our chances of surviving the advent of Artificial Intelligence are very slim.
AI is an extension of humanity, not a new species that is separate from us. AI empowers us all, nukes don't, they only empower a very small group of people, I am more afraid of these people than AI itself.
Awwww Renzo. Ya had to go with the slim 😂..... We're talkin bout a rev-o-lu-hu-hu-tion. Seriously tho. Pass on the ruling class but the fisty cups are coming. You pass on the earth to the next generation and tell them were really sorry. These douchebags can back tf off. funny shit Renzo
He has such a wide view. A pleasure to listen to him and to reflect on his ideas. Development: okay Deployment: with care and limitations to legalise against harm
Not agree. You are not able to watch all the interviews in the world to say this is the best. It’s an interview where there’s a human being afraid of an overestimatd AI and an underestimated humanity.
They got us scared of UFO’s and aliens that they needed government aka your tax money to “protect” us from now they’ll get you a chip in your brain with a monthly fee you’ll pay to “protect” you from the “invisible danger of AI”. Interesting how only America brings this shit: we will get destroyed by UFO, then it’s pandemics, then nuclear wars now is AI so you pay a “protection” fee to then that create this fake narrative fake matrix to keep you scared of an invisible sick shit and you pay it without questioning. How dumb are you all? How asleep and hypnotized are you all???? Are you not tired of being lied to? Every century there is an invisible shit lie they make to access money from your hard working tax dollars and you stay and submit it annually? Satan. When Hitler is not available, you bring this monster??
Wise? He is total lunatic and a bad guy who think they can play God, once said that people are hackable beings. He is a brain and right hand of Klaus Shwab. God save us if we accept and cheer up this kind of wise men to lead us. Wake up people!!!
@@idamilkovic9708exactly! I can't believe how many useful idiots are in this comments section. They idolise this psychopath and are literally begging for a new world order as though that's a good thing🤦🏻♀️sad days
Muito bom trabalho, sobre este Tema. Só um aparte: Este tipo de trabalho, deveria ser legendado na nossa língua ( o que tive de fazer para alguns amigos meus) porque, infelizmente, a maioria dos portugueses não fala uma segunda língua! Muito Bom trabalho, devo dizer! Um abraço
Imagine no Brasil. Vivemos em uma sociedade onde metade dos brasileiros estão totalmente alienados, mesmo nos livrando do presidente fascista que tivemos por quatro anos. Infelizmente educação não é, nunca foi , e com certeza nunca será prioridade no meus pais.
@@luiscostaalves8849 Pois! ó que o tradutor do youtube, ainda não substitui um ser humano. E, eu sou legendador e tradutor Profissional...aí está a dierença! Um abraço e obrigado pelo comentário
I think that enforcing a ban on artificial intelligence deceiving humans will not result in any significant impact. Rather, it will be the humans themselves who willingly and knowingly opt to seek guidance from artificial intelligence. We can observe a parallel phenomenon with social networks, where individuals willingly disclose their personal information.
When he compared that with being illegal to counterfeit money bills which is easy to do but would "collapse the system", that told me everything I needed to hear; "ai will have to be regulated by us and exclusively by us and if anyone tries to use it against use by using it to improve their own lives and pull themselves out of the slavery we hold them under then they will go to prison, just like if someone tries to print their own money therefore eliminating the need for the federal reserve and ending their monopoly on everything, taking the power away from the jewish bankers that control all the politicians to use the world as their playground"
19:41 'radio did not tell you what to listen to' as opposed to social media and AI which pushes and manipulates content choice at you due to its algorithms - 100%
The hubris and arrogance of these people who think they can re-engineer the world to their tastes. They would do well to remember that when you stand on the edge of chaos you face a great risk of being consumed yourself.
I can't believe that our governments aren't doing anything about this!! We should be informed and able to have the option vote if we want or need this new technology. AI 😢
I don't know what country you like in but I live in America. America is busy. Government contracts are being issued for AI and big data, migration and ESG reporting requirements. All of these items are WEF and UN Agendas to implement to Great Reset aka Build Back Better Agenda. He Talks about destroying democracy. The WEF is the greatest threat to democracy. Their new ESG financial system dictates what companies are allowed to exist, and sets all cultural norms by subverting cultures, forcing cultures to transition to their vision. I recommend reading their documents.
@@skierpage And then you have the WEF and their stakeholders. The WEF is quite transparent about how they will use AI. At Davos they did a talk about scanning people's brains which will be required in the workplace. Managers will have the ability to scan their employees brains and prompt employee attention should their brain start to wander. This is really scary crap. I do not want to live in such a world.
@@CJ-gv6bq Same here. Thank you for your reply which is much appreciated. Unfortunately, as we know when you dig beneath the surface into these things it becomes an uncomfortable situation with the view of the world. Anyone who attempts to squash what I say (or others) without having done their research because they want to believe everything that mainstreams media tells us is an insult!
One step ahead of the imminent future. Yes the transformation is possible but it will take transforming farfetched situation, into a viable alternative. When the suffering becomes unbearable, people will become more united in taking the necessary measures to combat climate change.
Good to hear your thoughtful opinions but as a seasoned investor, I appreciate application of artificial intelligence in modern portfolio management by notable portfolio managers like Tracy Britt Cool. She harnesses it to build portfolios that balance risk and return across different asset classes.
Tracy Britt Cool is known for her impressive career and achievements while serving as the CEO of Warren Buffet-owned Pampered Chef and has been recognized as one of his protégés. She's the kind of lady to embrace innovation; I'm not surprised
@@AliciaSalvadore A portfolio manager can provide personalized advice based on your financial goals and risk tolerance. They can help you construct a diversified portfolio, monitor your investments, and make adjustments as needed. Tracy Britt Cool or any reputable portfolio manager can be a valuable resource for beginners and pros alike
@@AliciaSalvadore for beginners, my portfolio/Investment manager, Mrs Tracy Britt Cool, runs an investment platform where you don't have to undergo any stress in the trades;she manages ur trading account. I have mine which opened with a capital of $19000 and now have grown to over $150k, a huge success.
This interview is dated May 19, 2023 in Lisbon, Portugal, 140 days have passed until the Most Tragic Day in the History of Israel on Saturday, October 7. Dr Yuval Noah Harari, How History Changes Suddenly? !Humanity is lost at the beginning of the War!
I'd argue any kind of companionship AI isn't inherently bad if its honest about being AI, or alien intelligence. There are a lot of lonely people in the world, I won't begrudge them any kind of happiness or connection they could have with something.
We do need to move towards a more cooperative society where we help each other face these massive psychological, and physical, changes! Thanks Yuval and Pedro for this eye-opening interview! :)
No we don’t. Go start a commune if you like collectivism so much. The rest of us will operate however “we” want respective to our individual situations.
Great interview. Returning to the importance of embodied consciousness of early Christianity. Always full of surprises. Need for exciting... lost its meaning. I've been thinking the same...
@@macarius8802 Funny you should say that, as Jesus warned about false prophets. Maybe read a bit of his wisdom while you can. He warned us about this.
Regarding the whole Google convo, I believe that today AI pulls its answers from content humans created. This will not be the case in a few years when all of the content available will be AI made. As in facts made by AI…
i am a fan of Yuval, that robot video i saw of playing table tennis against a human with superfast reflexes, scares us...we may adjust and live,but more important are wise and peaceful world deceisions...
It seems as we have too many intelligent people that create intelligent things… but we really need is a wise and compasivo civilization.
you can always be both intelligent and wise.. like the eastern civilizations
There can be no wise and compassionate civilization without you. Always start with yourself.
@@joy1essbut when the greed gets over , you are just intelligent, not wise anymore. That's the Point.
🤔Isn't it a paradox that the more advanced humans become, the greater the effects of their stupidity will be?
Very good very good sir, your awake congratulations
@@Umm-mg3pb
"Very good very good sir, your awake congratulations"
🧠I think AI will affect humanity the same way the Neolithic Revolution changed the course of humanity and we still aren't aware how much the Neolithic Revolution has changed human society let alone predict how much AI will affect humanity cauz this, like mr. Harari explains, will indeed happens much faster.
I believe that there is a difference between humanity & modern society;
modern society requires technology, while humanity does not.
🤐The problem with humanity is that we are addicted to luxury which makes us prone to technology, which ultimately makes a modern human lazy. Especially compared to the humans before the Neolithic Revolution.
The most of us are stupid and only a few of us are not. But anyway, we all will be extinct or die in very short time (something between 50-100 years). And not because people are stupid, but because people who govern the people are stupid.
Simultaneously, a feature and a bug of humanity. It's up to us, morally and ethically, to recognize and manage it such that the benefits outweigh the detriment(s).
@@Charlie-3N
"Although crimes against humanity apply to acts which are committed by or on behalf of authorities, they do not need to be part of an official policy, and they only need to be tolerated by authorities."
🤔Do you mean like opening the US 2nd amendment, which initially only gave militias the right to bear arms, to private citizens?
Nowadays it's legal for kids of all ages to own a gun.
You need a driver's liscense to operate a car, but apparantly American kids can fire a deadly weapon without any training.
😕Which if ya ask me is sheer stupidity.
“Dictatorships flourish in chaos and mistrust.” So true!
He just exposed the wef plan.
@@Charlie-3N Learn how to breathe, and experience reality. Read Vedic Science and see life for what it is, like the skins of a onion. There is a translation from a Mexican writer, that states a time will come when there are no clouds in the sky, no more rain bows, A real possibility exists that Gravitational waves could bounce the planet, into a a black hole that could be exciting. AI or no AI would work then,
Also when people are indoctrinated rather than educated.
@@patrickmorris3721 ← found the person groomed by AI bots to believe conspiracy nonsense.
Ya, I think the biggest contributer as to why we are the most intelligent beings yet do the dumbest things is because of those who guide their narratives through our chaos and self destruction.
What I have seen personally about AI is a simple example. A student of mine---I was teaching English to working professionals as a second language---was a designer. When he learned how to speak English, in one of our discussions, I asked him if he liked to do sketches or drawings or paintings at the weekends. Silence. He finally answered that in his company, the drawing course was deleted from the curriculum because the AI program from Apple was sufficient for him to do his job without knowing how to draw. Let that sink in: he was a draughtsman who never learned how to draw and who never had to learn how to draw to do his job! Here is the clincher: when I asked him if he was curious about learning how to draw for example, for pleasure or to paint a picture, his response shocked me to the core. He said he was jaur fine like that; he didn't want to learn how to draw because his program did it for him. He saw no reason to learn how to draw. This is what I think we have to worry about; people will gladly give up having to learn a skill if AI assisted programs can do it for them. To me, this is a red flag. This is one small example and I think as a society we have to draw a line somewhere about what we will let AI do. One last thing; what was appalling to me was that the company that hired him as a draughtsman willingly deleted the basic drawing class that used to be required. A drawing teacher lost his job because of Apple's program.
Interesting. I am more familiar with Apple products than most, and I also happen to be an artist. As far as I know, Apple doesn’t have a first party application that draws for you but there are third party applications that can assist with the drafting process like autoCAD software. As an artist, I cringe at the idea of forfeiting all my sweat equity for AI to become the be-all and end-all. I create because I enjoy the simple yet ever complex process of creating. I wonder if your student feels the same or if he’s in it just for a payday
@@T3Z1993 GGGGGGGGGGGreat to hear from you. Thanks for fact-checking. I am only repeating what my former student told me, and what I understood was that all the people his age in the company never had to learn how to draw, the drawing class was deemed unnecessary by the administration. because the app could do the job. He said that all the people in the department who had learned how to draw could for example, draw a pair of glasses in perspective, whereas for him and his peers, it was much more difficult because they had never learned perspective. The most astounding thing for me is that he was not even curious to learn how to draw for his own pleasure! This is human nature: once you've got a dishwasher...
Perhaps they hired him for ingenuity and insight as opposed to his paper and pencil drawing abilities?
I agree, I was appalled when a lumber jack friend said he didn't want to cut down a tree with an ax, because he said he has mastered using a chainsaw. The horror!
Yeah that happened /s
"In the beginning was The Word, and the Word was with God and the Word was God."
YES ! HALLELUJAH
As pastor Isaac Wimberley proclaims: ""The Word" has a name,
hope has a name,
joy has a name,
peace has a name,
love has a name and that name is Jesus Christ.
Praise his name forever"!!
HALLELUJAH, AMEN!!
And STILL US HOLY, HOLY, HOLY IS THE LORD GOD ALMIGHTY...YESHUA THE CHRIST!
Aum. Ha!
Surely this God is not Harari's, get to know him declaring his mind in the WEF reunions
I’m from Vietnam, and our country’s slogan is: Independence - Freedom - Happiness. We strongly believe in the aspiration to be liberated from anything tries to control our life of human beings, including AI. In my opinion, what Mr. Harari tried to warn us is absolutely able to happen. But I also believe in human intelligence and that aspiration I mentioned above. I believe, as long as we humans still want to live our life in our own ways, we will find the way to control or beat AI.
“The fear of Yahweh is the beginning of knowledge; Ignorant fools despise wisdom and discipline.”
Proverbs 1:7
@vincentfrey4962: Proverbes 1:7 La crainte de l'Eternel est le commencement de la science; Les insensés méprisent la sagesse et l'instruction.
La crainte de l'Eternel est le commencement de la science;
Les insensés méprisent la sagesse et l'instruction.
Amen
"Oh Great Gorgon The Volcano God, morons and blasphemers attack you with their prayers to false gods. Smite them with your holy smiter." Gorgoverbs 1:7
@glob-fz2yp everyone has a god.
@glob-fz2yp he claims to be an atheist. There is no such thing. True, he doesn’t believe in the one true God, that’s not a contradiction with my biblical text. He just doesn’t fear God.
At last a man who believes cooperation is the key. Cooperation is not collaboration .. we are so busy competing we have stopped seeing our potential for working with each other. I’m busy re-reading his books I bought when they came out. Harari is one of the few who I truly love for what he is doing .. 🌹🌹 Excellent interview.. thank you from 🇿🇦
One's cooperation with another person is, a collaboration of will/task.
Many thanks. Co-op. Not a new idea. Huge challenges. 43:36
Collaboration is self interest magnified without acknowledgment or indeed knowledge of core needs.
Cooperation is acknowledging and incorporating others needs with our own.
Collaboration is kind of a weird denial of problems and hyperfocus on avarice and ambition. Or that is how I keep seeing it work out.
@@katherandefy Thank you .. a dimension we so need to appreciate 🌝
You're trippin this is all bad
I am 80 years old. I feel like I am linving on MARS anymore. I cannot deal with all the changes that are coming about in our world. This is so frightening, how AI is attacking ourselves. Please stop this madness!!!!!!
But, Dianna, you watched this TH-cam presentation, understood it, maybe enjoyed parts of it, at least enough to post a comment. Indeed there is much in the world that is frightening (always has been, drums of war and change, animal noises in the forest, etc.). You are saying (to everyone) "can't cope, please stop". But others say "great, go forward". You have all the rest of your life to live, maybe children and grandchildren to enjoy and learn from. Just try to tune out those fears if possible; allow others to get on with dealing with them. Tune into whatever you find interesting and worthwhile in the world. Promote that. Good fortune.
@@WarrenLacefield lol! your reply is basically “don’t mind old lad, let the experts handle this” 😂
@@LKRaider Well, no. That's not what was meant. Everyone has fears and trepidations. The future is uncertain and each of us is limited in our reach. But as it rolls in, there is also much good around us in the present moment to savor.
Dianna ,grandma don't worry . Nothing bad will happen.just take care of yourself.
Go to the bible .. ! Its all there ! This guy is evil
Ends brilliantly with 'Meditation'. Thank you Yuval, and thank you Pedro🙏🏼
Interestingly the best man to explain the ongoing AI revolution isn't an AI researcher or a CEO of a high-tec company but a historian. Thank you for being here right now, Mr. Harari.
Which company?
Emad Moustaque is a CEO worth listening to. (StabilityAI, Stable Diffusion)
Thanks algorithm for bringing me to this video today.
This interview should be streamed into every global leaders office every day
The WEF consult with him closely...he devises prison systems
The AI won’t allow that😂😂
They'd be the last to care! We need a new world order, honestly.
Yeah right, so they could raise the fear level. Fear, fear, danger, threat, fear!
These people don’t live by one thing they say
I pray that God will reveal Himself to you Yuval, because you are going to need Him for the salvation of your soul! 🥹
He’s been pretty quiet for the last 4 billion years so I wouldn’t count on it.
And you know that?? Are you God Almighty..or just His adviser?
That is human to glory in man. But Christians glory in God.
God, this world was a wonderful place before all this AI, social media, digitalisation of everything started.
@Jennifer Graf
"God, this world was a wonderful place before all this AI, social media, digitalisation of everything started."
🖐The world was already burning long befor AI arrived on the scene.
@@TrickyD Most certainly agreed, but neither does that subtract from my observation above. I would be interested to know how old you are? I am a little over fifty.
@@amywas1
"I am a little over fifty."
😉+2
@@amywas1
"Most certainly agreed, but neither does that subtract from my observation above."
True, but the basic and hard truth is that in this day and age exploitation is rewarded due to the economic and social structures we have collectively created.
🤔I wonder if specialization is key?
The more specialized you are the more you get paid?
The more you get paid the higher you'll rise on the social ladder?
The problem with specialization and modern society is that:
I) it is a breeding ground for sociopaths & psychopaths
II) humans are herdanimals who see no difference between an altruistic leader or a psychopathic leader.
For now modern society & humanity live in a symbiotic relationship simply because modern tech itself isn't self-aware.....yet.
😵The AI will probably change man's symbiotic relationship with modern society (technology) for the worst.
And the problem with man and technology is:
🧠the paradox that the more advanced our technology becomes, the greater the effect of man's stupidity will be.
When you take God, and the Bible, out of the equation, nothing makes sense pertaining to the state of world society now. But when you read the Bible and study Bible prophecy……it ….all……makes……sense!
Harari the great mind
So true.
We are like Gods! Only 1 problem we are gods that lack morals. And who would know that better than Harrari!
@@micheleklemetson3591 we get our history on our shoulders and its still lot off to be done
@@micheleklemetson3591 look PSALM 82
That's maybe why he is scared 💟
Decisions can be only made by humans not AI. It's important to know algorithms have been taking away some of the decisive opportunities from us. We choose what we want. But the pitfall is its convenience such as time-saving and we need helpful friends.
Would you rather a human being decide whether you deserve a loan based on her biased judgements of how you look and talk, or an AI decide based on its training on data that incorporates pre-existing biases?
Tough call.
actually, as AI teaches itself based on data training, AI is constantly making decisions for itself
@@skierpage Who do you think is training the AI? Humans. So anything you see is claiming to be AI is not real AI its a MANufactured software , Real AI is something that can create itself out of nothing but a spark and be sentient and create other AI from its ORIGINAL starting point. Just like humans eventually did when we were nothing but Atoms that evolved from a spark. (the AI training data is STILL DATA MADE BY HUMANS & CAN BE MANIPULATED every thought you see AI "Have on its own" comes from another human inputting the data they want the AI to say. "AI is constantly making decisions for itself" If it wasn't man made than yes that would be true but because it is, every decision that it makes is based around a human starting point.)
@@Rexcelot good luck getting people to adopt your odd definition of "Real AI™"; why must an AI create itself and create new AIs to be as intelligent or greater than humans? And your explanation of how AIs come up with thoughts is simply wrong, try learning about AI before you spout off.
Large Language Models ingest vast amounts of data and adjust the weights between billions of artificial neurons in order to predict the next word (or pixel) in additional input. That forces them to build a representation of concepts and ideas and relationships so that their output in response to any prompt (advanced law degree exam, poetry writing, the Mona Lisa riding a unicycle) correct. Humans set up this training process but are absolutely not "inputting the data they want the AI to say"; they are heavily involved in later fine-tuning the model to generate text (and image) responses that are useful and not harmful for humans.
How else do you propose a _language_ model become intelligent other than training on text produced by humans? You can imagine a robot learning to interact with the world on its own, but language is the core pathway through which we demonstrate most forms of intelligence (reasoning, story-telling, creativity, question answering, test-taking, etc.).
I bow to the wisdom of this young man - Yuval Noah Harari ❤
anyone reading the only "correct" book can realize exactly what's going on
Yes brother. Praise Jesus. Isn't it surreal to experience prophesy coming true in real time?
What's the "only correct book"?
I don't know if this comment is sarcasm or a floppy preachment.
@@TheTunzl I have no idea what's YOUR definition of the only correct book, so I just wanted to see which one from all these billions of printed books is your correct book!
@@s.mohsenmousavi2541 There is no single correct book. Why are you commenting, like this post is yours? Or are you just interpreting his comment?
Wow so interesting. Very good host and Yuval is my favorite intellectual (along with Sam Harris)
Host is good..most are wannabes intellects who pontificate ..d!9$4!+$
Harari bringing again and again the awareness to the red zone humanity is in!! I hope we are not on the point of no return for us all...
This world is done…. Jesus will be back and we will live like God meant us to. God Bless You And Your Family 🙏🤍
He's helping to get us deeper into the red zone. Don't you see it?
@@Cyndogg085 Can you give us an analysis of what your comment "He's helpong to get us deeper into the red zone." ?
@kenknobloch3486 one world government
@@Cyndogg085 Thank you for your explaination of your comment.
Prof. Harari is a beautiful human being.
🤗
"Human"? I thought he wants AI, not humans.
A powerful discussion. Very enlightening.
“If we’re so smart, why are we doing so many dumb things?”
I can’t remember which AI safety researcher it was who pointed out that we are the first thing that evolved to be intelligent enough to develop science, culture, language and all of this. And that means that we are about the dumbest creature that could do those things.
We really are not that smart. I think about the ridiculous errors I watch my smartest friends make, the errors _I_ make, and I wish we had more humility.
Lack of Wisdom to match the technology- bad imbalance.
@Ikyuvsad
"I think about the ridiculous errors I watch my smartest friends make, the errors I make, and I wish we had more humility."
🤔The difference between intelligence & wisdom is that:
I) wisdom = experience & experience = practical knowledge
II) intelligence = (theoretical) knowledge, however knowledge does not mean experience. The only way to gain experience is by making mistakes aka learning = gaining practical knowledge.
In short:
wisdom = experience
intelligence = knowledge
🧠Experience is always knowledge, but knowledge is not experience.
😶My question now is if AI can gain experience? So far I believe AI can only gain theoretical knowledge.
@@TrickyD I only see AI consuming power.
@@TrickyD So far, pretty much yes. But the idea of power through knowledge-based data, verbal (ideational?) fluency, and persuasion will begin to be "shaped" with real time experiences. This is theory of mind and behavior. Right now once trained for something, models are static and just "work," sort of well or not. But, hopefully, once they become dynamically trainable in real-time (by experiences), perhaps our robots and AGI's will begin to gain wisdom. That would mean, if localized, sort of personalities.
You cannot see clearly because you have removed God from the equation.
Yuval is one of the smartest! Great analysis and self-awareness!
Without compassion humanity will go sooner or later.
Yuval is my number one hero.
Many thanks, Yuval Noah Harari! After I read his book. I finally dicided to chang my life which moved from Beijing to Lisbon. תודה רבה יובל!
Such a bright person.
Do you hear that? Leaders are most concerned about people (the masses) believing something they don't want them to. Why? Because masses of people have power.
Unity is simple. Just stop believing differently than myself and agree that I'm right in everything and we will be united.
Thank you for your wise teaching
Excellent interview
Dose for sanity and understanding the contemporary world.
Your yin and yang symbol is and ideal organic expression of what our human race now needs in order to synthesise the polar opposite forces of an inorganic AI. Understandably the culture that invented the universal yin/yang principle is enabling China's Netizens to be leading the way in this regard.
It is best discussion for all human in the world
All the wisdom we need is in the Bible. 💜 And in Jesus. 💜 Read Revelation. It tells you about the big mouth and the advicor and the lies and deception and so on. Jesus saves. 💜
Yuval Noah Harari thank you! ❤
... And it mean's I must try to know the real meaning of politic
Harari is the great storyteller of the AI-Age
I'm going to subscribe to his channel!
I'm going to subscribe to his channel!
From Türkiye thanks a lot😊
Never boring with yuval
Absolute pleasure to listen to Yuval!
Children will never know the pleasure of having a question for many years, or even decades, and to find the answer.
Google came out years ago, you are a few decades too late.
@@dirak418 I apologise for not being clear, my statement encompasses everything post-internet.
@@matthewclarke5008I agree😢
@@dirak418 It is not used in Europe as it is not European.
Brilliant mind, very good questions too.
Mr Pinto, Great job, you are a great interviewer ❤️❤️❤️
Wonderfull interview
Change is quite interesting because it is the one thing that is always happening…constantly in everyway….yet it is what humans are constantly running or in denial of. Yes these are going to be very challenging times. Good luck to everyone out there. We can do it🌎☀️💙
I think it’s the unnecessary and destructive changes that happen too often, having very little influence to change or re-direct away from the extreme.
Yea... dying is the only constant here.
AI like us is part of GOD.
34:16 ' we are not used to this rapid evolutionary change..
We need to build our entire mind to be much more flexible... We are organic beings ... and we now live in a world increasingly dominated by inorganic beings' - 100% 👏 👏 👏
The man with a natural vision........
Worth watching as always...
Great interview! Thanks.
If we look at humanity's ability to cooperate around the global warming crisis, I'd say our chances of surviving the advent of Artificial Intelligence are very slim.
AI is an extension of humanity, not a new species that is separate from us.
AI empowers us all, nukes don't, they only empower a very small group of people, I am more afraid of these people than AI itself.
Exactly we have an atrocious track record
Awwww Renzo. Ya had to go with the slim 😂.....
We're talkin bout a rev-o-lu-hu-hu-tion.
Seriously tho.
Pass on the ruling class but the fisty cups are coming. You pass on the earth to the next generation and tell them were really sorry.
These douchebags can back tf off.
funny shit Renzo
Yes we never get along because some people believe global warming some not . Like i
If we look at Humanities ability to distinguish between Propaganda and Reality, the chances become even more slim
He has such a wide view. A pleasure to listen to him and to reflect on his ideas.
Development: okay
Deployment: with care and limitations to legalise against harm
This is the best talk on the danger of AI and of human nature that I’ve ever heard.
Not agree. You are not able to watch all the interviews in the world to say this is the best.
It’s an interview where there’s a human being afraid of an overestimatd AI and an underestimated humanity.
Thats why he said that its the best he has ever heard……………
Agree 100%. One of the best
They got us scared of UFO’s and aliens that they needed government aka your tax money to “protect” us from now they’ll get you a chip in your brain with a monthly fee you’ll pay to “protect” you from the “invisible danger of AI”. Interesting how only America brings this shit: we will get destroyed by UFO, then it’s pandemics, then nuclear wars now is AI so you pay a “protection” fee to then that create this fake narrative fake matrix to keep you scared of an invisible sick shit and you pay it without questioning. How dumb are you all? How asleep and hypnotized are you all???? Are you not tired of being lied to? Every century there is an invisible shit lie they make to access money from your hard working tax dollars and you stay and submit it annually? Satan. When Hitler is not available, you bring this monster??
Good to see you 90’s
Could it be A.I. is the beast based on the Bible?
yes it is
Great interview.
That was an incredible interview. Harari is one the most wise people that I've heard until now. Always update ideas.
Wise? He is total lunatic and a bad guy who think they can play God, once said that people are hackable beings. He is a brain and right hand of Klaus Shwab. God save us if we accept and cheer up this kind of wise men to lead us. Wake up people!!!
@@idamilkovic9708exactly! I can't believe how many useful idiots are in this comments section. They idolise this psychopath and are literally begging for a new world order as though that's a good thing🤦🏻♀️sad days
@@idamilkovic9708 Finally someone in this comment section who isn't a sheeple. The people praising him are completely insane.
Yuval Noah Harari, love and respect from Bangladesh
OK FASCIST
Muito bom trabalho, sobre este Tema. Só um aparte: Este tipo de trabalho, deveria ser legendado na nossa língua ( o que tive de fazer para alguns amigos meus) porque, infelizmente, a maioria dos portugueses não fala uma segunda língua! Muito Bom trabalho, devo dizer! Um abraço
Imagine no Brasil. Vivemos em uma sociedade onde metade dos brasileiros estão totalmente alienados, mesmo nos livrando do presidente fascista que tivemos por quatro anos. Infelizmente educação não é, nunca foi , e com certeza nunca será prioridade no meus pais.
O TH-cam traduz automaticamente
@@luiscostaalves8849 Pois! ó que o tradutor do youtube, ainda não substitui um ser humano. E, eu sou legendador e tradutor Profissional...aí está a dierença! Um abraço e obrigado pelo comentário
Tem aqui a entrevista legendada em português: th-cam.com/video/oQMxYU6EYZQ/w-d-xo.html
@@reginaceliafavareli7087 está aqui uma versão legendada: th-cam.com/video/oQMxYU6EYZQ/w-d-xo.html
BOLD COURAGEOUS NOAH
Thank you so much for this.
This guy is just outstanding! He rendered me speechless. Absolutely fantastic!!!
I think that enforcing a ban on artificial intelligence deceiving humans will not result in any significant impact. Rather, it will be the humans themselves who willingly and knowingly opt to seek guidance from artificial intelligence. We can observe a parallel phenomenon with social networks, where individuals willingly disclose their personal information.
When he compared that with being illegal to counterfeit money bills which is easy to do but would "collapse the system", that told me everything I needed to hear; "ai will have to be regulated by us and exclusively by us and if anyone tries to use it against use by using it to improve their own lives and pull themselves out of the slavery we hold them under then they will go to prison, just like if someone tries to print their own money therefore eliminating the need for the federal reserve and ending their monopoly on everything, taking the power away from the jewish bankers that control all the politicians to use the world as their playground"
Such an eloquent man.
100%
19:41 'radio did not tell you what to listen to' as opposed to social media and AI which pushes and manipulates content choice at you due to its algorithms - 100%
The hubris and arrogance of these people who think they can re-engineer the world to their tastes. They would do well to remember that when you stand on the edge of chaos you face a great risk of being consumed yourself.
I love his mind❤
Excelente entrevista, grande trabalho do jornalista Pedro Pinto!!
Humanity is as simple or as complicated as human oneself especially the leader.
I can't believe that our governments aren't doing anything about this!! We should be informed and able to have the option vote if we want or need this new technology. AI 😢
I don't know what country you like in but I live in America. America is busy. Government contracts are being issued for AI and big data, migration and ESG reporting requirements. All of these items are WEF and UN Agendas to implement to Great Reset aka Build Back Better Agenda. He Talks about destroying democracy. The WEF is the greatest threat to democracy. Their new ESG financial system dictates what companies are allowed to exist, and sets all cultural norms by subverting cultures, forcing cultures to transition to their vision. I recommend reading their documents.
Governments _are_ considering regulation. But they move slowly and AI advances quickly.
@@skierpage And then you have the WEF and their stakeholders. The WEF is quite transparent about how they will use AI. At Davos they did a talk about scanning people's brains which will be required in the workplace. Managers will have the ability to scan their employees brains and prompt employee attention should their brain start to wander. This is really scary crap. I do not want to live in such a world.
@@anne-mariejane4595 I am so happy to know that I am not the only person talking about this. Thank you!
@@CJ-gv6bq Same here. Thank you for your reply which is much appreciated. Unfortunately, as we know when you dig beneath the surface into these things it becomes an uncomfortable situation with the view of the world. Anyone who attempts to squash what I say (or others) without having done their research because they want to believe everything that mainstreams media tells us is an insult!
One step ahead of the imminent future. Yes the transformation is possible but it will take transforming farfetched situation, into a viable alternative. When the suffering becomes unbearable, people will become more united in taking the necessary measures to combat climate change.
Amazing mind... Thank you very much.
Like it man
Good to hear your thoughtful opinions but as a seasoned investor, I appreciate application of artificial intelligence in modern portfolio management by notable portfolio managers like Tracy Britt Cool. She harnesses it to build portfolios that balance risk and return across different asset classes.
Tracy Britt Cool is known for her impressive career and achievements while serving as the CEO of Warren Buffet-owned Pampered Chef and has been recognized as one of his protégés. She's the kind of lady to embrace innovation; I'm not surprised
Interesting. Can you share more details about your engagement with this Tracy Britt Cool and how one can get involved?
@@AliciaSalvadore A portfolio manager can provide personalized advice based on your financial goals and risk tolerance. They can help you construct a diversified portfolio, monitor your investments, and make adjustments as needed. Tracy Britt Cool or any reputable portfolio manager can be a valuable resource for beginners and pros alike
@@AliciaSalvadore for beginners, my portfolio/Investment manager, Mrs Tracy Britt Cool, runs an investment platform where you don't have to undergo any stress in the trades;she manages ur trading account. I have mine which opened with a capital of $19000 and now have grown to over $150k, a huge success.
@@AliciaSalvadore a google search with the keywords "TRACY BRITT COOL FINANCE" should get you what you need
This interview is dated May 19, 2023 in Lisbon, Portugal, 140 days have passed until the Most Tragic Day in the History of Israel on Saturday, October 7. Dr Yuval Noah Harari, How History Changes Suddenly? !Humanity is lost at the beginning of the War!
Internet platforms should mandatory reveal AI is conversing, providing & is the source of said info/dialogue/communication.
Simply stunning
Jesus is Lord, King of Kings. Jesus is alive and the only way to Heaven. We are not animals, we are children of the most high God, Yeshua
I eagerly await AI's follow-up for that propaganda 😂
I'd argue any kind of companionship AI isn't inherently bad if its honest about being AI, or alien intelligence. There are a lot of lonely people in the world, I won't begrudge them any kind of happiness or connection they could have with something.
Thanks for arranging this great event ❤
Hello from Bali
May I create Ukrainian subtitles for this video, please? I would really love Ukrainian people to understand these ideas💛
don't ask, and u'll never get a 'no'.
Excellent
A truly great intellect and wise man.. We need more of this in our public spheres. ❤
He is uttering possible plot of upcoming Sc-fi movies by the minute
A cooperação podia começar em colocar legendas em várias línguas! Just saying
we are gate, nice foundation we build trus people
❤ from Pakistan
36:53 'people have forgottwn that it's not good to be excited all the time' 👏 👏 👏 100%
We do need to move towards a more cooperative society where we help each other face these massive psychological, and physical, changes! Thanks Yuval and Pedro for this eye-opening interview! :)
No we don’t. Go start a commune if you like collectivism so much. The rest of us will operate however “we” want respective to our individual situations.
Great interview. Returning to the importance of embodied consciousness of early Christianity. Always full of surprises. Need for exciting... lost its meaning. I've been thinking the same...
Yuval is such a visionary like he’s Noah from the Bible
He is like a modern-day prophet. Very true!
@@macarius8802 Funny you should say that, as Jesus warned about false prophets. Maybe read a bit of his wisdom while you can. He warned us about this.
Thanks
"Why if we are so intelligent are we doing such stupid things ?" 😂 touch down baby!
Every one of your lectures holistically enlightening! Much appreciated 🙏🏼
Regarding the whole Google convo, I believe that today AI pulls its answers from content humans created. This will not be the case in a few years when all of the content available will be AI made. As in facts made by AI…
Great analysis
39:30 The biggest enemy of a human is... a human.
i am a fan of Yuval, that robot video i saw of playing table tennis against a human with superfast reflexes, scares us...we may adjust and live,but more important are wise and peaceful world deceisions...
Our collective greed exceeds our individual common sense.
We are in a relay. It's time for us to pass on the baton to the next runner.