I absolutely hate hearing people say, "Taiwanese culture is the true Chinese culture," as if they come to Taiwan just to pursue their fantasy of an authentic China. Temples exist in Japan and Korea too, yet no one says that about them. In reality, Taiwanese culture is a fusion of many influences: Japanese culture, American culture, Southeast Asian culture, and even the indigenous Māori culture from New Zealand. Historically, the Dutch and Spanish also brought various cultural elements to Taiwan, including Catholicism.
I'm not disagreeing with you but there are a few things I have my own opinion on. Chinese culture definitely has a stronger influence on Taiwan than Japanese culture or American culture. Temples in Korea and Japan have been there a lot longer and the culture around them has had enough "time in the oven" to be considered uniquely Japanese or Korean. Also Maori people and other indigenous people around SEA can trace their roots to Taiwan. There are videos about it and I recommend watching them. It's interesting stuff!
Most with little education and ethics like china. We were always taught to be civil/polite unless there is good reason not to. You see this especially with minorities in the US.
In the view from the whole world, Japan is actually a large country in population. While the area of Japan is only smaller than a dozen of big continent countries.
The psychological makeup of the 2 countries is basically day and night. Anyone who has spent an extended period in China will know just how rude and uncaring a large portion of the populace in China can be. It is honestly quite depressing.
@ Universal values are fundamental principles and standards that are widely recognized and upheld across various cultures, societies, and nations, not necessarily from the Bible. For example, honesty and compassion could be considered universal values, and to be honesty I found both of these two to be severely lacking in China.
台灣並不是只有吸收中國文化還有日本文化，其實本土台灣人家庭受到日本文化的影響遠遠勝過中國文化，而有人說台灣是正統中國文化那其實只是他們覺得台灣這部分比較好，他們就把好的部份說成是屬於中國文化的一部份，而且大部分會這樣說的人都是與中國有關聯的人，可能是1949年流亡來台的後代子孫(其實他們早就被台灣文化深深影響但他們卻不認同)或是現在的中國人，他們總是認為台灣的一切都來自於中國，而這是非常荒謬的，原本本土的台灣人好像不存在，本地台灣人也會創造自己的文化，並不是什麼都是中國來的，但中國人數量龐大所以在社群媒體上就都會是中國人說的內容成為多數人閱讀到的。 Taiwan is not just absorbing Chinese culture, but also Japanese culture. In fact, the influence of Japanese culture on local Taiwanese families far exceeds that of Chinese culture. Some people say that Taiwan is authentic Chinese culture, but that is actually because they think that this part of Taiwan is better. The good parts are said to be part of Chinese culture, and most of the people who say this are people who have connections with China, perhaps the descendants of those who fled to Taiwan in 1949 (in fact, they have long been They are deeply influenced by the culture but they do not agree with it) or the Chinese nowadays, they always think that everything in Taiwan comes from China, which is very ridiculous. It seems that the original native Taiwanese do not exist, and the local Taiwanese will also Create your own culture. Not everything comes from China, but the Chinese population is huge so on social media, most people will read what the Chinese say.
台灣在殖民時期確實有受到日本影響，但是一個社會有現今的氛圍，最主要還是受在地人影響，我是覺得台灣人不像日本人那麼注重一些細節上的禮貌，但是我們也對陌生人更友好與和善，可以看成是兩個不同的風土民情了 Taiwanese aren't like Japanese. I mean, there are many differences between our cultures, and I think Taiwanese are kinder to strangers compared to Japanese. We don’t need to be colonized by the Japanese to learn how to treat others nicely.
As a Chinese, I just don't give a ****. That 'don't give a **** ' attitude makes Europeans call Chinese people the Italians or Texans of Asia. It has to do with arrogance, not culture.
My first time living in China I was in a small, rural, countryside town in Jiangxi province. I was inexperienced and all the stares and shouts of "laowai" I didn't consider rude at the time, but it is quite rude really. Even most students at the school I worked at would just say "Hello, Laowai" instead of teacher. People following and watching me in town was weird. I understand though, that they probably didn't realise it was rude. That town had like one bank with ATMs and I needed money one day so I went to the bank and both ATMs were in use so I stood back a little bit, waiting for one of them to be free (nobody else was there). Then this man walks in stands right next to the girl on the ATM (at a 90 degree angle, basically staring at her uncomfortably closely) and gets on it as soon she moved, I called him out though and he let me on it. A few months later I was in living in Suzhou and my new flatmate had just arrived in China. We went to RT-Mart and we put our stuff on the conveyer belt and then this older man just walked in front of us and put his stuff in front of us. My flatmate just said "No." and moved the man's behind our stuff. One day, my flatmate and I were doing a bit of exploring in our local area in Suzhou at night. As we were walking alongside the road there was this little grassy patch and a tree to our right and next to the tree, in full view of the road (only a few metres away) was a guy squatting taking a dump on the grass (his arse in complete full view). He was not hidden at all! Once, I was in Shanghai Hongqiao Train Station, about to go back to Suzhou. I noticed there was about 15 minutes until the gate opened so I decided to line up to get through first. There was a line on the floor that said to not stand in front of it and to line up behind it. So I went right up to the line because I knew someone would try to cut in front of me if I didn't. After about 10 minutes a line was behind me and this random guy just walked up and stands right in front of me in front of the line on the floor. I called him out too, pointing out the line on the floor and told him to go to the back of the line and he left. There was one time I was in a train station in Shangrao and waiting in the high-speed train waiting room. There were public toilets in there very close by and it wasn't busy. This toddler was running around then his mother picks him up, opens the split pants, spread his legs and seemed to ENCOURAGE him to piss ON THE FLOOR. There were actual toilets nearby, I have no idea why she'd do that! I didn't say anything though, because I knew it would be futile. Of course, not all Chinese people are rude, these are just a few experiences I had. I've never had stuff like this happen in Taiwan! Most people here are very polite!
I am Chinese American that came from mainland, I am so proud of being very polite, caring and respectful since i was a kid. Not everyone is rude. Nowadays during the young generation, especially with good education and experience traveling or studying in overseas, more and more are polite and respectful.
@@carlric i agree. Once a while when I went back to mainland, I could still experience rudeness, especially from the population in their 60’s or 70’s who were grew up during Chairman Mao time ( culture revolution time), and the younger generations are much better than them.
I was living in China when the little girl was run over by 3 cars. There is video of people walking around her after the first car ran over her, which didn't stop. Leaving her there to be run over twice more before a woman that knew her mother picked her up and took her to her mother.
@@John_Smith_86 The video shows that within 7 minutes after the little girl was hit, 18 people passed by. They saw a little girl lying on the road, but no one took a second glance or carried her to safety. Instead, they let her continue lying on the road and get run over by a second vehicle. This is a country devoid of humanity.
To understand Chinese attitude and rudeness mentality, you actually have to go back even further, for half of the Qin dynasty (or for almost 500 years) the country has been unstable, no one promoted culture, habitat changes , the so call culture, social skills were completely lost for almost 500 years,, whereas Taiwanese been through tough Japanese culture change for 5 decades,
Why would one want to stay in a place where people are rude to strangers and nice to people they know? This just shows how two faced it is. I rather be in a place where people are nice and civilized across the board.
Bcause you are not people to them. You are just a primate, who happens to look a bit similar. So, they are indeed being consistent within the context of their culture
@@chrischang4989 Taiwan still has lots of rude people and a government + banking system that discriminates against non-Taiwanese. The reality is not what you think it is.
Cuz if ppl in PRC meet Caucasians. They will smile or even behave like you’re the emperor in ancient time (sorry, I couldn’t find a precise word to describe this, given English is not my mother tongue), and speak with you friendly in their broken English. That’s wouldn’t be rude in your eyes, I believe
Thanks for a very good analysis. As someone from Taiwan, I'd say that, as you suggested, the prevalence of religious beliefs, most of which preach morality and altruism, has played an important role in shaping the people of Taiwan's social mind, in addition to a collective willingness to learn from best practices abroad.
You forgot to mention one very and probably the MOST IMPORTANT factor is Taiwan has been ruled by Japan for 50 years which has a big impact on Taiwanese culture and everything. It plays a crucial role in Taiwan's modernization and civilization.
@@denzilwashingboard This proves that China has now killed Confucius's thought, while other normal countries have accepted and deepened the good parts.
@@AllenYangZzz From a geographical point of view, South Korea is surrounded by extremely authoritarian countries, North Korea and China, so it is difficult not to be affected!
Nah…you don’t have to be ruled by Japanese to have good manners or get Japanese to show you how to be polite. I found people overly credit Japan and accidentally ignored the development from its own society. Taiwanese society, education and people are the ones who made the effort to build the culture.
KMT promoted (more like forced) Chinese culture and language onto Taiwanese people to erase Japanese culture influences and language. My grandparents only spoke Taiwanese and Japanese so it was hard for us to communicate with them - as we were banned from learning Taiwanese.
Literally, if China is so great, then why so many Chinese people fleet their country and come to the US or other western countries to apply for asylum????????
We only started promoting traditional culture very recently because we noticed how fast it’s being replaced by the new so we’re doing our best now to preserve what’s still left for future generations to learn and possibly enjoy. I think politeness in Taiwan was heavily influenced by the Japanese when they were in control for 50 years. And of course from not going through things like the culture revolution and famine where people were pretty much forced to fend for themselves and not trust anyone even their own family members. That was brutal and destroyed traditional Chinese virtues which thankfully was preserved in Taiwan.
In those 50 years that Japan was in Taiwan, they attacked and occupied their neighbors in Asia, including China (as set out in The book The Rape of Nanjing), killed hundreds of Americans ( as in the Bombing of Pearl Harbor) and was nuked twice by the US of A to end WW2
Prozzie is right. Taiwan is indeed very globalized. So the difference between Prozzie and Taiwan in life attitude is not that big. On the contrary, the gap between China and Taiwan is huge. Really huge. Prozzie 說的很正確，台灣確實是全球化很明顯的，所以Prozzie與台灣的生活觀念態度差異其實不大，反而中國與台灣的差距很大，真的很大
謝謝你的分享和你觀察到在中國土地上的人的價值觀和在台灣地區生活的中國人的價值觀的差異。我很感激你的發表一我也很你的影片上了一課，謝謝你也更喜愛住在台灣~❤❤❤ l Thank you for sharing and for observing the difference between the values of people in China and the values of Chinese living in Taiwan. I am very grateful for your post. And I also learned a lesson from your video. Thank you for loving living in Taiwan more~❤❤❤
Yes, China people haven't been to other countries. In 2023, the number of people leaving the country was only 201 million, only 10 times that of Taiwan.😂😂😂
The real question should be why in the world 🌎 would you stay that long of a time over there in China 🇨🇳 ???Especially when you got royally Reamed $$$ by that Chinese elderly woman who made a extremely big show and scene over your motorbike accident incident with her?? Everything is all relative in that it must of been bad where 😅you originally came from to even put up with such nonsense over there.
I think the Taiwan culture is influenced mainly by the Japanese since they ruled Taiwan for a period of time. The so-called Chinese culture that KMT brought to this island was very conflicted with local Taiwanese culture (Japanese influenced) at the time. I would not say that Chinese culture was fully replicated here since Taiwan culture nowadays is definitely a mix of various cultures. When making it specifically to politeness, I'll give more credit to the Japanese influence for sure.
Correction: Why are some Chinese people from the Mainland are rude like some of those from the US, Tainwan? Hint: think about the "zero purchases" in US stores.
I think the "one child policy" in China had another effect on the culture, where after a couple of generations, a lot of people no longer had relatives. The only child also became spoiled by their parents, they no longer have siblings where they learn how to treat and work with others. The only child became the center of attention and self-centered.
You talking old story dates years 2000 , everywhere also have rudeness people even westerners we ASEAN nation also encounter . Why is their the pathetic western guys try to show to the world?
for the reason why taiwan is more polite than china: the globularization in the last century was actally a kind of chinalization. the world opened to china, and at the same time, vice versa. but the problem was not enough, especially when thinking about how many people is living oin his salary lower than the hungry line, strugling for earning life. but if most of their 1.4B people knows the world, there is no more CCP. on the other hand, taiwan was immersed under chinese culture and tradition. but the number of taiwanese people who passed through national tests and allowing to working in central government of Qing empire was 1/10 less than Fujian province. so the core of chinese culture, Machiavelli's-Politics type empiral administration was not so deepling penetrating into Taiwan. perhaps Japenese administration also help to remove some negative sides of chinese culture too. Luckly
Easiest question in my life. Education and social norm. Btw I raised and live in PRC, and I hate ppl don’t know manner and etiquette. And I believe it’s not just a social issue in PRC. cuz I met a lot Egyptian guys in hotel gym. they always say ‘are you use these?’, no excuse me, or even not a hello at the beginning in their saying
It's NOT just "a different way of looking at things". There are universal values. Chinese people lack culture, and you explained some of the causes that lead to that. How can you say it doesn't count as being rude, because it's "a different way of looking at things"?! Sure, there are certain things that are considered rude in one culture that aren't in another, but what you're talking about here is basic human decency. Caring about people outside your own tiny circle is a thing called "compassion". If you don't care about someone who just fell down and hurt themselves in front of you, no matter what part of the world you come from, you lack compassion and empathy.
Good analysis, pretty much what I have taken from my 10 years in beijing... However, for me the unwillingness to see otherwise, or accept constructuve comments/suggestion without having to deal with the truckload of BS excuses, or personal attacks and aggressivity put them in the unredeemable knuckle-heads category for me; and no matter how hard i've tried to rationalize this TOTAL BS BEHAVIOR, I've never succeeded, and they'll always remain ther ein my heart... This place is dead inside!
Interesting insight, but I can't fully agree with your viewpoint. I believe that China, Taiwan, and even the whole of East Asia have been deeply influenced by Confucian culture, which promotes "仁" (kindness to others) and does not even encourage individualism in the way Western culture does. The main causes, in my opinion, were still the Great Leap Forward and the Cultural Revolution. I used to work in China and learned about the characteristics of people shaped by the influence of Chinese communism. However, it wasn't until I interacted with people from Eastern Europe, who were also under communist regimes, that I realized communist societies can still foster kindness among people. The Great Leap Forward and the Cultural Revolution, I believe, were the key differentiating factors. Lastly, I must say that your Mandarin subtitles are a bit exaggerated. "一切都是阿共ㄟ陰謀" was hilarious! Great video to inspire contemplation. 👍🏻
Taiwan is abandoning Chinese traditions, for example, the great unification belief, never betray your ancestors, etc., while the mainland China is practicing those traditions.
Dude, what century are you stuck in? The video only halfway redeems itself at the end, showing you’re just a narrow-minded, cookie-cutter thinker who’s been squinting at China through your biased lenses all along. Learn some Chinese will help you!
You HK ppl are worst than mainlanders simply because every one knows exactly how mainlanders will behave like it is not. But you hkers put a fake facade of niceness but end up acting like mainlanders or even worst than mainlanders when you can’t handle a situation. All if you say “Dui Lui Lo Mo” DLLM every chance you get in an argument. Very easily hostile and rarely smile.
I don't understand how this is one sided. I read books about Chinese culture and lived there for years. I did research, and didn't explain these topics with any hate in my heart. Do you disagree with anything I said?
Yep. Just another classic video on TH-cam filmed by average White Peopele Misunderstanding Taiwan and Taiwanese Culture Fun Fact : The word “Taiwanese” came out so much earlier than “Chinese” So yes Western ppl definitely should rlly study more
I absolutely hate hearing people say, "Taiwanese culture is the true Chinese culture," as if they come to Taiwan just to pursue their fantasy of an authentic China. Temples exist in Japan and Korea too, yet no one says that about them. In reality, Taiwanese culture is a fusion of many influences: Japanese culture, American culture, Southeast Asian culture, and even the indigenous Māori culture from New Zealand. Historically, the Dutch and Spanish also brought various cultural elements to Taiwan, including Catholicism.
这不成杂种了？
well said.
But Maori is from Taiwan to New Zealand actually
@@jiadetong6144 按照中國憲法 zhina人是50+民族的大雜種 只是遵循一個大中華法西斯主義 所以統稱成一個民族
I'm not disagreeing with you but there are a few things I have my own opinion on. Chinese culture definitely has a stronger influence on Taiwan than Japanese culture or American culture. Temples in Korea and Japan have been there a lot longer and the culture around them has had enough "time in the oven" to be considered uniquely Japanese or Korean. Also Maori people and other indigenous people around SEA can trace their roots to Taiwan. There are videos about it and I recommend watching them. It's interesting stuff!
I think the island mentality also reduces rudeness. Most "rude" cultures are from large counties.
Most with little education and ethics like china. We were always taught to be civil/polite unless there is good reason not to. You see this especially with minorities in the US.
Did prozzie already delete my comment.
@@xcalibertrekker6693yes😢
In the view from the whole world, Japan is actually a large country in population. While the area of Japan is only smaller than a dozen of big continent countries.
是啊，最重要的因素還是地理，中俄是陸權，美日台是海權國家，光是對國際貿易的觀念和依賴度就存在本質差異
台灣還受到日治時期的影響，日本帶來了先進的基礎設施和文明觀念，台灣人也因為地處邊緣又隔海的關係不像中國人一樣接受了上千年的皇權統治，和美國一樣以移民組成的社會本就容易形成多元包容的風氣
The psychological makeup of the 2 countries is basically day and night. Anyone who has spent an extended period in China will know just how rude and uncaring a large portion of the populace in China can be. It is honestly quite depressing.
為什麼中國人應該要符合你們心目中的善良？你們定義的善良就是善良？
@dimmoony there is a thing called universal values
@@cpa314 Where is it from? Bible?
@ Universal values are fundamental principles and standards that are widely recognized and upheld across various cultures, societies, and nations, not necessarily from the Bible. For example, honesty and compassion could be considered universal values, and to be honesty I found both of these two to be severely lacking in China.
@@cpa314 Maybe you can look for Kant and see how he tried to find out the foundation about ethics.
台灣並不是只有吸收中國文化還有日本文化，其實本土台灣人家庭受到日本文化的影響遠遠勝過中國文化，而有人說台灣是正統中國文化那其實只是他們覺得台灣這部分比較好，他們就把好的部份說成是屬於中國文化的一部份，而且大部分會這樣說的人都是與中國有關聯的人，可能是1949年流亡來台的後代子孫(其實他們早就被台灣文化深深影響但他們卻不認同)或是現在的中國人，他們總是認為台灣的一切都來自於中國，而這是非常荒謬的，原本本土的台灣人好像不存在，本地台灣人也會創造自己的文化，並不是什麼都是中國來的，但中國人數量龐大所以在社群媒體上就都會是中國人說的內容成為多數人閱讀到的。
Taiwan is not just absorbing Chinese culture, but also Japanese culture. In fact, the influence of Japanese culture on local Taiwanese families far exceeds that of Chinese culture. Some people say that Taiwan is authentic Chinese culture, but that is actually because they think that this part of Taiwan is better. The good parts are said to be part of Chinese culture, and most of the people who say this are people who have connections with China, perhaps the descendants of those who fled to Taiwan in 1949 (in fact, they have long been They are deeply influenced by the culture but they do not agree with it) or the Chinese nowadays, they always think that everything in Taiwan comes from China, which is very ridiculous. It seems that the original native Taiwanese do not exist, and the local Taiwanese will also Create your own culture. Not everything comes from China, but the Chinese population is huge so on social media, most people will read what the Chinese say.
土生土長的台灣人是原住民好嗎? 妳以為是200年前先來的中國人? 要不是明清時期漢人來台侵略原住民土地 現在這塊島嶼才不會如此烏煙瘴氣 我是建議大家驗一下血統 沒有75%原住民血統的都要回歸中國 還島於"民" 漢人除了把福建 廣東原有家鄉文化帶過來還創造甚麼自己文化? 不要自欺欺人了 真正的台灣人是屬於原住民的
台灣在殖民時期確實有受到日本影響，但是一個社會有現今的氛圍，最主要還是受在地人影響，我是覺得台灣人不像日本人那麼注重一些細節上的禮貌，但是我們也對陌生人更友好與和善，可以看成是兩個不同的風土民情了
Taiwanese aren't like Japanese. I mean, there are many differences between our cultures, and I think Taiwanese are kinder to strangers compared to Japanese. We don’t need to be colonized by the Japanese to learn how to treat others nicely.
哥們要去中講清楚一點，也做徹底一點，不然只是嘴炮做半套而已
首先記得死後不要辦中式法會，不要做頭七。清明更不要拜拜
然後別學中國人用筷子吃飯，學印度支那用手抓或者歐美用刀叉，更不要吃中餐
應該每餐改成吃壽司或者漢堡😂
還有記得別用儒家文化的那一套，禮義忠孝等等
最後記得學馬來華人一樣，中文名字也改成英文。
As a Chinese, I just don't give a ****. That 'don't give a **** ' attitude makes Europeans call Chinese people the Italians or Texans of Asia. It has to do with arrogance, not culture.
受到日本的影响大，指被三天两头被东北亚水鬼屠😋，那确实影响够大了👍🏻
Thanks! That really is a great point of view.
thank you!
My first time living in China I was in a small, rural, countryside town in Jiangxi province. I was inexperienced and all the stares and shouts of "laowai" I didn't consider rude at the time, but it is quite rude really. Even most students at the school I worked at would just say "Hello, Laowai" instead of teacher. People following and watching me in town was weird. I understand though, that they probably didn't realise it was rude.
That town had like one bank with ATMs and I needed money one day so I went to the bank and both ATMs were in use so I stood back a little bit, waiting for one of them to be free (nobody else was there). Then this man walks in stands right next to the girl on the ATM (at a 90 degree angle, basically staring at her uncomfortably closely) and gets on it as soon she moved, I called him out though and he let me on it.
A few months later I was in living in Suzhou and my new flatmate had just arrived in China. We went to RT-Mart and we put our stuff on the conveyer belt and then this older man just walked in front of us and put his stuff in front of us. My flatmate just said "No." and moved the man's behind our stuff.
One day, my flatmate and I were doing a bit of exploring in our local area in Suzhou at night. As we were walking alongside the road there was this little grassy patch and a tree to our right and next to the tree, in full view of the road (only a few metres away) was a guy squatting taking a dump on the grass (his arse in complete full view). He was not hidden at all!
Once, I was in Shanghai Hongqiao Train Station, about to go back to Suzhou. I noticed there was about 15 minutes until the gate opened so I decided to line up to get through first. There was a line on the floor that said to not stand in front of it and to line up behind it. So I went right up to the line because I knew someone would try to cut in front of me if I didn't. After about 10 minutes a line was behind me and this random guy just walked up and stands right in front of me in front of the line on the floor. I called him out too, pointing out the line on the floor and told him to go to the back of the line and he left.
There was one time I was in a train station in Shangrao and waiting in the high-speed train waiting room. There were public toilets in there very close by and it wasn't busy. This toddler was running around then his mother picks him up, opens the split pants, spread his legs and seemed to ENCOURAGE him to piss ON THE FLOOR. There were actual toilets nearby, I have no idea why she'd do that! I didn't say anything though, because I knew it would be futile.
Of course, not all Chinese people are rude, these are just a few experiences I had.
I've never had stuff like this happen in Taiwan! Most people here are very polite!
Given that those assholes backed down when you called them out on it, I would consider them already very polite for China
It's important to know the difference between China and Taiwan. I am Taiwanese and we are much more civilized and polite than Chinese.
Jiang Xi was once the base of the commies when they hadn't established the country. No wonder.
In New York, I also saw similar strange rude things. Such kind of rudeness happens almost any human societies.
@@AmairaNymativy-uy7vf 但中共國人比例偏很高
大饑荒餓死的數字是超過千萬，影片中說只有百萬是錯誤的，保守估計官方自己有的說法是兩千多萬，民間調查的說法是達四千多萬，不是百萬。
另外傳統中國都是宗族文化，權貴都是宗族文化抱團。
安部人口統計處的副處長趙文奇來主持；最後他們得出一個結果，「餓死的農民合共9600萬人」。 據稱這個數字太令人震驚，當時的公安部高層也不敢相信，兩次詢問趙文奇能否確認這個數字。 據稱當時趙文奇回覆說：「這個數經過我們反覆核對，是正確的，而且已經存在公安部人口統計處的檔案裡邊了。」
他說的確實是幾千萬tens of million people，是字幕寫錯了
I said "tens of millions of people", but the subtitles were wrong. Sorry about that!
@@Iwinthejackpot 蟾蜍能不能統一口徑啊，又變9600萬人了。難道不是96億嗎？
蜘蛛，在笼子外面没有“统一口径”这件事存在❤每家媒体的口径都是不太一样的，蜘蛛可能不习惯❤
謝謝！
Thank you!
林語堂那段很有意思，中國人沒有社會意識這個觀點也很有趣值得人深思，謝謝分享
有時會在部分國外youtuber的影片裡看到中國人和善的一面，但是又有一批人說實際上不是如此，這些影片也讓我們開始反思現代中國的面貌到底是如何。
@@ericxd-y1c 只能靠你们自己岛内自救了
@@ericxd-y1c 可惜你们现在估计都已经没有人还记得这位大师了吧，李傲走后台湾真的没有什么能人了
@@jameshuang2 俺就是能人 懂呀?!
@@jameshuang2你什麼都不是
Here in Canada, chinese people from mainland are very rude in general, but taiwanese people are nice.
I am Chinese American that came from mainland, I am so proud of being very polite, caring and respectful since i was a kid. Not everyone is rude. Nowadays during the young generation, especially with good education and experience traveling or studying in overseas, more and more are polite and respectful.
@@sunnywu7205 Of course there are nice mainlanders, I have friends from there and are nice.. I'm just talking in general...
@@carlric i agree. Once a while when I went back to mainland, I could still experience rudeness, especially from the population in their 60’s or 70’s who were grew up during Chairman Mao time ( culture revolution time), and the younger generations are much better than them.
@@sunnywu7205 Thanks :)
Taiwanese people are only kind to white people tbh. I won’t say all but most of them are racist as f 😂
公安部人口統計處的副處長趙文奇來主持；最後他們得出一個結果，「餓死的農民合共9600萬人」。 據稱這個數字太令人震驚，當時的公安部高層也不敢相信，兩次詢問趙文奇能否確認這個數字。 據稱當時趙文奇回覆說：「這個數經過我們反覆核對，是正確的，而且已經存在公安部人口統計處的檔案裡邊了。
感謝情報，原來還有9600萬一說，感覺中國人是真的不在乎死亡數這種事情，他們連疫情清零政策造成的災害都快遺忘了
這解釋了為什麼中國能在游泳、體操、桌球、羽球等個人競賽奪牌；但在籃球、排球、足球、棒球等團體合作總是淘汰👍
但在籃球、排球、足球、棒球等團體合作總是淘汰,--------可台灣從來都沒進入這些賽段，好意思嘴硬
@@泰勒魏恩 影片討論中國，不是台灣，也不是和台灣做比較。
為什麼一提到中國，你就罵台灣？？
你不喜歡看帕西的影片，可以離開，不喜歡台灣、你可以去中國。
@@泰勒魏恩笑死你还真跟他认真讲…女排赢了他也看不见，这种rz有什么好交流的
你蠢到家了，中国这些项目基本至少属于亚洲一流，你撒泡尿照照自己，把内裤捂嘴上别出声了
@@泰勒魏恩了解一下 中國女子足球和女子排球？😅
Great video with great insights. Thank you Prozzie 🙏
It might be a different view of life, but it's still rude. :p
So true 😂
😂🎉
I was living in China when the little girl was run over by 3 cars. There is video of people walking around her after the first car ran over her, which didn't stop. Leaving her there to be run over twice more before a woman that knew her mother picked her up and took her to her mother.
Yea, but it is the law. What can you do?
@@John_Smith_86 The video shows that within 7 minutes after the little girl was hit, 18 people passed by. They saw a little girl lying on the road, but no one took a second glance or carried her to safety. Instead, they let her continue lying on the road and get run over by a second vehicle. This is a country devoid of humanity.
I was in China when that happened. I think it was 2011. It was a shocking video.
To understand Chinese attitude and rudeness mentality, you actually have to go back even further, for half of the Qin dynasty (or for almost 500 years) the country has been unstable, no one promoted culture, habitat changes , the so call culture, social skills were completely lost for almost 500 years,, whereas Taiwanese been through tough Japanese culture change for 5 decades,
Why would one want to stay in a place where people are rude to strangers and nice to people they know? This just shows how two faced it is. I rather be in a place where people are nice and civilized across the board.
You definitely have to visit my country Taiwan ❤
Bcause you are not people to them. You are just a primate, who happens to look a bit similar. So, they are indeed being consistent within the context of their culture
@@chrischang4989 Taiwan still has lots of rude people and a government + banking system that discriminates against non-Taiwanese. The reality is not what you think it is.
taiwan is nice to strangers and rude to people they know :D
Cuz if ppl in PRC meet Caucasians. They will smile or even behave like you’re the emperor in ancient time (sorry, I couldn’t find a precise word to describe this, given English is not my mother tongue), and speak with you friendly in their broken English. That’s wouldn’t be rude in your eyes, I believe
Thanks for a very good analysis. As someone from Taiwan, I'd say that, as you suggested, the prevalence of religious beliefs, most of which preach morality and altruism, has played an important role in shaping the people of Taiwan's social mind, in addition to a collective willingness to learn from best practices abroad.
You forgot to mention one very and probably the MOST IMPORTANT factor is Taiwan has been ruled by Japan for 50 years which has a big impact on Taiwanese culture and everything. It plays a crucial role in Taiwan's modernization and civilization.
but a japanese once told me japan ettiquite came from confucious ... so who knows
受日本教育的都8~90歲以上了，你搞笑吧
@@denzilwashingboard你们完全不懂中国文化，却在这边胡言乱语。
@@denzilwashingboard This proves that China has now killed Confucius's thought, while other normal countries have accepted and deepened the good parts.
Japan bombed Pearl Harbor …the US nuked Japan TWICE!
又來看Prozzie了，廢話不多說趕緊先按個讚
Taiwan was ruled by Japan for decades. That had an impact on their culture as to why Taiwanese people tend to be polite like Japaneses.
不，日本帶給台灣的只有歧視文化，台灣人文明是因為中國文化教育
Korea was so.
But
台灣人傳承的是中華文化而非被中共扭曲的中國狼性文化
@@AllenYangZzz From a geographical point of view, South Korea is surrounded by extremely authoritarian countries, North Korea and China, so it is difficult not to be affected!
Nah…you don’t have to be ruled by Japanese to have good manners or get Japanese to show you how to be polite. I found people overly credit Japan and accidentally ignored the development from its own society.
Taiwanese society, education and people are the ones who made the effort to build the culture.
KMT promoted (more like forced) Chinese culture and language onto Taiwanese people to erase Japanese culture influences and language. My grandparents only spoke Taiwanese and Japanese so it was hard for us to communicate with them - as we were banned from learning Taiwanese.
我67歲是在花蓮出生的外省二代、在家都說國語。你無法和祖父母溝通我想大約是你父母的關係吧?我讀的學校並沒禁止方言，我還在學校跟同學學會說台語和客家話，家母也是用日語和鄰居【原住民】聊天。村子裡的村民們都說方言無人禁止說方言。家父也努力學台語和客家話，和村民聊天時因為口音的問題常逗得它們笑哈哈的。
@@susuma9834
我小時候在學校說台語，被老師罰嘴裏含石頭。
日奴要高级一点
@@susuma9834我52稅我52歲
我讀國小時因為說方言被罰過錢2次
台灣中國 一邊一國，分立一甲 互不隸屬。
☑️
Wow...awesome video and explanations. Tks Prozzie
This is one of your best videos IMO.
@@TrailWalker03 thanks!
IMO
台湾五毛？
@@Prozzie你让看视频的台湾人以及住在台湾的外国人集体高潮了，😂😂😂，台湾真棒。
現在很多台灣人旅遊也是偏自私，沒有入境隨俗，行李亂擺放給人造成影響。希望國人在嘲笑他人時自己也需要以身作則😢
說的很好，而且分析不帶仇恨
@@ponponhsia 外國人自然沒有仇恨，有仇恨的大多是我們華人，直接間接被波及的人數龐大。
我覺得Prozzie一開始舉的例子滿爛的😆
那個感覺只能說明中國人很冷漠，不能稱之為中國人很無理，真的要說的話那些在路上碰瓷的中國人就真的要無理得多得多了。但我滿同意只要足夠全球化的一個地方就可以變得禮貌且文明，例如在中國一線城市長大的人們明顯比農村來的人有見識些，也更懂得禮貌。
但我想反駁的是"中國人給人感覺比較無理是因為中華文化本身就比較冷漠一點"這個論點，其實亞洲許多國家都有這種冷漠的特質，甚至在台灣也不例外，不過看一看日本人其實就可以了解，冷漠其實也是可以冷漠的很有禮貌的，如果去找一些中國清朝留下的一些珍貴錄影，當時的人們其實也很有禮貌。我們先退回到Prozzie跌倒沒人扶的那裏，這裡導致這個結果的原因是因為中國社會普遍的冷漠嗎?我認為不是。
其實去找一些中國人對於見到老人跌倒不扶的說法，這個行為其實可以追溯到好幾年前我沒記錯的話是一個老人家跌倒，路人把他扶起後反而被告了，說是扶他的人推倒他的要求扶他的人要賠償他，而最後法院定路人罪的原因竟然是"人不是你撞的，你扶他幹嘛?"
雖然最後的判決我個人認為只能證明他們地方法院的檢調法官相當的沒有法律素養，但這件事情的起因仍然能夠說明，第一，其實中國傳統文化的冷漠並沒有冷漠到連人倒在路上都不願意扶，第二，造成這一切無禮行為我想更應該是中國在經歷大躍進、大革命以後，遺留下來的那種自私文化，還有那種為達目的不擇手段的心態，飢荒導致人們自私，革命使的人們粗暴，文化抹除導致人們不再在乎做了壞事會不會遭到報應，只要不犯法我再壞又怎麼樣，插你個隊又不犯法，餵鹿吃他自己的糞便又不犯法，在便利商店門口直接如廁又不犯法。
這些我覺得都已經和冷漠和自掃門前雪無關了，這已經是自私了，而我認為這一連串的徵狀，包括中國的不夠全球化，還有現在很強烈的民粹化，在在都顯示了這些都是中國共產黨深化影響以及實行愚民教育下的結果，當然，一些大城市除外。
Literally, if China is so great, then why so many Chinese people fleet their country and come to the US or other western countries to apply for asylum????????
中國14亿人口，出去的还是占少数的，台湾也有一堆人去大陆讨生活，去柬埔寨东南亚搞诈骗的。
因為赴美是生活. 在中國只有被割的份
Oh my! You do dig out the real mindset of the Chinese. That deserves tons of LIKES!
我覺得不是全球化的影響耶，中國在2000年後也是大開放吸引眾多外國人到訪，但他們本質依舊沒變
中國人口數和在中外國人人口數不成比例 不能這樣算 中國現在還是封鎖外來文化 所以文化並沒有全球化
還是受中共體制影響吧，這個邪惡體制只會把人性邪惡面放大
我個人覺得中國是一個高度政治化的國家，不管是教育、文化、體育、甚至是娛樂都在共產黨的控制下運作的。我沒去過中國但我有時會關心中國時事（靠逃出中國的ＹＴＲ介紹）。在中國曾經有一位老先生跌倒，路人有去幫他反而被老先生告去法院。事後法院判路人要賠償老先生，原因居然是路人沒撞到老先生卻為何要幫老先生呢？由此可知這社會會有良善嗎？
是的当年这个事件让中国的道德简直倒退50年，这个法官被人骂臭了。现在有人摔倒还是会有人去扶的，大家现在都会带个手机去扶的。您的信息获取太单一了，
欢迎来大陆游玩，不管在哪个地方好人都会比坏人多的。
算了吧，不能一个列以偏概全。就像台湾诈骗犯粉碎了很多家庭，你们有个P的善良。
the youtube algorithm brought me to your video. now i’m subscribed 😊
@@Kevin-fq3zh glad to have you!
We only started promoting traditional culture very recently because we noticed how fast it’s being replaced by the new so we’re doing our best now to preserve what’s still left for future generations to learn and possibly enjoy. I think politeness in Taiwan was heavily influenced by the Japanese when they were in control for 50 years. And of course from not going through things like the culture revolution and famine where people were pretty much forced to fend for themselves and not trust anyone even their own family members. That was brutal and destroyed traditional Chinese virtues which thankfully was preserved in Taiwan.
In those 50 years that Japan was in Taiwan, they attacked and occupied their neighbors in Asia, including China (as set out in The book The Rape of Nanjing), killed hundreds of Americans ( as in the Bombing of Pearl Harbor) and was nuked twice by the US of A to end WW2
Thanks for sharing your experience
Thanks for watching!
真正諷刺的是
經過了文化大革命
新中國變成俄羅斯文化為骨幹的發展體
現在倒過來跟台灣講傳統文化......
Prozzie is right. Taiwan is indeed very globalized. So the difference between Prozzie and Taiwan in life attitude is not that big. On the contrary, the gap between China and Taiwan is huge. Really huge.
Prozzie 說的很正確，台灣確實是全球化很明顯的，所以Prozzie與台灣的生活觀念態度差異其實不大，反而中國與台灣的差距很大，真的很大
Taiwan is very globalized 😂
@@Janpan69 人礦野蠻人又爬牆出來了XD
@@Janpan69🇹🇼（吃瓜🍉:3
Lin Yutang makes a comeback! I'd love to hear more insights you've gotten from studying Chinese culture and learning about him! Great video!
謝謝你的分享和你觀察到在中國土地上的人的價值觀和在台灣地區生活的中國人的價值觀的差異。我很感激你的發表一我也很你的影片上了一課，謝謝你也更喜愛住在台灣~❤❤❤
l Thank you for sharing and for observing the difference between the values of people in China and the values of Chinese living in Taiwan. I am very grateful for your post. And I also learned a lesson from your video. Thank you for loving living in Taiwan more~❤❤❤
你推倒我了！你推倒我了！
很有趣的影片，對Prozzie來說，「無視」是一種無禮粗魯的行為，這真的是東西文化差異！（我還是覺得中國人無禮粗魯，不過不是這個原因）
如果我遠遠的看到一個人跌倒了，我可能會在心裡暗暗擔心，看到他站起來、看起來很ｏｋ，我就會放下心，放下這件事。
除非他看起來需要幫忙，不然我不會想到要去打擾他耶，哈，謝謝Prozzie有趣的影片！有趣的文化差異
我和你一样。难道我不是河北人是台湾人？😂
@@xiwang2541你在胡言亂語什麼？文法糟糕
@ 呵，我的意思正是說：我的反應和Prozzie 影片裡提到的中國人一樣。
這正是東西文化差異。
推薦 Prozzie 另一本書：「醜陋的中國人」
講解到位👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Very good analysis, Prozzie.
你們認識的那位中國女孩，有沒有因為你而改變？
中國人要與世界溶合還須要很長的時間，在這之前對世界來說都是一場埸災難
Yes, China people haven't been to other countries. In 2023, the number of people leaving the country was only 201 million, only 10 times that of Taiwan.😂😂😂
It’s the lost of civilization that you’re delving into.
No misunderstanding, they are rude, period. I don't blame them though, it's part of their education and culture.
The real question should be why in the world 🌎 would you stay that long of a time over there in China 🇨🇳 ???Especially when you got royally Reamed $$$ by that Chinese elderly woman who made a extremely big show and scene over your motorbike accident incident with her?? Everything is all relative in that it must of been bad where 😅you originally came from to even put up with such nonsense over there.
禮儀之邦
課本裡學的不同
課本裡老師都有教禮義廉恥
忠孝仁愛信義和平，中國課本台灣課本大不同，學校可見的標語也不同，諸如此類就是台灣人學的
所以台灣人對中國有很錯誤的想像，唉
你推倒我了！你推倒我了！
I think the Taiwan culture is influenced mainly by the Japanese since they ruled Taiwan for a period of time. The so-called Chinese culture that KMT brought to this island was very conflicted with local Taiwanese culture (Japanese influenced) at the time. I would not say that Chinese culture was fully replicated here since Taiwan culture nowadays is definitely a mix of various cultures. When making it specifically to politeness, I'll give more credit to the Japanese influence for sure.
Great video, Prozzie. Very educational and a good explanation of Chinese behavior.
我覺得共產黨前的中國人到底是怎麼樣的，你應該還要把視野放大，納入民國以前的清朝社會狀況。清朝是個外來民族建立的帝國王朝，所以他們發動文字獄、禁止人民集黨結社，在一定的程度上來說，這樣的行為對中央集權的統治者來說是不可容忍的，因為會提高人民團結後造反的機率。在這種前提之下，無血緣關係或不認識的人之間又有什麼機會產生公共社會意識？之後清朝最後的皇帝退位，在動亂之中建立新民國，然後又出現共產黨，基本上中國原本在民國時期可以實施的所有改革，全部中途夭折，然後又發生大躍進、文化大革命，以及無限循環的權力鬥爭，因為不鬥就活不下去，最後轉向現在所謂的新中國發展。這就像平行宇宙，不管你是主動或被動選擇，經歷的東西不同，最後獲得的結果也不同。
你推倒我了！你推倒我了！
從兩本書就可以看出千年的中國人性, 建議魯迅的阿Q正傳, 與李寶嘉的官場現形記. 都是晚清的作家. 林語堂算是發起民國文化的愛國主義者, 才會創造"中國"這個名詞.
Basically if Chinese people don't know you, you are considered an NPC. 😂
Chines people don't know much.
Look guys, the American counter measure to the recent RedNote trend has been deployed. 😂
i dont know who you are, but hey i am glad that ppl start notice the different between Chinese and Taiwanese.
Correction: Why are some Chinese people from the Mainland are rude like some of those from the US, Tainwan? Hint: think about the "zero purchases" in US stores.
Correction : Mainland is not a thing.
林語堂不是台灣人。他從中國來到台灣就只跟少數的當權者生活在一起，住在陽明山山上。要說他跟台灣的關係，算是refugee吧。
我是超厭惡簡體字的人，網路所有中國資訊，都被我點選 "不感興趣" 全部ben掉
所以我看待中國人都帶很多極端厭惡感
prozzie的經歷和見解，讓我覺得沒帶多極端厭惡感的見解，還滿特別
知己知彼，才能是全面的判斷，日文中也許多簡體字，又如何
現在台灣的簡繁之爭，已被某時期的“正體”領袖，帶窄了
@tom-my2xw 我寧願學日文漢字，也不要看中共殘體字
我覺得他還是透過中國理解台灣。其實台灣不管是地理位置、人種、文化和複雜性都是全世界特有的，而且持續演化中，雖然人口不多。要用某個國家、文化框住台灣是什麼樣子，很難。我只知道獨一無二。旅外12年的心得。
說得很好
美國傳教士明恩溥1899年的著作「中國人的性格」也曾提到很多類似的觀點，例如中國人完全不會好奇家附近的外國人從哪裡來、一輩子不離鄉、對外面的世界一無所知，只要是公眾的東西都會隨便拿走，還會取笑談論政治的人等等，真的很有意思
欺騙是中國文化的特徵。因為他們推崇君子、聖人。
很多中國人就算接觸外國文化或移民到國外，他們的心還是小粉紅，不會變的，在國外看到台灣人就會沒禮貌的問支不支持一個中國？如果不是，你就會用言詞辱罵😅
您超有說服力，因為兩邊都住過
I think the "one child policy" in China had another effect on the culture, where after a couple of generations, a lot of people no longer had relatives. The only child also became spoiled by their parents, they no longer have siblings where they learn how to treat and work with others. The only child became the center of attention and self-centered.
謝謝Prozzie這部影片，內容很讚也很有幫助對中國歷史與影響的了解
全球化已經是1990年以後的事了，其實答案就是1895-1945的日本文化與殖民。
背景是台中？
You talking old story dates years 2000 , everywhere also have rudeness people even westerners we ASEAN nation also encounter .
Why is their the pathetic western guys try to show to the world?
我喜歡你的觀點，謝謝你的分享❤
這些不是中華吧！想想中國共產黨前身叫什麼？
中華“蘇維埃”共和國！赤化中國是它們成立的目的
換掉中華文化是赤化後的成果
中華文化是散落世界各地的
有因為戰亂逃到香港
有因為以前是中國藩屬國的越南、韓國
有因為沿海人民移民求生的大馬
有因為國共內戰的臺灣
正統的中華文化真的不是在中國
根本就不存在什麼狗屁中華文化
懂嗎低能？
中華文化 四個字是被發明出來洗腦的
很抱歉啊！清朝無法代表中國漢人，最原先的漢人入閩後跟北方人產生很大的區別這不只是一百年而已吧，宋雖亡但人民還是留下許多文化風俗經過清朝、日本的破壞在民間的『漢閩』依然不滅這就是『中國的舊社會觀』
以簡單的文字大致說明，每個中國人都是同屬不同種。
我們所謂的（人）應該是（種），中國人的（人）是（屬），所以我們跟他們的基點不一樣。
希望你能理解我說的。
你推倒我了！你推倒我了！
Prozzie今天的打扮很帥👍
共慘黨有深入的去研究它們中國人，而且很信奉日本人對中華民族的評價(貪財、怕死、愛面子)
是的中国只会越来越衰败
dont waste your precious time on Chinese Topic.... i should spend our time on something worth it.
And we are not even from China🤣
我不完全認同你的分析，因為讓中國人不關心個人和家庭以外的人，並非是傳統中國文化造成的。譬如儒家思想就是個明顯的證據，由內而外，「修身齊家治國平天下」，人應有「惻隱之心」，不可能看到你摔倒還無視你。現在的中國人會變成如此無禮自私與冷血，基本上與文化大革命息息有關。在那個統治者鼓吹骨肉至親彼此之間互相舉報，造成名譽甚至身家性命都損失的時代，帶來的影響顯然導致如今中國人對彼此不信任、習慣從他人的不幸中獲取自己的利益，冷血自私自利。而且失去做人的底線。
Thank you for sharing this video with us ❤
for the reason why taiwan is more polite than china: the globularization in the last century was actally a kind of chinalization. the world opened to china, and at the same time, vice versa. but the problem was not enough, especially when thinking about how many people is living oin his salary lower than the hungry line, strugling for earning life. but if most of their 1.4B people knows the world, there is no more CCP. on the other hand, taiwan was immersed under chinese culture and tradition. but the number of taiwanese people who passed through national tests and allowing to working in central government of Qing empire was 1/10 less than Fujian province. so the core of chinese culture, Machiavelli's-Politics type empiral administration was not so deepling penetrating into Taiwan. perhaps Japenese administration also help to remove some negative sides of chinese culture too. Luckly
Mainland Chinese are also polite comparing with US people, where you see a lot of zero-dollar-buy(robbery) and gun violence.
Easiest question in my life. Education and social norm. Btw I raised and live in PRC, and I hate ppl don’t know manner and etiquette. And I believe it’s not just a social issue in PRC. cuz I met a lot Egyptian guys in hotel gym. they always say ‘are you use these?’, no excuse me, or even not a hello at the beginning in their saying
It's NOT just "a different way of looking at things". There are universal values. Chinese people lack culture, and you explained some of the causes that lead to that. How can you say it doesn't count as being rude, because it's "a different way of looking at things"?! Sure, there are certain things that are considered rude in one culture that aren't in another, but what you're talking about here is basic human decency. Caring about people outside your own tiny circle is a thing called "compassion". If you don't care about someone who just fell down and hurt themselves in front of you, no matter what part of the world you come from, you lack compassion and empathy.
Good analysis, pretty much what I have taken from my 10 years in beijing... However, for me the unwillingness to see otherwise, or accept constructuve comments/suggestion without having to deal with the truckload of BS excuses, or personal attacks and aggressivity put them in the unredeemable knuckle-heads category for me; and no matter how hard i've tried to rationalize this TOTAL BS BEHAVIOR, I've never succeeded, and they'll always remain ther ein my heart... This place is dead inside!
Interesting insight, but I can't fully agree with your viewpoint. I believe that China, Taiwan, and even the whole of East Asia have been deeply influenced by Confucian culture, which promotes "仁" (kindness to others) and does not even encourage individualism in the way Western culture does.
The main causes, in my opinion, were still the Great Leap Forward and the Cultural Revolution. I used to work in China and learned about the characteristics of people shaped by the influence of Chinese communism. However, it wasn't until I interacted with people from Eastern Europe, who were also under communist regimes, that I realized communist societies can still foster kindness among people. The Great Leap Forward and the Cultural Revolution, I believe, were the key differentiating factors.
Lastly, I must say that your Mandarin subtitles are a bit exaggerated. "一切都是阿共ㄟ陰謀" was hilarious!
Great video to inspire contemplation. 👍🏻
沒錯，中國的改變是源自內部的改變，而台灣是源自外部。有時我覺得人的性格改變不需要DNA在漫長的時光中逐漸改變，只要經歷大躍進和文化大革命能存活下來，他就是了。
Taiwan is abandoning Chinese traditions, for example, the great unification belief, never betray your ancestors, etc., while the mainland China is practicing those traditions.
Chinese tradition?
With limited resources available in China with the most population count, people sometime will fight as like their last life for anything
這正是現在的台灣人應了解的現代中國！
現在的中國基本上只是在同一土地，但文化、精神等層面早已跟歷史中生活在同一土地上的人不同了。
更糟糕的是，共產黨想要將這種對於現代中國的殖民思想擴展到世界各地，企圖改變世界秩序和價值觀。
你才應該要多讀點台灣史書
就會發現 台灣人本來就跟中國沒任何關係
0:41 so basically there’s not much difference between Taiwan and China. Got that
Very good insight view, I felt it with my own family members .. that makes me so not fit in with them. They called me naive stupid and poor
We Taiwanese are civilized and learn manners
😂😂😂 笑死我
Then admit Taiwan is part of China. Otherwise you are not civilized and no manner
连国家是谁都搞不懂确实很civilized 😂
Dude, what century are you stuck in? The video only halfway redeems itself at the end, showing you’re just a narrow-minded, cookie-cutter thinker who’s been squinting at China through your biased lenses all along. Learn some Chinese will help you!
haha yeah ok China is perfect
韭菜還愛繁體字.
sad to say I felt the same coldness when I was in Russia. My impression is that people are cautious against strangers after communism brutalities
If you understood 碰磁 meaning for Chinese, you will really know new Chinese. Check 南京彭宇案 and how all Chinese ignore any accident on the road.
Same as Hong Konger, they are also very open to the world, that’s they don’t really get along with the OG Chinese.
You HK ppl are worst than mainlanders simply because every one knows exactly how mainlanders will behave like it is not. But you hkers put a fake facade of niceness but end up acting like mainlanders or even worst than mainlanders when you can’t handle a situation. All if you say “Dui Lui Lo Mo” DLLM every chance you get in an argument. Very easily hostile and rarely smile.
台灣與中國都學孔子 學儒家思想 忠孝仁義 禮義廉恥 學漢唐宋元明清 等歷史 當然也同樣學成語 如 恃強凌弱 但現今 中國人都只學黨國一體 大於一切
Hope most of western world could have the chance to see your video too
因為中國大陸社會常發生訛人（栽髒別人要賠償）的事件 ，所以現在大多看到有人跌倒什么的都主動幫忙
十分片面的观察，非常浅薄的见解
粉儿又急了😏
🇨🇳🗑
@@独裁者-q9u 粉兒愛鐮刀
I don't understand how this is one sided. I read books about Chinese culture and lived there for years. I did research, and didn't explain these topics with any hate in my heart. Do you disagree with anything I said?
Yep. Just another classic video on TH-cam
filmed by average White Peopele
Misunderstanding Taiwan and Taiwanese Culture
Fun Fact : The word “Taiwanese” came out so much earlier than “Chinese”
So yes Western ppl definitely should rlly study more