Has no one ever took a hot minute to read and understand Peace Treaty of San Francisco 1952? No one owns Taiwan and Penghu except the Taiwanese , both chinas have no claim to Taiwan since 1895.
I just gonna saving this video, every time when any fellow Canadian worrisome and anxious asked me about this question that I’ve been answering millions of times. I can save my time and make them watch it. Thanks guys, great video. 👍
TikTok is not banned in Taiwan. Many teachers don't bother playing video clips from TikTok in school and that should be one of the reasons Chinese influence can be so strong today. (Many school teachers are pro KMT.)
As an American who has lived in Taiwan for over 20 years, I've had to deal with constant worries about this issue from my family back in the States. Especially my father. I've had countless arguments with him as he just listens to the U.S. media fearmonger about an imminent Chinese invasion into Taiwan. This reached its climax when Putin invaded Ukraine. He was convinced that Xi would follow suit and launch an invasion into Taiwan. Anytime I tune into "analyses" on U.S. media outlets, I constantly hear the idea that any weakness shown by the U.S. towards the Ukraine invasion will signal to Xi that similar weakness will be shown to an invasion of Taiwan. These "analysts" seemingly have no understanding of the gigantic differences between the Taiwan/China situation and the Ukraine/Russia situation. 1. Geography: Taiwan is, of course, an island. Not only that, it is an island that would be extremely difficult to launch any sort of amphibious assault on. Anyone who has lived here knows how few locations there are around Taiwan where it would be feasible to unload a boots-on-the-ground military force. In Ukraine, Putin just drove his tanks and vehicles up to the border and told them to cross. 2. History: The status quo in Taiwan/China relations has been largely stagnant for 80 years whereas the relationship between Ukraine and Russia has been in constant flux since the breakup of the USSR. 3. Economic Status: Taiwan plays a much larger role in the world economy than Ukraine ever has. Not to mention, any actual military invasion of Taiwan would end up destroying the entire reason that China would like to control it: its semiconductor production capabilities. 4. The People: The areas of Ukraine that Putin is trying to cease control of were already engaged in a civil war with the central Ukrainian government and are home to large groups of people who are sympathetic to or even pushing for being part of Russia. That is just not the case in Taiwan. Outside of maybe Jinmen or Matszu, there is no sympathy for CCP rule in Taiwan. In fact, there is widespread detest of anything having to do with mainland China in Taiwan. Do these reasons mean that it's impossible that China will ever invade Taiwan? No. But I do think it is highly unlikely. The only thing that could possibly motivate China to invade Taiwan would be "losing face." If Taiwan were to declare independence on the international stage or if some major countries were to recognize Taiwan independence, they might feel that their hand is forced. But I don't see that happening.
Taiwan's democracy was obtained by a large number of Taiwanese after decades of armed struggle with the Kuomintang to defeat the Kuomintang autocratic regime. Therefore, in the face of the Communist Party's invasion of Taiwan, moderate Taiwanese will be organized, disciplined and bravely when needed, and will not let China succeed in invading Taiwan.
China is not going to take Kinmen because (1) Kinmen has very close relationship with China, many locals support one China policy, have relatives in Xiamen, even bought houses in Xiamen, and the drinking water there is supplied by mainland China; (2) China wants to take over Taiwan, is not interested in these small islands, the CCP worries that Taiwan unification will be harder if these islands are taken over by China, these islands serve as bridges between China and Taiwan, that is why China never touches these islands near Chinese coast.😅 The ROC used to have two provinces, namely Taiwan and Fujian, Kinmen island was ruled under ROC’s Fujian province, however later on the ROC government abandoned provincial governments.😂
我是台灣人,但是我也是中國人..I am a man born and grown up in Taiwan but I am still a Chinese...I support Taiwan united with mainland China as soon as possible ..thanks for sharing :)
常常看到你們有騎樓不走，走在大馬路上，你們是不是不知道台灣的騎樓是設計給行人走的？有騎樓的地方還是盡量走騎樓比較安全，下雨天還不會淋到雨。騎樓 means the arcades, the spaces under the building overhangs, they are designed for pedestrians by laws, safer and convenient, especially when it rains.
Your right! 😅 I really only look at USD charts and I remembered how the RMB has lost value to the USD since 2013. I recently read a headline praising the NTD but when I looked at the charts its also weaker to the USD in recent years, in the 10 year span the NTD is about the same though
as an israeli, please learn from our mistakes. you can know that an invasion can 100% happen and still don't believe it will come until its too late. continue living your life, but never be too relaxed or believe that something cant happen.
The PRC has been involved in wars on the Korean peninsula; they annexed Tibet in the name of "liberating" the people there; they quarelled with the Soviets; they had border wars with India; they invaded Vietnam; they are harrassing the Philippines; they have annexed some of Bhutan's territory; they are constantly poking at Japan. It's almost like there is a pattern here.
I think you are a little naive when it comes to semi-conductors, about China's advancement in the technology, and about the future willingness of Europe(especially ASML), Japan, Korea, and......TSMC..... to sell to China in the future. In fact, the US got angry with TSMC last year when its components were found in Huawei's AI chips. Doesn't TSMC still have their factory in China, they haven't packed up and gone yet, have they?? There is one TSMC factory in the US already, and no doubt huge pressure is likely to be placed on Taiwan to further increase production in the US. The US goal is the production of high grade chips there as part of their national security policy. Once that happens, how much will they still need Taiwan? Will Taiwanese leaders bow to the pressure, surely they won't be that dumb? President DT has made it very clear to allies of the US that the game has changed, threatening them all with tariffs. So I think both of you are a little complacent.
Thank you for another good episode. What Uncle Topher talks about is good common sense. I hope he's right but as we know, common sense doesn't always prevail in Taiwan otherwise the result of our 2024 legislative elections would have been very different. And Xi Jinping has done a lot of things that defy common sense. As many of your followers are Taiwanese, I hope you wouldn't mind me finding fault with the subtitles -- which may be the work of AI -- in which human intelligence was translated as 人類智慧.
At the end of the day we are all the same people so really that whole "cultural invasion" stuff is a bit inevitable and by your logic you should also be concerned about people celebrating chinese new year in taiwan too because that's "too chinese".
Taiwan is currently using the name "Republic of China", which was founded by Sun Yat-sen, a Chinese. So, where does the claim of "China invading Taiwan" come from?
Taiwan is different from Ukraine. Ukraine is a sovereign and independent country recognized by the United Nations, but Taiwan is not. An American and a Canadian are advocating Taiwan independence in Taiwan!
Always fun chatting with you! Let's see how many sponsors you lose now because you talk to me 😂
www
haha jokes on you, I didn't have any to begin with
謝謝，謝謝，我是台灣人，要是真的需要一戰我也會站出來的，雖然我的年紀已經除役了。
沒錯..中國目前很難軍隊入侵台灣
所以..用立委入侵
Has no one ever took a hot minute to read and understand Peace Treaty of San Francisco 1952?
No one owns Taiwan and Penghu except the Taiwanese , both chinas have no claim to Taiwan since 1895.
Topher還是一如既往地務實理性～真的很喜歡聽他說話
小紅書讓美國人親身體驗到共產式言論自由真的很讚😎
說真的金馬選出來的立委真的讓人非常失望，尤其是陳玉珍，但也不能把金馬送給中共白白便宜敵人，而且說真的中共也沒很想要這兩塊地，金馬送給中共就是一個沒用的區而已，目前覺得比較好的解方只有把金馬改為軍事專區，取消立委席次
讓金馬人簽屬轉換國籍協議，想當中國人就盡快，政府協助您
直接像你說轉換成軍事專區，嚴加打擊偷渡和走私
大家都知道金馬人一堆都靠中國走私賺錢，所以一心向中國不意外
哈哈哈，是YT式言论自由吧，不知道你能不能看见。
我有一個想法不知是否可行，金門以前的存在是為了對抗中共，後來因為解嚴徹軍失去地位，金門人也一直夾在中台之間而感到不安，可否將金馬設為戰略特別行政區，必要時可割捨（當然要依法），並鼓勵金馬人民遷台？
@@f15tomy3 中共到时候跟美国商量，用加拿大换台湾，川普商人属性，估计会点头。
@ 请问你超过14岁了吗？
不敢相信二個外國人對台灣與中國的了解與政治局勢比很多台灣人還要了解！
分析的很正確👍🏻 台灣人真的要加油團結！
I just gonna saving this video, every time when any fellow Canadian worrisome and anxious asked me about this question that I’ve been answering millions of times. I can save my time and make them watch it. Thanks guys, great video. 👍
I'm Bruneian汶萊人🇧🇳.I support Taiwan!🇧🇳🤝🇹🇼
Cool I'm a Pisces
@Prozzie hi,me too
What do you support? The US says Taiwan is a part of China. Are you going to your US embassy and protest?
@@ROCnotforsale 美國稱台灣是中國的一部分,什麼時候?什麼文件?
@@ROCnotforsale hi,who say leh?R u dare to speak Chinese wf me?U this mdrfkr little pink
謝謝你們🫡🫡🫡
Wish you a fruitful and prosperous year!!
Topher is the perfect person to have talking about this issue and he’s completely right about everything he says.
I ever been Air Force soldier, we are fearless
好厲害 謝謝
相信你，加油，争取打下十架无人机。
放心，我是現役的，我會拼死保護國家，絕不投降，縱然應該會有不少人不以為意，但我會站第一線。
感謝你❤❤❤
T _ T 哥 你最帥
我也站第一線，62歲，
保護一個連美國都不承認的國家? 幾十億幾百億這樣花的? 美國一直以來說啥? 不支持台灣獨立. 台灣既然不獨立哪來的國家?
放心吧！你面对的会是一只机器狗。
有陳玉珍在，台灣人漸漸的想放棄金門了。
應該也放棄澎湖，小琉球，綠島，藍嶼和龜山島。😂
@@icebaby6714你說的地方沒有陳玉珍
中國人都不用說~器官就能放棄他們
不是台灣人想放棄金門 是金門人只差沒公投而已😂
@@icebaby6714你說的這些人 出國說英文的時候 都說自己是Taiwanese 😂
感謝兩位的深入分析😄
Thank you for talking about this topic🙏
TikTok is not banned in Taiwan though.
Stay and fight
Great perspective fellas. Thanks for posting Prozzie.
I'm visiting Taiwan in June. Please, no invasions, earthquakes or typhoons during that time.
Man, that is a planetary event. Polar shift is happening. Instead, I dont recommend Southern Europe or Israel, WW3 will break out from those places.
有xx人預言2025/7月,日本會有大地震!
地震跟颱風很難說😅😅
❤You guys were walking in my old neighborhood ❤❤❤
From a Taiwanese currently resides in Canada 🇨🇦
4:12 雖然很多人不喜歡聽到，但我還是要說：立法院正在降低這個代價
罷免不能停
看完這部影片，讓我更確信
中共現階段無法打台灣只能騙或買台灣
所以中共目前對台方針就是瘋狂統戰工作與洗認知作戰
直到成功從內部破壞台灣或國民黨取得政權後才有可能達成他們的目的
而剩下的唯一可能發生戰爭的情況
就只有習近平發瘋了，不計任何代價，就是要入侵台灣而已
因為但凡能稍微動點腦去權衡一下利弊
就知道武力犯台是百害而無一利的一件事
所以唯有領導人發瘋了才有可能發生戰爭
不要低估共軍的軍力。中共每年的軍費是台灣16倍，其實中國在過去20年已經做好了攻台的準備，建大量航母，能直立發射大量飛彈的大型054 和 055 驅逐艦，大量潛艦，大量殲20，殲35戰機，空對空500公里的遠程飛彈，能避開雷達在空中轉換軌道的10-15馬赫的極音速飛彈，能覆蓋美國本土全境的洲際飛彈，能擊沉美國航母的射程3000公里的「航母殺手」飛彈。共軍在對面的福建沿海就有5個無人機基地，並準備在2030年前再建造一百萬架自殺無人機。共軍的大型遠程無人機從2023年開始在台灣東部出沒並能在空中停留24小時。共軍犯台並不困難只是要防備美日可能會從北從東從南介入，所以，共軍要建多個航母戰鬥群在台灣的北東南對付美軍的軍事介入。日本新首相石破茂即將訪中，他最近告訴中共台灣有事並非日本有事。
其實...我覺得....你錯很大
首先
中國政府跟中國民眾你已經分不清
第二 你對國民黨的認知很...幼稚
沒有一個自己能爽爽執政的黨會想被人騎在頭上的
沒有
要是那麼白癡他們也弄不了政治
再來
其實台灣在軍事上給中國競賽其實是明顯輸的只能依賴美日去恐嚇平衡
在經濟上因為對岸體量大所以如果不看平均其實台灣經濟是遠遜對岸
可是！！
有一樣東西我們是遠超的優勢
那就是民主自由的生活跟文化還有包容度
所以要威脅中國？
😂麻煩盡量讓對岸孩子來臺讀書讓他們來台灣觀光
對岸的政治多脆弱？
一張白紙都能威脅他們的程度
所以？
我們怕個屁統戰？老共才怕好嗎？
台灣的存在正是證明華人是可以民主的而且民主是過的更好的是可以沒有黨都能活的
這才是老共會怕的
@@icebaby6714我是大陆人，但我觉得他说的有一定道理，就是如果我们要打你们肯定是扛不住的，但是我们打不打你们也就在我们家门口，不会像一艘船一样跑到美国边上，而且短期来看确实没有什么能崛起的可能性，所以放着在这儿保持着干涉但是不直接入侵是比较明智的做法，一旦动武了西方一定会大肆宣传加制裁，目前经济本身全球都在下降，打了只会更糟。
无法打台湾?你台湾是什么超人吗
我們要實現真民主，這次罷免行動不能再置身事外，把不適任的立委趕出去
謝謝你們的分享與介紹❤❤❤
TikTok is not banned in Taiwan. Many teachers don't bother playing video clips from TikTok in school and that should be one of the reasons Chinese influence can be so strong today. (Many school teachers are pro KMT.)
⭕對中國來說，金門和馬祖是證明台灣與中國大陸不可分割的臍帶，如果佔領金門馬祖，那麼台灣就可以立刻宣布獨立，那麼中國打台灣就師出無名，變成侵略者，而不是同一個國家的內政問題，只有直接打台灣的統一戰爭才可行，但中國要評估的是打台灣，是不是等於和美國宣戰，這樣的代價是不是負擔的起。
就算退一萬步不提美國，中共也該擔心它能不能成功地執行兩棲登陸作戰，這可是人類史上傷亡最大又難度最高的作戰方式……以解放軍的實力恐怕很難，最近習還一直以貪腐之名清洗軍隊高層
自古以來..拿下台灣..根本不用花一兵一卒...1895年..清朝北洋艦队.被日本打敗了....男無情女無義鳥不語花不香瘴癘之島..割給了日本
二戰時美國打敗日本..把台灣給了蔣介石..
所以打敗美國了..台灣就屬於戰胜美國的人所有..
傻B才打台灣..根本不用打...打敗美國即可
美国又不敢和中国打，中国近海美国现在敢来吗😂
@@hyjcxyz 笑死人了 害怕的是中共。
中國不怕哪會在那邊叫囂幾十年武統還在原地踏步
中国留着金马不收复，就是安插在台湾里面的一枚棋子!
My friend is a retired navy captain. He said don’t worry.
謝謝你製作這影片❤
又來看Prozzie了，廢話不多說趕緊先按個讚
謝謝！
As an American who has lived in Taiwan for over 20 years, I've had to deal with constant worries about this issue from my family back in the States. Especially my father. I've had countless arguments with him as he just listens to the U.S. media fearmonger about an imminent Chinese invasion into Taiwan.
This reached its climax when Putin invaded Ukraine. He was convinced that Xi would follow suit and launch an invasion into Taiwan. Anytime I tune into "analyses" on U.S. media outlets, I constantly hear the idea that any weakness shown by the U.S. towards the Ukraine invasion will signal to Xi that similar weakness will be shown to an invasion of Taiwan. These "analysts" seemingly have no understanding of the gigantic differences between the Taiwan/China situation and the Ukraine/Russia situation.
1. Geography: Taiwan is, of course, an island. Not only that, it is an island that would be extremely difficult to launch any sort of amphibious assault on. Anyone who has lived here knows how few locations there are around Taiwan where it would be feasible to unload a boots-on-the-ground military force. In Ukraine, Putin just drove his tanks and vehicles up to the border and told them to cross.
2. History: The status quo in Taiwan/China relations has been largely stagnant for 80 years whereas the relationship between Ukraine and Russia has been in constant flux since the breakup of the USSR.
3. Economic Status: Taiwan plays a much larger role in the world economy than Ukraine ever has. Not to mention, any actual military invasion of Taiwan would end up destroying the entire reason that China would like to control it: its semiconductor production capabilities.
4. The People: The areas of Ukraine that Putin is trying to cease control of were already engaged in a civil war with the central Ukrainian government and are home to large groups of people who are sympathetic to or even pushing for being part of Russia. That is just not the case in Taiwan. Outside of maybe Jinmen or Matszu, there is no sympathy for CCP rule in Taiwan. In fact, there is widespread detest of anything having to do with mainland China in Taiwan.
Do these reasons mean that it's impossible that China will ever invade Taiwan? No. But I do think it is highly unlikely. The only thing that could possibly motivate China to invade Taiwan would be "losing face." If Taiwan were to declare independence on the international stage or if some major countries were to recognize Taiwan independence, they might feel that their hand is forced. But I don't see that happening.
為什麼要在路上邊走邊錄製影片？有點危險‼️在公園比較安全！
兩位說的話太好了太好了我愛你們
说的不错，只可惜要是真打起来，这俩货跑的比谁都快，就跟八炯不当兵，骗了台湾几个亿的雷神公司胡振东天天吹牛逼一样
I'm in Taiwan right now boss Taichung
Taiwan is safe
Look, the frog is well cooked.
Love both of you ❤❤
垃圾車是固定好的路線 ! 他們有他們的範圍而且時間是固定的，會繞街，你們剛好是在收垃圾的時間採訪，一直繞圈圈沒有出範圍就會遇到😂
看到街景你們是在華美街、中美街還有美村路，那邊就是以前美援與美軍顧問團駐台時代在台中的駐點喔 ! 而且還有公益路上的日式裕毛屋， 附近也有不少日本人
存中街與美術綠園道、經國綠園道兩旁的，當年標榜的就是在美軍高級住宅區的高級別墅，以前因為那邊美軍軍眷住的地方，所以道路都有個 " 美 " 名，歡迎歡迎 !
周圍也有很多舞廳、教會，我以前上課念書也住那邊，我的房東阿姨就是很虔誠的基督教徒，就是巷子很小塞滿了人車
因為附近就是SOGO、綠園道，平日就差不多這樣，假日去更是滿滿滿都是人，活動也很多，爵士音樂節都也辦在市民廣場那邊，外國人很多
那每天就要抽时间在固定时间去丢垃圾吗？
@@王锦超 對 垃圾不落地政策
沒追到垃圾車也沒關係 也有定時定點的垃圾車
Taiwan's democracy was obtained by a large number of Taiwanese after decades of armed struggle with the Kuomintang to defeat the Kuomintang autocratic regime. Therefore, in the face of the Communist Party's invasion of Taiwan, moderate Taiwanese will be organized, disciplined and bravely when needed, and will not let China succeed in invading Taiwan.
希望有足够多的台湾人去当兵，否则所有口号都像笑话。这和民进党一个风格，反中口号震天响，几艘海巡船转转就老实了，哈哈哈哈哈
Love that last clip. Headed to Uptowner? 😉
China is not going to take Kinmen because (1) Kinmen has very close relationship with China, many locals support one China policy, have relatives in Xiamen, even bought houses in Xiamen, and the drinking water there is supplied by mainland China; (2) China wants to take over Taiwan, is not interested in these small islands, the CCP worries that Taiwan unification will be harder if these islands are taken over by China, these islands serve as bridges between China and Taiwan, that is why China never touches these islands near Chinese coast.😅 The ROC used to have two provinces, namely Taiwan and Fujian, Kinmen island was ruled under ROC’s Fujian province, however later on the ROC government abandoned provincial governments.😂
well said
Ray Dalio thinks there's a 30-40% chance of a significant Taiwan conflict this decade (blockade, invasion, etc).
Dalio的投資很看好中國，他的言論只能看看，真正還得實際評估戰爭的利弊得失，為了台灣冒著中國內部分裂有人趁機造反，若不是瘋了，正常人不敢冒這風險，最好就是扶植親共政權，像國眾兩黨現正在做的事
感謝分享🙏
More young Taiwanese should watch this video😢
I don't think many in Ukraine were worried either....
Because Taiwanese has no choice, worry or not worry makes no difference.
What we Taiwanese prepared for war are the same as what we prepared for earthquake, typhoon, flood and Pandemic.
看街景，這裡是中美街跟華美街，我以前住這裡六年，哇~ 好懷念呀
老共如果入侵金門，陳玉珍就不能當立委了～笑死🤣
對！但有沒有可能她期待的，其實一直是人大代表？😂
他為了當人大代表這兩天還跑去廈門發春聯呢！
有人說她想當金門特首~過去國民黨投共都下場很慘，陳玉珍最好燒香祈禱自己不會被自殺、被心臟病、被貪瀆坐牢........
@@WishPeace4ever她這種智商，沒有台灣人身分以後對對面還能有什麼價值⋯
@@WishPeace4ever 她想太多了，中共不會給她當人大的，等兩邊打起來，中共願意讓她提鞋，就算很給她面子了
她還沒錢讓中共當韭菜呢
1st comment 🇹🇼
I mean young people are exactly that, young. I wouldn't expect them to be wise.
總人來說兩位好棒，訂閱 分享
4:32時提到的「牛B」，指的並不是公牛的生殖器。那個詞的正確用字其實是「牛屄」，望文生義你其實很容易了解原詞指的到底是哪個器官。
It's still weird in English regardless of what you call it 🤣
@@Prozzie 事實上，在中文中也是非常奇怪
我始終很困惑為何中共會將之代稱為一種讚揚用語
@@windcloudcamel我在中國的社交網絡上有一個賬號😊這個其實是非常粗鄙的表達
中國很多用語都是非常粗鄙的……牛B就是其中之一，這詞粗鄙到台灣人在被中國用語嚴重影響的情況下也不會跟著喊
之前還看到中國人把漂亮稱為「媽生好皮」的，指「媽生的好皮囊」，實在是太過俗氣，支持台灣人繼續使用「天生麗質」😅
挑中美街拍這個主題
問題是中美街車多
建議走靜巷車少收音也好😅
我想不只外國人在乎 連外星人也在乎
我是台灣人,但是我也是中國人..I am a man born and grown up in Taiwan but I am still a Chinese...I support Taiwan united with mainland China as soon as possible ..thanks for sharing :)
如果你聽過_放羊的小孩_你就知道為什麼我們台灣人沒甚麼反應了！
有反应又能怎么样呢？只能破罐子破摔
政府真的要禁tittalk，否則發布太多假訊息，太洗腦了
，我只能说，所有美国APP里的洗脑假讯息比那个多100倍，猜猜谁喜欢受骗？
Spy inside
人行道都被車子堵住超尷尬😅
11:05 I think in here, "human intelligence" means "人力情報" ？
常常看到你們有騎樓不走，走在大馬路上，你們是不是不知道台灣的騎樓是設計給行人走的？有騎樓的地方還是盡量走騎樓比較安全，下雨天還不會淋到雨。騎樓 means the arcades, the spaces under the building overhangs, they are designed for pedestrians by laws, safer and convenient, especially when it rains.
台中騎樓障礙物多 只好走馬路
台灣的騎樓常常很多障礙物 而且地面會忽高忽低沒有統一規劃 有時候還有人騎摩托車跑出來 還有小吃擺攤 超難走的
台中的騎樓很多是高低差很多，或是某一段圍起來，或是商家貨品堆在騎樓，真的非常難走！！！
他们是美国爸爸，横着走
yes
7:18 this is not correct. NTD actually declined slightly against the RMB over recent years. Maybe Topher is mixing it up with Japanese Yen?
台幣兌美元也快要33了
Your right! 😅 I really only look at USD charts and I remembered how the RMB has lost value to the USD since 2013. I recently read a headline praising the NTD but when I looked at the charts its also weaker to the USD in recent years, in the 10 year span the NTD is about the same though
All currencies are dropping against the dollar right now, aren't they?
Keep your stick on the ice! 🇨🇦🇨🇦
as an israeli, please learn from our mistakes. you can know that an invasion can 100% happen and still don't believe it will come until its too late. continue living your life, but never be too relaxed or believe that something cant happen.
I would be a fun conversation for the Canadian and the American talk about Trump and his tariffs and his 51st state “offer”.
What happened in Korea could be considere an internal coup.
臺灣人、臺灣的孩子、臺灣的ㄓㄥ\ ㄉㄤv , 都要有 ㄈㄤ/ ㄈㄢ\ 意識 才行。❤拜託，不要再 ㄏㄨㄚ/ ㄉㄡv 一ㄣ了❤
讚同豆腐叔叔分析台灣被中國統治將會一無所有的想法，豆腐叔叔可以在自己頻道再說一次🎉
Honestly, lm more worry about Usa stupidity than china. Can someone tell me how many wars china started or provoked
大约是美国的1/100
how many isnt relevant ! constantly bullying taiwan is annoying enough ...doesnt it count? provoke
The PRC has been involved in wars on the Korean peninsula; they annexed Tibet in the name of "liberating" the people there; they quarelled with the Soviets; they had border wars with India; they invaded Vietnam; they are harrassing the Philippines; they have annexed some of Bhutan's territory; they are constantly poking at Japan. It's almost like there is a pattern here.
@@stein0610 当台湾当政者抱紧美国爸爸，处处与大陆为敌的时候，大陆轰炸过台湾城市？枪杀过台湾人？只能说皮痒痒找打的就是你们！
speaking of information bubble,,,,,
I think you are a little naive when it comes to semi-conductors, about China's advancement in the technology, and about the future willingness of Europe(especially ASML), Japan, Korea, and......TSMC..... to sell to China in the future. In fact, the US got angry with TSMC last year when its components were found in Huawei's AI chips. Doesn't TSMC still have their factory in China, they haven't packed up and gone yet, have they??
There is one TSMC factory in the US already, and no doubt huge pressure is likely to be placed on Taiwan to further increase production in the US. The US goal is the production of high grade chips there as part of their national security policy. Once that happens, how much will they still need Taiwan? Will Taiwanese leaders bow to the pressure, surely they won't be that dumb? President DT has made it very clear to allies of the US that the game has changed, threatening them all with tariffs. So I think both of you are a little complacent.
你认为台湾政府不够愚蠢吗？我觉得美国爸爸要做的事，他们只能硬着头皮也要做，看看特朗普如何吸血吧，反正反共就好了，自杀都无所谓。
Liberation from American influence, sounds like a bright future
No worry, with America around no one dare to touch Taiwan except nature
去過金門一次，上面多少台灣人？都是中國人，拿著台灣的福利養的中國人。
影片走在台灣的路上沒人行道可走，汽車也會按喇叭趕人，不趕人就是行駛在雙黃線。台灣交通爛那麼久為什麼一直不改???
問個問題?如果有一天台灣只有剩綠、然後中共發現無法【和統】
所以中共發動武統第一步:中共圍台【圍而不打】台灣這時怎麼辦?
更大声的喊口号啊！民进党最有能力的做法。
Thank you for another good episode. What Uncle Topher talks about is good common sense. I hope he's right but as we know, common sense doesn't always prevail in Taiwan otherwise the result of our 2024 legislative elections would have been very different. And Xi Jinping has done a lot of things that defy common sense.
As many of your followers are Taiwanese, I hope you wouldn't mind me finding fault with the subtitles -- which may be the work of AI -- in which human intelligence was translated as 人類智慧.
Which dictator in history care about people?
事情都要分析，怕是有人被滲透，不然臺灣為這一刻已經準備幾十年了，以前全部男人都要當1至3年兵役，誰廢除兵役跟不買武器不投入武器研發或製造，我都認為是中共同路人
Hi guys, I'm still wondering, does Canada belong to USA 😁
So many Americans coming to Canada now, we need to build a wall to keep them out.
No.
美國隊長下次，可以找斯伐洛克大隊長聊政治😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
🙂🙂🙂
👍👍
Ｂ應該是女生的，牛是指很厲害。不是指牛的那個，Ｂ只是語助詞。
任何仇恨散播與戰爭宣傳
都來自那些不用上戰場的人
人類6000年文明史
幾千幾萬個國家已經消失
但是漢摩拉比法典與混凝土技術被留了下來
體量大 技術強 分配制度好的國家自然會留下來
若是打不過加入就好
何必白白犧牲性命
傳承先賢的思想與技術
人類文明仍會持續下去
來自：兩個兒子的台灣爸爸
我從孩子到中年，對岸都說要入侵台灣快50年了，還有飛彈恐嚇😂😂
你是必需见血才舒服?
TikTok is not banned in Taiwan, lots of kids are still using it 😢😢😢. It really should’ve been banned.
擔憂只出現在1986年。之後，隨時備戰狀態一直都存在台灣人的生活。即便中國目前想用文化經濟娛樂等方面入侵台灣進而漸漸同化台灣人。那也不會成功的。
🎉
我还记得你以前的视频当中说，如果发生战争，你不会离开台湾。那问题来了，如果战争结果不符合你的预期，你是否会离开台湾？
很多臉書跟我吵架的親中人士，我點進去看他們生活照很多都是年輕人，這類人令我很擔憂。
為什麼跟你吵架就是親中人士?? 為什麼不是中華民國人士?
@ 因為就是像你這種為了酸而酸，我都說了我去看過他臉書讚揚共黨，你是腦袋有什麼問題？
因為就跟你這種為了酸而酸一樣，我都說過去看過他臉書，你腦袋到底有什麼問題？
真心希望你们能战斗到最后一刻
不知道是不是你做補習班的原因，不過你的觀察滿入微的，確實以前台灣人不知道，就算知道也不會用牛比這個詞
留言笑壞阿嬤了！中國網民留言真是沒禮貌😂😂
與其擔心中國軍隊 , 不如多擔心台灣行人...走在路上還更危險..XD
應該擔心台灣的內奸，國民黨跟民眾黨
😂馬路三寶更猛
現在還多一個毒駕
喪屍煙彈感覺超氾濫啊！
我是个大陆的游戏开发者，从个人感情上是希望和平能够一直维持，因为人们的安定生活才是最重要的。毕竟无论什么样的政体都是为了人的生活服务的。不过感觉现在的气氛确实开始针锋相对。。。希望大家都能过得好，不要吵架打架哈哈
事實上真的是這樣。只是總是有政權要為了鞏固帝制傳統而不斷的想搞事以讓某群既得利益群體能一直傳承下去，甚至不惜犧牲自己國家人民的各層面⋯
很遺憾，真的不是什麼政體都是為了人民服務的。
只能祈禱有個愛好和平的有權者來推翻黨囉~
@@好不-i8c不可能的，中共的逆淘汰機制注定能得到權力的都不會是好東西，而是習近平之流的庸才，政府又完全掌控暴力機制和監控系統，能把平民反抗的苗頭直接掐死
@@yctsai9500不如說為人民服務的政體是少數吧，在人類漫長的歷史中獨裁一直都是主流
😂你們做遊戲不要他喵的死課金會怎樣！！！
😂終於給我逮到一個可以罵的遊戲開發了！！！
At the end of the day we are all the same people so really that whole "cultural invasion" stuff is a bit inevitable and by your logic you should also be concerned about people celebrating chinese new year in taiwan too because that's "too chinese".
过年了，又出来组团要饭了
假性文化"殖民"冷靜想清楚看似是中文這跟原本台灣中文文意是平行世界,逃難出來國人都是基本上是很難溝通不是被同化或是同化走在世界基本法則
你是？ ：0
Taiwan is currently using the name "Republic of China", which was founded by Sun Yat-sen, a Chinese. So, where does the claim of "China invading Taiwan" come from?
Taiwan is different from Ukraine. Ukraine is a sovereign and independent country recognized by the United Nations, but Taiwan is not. An American and a Canadian are advocating Taiwan independence in Taiwan!
他們鼓吹不讓獨裁入侵
Canada is ready to become a state of the United States, and it is still here to talk about the Taiwan issue. Go home and defend your country.😂