Atheism Islam God Allah | Open Q/A & Conversation | Ask Shaykh Asrar Episode 3
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ก.ค. 2024
- 0:00 - Introduction
1:53 - Hanafi Usul in Fiqh
4:37 - Logical fallacy of Atheists
5:38 - Difference between miracles & magic
7:20 - The Nuzul and Saaq of Allah
11:11 - Is Allah everywhere?
13:04 - Zakat and jewellery of women in the Shafi’i school
13:46 - View On Ibn Kathir
15:38 - Navigating the End of Times reprint
15:51 - Can we say Allah is everywhere?
18:14 - What do we say to a child that asks ‘where is Allah?’
19:24 - Understanding of statements such as ‘a light from the light of Allah’?
21:32 - Preservation Of The Prayer.
28:29 - Ruling on the one who doesn’t pray
28:56 - Freewill and Allah’s power
30:07 - The age of Sayyidah ‘Aishah رضي الله عنها
32:09 - Sulayman bin ‘Abd al-Wahhab
33:23 - The arguments from Fitrah for the existence of Allah
34:40 - Books for beginners
36:10 - Update on the debate with the Qadiyanis
36:50 - Zakat and mortgage
37:24 - The law regarding apostates
39:14 - Israel Is Losing The War
39:34 - The striking mentioned in Surah al-Nisa
40:46 - Awrad & Palestine
42:07 - What happens to America before Imam al-Mahdi
43:24 - Father doesn’t pray and shaves his beard
44:06 - Books on Islamic Economy
44:40 - Homonyms in the Qur’an
45:30 - Choosing a opinion in the Hanafi school
47:03 - Shaykh Ramadan Sa’id al-Buti and the Syrian Regime
49:46 - The impossibility of Allah lying
50:20 - ADHD, Bipolar and sins
51:24 - Are the Taliban from Ahl al-Sunnah?
53:32 - Shaykh Asrar’s favourite chip shop
54:05 - Tahsin and Taqbih
55:33 - ‘Allamah Ghulam Rasul Sa’idi
56:21 - Who’s the funniest scholar?
56:33 - Advice on increasing memory
57:38 - Was Pakistani State Secular
59:23 - Du’a request
1:00:29 - Where to read about Islam’s response to poverty
1:00:56 - What stage of the end of times are we in?
1:01:08 - Did the Qadiyanis reach out for a debate?
1:01:30 - How do we explain that Allah exists without a place?
1:01:59 - The title of ‘Shaykh’
1:02:59 - Balancing GCSEs and studies
1:03:43 - Question on advice on starting a cult
1:04:17 - Reading Qur’an for those who have passed away
1:04:24 - Response to Ali Dawah
1:05:08 - Trimming the beard less than a fist length
1:05:20 - Intentions for studying the Deen
1:05:41 - Was the Nur of the Prophet ﷺ the first creation?
1:06:41 - The Najdi destruction of the al-Baqi’ cemetery
1:08:02 - Growing the mustache without a beard
1:09:39 - Working at a valet company
1:10:19 - Can we visit al-Baqi’
1:11:34 - Saifi Tariqah
1:12:15 - Reciting Surah Yasin at the graves
1:13:15 - Starting a Tariqah
1:13:44 - Shaykh Asrar and Shaykh Sayyid Muhammad ‘Alawi al-Maliki
1:14:11 - Are Jinns made of electricity
1:14:53 - Reciting Ayat al-Kursi each time you get into bed
1:15:22 - Will the Caliphate be re-established before Imam al-Mahdi
1:15:51 - Ibn Taymiyyah’s accusation on Imam al-Razi
1:17:13 - Hanafis & Raf'ay-yadayn
1:17:58 - Is it Haram to use numerology?
1:19:27 - Democratic elections
1:20:40 - The Hadith about the fall of Constantinople?
1:21:45 - Yemenis and Houthis
1:23:09 - Who should we support in elections in Europe?
1:23:37 - The splitting of the moon
1:24:27 - Have all thirty Dajjals appeared before the final one?
1:25:12 - Visiting Shaykh Asrar
1:25:39 - The Zaydi school of thought
1:26:52 - Does everyone have the same opportunity to embrace Islam?
1:27:57 - The Du’a for having a baby boy and raising children
1:29:31 - Exaggerating Shuyukh
1:30:34 - Are hair transplants Halal?
1:31:09 - Sitting with Hamza Yusuf and Nuh Keller
1:32:35 - Ibn Qudamah and the Ash’aris
1:34:11 - Is missing salah kufr? What Is Qada?
1:35:12 - Our position on Ibn Taymiyyah
1:36:54 - Should Muslim countries consider joining BRICS?
1:37:08 - The Sunni position on the Battle of Siffin and the Battle of Karbala
1:39:11 - Is Ibn ‘Abd al-Wahhab an apostate?
1:39:43 - The purpose of life
1:40:30 - Are all democratically elected Muslim presidents Kuffar?
1:41:11 - Arranging a meeting with Shaykh Asrar
1:41:42 - How does one actualise Allah’s existence?
1:43:10 - Books for learning Ibarat
1:43:24 - The misguidance of Osama bin Laden
1:44:56 - Missing three Jumm’ah prayers
1:45:44 - How long did it take to speak Arabic?
1:46:47 - Evidence for celebrating Mawlid
1:48:55 - What should we invest in?
1:49:21 - Does ‘Isha end at midnight?
1:49:54 - What is classed as Qaza’ haircut?
1:51:45 - Did Ibn Taymiyyah retract?
1:52:12 - Hadith about the donkey of al-Dajjal
1:52:55 - Studying Christmas Carols in school
1:53:29 - Is it permissible to watch the ‘Omar’ series?
1:53:43 - Books for Dars-e-Nizami students
1:54:49 - Shaykh Dr. Ayman Suwayd
1:55:52 - Taking knowledge from Salih al-Fawzan
1:56:01 - Discussion on Islam, atheism and doubts
1:58:15 - Shaykh ‘Uthman Dan Fodio
1:58:39 - Decrease in Iman from doubts and the solution
2:00:50 - Leaving Sunnah prayers
2:01:30 - Are all three schools of theology from Ahl al-Sunnah?
2:02:08 - Do doubts take you out of Islam?
2:03:01 - When is the Niqab Fard?
Timestamps have been added in the description.
Subhanallah ﷻ ♥️ shaykh
Good job admin, you getting better
Jazakallahu Khair..much needed
Salaam. Sheikh, I wanted to ask you a question. I hope you can answer it in some detail in the future. The question is: if someone is an atheist, or is in doubt about the existence of God, then can we use the "Pascal's wager" argument to try and bring him to theism? Secondly, will a person's decision to believe in God merely as a consequence of the Pascal's wager actually even count as faith according to Islam?
MashaAllah may Allah bless you shykh in this life and hereafter ..your suggestion for Indian Muslims under these circumstances when they are oppression.
every single session of sheikh asrar is enlightening ! one day I will visit him inshallah I am from Germany
insha'Allah
So true
One day?visit him immediately you are in the heart of Europe and he is in the heart of Europe
@@mohammadjatoi8662as he said one day. Shaykh Asrar is very busy
@@mohammadjatoi8662 I would but can’t find where in Birmingham and how to contact him before
By Allah this is the truth and this man is no liar. Allah increase him Rank ameen
I cannot wait to see the video in Hide Park. We need more Alhu Sunnat Wa'Jammat English speakers out there.
Time stamps are necessary in all lectures
Sheikh asrar rashid is the biggest nightmare for wahabis/MADkhalis. Subhanallah allah has gave him beautiful knowledge with humbleness.
Maybe for them, but there is a broad spectrum. Whilst not being a salafi, I like most Muslims don't believe in nor do istighata to other than Allah, which this Sheikh promotes. It goes against the very foundation of Islam. Even though the sheikh mentions that the fitrah recognises the creator and is inclined to call upon him.
@@ishtiaq968 but what’s wrong with asking a human for help?
@@Tinolg7 don't try to play games. A human who is alive and present. Now tell you would you call out to your doctor for help, if he was in another town?
@@ishtiaq968If I would call an awliyah with the aqida that allah subhanahu wa taala has given his awliyah the power to hear the fariyad, what's wrong in this and what issue do you have?
The deobandis actually call istighatha haram and whatever, but one of their foundational aalim Rashid Ahmed Gangohi has written in his fatawas that if somebody calls Sheikh Abdul Qadir gilani rahimahullah with the belief that the allah subhanahu wa taala has given him the power to hear him and help him, it is completely jayaz.
I've already given you reference that awliyah are alive in their grave and also I had given you some references regarding istighatha......so what's the deal?
@@ishtiaq968 matter of fact I do! my dentist is in a different town who I see 🤷♂️ what’s your point? I know for 100% this sheikh has more knowledge than you with evidence aswel, I’m sure he mentioned that in one of the questions. You don’t have to follow his opinion about this matter simple as that 🤷♂️.
Thank you for the time stamps sheikh ❤
Love you Sir Shaykh Asrar Rashid ❤❤❤
I found his name on Green gate trust and SubhanAllah this man is gem!!
Green gate? Wdym?
Where?
Jzk Shaykh. May Allah SWT grant you barakah and increase you.
Thank you Mr Shaikh Asrar Rashid.. very direct and educational ❤
جزاك الله خيرا يا شيخ ❤
Jazakumallah Khair
I can’t wait for you to come to our mosque!
Jazakum Allah khair
Please Ya Shaykh Asrar more frequently talk about the Wearing of the Sunnah dress Turban the Ring & the Sunnah Stick or Staff
Especially no days the Wahabis & Salafis always talk about Sunnah Sunnah but were is there Sunnah dress. The power in the Sunnah dress code
If Ibn Abideen has called him sheikh al-Islam, it's to bring people's attention to him. It doesn't mean he accepts him as sheikh al-Islam. It's no different to people calling MIAW, Albani and others Sheikh
Sitting down with Sheikh Hamza Yusuf and Sheikh Nuh Keller would be very beneficial, as they have a significant following and have accomplished excellent work for Muslim youth in the West. Achieving unity requires humility and sincerity; ego will never allow for unity.
@MrRiz157 would highly recommend a genuine Sunni bro/sis to keep well away from those two filthy garbage human beings. Protecting one's imaan is number 1 priority
AssalamuAlaikum sheikh what advice would you offer to young individuals that are trying to establish their Nikkah but are denied this or delayed this right due to studies and other materialistic reasons such as "Needing a house, car, money" etc JazakhAllah Khair.
Does anyone have a link to “hizmet books” the shaykh reffered to?
Does anyone have link to the volumes books you can buy in Turkey?
Does Sheikh teach tafseer online?
When debating with a Christian how do we answer when they say “why are you limiting by saying he cannot limit himself to human form”
Test their consistency…
Ask them if god can cease to exist if god can really do anything?
If they are reasonable. They will realize that God will only do things that befit his majesty.
@@halaldigest they aren't reasonable 😂
The majority of Taliban are linked with deobandi madaris. I respect you call then ahle sunnah but barelwis would state that the fact the taliban leadership doesn't view deobandis as kafir then they too are kafir. Are you stating that as long as someone is hanafi and doesn't involve themselves in differences of what some deobandi scholars have allegedly said then that is fine? Even if those Taliban openly sit, pray behind and follow some deobandi scholars?
Deobandi means being Maturidi in Aqeeda and Hanafi in fiqh and a follower of one of the 4 schools of tasawwuf. That is Ahl as Sunnah. When the taliban are called deobandi that’s what it means, not the brelvi understanding of deoband.
Time stamps plzzz
In the description
Please add timestamps with questions
I second you❤
Or respect the sheikh and listen to the whole video instead of coming for your ego
@@electronicjihad what if i asked for it, so i can come back later to it in case i forgot the answer to a certain question? Would that make me an egoistic human being?
I am your sister from Yemen, and by Allah I only spoke out of hunger and distress. My mother, my brothers, and I lessons and tears. We are in a situation that only God knows about. God is sufficient for us, and He is the best disposer of affairs for those who brought us to this situation. By Allah Almighty, I did not write this appeal out of distress and distress. Poverty, O world, they have felt it So, I hope for you. By Allah Almighty, Lord of the Great Throne, he ate what I had in the house. By Allah, my brothers, he is my brothers by sitting in the house. Who has no food? By God, we are in a very difficult situation. We have 4 people entering the house, and my father has died, and there is no one who can depend on us and who lives in it.We live in a rented house because we cannot pay the rent we owe. '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''' My brother, my first words are: I swear to God that I will not lie to you or deceive you. I am a Yemeni girl displaced from the war. My family and I live in a rented house in Al-Shahrab 20,000 Yemenis among us, and now we owe 60,000 for 3 months. The owner of the house is one of the people who does not have mercy, by God, my brother. He comes every day, insulting us, talking about us, and moving from the house to the street because we were unable to pay him the rent. The neighbors saw us crying and came back.They came back to talk to the neighbors and we were given the weekend. So we made him swear by God. He will take us out into the street. Have mercy on him and us. Our country is due to this war and we do not find food for our day, and my brothers and I live in a difficult life. Our father died, may God have mercy on him, and we have no one in this world who was with us in these harsh circumstances. My younger brothers went out into the street and saw...The neighbors eat and stand at their door in order to give them bread even if they break it. By God, to whom belongs the dominion of the heavens and the earth, they closed the door and expelled them and came back crying. They are dying of hunger. No one has mercy on them and a holiday is returned. I have made a living, and now if one of us helps us with a kilo of flour, I swear to God, I am dying of hunger. My brother, I am an alien to God. Then, I ask you to help me for the sake of God. I ask you, by God, to love goodness and to help me, even if you can, by messaging me on WhatsApp.On this number 00967716649494 and ask for the name of my card and send it and do not be late and may God reward you with all the best, my brothers Sagar, see how they are and help us and save us before they throw us out in the street, you will be lost or we will die of hunger. My family and I ask you, by God, if you are able to help us, do not be late and may God reward you well..`/--~«««~-♡~♡~♡~~•~•~♡~♡~♡~♡~♡~♡♡♡~~~: ~:~¡~¡~¡~;I.i.i.i.i.i. i.I.|-◖˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹˛˹ː↿⁞ː&}↑]&}↑]&}↑]&}↑]&}↑]&}↑]&}↑]&}↑]&}↑]&}↑]^√:√|^^•\^π•°|\°\|\°|√|\√¶|°¶|√|¶|√\√|√|\\√|√\|√\|\√|√|\
Our Sunni fiqh books are filled with Sunnah. Take an effort to read them
He have to learn at tawheed. May Allah swa guide him to islam
Do u mean to say he does shirk ? If so, do u have any compelling reasons to say so. Fear Allah before you slander
How could Muhammad A.S say missing Jumuah prayers , when he did not do any of khutba ?
... yaum ul jumuah in the Qur'an is not Jumuah Salaah...
Thanks for the time stamps! As an atheist, I came to the video because of the title, and that's all I really want to address. So, let's see what you've got...
_"Can Allah create a person more powerful than him?"_
*That's* your "logical fallacy of atheists"? Really? Have you ever _met_ an atheist? Have you ever talked to one of us? Because that's just silly.
Note that nothing in that even _mentions_ atheists. And I suspect that no one older than ten or 12 would ask anything that silly, anyway. If _that's_ what you think atheists are asking, it's no wonder you think you have all the answers!
Here's _my_ question: How about one piece of good evidence, specific enough and in enough detail that I can judge it for myself, that your god is real, rather than just imaginary? Just *one,* please, but be specific. Why is *one* too much to ask? Why is *one* _always_ too much to ask?
Evidence is how we distinguish reality from delusion and wishful-thinking. So, basically, I'm just asking if you have anything - *anything* - distinguishable from wishful-thinking backing up your religious beliefs? Or is this just what you were taught to believe as a child, and you really, really _want_ it to be true?
Thanks again for the time stamps. But I _would_ like an answer to my question, if someone here would care to try to demonstrate *something* distinguishable from wishful-thinking backing up this stuff.
What do you suppose we do when you're looking for material evidence with sensory perception and we're not making a claim about a material god?
How does a scientist explain quantum theory to a caveman?
Yes, Shaykh have debates with atheists and wrote a profound book, "Islam Answers Atheism" . You should definitely check it
@@ayyubvernon1557
OK. So, nothing, then? You have *nothing* distinguishable from wishful-thinking backing up your religious beliefs? Well, that's why I can't take your religious claims seriously.
After all, claims are easy. _Every_ religion makes claims, just because of how easy it is to make claims. Typically, worldwide, which claims a theist believes almost always depends on which claims he was taught to believe as a child. So, _clearly,_ that's not a reliable path to the truth.
It's just a reliable path to wishful-thinking.
@@hamza_hasnat_hbk
Have _you_ read that book? Then how about an example? After all, there are far more books in the world than I'll ever have time to read. And most religious apologist books seem to be written to comfort believers, not convince atheists. So please show me that your book is worthwhile, with one specific example.
How about one piece of good evidence, specific enough and in enough detail that I can judge it for myself, that your god is real, rather than just imaginary? Just *one,* please. Why is *one* too much to ask?
Thanks for the reply.
Your Question is
" can Allah create a person more powerful than him ? "
Since your question is regarding Allah's power, Islam says Allah has absolute power not limited
1st answer :
Your question is like asking this question " can ( an absolute powerful being ) create a person or (a thing) more powerful than him ? "
- how can there be something more powerful than absolute powerful ? By definition it's impossibility
Last point I want to make : by definition and deductive reasoning there can only be a single absolute powerful not anymore than that, if there more than a single absolute powerful being then logically none of the supposed absolute powerful beings have absolute power
Great job for looking for answers of your doubts, if you agree to my answer please let me know but if you disagree then please provide your reasoning for your disagreement and counter arguments against my answer
wahabi's and deobandi's and sulla-qulli's and shiyah's have chosen to split off and isolate themselves from the continuing pure Islam from approx 1400 years ago, not sure why many bother to be nice to them and bend over backwards to accommodate them sometimes, best to let them be and wonder around in the pitch-black, if they genuinely ask for help or clarity then can assist them to best of one's ability. because I noticed Sunni bro's'/sis' get frustrated with each other and family members and start quibbling (arguing) amongst each other - because that wahabi / deobandi (tablighi) / sulla-qulli / shiyah 'energy' rubs off on them a bit (the two face'd-ness, the clumsy clown like joking manner, snide remarks)
Their weapons are so dangerous, that they try to persuade people that they are doing shirk. I think this is the primary cause of our frustration
Rasul Muhammad A.S never ever documented Hadith or Ahadith brother , get your language or facts correct please ... Do not think we discard it ... The way you portray it reflects your arrogance
Salamun Alaykum ...
Rafdi identified😂
You Scholars misrepresent and call everyone else mis guided ... Either get your wording precise or rather close your mouth , and restrain your tongue 👅
Shaykh Asrar is different
@@DocumentingMoments @I0888 - there is only one saved sect, and 72 other sects of Islam will be misguided/deviants. after we die on planet earth we will find out which was the saved sect of the Deen
@_Sensei_8 seems like the 72 has been surpassed by a larger number , hence everything can not be taken literal ...
I am not Brittish , I am South African ... we know and understand how the ideologies work , & how the British & Co influence our country...
As far as your quote from the narrations go , we accept it , but not blindly & not absolutely literal as in this case , else it's proven wrong ...
@DocumentingMoments We hope so IA... There was a dialogue/ debate with Mufti Laith Maliki that we viewed , and it did not sit very well with us ... Mufti's should be held in high regard , their faculties of knowledge are superior to most , irrespective of outer appearance...
Furthermore, Your Sheikh is very knowledgeable on a multitude of subjects , although he should know , above every knower is another knower ... So we don't become too rigid & arrogant , especially for our younger ones listening in...
@@I0888 perhaps its the 72 that has split off making it look like there is more than 72 as you said/have-observed-personally, but at the sub-root making it 72. either way there are a lot of misguided deviants sects who have decided to isloate themselves and seperate from true pure Islam and letting themselves be eaten by the wolf(s)
5:39 i think there needs to be a correction here; a mo’jza is basically a miraculous act done by a Prophet, it may or may not be imitable; while magic is done by magicians who are not claiming to be prophets; magic also doesn’t change the nature of a thing, while prophetic miracle does change it; magic is fooling the senses; and jinns are usually involved in magic. Magic can be defeated and it’s effects are cancelled by the death of the magician while the same is not true for a prophetic miracle.