Sir,1971 was more or less a repeat of 1947,only the players were different. In 1947 it was hindus vs muslims. In 1971 it was muslims(Punjabi,sindhis) vs muslims(bengalis). Both historical events were extremely painful and yet inevitable with trauma. Time,history,nations do not stop moving and changing and there is no alternative except to move on.
Gheroon KO morad ilzam tehrane SE Acha hai Apne gareban mein dekna Chahiye ke ham ne Apne musalman Bengali bhaion ke sath Kia Ka M Kia aur is SE hame sabaq sekna Chahiye Kia ham ne sabaq sekna.pakistan banane mein sab ziada kirdar bangali bhaion Ka tha.un KO ithna majboor Kia Gia ke unhen gheroon ki tharaf dekna phara ye bebasi ki akhari had Hoti hai.
Very objective analysis. We don't waste time in learning from history Dr. Saheb. We love the past and live in the past, doing what we have always been doing.
Continuation of prev my comment. 1. Agar Yahya Khan 25 march 1971 wala Assembly ka Ijlaas multawi na karta to surely yeh saneha na hota 2. Bhutto ne kaha thaa jo bhi west pakistan se assembly ke ijlaas mein shirkat karne jaye, woh one way ka ticket lekar jaye . Ppp ke Ahmed Raza Qasuri Dacca gaye, iske ilawa ppp 137-82 = 55 arkan west pakistan se phonche 160+55= 215. Yeh do tihayee banti hain. Bhutto ko andaza ho gaya ke Aayeen Ban jayega Then Yahya cancelled First meeting of assembly. Which broke out violence in Dacca. I listen on BBC that crowd attacked on Pak Fauj chowki and set fire . Who advised yahya for this step, the name came was Bhutto. Yahya not being politician should not do that and waited for outcome from assembly efforts in drafting constitution.
My friend, When armies mistreat the people and earn their hatred, Those armies are incapable of defending their countries: Who committed the first wrong: It was General yahya who was not interested in the larger interest of the country but in perpetuating his own power: Mujib had won the election of united Pakistan and wanted to be PM But international powers, short sighted West Pakistan politicians Bhutto in particular made Indian design successful: We have not learned anything from history: MILITARY IN PAKISTAN IS RESPONSIBLE FOR ALL OUR MISERIES BUT IS ADAMANT TO KEEP ITS STRANGLEHOLDON POWER : A powerful and impassioned plea for dialogue and reform! Indeed, history shows that oppression often leads to resistance and ultimately, reckoning. The military's brutal tactics will only fuel the flames of dissent, and arresting women and children will not silence the voices of the people. The analogy with the French Revolution is apt, and the reference to Form 47 highlights the illegitimacy of the current government. The call for a win-win situation, negotiated through dialogue between the military and Imran Khan, is a sensible and pragmatic approach. The question posed is poignant: if the military could negotiate the surrender of Dhaka with Indian generals, why can't they engage in dialogue with Imran Khan to find a peaceful resolution? It's a reminder that dialogue and diplomacy are essential for finding solutions that serve the larger interests of Pakistan. Let's hope that reason and wisdom prevail, and that the military and government heed the call for dialogue and reform, rather than continuing down a path of oppression and violence. The future of Pakistan depends on it.
You didn’t mentioned why General yahiya didn't call assembly? Why he left Dhaka in hiding and ordered a military operation while negotiation between Awamileague and PPP was going on?
yahya was not a punjabi,punjabi was not imposed in leu of bangali,bhutto again was not punjabi but still I believe punjabis should have stood firm to give power to mujeeb and saved pakistan and most of all saved pak army from surrender.
شدید ترین افسوس کی بات یہ ہے کہ بھارتی پروپیگنڈہ تو اور بنگلادیش کی مجبوری تو اپنی جگہ موجودہ دور کی ایک سیاسی جماعت کے پروپیگنڈے کی وجہ سے پاکستانی خود پاکستان اور پاکستانی اداروں کے بارے میں شدید غلط فہمی کا شکار ہو کر رہ گئے ہیں۔ اللہ تعالی پاکستان اور بنگلادیش کو دنیا میں عظیم مقام عطا فرمائے۔ دونوں ممالک کے عوام اہل سیاست اور اداروں میں محبتیں پیدا فرمائے
People of Pakistan actually so afraid to admit What they systematically inhuman injustice did Against people of east Bengal.Pakistan army officially ordered & came to change nasal or race of Bengali people but people of east Bengal change the geography and history of Pakistan
Pakistan will never learn from their mistakes coz they don't own their mistakes instead blame others. Also this is one of the main reasons for today's economic situation... They will very soon lose balochistan coz their attitude is still the same like in 1971 when Pakistan was broken into 2 parts....
Acha. Mere bhai drasal apko bolne k bht azadi islye ap ye bakwas kr rhe ho..apse swal h... Indian punjab m 1984 golden temple apke smne h..kya kuch hua..aaj bhi india sikho k khilaf active h..or had se barh k ye ke after 1947 india ne punjab ko 3 or parts m devide krdia... Mre drasal waha india m yha se kahin zada hojata h or pata bhi nhn chlta q ke wahan k awam or media ko lagaam di v h or yha hota jo ho yha k log use itna barha charha ke pesh krte h k had se bahar baat hojati h...abhi recently manipur apke smne h bhai...
جو پاکستان کے دشمن ہیں وہ پاکستانیوں کو مایوس کرتے ہیں الحمدللّٰہ ہمیں اپنے ملک سے محبت ہے اور مرتے دم تک رہے گی سچا محب وطن بنگالی کی طرح غداری نہیں کرتا ہندو کے ساتھ مل کر مسلمانوں کا خون بہایا اس کا حساب دینا ہوگا
We as pakistani must think we are one nation no punjabi pushtoon sindhi Baloch pahle pakistan one religion one q Quran and the masaanger Mohammad peace be upon Him ❤
What is your opinion about if all other religious majorities follow your rule ?you have to bear 15crore more Muslims from India and Bangladesh has to bear 10 crore Muslims from India..,
Genocide of Bengali peoples started by Pakistan army From 25/3/71 and continued upto surrendering of pakistan army. Nobody knows actual number of peoples killed by Pakistan army in genocide.Genocide was started from 25/3/71 and continued upto surrendering of pakistan army. Pak army killed many innocent peoples in rural area of all subdivision of east pakistan. Started burning houses of bengali peoples. Pak airforce fighter jets dropped bombs in many area of Bangladesh. EPCAF newly formed by Bihari qaom for help for genocide of Bengali peoples. ( East Pakistan civil armed forces). Many pak army soldiers died in railway wagon without food and water as pow on the way of Indian camp of POW..
Bihari Muslims Mohajireen as a Pakistan 🇵🇰 creators, just want to save Combined Pakistan otherwise historically All Biharies (Hindu/Muslims) are living in West Bengal with Bengalies as well as millions bengalies are living in Bihar province with great Brotherhood since thousands of years But A group of Indian army trained (Mukti bahni) were genocide innocent Biharies only due to Biharies were Loyal to Solidarity of Pak Watan (Pakistan 🇵🇰)
We must learn from the past but still we couldn't realize rather not learned the lesson. Everyone is responsible who are on the helm of affairs, now bengali are much better than us but we still roaming in dark lane of our journey facing injustice everywhere due to our mistakes and incompetent, selfish and greedy.....!!!! چھوڑے کس کس کو کوستے رہینگے۔۔۔۔قوم کیا بڑے بھی سدھرنے والے نہیں اللہ پاکستان پر رحم کرے ورنہ ھم نے قوم پر اور ملک پر رحم نہیں کرنا ۔۔۔
They were few in numbers,at least 15 ,15 miles from each other,when they were attacked,one group of the picket ran 15,18 miles to reach the other group.every it was there daily routine,how can they kill so many in rural area,s .10 ,20 attacked by 2 ,300 hundred people.in the end most of soldiers were shoeless.
When 50,000 women in the mosque.they were 3000 bangalis and indian army disguised as mukti,then they gathered in large numbers to attack,when they attacked,tikka attacked them,3000 bangalis were killed.
Assalamualaikum warahmatullah. I am a Bangladeshi. I think Pakistan government , media bloggers as well as civilians should come forward more actively to rebuild relationship between Pakistan and Bangladesh. At the same time we together trough out indian hegemony from Bangladesh and Pakistan.
The Bengalis are better off running their own affairs. At the time of Dhaka fall West Pakistan was 70% richer than East Pakistan. Today Bangladesh is 45% richer than Pakistan. The Bengalis are honest and hard working people. That is the reason even Pakistani businessman have moved their businesses to Bangladesh. I have never seen a Bengalis beg in the M.E. or North America, On the other hand I have seen Sindis beg on Mount Hirah in KSA and Punjabis beg on Toronto subway stations. Today Pakistan is living on handouts from IMF, World Bank, Rich Gulf Arabs & China!
Middle East is FILLED with Bangladeshi Muslims doing menial jobs like drivers, cleaners etc. Just take a cursory look at Dhaka and you will find poverty everywhere. Just look at the cycle rickshaw drivers and their miserable lives. Such impoverished people still make up ninety percent of Bangladesh's population. Just because a few people got rich only means that the so-called booming Bangladeshi economy made very little difference in the lives of the poor!
میں آپ سے سو فیصد متفق ہوں احساس محرومی کے نام پر انڈیا نے کبھی کشمیریوں کو معاف نہیں کیا انہوں نے کرش کرکے کے رکھا ہوا ہے پاکستان نے مکتی باہنی کی طرح کسی کو سپورٹ نہیں کیا کوءی اسلحہ نہیں دیا صرف احتجاج کیا کشمیر کیوں نہیں آزاد ہوتا ہے جو ان کا قانونی حق ہے کشمیر میں ہندی زبان کیوں نہیں ختم ہوتی
Nasalwadi jatiwadi turki , irani mangoli ashraf lottery urdu musalman ? Allahtallah ne bangla bashindo ko unki hukumat de di hai aur tumahari nasalwadi jatiwadi mughal hukumat ko pakistan naam ke tukde tak mahedud karr diya ? Aage pakistan ke bhi tukde karega allah ?
Fall of Dacca us din sy ly kar Aj ky din tak mery dill main ek teer ki tarha pewast hy, khun ky aansoo roo raha hon. Magar PAKISTAN (Nation) ny us HADSA sy koi SABAQ nahin sekha our na sekhna chahty hain. *HAM* Sindi, Balochi, Punjabi, Pathan our Mohajar bannay ko tarjee dety hain *PAKISTANI* nahi. PAKISTAN LAHOO LAHAN hai Khuda rah is ki MARHAM PATTI to kar do.
@@md.zahidurrahmansardar694mr zeeshan sahab...ap mj ye btyn ke pakistan kaha ghalat h🤔🤔🤔 or jab pakistan m ap jese log khuli dushmani k zuban lye ghumtey h to mulk k.khilaf dushmano ka kaam ap hi kar dete ho... Mere bhai aap ye btao indian pujab 1984 golden temple k bare m ap kya kehte h🤔🤔🤔 Phir m agey or sawal.krta h apse
ڈاکٹر صاحب حقائق کو نہ مان نے کے ایسے نتائج نکلتے ہیں اور آپ نے ٹھیک فرمایا ہم اب بھی حقائق کو تسلیم نہیں کر رہے دن بہ دن ھر لحاظ سے ریورس گیئر میں ہیں
Your research is partial and ambiguous... You need to revise your research process and bring all facts to light impartially.... Quoting some instances from few authors and journalists doesn't make sense. Read more text in this context... As researchers, we must not stain the facts.
The separation of Pakistan in 1971 was a sorrowful, sorrow, painful fact. I can say for an ordinary Pakistani it was an unfortunate moment. I cannot forget this painful history. I don't know what was the reason. We must learn from our history and be careful next time not to be involved in such activities that damage our home Pakistan. I always have good feelings for Bangladeshis. Bangladeshis should know now what was involved in the murder of Bangladeshis.
ہمیں اُن غلطیوں سے سبق سیھکنا چاہئے جو سقوط ڈھاکہ کا باحس بنی فوج کو اپنی حد ذمہ داریاں جو کہ دفاع ہے اسے نبا نا چاہئے نا کہ حکومتی ماملات میں مداخلت کرے۔ اسی طرح ہماری حکومت کو بھی چاہئے کہ وہ ڈیلور کرے ملک کے لئے سچھے دل اور لگن سے کام کرے۔اور عوام کے لئے آسانیاں پیدا کرے ۔کیونکہ جب عوام خوشحال ہو گے تو مسائل خود بخود حل ہو جائے گے۔
Correction, Assembly, till completion of constitution will be summoned as AAYEN SAAZ assembly. maximum period allowed was 90 days. Thereafter transfer of power will be made according to the constitution. If not succeeded in making constitution then Yahya Khan will head the govt, under his PCO. I was 21 when this tragic moments was in flow.
جو کچھ ھمیں کتابوں میں بتایا گیا ھے 1971 کا سا نحہ کیوں اور کیسے اور کون لوگ تھے اس کے زمہ دار وہ۔ آج 2024 میں ھم آنکھوں سے دیکھ رھے ھیں پہلے شیخ مجیب الرحمٰن تھا آج عمران خان
Most of those killed were Pakistanis , those who were ethnically Bengalis but were loyal to Pakistani and Bihari Muslims who had preferred to live in East Pakistan on or after 1947.
آج پھر پاکستان کی کہانی دھرائی جا رہی ہے اگر لالچی سیاست دان اور اسٹیبلشمنٹ کے مزاج درست نہ کیے گئے تو ڈر ہے کہا نی پھر نہ دھرائی جائے اللّٰہ تعالیٰ پاکستان کو سلامت رکھے آمین
Pakistan was broken due to mainly Punjabi racism and partly a reactive Bengali racism why Bengalis were not given their due share of 54 percent in the affairs of the United Pakistan why 25 percent punjabis became the sole owner contractor and landlord of the entire Pakistan!! Punjabis are still cold hearted towards rest of the Pakistan now all provinces in the existing Pakistan are so much became alienated from each other only currency and banks give the feeling as if Pakistan still does excist!!
When Pakistani army attack police & EPR camp and tried to disarm the Bangal Ragement then they revolted and come as mukti Bahini. Pakistani Bahini didn’t killed any Bangale? You are lying? You didn’t not mentioned about 1947 -1971 disparities.
You all forget that India attacked east Pakistan,or rather conquered,it was international conspiracy,Russia helped and USA gave a nod to India for go ahead
ہمارے حکمران سقوط ڈھاکہ کی تاریخ کی غلطیوں کو دوھرا رہے ہیں انہوں نے کوئی سبق نہیں سیکھا اور ان کو اب بھی ملک کی کوئی پرواہ نہیں ہے اور عوام ان سے بہت تنگ ہیں اللہ ہی مالک ہے
Yarr jitna marzi ho aap chupane ki koshesh karo leken haqaiq nhi chupte aor na hi hamare janralz ne 1971 se kuch sekha he aj balochistan aor khyber pukhtoon kwah ke halat 1971 se zayada posheeda he Jo marzi ho kaho ghaltiya hamre hi foujiyo ki thi
*What nonsense ? I am from Abottabad KPK and I am living in Karachi KPK may sab khuch proper theek hai koi KPK ki taraf gandi nazar se dekhne ki bhi himmat na kare agr kisi ko objection hai to woh apni nationality change kr le KPK and Balochistan may jo issues hai woh durand line Ki wajah se hai Afghanistan ko KPK and Balochistan un k dream may hi mubarak ho*
کسی اطہر عباس کے جملے نہیں بلکہ یہ جملہ خوُد بھٹّوُ نے ادا کیا تھا، جب کے بھٹّوُ بہت ذیادہ ووُٹ سے ہار گئے تھے اور شیخ مُجیب اکیلی حیثیت سے اسمبلی بنا سکتے تھے، بھٹّوُ نے اپنی ایک عوامی تقریر میں بنگالیوں کوُ سوُّر کے بچّے کہہ کر گالی بھی دی تھی، جو کہ اب بھی میڈیا پر سُنی جا سکتی ھے،،
Yes it was a cruel retaliation Jnab Dacca mn is wkt bhe Muhammadpura camp hay Jahan aaj bhe Pakistan ko favour krnnay ki sza mil the hy, Bilkul UN k rights snub kye huay thay,
Thank you so much for sharing this ... I utterly needed this information... I had a worst argument with a Bengali on Telegram... I commented there in favour of Palestine but this man out of nowhere started all repeated things ... Pakistan, genocide, rape blah blah blah ... I tried to calm him down but when you are fed with hatred by birth then you can't open up to reality... By the way! At the end when he kept misbehaving I gave him a big shut up call because he forced me to do so. I got to know that they are taught in their school against Pakistan and feed their kids with anything fabricated and exaggerated.
Tum log itne gire hue ho ki aaj bhi is baat par bahas kar rahe ho ki kitne mare aur kisne mare, apni galti naa manne ki wajah se hi aj tum logo k ye halat hain, har jagah har baar beizzat hote ho, koi tumhe pasand nahi karta, Arab ho ya Afghani ya Balochi sab tum par thookte hain
That was unfortunate Nightmare the only resposible i believe was Field Marshal Ayub khan his policies and incompitence to be a president make uss reach that point . He ruled such a way that he didn't work on Nation Buillding and ignored east Pakistan the he mase another bulunder appointed Yahya khan as Army chief To be honest as a Nation we love Bengalies as both are Muslims
Election of 1970 was not provincial election. Democracy as per population not area of land. What was happened in 1971? In 1965 east Pakistan was not separated. India not helped Bengali peoples in war, why helped in 1971?
Diluted vlog, failed to identify the true facts. Pak army is the orchestrator of the atrocities where the winner declared loser, similarly form 45 and 47 today's result.
Sir aap aaj keh rahe hein k kash hum log bangali zuban or bangaliyo ko apnate. Apko nazar nahin aata k karachi me muhajiron k sath wohi behaviour he foj ka jo kabhi bangaliyon k sath tha.
سیاست میں فوج کا عمل داخل کرنا جو اب بھی فوج کر رہی ہے انداز لگتا ہے فوج نے ہی مشرقی پاکستان کی عوام کو شہید کیا ۔۔۔70ہزار وزیرستان میں شہید امریکہ کو خوش کرنے کے لیے فوج نے شہید کیا سوال تو بنتا ہے؟؟؟
1970 ka Election ke bad usko West Pakistanio ne inkar kar dia, kui ki Ektedar East Paksanio me chala ja ra ha tha. Ye main waja apne highlight nahi ki he. To galti to ap aj ki Pakistanio ne ki thi vy, to Mafi mangne se itna dhikkat keu hai. Ebrat na sikhne ke sath sath ap logone ghamand vi nahi sori aj tak, sorry to say but it is the reality I think.
Sir,1971 was more or less a repeat of 1947,only the players were different.
In 1947 it was hindus vs muslims.
In 1971 it was muslims(Punjabi,sindhis) vs muslims(bengalis).
Both historical events were extremely painful and yet inevitable with trauma.
Time,history,nations do not stop moving and changing and there is no alternative except to move on.
Gheroon KO morad ilzam tehrane SE Acha hai Apne gareban mein dekna Chahiye ke ham ne Apne musalman Bengali bhaion ke sath Kia Ka
M Kia aur is SE hame sabaq sekna Chahiye Kia ham ne sabaq sekna.pakistan banane mein sab ziada kirdar bangali bhaion Ka tha.un KO ithna majboor Kia Gia ke unhen gheroon ki tharaf dekna phara ye bebasi ki akhari had Hoti hai.
Very objective analysis. We don't waste time in learning from history Dr. Saheb. We love the past and live in the past, doing what we have always been doing.
Thanks....love from Dhaka,🇧🇩
I am from pakistani but my muslam brother bangali the mind set hindus terrrisam makti bani
@@ShahzadAli-ic4qgChup
Pakistan and Bangladesh Zindabad ❤
@@ShahzadAli-ic4qgbikhari tera army sabse jahil hai. Pura dunia janta hai. Tera opinoon tere pass rakh.
ہمیں بس اتنا معلوم ہے کہ جی سب ہمارے جرنیلوں کا کیا دھرا تھا جو کچھ موجودہ دور میں ہو رہا ہے اس سے اکہتر کے حالات کا اندازہ لگانا مشکل نہیں
India nay Mujeeb kah Mukhte Bahne ku direct support karta ta.
Yeh jo b AJ ho rha hai yeh tb sy e shuru hai is ka Sahi end ab tak nhi hua
Dr. Sb, I was working in DAWN khi, and am a witness to 1971 war😊
DAWN !!!! Bs samajh gai
@@ibrahimshahzadsperspective1623 Pakistan army ki jahiliyat samaj gayi.
@@wasifulalam4215 tm KO 71 men sahih samjhaya tha
It was simply rejection and dishonouring the public mandate.
اللہ تعالیٰ پاکستان کے مظلوم عوام کو بھی ان ظالموں ظلم نجات دے آمین ثم آمین یا رب العالمین
I recommend everyone to search Anthony Mascarenhas a pakistan army appointed journalist and his stories about 1971
Continuation of prev my comment.
1. Agar Yahya Khan 25 march 1971 wala Assembly ka Ijlaas multawi na karta to surely yeh saneha na hota
2. Bhutto ne kaha thaa jo bhi west pakistan se assembly ke ijlaas mein shirkat karne jaye, woh one way ka ticket lekar jaye .
Ppp ke Ahmed Raza Qasuri Dacca gaye, iske ilawa ppp 137-82 = 55 arkan west pakistan se phonche
160+55= 215.
Yeh do tihayee banti hain. Bhutto ko andaza ho gaya ke Aayeen Ban jayega
Then Yahya cancelled First meeting of assembly.
Which broke out violence in Dacca.
I listen on BBC that crowd attacked on Pak Fauj chowki and set fire .
Who advised yahya for this step, the name came was Bhutto.
Yahya not being politician should not do that and waited for outcome from assembly efforts in drafting constitution.
hamiddura rahman commettiee report must be published for common people
My friend, When armies mistreat the people and earn their hatred, Those armies are incapable of defending their countries: Who committed the first wrong: It was General yahya who was not interested in the larger interest of the country but in perpetuating his own power: Mujib had won the election of united Pakistan and wanted to be PM But international powers, short sighted West Pakistan politicians Bhutto in particular made Indian design successful: We have not learned anything from history: MILITARY IN PAKISTAN IS RESPONSIBLE FOR ALL OUR MISERIES BUT IS ADAMANT TO KEEP ITS STRANGLEHOLDON POWER : A powerful and impassioned plea for dialogue and reform!
Indeed, history shows that oppression often leads to resistance and ultimately, reckoning. The military's brutal tactics will only fuel the flames of dissent, and arresting women and children will not silence the voices of the people.
The analogy with the French Revolution is apt, and the reference to Form 47 highlights the illegitimacy of the current government. The call for a win-win situation, negotiated through dialogue between the military and Imran Khan, is a sensible and pragmatic approach.
The question posed is poignant: if the military could negotiate the surrender of Dhaka with Indian generals, why can't they engage in dialogue with Imran Khan to find a peaceful resolution? It's a reminder that dialogue and diplomacy are essential for finding solutions that serve the larger interests of Pakistan.
Let's hope that reason and wisdom prevail, and that the military and government heed the call for dialogue and reform, rather than continuing down a path of oppression and violence. The future of Pakistan depends on it.
Logical, impartial and brilliant.✔️
Well needed video, good job ❤.
Peacefuls never own their crimes and atrocities. They committed endless heinous crime but put the blame on others
EXACTLY as the Bengali-speaking "peacefuls" do NOT own up to the genocide of Chakmas in the Chittagong Hill Tracts!
It's just your hate propoganda.....
The rise of Dhaka. Not the fall
You'll be answered by ALLAH Tala on the day of judgment
Very very true
But eventually Dhaka will fall under the debts of it's beloved neighbour.
Don't trust me check your foreign reserves
@@commodusmeridius4718it's is better than Pakistan 😅😅😅😅
@@ibrahimsyed7387Allah tala not support racist people.he no what kala Bangali gets from racism
You didn’t mentioned why General yahiya didn't call assembly? Why he left Dhaka in hiding and ordered a military operation while negotiation between Awamileague and PPP was going on?
India was not responsible for separation of east pakistan. Punjabi fouji hukumat aor Bhutto was responsible for separation of east bengal.
Indira gashti bhi shaamil ti
Perhaps you forgot the statement of Modi that he had given in Bangladesh.
Zeeshan sahab ap ye btao pakistan kaha ghalat tha🤔🤔🤔
yahya was not a punjabi,punjabi was not imposed in leu of bangali,bhutto again was not punjabi but still I believe punjabis should have stood firm to give power to mujeeb and saved pakistan and most of all saved pak army from surrender.
SAHI KAHAN THA?
KEON HAKOOMAT UNKEY HAWALEY NAHI KI JO MAJORITY ME THEI?@@RaliGenix
I'm from Bangladesh
👌👌👌👌
❤❤❤❤
The government should had to given Sheikh Mujeeb ur Rehman
شدید ترین افسوس کی بات یہ ہے کہ
بھارتی پروپیگنڈہ تو اور بنگلادیش کی مجبوری تو اپنی جگہ
موجودہ دور کی ایک سیاسی جماعت کے پروپیگنڈے کی وجہ سے پاکستانی خود پاکستان اور پاکستانی اداروں کے بارے میں شدید غلط فہمی کا شکار ہو کر رہ گئے ہیں۔
اللہ تعالی پاکستان اور بنگلادیش کو دنیا میں عظیم مقام عطا فرمائے۔ دونوں ممالک کے عوام اہل سیاست اور اداروں میں محبتیں پیدا فرمائے
Pakistani establishment has not learned the lesson and still living in the denial mode that is very dangerous to the future of the country.
People of Pakistan actually so afraid to admit What they systematically inhuman injustice did Against people of east Bengal.Pakistan army officially ordered & came to change nasal or race of Bengali people but people of east Bengal change the geography and history of Pakistan
Pakistan will never learn from their mistakes coz they don't own their mistakes instead blame others.
Also this is one of the main reasons for today's economic situation...
They will very soon lose balochistan coz their attitude is still the same like in 1971 when Pakistan was broken into 2 parts....
Acha. Mere bhai drasal apko bolne k bht azadi islye ap ye bakwas kr rhe ho..apse swal h...
Indian punjab m 1984 golden temple apke smne h..kya kuch hua..aaj bhi india sikho k khilaf active h..or had se barh k ye ke after 1947 india ne punjab ko 3 or parts m devide krdia...
Mre drasal waha india m yha se kahin zada hojata h or pata bhi nhn chlta q ke wahan k awam or media ko lagaam di v h or yha hota jo ho yha k log use itna barha charha ke pesh krte h k had se bahar baat hojati h...abhi recently manipur apke smne h bhai...
جو پاکستان کے دشمن ہیں وہ پاکستانیوں کو مایوس کرتے ہیں الحمدللّٰہ ہمیں اپنے ملک سے محبت ہے اور مرتے دم تک رہے گی سچا محب وطن بنگالی کی طرح غداری نہیں کرتا ہندو کے ساتھ مل کر مسلمانوں کا خون بہایا اس کا حساب دینا ہوگا
*Wolverine 1902 in your dream*
We as pakistani must think we are one nation no punjabi pushtoon sindhi Baloch pahle pakistan one religion one q Quran and the masaanger Mohammad peace be upon Him ❤
Still confused
What is your opinion about if all other religious majorities follow your rule ?you have to bear 15crore more Muslims from India and Bangladesh has to bear 10 crore Muslims from India..,
Genocide of Bengali peoples started by Pakistan army From 25/3/71 and continued upto surrendering of pakistan army. Nobody knows actual number of peoples killed by Pakistan army in genocide.Genocide was started from 25/3/71 and continued upto surrendering of pakistan army. Pak army killed many innocent peoples in rural area of all subdivision of east pakistan. Started burning houses of bengali peoples. Pak airforce fighter jets dropped bombs in many area of Bangladesh. EPCAF newly formed by Bihari qaom for help for genocide of Bengali peoples. ( East Pakistan civil armed forces). Many pak army soldiers died in railway wagon without food and water as pow on the way of Indian camp of POW..
Bihari Muslims Mohajireen as a Pakistan 🇵🇰 creators, just want to save Combined Pakistan otherwise historically All Biharies (Hindu/Muslims) are living in West Bengal with Bengalies as well as millions bengalies are living in Bihar province with great Brotherhood since thousands of years
But
A group of Indian army trained (Mukti bahni) were genocide innocent Biharies only due to Biharies were Loyal to Solidarity of Pak Watan (Pakistan 🇵🇰)
Operation search light started by tikka khan was a turning point where bengals started hating with army,baharis and west Pakistanis.
We must learn from the past but still we couldn't realize rather not learned the lesson. Everyone is responsible who are on the helm of affairs, now bengali are much better than us but we still roaming in dark lane of our journey facing injustice everywhere due to our mistakes and incompetent, selfish and greedy.....!!!!
چھوڑے کس کس کو کوستے رہینگے۔۔۔۔قوم کیا بڑے بھی سدھرنے والے نہیں اللہ پاکستان پر رحم کرے ورنہ ھم نے قوم پر اور ملک پر رحم نہیں کرنا ۔۔۔
They were few in numbers,at least 15 ,15 miles from each other,when they were attacked,one group of the picket ran 15,18 miles to reach the other group.every it was there daily routine,how can they kill so many in rural area,s .10 ,20 attacked by 2 ,300 hundred people.in the end most of soldiers were shoeless.
When 50,000 women in the mosque.they were 3000 bangalis and indian army disguised as mukti,then they gathered in large numbers to attack,when they attacked,tikka attacked them,3000 bangalis were killed.
Assalamualaikum warahmatullah. I am a Bangladeshi.
I think Pakistan government , media bloggers as well as civilians should come forward more actively to rebuild relationship between Pakistan and Bangladesh. At the same time we together trough out indian hegemony from Bangladesh and Pakistan.
The Bengalis are better off running their own affairs. At the time of Dhaka fall West Pakistan was 70% richer than East Pakistan. Today Bangladesh is 45% richer than Pakistan. The Bengalis are honest and hard working people. That is the reason even Pakistani businessman have moved their businesses to Bangladesh. I have never seen a Bengalis beg in the M.E. or North America, On the other hand I have seen Sindis beg on Mount Hirah in KSA and Punjabis beg on Toronto subway stations. Today Pakistan is living on handouts from IMF, World Bank, Rich Gulf Arabs & China!
Middle East is FILLED with Bangladeshi Muslims doing menial jobs like drivers, cleaners etc.
Just take a cursory look at Dhaka and you will find poverty everywhere. Just look at the cycle rickshaw drivers and their miserable lives. Such impoverished people still make up ninety percent of Bangladesh's population.
Just because a few people got rich only means that the so-called booming Bangladeshi economy made very little difference in the lives of the poor!
You are exactly a rare addict.
The rise of Dhaka. Not the fall..
ہم نے تاریخ سے کچھ نہیں سیکھا اور نہ ماضی سے سیکھنے کا کوی ارادہ ہے۔ ۔واہ
A nice ,fair n comprehensive report
Bangladesh and Pakistan as a Muslims brothers love from Pakistan and we one nation despite due to Indian invloment we separated but we one nation.
Good sir ❤
احساس محرومی کے نام پر علیحدگی پسند غداروں اور فتنہ انگیزی کرنے والوں کی حرکتوں کو نظر انداز نہیں کرنا چاہیے
میں آپ سے سو فیصد متفق ہوں احساس محرومی کے نام پر انڈیا نے کبھی کشمیریوں کو معاف نہیں کیا انہوں نے کرش کرکے کے رکھا ہوا ہے پاکستان نے مکتی باہنی کی طرح کسی کو سپورٹ نہیں کیا کوءی اسلحہ نہیں دیا صرف احتجاج کیا کشمیر کیوں نہیں آزاد ہوتا ہے جو ان کا قانونی حق ہے کشمیر میں ہندی زبان کیوں نہیں ختم ہوتی
اگر انصاف کیا جاتا تو احساسِ محرومی پیدا ھی نہ ھوتا۔۔۔۔۔اور نہ علیحدگی کی نسبت آ تی۔۔۔مگر افسوس آ ج تک اس سے سبق حاصل نہ کیا جاسکا۔۔۔۔۔۔
Nasalwadi jatiwadi turki , irani mangoli ashraf lottery urdu musalman ? Allahtallah ne bangla bashindo ko unki hukumat de di hai aur tumahari nasalwadi jatiwadi mughal hukumat ko pakistan naam ke tukde tak mahedud karr diya ? Aage pakistan ke bhi tukde karega allah ?
جنھوں نے ڈھاکہ میں پینٹیں اتاری اور لیٹ گئے وہ بھی آپ سے زیادہ بڑی باتیں کرتے تھے
Mash Allah best explanation.
Fall of Dacca us din sy ly kar Aj ky din tak mery dill main ek teer ki tarha pewast hy, khun ky aansoo roo raha hon. Magar PAKISTAN (Nation) ny us HADSA sy koi SABAQ nahin sekha our na sekhna chahty hain. *HAM* Sindi, Balochi, Punjabi, Pathan our Mohajar bannay ko tarjee dety hain *PAKISTANI* nahi. PAKISTAN LAHOO LAHAN hai Khuda rah is ki MARHAM PATTI to kar do.
Pakistan is country of punjabi fouji only. Punjabi original Pakistani.
@@md.zahidurrahmansardar694Punjabi khudtang hain
@@md.zahidurrahmansardar694mr zeeshan sahab...ap mj ye btyn ke pakistan kaha ghalat h🤔🤔🤔 or jab pakistan m ap jese log khuli dushmani k zuban lye ghumtey h to mulk k.khilaf dushmano ka kaam ap hi kar dete ho...
Mere bhai aap ye btao indian pujab 1984 golden temple k bare m ap kya kehte h🤔🤔🤔
Phir m agey or sawal.krta h apse
پاکستان کے لیے بہاریوں کو بنگلہ دیش سے لاؤ وہ کیوں سر رہے ہیں وہاں ان کا قصور کیا تھا جن کو مکتی باہنی نے شہید کیا
East and west pakistan are one thousand miles apart their fedration was irrational and illogical but pakistanis do not understand
بہت بہترین مگر بہت مختصر
Where was Sheikh Mujib in Pakistan in 1971?
ڈاکٹر صاحب حقائق کو نہ مان نے کے ایسے نتائج نکلتے ہیں اور آپ نے ٹھیک فرمایا ہم اب بھی حقائق کو تسلیم نہیں کر رہے دن بہ دن ھر لحاظ سے ریورس گیئر میں ہیں
ہم سے اچھے رہے یہ لوگ علیحدہ ہو کر ۔
دور کے ڈھول سہانے ہوتے ہیں قریب جاؤ کان پھٹتے ہیں آپ کو کیا پتہ انڈیا کی ریاست بننے پر آپ انہیں بہتر اور خود کو غلط افسوس آپ کی سوچ پر
Himmat ka himayati Allah hai
کیا بنگلہ دیش ہم سے الگ ہوا یا ہم بنگلہ دیش سے الگ ہوئے؟ کیونکہ بنگالی اکثریت میں تھے۔ اکثریت کب اقلیت سے الگ ہوئی ہے؟
Brilliant logical reasoning.✔️
Zulfikar bhutto was responsible
💯✔️✔️✔️
Your research is partial and ambiguous... You need to revise your research process and bring all facts to light impartially.... Quoting some instances from few authors and journalists doesn't make sense. Read more text in this context... As researchers, we must not stain the facts.
قانون کی بالا۔دستی سے انحراف اور ھوس اقتدار کی خواہش پاکستان کے دو لخت ھونے کا سبب بنی
The separation of Pakistan in 1971 was a sorrowful, sorrow, painful fact. I can say for an ordinary Pakistani it was an unfortunate moment. I cannot forget this painful history. I don't know what was the reason. We must learn from our history and be careful next time not to be involved in such activities that damage our home Pakistan. I always have good feelings for Bangladeshis. Bangladeshis should know now what was involved in the murder of Bangladeshis.
ہمیں اُن غلطیوں سے سبق سیھکنا چاہئے جو سقوط ڈھاکہ کا باحس بنی فوج کو اپنی حد ذمہ داریاں جو کہ دفاع ہے اسے نبا نا چاہئے نا کہ حکومتی ماملات میں مداخلت کرے۔
اسی طرح ہماری حکومت کو بھی چاہئے کہ وہ ڈیلور کرے ملک کے لئے سچھے دل اور لگن سے کام کرے۔اور عوام کے لئے آسانیاں پیدا کرے ۔کیونکہ جب عوام خوشحال ہو گے تو مسائل خود بخود حل ہو جائے گے۔
still Pakistan dose not learn anything from 1971
Love ❤
Correction,
Assembly, till completion of constitution will be summoned as AAYEN SAAZ assembly.
maximum period allowed was 90 days.
Thereafter transfer of power will be made according to the constitution.
If not succeeded in making constitution then Yahya Khan will head the govt, under his PCO.
I was 21 when this tragic moments was in flow.
جو کچھ موجودہ دور میں ہورہا ہے اس سے یہ اندازہ لگانا مشکل نہیں کہ 1971 میں مشرقی پاکستان میں کیا ہوا تھا
Good sir ❤pak army❤
جو کچھ ھمیں کتابوں میں بتایا گیا ھے 1971 کا سا نحہ کیوں اور کیسے اور کون لوگ تھے اس کے زمہ دار وہ۔ آج 2024 میں ھم آنکھوں سے دیکھ رھے ھیں پہلے شیخ مجیب الرحمٰن تھا آج عمران خان
Imran is only thinking about himself and not about Pakistan.
Most of those killed were Pakistanis , those who were ethnically Bengalis but were loyal to Pakistani and Bihari Muslims who had preferred to live in East Pakistan on or after 1947.
Behtreen mashahedah
Good sir
بہترین 🎉 مشاہدہ کیا ہ آپ ن
Idher hum udhur tum bhutto responsible if Mujeeb was prime Minister of PKistan but we still love our Bangla Desh our Muslim brothers 😊
First comment from a Bangali hum ne Punjab se Azadi hasil kerli 😢
ماشااللہ بہت خوب صورت بات کی ماشااللہ خوبصورت انداز میں کی
آج پھر پاکستان کی کہانی دھرائی جا رہی ہے اگر لالچی سیاست دان اور اسٹیبلشمنٹ کے مزاج درست نہ کیے گئے تو ڈر ہے کہا نی پھر نہ دھرائی جائے اللّٰہ تعالیٰ پاکستان کو سلامت رکھے آمین
Very shamefull .93000 pak army personals surrendered in front of indian army.The largest surrender ceremony in the world history.
Where ISI was sleeping in entire 1971 till 16th December.?????
Lovely vlog brother 👍
Thanks a ton
Right sir
Pakustan usdin tota jub jinah nay urdu ko Qomi zaban benaya
Pakistan was broken due to mainly Punjabi racism and partly a reactive Bengali racism why Bengalis were not given their due share of 54 percent in the affairs of the United Pakistan why 25 percent punjabis became the sole owner contractor and landlord of the entire Pakistan!! Punjabis are still cold hearted towards rest of the Pakistan now all provinces in the existing Pakistan are so much became alienated from each other only currency and banks give the feeling as if Pakistan still does excist!!
Nasir sb
Mn eye witness Hoon 1971 ka, an I was in the DAWN Eng
When Pakistani army attack police & EPR camp and tried to disarm the Bangal Ragement then they revolted and come as mukti Bahini. Pakistani Bahini didn’t killed any Bangale? You are lying? You didn’t not mentioned about 1947 -1971 disparities.
5% Ashraf irani urdu pakistani lotters always layer and thief ?
زندہ باد
اچھی باتیں اور سہی باتیں
Asal zimmedar to Bhutto hi tha
💯💯✔️
You all forget that India attacked east Pakistan,or rather conquered,it was international conspiracy,Russia helped and USA gave a nod to India for go ahead
ہمارے حکمران سقوط ڈھاکہ کی تاریخ کی غلطیوں کو دوھرا رہے ہیں انہوں نے کوئی سبق نہیں سیکھا اور ان کو اب بھی ملک کی کوئی پرواہ نہیں ہے اور عوام ان سے بہت تنگ ہیں اللہ ہی مالک ہے
Yarr jitna marzi ho aap chupane ki koshesh karo leken haqaiq nhi chupte aor na hi hamare janralz ne 1971 se kuch sekha he aj balochistan aor khyber pukhtoon kwah ke halat 1971 se zayada posheeda he
Jo marzi ho kaho ghaltiya hamre hi foujiyo ki thi
*What nonsense ? I am from Abottabad KPK and I am living in Karachi KPK may sab khuch proper theek hai koi KPK ki taraf gandi nazar se dekhne ki bhi himmat na kare agr kisi ko objection hai to woh apni nationality change kr le KPK and Balochistan may jo issues hai woh durand line Ki wajah se hai Afghanistan ko KPK and Balochistan un k dream may hi mubarak ho*
کسی اطہر عباس کے جملے نہیں بلکہ یہ جملہ خوُد بھٹّوُ نے ادا کیا تھا، جب کے بھٹّوُ بہت ذیادہ ووُٹ سے ہار گئے تھے اور شیخ مُجیب اکیلی حیثیت سے اسمبلی بنا سکتے تھے،
بھٹّوُ نے اپنی ایک عوامی تقریر میں بنگالیوں کوُ سوُّر کے بچّے کہہ کر گالی بھی دی تھی، جو کہ اب بھی میڈیا پر سُنی جا سکتی ھے،،
Yes it was a cruel retaliation
Jnab Dacca mn is wkt bhe Muhammadpura camp hay Jahan aaj bhe Pakistan ko favour krnnay ki sza mil the hy,
Bilkul UN k rights snub kye huay thay,
These people opt Pakistan in 1971 war and after Independence of Bangladesh. Your Govt promised to take them in Pakistan and betrayed them.
Adha Sach, namaqool generals ki batain....books ka reference dainay say jhot Sach nai bansakta...sharam ani chayee
Thank you so much for sharing this ... I utterly needed this information... I had a worst argument with a Bengali on Telegram... I commented there in favour of Palestine but this man out of nowhere started all repeated things ... Pakistan, genocide, rape blah blah blah ... I tried to calm him down but when you are fed with hatred by birth then you can't open up to reality...
By the way! At the end when he kept misbehaving I gave him a big shut up call because he forced me to do so.
I got to know that they are taught in their school against Pakistan and feed their kids with anything fabricated and exaggerated.
میں اس حادثہ کی عینی شاہد ہوں یہ قوم معاف کرنے کے۔قابل اللہ نے اس ملک کو اپنا دینا بھی پسند نہیں کیا جو ہم نے دیکھا وہ ناقابل یقین یے 😢😢
کیا میں آپ سے بات کرنے کا شرف حاصل کر سکتا ہوں؟ میں آپ کے مشاہدے کو تحریر کرنا چاہتا ہوں
Plz send me your cell number, Zafar ali from Sialkot
Pakistan ka past chodo saab, apna present dekh lo, dr. Saab ye toh aap ke saamne hai
شکر ہے بنگالیوں سے جان چھٹی
👍👍👍❤️❤️🇧🇩
Thanks
If you are afraid to tell the truth, then shut up
Fall of Pakistan, and the rise of Bangladesh
Love ❤️
قیامت کے دن دیکھ لینا۔ مشرک کی پشت پناہی حاصل کر کے جیتنے والے اور اللہ پر بھروسہ کر کے ہار جانے والے کا فرق۔
Pakistan is not fail pakistan mean L ilha ha illala Muhamdun RasolAllha
Tum log itne gire hue ho ki aaj bhi is baat par bahas kar rahe ho ki kitne mare aur kisne mare, apni galti naa manne ki wajah se hi aj tum logo k ye halat hain, har jagah har baar beizzat hote ho, koi tumhe pasand nahi karta, Arab ho ya Afghani ya Balochi sab tum par thookte hain
Bangali tab bhi hamare sath rehte the aur aaj bhi hamare sath rehte hain, unhone tumhe chhoda hame nahi.
That was unfortunate Nightmare the only resposible i believe was Field Marshal Ayub khan his policies and incompitence to be a president make uss reach that point . He ruled such a way that he didn't work on Nation Buillding and ignored east Pakistan the he mase another bulunder appointed Yahya khan as Army chief
To be honest as a Nation we love Bengalies as both are Muslims
Good effort to understanding youths direction in international propaganda
Pakistan Zindabad
اگر بنگا لی زبان کو بھی قومی زبان کا درجہ دے دیا جاتا تو کیا حرج تھا۔
*1956 and 1962 k constitution may bangali bhi Urdu k sath Pakistan Ki national language thi but inhe Urdu language se humesha problem thi*
Election of 1970 was not provincial election. Democracy as per population not area of land. What was happened in 1971? In 1965 east Pakistan was not separated. India not helped Bengali peoples in war, why helped in 1971?
Diluted vlog, failed to identify the true facts. Pak army is the orchestrator of the atrocities where the winner declared loser, similarly form 45 and 47 today's result.
1971 میں انڈیا نے مکتی باہنی کے ساتھ مل کر پاکستان کو دو ٹکڑے کر دئے اب یہی تاریخ 2024 میں PTI کے ساتھ مل کر انڈین دوبارہ دوہرانے کی کوشش کر رہے ہیں
Pak army ka karnama ki kushbu baloch ka har gar may mahakraha hai
قصوردار مغربی پاکستان کے پنجاب تھا
aksiriat mein hone ke bawajood unhen ghulam banaya kyun rakha jabkeh hukmrani un ka haq tha. Is se bada juram aur nainsafi aur kia ho sakti thi.
💯✔️
বাংলাদেশ 🇧🇩
ভারত 🇮🇳 মৈত্রী চিরজীবী হোক 🌹🌹
জয় বাংলা জয় হিন্দ বীর মুক্তিযোদ্ধা বিচছু জালাল
Well Done. Nasir weproud.
of you😭😭😭
Very impressive presentation
AJ muhajir Bhi😢😢😢 ahsasay mharoomi ka shikar hai
Excellent
Well done United Pakistan East Pakistan and west Pakistan Zindabad. But we are divided
Sir aap aaj keh rahe hein k kash hum log bangali zuban or bangaliyo ko apnate.
Apko nazar nahin aata k karachi me muhajiron k sath wohi behaviour he foj ka jo kabhi bangaliyon k sath tha.
Pakistani Army Real face
Thanks.🙏
سیاست میں فوج کا عمل داخل کرنا جو اب بھی فوج کر رہی ہے انداز لگتا ہے فوج نے ہی مشرقی پاکستان کی عوام کو شہید کیا ۔۔۔70ہزار وزیرستان میں شہید امریکہ کو خوش کرنے کے لیے فوج نے شہید کیا سوال تو بنتا ہے؟؟؟
1970 ka Election ke bad usko West Pakistanio ne inkar kar dia, kui ki Ektedar East Paksanio me chala ja ra ha tha. Ye main waja apne highlight nahi ki he. To galti to ap aj ki Pakistanio ne ki thi vy, to Mafi mangne se itna dhikkat keu hai. Ebrat na sikhne ke sath sath ap logone ghamand vi nahi sori aj tak, sorry to say but it is the reality I think.
❤❤❤❤