StarTalk @ NY Comic Con: It’s About Time! (Brian Greene & Neil deGrasse Tyson)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ต.ค. 2019
- Time is of the essence! Or, is it? Is time travel possible? Can we change the past? On this episode of StarTalk Radio, Neil deGrasse Tyson explores the wibbly wobbly, timey wimey nature of time itself with theoretical physicist Brian Greene, comic co-host Chuck Nice, and Impractical Joker James “Murr” Murray (@thetenderloins).
Join us on a pop culture adventure, from the TARDIS of Doctor Who, to the shrinking capabilities of Ant Man and the Wasp, to the Upside Down parallel universe of Stranger Things. Explore if the laws of physics allow time travel to be possible. You’ll learn how the physics of time travel differs depending on whether you’re going into the future or the past. We discuss wormholes and what happens when you place a wormhole next to a black hole.
Find out about the “chronology projection conjecture,” a concept first introduced by Steven Hawking. Ponder the logic paradox that occurs when you travel into the past. You’ll find out if other species process time similar to the way humans do. We also venture into the fourth dimension as we explore the TARDIS and it’s capabilities.
Next, we move from time travel to the Quantum Realm as we discuss the shrinking science of Ant Man and the Wasp. You’ll learn what the laws of physics say about shrinking. Discover more about the empty space inside atoms. Investigate “molecular disequilibrium,” quantum entanglement, and what Einstein called the “spooky action.”
Neil gives praise to the movie A Bug’s Life on its ability to represent the microscopic (besides the obvious error in ant anatomy).
Lastly, we take a trip to the Upside Down as we investigate parallel universes. Find out more about string theory and the “brane” idea. Explore the idea of a “gravity phone” used to send out vibrations in space time rather than vibrations through air. Unlock the possibilities of the Many-Worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics and learn more about the “order of infinites.” All that, plus Neil offers an emotional, poignant happy birthday message to his birthday buddy, NASA.
This was recorded at NYCC 2018.
Support us on Patreon: / startalkradio
Subscribe to StarTalk: th-cam.com/users/startalk...
Follow StarTalk:
Twitter: / startalkradio
Facebook: / startalk
Instagram: / startalkradio
About StarTalk:
Science meets pop culture on StarTalk! Astrophysicist & Hayden Planetarium director Neil deGrasse Tyson, his comic co-hosts, guest celebrities & scientists discuss astronomy, physics, and everything else about life in the universe. Keep Looking Up!
#NYCC #DoctorWho #StrangerThings - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
Brian Greene tests his patience by coming on this show lol
Brian Greene likes to get out there because he LOVES ATTENSION
You could tell he was like why are these annoying non science guys here
Shut up you negative progression. The meaning of life is positive progression. Mean
yes... "he tasks him."
Brian is good.
I love NDT, what an emotional ending to the show. The chemistry between Chuck and NDT is unbeatable. Thank you to you both for Startalk.
I really like how Chuck closed out for him..that was cool.
It's the first time I've seen Neil crying. A beautifully written and thoughtful letter. It touched me, too as a science educator. Cheers, Neil.
it give me chills hearing a crowd of young people cheering like this for scientists 😊
I felt completely apathetic throughout the entire show
You gonna cry about it?
Like a comedie show 😂
Happy birthday Dr. Tyson 🎉 That was a beautiful personal letter.
it was a book not a letter
@@FMFvideos Was it from Mein Kampf?
HAPPY BIRTHDAY NDT 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎁🎁🎁🎂🎂🎂
The letter was from the heart. Happy Birthday!
@@user-sj2vg8hb5q Really?? If that's your mentality, why did you even watch this?
There should be a rule that if a comedian bombs three jokes in a row he gets booted off the stage.
Bong bong bong gong gone!
It's almost funnier when they bomb a joke though because of NDT's reactions
the guy on the right is gone after 10 mins
Chuck Nice would never get another gig ever. No lose there. The man is funny like a toothache.
It is a rule it's called the Apollo rule, but sadly the sandman has retired
Dr Tyson's Voice starts Breaking up
Me: I'm not gonna Cry I'm not Gonna Cry
also me : Here comes the Tears
Get a grip, theoretical physicist and / or astrophysicist phenom fanboy.
This man has giving his life to this...happy birthday Mr tyson
😂😭😭😭😭😭ikr
Wow, well done Neil, I could see your pain when "Murr" opened his mouth, you handled it much better than I ever could
I felt Neil's pain. Murr made me cringe
The pain is almost viceral, 19:42 Neil's face is on par with "SHUT THE FK UP!"
Hater
I cringe sooo Hard.. Brrrrrrr
"keep telling yourself that!"
Thanks NDT for not interrupting Brian like you usually do. Respects. Also HAPPY BIRTHDAY !!! 🎉🎉🎉🎈🎈🎈🎁🎁🎁🎂🎂🎂
Did you not watch the thing?
Passive aggressive much?...
You guys are all crazy
@@dr.withoutthedegree3990 he does interrupt him a lot tho
Neil and Brian are legends, when they explain something is like 1 + 1 = 2....they make difficult topics so easy to understand.
I just want Neil to live forever
He doesn’t want that
We ALL do! He is a world wide treasure!He will be cherished for centuries after his passing. But, let's pray he lives forever!
No one told me i was going to cry at the end.
Because there is one unbreakable rule in the universe: do not spoiler emotions. They beauty is much more valuable when appear unexpected.
You are not alone! I was crying, well tearing up during the last half of his life story!
Dr. Tyson took that turn at the last moment, sharing struggle I never knew before inspiring me and hopefully a lot of others. NDT is great human!
Indeed! One of the greatest humans to walk this blue marble we call home.
I had the privilege to see him live in a southern US town that had many civil rights struggles. He exceeded expectations, speaking for 3 hours on a school night and the kids fought to stay awake so they would not miss a moment and us adults could have listened all night.
Know what else it's time for?
COSMOS 👏 SEASON 👏 2
What kinda bear is best Dwight?
Technically it’s season 3. Season 1 was Carl Sagan’s season
Yes!
Unfortunately we will have to wait until 2021 for season 2 :(
Starlings murmuration Really? Where did you learn that from? I couldn’t find anything concerning any release date details
Dr. Tyson has literally rekindle the flames of curiosity of learning about space and everything that comes with it I haven't been this excited about learning stuff since I was a kid and I'm 30 years old now I think he is truly undervalued and underrated for his ability to teach anybody that wants to learnsome of the most complex things on the planet and make it seem easy
Yep that ending got me😢 awesome hour 🔥
it was very deep.
I pity Marr for being out-of-place. Although, I gotta say that he has the nerve to admit that he doesn't belong there.
And that really saves him in my eyes 👀 from being just jerk still, annoying at times.
He reminds me of a Greek Chorus, a stand-in for the audience. It didn't mind him at all.
It was weird, I don't think improv is his thing, he made a few serious science points to show he wasn't uneducated in the area and handled his bombs well, he just doesn't seem to have the quick wit required to do comedy commentary...
Well he was right lol
Brian greene and neil 😍😍😍
Brian is my favourite guest
Neil: "Brain, is time travel possible?"
Brian: "Well Nei...."
Neil: "OH BY THE WAY..."
smh.
He's obnoxious facepalm
So what?! They are Friends, dont you talk with Friends like that?! He just wanted to add sth, maybe it was important🤔
But they're actual mates so they are aware of each other communication patterns
Neil the type of guy to ask you a question and just when you start answering he goes
“And I forgot but cosmic background radiation is expanding into the vast reaches of space...oh sorry go ahead.” 😳
Murr needs practice as a comedian. We take Chuck for granted he's really good at being a learner and comedian at the same time
1000% agree
Wdym he’s decently funny
Hes a joker, not a comedian. Is there a difference, idk.
Idk that scrapbook c9mment was great
That ending was a tearjerker
after a couple decades of hearing the man talk in interviews and lectures i've never seen him getting emotional, and he talked about very emotional subjects over the years. I wondered how he kept those tears from coming out at any other time. Now i finally see, NDT, is just a man like you and me.
I kinda feel bad for Murr, he did make some unfunny jokes but it's the host's responsibility to make everyone feel comfortable and welcomed, because they chose to have them up there with them. Instead of just being so awkward at Murr's unfunny jokes, Neil could have added something funnier or wittier, or at least acknowledged the effort with a few more laughs and moved on with the conversation, that would have certainly made the vibe up there a bit less awkward and more positive.
So did I. Murr was understandably nervous the entire time being on stage with the big brains: NDT and Brian Greene. He was also under a lot of pressure to perform. He's a really funny guy on Impractical Jokers, so it's kinda sad seeing these hateful comments towards him.
Ya i noticed a couple times when neil has dialogue going and Murr jumps in and says something, just like chuck and him are there to do, you can visually see the annoyed look on Neil's face with a tone shift that doesn't help anything he says flow, could for sure be wrong here but there was definitely a lack vibe to where the group just does not play off eachother
agreed
@@troywashington8925 Yea, it really looks like NDT doesn't like Murr on a personal level.
I agree. NDT disrespected Murr throughout this, which made me lose a bit of respect for him.
Happy birthday, Dr. Neil! May your future be full of new and amazing discoveries.
Murr: i am just happy to be here
Viewers: we are not...
even the none viewers weren't happy Murr was there
15:15 umm I speak chicken like all the time.
Murr: literally anything
NDT: No no no, no no, no no
🤣
Is he really a comedian? Like Im not even smile when he throws line. Not even the butt of the joke Chuck is not even top comedian, but at least he is far way better than this guy.
@@naz6james570 Hahaha Lol so true.
Chuck has a much better attitude too. He doesn't look down on geeks and nerds.
Chuck is also very curious and open minded.
Murr showed no respect and therefore got none back.
Thank you so much for the subtitles. It helps a lot if English is not your native language.
James “Murr” Murray...thanks for spoiling the show...
I kept fast forwarding every time he made a sound
Hes trying to be cool with us geeks. Stop hating
He didn't spoil it for me I learned things . The theory that a black hole , if we have a multiverse the black hole in the other universe meet that black hole that it could be a portal to that parallel universe blows my mind
I have one question “Why Murr?”
36:47 Was it just me or was Dr. Tyson calling Murr "The Mole"?
The "Moe", as in one of the Three Stooges.
Powerful birthday-wish letter from Dr Tyson to NASA. Probably the humblest I've ever seen Dr Tyson. Really special moment for those of us watching.
If ever there were a real person to give the Star Trek speech “where no man has gone before,” it would be NDT. It’s always been an emotional thing to me and I think he truly gets it. If only we were there... alas, we are pretty much where Star Trek predicted our journey would take us before we put aside petty things.
Am watching this on 29 March 2022 and it is still amazing. Loads of Love from KENYA.
Neil I love you man and I know you're pressed for time usually but you really gotta work on not interrupting people
I have never noticed that🤔
Never seen NDT so emotional before. Very touching speech and great to see such passion for what he believes.
Imagine getting called “the mole” by neil tyson lol
I did not expect to cry at the end when I started watching this episode of Star Talk! I have such a deep admiration for NDT. What an amazing letter. What an inspirational figure for our society to have to look up to.
I'm so grateful for his presence here, educating and inspiring our society that so desperately needs people like him. ❤
Doctor Tyson, thank you for being you, and also happy birthday :)
Why do they have to have comedians on these panels?
Edit 1:We need another episode with just NdT and Brian Greene.
Edit 2: we need another episode with just Brian Greene
The comedians are annoying asf
Oh dang, I love Brian Greene; I've seen his [pbs] series on string theory tons of times over the years. :D
I highly recommend his book 'The Elegant Universe', if you haven't read/listened to it yet. It's a great breakdown of String Theory and the quantum properties thereof.
i LOVE to see an episode with neil & michiu kaku
Seriously, I love comedians, but in this sort of setting, they just confuse the conversation.
I would give my full attention to the panel if it were just scientists.
I agree, love Star Talk and the topics, etc., but the comedians are not helping (imo). I feel like they're trying too hard and might be different if they were actually funny, but who knows.
Maybe you would but the point of comedy in this case is to get science to more pop public
@@KaterinaTalantliva Maybe it is, but I think the point is, this isn't doing that.
Essero Eson you wouldn’t last 2 minutes in the vid
TRUE! THIS IS NOT THE VENUE FOR COMEDIANS!
6:19 Aaaaand THERE Chuck was Nice enough to make this the first proper episode of 'Star Talk, After Hours'. Thanks, Chuck!😁❤👍
I have watched many of Neil's vids but have never seen him moved like this.
Got me right in the feels and made me cry as I share his undying passion for all things in the sky. Thabk you NeiI, thoroughly enjoyed the entire thing. Was funny, Insightful and thoughtful to incorporate themes that comic con fans would enjoy. What a great idea. Do more pls. Oh and a Bugs Life rules haha
Don’t get why everyone’s hating on the second comedian...I’m glad to see startalk having funds to employ him and I appreciate his enthusiasm
It should be about science, not about shows.
We dont need more and more comedians, chuck is the best fit for this show😉
Thank you! People are just haters
That open letter at the end was something else. Congratulations, Dr. Tyson.
A Bugs Life, The three Amigos, Battle beyond the stars, The magnificent seven, and others were all reimagined remakes of the Seven Samurai.
Absolute classic
Murr already lost when he said "That's all I got!" He basically said: "Lower your standards."
And then Murr went on to hijack Chuck's laughs by following up Chuck's jokes with his punchlines. smh
2 of my favorite Scientists, Dr Tyson and Brian Greene. This was amazing to watch
44:26 just gonna leave this timestap here for I think the first time Neil loudly laughed at a Murr joke. I know Murr was feeling over the moon when he finally heard that laugh
Antman releasing most of his mass as energy would dwarf the tsar bomba by a factor of over 10.
that would be a very interesting light effect! :)
and happy birthday Dr. Tyson
Heron von Tremonia Finally! i was on quest for this comment 😂
BRIAN GREEN.. ♥
NDT remembered his youth when he choked up. "Dreams fueled by a pipeline..."
It's quite possibly the best thank you ever.
The comics make this very hard to watch. I came for the science, they just keep interrupting with unfunny jokes
cringe unfunny awkward. smh
From all the words you have spoken those last words to Nasa I have no doubt they wher true and from the heart.
(I know you told us to question everything and I honour you in return by questing the advice itself) Salute from The Netherlands
YOU MADE ME CRY MAN AS WITH YOUR STRENGTH,, DETERMINATION AND COURAGE YOU MADE IT POSSIBLE FOR MANY TO FOLLOW YOUR STEPS. LOVE YOU AND ALL BLESSINGS TO YOU.
Man i cried with Neill fr, such a humble guy and you can tell how much it means to him to be doing this changing the word.
You are an amazing guy mr Tyson. We respect you man!!!!
Lets Get It!!!
Keep looking up!!!
I have never seen so many instances of pity-laughter be so pitiful it turns into an actual genuine laughter.
I really really really hate to say this, but THAT was funny and I figuratively laughed out loud 😂
Hats off to murr, he definitely tried. Not really succeeded, but tried and most "geniuses" here in the comments section wouldn't have done jack
Only Chuck and Russell Peters belong on StarTalk as comedians.
Hater
@@nicholaslynn2944 Nope. I love Murray. But not everybody fits in this format.
James 'Happy to be here' Murray
Neil made science fun for me. 👍🏽
Drink!!!
🍹🍸🥃🍷🍺
Every time Neil says, "So..." 😂
TWSTF 8 I did, now I’m dead
I am so thrilled that Neil is a whovian. I’ve been a fan of Neil since finding out about the return of cosmos. my first doctor was Tom baker. I love listening to Neil talk doctor who because I actually understand what he’s saying and I believe that doctor who crosses into a he realm of if time travel was possible, here’s how you’d do it.
Chuck is King of the one liners
Happy Birthday .... The Letter to NASA was great ! The Finally Realized they needed some More Melanin on that Panel lol ....
In another universe DMT smokes Joe Rogan
That eye roll at 19:43 loool. And Neil is over laughing at Chucks jokes to make Murr feel bad.
We,who are about to have our minds blown,salute you. Happy birthday professor Tyson.
Beautiful speech, Neil! Happy Birthday!!! Love from France.
I admit Murr had some bad moments here, but he definitely had some good ones. They all seemed a little nervous, but Murr seemed like he felt out of place. I think if the group spent a lot of time together their discussions would sound more natural and things would flow better.
Awww!!!!! ❤ That ending speech/letter. ❤❤❤🥰❤❤
Belated happy birthday Dr Tyson, the world is a better place for having you in it.
Wow, the 60th Birthday speech has me in tears!
38:46 "Or Jelly" LMAO
28:15 Chuck Nice with the great Ruth Bader Ginsburg sentiment.
His speech at the end choked me up. I look forward to the future of exo-exploration
Murr is better at talking when someone’s in his ear telling him what to say
Greene is real class!
This is a real man talking from his heart about his love for Nasa and his discouragement about his dream in America by an older generation that didn't know how great evey person can be and that their color means nothing except a different perspective... Neil Degrasse Tyson is the reason I became curious again and fell in love with science and the vastness and wonders of the universe!!! Thank you Neil your an inspiration for all of us!!!
I’m learning more about our universe everyday through your videos Dr. Tyson. Thank you!
El comic will not be invited back any time now, in the past, or in the future
This whole show was amazing.
what amazing dialogue. thanks NDT and Brian Greene!
Dr Tyson, belated happy birthday to you. Great discussion and that letter in the end was just so on point.
I am always amazed how even after knowing so much in astrophysics Niel always acts like he is always acting like he needs to have more knowledge 🙏
Can someone please edit this to remove that "nails on a chalkboard" James Murray from the video in it's entirety? Thanks in advance
Oh I hear you. I cringed so much every time he opened his mouth.
The most right thing was said by Murr at the start when he said he didn't belong here
This is encouraging to see the crowd loving this so much. Stuff like this gives me hope in humanity.. No more politics for me right now.. Stuff like this is way more stimulating and fulfilling
Just when I say I cannot love Brian anymore, here he is
What are you talking about
Any more then you already doo? Orr
For comedic relieve, Chuck and the other big guy that appears on other startalk episodes will suffice, these random comedians are just not as funny. Can we appreciate Chuck now.
Chuck is awful
Drew hater G
Hes trying to be cool and learn with us. Hatet
@@nicholaslynn2944 I'm not a hater.. but seriously he wasn't funny..or cool... maybe he was a bit confused or feelin awkward.. but yeah he could handle the situation in a different way. .
I'm sorry but i didn't mean he's not a great comedian but he just doesn't fit up there.. look at his expressions and random jokes that just makes me cringe..
Would've been better if they'd replaced these two comedians or atleast one with bill nye..or someother smart guy..
Chuck b on point
Love you Dr. Tyson... You never cease to inspire me...
23:33 I loved neil's face...
I'm dyeing laughing...lol
I Love StarTalk.
Well, Chuck, I frequently wonder about the fabric of time. Put that in your pipe and smoke it.
Typing with hooves is also really hard. I crushed four smartphones this month alone.
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Wish we could get Dave Chappelle on Startalk. Really wonder how he would gel with Neil.
Dave and Chuck too!
Tundra Boy that would be interesting.
Dude i would pay actual money to see that..
NDT... a truly inspirational educator and incredibly insightful human being. Love this guy!
Why not?
Mr Degrasse, beautiful letter hope it inspires the world! thankyou
🇧🇪check