Menachem Begin sharp response
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ต.ค. 2024
- In this updated clip, shared by Israel's industry minister Naftali Bennet, legendary Prime Minister Menachem Begin reacts to criticism over his opposition to the creation of a Palestinian state.
When Mark Twain visited the territory of Palestine in 1867, he said:
"[a] desolate country whose soil is rich enough, but is given over wholly to weeds - a silent mournful expanse... A desolation is here that not even imagination can grace with the pomp of life and action... We never saw a HUMAN BEING on the whole route... There was HARDLY a tree or a shrub ANYWHERE. Even the olive and the cactus,those fast friends of the worthless soil, had almost deserted the country."
The Peel Commission of 1937 found Arab complaints about Jewish land acquisition were baseless. It pointed out that "much of the land now carrying orange groves was sand dunes or swamp and uncultivated when it was purchased...there was at the time of the earlier sales little evidence that the owners possessed either the resources or training needed to develop the land."
Moreover, the Commission found the shortage was "due less to the amount of land acquired by Jews than to the increase in the Arab population" due not to birthrates, but the massive immigration of migrant workers from Egypt, Syria, Transjordan and Lebanon and elsewhere.
In 1937, local Arab leader Auni Bey Abdul-Hadi told the Commission, which ultimately suggested the partition of the Palestinian Mandate: "There is no such country [as Palestine]! 'Palestine' is a term the Zionists invented! There is no Palestine in the Bible. Our country was for centuries part of Syria."
The representative of the Arab Higher Committee to the UN submitted a statement to the General Assembly in May 1947 that said, "Palestine was part of the Province of Syria" and that "politically, the Arabs of Palestine were not independent in the sense of forming a separate political entity."
A few years later, Ahmed Shuqeiri, later the chairman of the PLO, told the Security Council: "It is common knowledge that Palestine is nothing but southern Syria."
If the local population were wronged after being told by the 5 Arab armies to leave their homes, and return later after they massacre the Jews in Israel, how come they weren't given their political independence by Egypt and Jordan which respectively occupied Gaza and the Jordanian West Bank for 19 years?
Why did only Britain and Pakistan recognize Jordan's annexation of the West bank in 1949?
How come no Arab leader even visited Jerusalem for the 19 years Jordan occupied it?
Why was the Palestinian Liberation Organization founded in 1964, 3 full years before the Six-Day War? Their targets weren't in Jordan, they were in Israel as their Charter to THIS DAY clearly states (a charter in direct violation of the Oslo Accords)?
If Arabs are all brothers, and every human life is essential and valuable, why didn't anyone do the humanitarian thing and let them immigrate to one of the TWENTY-TWO Arab-Muslim states in the world to become a citizen?
A targeted, sustained de-legitimization campaign against Israel has been going on now for over 65 years.
What a wonderful post, Larry. I copied it, and will spread it far and wide, with our without your name as you wish. Especially during these BDS weeks, we need to counter the propaganda that is ramping up anti-Semitism all around the world. Your words are a concise, accurate summation.
Alana Ronald Hello Alana. Thank you for your kind words. Spread this far and wide, I don't need any recognition. The truth must be spread and the lies exposed.
Larry Brikman Very well written and so true! Thanks Larry!
Sorry, Mark Twain was a complete fraud, just like you
❤️🔥 🇵🇸 Free Palestine 🇵🇸 ❤️🔥
Over 5000 years old nation and going strong .
another khazar lie
+fisch kopf u ain t worth any attention
zaodizao , 1906 Jewish Encyclopedia Volume 4, tells the conversion of Khazaria to Jews!!!
5,000 years? Did you ever go to maths class? Israel was illegally founded in 1948, 70 years ago this May!
5000 yrs sgo..???
2000 yrs ago, ur Ancestors snitched on Jesus and caused his crucifixion.
begin was the man!!!!!!!!!!!!!
for sure
No wonder Menachem Begin is already a legend. No Palestinian State, ever, ever, ever...and no Nazi State as well. (Same thing)
There's already a neo nazi state, It's called israel.
In case you didn't uderstand, state practitioners of genocide,are nazis. And don't give us the crap about the common useage definition of genocide. Genocide, in case you didn't understand, is a crime. As such, its definition is to be found in a dictionary of legal terms, or on the website of the International Criminal Court
John Somebody Nazi means "genocidal antisemite". Of course that's very rare to find among Jews. But very common in Arab countries where antisemitism is endemic, above the 80% level. John Nobody is probably from there.
Yosef Kutner R O T F L , where did you get that definition of a nazi, then ? Odd that it fits neo - nazi excuses to practise genocide, against Semitic Palestinians and ignores defining characteristics of behaviour.
Do you understand the prefix, "neo", or don't you ?
***** Blah blah blah is to be expected from neo - nazi thugs when they're being confronted about something they have no true defence against
John Somebody as if the Nazis aren't something you would have supported.
To those calling begin a terrorist, keep in mind that in israel he is revered as a war hero of the war of independence. In America we have the same thing. One of the reasons jfk was elected was because he was a war hero. And to those assholes who will give me the terrorism not war argument, two words. American Revolution.
& you obviously didn't read all of my post. i already made an argument for people like you. as i said, two words. american revolution.
if you lived at the time of the american revolution, people would have pegged you a tory. thomas jefferson said, "the tree of liberty must occasionally be fertilized be the blood of patriots and tyrants." of, course, a person like you would misunderstand that and not realize what he means. what he means exactly is that desperate times call for desperate measures. at times you need to fight for what is yours.at times you even have to kill for them. but only during those times.
but go ahead with your frame of mind that the irgun was the same as the current islamist terrorist, while in reality the irgun was unique in the act of sending a warning before every bombing, while in israel, a terrorist would bomb right out of nowhere. also, israel was and is willing to negotiate with the palestinians, while britain has a deep history of holding on strongly to their empire.
I agree with you Chaim. I cannot classify him as either a terrorist or a freedom fighter - and thus the same goes for Yasser Arafat and even Hammas (think back to Irgun)...
But menachem begin didn't use civilians as shields.
***** Against what? They were the attacking force... Anyway,I genuinely am not here for an argument. I have been researching the issue of Palestine/Israel for a few years as I have family in both camps and really do hope for a better way forward. I dont know how of course (else I would be winning the Nobel PP) however what I do know is that both parties have acted both as terrorists and freedom fighters at different stages. Perhaps the one thing I can say today, is that continuation of the settlements will continue invoking murders. There should be a point where one can say they have enough, being too greedy will not work.
Israel needs more leaders like him he is a legend
I love this man and the way he speaks.
He was a racist. Maybe that’s why🥹
@@Mr-Fuman-Jah He's right
@@colombianblitz who is right? U dumb fack ?
The suffering of the of the Jews in Europe from the 1880s-1940s does not justify the current ill treatment of people descended from the Ottoman-ruled Palestine who have known no other home. If Catholic Mexicans used massive waves of settlements to take over Texas, Arizona, New Mexico, and California, seceded from the Union, and refused rights to the Americans remaining in "their" borders, how would you would react? I know militant Islamic states and state-sponsored terrorists in the region have a history of attacking Israel. That's one piece of the problem. It's not the underlying issue.
There are ways to become more humane to all people living in the region without compromising the security of a nation. There are ways to divorce religiosity from governance to create a platform that earns a mandate from all the people who call a slab of ground home. And it is possible to reject fear created by generations of persecution and govern with an open heart. I hope Israel -- both Jewish and non-jewish -- becomes a nation of all the people, not just the ones currently holding power.
Israel has been and already is a nation of "all the people". It has welcomed and absorbed immigrants from all over the world. It is a democracy, too, that also protects its minority communities. Arabs and Jews work, shop, and play side by side. Arabs are represented and hold high positions in the Supreme Court and Parliament. There also Arabs in the military. Can you show me a neighboring Arab country that can make the same claims with regard to Jews or Israelis? Israel has its problems like any civilized society including ours but I believe, and the facts support that Israel is probably one of the most humane societies in existence today.
You really should stop relying on Arab propaganda as you source of information, it makes you sound foolish. All those who want peace and live in peace are treated well. the problems are with those who want to kill us and I am sure that you also would not tolerate anyone who threatened you.
We love you and miss you Menachem Begin!!!
What a Man!
! Israel needs strong leaders like him!
Begin hit it on the head. He wasnt afraid of world image and reaction.
+Marc Edelstein He was after Shaba and Shatila.
+Marc Edelstein What does a Palestinian state have to do Nazis, stein?
@@limcako41 , sabra and Shatilla done by Christians
@@davidweiss9891 yes you're right.But the IDF sent them in and did not stop them when they started killing people
@@davidweiss9891 I am not scapegoating Jews.Even an Israeli enquiry commission and judges stated Ariel Sharon guilty along with tens of thousands of Israelis marched for his sacking
without a doubt one of the best leaders our nation has ever had!
***** thx
Arche Nova go troll elsewhere.
+Beni Habibi you must be so proud if theres a hell and worldly justice hes there :) was responsible for the
1946
terrorist bombing of Hotel King David, the 1948 massacre in
the Palestinian village of
Deir Yassin
and the 1982 invasion of Lebanon and the
Sabra-Chatila massacre of up to 2 000 civilian Palestinians.
such a nice person :)
+itsbitchpudding toyou657 Sabra and Shitila were carried out by the Xian militias. Dir Yasin was an Arab fabrication. king David was against an occupying force. If you are going to post at least get your facts correct.
itsbitchpudding toyou657 you already posted this to me, and my response is the same as last time. but in case you didn't want to read it, RichardGMoss gave you a good answer.
Begin lived in the worst of times, saw the worst of horrors. Of course you don't understand. You weren't there, you will never know.
It's time to stand. It's time to say not only NO, but HELL NO!
King David Hotel bombing
Great Man and Leader. Need more like him.
Terrorist
The big problem that will eventually catch up to Israel is that if there is no Palestinian State, then Israel will have no choice but to become a single, bi-National state, with Palestinians having the same legal rights as Israeli citizens. Is this REALLY what Israel wants? The situation as it is now cannot be sustained forever. Just ask former rulers of apartheid-era South Africa.
RIP Menachem Begin
the best leader ever he didnt fuck around
The best leader Israel ever had. Iran would not be an issue if he was around.
Dear Prime Minister Netanyahu, is this not the way to respond to President Obama?
The most wanted Man by Mi5 and declared a terrorist becomes a prime minister.
Tables have turned and now hamas is the terrorist. Maybe one day Hamas leaders might become recognised leaders
begin looks like adolf eichmann
Not really
Absolutely right. Israel will never ever be secure with a Palestinian state in Judea and Samaria. Anyway Abu Mazen refuses to accept/recognise Israel as a Jewish State. He has shot himself in the foot in adopting that stance which fully justifies Israel in jettisoning negotiations towards a 2 state solution which will be as workable as the Gaza debacle.
What does Palestine have to do with Germany? Answer any time.
+Aeschlimann1 Nothing - Germans exist, while Palestinians are a made up people w/ 0 historical evidence of their existence
bigmedge NOW YOU SOUND LIKE BEGIN.
bigmedge WHO THE HELL WOULD WANT TO EXPEL YOU FROM 100 COUNTRIES???
Aeschlimann1 "NOW YOU SOUND LIKE BEGIN" Thank u, that's very kind of u, but Begin is a far greater man than me, considering what he overcame & what he achieved. Still, it's a nice thing to hear b/c I didn't expect such a kind compliment from a deranged & deluded antisemite. I take that as a subtle sign that you're finally starting to acknowledge Israel's moral, technological, & military superiority - so maybe there's hope for u yet.
Wish it was like this today!
Need the government to be more honest like this...
EPIC DIALOGUE DELIVERY HATS OFF TO HIM
re tell it like it still is.we have not forgotten
Bravo, exactly my thoughts !
Are you aware of any other clips of Begin speaking? I've been looking for clips like this - Thank you for sharing.
well then listen to your hero here:
"Egyptian army concentrations in the Sinai approaches did not prove that Nasser was really about to attack us. We must be honest with ourselves. We decided to attack him."
tadaaaaaa....
Great person! God bless Israel!
God will bless Israel! Wish the rest of the world would too.
I so love this!!
I love it, It brings tears of pride to my eyes. What boat did the present Israeli leadership come over on? They have obviously forgotten the great courage and Jewish pride of their forefathers and may Hashem help them.
Jerome S. Kaufman www.israel-commentary.org
Begin was a man who made no mistakes.
ABSOLUTE LEGEND!!!
❤️🔥 🇵🇸 Free Palestine 🇵🇸 ❤️🔥
what a hero !!!
"Our race is the Master Race. we are divine gods on this planet. We are as different from the inferior races as they are from insects.... Other races are beasts and animals, cattle at best. Our destiny is to rule over the inferior races. The masses will lick our feet and serve us as our slaves"
This is the "Great Leader" do you support?,Menachem Begin was a dirty Terrorist worst than Hamas or another Palestinian who'she resisted the demolition of his house
,and Menachem Begin was the responsable of the King David Hotel attack in 1946,hypocrites
BOSS, this is a different generation. If we had a leader like this now.............wow
Anne Frank would have been so disgusted by such an attitude...
Yes, PP20120, Anne Frank---an adolescent girl forced to live her last years hiding from Nazis in an attic---would've undoubtedly been a hardcore, pro-Palestinian Leftist. And also, she would've spoken out for gay rights, legalized pot, euthanasia & affirmative action.
Feel free to put words in the mouths of murdered children, you dumb@$$.
TimeWarp66 Seriously, zio - nazis, (state practioners of genocide as described by Article 6 Rome Statute, ICC), make me vomit. But then I feel better, as I realise you're helping to destroy zionism, by proving how insane zzio - nazis are
TimeWarp66 If neo - nazis like you could include some intellectual content in their comments, I could reply to them.
TimeWarp66 Your saying that I've used such a technique, is not even evidence that I have.
Also : 1. Jews being victims of nazis, 70 years ago does not diminish the fact, that israel depends on state practitioners of genocide, (neo - nazis), in order to exist, TODAY. And you're pretending that I had accused all Jews of being neo - nazis. I have not.
2. Jews being victims of people, (terrorists or not), who do what they do, BECAUSE, neo - nazis have been terrorising them, does not diminish the fact, that zionist neo - nazis have been terrorising them, ever since invading Palestine.
3. Hamas created the Hamas Charter, after 30 YEARS of zionist neo - nazi genocidal war, ahgainst a cvilian population, WITHOUT Hamas. And Hamas were then created, with encouragement, and at first, funding, by israel, in order to undermine the PLO.
4. Irrespective of how long Jews have lived in PALESTINE, Palestinians have lived there since the days of Canaan.
You go on and on, repeatedly scraping the zio - neo - nazi barrel. Any hatred I might be motivated by, would include hatred of racist filth like you.
AnnFrank would have been so disgusted by shitler-loving antisemites such as JohnNobody and partyPeople2010
Ah… when ppl had a backbone
NO WAY! HE WAS RIGHT. IT IS JEWISH STATE. 100% Given them by GOD himself
No it isn’t. East Europeans were NOT granted land from a fascist deity.
It’s 2024, not 200BC. You need help.
G-OD bless your great soul .
tell them begin these nazis of chancelor in Germany.
He certainly had more traits similar to the Nazis than the blessed chancellor Schmidt.
He was funny. My father loved him. I believe he was from the labor party.
+Raven R he was from the likud
+Raven R nope - he FOUNDED the Likud party and stood for a strong Israel.
Last decent President we had. He was strong, and had a lot of guts. Unlike, all the kiss ass Presidents we've had had since him. I knew him personally. He was one great leader.
מצוין, אך הבעיה היא שבגין נתן להם אוטונומיה...
Free Palestine and we will return to Palestine 🇵🇸✌️🇵🇸
🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬
TOTALLY,
There is and it's called Jordan. Unfortunately ruled over by the minority Hashemites.
The land belongs to the Jewish people. When two parties to a dispute come to court to settle their difference, the first words out of the judge's mouth are, "let's start from the beginning," and "present any evidence(s) you have."
The earliest mention of the Holy Land as Palestine (probably in reference to the Philistines, a non-Arabic, non-Semitic people from the Greek Isles who invaded the southern coast of the Holy Land in the 2nd half of the 12th Cen. BCE) is by the Greek historian, Herodotus (5th Cen. BCE).
In contrast, one of the earliest mention of the Holy Land as Israel is the 9th Cen. BCE archaeological find the Mesha Stele commissioned by the king of Moab (present-day Jordan) which mentions Israel and a king of Israel, namely, Omri. (The Mesha Stele aka Moabite Stone is housed at The Louvre in Paris, France.)
The claim that the land belongs to the "Palestinians" should be reflected in the archaeological records. Can someone cite one archaeological evidence for the "Palestinian?"
the historic argument wouldn't be accepted by any court and certainly not under international law. whole peoples have always changed their settlements within the last 2000 years without being able to reclaim land.
@@nightwish1000 In that case, indigenous rights are null and void. I disagree with your logic, not to mention that the Jewish home was colonized and then most of the Jews were forcibly exiled. In other words, we didn't move around, we were kicked out of our own land where we became a people 3300 years ago.
War Criminal!
🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬
The Father of T3rror1sm ladies and gentlemen
Mr Begin seems to forget in his maybe emotionally understandable antigerman stance that Israel would have hardly existed at this time without early German support that he opposed so vividly.
the person had saw a bad and horrendous past just because of the people whom they considered their friends now and they had their golden time because of the people they genocide murder and oppress in any possible way now.....ain't it irony........Palestine wil rise and conquer from river to the sea...islam will win now and always......Allah hu Akbar
Do you not see youre doing the same thing that happened to your own people, to the Palestinians? The persecuted become the persecutors
Ridiculous. Nobody's sending Palestinians to death camps. There are no mass graves. Their population is growing. There are more Palestinian citizens of Israel today, than even existed in 1948. You need a history lesson.
Bullshit!!!
Irwin Graulich Please show us the transportation depots for death camps and the mass graves. (Perhaps you can upload of video showing these sites!)
Stuart Einbinder Irwin Graulich Dear both, putting aside the typical emotive and irrational commentary from Irwin as usual (!), Stuart your question is sensible. The answer is here www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/04/mass-graves-jaffa-israel-palestine-1948_n_3385011.html. But apart from that, we know and papers exist that Israel has committed War Crimes, we know the massacres fof 46 of the indigenous population at the time by the incoming Europeans etc... That however is history. More importantly, I honestly think Israel is its own worst enemy. It can progres but there is a limit, a better solution is required. And finally, yes, the victim has become the aggressor and that is a real shame.
Bazzi Seventyeight boom. perfectly consistent with what israeli founding father matityahu peled , his son, general M. Peled and his nephew Miko Peled are telling us, without even being heard.
to all who really support the israeli government, watch some speeches of miko peled, then consider for yourself. there are enough of him on youtube.
btw. it really doesnt even matter if there where death or working camps. the palestinian struggle began what is known as the nakba, and the nakba did not end up until today. the people do suffer. some more, some less, some much more, inside and oustide of israel. this is nothing that can be supported.
Over 5000 years old nation and going strong .
+zaodizao No proof of that whatsoever.
+Aeschlimann1 says the guy who thinks that the USSR was Jewish.
I just bet you are using a device with an intel chip in it developed in the zionist state to post some slander everywhere you can , we don't care your boycott of veggies and humus just sayin', the only proof there is is how strong your hatred is and how lil we , I care