Due Super interpreti del Melodramma...Renata Scotto tra le grandissime soprano ...e ..Luciano Pavarotti tenore eccelso...una coppia del bel canto assoluta...quando mai potremo sentire una tale meraviglia.❤👏👏👏🙏
The pianist deserves an award. I can't imagine playing this piece as much movement and ritardandos it has! Bravo for a job well done. The singers = sublime!
sorry to be so offtopic but does any of you know of a tool to get back into an Instagram account? I stupidly forgot the login password. I appreciate any tips you can offer me.
@Kace Rory I really appreciate your reply. I got to the site through google and Im trying it out atm. Seems to take quite some time so I will reply here later with my results.
and as you can hear Pavarotti had not a tiny voice lyke a lot of people thinks, far from tiny actually and with a mindblowing resonance what a voice what a man ! I miss him so much
@@ransomcoates546 large small, but so beautiful, resonance, diction, color, darken as he aged, he could still pump out an amazing sound even when he was dying on his feet.
Quiza no fuera la mejor voz... pero, por qué se le criticó tanto?, tan difícil es escuchar lo que te gusta, sin vomitar opiniones despectivas de los demás cantantes?. A mi Pavarotti me encanta, y no tendria un sonido tan mediocre cuando fue de los pocos tenores que se igualó con "la Stupenda" o "la Superba". La propia Callas dijo que Pavarotti era "El tenor". No se, no digo que no tengas tu opinión, pero si este es un cantante que no te agrada demasiado... escucha a otros. Yo pagaria a dia de hoy 10.000 € por ver a Pavarotti, antes que 500 por escuchar a Tuker. Pd: creo que tú harías lo mismo.
This recording makes you feel like you are sited right there, the sound is so live. This is close as I could get to hear Pavarotti live I think. Wonderful voices, both of them! Pavarotti sounds incredible...I love Scotto anytime. Celio
this is like watching figure skating or something...i love at 7:59 when they move that line together. i love these home-made videos of recitals or shows. you really get to see the true artistry and there are no silly camera angles It's just as if you're sitting in the audience. THANK YOU SO MUCH!
MAMMA MIA KE BRIVIDI CON QUESTI VIDEO! LA VOCE DELLA SCOTTO SI FONDE COMPLETAMENTE A QUELLA DI PAVAROTTI SONO STRAORDINARI! NON ASCOLTEREMO MAI PIU VOCI COSI'! :(
Lovely and quite different from Corelli and Crespin. A lot of flexibility in the long slow duet so the farewell sails along. This was Pavarotti's first long Verdi role and he sang it often after rolling out Rigoletto. The recording sounds just like they did in the house: Brilliantly clear without being wall busters. Really great singing from both. Brings back memories of seeing them together.
@@BoleDaPole Ah la Garanca Nebtreko 😴😴😴 I wouldn't go to any of these events even if it was free. Stay safe my friend 😷💙💉 Greetings from France & Spain Arnold Bourbon Amaral
Scotto, to this day, has the absolute, definitive performance of "Suor Angelica" on the Columbia recording from the 1980's. With nuanced inflection and rubato, it chills your spine and breaks your heart! (Bonus on the recording: Marilyn Horne sings the role of her aunt.)
That's the only recording I have of Scotto. Sorry to say I never liked Marilyn Horne for obvious reasons. But I did discover Ileana Cotrubas my all-time favorite pure form lyric soprano. Please stay safe my friends 💙😷 Greetings from France & Spain. Arnold Bourbon Amaral 🇪🇸🇫🇷💙
@@KmwAmg I have it a VCR converted it to DVD it's a treasure. Thank you for the reminder my wife and I too we're teary eyed. And a few months before she was booed at the Met when she perform Norma. Poor Renata. She had such great artistic instincts. But failed to choose her roles carefully. Please stay safe. 😷💙💉 Arnold Bourbon Amaral
@@arnoldamaral7406 What are the “obvious reasons” for not liking Marilyn Horne? You should be more modest about your musical appreciations that don’t allow you to appreciate Horne. Your failing should not be blamed on her, for obvious reasons.
Oh, i'm sure this is from the October 1976 (First) Richard Tucker Gala. I was there. It was after this performance that People Magazine (yes, People!) snapped a pic of the two of them together with Luciano licking Renata's shoulder.
It was probably pass his midnight snack.. How disgusting that must have been. 🐷 Please be safe. My friend. 😷💙 Renata Scotto was always so extreme to her detriment. Arnold Bourbon Amaral
This is wonderful!!! so sensitive and romantic! and agreed this sounds like you are actually sitting in the audience!! it's truly the first time my ear has head pavarotti like this
This is incredible! I have a tape of Scotto and Pavarotti singing this opera in '75 from Hamburg and they are superb. By the time they sang it again in the early 80's in Chicago (their last opera performance together due to their feud over the Gioconda telecast), Scotto was not in this kind of voice. This is a treasure to see her in such complete command, esp. the top. Can anyone tell us what year and where this is from? They never gave a joint concert in the States that I am aware of.
Gosh how fascinating! She doesn`t even mention him by name in her autobiography, but I think they made their peace before he died. Perhaps their SFO Gioconda will be issued on dvd? Great singing here. Thanks for sharing.
This must have been before her first Norma, after that the voice was never the same! They sound like the last two divinities who really understood Verdi style.
@pkunzip501Lastly,she sang only Amina in the fifities, amigo.Recorded Lucia in '59, sang it on stage in '60.She sang those bel canto roles in the sixties primarily.ThenStraniera,Vestale,Anna Bolena,Norma,etc.Cigna & Cabale sang Straniera. She is well known as the last great verista: Adriana,Maddelena, Angelica,Butterfly,Santuzza were extraordinary.If she is not a full lyric &she is not a coloratura, what was she?I know:YOU KNOW:& far more than Serafin,deSabata,Abbado,Muti,Maazel,Karajan,Levine.
+operadoc This is most definitely before the '79 Gioconda. She shed some 50 lbs after the Boheme telecast which was early '77. After that she was glamorously slim as in the Otello telecast with Vickers in '78 and thereafter. I date it mid-70's but from where? If broadcast, I have never seen even an audio tape listed. This is a treasure!
@leonardovittori1You are mistaken:Traviata IS NOT A COLORATURA operaThe fact that Berthe inProphete has coloratura to sing does not make it a coloratura part.Muzio sang it at the MET!FamousViolettas:Tebaldi,Stella,Tucci,Caniglia,delosAngeles.Where they coloraturas>YesTucci had a highEb.GlauceIN NOT a coloratura part:Lorengar and Tucci sang it!Gencer sang all these roles with high notes!So what?Ricciarelli sang these parts.WHERE YOU THERE to say she was not a full lyric?What COULDyou like her in?
I do not agree with you that she is pushing. You are saying that after the fact because she had vocal problems. She was not a soprano leggerio.She always sang Butterfly, Faust, Traviata...even Lisa in Pique Dam. Why do you think she was a coloratura?Because she sang Lucia and Amina?What other roles? She could sing coloratura at a certain point in her career, but it was pure technique. When the voice got darker and heavier,she dropped them.Their feud is legendary.Read her book: More Than A Diva.
...using the mike built into the camera with people moving near me. Let's see/hear you do better "back then" - under those conditions using that equiptment. A monster camera, manual zoom and holding it pretty phuquing steady.
@pkunzip501 Sigh... I hated Tebaldi Stell Tucci etc as Violetta.. If you do not have a solid coloaratura technique yofu cannot get through The first act aria... and it is SO important.. I cannot stand Violetta's who sound like they are relieved when sempre Libera is over.. E flats not withstanding. For instance Fleming, does not take E flat all the time, but all her fiorture before sounds like she is working really hard. Berthe is a coloratura part. Listen to it.
Due Super interpreti del Melodramma...Renata Scotto tra le grandissime soprano ...e ..Luciano Pavarotti tenore eccelso...una coppia del bel canto assoluta...quando mai potremo sentire una tale meraviglia.❤👏👏👏🙏
The absolute Greatest Maestra and Maestro
Oh My God is this beautiful! ...and Pavarotti...! What is there to say? This is why Luciano is Luciano. There will never be another.
The pianist deserves an award. I can't imagine playing this piece as much movement and ritardandos it has! Bravo for a job well done. The singers = sublime!
sorry to be so offtopic but does any of you know of a tool to get back into an Instagram account?
I stupidly forgot the login password. I appreciate any tips you can offer me.
@Kendall Joshua Instablaster =)
@Kace Rory I really appreciate your reply. I got to the site through google and Im trying it out atm.
Seems to take quite some time so I will reply here later with my results.
@Kace Rory it did the trick and I now got access to my account again. Im so happy!
Thank you so much, you saved my account :D
@Kendall Joshua happy to help =)
and as you can hear Pavarotti had not a tiny voice lyke a lot of people thinks, far from tiny actually and with a mindblowing resonance what a voice what a man ! I miss him so much
Not tiny, but not as big as say, Tucker. P. had real 'point' in the voice that made it penetrate orchestras, but it was not in itself a large sound.
@@ransomcoates546 large small, but so beautiful, resonance, diction, color, darken as he aged, he could still pump out an amazing sound even when he was dying on his feet.
He has a lyric voice, not even spinto..
Quiza no fuera la mejor voz... pero, por qué se le criticó tanto?, tan difícil es escuchar lo que te gusta, sin vomitar opiniones despectivas de los demás cantantes?. A mi Pavarotti me encanta, y no tendria un sonido tan mediocre cuando fue de los pocos tenores que se igualó con "la Stupenda" o "la Superba". La propia Callas dijo que Pavarotti era "El tenor". No se, no digo que no tengas tu opinión, pero si este es un cantante que no te agrada demasiado... escucha a otros. Yo pagaria a dia de hoy 10.000 € por ver a Pavarotti, antes que 500 por escuchar a Tuker. Pd: creo que tú harías lo mismo.
OMg this is out of this world SCotto is brilliant and PAv is at his best
great strength in his stillness, evident here more than ever
Pavarotti and Scotto at their best.
She sounds WONDERFUL here.
first step on the moon, first step for mankind, this is the first path to the heart of mankind !
This recording makes you feel like you are sited right there, the sound is so live. This is close as I could get to hear Pavarotti live I think. Wonderful voices, both of them! Pavarotti sounds incredible...I love Scotto anytime. Celio
грандиозноооооо!!!!!
Both of them... Spectacular!
this is like watching figure skating or something...i love at 7:59 when they move that line together. i love these home-made videos of recitals or shows. you really get to see the true artistry and there are no silly camera angles It's just as if you're sitting in the audience.
THANK YOU SO MUCH!
You're welcome.
Thanks. I guess schlepping all that video equipment (under cover) - especially in 'that' Hall, was worth it.
MAMMA MIA KE BRIVIDI CON QUESTI VIDEO! LA VOCE DELLA SCOTTO SI FONDE COMPLETAMENTE A QUELLA DI PAVAROTTI SONO STRAORDINARI! NON ASCOLTEREMO MAI PIU VOCI COSI'! :(
No le voci ci sono, occorrono gli insegnanti!
Lovely and quite different from Corelli and Crespin. A lot of flexibility in the long slow duet so the farewell sails along. This was Pavarotti's first long Verdi role and he sang it often after rolling out Rigoletto. The recording sounds just like they did in the house: Brilliantly clear without being wall busters. Really great singing from both. Brings back memories of seeing them together.
Pianist might be Richard Woitach. Concert may have occurred 10/31/1976 at Carnegie Hall as a tribute to Richard Tucker (who died in 1975).
You are Correct!!
Wow title says it all. Glorious.
amazing singing!! I wish we could see it nowadays!!!
Josep VIADER I wish we could too!!
It's all lip syncing and computer enhanced techo Crap
@@MrStpendouslvforjo Saioa Hernandez is a rising star my friend. Stay safe 💙😷💉 greetings from Spain and France 🇪🇸🇫🇷 Arnold Bourbon Amaral
@@BoleDaPole Ah la Garanca Nebtreko 😴😴😴 I wouldn't go to any of these events even if it was free. Stay safe my friend 😷💙💉 Greetings from France & Spain Arnold Bourbon Amaral
That's shining voices of them
Scotto, to this day, has the absolute, definitive performance of "Suor Angelica" on the Columbia recording from the 1980's. With nuanced inflection and rubato, it chills your spine and breaks your heart! (Bonus on the recording: Marilyn Horne sings the role of her aunt.)
Saw her do the role at the Met .Scotto made me cry !
That's the only recording I have of Scotto. Sorry to say I never liked Marilyn Horne for obvious reasons. But I did discover Ileana Cotrubas my all-time favorite pure form lyric soprano. Please stay safe my friends 💙😷 Greetings from France & Spain. Arnold Bourbon Amaral 🇪🇸🇫🇷💙
@@KmwAmg I have it a VCR converted it to DVD it's a treasure. Thank you for the reminder my wife and I too we're teary eyed. And a few months before she was booed at the Met when she perform Norma. Poor Renata. She had such great artistic instincts. But failed to choose her roles carefully. Please stay safe. 😷💙💉 Arnold Bourbon Amaral
@@arnoldamaral7406 What are the “obvious reasons” for not liking Marilyn Horne? You should be more modest about your musical appreciations that don’t allow you to appreciate Horne. Your failing should not be blamed on her, for obvious reasons.
Oh, i'm sure this is from the October 1976 (First) Richard Tucker Gala. I was there. It was after this performance that People Magazine (yes, People!) snapped a pic of the two of them together with Luciano licking Renata's shoulder.
It was probably pass his midnight snack.. How disgusting that must have been. 🐷 Please be safe. My friend. 😷💙 Renata Scotto was always so extreme to her detriment. Arnold Bourbon Amaral
5 STELLE! HO ANCORA LE LACRIME AGLI OKKI! INCREDIBILE CIO KE RIESCONO A TRASMETTERE QUESTE DUE GRANDI VOCI!
amazing! so pure
A rare gem! Brilliant!
This is so fabulous! Thank you so so much!
Very exciting!! Excellent!
Fantastique!!
this material is priceless! thanks for sharing
Amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Priceless
AMAZING!
Que maravilloso dúo...bravo increíbles cantantes...viva la ópera
Magnificent
FANTASTIC!
Thank you for up loading this.
Great Scotto&Pavarotti,
pianist, and...Verdi.
This is wonderful!!! so sensitive and romantic! and agreed
this sounds like you are actually sitting in the audience!!
it's truly the first time my ear has head pavarotti like this
Stupendos! Bravissimi..
mamma mia ! Bravi bravissimi! !!
Splendid!
Brillante!!!!!!!!!!!
Bravi, bravi, bravi!!!
Favolosi entrambi
Wow~!
Какая услада ушам и сердцу! Великие, несравненные, любимые певцы!
The best of the best!
Both are sensational! Thank you for this extraordinary gem!
Esto es cantar ! Bravooooooooooooooo !!
ESPLENDIDOS
This is so hard to imagine... how hard this duet is... this parlando sequences...
BRAVISSIMI!!!!
BRAAAAAAAAAAAVI!
🎶🥰🥰🥰👏👏👏🎶🎶🥰
Wow Bravoooooooooooooooo
Loove
Unvergleichbare Stimme
bravo! bravo! bravo! bravo! bravo! bravo! bravo! bravo! bravo! bravo!
Превосходно👏👏👏👏
Прекрасно
Wow
This is incredible! I have a tape of Scotto and Pavarotti singing this opera in '75 from Hamburg and they are superb. By the time they sang it again in the early 80's in Chicago (their last opera performance together due to their feud over the Gioconda telecast), Scotto was not in this kind of voice. This is a treasure to see her in such complete command, esp. the top. Can anyone tell us what year and where this is from? They never gave a joint concert in the States that I am aware of.
pkunzip501 great
Wonderful....scotto must be wearing 6 inch heels! Both in their prime here.
WOWW HE BESTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT
Bravi! Mme. Scotto's best dramatic Verdi.
How did you get this footage? Thanks so much for sharing it with us!
That was astounding.
Gosh how fascinating! She doesn`t even mention him by name in her autobiography, but I think they made their peace before he died. Perhaps their SFO Gioconda will be issued on dvd? Great singing here. Thanks for sharing.
Do we know if they made peace
mamma mia....
tiny voice? No way!!! Pavarotti sang over dense orchestras...!
@me3775 Just an fyi. Her Suor Angelica recording was from around 76/77 not the 80's. She was in much fresher voice in the 70's.
What year was this please??
yeah that's what i said ! glad to find i'm not the only one to say it :D
This must have been before her first Norma, after that the voice was never the same! They sound like the last two divinities who really understood Verdi style.
What year is this?
¿De qué año es?
CANTA!!!!!!!!!!!
I suspect this is from around 1976-77. Maybe from the time they were both singing Boheme at the Met?
which isn't to say their voices weren't AMAZING.
@thomassmile like*
I guess this was before they started to hate each other in San Francisco.
@pkunzip501Lastly,she sang only Amina in the fifities, amigo.Recorded Lucia in '59, sang it on stage in '60.She sang those bel canto roles in the sixties primarily.ThenStraniera,Vestale,Anna Bolena,Norma,etc.Cigna & Cabale sang Straniera.
She is well known as the last great verista: Adriana,Maddelena, Angelica,Butterfly,Santuzza were extraordinary.If she is not a full lyric &she is not a coloratura, what was she?I know:YOU KNOW:& far more than Serafin,deSabata,Abbado,Muti,Maazel,Karajan,Levine.
pkunzip501 .
Who's the pianist? Leone Magiera?
The pianist is Richard Woitach.
it has to be before they did Gioconda in San Francisco since they feuded after that
+operadoc This is most definitely before the '79 Gioconda. She shed some 50 lbs after the Boheme telecast which was early '77. After that she was glamorously slim as in the Otello telecast with Vickers in '78 and thereafter. I date it mid-70's but from where? If broadcast, I have never seen even an audio tape listed. This is a treasure!
I think that Scotto in one or two points sings lower than written. Her C however, together with Pavarotti's, is superb...
She sings the score exactly as it's written.
@lyside1 : Non lo è. E' assolutamente in tono. Garantisco ;)
Tempo bit fast?
@kgarmaker123 Yeah right, like the best directors of the world were wrong and you are right?... yeah right!
@leonardovittori1You are mistaken:Traviata IS NOT A COLORATURA operaThe fact that Berthe inProphete has coloratura to sing does not make it a coloratura part.Muzio sang it at the MET!FamousViolettas:Tebaldi,Stella,Tucci,Caniglia,delosAngeles.Where they coloraturas>YesTucci had a highEb.GlauceIN NOT a coloratura part:Lorengar and Tucci sang it!Gencer sang all these roles with high notes!So what?Ricciarelli sang these parts.WHERE YOU THERE to say she was not a full lyric?What COULDyou like her in?
Pavarotti bet her at the high C she couldnt be heard good on you Pav
I do not agree with you that she is pushing. You are saying that after the fact because she had vocal problems. She was not a soprano leggerio.She always sang Butterfly, Faust, Traviata...even Lisa in Pique Dam. Why do you think she was a coloratura?Because she sang Lucia and Amina?What other roles? She could sing coloratura at a certain point in her career, but it was pure technique. When the voice got darker and heavier,she dropped them.Their feud is legendary.Read her book: More Than A Diva.
...using the mike built into the camera with people moving near me. Let's see/hear you do better "back then" - under those conditions using that equiptment. A monster camera, manual zoom and holding it pretty phuquing steady.
I think that Scotto in one or two points sings lower than written.
Is i really from 1973? He was not so fat at that year
il duetto mi smbra non essere in tono ..è abbassato
Scotto should have demanded that he ditch the 'fazzoletto'.
@pkunzip501 Sigh... I hated Tebaldi Stell Tucci etc as Violetta.. If you do not have a solid coloaratura technique yofu cannot get through The first act aria... and it is SO important.. I cannot stand Violetta's who sound like they are relieved when sempre Libera is over.. E flats not withstanding. For instance Fleming, does not take E flat all the time, but all her fiorture before sounds like she is working really hard. Berthe is a coloratura part. Listen to it.
Che voci
Dio e Dia cantavano.