Hey man, I just wanted to say thanks a lot for making this cover. I used it in my application to a film school and I got accepted! I can't help but think that your perfect rendition of this song helped me enormously in getting in. So again, thanks a lot.
I've seen this video many times, repeatedly. Sometimes, I guess I like it even more than the original. Your version is a little slower. Love it!! Thanks
I'm sorry, I did use notes for reference, but most of this song is learned by ear. I unfortunately don't have the notes anymore since it's been years since I learned this song. If you search around for it I'm sure you'll be able to find some decent sheet music.
I haven't made any "conscious" modification. I was trying to play it as correctly as possible, although there are a few things I'm sure I play incorrectly, so I may rerecord it whenever I can be bothered to figure out the fully correct way.
this is a really beautiful cover! really nice job! i've had the same problem trying to figure out how to play this song. your cover is one of the best that i've seen. :)
@artslover125 Thank you very much for your comment! (: Yeah, I've listened to this song over and over, trying to figure it out. I do believe I have it mostly correct, but it's the short part at 0:17 - 0:20 that sounds different. I can't even explain it, the original just sounds different there. If I figure out a better way to play it I'll definitely upload an improved version in the future. (:
Although I would've preferred if you had asked permission to use it, I'm honored you took such a liking to it! And I'm very happy you were accepted. I'm still not convinced I have it down perfectly, but I'm glad someone does. Thank you very much for your words! (:
If it's any consolation, I feel the same. I'm glad so many people like my rendition, but I was never quite satisfied with it. There's just something I'm missing that's in the original piece, and I can't pinpoint what.
Thank you very much, that means a lot! There are still a few tiny aspects I'm not satisfied with, so I haven't thought about doing a tutorial. However, these piano videos were mostly uploaded for my own sake. I tried to get it as clear as I could with my crappy camera for the sake of being able to listen and see how I played it, in case I ever forget any of the songs I know. So perhaps it might be possible to play it by ear from this video? (:
I just started playing the piano, so learning "by ear" won't be possible for me I'm afraid. I tried to play it like you, but I'm just not there yet... well one day perhaps :)
Yeah, I've been playing on and off for several years. If you just keep at it you'll improve faster than you'd ever imagine. (: I learned this song just by googling "Jon Brion Row Sheet music", though I did of course make a few modification myself, since I didn't think the sheets accurately represented the song. Maybe I'll do a tutorial one day, I'll keep it in mind. :D
Don't worry about it, but again.. there are C# even in the left hand, I'm positive. I do know one part of the song that I have wrong, but it doesn't have anything to do with C#. xD Are you really sure you're saying the right note? And thanks for the offer, but I'm pretty sure I found all the sheet music that was available when I learned it, I spend a good while looking, but there wasn't a single one that was actually correct, which is why I played the song mostly by ear.
@artslover125 Oh, I'm not as good as you make me out to be! I do understand what you mean, and after trying it out it's a good guess. Though even if it's correct, it still feels like there's something missing.. If I can figure it out so that I'm satisfied I'll rerecord a new version of it.
I'm sorry, I used some sheets I found online when I learned this years back, but they were riddled with mistakes so I adjusted it a lot by ear and I never transcribed it.
I've also listened to the song over and over trying to figure it out but I am sure I'm a much less experienced piano player than you so it is hard for me and I am really far behind from figuring it out. I know what you are talking about between 17 and 20 seconds, I'll try to explain what I think it is. I'm pretty sure that instead of playing with the right hand f sharp to d sharp like in the regular verse, it kind of reverses to d sharp to f sharp, if that makes any sense. Try to figure it out
HOW DID YOU LEARN THIS! i really want to learn how to play this. could you send me this sheet music and notes you used? or tell me how to play it? i've been dying to play this for the longest time
+Prince MoMo Cat I'm sorry, but I have no plans of doing a tutorial for any of my piano videos. The keys are relatively clear on the screen so you could attempt to copy it by eye and ear, and if there's anything specific you're trying to figure out I could help you out, but other than that, nothing I'm afraid.
+Shilag Would you consider transcribing and putting a pdf up? The keys and what you're playing are relatively clear, but I just don't learn that way (and I'm sure I'm not the only one). If I could read it and work on it on my own without having to start and stop the video, I could get it easily. Using one of the many incorrect transcriptions out there as a skeleton shouldn't make it too much of an undertaking. And I know it'd be a chore on your part, but I would offer to pay you for it (and I'm again sure I'm not the only one).
+Taylor Townes I'm flattered, but I wouldn't feel good about doing that. I'm not a professional musician or composer, and I'm not convinced the way I'm playing it is completely correct. If you legitimately don't mind spending money, I'm very sure you can commission a professional who would do a much better job.
+Shilag Good point. Thanks for considering, anyway. If I get it from watching the video, I'll take a crack at the transcription. If it's not perfect, it'll at least be better than the one that's out there, found at the link below. Michael Jordan should stick to basketball. www.scribd.com/doc/49722643/Jon-Brion-Row
Hey man, I just wanted to say thanks a lot for making this cover.
I used it in my application to a film school and I got accepted! I can't help
but think that your perfect rendition of this song helped me enormously in
getting in. So again, thanks a lot.
I hope that adventure turned out well for you. I wonder where you are now.
@@skelebones4979 graduated and working full-time now :)
@@JamesMalekzadeh ik it's been 12 years but by any chance could you share the video w us 🥺
Dude, seriously, you play this so well. Great job! The impervisions add some well needed sublte complexity.
I love the delicacy and fascination with which he plays. :')
I've seen this video many times, repeatedly. Sometimes, I guess I like it even more than the original. Your version is a little slower. Love it!!
Thanks
I usually play things too fast, so I tell myself to slow down mid-song, and I guess it ended up slower than the original!
I'm glad you like it!
I'm sorry, I did use notes for reference, but most of this song is learned by ear. I unfortunately don't have the notes anymore since it's been years since I learned this song. If you search around for it I'm sure you'll be able to find some decent sheet music.
Stop making me cry my man! Brilliant... P.S. I love the fact you're in pj's
+BonesBrigade73 Always...
Always.
I need a tutorial :( this was amazing
This is so pretty! I’m currently trying to learn this song for my mother. This is one of her favorite songs and was in one of her favorite movies.
I haven't made any "conscious" modification. I was trying to play it as correctly as possible, although there are a few things I'm sure I play incorrectly, so I may rerecord it whenever I can be bothered to figure out the fully correct way.
I'd say your version is the best on youtube. A tutorial would be awesome :)
this is a really beautiful cover! really nice job! i've had the same problem trying to figure out how to play this song. your cover is one of the best that i've seen. :)
I've always enjoyed this poignant song from the movie. You played it well. Nice job.
It sounds very heavy, but that's how it's supposed to sound. Love this song so much- you capture it very well :-)
obligatory i still listen to this in 2019 comment
ur almost a year old buddy, we are living in a special kind of situation now. :(
Obligatory I still listen to this in 2020 comment.
@@Scizzors512 I’ll take over fellas
best rendition i've found online.... great job. I'm working on getting the 2nd part down myself
Best song from the movie, I use it as my alarm on my phone lol
@artslover125 Thank you very much for your comment! (:
Yeah, I've listened to this song over and over, trying to figure it out. I do believe I have it mostly correct, but it's the short part at 0:17 - 0:20 that sounds different. I can't even explain it, the original just sounds different there.
If I figure out a better way to play it I'll definitely upload an improved version in the future. (:
lots of love from India
your piano sounds amazing
Thank you very much. I'm glad you like it!
Thanks so much for posting! My favorite movie and my favorite song off the movie. If you ever decide to do a tutorial I’ll be watching!
Although I would've preferred if you had asked permission to use it, I'm honored you took such a liking to it! And I'm very happy you were accepted. I'm still not convinced I have it down perfectly, but I'm glad someone does. Thank you very much for your words! (:
@Akhaman2 Thanks! Glad you like it!
I cannot get this piece right for the life of me
If it's any consolation, I feel the same. I'm glad so many people like my rendition, but I was never quite satisfied with it. There's just something I'm missing that's in the original piece, and I can't pinpoint what.
This is beautifully played! Well done :-)
Este cover es tan hermoso ♡
Que talento! Ojalá yo pudiese tocar así 👏👏👏👏👏😁
wow great playing and awzome song
Beautiful
Thank you very much, that means a lot! There are still a few tiny aspects I'm not satisfied with, so I haven't thought about doing a tutorial. However, these piano videos were mostly uploaded for my own sake. I tried to get it as clear as I could with my crappy camera for the sake of being able to listen and see how I played it, in case I ever forget any of the songs I know. So perhaps it might be possible to play it by ear from this video? (:
Great job.
Beautiful!
I just started playing the piano, so learning "by ear" won't be possible for me I'm afraid. I tried to play it like you, but I'm just not there yet... well one day perhaps :)
Thank you
Thanks. Good job
@loisjuliecollins Thanks a lot! (: Though I'm not fully satisfied with it, myself. I'll probably try redoing this in the future. ;)
Perfect.
This is beautiful what modifications have you made?
Yeah, I've been playing on and off for several years. If you just keep at it you'll improve faster than you'd ever imagine. (: I learned this song just by googling "Jon Brion Row Sheet music", though I did of course make a few modification myself, since I didn't think the sheets accurately represented the song. Maybe I'll do a tutorial one day, I'll keep it in mind. :D
When's the tutorial dropping?
great job
@loisjuliecollins Thank you, yet again! You flatter me! x)
Don't worry about it, but again.. there are C# even in the left hand, I'm positive. I do know one part of the song that I have wrong, but it doesn't have anything to do with C#. xD Are you really sure you're saying the right note?
And thanks for the offer, but I'm pretty sure I found all the sheet music that was available when I learned it, I spend a good while looking, but there wasn't a single one that was actually correct, which is why I played the song mostly by ear.
okay.. +shilag hope you change your mind..your a beautiful player
Thanks!
@artslover125 Oh, I'm not as good as you make me out to be!
I do understand what you mean, and after trying it out it's a good guess. Though even if it's correct, it still feels like there's something missing.. If I can figure it out so that I'm satisfied I'll rerecord a new version of it.
well done
any chance you could share your transcription if you have it written down anywhere? Also great job!
I'm sorry, I used some sheets I found online when I learned this years back, but they were riddled with mistakes so I adjusted it a lot by ear and I never transcribed it.
What is the name of this kind of piano?, i need for kontakt... Please
I can't really tell you much. It's just a Swedish brand by someone named "J. G. Malmsjö" from Gothenburg. I bought it used.
Thank u man!
I've also listened to the song over and over trying to figure it out but I am sure I'm a much less experienced piano player than you so it is hard for me and I am really far behind from figuring it out. I know what you are talking about between 17 and 20 seconds, I'll try to explain what I think it is. I'm pretty sure that instead of playing with the right hand f sharp to d sharp like in the regular verse, it kind of reverses to d sharp to f sharp, if that makes any sense. Try to figure it out
neat
if u transcribed this into sheet music while trying to learn to play can you upload it somewhere?
There... are actually quite a few C# in the song.. Are you sure you meant the correct note? (:
Nice
Hey I was wondering if you had sheet music for this? I can't find any online.
I can’t play the piano. I’m making it my life’s mission to learn to play this. It’s hard!
HOW DID YOU LEARN THIS! i really want to learn how to play this. could you send me this sheet music and notes you used? or tell me how to play it? i've been dying to play this for the longest time
eternal sunshine of a spotless mind vibes
we really need a tutorial omg ive been trying to learn this song😔
I wanna learn how to play this so bad
i can play clair de lune but not this, idk my brain feels wired weirdly
Can you teach us how you play it your version?
+Prince MoMo Cat I'm sorry, but I have no plans of doing a tutorial for any of my piano videos. The keys are relatively clear on the screen so you could attempt to copy it by eye and ear, and if there's anything specific you're trying to figure out I could help you out, but other than that, nothing I'm afraid.
+Shilag Would you consider transcribing and putting a pdf up? The keys and what you're playing are relatively clear, but I just don't learn that way (and I'm sure I'm not the only one). If I could read it and work on it on my own without having to start and stop the video, I could get it easily. Using one of the many incorrect transcriptions out there as a skeleton shouldn't make it too much of an undertaking. And I know it'd be a chore on your part, but I would offer to pay you for it (and I'm again sure I'm not the only one).
+Taylor Townes I'm flattered, but I wouldn't feel good about doing that. I'm not a professional musician or composer, and I'm not convinced the way I'm playing it is completely correct. If you legitimately don't mind spending money, I'm very sure you can commission a professional who would do a much better job.
+Shilag Good point. Thanks for considering, anyway. If I get it from watching the video, I'll take a crack at the transcription. If it's not perfect, it'll at least be better than the one that's out there, found at the link below. Michael Jordan should stick to basketball.
www.scribd.com/doc/49722643/Jon-Brion-Row
Me like! (y)
so you are not going to do a tutorial? You cant see that clearly all the way...
+Karina Camacho Sorry, there are a multitude of reasons why I'm not looking to make any more piano videos or tutorials for the forseeable future.
omg make a tutorial