I, too, never miss an opportunity to hear Professor Snyder speak. But here I want to thank the moderator for asking the right questions, for getting at the many things that make paying attention to what Professor Snyder has to say, so worthwhile.
Professor Snyder: I am a retired professor,and I see you as extremely well prepared to talk about Germany, Poland, Russia and of course Ukraine. You are very articulate about the meaning of history and how history warns us about the future. I tremendously admire your clarity and your insights. My cousins live in Ukraine. I understand everything you are saying. And I appreciate it
Prof. Snyder has touched many people, has great courage. I ran across him on Twitter, around 2017, after the 2014 invasion, before Trump's "perfect phone call". At the time, I only had a vague idea of where Ukraine was on the map. At 76, I often feel I am history, a privilege I guard. But reading history is daunting, my knowledge is broader than most, but not deep. When they first started the MOOCs had some good history offerings, but they largely dropped liberal arts, I haven't checked in years. Certainly there is room on TH-cam? (Hint hint) ✌
@@Eurydice870 hi I am also 76. I don’t have the historical knowledge that Prof. Snyder has, but I was in Poland for the year of Solidarity and Ukraine in 2014, right after the ouster of Janocovitch. I met some army guys just returning from fighting in the east. They had little real equipment. They gave me some patches from their uniforms. These last two weeks I have been meeting with Ukrainian servicemen who are here in the USA studying English. Thanks for your interest in history and Ukraine. Peter
Tim Snyder is the best. A while back I took the time to view his Yale course-The Making of Modern Ukraine. All 23 lectures were on TH-cam for free. I try to view all of his panels and lectures on TH-cam. He is the best antidote to the Profa madness in US political culture, 45 and his enablers.
@margaretsaleeby :: Every dangerous can of toxic substances has a warning label. Snyder has already been historically detoxified by the article :: _The Lies of T.S._ Read it to get refitted into a haz-mat, razzmatazz suit. Detox your body and your mind will follow. He may be right about some things ; such as, WW1 was followed by WW2 ... everything else must be read with a microscope. When he tries to equate Hitler with following Stalin's example of all kinds of bestial behavior ... such as the German concentration camps coming from the Gulag idea. T.S. leaves the idea that if it wasn't for Stalin, H would have been a philanthropist. _⚠️ WARNING ⚠️_ T.S. has been universally denounced, detoxified, debunked, punctured.
🇺🇦 It's on the Yale TH-cam Channel. The Class is outstanding and it's free! Well worth the time to listen to ALL the lectures. A real gift to those looking for the historical truth up to the present day on Ukraine.😎✨️
Profesor Snyder has the brilliance to put into words what the world is living right now, I never miss the chance to hear what he has to say, thank you Professor!
You'll note that Timothy Snyder evokes vocal hatred from those who worship power and hold the ideas of democracy and freedom in contempt. This is unusual. I know many historians, and, as a rule, nobody pays any attention to them. What distinguishes Snyder is that he reaches out to people and can express himself in a way that a broader public can understand, while most historians can only comfortably communicate with other historians. I don't always agree with Snyder's interpretation of events, but he is a scholar whose credentials and accomplishments are undeniable. Most important, he is standing up to defend freedom, democracy, and civilization --- values that rightfully belong to ALL human beings.
He's raising money for weapons systems in a war with no clear military objective; and has therefore been shunned by almost everyone in the academic community. Much of the "Vocal" hatred is for this reason alone.
@@jasonsmith1155 Resisting imperialist conquest and genocide, and opposing totalitarian slavery seem to me pretty clear objectives. It is certainly my objective, and the objective of all decent human beings. Nothing unclear about it. There is nothing new about some academics and intellectuals sucking up to dictators and supporting their crimes --- we have a long, sad history of that sort of thing. Every genocidal monster in history has found favour among such little weasels. And we have an equally long history of Trumps and Quislings and other politicians eager to "make deals" with evil, or rich people eager to profit from the crimes of dictators. You are spouting the same nonsense that has enabled every tyrant and mass-murderer in history.
@@philpaine3068 tyrants like victoria nuland? She wasn't exactly shy about invasion herself, or overthrowing democratically elected leaders. Tell me, have the good people of Raytheon shown any profit since this war began? or is this an argument based purely on emotional catchphrases like evil tyrant? because the West has NEVER supported any of THOSE guys. btw, ever heard of Haiti? or South America, or the middle east? LMAO
@@jasonsmith1155 The objectives are clear and he is not shunned. He argues and articulates well. The objectives are to liberate Ukraine from the occupier, and contain and defeat Russia. Simple.
@@DaniRaj666 Very Simple, until we start to ask what containing and liberating look like, and then ask whatever happened to the democratically elected leader before the coupe, why was Nuland handing out cookies and deciding what positions people would hold in the new government. Perhaps they should be liberated from those CIA bases that have been there for ten years and once again become a neutral country? Would that not be very simple? and how do you propose to contain a country that's that much larger with strong industrial base? And with Ukraine having zero air-cover. I'm guessing more tax money from Americans who can barely afford to pay rent, which will then be laundered to the corporations? BTW, how's the Ukraine frontlines holding up? Any American journalists been killed by the Ukraine government? Why are their more than 500 streets named after Bandera? Do you think all Ukrainians' are willing to fight to the death for the new Ukraine government? If winning is possible, why is it predicted to fall by october? and finally, how much money will it take to contain a superpower with stronger industrial capacity than the unted states? another 61 billion or zillion or fucktwillion? one or two or 50 fighter jets? Maybe a new type of drone just coming out this week? The answer you proposed was not simple at all -it was merely simplistic , which, along with emotional simplifications, seems to be the fallback position of every TH-cam NATO war-pig these days.
What i really like about this man is the complete absence of FALSE modesty. Signalling a stance in life that is something like this: "Before you speak you have to do the work, but after you've done the work you need not be afraid to speak". I like that a lot. Under the surface there is a strong believe that knowledge is true power and misinformation is false power. And true power can and must be wielded.
I never miss a Timothy Snyder clip! I’ve learned so much from all of his talks. He is one of the most important voices in this moment. It is a pleasure and sadly a real rarity to listen to someone who has such deep knowledge and grasp of history. I admire his ongoing support and advocacy for the people of Ukraine, as well. It is obvious the genuine feeling he has for the country and its people and they for him. Thank you for this talk and thank you to Dr. Snyder!
@@cliffgaitherHow that? He is a serious historian PLUS he draws the logical conclusions, assumes responsibility & stands up for well founded convictions. Unlike academics that refuse to leave their cloistered & sterile communities & actually talk to mortals.
People who support the authoritarian _never_ imagine that the authoritarian could eventually turn on THEM. He hates the same people I do, so he has my vote! Time and time again, I've heard from insiders how Donald Trump absolutely DETESTS the sort of rank-and-file people who support him, but they think he's on their side.
@karldubhe8619 this type of political propaganda is what brings about catastrophe. This administration has dragged us into a state of perpetual crisis. Every American sees it.
24.55 "People think about dictatorship... 'a strongman's gonna come, and he's gonna do what I want him to do'. And that's not true. He's gonna come and do the stuff that HE wants to do."
Thanks for this excellent interview with Tim Snyder. He is true, Americans could learn from the painfull history of Europe, to prevent the same mistakes. Greetings from Western-Europe ❤️🇪🇺🇺🇸❤️.
Thank you a million times over, for educating Americans that there was more, many more, than one Holocaust; and suffered by more than just "one" ethnic group.
Every time I listen to Professor Snyder give an interview or lecture, there's always some brilliant unexpected insights he brings that are really "aha!" moments, where the puzzle pieces come together. I have many of his books. One of my favorite articles he wrote recently was "The Strongman Fantasy" ...and I sent this to all my Trump -loving relatives, in the hopes that they really consider the consequences of their vote this November, even though the article isn't about, specifically, Trump. Thank you for hosting this interview !
Thank you. I won't read "Bloodlands" it will be too traumatic, but I'm glad to hear that "Black Earth" is Snyder's book review of "Bloodlands," has a bunch of analysis and is more argumentative. I can read that one!
Doctor, I've heard you talk about the US being at the end of the value end of the Ukraine support system. We don't donate as much as the other NATO members. Where do we rank in importance in keeping Ukraine going?
Thanks Tim for history at its best. Mao adopted Stalin's policy of trading grain for factories and killing "class enemies" resulting in 50 to 100 million "excess" deaths, according to "Mao: The Unknown Story" by Chang & Halliday. The low number is official CCP estimate.
Fascinating and new overview perspective on the subtle and complex currents and factors that unify Stalinism, Fascism or any us/them idealogy into eras and decades. As my beloved history teacher used to intone orotundly to each new grade; Man's natural state, is one of conflict. That is the beginning and the end of all of history. And my gran taught me.... The Russians are rushin' to finish the Finnish, and the Finnish are rushin' to finish the Russians. Scary world, but it always seems to be the '20s & 30s of each century that produce the cataclysmic upheavals in social order.
Tim, I'd love to get your thoughts on Britain's historical competition for resources, i.e., like starting the Great War in order to seize the Ottoman Empire's oil fields, basically, the entire middle east. Thanks to the rich Brits and their actions in WWI and II, the world is the way it is today.
I’m amazed that eugenics and its history wasn’t mentioned here! Eugenics was born in Long Island US and ended In Germany! Refer to a book called “The war against the weak”. Eugenics a contributing factor to the examination of Jews among other people! As for Russia elimination of elites in Poland the main factor was to remove cultural and identity of Polish people! Part of the reason why I’m in Australia while most of my family was killed in Siberia! most of our estates was taken never to be returned! Thanks to the western powers for selling us to the Russians communists!!!
I really appreciate Snyder‘s closing segment, his response to the question about Tyranny. He said he publicly predicted that Trump would pull some sort of Reichstag-is-burning trick a la Hitler if he list the 2020 election, and the prediction came true. To echo Snyder, there’s vast parallels between the orocesses that led to Germany’s acceptance of Nazism over time and Trump’s schtick. Trump’s rallies seem to he Nuremburg inspired experiences, where the pre-speech spectacles and entertainment are effective at dulling the individuals in the audience’s intellect, and simultaneously at building a feeling of common cause and purpose. But the messaging is the same - you’re the key to reversing everything that’s been making you feel bad. But together real “patriots” like us can fight everyone else and make a better world. But the concept of patriotism is delusional. It’s that the only patriots are the believers in the idea that everyone else is bad or flawed. The concept doesn’t focus on First Amendment freedoms of multiple points of view or beliefs, but in the supremacy of Trump supporter’s views & beliefs. The pre-speech rallies focus on white Christian nationalism, exclusion of others, gun mania and paranoia about gun regulation, and that anything one might hear outside the rally is a threat and fake. And that all government is Marxist and immoral, and that diversity means replacement. Trump’s strategists have adopted the lessons of historic 20th C. tyrants well.
I like it how you put name cards in every time the frame switches. Unlike newschannels that verbalize names somewhere near the beginning and that's it.
Thank you for your support for Ukraine, Mr. Synder. It's in the best interest of all free, independent and democratic countries to support Ukraine. A Ukrainian victory will strengthen all present-day free countries and may even lead to more joining our ranks.
I don't understand how we can defend little countries unless we make armed invasions anathema. Big nations have the power to make something like the UN be the arbiter of border disputes and the policeman against armed invasions. I see no good result from armed invasions, neither Russia's nor ours of Afghanistan, nor ours of Iraq or Grenada or the Panama Canal Zone, nor Russia's of Ukraine, etc. Shouldn't there be a push to prohibit armed invasions unless requested by (something like) the UN?
A.H . DID SAY AFTER 1936 APPEASEMENT GAVE HIM CARTE BLANCHE SIGNIFYING THE END OF INTERNATIONAL MORALITY. TODAY WE CALL IT "INTERNATIOAL RULE OF LAW" I LIKE THE OLD PHRASE INTERNATIONAL MORALITY.🔱⭐
Snyder brings up freight trains of excellent deeply-researched points on authoritarianism. His views on Ukraine and other complex int’l and historic issues are spot on as far as I can presently(or probably ever) tell. However, I missed his mentioning that NO centralized “rules and regs” can ALSO lead to a sort’ah “dictatorship”. And, that our BILLIONAIRES are shaping public policy everywhere through the power of their “nickels” RIGHT NOW; which is also many miles from democratic. Maybe Snyder has mentioned these things in his books and other elaborations? PS) Democracy requires en masse educated informedness of responsible voting citizens with good options to choose from. “Whoops/Sorry”.
I'm a retired bioscientist, not a historian, a US citizen who has lived in Eastern Europe for more than 30 years. I'm familiar with all of Synder's talking points, and I'm in communication with people from all nthe countries he mentions. Did I miss it, or did he forget to mention or not know about the Victoria Nuland-orchestrated coup in Ukraine in 2014? Synder's analysis sounded a bit too "black and white" to me based on my personal knowledge of players on various sides.
doesnt the politics of bread goes back centuries in the region. I have a papaer to read about jewish middlemen and grain prices in the 17th c Commonwealth . . .
It's really bizarre that such well known and obvious truths need to be spelled out for these people who are not getting it anyway. And then, it's also so boring, trivial and repetitive, perhaps cos I lived long enough to experience these truths so many times.i lived thru experience of my parents and greate parents, thru so many wars and injustices. It all blends in the color of disgust and sadness. And all these sufferings are useless for more is coming, I can clearly see the signs
Great stuff, thanks Timothy. Are dangerous people like Putin and Trump "loners" or do they have a team or some few individuals close to work out their hypotesis and/or synthesis?. All the best.
The advantages of democracy over autocracy are taken for an axiom, which is wrong. Autocracy has many advantages , a more efficient decision making process being but one of them.
It’s fascinating how Snyder takes such a complex and nuanced moral approach to history, but then completely throws that out the window when pushing modern political dogmas. How disappointing. I hope that’s not a reflection of his efforts in Bloodlands
challenge to Timothy: this same view on history, in which the 'hallowedness' of the holocaust must be relativised so that we can learn for our present times: this is also relevant to Israel/Palestine, but possibly more controversial.
Good god. Snyder has lost the plot. At 8:25 he speaks about global warming, seemingly having never, ever looked at a graph of deaths due to climate-related disasters (down 96% over the last century), or graphs of food productivity (which increases with increased Co2). It's profoundly depressing. He should stay in his lane rather than parroting drivel.
I dont think Tim Snyder shares the understanding of Nato expansion through eastern Europe as driven by the US arms industry. That was the perspective of the NYTimes at the time of the first wave of admissions to NATO in the Clinton 90s. It's still quite a compelling analysis of the causes of Russia's invasion
NATO doesn't 'expand', it admits countries that want to join. This 'everything is caused by the US' mentality denies countries who feel menaced by Russia any agency.
He, having studied and written about Stalin and Hitler, has shown understanding of both. When the left gives its strongman a pass for trying to send stormtroopers to the Capitol or purging his opponents, I imagine Snyder would be quick to raise the alarm. But this is today, and it's the right that is giving its charlatan that cover. Today, we can criticize the leftish leader. Tomorrow, we won't be able to, if we keep thinking, "There are good people on both sides."
@@erincaitlin1655 Totalitarian censorship, cancel culture, greenwashing, antisemitism, DEI racism, white supremacist witch hunt, defund the police, antifa, open border, BLM riots, woke mind virus...
‘The war began because Stalin was willing to agree with hitler etc etc’ - this is standard western spin. In reality the Soviets were driven to a non-aggression pact with Hitler in 1939 because the west had signed one with Hitler in 1938.
Driven to a non-aggression pact involving aggression against the rest of Eastern Europe? Wow, poor Soviets, driven by Hitler like genocidal lambs to the slaughter of others. No wonder Putin exists.
I'm pretty sure at the same time you're passionately craving a rerun of that infamous treaty of Munich in the current situation. That's a whole lot of contradiction.
There was no non-aggression pact in the Munich Agreement. Hitler's goal was always to expand eastwards, and he attempted to align with Poland and offer them Soviet territory, but they backed out due to the deal making them dependent on Germany. Hitler then pivoted to the USSR and invaded Poland. The USSR meanwhile happily signed the pact because it meant an escalation of trade to export metals and oil, in addition to territorial gains in Poland in the aftermath of the humiliating events of the treaty with Imperial Germany in 1918 and the Polish-Soviet war of 1920. Stalin chose this willingly out of imperial aspirations.
@@JakCeiAnd the USA happily remained friends & partners with nazi-Germany until Dec 11th, 1941. When the Holocaust was already 6 months underway, and Jews had been murdered since Sept 1939, locked up in ghettos since 1940, and were massmurdered since June 1941. Still friends with the USA, huh? Why don't you talk about the USA for a minute, huh?
People also ask What nation did Germany sign a non-aggression treaty with? German-Soviet Pact | Holocaust Encyclopedia the Soviet Union It is also known as the Nazi-Soviet Pact or the Hitler-Stalin Pact. The arrangement included a 10-year non-aggression pact between Germany and the Soviet Union.
I, too, never miss an opportunity to hear Professor Snyder speak. But here I want to thank the moderator for asking the right questions, for getting at the many things that make paying attention to what Professor Snyder has to say, so worthwhile.
How are things in Banderistan?
Professor Snyder: I am a retired professor,and I see you as extremely well prepared to talk about Germany, Poland, Russia and of course Ukraine. You are very articulate about the meaning of history and how history warns us about the future. I tremendously admire your clarity and your insights. My cousins live in Ukraine. I understand everything you are saying. And I appreciate it
Prof. Snyder has touched many people, has great courage. I ran across him on Twitter, around 2017, after the 2014 invasion, before Trump's "perfect phone call". At the time, I only had a vague idea of where Ukraine was on the map. At 76, I often feel I am history, a privilege I guard. But reading history is daunting, my knowledge is broader than most, but not deep. When they first started the MOOCs had some good history offerings, but they largely dropped liberal arts, I haven't checked in years. Certainly there is room on TH-cam? (Hint hint) ✌
@@Eurydice870 hi I am also 76. I don’t have the historical knowledge that Prof. Snyder has, but I was in Poland for the year of Solidarity and Ukraine in 2014, right after the ouster of Janocovitch. I met some army guys just returning from fighting in the east. They had little real equipment. They gave me some patches from their uniforms. These last two weeks I have been meeting with Ukrainian servicemen who are here in the USA studying English. Thanks for your interest in history and Ukraine. Peter
Tim Snyder is the best. A while back I took the time to view his Yale course-The Making of Modern Ukraine. All 23 lectures were on TH-cam for free.
I try to view all of his panels and lectures on TH-cam. He is the best antidote to the Profa madness in US political culture, 45 and his enablers.
Brilliant. Thank-you for your immense effort Professor Snyder.
IMO Dr. Snyder is a national treasure because of his unrelenting effort to keep us informed about historical issues at play in today’s world!
@margaretsaleeby ::
Every dangerous can of toxic substances has a warning label. Snyder has already been historically detoxified by the article :: _The Lies of T.S._ Read it to get refitted into a haz-mat, razzmatazz suit. Detox your body and your mind will follow. He may be right about some things ; such as, WW1 was followed by WW2 ... everything else must be read with a microscope. When he tries to equate Hitler with following Stalin's example of all kinds of bestial behavior ... such as the German concentration camps coming from the Gulag idea.
T.S. leaves the idea that if it wasn't for Stalin, H would have been a philanthropist.
_⚠️ WARNING ⚠️_
T.S. has been universally denounced, detoxified, debunked, punctured.
Read the reply outside of your thread.
I see Snyder, I click 🥳
Same here
same
Count me in on that too! 👏
I think Dr. Snyder's series "The Making of Modern Ukraine" is absolutely outstanding.
I agree but it is a class where you were expected to have done certain reading. It wasn’t designed for the TH-cam audience. I recommend it also.
💙💛
@@nurseSean Do you have a copy of the syllabus and/or the reading list?
🇺🇦 It's on the Yale TH-cam Channel. The Class is outstanding and it's free!
Well worth the time to listen to ALL the lectures.
A real gift to those looking for the historical truth up to the present day on Ukraine.😎✨️
Profesor Snyder has the brilliance to put into words what the world is living right now, I never miss the chance to hear what he has to say, thank you Professor!
I admire Professor Snyder's efforts to keep educating the West about the history of Eatern Europe, particularly Ukraine.
You'll note that Timothy Snyder evokes vocal hatred from those who worship power and hold the ideas of democracy and freedom in contempt. This is unusual. I know many historians, and, as a rule, nobody pays any attention to them. What distinguishes Snyder is that he reaches out to people and can express himself in a way that a broader public can understand, while most historians can only comfortably communicate with other historians. I don't always agree with Snyder's interpretation of events, but he is a scholar whose credentials and accomplishments are undeniable. Most important, he is standing up to defend freedom, democracy, and civilization --- values that rightfully belong to ALL human beings.
He's raising money for weapons systems in a war with no clear military objective; and has therefore been shunned by almost everyone in the academic community. Much of the "Vocal" hatred is for this reason alone.
@@jasonsmith1155 Resisting imperialist conquest and genocide, and opposing totalitarian slavery seem to me pretty clear objectives. It is certainly my objective, and the objective of all decent human beings. Nothing unclear about it. There is nothing new about some academics and intellectuals sucking up to dictators and supporting their crimes --- we have a long, sad history of that sort of thing. Every genocidal monster in history has found favour among such little weasels. And we have an equally long history of Trumps and Quislings and other politicians eager to "make deals" with evil, or rich people eager to profit from the crimes of dictators. You are spouting the same nonsense that has enabled every tyrant and mass-murderer in history.
@@philpaine3068 tyrants like victoria nuland? She wasn't exactly shy about invasion herself, or overthrowing democratically elected leaders. Tell me, have the good people of Raytheon shown any profit since this war began? or is this an argument based purely on emotional catchphrases like evil tyrant? because the West has NEVER supported any of THOSE guys. btw, ever heard of Haiti? or South America, or the middle east? LMAO
@@jasonsmith1155 The objectives are clear and he is not shunned. He argues and articulates well. The objectives are to liberate Ukraine from the occupier, and contain and defeat Russia. Simple.
@@DaniRaj666 Very Simple, until we start to ask what containing and liberating look like, and then ask whatever happened to the democratically elected leader before the coupe, why was Nuland handing out cookies and deciding what positions people would hold in the new government. Perhaps they should be liberated from those CIA bases that have been there for ten years and once again become a neutral country? Would that not be very simple? and how do you propose to contain a country that's that much larger with strong industrial base? And with Ukraine having zero air-cover. I'm guessing more tax money from Americans who can barely afford to pay rent, which will then be laundered to the corporations? BTW, how's the Ukraine frontlines holding up? Any American journalists been killed by the Ukraine government? Why are their more than 500 streets named after Bandera? Do you think all Ukrainians' are willing to fight to the death for the new Ukraine government? If winning is possible, why is it predicted to fall by october? and finally, how much money will it take to contain a superpower with stronger industrial capacity than the unted states? another 61 billion or zillion or fucktwillion? one or two or 50 fighter jets? Maybe a new type of drone just coming out this week? The answer you proposed was not simple at all -it was merely simplistic , which, along with emotional simplifications, seems to be the fallback position of every TH-cam NATO war-pig these days.
What i really like about this man is the complete absence of FALSE modesty. Signalling a stance in life that is something like this: "Before you speak you have to do the work, but after you've done the work you need not be afraid to speak". I like that a lot. Under the surface there is a strong believe that knowledge is true power and misinformation is false power. And true power can and must be wielded.
Thanks to all of you for this conversation.Essential for this time.
I never miss a Timothy Snyder clip! I’ve learned so much from all of his talks. He is one of the most important voices in this moment. It is a pleasure and sadly a real rarity to listen to someone who has such deep knowledge and grasp of history. I admire his ongoing support and advocacy for the people of Ukraine, as well. It is obvious the genuine feeling he has for the country and its people and they for him. Thank you for this talk and thank you to Dr. Snyder!
I am totally in love with this man, he is a hero of science
@JuliaFF :: pseudo-scientist.
@@cliffgaitherHow that? He is a serious historian PLUS he draws the logical conclusions, assumes responsibility & stands up for well founded convictions.
Unlike academics that refuse to leave their cloistered & sterile communities & actually talk to mortals.
@@cliffgaither YOUR Z WORD IS NOTHING AGAINST HISTORICAL EVIDENCE. YOU LOST
Thank you professor Snyder, glory to the Heroes
People who support the authoritarian _never_ imagine that the authoritarian could eventually turn on THEM. He hates the same people I do, so he has my vote! Time and time again, I've heard from insiders how Donald Trump absolutely DETESTS the sort of rank-and-file people who support him, but they think he's on their side.
Ah yes the world is a much freer and stabler place under Joe. 😂
@karldubhe8619 this type of political propaganda is what brings about catastrophe. This administration has dragged us into a state of perpetual crisis. Every American sees it.
24.55 "People think about dictatorship... 'a strongman's gonna come, and he's gonna do what I want him to do'. And that's not true. He's gonna come and do the stuff that HE wants to do."
Gotta give kudos to the hosts. Great deep dive into Tim's work. Well done!
Thank you for this brilliant, deep, sobering discussion.
Snyder.... always a pleasure to listen to.
Thanks for this excellent interview with Tim Snyder. He is true, Americans could learn from the painfull history of Europe, to prevent the same mistakes. Greetings from Western-Europe ❤️🇪🇺🇺🇸❤️.
Tim Snyder is one of the most important thinkers of our time. Period.
Thank you a million times over, for educating Americans that there was more, many more, than one Holocaust; and suffered by more than just "one" ethnic group.
I eish more people would listen to Timothy Snyder.
the more I hear prof Snyder, the more ignorant i realise I am. and yet I keep coming back for more!
Thank you, Prf Snyder, for your choice to be on the right side of history.
Great first question. Thank you.
Thank you for a brilliant interview with a great historian and analyst of today's challenges.
THANK YOU 💐💐💐
WWII was started by Stalin and Hitler; never forget that the Russians bear as much responsibility for WWII as the Nazis do.
Of course. The Spanish have known this from the beginning. Many fascists from the Falange fought for Hitler/Stalin.
Plenty of Putin trolls here with their lies.
What a clever man.
Excellent interview, great points highlighted.!
No matter how many times I listen to TS, I always walk away with something new.
Thank you ❤ 🇱🇹
I love listening to Timothy Snyder - I read all his books - he is a national treasure
Thanks, Timothy Snyder, for trying really hard to open our eyes to our present state in the world
Дякую 💪🇺🇦🇺🇸❤️
Brilliant and a thankyou for the show and highlighting the author u made me go look up Mr Snyder.
Every time I listen to Professor Snyder give an interview or lecture, there's always some brilliant unexpected insights he brings that are really "aha!" moments, where the puzzle pieces come together. I have many of his books. One of my favorite articles he wrote recently was "The Strongman Fantasy" ...and I sent this to all my Trump -loving relatives, in the hopes that they really consider the consequences of their vote this November, even though the article isn't about, specifically, Trump. Thank you for hosting this interview !
Mr. Snyder is always clear and calm even when describing politically contentious issues.
Always a pleasure.
Разом ми переможемо
Thank you. I won't read "Bloodlands" it will be too traumatic, but I'm glad to hear that "Black Earth" is Snyder's book review of "Bloodlands," has a bunch of analysis and is more argumentative. I can read that one!
Doctor, I've heard you talk about the US being at the end of the value end of the Ukraine support system. We don't donate as much as the other NATO members. Where do we rank in importance in keeping Ukraine going?
Thank you for oportunity to understand history
✨Merci!✨
Please have John Mearsheimer on to talk about the Ukraine Russian conflict
Thank you very much Mr President Duda for your support of Ukraine during your last stay in the USA 🇵🇱❤🇺🇦
Thanks Tim for history at its best. Mao adopted Stalin's policy of trading grain for factories and killing "class enemies" resulting in 50 to 100 million "excess" deaths, according to "Mao: The Unknown Story" by Chang & Halliday. The low number is official CCP estimate.
Fascinating and new overview perspective on the subtle and complex currents and factors that unify Stalinism, Fascism or any us/them idealogy into eras and decades.
As my beloved history teacher used to intone orotundly to each new grade;
Man's natural state, is one of conflict. That is the beginning and the end of all of history.
And my gran taught me.... The Russians are rushin' to finish the Finnish, and the Finnish are rushin' to finish the Russians.
Scary world, but it always seems to be the '20s & 30s of each century that produce the cataclysmic upheavals in social order.
Who is going to bring Prof. Snyder's words to the Trump base? These are absolutely horrifying times.
Outstanding
Tim, I'd love to get your thoughts on Britain's historical competition for resources, i.e., like starting the Great War in order to seize the Ottoman Empire's oil fields, basically, the entire middle east. Thanks to the rich Brits and their actions in WWI and II, the world is the way it is today.
Whoever chose this particular frame the thumbnail… Why?
If you think a Trump dictatorship is no big deal, think again
very interesting...
Painfully short interview.
I’m amazed that eugenics and its history wasn’t mentioned here! Eugenics was born in Long Island US and ended In Germany! Refer to a book called “The war against the weak”. Eugenics a contributing factor to the examination of Jews among other people! As for Russia elimination of elites in Poland the main factor was to remove cultural and identity of Polish people! Part of the reason why I’m in Australia while most of my family was killed in Siberia! most of our estates was taken never to be returned! Thanks to the western powers for selling us to the Russians communists!!!
I really appreciate Snyder‘s closing segment, his response to the question about Tyranny. He said he publicly predicted that Trump would pull some sort of Reichstag-is-burning trick a la Hitler if he list the 2020 election, and the prediction came true. To echo Snyder, there’s vast parallels between the orocesses that led to Germany’s acceptance of Nazism over time and Trump’s schtick.
Trump’s rallies seem to he Nuremburg inspired experiences, where the pre-speech spectacles and entertainment are effective at dulling the individuals in the audience’s intellect, and simultaneously at building a feeling of common cause and purpose. But the messaging is the same - you’re the key to reversing everything that’s been making you feel bad. But together real “patriots” like us can fight everyone else and make a better world. But the concept of patriotism is delusional. It’s that the only patriots are the believers in the idea that everyone else is bad or flawed. The concept doesn’t focus on First Amendment freedoms of multiple points of view or beliefs, but in the supremacy of Trump supporter’s views & beliefs. The pre-speech rallies focus on white Christian nationalism, exclusion of others, gun mania and paranoia about gun regulation, and that anything one might hear outside the rally is a threat and fake. And that all government is Marxist and immoral, and that diversity means replacement.
Trump’s strategists have adopted the lessons of historic 20th C. tyrants well.
I like it how you put name cards in every time the frame switches. Unlike newschannels that verbalize names somewhere near the beginning and that's it.
Thank you for your support for Ukraine, Mr. Synder. It's in the best interest of all free, independent and democratic countries to support Ukraine. A Ukrainian victory will strengthen all present-day free countries and may even lead to more joining our ranks.
Good
Spot on. If we place the holocaust outside of history, then we risk repeating it.
I don't understand how we can defend little countries unless we make armed invasions anathema. Big nations have the power to make something like the UN be the arbiter of border disputes and the policeman against armed invasions. I see no good result from armed invasions, neither Russia's nor ours of Afghanistan, nor ours of Iraq or Grenada or the Panama Canal Zone, nor Russia's of Ukraine, etc. Shouldn't there be a push to prohibit armed invasions unless requested by (something like) the UN?
A.H . DID SAY AFTER 1936 APPEASEMENT GAVE HIM CARTE BLANCHE SIGNIFYING THE END OF INTERNATIONAL
MORALITY.
TODAY WE CALL IT "INTERNATIOAL RULE OF LAW" I LIKE THE OLD PHRASE INTERNATIONAL MORALITY.🔱⭐
23:15 It's unclear what kind of "Reichstag Fire event, about which he was 100% correct" Snyder was referring to...
Snyder brings up freight trains of excellent deeply-researched points on authoritarianism. His views on Ukraine and other complex int’l and historic issues are spot on as far as I can presently(or probably ever) tell. However, I missed his mentioning that NO centralized “rules and regs” can ALSO lead to a sort’ah “dictatorship”. And, that our BILLIONAIRES are shaping public policy everywhere through the power of their “nickels” RIGHT NOW; which is also many miles from democratic. Maybe Snyder has mentioned these things in his books and other elaborations?
PS) Democracy requires en masse educated informedness of responsible voting citizens with good options to choose from. “Whoops/Sorry”.
In 2022, 44.2 million people in the United States lived in households that were food insecure
Would like to see a debate between Mearsheimer and Snyder
Is there not some corrective surgery for this host's nasal passages ?
3:56, Prof.Snyder talks about the mass killing in Poland, etc.
World’s busiest historian.
I'm a retired bioscientist, not a historian, a US citizen who has lived in Eastern Europe for more than 30 years. I'm familiar with all of Synder's talking points, and I'm in communication with people from all nthe countries he mentions. Did I miss it, or did he forget to mention or not know about the Victoria Nuland-orchestrated coup in Ukraine in 2014? Synder's analysis sounded a bit too "black and white" to me based on my personal knowledge of players on various sides.
Ruzzki trollzki. Not US citizen.
Looks a lil like Kevin Mc Carthy.
Sorry Dr 🤭
Time for eye glasses ....
Why do so many War-Pigs resemble turtles from the looney tunes?
I would like to hear his disquisition on Palestine
Fantastic content, but man your voice is nasal! Any chance on relief?
doesnt the politics of bread goes back centuries in the region. I have a papaer to read about jewish middlemen and grain prices in the 17th c Commonwealth . . .
Wilson Joseph Jackson Michael Hall Thomas
What about killings in Gaza?
The C.I.A thanks Mr. Snyder for his service.
Jim needs to empty his nostrils so he can speak clearly. Wonderful guest in TS
@dw please interview
It's really bizarre that such well known and obvious truths need to be spelled out for these people who are not getting it anyway. And then, it's also so boring, trivial and repetitive, perhaps cos I lived long enough to experience these truths so many times.i lived thru experience of my parents and greate parents, thru so many wars and injustices. It all blends in the color of disgust and sadness. And all these sufferings are useless for more is coming, I can clearly see the signs
Grover Furr has unmasked this guy as a scammer.
An argument for interventionist tactics. However, it was Russia that advanced the Nord Steam 2 pipeline. 🦒
Great stuff, thanks Timothy. Are dangerous people like Putin and Trump "loners" or do they have a team or some few individuals close to work out their hypotesis and/or synthesis?. All the best.
Spyder's attempts at keeping his academic reputation afloat are remarkable considering ample evidence of his total bias and inadequacy.
he's a dangerous ideolge
Nope. Putin's a garden variety fascist.
The advantages of democracy over autocracy are taken for an axiom, which is wrong. Autocracy has many advantages , a more efficient decision making process being but one of them.
It’s fascinating how Snyder takes such a complex and nuanced moral approach to history, but then completely throws that out the window when pushing modern political dogmas. How disappointing. I hope that’s not a reflection of his efforts in Bloodlands
One of the most influencial intelectuell gangsters of this century.
The "Warning"? It is Gaza today.
challenge to Timothy: this same view on history, in which the 'hallowedness' of the holocaust must be relativised so that we can learn for our present times: this is also relevant to Israel/Palestine, but possibly more controversial.
Good god. Snyder has lost the plot. At 8:25 he speaks about global warming, seemingly having never, ever looked at a graph of deaths due to climate-related disasters (down 96% over the last century), or graphs of food productivity (which increases with increased Co2). It's profoundly depressing. He should stay in his lane rather than parroting drivel.
I dont think Tim Snyder shares the understanding of Nato expansion through eastern Europe as driven by the US arms industry. That was the perspective of the NYTimes at the time of the first wave of admissions to NATO in the Clinton 90s. It's still quite a compelling analysis of the causes of Russia's invasion
NATO doesn't 'expand', it admits countries that want to join. This 'everything is caused by the US' mentality denies countries who feel menaced by Russia any agency.
Nope. NATO's expansion is driven by newly independent nations' desire NOT to be under the Russian jackboot.
It seems to me that Timothy is sensitive to only extremism from the right and not from the left.
He, having studied and written about Stalin and Hitler, has shown understanding of both. When the left gives its strongman a pass for trying to send stormtroopers to the Capitol or purging his opponents, I imagine Snyder would be quick to raise the alarm. But this is today, and it's the right that is giving its charlatan that cover. Today, we can criticize the leftish leader. Tomorrow, we won't be able to, if we keep thinking, "There are good people on both sides."
It’s not 1969.
@@foxfreeman1672 No, it's worse than 1969
For example, today ??????
@@erincaitlin1655 Totalitarian censorship, cancel culture, greenwashing, antisemitism, DEI racism, white supremacist witch hunt, defund the police, antifa, open border, BLM riots, woke mind virus...
More lies from Timothy Snyder.
Ruzzki trollzki.
@@mbasirYep! They are so stupid and obvious! 😅💥
‘The war began because Stalin was willing to agree with hitler etc etc’ - this is standard western spin. In reality the Soviets were driven to a non-aggression pact with Hitler in 1939 because the west had signed one with Hitler in 1938.
Driven to a non-aggression pact involving aggression against the rest of Eastern Europe?
Wow, poor Soviets, driven by Hitler like genocidal lambs to the slaughter of others. No wonder Putin exists.
I'm pretty sure at the same time you're passionately craving a rerun of that infamous treaty of Munich in the current situation. That's a whole lot of contradiction.
There was no non-aggression pact in the Munich Agreement. Hitler's goal was always to expand eastwards, and he attempted to align with Poland and offer them Soviet territory, but they backed out due to the deal making them dependent on Germany. Hitler then pivoted to the USSR and invaded Poland.
The USSR meanwhile happily signed the pact because it meant an escalation of trade to export metals and oil, in addition to territorial gains in Poland in the aftermath of the humiliating events of the treaty with Imperial Germany in 1918 and the Polish-Soviet war of 1920. Stalin chose this willingly out of imperial aspirations.
@@JakCeiAnd the USA happily remained friends & partners with nazi-Germany until Dec 11th, 1941. When the Holocaust was already 6 months underway, and Jews had been murdered since Sept 1939, locked up in ghettos since 1940, and were massmurdered since June 1941. Still friends with the USA, huh?
Why don't you talk about the USA for a minute, huh?
People also ask
What nation did Germany sign a non-aggression treaty with?
German-Soviet Pact | Holocaust Encyclopedia
the Soviet Union
It is also known as the Nazi-Soviet Pact or the Hitler-Stalin Pact. The arrangement included a 10-year non-aggression pact between Germany and the Soviet Union.
This Snyder muppet is entirely overrated
How derogatory!😝
lol the russian trolls had to show up to childishly try to smear Snyder... Go back to your cope hole mate.
@@Timmerdetimmerdetim indeed... I kept it civil
Whose book did you read instead?
Insults are not arguments.