Ramzi and Halil Death Scene | Rumbling on Marley
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ก.ย. 2024
- Shingeki no Kyojin newest episode english subtitle
Eren cries and say sorry to Ramzi, Eren kills all Marley people with rumbling. Ramzi crushed by titans.
#attackontitan #erenyeager #leviackerman - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
How GOKU, NARUTO, LUFFY Get Destroyed in Epic Battle: th-cam.com/video/FRhohKY7lFY/w-d-xo.html
The way they animated the teeth being crushed and the blood splattering on the camera is just too smooth
Dude i keep trying to share clips with normies who know nothing of why anime is so popular and have misconceptions.
Its absolute brilliance and avant garde sophistication of storytelling, production and voice acting.
Its literal cultural gold. And will get its full praise way late as usual lol
Jeez...
Bro?...
That was disturbing. Such a wholesome backstory to those kids, followed by a death with which they didn’t hold back. Makers of AOT truly got the cojones to portray this scene as it is.
Tener cojones se traduce como "having guts" xd
Yo leyendo súper serio el comentario y cuando vi la palabra cojones me descojone de la risa 😂😂😂
Manga did it better. It shows halil’s head actually split open dead instead of a rock over it
@@crackysnacky7235 Manga version was much more brutal, actually it was one of the most disturbing scenes of the entire manga, at least for me
@@speed8948Just a draw
Anime with superb voice acting music & vfx is way worse
Kudos to the animation team for working so hard to make this huge masterpiece come to life
When will the anime come out in English
@@abdullahshaibu5274last week
@@abdullahshaibu5274idk
And the small things like having blood splatter on the “camera”. So gross to draw oof
@@abdullahshaibu5274 it's out!
Is this how ants view us when we destroy their nest lol
Some ants that got caught in a marching band 💀
Imagine how the ants view the colossal titans then
@@christianjoyner1999 that sounds horrifying to think about
Eren die
I just thought of something and this is a question if anyone can help me answer this
In the last episode before part 3 of attack on Titan when
eren and his friends went to the other side of the sea on Marley when eren was crying whilst ramzi was waving at him and later on when mikasah and him were talking and the old man offered a drink did he do that because ramzi told his grandpa that eren saved him from the three people that beat him up is that why eren and his friends were invited to a party
This whole series is not afraid of showing things this gruesome
Despite the fact that some stuff was censored this was still somehow more gruesome than then manga 💀💀
@@matthewh4124 I would agree but the fact that Halil's bashed in head was actually shown without the debris in the manga makes me still put the manga on top, especially with the colored version because the person who did that showed his brain leaking out.
However in terms of overalll dread, the anime definitely wins.
@@matthewh4124 Lol, no it isn't. I went and checked out the manga panel just out of curiosity and you gotta be smoking crack if you think this is more gruesome.
@@ThisHandleSystemCanGetNicked that panel do be messed up fr
I tried holding it back, tears and lunch wise with this scene but with Eren’s heartbreak and the kid’s death, neither could be held back
Eren die
Chill out brother, it's just an anime
Don't hold it back. It's not healthy
@@muhammadtaha2332
you chill the fk out
@@DCB20 what?
Love how they always draw individual teeth when the characters express extreme emotion
when the titan was crushing ramzi, you can see his teeth shattering while he's being crushed, this is crazy
Right that shit was lit!
It was the blood pooling in his eyesight for me. I nearly died with him
Eren die
Seeing him getting crushed in slow motion was gruesome
Yup just like in the manga.
The cinematography of this scene perfectly captured the haunting essence of humanity and human desires. It was truly mortifying.
What most people don't realize is that the AOT world map is literally Africa upside down, with Madagascar as the Paradis Island.
Is that it? The only continent in AOT universe is upside down Africa? If there's more, is that all Eren rumbled?
@@mushroomarmy8802That is just Marley, google the aot world map
@@mushroomarmy8802 he rumbled it all, 80% of humanity died.
@keithfilibeck2390 in manga eren sent million wall titan all around world to destroy every island and continent
I thought Paradis resembled the Island Nation of Japan while Marley represents the Mainland China
Eren admitted here that he wanted to flatten the world because he wasn't happy with the idea of the world and what he called freedom not being a reality. He was never going to be happy even if he achieved his so-called freedom. Juxtapose this with Armin who was always free even inside of the walls, Eren was only free in death. But the sympathy we built for Eren made him arguably one of the greatest villains in fiction.
If that's how you spin this convoluted and contrived plot to help u sleep at night,okay then. Armin literally had no plan, and he stated as much. Also nice Gass lighting as Eren didn't choose this because that's his idea of freedom. He chose this because he was left with no other choice. His selfish desire is to go out and see the world while leaving the walls entirely. The problem is the World despises him on his race and want to annihilate his homeland just because of things that happened a century ago.
It's crazy how someone like me who can't stand AoT can follow the plot better than a fan like you. Actually the big reason I can't stand AoT is this arc in particular on how the author craps on a sensitive/delicate topic of race issues just to attract some buzz for his manga. Couldn't even write this situation right but I digress.
@@mr.unknown731 are you accusing the author of political pandering just because you're unsatisfied with something going on in the real world?
@Pink Yogurt No I hate this author for lazy writing that was so bad that it ironically supports Rascism at the end of said manga. It also ironically shits on the point the Black character was making to Armin.
This is what happens when a writer handles a delicate subject with the care of a hammer to a nail.
@@mr.unknown731 are we even watching the same show?
@@MCUFAN-vy4rjhere did he confirm this? This speech legit says that he was disappointed there were people outside the walls.
He wanted a whole world to explore that wasn’t tainted by humanity. It’s not the main reason for the rumbling but he’s a ashamed that part of him wished for this level of destruction.
Even if he feel bad about the rumbling even if he’s doing it for his friend’s even if he lost everything, he actually felt good knowing that no one can stop him….he finally felt the taste of fredoom. It is true him and Reiner are really the same.
Oh no like he said…he’s actually worse than Reiner
@@90snickshows84why?
@@Supe204 he pretty much explains why he feels he’s worse than him. Reiner when he attacked the Walls wasn’t under the impression that he did anything wrong he was just following the Marleyan propaganda because it was all he knew and because he wanted to be a hero. Even when he found out how the people on Paradis were he still tried to convince himself that he was the good guy. Eren on the other hand knew what was in store for his future and knew he was on the warpath to commit this genocidal act and knew it was wrong from the very beginning especially with how high the death toll would be compared to what Reiner did but he still chose to follow it not because he wanted to be a hero but to pursue his overwhelming desire for freedom.
I just thought of something and this is a question if anyone can help me answer this
In the last episode before part 3 of attack on Titan when
eren and his friends went to the other side of the sea on Marley when eren was crying whilst ramzi was waving at him and later on when mikasah and him were talking and the old man offered a drink did he do that because ramzi told his grandpa that eren saved him from the three people that beat him up is that why eren and his friends were invited to a party
@@abdullahshaibu5274 yes this is all true bro
A lot of deaths affected me but seeing him being crushed in slow motion does something too😭😢
living Eren’s life after he kissed Historia’s hands must’ve been horrible. Imagine living every day of your life knowing what’ll happen tomorrow and knowing EVERYTHING you do means nothing, cause the results always remain the same. The Rumbling.
Absolutely exactly said 😢🙁😔😖😡🤬😡
its worse than that, he isn't just learning the determined future, he also learned the determined past, which he has to determine himself, even though its already happened, he is the least free being alive, because only he knows that everything is fatalistic, at least until the Titans powers are erased.
Its scenes like this that reminded me on how young Erin was. He was put in this position to make hard choices but in reality he was still just a child of war
With someone constantly experiencing those things with no time to process or grieve, im not surprised he ended up going with the most ruthless and drastic choice, even if his choices were just being led by pure ptsd delusions
he didn't make any choices, Eren's fate is deterministic, just as he manipulated the past (which he ALWAYS does, it isn't time travel/alteration) so too is the Rumbling a determined outcome, all before Eren was ever born, either Future Eren, or Ymir made it so, long before Eren was ever born.
Please stop calling him a child when he's 19 years old. He's an adult.
@@ShadowSkyX Did we not watch him since he was a literal kid at the start of the show... Just because he's 19 doesn't change the fact that he grew up horrifically and that it would've definitely affected his choices.
@@keithfilibeck2390 I'm going by the original timeline theory that Erin would've had to have experienced these things in one life in order for him to know what to correct for the Erin we're watching in the show.
Is that really an excuse when Gabi was indoctrinated her whole life and still changed, a few days after seeing her friends get murdered?
The writer really did his research
Those characters names are Arabic names.
And even the Khalfa harbor, khalifa in Arabic means successor
Mia the Successor
@@KePzez good one
They also come from Turkish origin too due to the Ottoman Empire. Likelywise in the Attack on Titan universe the Ottoman Empire existed. But probaly got annihilated after the rumbling. Along with Halil and Ramzi.
The name ramzi could actually be indian tho. Ramzi is actually an anglicized version of his actual name ramuji, which is a common rame in india.
I thought these people could be Arabic as well but in episode 86 they're shown drinking some kind of alcohol (most likely a drink called "rakı" that's widely consumed in Turkey) and any type of alcohol is completely banned in Arabia. Also in Season 4 Episode 4 a guy with really similar clothing is shown selling Turkish ice cream. An ice cream that's known for stretching
What's especially brutalis that the kid who dies by the rubble had the most merciful death he could have gotten. And the flattened kid pretty much the same. Remember those peoplewho burned?
Heh, I don’t know. I think I would still go out the same way as the dude who shot himself before the rumbling got him, get to go out on my terms that way at least
The transition between past and present and superb voiceline by Yuki, really a masterpiece.
I aspire to be like these two, they died for the bag, gotta respect these legendary ass hustlers
MASTERPIECE
Eren disappointment of the world outside of the walls is extremely sad for me, my heart goes out to him 💔
Yh but I feel sadder for the innocent people getting crushed to death
Hahahahahaha he literally victimized Eren in this scene
The world leaders were that stupid
My heart goes out to the innocent people he crushed
@@Chukz05feel sorry for the people that are dying all over the world but that doesn’t stop you from going about your life🤷♀️
Now I understand what the lyric "Children cling to their coins" in My War meant...
What’s funny is eren will never truly be ‘free’ all he’s ever wanted is to escape from the walls. And he wasn’t satisfied with the results, after the only way he views to get ‘freedom’ is the rumbling. The titans following him are the walls, the walls follow him everywhere he goes.
Oh damn, never looked at it that way.
This part in the manga made my blood actually cold; I'm relieved to see they didn't skimp a single detail, especially the slow motion footstep kill. ( 2:11 although in the manga, you could see his dead eyes still open and his brains spilling out. But i wont complain because I would feel bad wishing for that level of gory details on a child character. 😆)
When I saw that panel in the manga I immediately knew they were gonna water it down with the gore for the anime 😂 Still one hell of a scene tho
I wish they did show it. That would just show that the anime is coming to an end and they aren't holding back to make it more memorable. They already have a disclaimer on Hulu and shit so why not 🤷
Fuck that
Let me see that brain across the street
@@TreadywayYTbro really wanted to see a kid’s splattered brains on the floor.
@@htfs493If we still have to witness a child’s skull get crushed in slow motion immediately afterwards…
*…why bother holding back?*
They did not hold back with animating this
This is such an amazing well animated scene you can genuinely tell eren feels so bad but knows the timeline is fixed. Its set in stone. He knows what he has to do
Its tough to watch. They poured their heart into the animation. The pain in Ramzi's face. His blurred and bloody vision.
I truly am fascinated with the point the story goes for to make you feel sorry for all of them including Eren-- he was once as innocent as those kids and so many others who died because of His action… that he was provoke by the actions of others to rewrite his own life (literally), which inevitably results in the wholesale destruction and slaughter of most of the world’s population-- the same way the world agreed to do to the ppl of the island of Paradis. It’s in the cycle of hate, fear, death and the madness of obtaining absolute power, which perpetuates this drama to an epic conclusion… and Eren is at the heart of the struggle of the human condition; between life, death, love hate, fear, courage, weakness and ultimate power-- but overall the experience of living in abject fear-- which is exactly what it is to be a slave-- and the struggle to be totally free!
if you notice at 0:10 thats reiners dad
Nice peep
So this is what they meant when they said "kids clinging to their coins" in first opening of season 4
I just noticed how Eren is a villain, he never wants peace and always full of wrath. he never settles anything with diplomacy or promises, only with physical abuse. notice how he fought Jean at dinner, he simply just never resort to peace option.
how the writer surround Eren with good characters as bumpers makes us forgot about Eren's brutality. Mikasa was hell bent on believing Eren was a good guy, Armin's diplomacy and PR skill makes Eren forgivable and 'look' as good guy.
when Reiner thought Eren was the worst person to have an Attack Titan, he was dam right. Eren is that one kid who would go too far if being provoked, and he would not find reasonable solution other than power.
Eren always had a naturally dark and angry disposition even as a child. He said it himself he was born like that. No one tried to brainwash him. He was bored when he lived a peaceful life. Had he been born in a normal world, he would've become a serial killer. Because he wants to wield absolute power over the world, that's his idea of freedom. He wants to flatten the world because it disappoints him.
He's similar to that Marleyan officer who pushes Eldians and Pure Titans off the wall and watches them fight for entertainment.
The kid that goes too far when provoke is me. I also love Eren because of the stuff he did, not killing kids and stuff but I mean him not acting like a total dumbass with power, like reverse flash in cw
"I can't save humanity and neither can the commander! But Armin can!
The only thoughts left in my head are full of hate! But Armin's not like that!!
He cares about MORE than fighting!
Tell him, Mikasa!!"
--Eren Yeager, S3, E10? Hero
@@Ch4rlz_ThA_Princ3 if one become a ruler, I'd agree Armin would be the best president out of those 3. but it's too bad they live in a time where power are absolute, and establishing diplomacy means compromising peace during that era. Armin being a hero afterwards were due to fiction genre in my opinion, if it's real world Armin would've been off'ed after the rumbling
Eren > attack on titan
how can people see innocent children dying like this and still support the rumbling
the same way people see innocent children dying in Palestine and still support Israel
@@DayMakerMusic🗿
Because it's either them or Eldia.
War is cruel, that's how it is.
Yeah. I understand it, but if you support it something is wrong with u
@@JacobIX99so Marley did nothing wrong too then 😊
Yep. Eren is a monster no matter how you cut it.
I don't think you understand the plot, whether he is a monster or not is irrelevant, he's stuck in a sort of "Dr. Manhattan" style fatalistic determinism the fact that his father, and the Attack Titan user before his father, were already influenced by future Eren, means that the Rumbling too, was always destined to happen, this scene is supposed to show you this, he knows he "kills that kid in the future" because he can experince the future as well as the past.
mind you, these events, and choices were locked into place long before Eren was born, and likely, by Ymir long long ago.
@@keithfilibeck2390 Or he could, you know, not? "Well, Future Me led me here so now I guess I HAVE to commit genocide, right? I mean, how could I not if everything in the past and future has converged here, it's not like I have free will >:DDD"
@@TheVellure he couldn't because he was a slave, he didn't even fully know it, he is a slave to Ymir's will, his entire life manipulated thousands of years in advance, all the things that led to Eren's birth were already set in stone, and were events Eren himself was forced to inact, such is his mother's death, its deterministic.
@@keithfilibeck2390 IDK, the ending still has him trying to rationalize this nonsense like he made a choice of his own. So it's pretty hard to excuse anything as being predetermined.
@@TheVellure it obviously is, lol, the entire plot is about Ymir trying to fudge reality to escape her predicament, which involves having no agency beyond whoever has the Attack Titan has certain urges. through this she manipulated events, Eren's existence is the final chess move to create a being who will achieve this. Eren's motivations, and life, were factored in, he does/did want the rumbling, because he was always going to want it.
0:47 this scene was heartwrenching, the fact that like idk a episode before this was all happy drunk eren and the group and then you could just hear the fear of the people and the man
The manga is more gruesome .. about the other kids head.. sliced up with that rock..
Just wait until the baby scene..
They censor some in the televised versions, suprised they showed even this much tbh. If you look up the blue ray editions of AOT more of the graphic stuff in the manga are shown in previous seasons
in the manga their bones aren't even showing while in the show well you know.
@@countchompula1896 the baby survived tho
@@PeeweePlugfr?
The more I watch this the more I feel sorry for Eren. He knows what he’s doing is wrong and never wanted this outcome. He was looking so hard for an alternative but the world was too full hate. Eren wants his friends to stop him so he doesn’t live with the guilt of committing genocide. And this is the big difference between him and Floch. They were working together but they had different goals. Eren wanted to do this and let himself be killed so that the world can see that even Eldians can be both good and have morals. Floch on the other hand is enjoying the destruction and death and is building a new empire and is willing to enslave or kill those who disagree with him. Eren hates everything he is doing right now. Every country he destroys, every life he takes including children. Eren has gone too far and even he knows it. He never wanted this but Marley could not let go of their hatred for people who had nothing to do with their ancestors. Floch revels in the fact that innocents who don’t want anything to do with the war on Eldia are being killed. It’s wrong to kill each other when there is always a peaceful solution to everything.
I agree with this. a lot of people said that when eren said he was disappointed people interpret it has him saying eren was disappointed in in just seeing humans
When in fact in 2020 a fan asked isyama about eren disappointment he said that “eren was disappointed that humanity outside the walls was cruel and towards paradise and each-other it wasn’t because humanity existed “
People also said that if people weren’t cruel to paradise eren would of still done the rumbling
Also eren doesn’t care about the scenery in armins book he cares because it was denied to him by the walls and humanity the outside the walls and across the ocean
He realised that if he were able to see those sights it will mean he is free from all walls and there will be nothing caging him and he wasn’t disappointed just by the existence of humans but he saw them as nothing but another cage
So if the world wasn’t trying to take his freedom he would have no desire to kill them and he even needed motivation to kill them by his mothers death
@@abdullahshaibu5274 indeed. Him doing the rumbling isn’t out of revenge or hatred. It’s because he’s trying to show that he is a monster that must be stopped by everyone including Eldians. He wants to die because he’s at the point of no Return.
@@TheToaprimezilla what did you think about attack on Titan part 3 what was your memorable moment and who is your favourite character and part for eren as a person is apparently he is not meant to be good or evil
@@abdullahshaibu5274 Hard to say. Eren back in part 3 was ready to save what he thought was the last part of humanity. He was different back then. So I don’t know to be honest
@@TheToaprimezilla maybe eren as a normal human being is nice but with the founding Titan he is not maybe but what do you think of him as a perosn and who is your favourite
messed up part but my favorite part due to the emotion and music here
The child-sized body outlines, and the remains of the closed gate got me good.
What’s crazy is ppl watched this and was still team Eden. And that is why AoT is goated
After watching 13 ghosts as a kid getting squashed to death especially slowly has always been my worst fear. Honestly I'd have just topped myself if the rumbling was happening.
All this happened because of the failure of the world leaders to look at every angle possible and seek a diplomatic solution instead of just declaring war on an island of people who haven't been politically active or simply active for 100 years..... This is the fact that somehow many in the community forget but they just blame Eren.
I mean, Marley used titan powers to rule the world for over a 100 years, so the fear for eldians was reasonable. What did not make sense was the whole world alliance with Marley to kill the eldians that lived in peace for a century. Realistically the world would seek an alliance with paradise to defeat Marley
@@dariellaahad1501 the whole nations fell to Willy Tybur propaganda and fearmongering of Rumbling story that they basically helping Marley to get Founding Titan power.
All because of greed (Marley) and fear (whole other nations)
To be fair, Hizuru trying to ally itself with Eldia didn't save it from the Rumbling
@@dariellaahad1501 That was something that bothered me too. Like they were actively in a war dropping titans on people, while attacking Paradis at the same time. Yet all these people go to Marley to hear a speech on how they should come together and slaughter Paradis. ???? Makes no sense to me.
@@dariellaahad1501also eldians: did the same thing for 2000 years
The fact that this dude never realized he was his own self-fulfilling prophecy is sad. The reason all these things happened was solely bc he insisted “they must”.
I feel like here we see the raw portrayal of who he is, his main reason for the rumbling is because he's simply disappointed that the outside world isn't like what he thought, it's not some wonderful adventure land, it was a terrible cruel place not just for Eldiens. He wanted to wipe it all away because his dream of seeing this beautiful magical world was turned into the harsh reality of the world being full of hate. Do I think Erens the hero? No, do I think he's the villain? Yes, but I don't think that he's completely evil, he's more just broken because of everything that happened.
Yeah I think that Eren's like a kid. When the kid receives something that doesn't fulfill his expectation, he will want to tear it apart or throw it away instead of accepting it. Of course I don't say every kid is like that but almost, that's just the nature of kid. In fact, I used to be like that too. But poor for Eren, he has so much power than a normal kid and his childish desire becomes a terrible future. And now he wants it or not, it's read-only and unchangeable
Are you stupid? He did it because the world was trying kill paradis and eren was defending it
@@desertdead5590 I mean all of them are villians if we get down too it
lol man,you guys really cut the whole suffering journey of eren and add it to armin book only,,dont u see how cruel aot world is!!
he is disspointed bcz outside people hate them,so he doesnt have the right to see the beautiful world!! he doesnt care about armin book he just saying there no freedom when he saw armin book thought there is freedom in reality there no feedom just enemy thats why he was dissapointed cz people take their freedom!! wannted them to die!!
he is saying he is doing this for armin book???no,,, lolllllllll!!! doesnt make sense at all!! how can you guys came to this kind of conclusion!! why you guys dont understand eren as a person!!!!,,,,i am just tired of it!! seeing the sight with armin he wanted because he thought a free person can go outside the world where there is freedom and beautiful sight!! but his true intension was having a world where there is no enemy!!
They can not make a story as epic as this again, AOT was the peak.
No one gonna talk about this amazing ost? Gah dayum the chills
I think it's a minor version of YOUSEEBIGGIRL
Ost is The Rumbling on Liberio
@@codexcodexcodexno it’s called an ordinary day
@@scr3verrrb70 my bad
I cried at least 4 times during this special.. It was the best series to be ever created without a question milking my tears out
it took the rumbling to finally make eren realise how far freedom should go
It was hinted in part 2 finale that Ramzi maybe Eldian. Here in his last moments he sees Ymir.
I wonder how she felt about it!
Eren accepted that a lot of Eldians outside the walls would die. The Eldians important to him were those inside the walls.
This scene made hate Eren
He escapes into a child version because he doesn't even have the guts to watch what he's doing and then he dares to cry in front of Ramzi and say "I'm sorry?"
Fucking Monster, at least Flock knows how fucked up the whole thing is and doesn't hide behind tears
??? Eren clearly understands that he’s doing something extremely fucked up. Him being upset is pretty reasonable as he doesn’t want to kill Ramzi but has to to get what he wants. Also, I personally don’t see why people hate characters that are bad people. I think Eren is a very interesting character, which is why I like him.
SPOILERS FOR FINALE:
Or I would see he WAS an interesting character but the ending really fucked shit up. Idk maybe I’d still say he’s a good character.
@@guyinahouse10it's not hating evil character
I don't like the fact that he tries to say he's sorry but then the anime shows him saying "this is freedom"
Be fucking honest with yourself at least
@@Ale-dd3ekYou have literally no media literacy💀
@@Ale-dd3ektell me u don't have any brain cells and did not understand shit at all☠️
@@Ale-dd3ek I think that the "This is freedom" scene represents that little Eren's dream of having a completely empty world outside the walls was fulfilled. And he uses it as a shield to protect his mind from the genocide he is witnessing. Remember that when he obtained the power of the founder, past, present and future became all one thing, so in order to protect himself from that terrible sight, he convinces himself that he fulfilled his wish to achieve his "idea of freedom". At least that's how I understand it.
He could have offered him and his entire clan asylum within the walls. They were literally living in tents & stealing to make a way. They were probably refugees from the country Marley defeated in the beginning of season 4
That's literally i was thinking! Initiate a refugee program for all eldians and oppressed around the world and start rumbling
That's literally i was thinking! Initiate a refugee program for all eldians and oppressed around the world and start rumbling
@@anshulkumar8922 They’d have to be very selective. They also should’ve allowed the Marleyan prisoners who sided with them to bring their families to Paradis. Onyonkapon should’ve done that. They had airships & boats by that point. They had 4 years to orchestrate it as well. Given the time period there was limited technology because the Marleyan government assumed those people were dead. They didn’t even know that Eren’s group had visited the country.
A lot of Attack on Titan is extremist to the point the logic isn’t the most sound because even with Eren predetermining the future, offering asylum to certain groups, doing raid missions to free Eldians around the world from their internment camps, he could have been the Eldian Harriet Tubman
I love how we're witnessing a genocide in fiction and yall in the comments act like it's a normal Tuesday on CNN
The va when Eren us crying saying sorry gives me chills
It should be noted that Eren admits here that this is what he wants. No one's forcing him to start the rumbling. Not even the circumstances. The reason he trampled the world was because he wished to do so, he dreamed of doing so. So no, Eren was not forced by Ymir or by the situation regarding Paradis. He has made abundantly clear many times that his dream is to flatten everything outside the walls, its just that learning that humans are living there especially good people as well made it hard for him.
uh yes, someone is forcing the Rumbling, it was always Ymir, the future was deterimined, its fatalistic, Eren ALWAYS manipulates the past of his father, and his own past, it already happened, meaning him seeing the rumbling, will always happen, his fate was written into stone before he was born.
@@keithfilibeck2390 Well, not quite actually. See, this is the problem with playing with time in a fictional story. What is the cause of this consequence? Was it all meant to happen for Eren to manipulate things or is it Eren who manipulates things to make it happen?
It's like the classic, which comes first, the chicken or the egg?
In any case, from what is shown in the story, Eren set himself up from the beginning. It's like a living paradox, Eren suffered all those traumas to eventually grow up and have those traumas suffer again as a child.
@@nk_nicolasmayoral The furthest we know Eren manipulating events is the Owl, but it would be interesting to consider that maybe his effect stretches way back.
@@arthur0023 Yes, for me, considering what we are told about the power of the founder and how it relates to the power of the attack titan, it is quite likely that he not only manipulated Grisha's memories to show him what was convenient for him, but also the Owl's and maybe himself. Perhaps even other bearers of the attack titan throughout the 2000 years of history. But who knows, Isayama never raised this, maybe because he didn't think about it or maybe because he wanted it to be this way so that we as readers/viewers would always question ourselves. Unfortunately it is a doubt that we will always have.
"I have defeated the enemy simply by marching"
You mean Wiping them out?
AOT looked like a happy anime with a good ending to me before I watched it
I knew it would be a happy anytime when I watched the first episode
But..then the other half….
And these type of moments…
Now this is a huge part of my life..and scary sometimes, even as someone about to be an adult soon…
all he said makes more sense now
いつ見ても感情移入して泣く
When you think about it in a messed up way that's how bugs feel when we step on them without care nor know that they're there.
It like from they're P.O.V
Eren couldn't stand for the kid being abused like that. He decided to help anyway, despite knowing the kid's fate. I feel like he was desperate to 'save' humanity from not only their suffering, but also their arrogance. So he just trampled everything and wiped them away, the good and the bad. Even though I feel it's unfair for the kid Ramzi to die like that. He has been suffering his whole life, had to steal and lost his arm for the sake of his own community, and in the end, he died running in terror, not having a single clue what the heck is going on. AOT is a true maaterpiece indeed.
the scene that shows us that eren had no free will, but also that all this was his doing kinda. Strange to explain.
As a Turk,I found the way that he call him Remzi so adorable,it sounds so cute and interesting to hear this name this much cute.
Cause usually it’s sounds like more strong in our language but this dub just melted my heart :’) I wish they wouldn’t die
You'll be carful, Ramzi is an arabic name, not a Turkish one ^^
Eren is also a Turkish name
ramzi and halil are arabian names
One of the saddest death in anime history😭
😭😭😭
i still can't believe how far they actually animated this scene.
They sent one colossal titan to him and sent thousands if not millions
The butterfly being crushed in aot season 4 part 2 title reminds me of this stain.
The music as the foot comes down, those horrific, rhythmic trumpets...it just sounds like a fucking horror movie.
Damn! No words can describe the horror.
Eren be like "damn sorry I have to kill you even though I could have literally avoided this outcome by not being a loser"
Pretty sure it was Marley's fault by attempting to commit genocide against eldia & paradise island.
@@guptapratik999 you are right. People always forget who started it first, if marley never sent titans to paradis and never sent the colossal and armoured titan to broke the wall in that day, eren wouldn't do the rumbling, and he knew that paradis wouldn't survive because marley would try to destroy it again
@@Nightfoxx444 The situation is a bit more complicated since as Eren confesses that he wanted this. Like part of him really just wanted an excuse to stomp people. Otherwise he wouldn't have gone through with it.
@@ajeshtantri9816 I doubt he wanted an excuse, it was more of a justification for his action. He wouldn't had breakdown in front of ramzi otherwise.
I think it's more about safety of his people. He can spare the world but it'll require historia and her children to become a Titans which would be hell for them, or he can just run away in which case, world will massacre paradise island.
Rumbling seems the best option in terms of saving his folks. I do hate the fact that writers and fans forgot what Reiner and Annie did in first 3 seasons. They killed alot of innocent folks, so they don't get to act as heroes in last arc. Whereas eren whose actions are atleast justifiable in self defence is portrayed as villian.
@@guptapratik999 Oi Reiner and Annie constantly get crap for what they did by the ones in paradi and they call themselves monsters too especially Reiner how could you ignore that? Reiner gets tons of crap from Galliard for getting his brother killed and Annie got trapped in a crystal for 4 years while still being conscious. Compared to them Eren got off easy for committing genocide.
do u think ramzi, while he was watching the rumbling arrive, was thinking "oh. thats why he was cryinggg ok i see"
Ever since the manga i patiently waited for this to be animated.
2:01 me after the last episode
Your inability to comprehend some aspects of the philosophical messages the series is what’s
Disappointing
Typical human idiocy
😂
/;;/
@@jhinabloomingflower807i think he meant he was just sas
@jhinabloomingflower807 "if you dont like the ending its because you dont unserstand the philosophical aspect" bro just no. Thats a terrible take and shows you have absolutely no idea what you're talkinh about.
@@jhinabloomingflower807bro he's trying to say he was sad or crying after the ending he did not say he hated it
@@AuroraBoost being absolute on a lot or some things will make you not very wise or objectively correct
Also I got a very good idea on what I’m talking and thinking about
The show doesn’t have to hold your hand and even if it explains a lot of things
People can be limited by many personal factors to make up philosophical conclusions
Because of Personal EXPECTATIONS
So no you’re wrong,but keep trying!
Just how subtly this scene shows that when you die you can not take the money with you you will have to leave it behind
One day, while doing nothing particularly out of the ordinary, because of natural laws he was completely powerless to understand or intuit, he was instantly killed in a horrifying way by forces vastly in excess of anything he was ever designed to experience, for no reason, to no ones particular surprise or upset. In this we are more like him than different.
Bro admits he didn’t want to save Elida but because he just wanted to commit genocide and people still defend him. It’s like they are rooting for hitler
1:08 Not to be rude but are you dull in the head? He literally said right here that he did indeed want to save Eldia, it just wasn’t the only reason he had for going through with starting his genocide. He had selfish reason for doing it as well, which he lays out in this scene. Why don’t y’all seem to understand that Eren’s reasons for doing The Rumbling were complex? He literally explains as much in his scene with Armin!
Also, comparing Eren to Hitler is really fucking stupid. No offense.
Ymir watching to see if anyone can betray what they love, Ramzi, loved money and died for it
This is the cruel reality of war, how children suffer the consequences of human conflicts.
MASTERPIECE !!!!
Agreed
Eren killed children, thats a very new low.
"In order to overcome monsters one must toss aside their humanity"
1:39 : Children cling to their coins
2:10 : Squeezing out their wisdom
Shinsei kamattechan - Boku no sensou
Seeing Ymir before he died fucked me up first time watching😬😬😬😪
Halili went to save the money, What good is money gonna be in a world where there's nothing?
So thats how strawberry jelly is made
This one made me look away it looked too real.. and then shows what remains
I would have already been gone, would have already been somewhere else I’m not goin out like tha
Sad/goosebumps 🥶 rumbling totally scary af
This was actually the only time i cried at marleans dying
They would have been he chance he survived longer if he did not go for the money
Not really.
Nope they still wouldn't
@pengtingman8631 well at the very least they wouldn't have been hit by debris
@@rooksclown316 yea maybe but they still would have died regardless it just would have been delayed
@sepeosd5122 Yeah, it's just delaying the inevitable
2:54
Run! Run for ya lives! :O
That's what money means, it kills people 😔
1:58 Me after watching the ending
Eren is a kid at heart
Just close your eyes, the sun is going down
You'll be alright, no one can hurt you now
Come morning light, you and I'll be safe and sound
Don't you dare look out your window, darling, everything's on fire
The war outside our door keeps raging on
Hold onto this lullaby even when the music's gone, gone
Both of them: BRO THE MONEY DROPPED
Wall titans: HURRY UP
Halil: GET DA MONEYYYY!!
Ramzi: BRO WE DONT GOT NO TIME
Halil: Oh sh- We messed up... AAAAAAA
Ramzi: He's dead.. YO YO YO WAIT SOMEONE HELP
The wall titans: MY OH MY WE FOUND YOU LACKING
Ramzi: CHILL BRO WTH, WAIT YO YO HELPPPPPP
This scene had me in tears dude 😭😭😭
Mappa mvp, they single handedly saved the bs pacing of the manga looool.
Have you all noticed that Reiner's father was beating up Ramzi, then Eren saved him! Reiner's dad is the one wearing apron
as callous as those merchants were i bet even they would be horrified if they saw what eren did to ramzi
The wall titan whose mouth is closed: 🗿
Btw what happen to 3 guy who punches ramzi
Eren beat them up and “saved” the boy. They didn’t show it here but it’s in the manga.
@@dragonballa5083 oh
@@dragonballa5083 they showed it in anime too
They feel asleep