I don't get why so many people are saying this song sucks?? There's a difference between you personally not liking a song and a song actually being bad. This song is not bad at all. It's well written and has amazing lyrics. Just because you guys are use to stock tiktok sludge music doesn't mean a song with actual character and effort put into isn't good.
@@damplamp3259 I don’t have to go anywhere. Sorry to be the bearer of bad news but you don’t have to shoot the messenger. This song sounds like complete dog crap live.
I saw them in Brisbane on November 30, 2022 and they played this. From memory Adrienne said that they had either just finished writing it, or had been working on it backstage, and when they played it they got through half of the first verse before having to restart it. I managed to snag a set list that night, and just dug it out to see if I remembered correctly, and it's on there! It was a great show too, first stop on the Australian tour and they were unpredictable and loose as hell, in a good way.
I had a dream she was singing this in an NBA stadium, except instead of singing “falling”, she was singing “Yao-Ming.” Now my brain wants to sing that haha
nah that's just what the realllllllly "artsy" artists do. It's a weird comparison, but check out Jewel. She does that stuff all the time; I think they're just musically gifted enough that they'd go insane if they didn't switch it up from time to time. I can understand that, I think!
i love big theif so much i listen to them at least 900x daily and i agree and would like to give more: love love love, blue lightning, interstate, and wolf :3
How I love this song and live version. THE PRIMAL SCREAM at the end is too the soul. You all should try and hook up with Michael Sipe for a song or album! ✌️👁️🗨️👍
Primal screen felt all the way to the soul huh 🤔 and then she followed that up with the most cringes painful “ hi nom” ever uttered on a live performance.
@@timtrefz5450 who cares? Evidently you do. Here you are responding to me personally not once , but twice even. “All the way to her soul” sheer foolishness.
@@gerardocastro2676 lol.... You talk about me ... Why I'm I talking about you... You started this! Go play on the play ground with your kind... the Trumpies. Put your diaper on too but you need it on your head too covering your moth.
Have y’all considered that if you think the song sucks/you don’t like it, then maybe it’s not meant for you? You’re obviously not the target audience so just ignore it and listen to something else.
Really really sad they cut out the word “row” because it makes it FLOW SO MUCH BETTER it’s a DUMB pause and takes me out of it, but I do think the official version is good other than that
imo it makes the statement more final, i have done this for the LAST TIME instead of i have done this for the last time in a row, i j feel like it implies there could potentially be another time, but in the official version there definitely won’t be if that makes sense?
@@rune6513 I agree but it also kind of ruins the nice rhythm that’s happening with “snow” and “let me go” it’s slowly growing on me but I’ll always miss the way that it sounded you know?
@@Urglewurgleburg no cuz it adds so much to how depressing the song is, we got comfortable with this thing and they took it away and now it’s a little odd and weird and off and uncomfortable and i think that’s part of why this song is so good
I love this song (and you for reuploading) but does anyone have any idea why the studio version is so much different? Not just in sound but the lyrics? It doesn't make sense to remove "in a row" especially when the following lyrics ends in "matches in the snow"
I feel like they changed it because saying "For the last time in the row" Implies this is the last time they will do it repeatedly, cutting out that part gives the feeling that this is the last time, They are walking into the dager for the very last time. Cutting out that lyric also give this empty, uncomfortable feeling, which is how the singer feels in the relationship. Thats just what I got out of it though lol
the thing that a lot of newer fans won't know is that Big Thief is ALWAYS slightly changing the lyrics to their songs. It's kind of their "thing", in a way. Never expect Big Thief lyrics to remain constant, because they never will :)
it’s for the meter, not just the rhyme. I’m relistening to the live version now after just DEVOURING the studio version, and those lines they took out are honestly jarring- especially the “fish and gills” line, it just does not fit the meter of the song AT ALL.
i wish i could hear this song for the first time again. i miss last summer
@@neva9164 have you heard Adrianne Lenker’s solo stuff? 🔥
icon legend saviour thanks for reuploding
my life aint been the same since i saw this demo months ago, i always come back for it
This song is like cocaine
addictive
the absolute chokehold this song has on me-
I don't get why so many people are saying this song sucks?? There's a difference between you personally not liking a song and a song actually being bad. This song is not bad at all. It's well written and has amazing lyrics. Just because you guys are use to stock tiktok sludge music doesn't mean a song with actual character and effort put into isn't good.
This girl has some serious pipes on her!
preach that
Everyone in this band always looks like they’re on the verge of a mental breakdown.
@@victorbruno271 they sound like it too
so do you lol
@@victorbruno271 aren’t we all?
you look like guy from my uni that got charged with date raping freshmen
so do their listeners!! (can confirm, i am crying :3)
“I walked into your dagger for the last time in a row” literally the best line ever
Could not agree more. Love this lyric.
Literally no. 👎
@@gerardocastro2676bro. you have left like six hate comments. instead of spreading negativity just leave.
@@damplamp3259 I don’t have to go anywhere. Sorry to be the bearer of bad news but you don’t have to shoot the messenger. This song sounds like complete dog crap live.
@@gerardocastro2676 judging by your pfp, your opinion is completely invalid (your entire existence actually).
so poetic i couldnt stop rewatching
I've listened to this on repeat for 4 days straight and never stopping
I almost had a heart attack not being able to find this
Song has been on repeat for a week. In love.
I honestly love the full release one more but still like this one too but I feel more emotional with the final version idk why
Fantastic, just discovered this band, and this song blew me away when I first heard it. Still does.
listening to this song is both pleasure and pain
she's just brilliant... So happy for her success and happiness!!!
Heard this song on the radio just now and fell in love one time .... love from the UK
I think she changes some lyrics on how she's feeling in the moment I've done it too, some words fit or sound better and she makes it work
I saw them in Brisbane on November 30, 2022 and they played this. From memory Adrienne said that they had either just finished writing it, or had been working on it backstage, and when they played it they got through half of the first verse before having to restart it. I managed to snag a set list that night, and just dug it out to see if I remembered correctly, and it's on there! It was a great show too, first stop on the Australian tour and they were unpredictable and loose as hell, in a good way.
I had a dream she was singing this in an NBA stadium, except instead of singing “falling”, she was singing “Yao-Ming.” Now my brain wants to sing that haha
i really miss the "in a row" in the spotify version
I think that people prefer this version because it is cleaner sounding and the vocals are so natural.
1:59 THE SECOND "FALLING YEAH" JUST HIT DIFFERENTTTT
I wish this was the actual release every day I listen to the actual version Big Thief decided to put out.
Honestly, this is still my favorite version of this song 🥰
Too good! I'm not exaggerating one bit when I say that this band has restored a bit of my faith in humanity... Thank you, Big Thief!
Great song writing. If the kids are doing this, they're on the right track. Lots of emotion in this one.
These guys are in their 30's but fair enough lol
Tada!
These theffs are the good ones! They found and saved me from an illegal untimely tragic death at the hands of my family!
It's been wild following these guys since Tiny Desk. They're my favourte.
I would love to see this in Shrek 5
Heard this on Sirius XMU yesterday and I was blown away. What a sound. Glad I finally discovered them!
it really is like nothing else at all
Thank you, I really love this version
The flute is such a wonderful touch. Haven't enjoyed a flute in a "rock" (not really, but whatever) song this much sense Jethro Tull :)
ikr, that’s why i’m so sad they took it out in the released
You need to check out Mercury Revs first two albums.
this is like the first time you eat pad thai
yup
OMG that gave me chills. Love this
I absolutely love this. Heard it once on the radio and had to look it up
Me too, just now on KBCS!
Will forever love this song❤❤❤❤
I start cracking up laughing every time she screams. Not in a mocking way, I love it.
we were ROBBED of that chorus
This is my favorite version of this song I love it
I bet Colbert absolutely loved them. During the last episode of the daily report he kept playing neutral milk hotel, his favorite artist
I was thinking the same thing. He also really likes John Prine's music. I'm sure this music is right up his alley
2:49 this song is js a really sad story, this song lives in my heart i swear
Meek's playing here is soo good! Lovely performance by a treasure of a band!
i’m emotionally attached to this version thank u sm for reuploading
Confirmed for the Newport Folk Festival, 2024! Welcome Back, Big Thief.
2:56 great to see Buck taking the opportunity to practice his sandwalk
omggg this song just opened something in me
Hypothesis: they keep changing this song so that fans will argue about which version is better.
I think Damon Albarn used to change Gorillaz lyrics at each show to show it was live and not a recording. Maybe the same idea?
@@thefinalanswerytyesss hahaha and in comment sections of feel good inc people would argue about the lyrics
nah that's just what the realllllllly "artsy" artists do.
It's a weird comparison, but check out Jewel. She does that stuff all the time; I think they're just musically gifted enough that they'd go insane if they didn't switch it up from time to time. I can understand that, I think!
They’re singing the demo version
How many versions are there? I just know of 2
I love her
So great. That is art.
1:38 THIS HITS HARD
Buck Meek just fucking groovin on his own planet separate from our solar system.
More big thief song recs: Masterpeice, black diamonds, Mary, mythological beauty, humans, not
TYSMMM
i love big theif so much i listen to them at least 900x daily and i agree and would like to give more: love love love, blue lightning, interstate, and wolf :3
2:34 may be the part youre looking for
This is going to be a classic
the end of the song is too good especially the scream
They need to officially release this version I beg
it's in adrianne's knew album!
@@unknown.k921 it’s not the same version at all?
@@unknown.k921 I’m late but ur so real for this thank u
❤OH my GOD!!! ❤PerFEcTioN!❤
How I love this song and live version. THE PRIMAL SCREAM at the end is too the soul.
You all should try and hook up with Michael Sipe for a song or album! ✌️👁️🗨️👍
Primal screen felt all the way to the soul huh 🤔 and then she followed that up with the most cringes painful “ hi nom” ever uttered on a live performance.
@@gerardocastro2676
Waa waa too yourself. Not about you bro!
And who care's what you think....
@@timtrefz5450 who cares? Evidently you do. Here you are responding to me personally not once , but twice even.
“All the way to her soul” sheer foolishness.
@@gerardocastro2676 lol.... You talk about me ...
Why I'm I talking about you...
You started this!
Go play on the play ground with your kind... the Trumpies. Put your diaper on too but you need it on your head too covering your moth.
Thanks for reuploading!!
Im in love with this ngl.
I LOVE THIS AND BIG THIEF
Just as Phenomenal live
I love this song the live version is amazing ❤
my heart my heart my heart
Why their vibes r like they came straight up from the 70s? THATS SO COOL
Because that's what happens when the generation before you does their best to destroy the future: might as well get real weird with it :)
The emotional in this omg
the best performance ever
lol yeah sure it is.
song is not even bad. it's telling a story alot of you cant understand bc you all close minded thank you.
this song is trash
Let people enjoy stuff fun police @@jtjoemamma
Your user is joemama@@jtjoemamma
Can you hear a little Mercury Rev sneaking in and out of this? Such a great version
Absolutely!! it's what made this version so good. I'll never understand why they released it without the flute. Makes no sense.
obsessed
Have y’all considered that if you think the song sucks/you don’t like it, then maybe it’s not meant for you? You’re obviously not the target audience so just ignore it and listen to something else.
its meant for people with no taste
@@jtjoemammaNo taste? Look at your username. You have no taste in humor
this one’s the best version
Why was the original taken down? This is my favorite version of this song honestly 🥲
Probably since it’s now released and the demo is different they took it down.
2:36 the guy looking at the people behind crazy 😭😭
This just deranges me
I am melting
Holy shit.
Holy fucking shit
tysm for reposting
Tadc
@@royalty9745 uh yeah
This is the good stuff
HI MEEMAW !!!
MEEMAW MEE MAW MEEMAW MEE MAW MEE MAW MEE MAW WOOOOO
why did they take the original down?? I listened to it like everyday
I’m not sure, maybe it has to do with the backlash they got for the studio version of this song
That’s what y’all get for bitching about a demo
@@monk3brain365 we aint even do nun 😭
@@vita7456 all videos uploaded by this channel are on here for a limited amount of time
i love it
this is so pretty i love it
its like a cranberries undiscovered hit
Terrible take, lead singer sounds nothing like that
Tone deaf comment
no it doesn't, not the cranberries.
so good
so gooooooooooood
Does anyone by chance have flute notes for the intro?😁
Really really sad they cut out the word “row” because it makes it FLOW SO MUCH BETTER it’s a DUMB pause and takes me out of it, but I do think the official version is good other than that
imo it makes the statement more final, i have done this for the LAST TIME instead of i have done this for the last time in a row, i j feel like it implies there could potentially be another time, but in the official version there definitely won’t be if that makes sense?
@@rune6513 I agree but it also kind of ruins the nice rhythm that’s happening with “snow” and “let me go” it’s slowly growing on me but I’ll always miss the way that it sounded you know?
@@Urglewurgleburg no cuz it adds so much to how depressing the song is, we got comfortable with this thing and they took it away and now it’s a little odd and weird and off and uncomfortable and i think that’s part of why this song is so good
I always love Them! One of favorite people ever! ❤❤❤❤
this version is so much better!! why did they shorten it?!
very cool sound I love it!
I love this song (and you for reuploading) but does anyone have any idea why the studio version is so much different? Not just in sound but the lyrics? It doesn't make sense to remove "in a row" especially when the following lyrics ends in "matches in the snow"
They do whatever tf the want I guess
I feel like they changed it because saying "For the last time in the row" Implies this is the last time they will do it repeatedly, cutting out that part gives the feeling that this is the last time, They are walking into the dager for the very last time. Cutting out that lyric also give this empty, uncomfortable feeling, which is how the singer feels in the relationship. Thats just what I got out of it though lol
the thing that a lot of newer fans won't know is that Big Thief is ALWAYS slightly changing the lyrics to their songs. It's kind of their "thing", in a way.
Never expect Big Thief lyrics to remain constant, because they never will :)
@@idontwantahandlethough oh neat!
it’s for the meter, not just the rhyme. I’m relistening to the live version now after just DEVOURING the studio version, and those lines they took out are honestly jarring- especially the “fish and gills” line, it just does not fit the meter of the song AT ALL.
Makes me cry
🤤🤤🤤🤤🤤🤤🤤 I want to marry this song
LOVE THIS SONGG
at 1.2x speed it's like El Scorcho from Weezer
you're so right
stop you’re right😭😭
Oh my god 😭😭😭
I love that Matt Davidson is part of this.
Hahah Adrienne is nobody’s baby! Fuck yeah!