Ceci composé étant un élève de 17 ans ! Mis dans un tiroir et tiré de l'oubli 80 ans après, bien longtemps après la mort en pleine gloire de l'auteur. Si nous remontons le temps, Bizet (hélas mort trop tôt) annoncait avec cette œuvre de jeunesse, le magnifique mélodiste qu'il fut par la suite, (cf. Carmen, Les Pêcheurs de perles, L' Arlésienne), toutes ces œuvres que nous mélomanes, chantonnons ou sifflotons de temps à autres 😊)
It certainly IS lovely 😍 I myself find the 2nd movement of Bach's double violin concerto, and the second movement of Shostakovich's 2nd piano concerto to be even more beautiful 😉
Oh yes, I do agree.... it is sensational and so few people actually know about it. Bizet, along with Mozart and Schubert were taken from us far too early - much to our eternal sadness.
magnifique magnifique , belle interprétation, je suis aux anges, transportée . Merci aviost de ce partage, depuis le temps que je la cherche cette symphonie.
It's lovely but it's not a song. Songs are sung (usually. except Songs without words). By singers. (It's all the fault of TH-cam, Spotify etc.__ It's a Symphony. Best wishes from East Anglia in England.
@@DAVEDIKIAN As non-English myself, I can confirm that calling this a "song" is a grave error. There is no song. The writer is using a pop music dialect to describe this piece.
This is a symphony that we rarely hear. And it seems that over the days we discover it. And to say that Georges Bizet never played it in public. Why, mystery of shyness or music too elaborate for its time. also, magnificent, beautiful interpretation, I am thrilled, transported. Thanks aviost of this sharing, since the time I seek this symphony.
I believe Bizet never published this symphony because it resembled his - Charles Guonod - mentor's Symphony in D. He was embarrassed and so withheld it from the public. It wasn't until 1935 that this symphony premiered.
He was just seventeen years old. It was a piece of homework. It was never performed in his lifetime. Thank goodness it was discovered when it was, in the 1930s
Wow - A whole lot of Beethoven in this symphony. ...after investigating I found he (Bizet) wrote this as a study of Beethoven's style and did not want it published and it was not published until after his death.
He actually wrote it as a 17 year old as an assignment at the Paris Conservatory of Music. His teacher never graded it. It is likely his teacher never even looked at it. Or he did, and hid it away, hoping to take credit for it, but in his old age, forgot where he had hidden it (in a desk). That is my friend Wally's theory. But... who knows really. This is an utter masterpiece.
I read it was a composition assignment for school. He didn't even want to do it. So, for a shortcut, he copied the program regarding exposition, development and resolution from a symphony composed by his instructor. Then all he needed was a melody that matched the meter of the original and the symphony wrote itself. I had never listened to it from the Beethoven angle before, but I can hear it now.
Voilà une symphonie que l'on entend rarement. Et il semble qu'au fil des jours on la découvre. Et dire que Georges Bizet ne l'a jamais joué en public. Pourquoi, mystère de la timidité ou bien une musique trop élaborée pour son temps.
Il étudiait au Conservatoire de Paris. En 1855. à 17 ans, il composa en moins d'un mois cette oeuvre qu'il considérait comme un simple exercice d'étudiant. Il la laissa dans ses tiroirs sans tenter de la faire jouer ou éditer. La partition fut retrouvée en 1933 et créée la même année.
Imagine that-those Turks can really play classical music. Well, I guess they can do anything, as they once had one of the greatest empires in history, that extended into Asia, Africa and Europe. Marvelous performance.
I dont mean to be so offtopic but does any of you know of a trick to get back into an instagram account?? I somehow forgot the login password. I love any tips you can offer me
I've heard this symphony, that Bizet wrote being only 17 y.o., since I was a child. This oeuvre reminds me of Beethoven style. But, as I don't have TH-cam Premium, in middle of first movement, I was warned that publicity would appear after 5, 4, 3, 2, 1" and it was abruptly interrupted. Incredible.
Very nice. Solid orchestra! (Though I do miss the usual European orchestra visuals: The older-than-dirt white-haired fella on violin; the unassuming "housewife" looking woman on clarinet; the mega-hott Asian chick on violin; and the fruity percussionist.)
He's mad because his husband was doing it with another man.
6 ปีที่แล้ว +1
Estoy usando el traductor de Google para escribir estos comentarios. Respeto todos los idiomas del mundo. Amo esta música. Amo a Bizet. Amo a Carmen Este es mi último comentario.
Bravo, cette merveilleuse musique de Bizet est excellemment interprétée.
Ceci composé étant un élève de 17 ans ! Mis dans un tiroir et tiré de l'oubli 80 ans après, bien longtemps après la mort en pleine gloire de l'auteur.
Si nous remontons le temps, Bizet (hélas mort trop tôt) annoncait avec cette œuvre de jeunesse, le magnifique mélodiste qu'il fut par la suite,
(cf. Carmen, Les Pêcheurs de perles, L' Arlésienne), toutes ces œuvres que nous mélomanes, chantonnons ou sifflotons de temps à autres 😊)
They are all so humble in gracious.
that second movement one of the most beautiful in all classical music
It certainly IS lovely 😍
I myself find the 2nd movement of Bach's double violin concerto, and the second movement of Shostakovich's 2nd piano concerto to be even more beautiful 😉
Oh yes, I do agree.... it is sensational and so few people actually know about it. Bizet, along with Mozart and Schubert were taken from us far too early - much to our eternal sadness.
At seventeen years old, genius.
I agree100%
They are all so incredible.
Mon Dieu ! C'est superbe. Merci au Hautboiiste un chef-d'oeuvre. Daisy Cler
Bizet wrote this masterpiece at seventeen years old!
Bizet sat down shortly after his seventeenth birthday and thought - what shall I do now? I know, I’ll write a symphony.
Oboe solo realy touches my heart
It is exquisite!
My teachers choreographed to some of this symphony when I was a youth ballerina. Imagine! Soaring with this music. Grateful for Bizet.
Magnificent Musical Masterpiece!
Those three repetitive notes. Genius. He wrote this masterpiece shortly after his seventeenth birthday
haunting at places, playful at others. Charming! Excellent interpretation of this piece.
Beautiful oboe solo in the Adagio.
Para mim, toda a Sinfonia é bela e maravilhosa, salientando, no entanto, o Terceiro e o Quarto andamentos. Do melhor em música clássica.
magnifique magnifique , belle interprétation, je suis aux anges, transportée . Merci aviost de ce partage, depuis le temps que je la cherche cette symphonie.
Gabrielle Milandre = Jack Fastag = Henri hpv ?? Un des nombreux mystères de notre planète (en danger !)
Love this song. Played it in my youth symphony in high school.
Diane Sheafor do you still perform? I’m attending a concert Saturday night in Illinois where this wii be performed
Sorry I'm not english but why do call this a''song' for it's a symphony with no vocal parts ?
Diane Sheafor song???? Oh, my Goodness!
It's lovely but it's not a song.
Songs are sung (usually. except Songs without words). By singers. (It's all the fault of TH-cam, Spotify etc.__
It's a Symphony.
Best wishes from East Anglia in England.
@@DAVEDIKIAN As non-English myself, I can confirm that calling this a "song" is a grave error. There is no song. The writer is using a pop music dialect to describe this piece.
Oboe solo it stays my spirit.
This is a symphony that we rarely hear. And it seems that over the days we discover it. And to say that Georges Bizet never played it in public. Why, mystery of shyness or music too elaborate for its time. also,
magnificent, beautiful interpretation, I am thrilled, transported. Thanks aviost of this sharing, since the time I seek this symphony.
It was a composition project
I was told, need t meant
I believe Bizet never published this symphony because it resembled his - Charles Guonod - mentor's Symphony in D. He was embarrassed and so withheld it from the public. It wasn't until 1935 that this symphony premiered.
@@davewright7441 A STUDENT compositional project.
He was just seventeen years old. It was a piece of homework. It was never performed in his lifetime. Thank goodness it was discovered when it was, in the 1930s
@@hughcapetienHe was just past his seventeenth birthday. Whatever the inspiration, it’s pure genius
Excellent performance, masterly conducting!
Even the conductor looks a little like bizet❣, what a great symphony.
incarnation
I Allegro vivo 00:13 - 10:57
II Andante: Adagio 11:08 - 21:25
III Scherzo: Allegro vivace 21:41 - 27:10
IV Finale: Allegro vivace 27:22 - 36:21
Unbelievable
Wow - A whole lot of Beethoven in this symphony.
...after investigating I found he (Bizet) wrote this as a study of Beethoven's style and did not want it published and it was not published until after his death.
He also incorporated a lot of Gounod in it.
Wasn't rediscovered until 1935.
He actually wrote it as a 17 year old as an assignment at the Paris Conservatory of Music. His teacher never graded it. It is likely his teacher never even looked at it. Or he did, and hid it away, hoping to take credit for it, but in his old age, forgot where he had hidden it (in a desk). That is my friend Wally's theory. But... who knows really. This is an utter masterpiece.
I read it was a composition assignment for school. He didn't even want to do it. So, for a shortcut, he copied the program regarding exposition, development and resolution from a symphony composed by his instructor. Then all he needed was a melody that matched the meter of the original and the symphony wrote itself.
I had never listened to it from the Beethoven angle before, but I can hear it now.
Well thank goodness it was finally discovered. Better late than never. 3:42
I enjoyed Ostrowki's conducting so much.
Bravo from California.
Commyfornia
Bizet trafił w dziesiątkę, symfonia C jest przepiękna!!!!!!!.
Appreciate beautiful performance
Exquisite masterpiece.
Those three repetitive notes throughout the Adagio are genius
Excellent, all round.
This symphony is very Beethovenian! I like it.
Bravo Turkey!!
Takes the repeat in the 1st mvt: bravo!
A thoroughly lovely performance of a VERY tricky piece, especially for the first violins.
Last movement wouldn't tricky without the speed
One my favourites .
Voilà une symphonie que l'on entend rarement. Et il semble qu'au fil des jours on la découvre. Et dire que Georges Bizet ne l'a jamais joué en public. Pourquoi, mystère de la timidité ou bien une musique trop élaborée pour son temps.
Il étudiait au Conservatoire de Paris. En 1855. à 17 ans, il composa en moins d'un mois cette oeuvre qu'il considérait comme un simple exercice d'étudiant. Il la laissa dans ses tiroirs sans tenter de la faire jouer ou éditer. La partition fut retrouvée en 1933 et créée la même année.
Charmante symphonie...
Imagine that-those Turks can really play classical music. Well, I guess they can do anything, as they once had one of the greatest empires in history, that extended into Asia, Africa and Europe. Marvelous performance.
Rockstar
Bravo!!
Wonderful and a really great maestro,only the first violin are so dirty
I dont mean to be so offtopic but does any of you know of a trick to get back into an instagram account??
I somehow forgot the login password. I love any tips you can offer me
@Denver Brayan instablaster :)
I've heard this symphony, that Bizet wrote being only 17 y.o., since I was a child. This oeuvre reminds me of Beethoven style. But, as I don't have TH-cam Premium, in middle of first movement, I was warned that publicity would appear after 5, 4, 3, 2, 1" and it was abruptly interrupted. Incredible.
This is not the Czech Philharmonic Orchestra as listed, it is a Turkish Orchestra.
Very nice. Solid orchestra! (Though I do miss the usual European orchestra visuals: The older-than-dirt white-haired fella on violin; the unassuming "housewife" looking woman on clarinet; the mega-hott Asian chick on violin; and the fruity percussionist.)
Does anyone else think the bassoonist looks like he's PO'd at 2:35 ?
Maybe he hates the oboist - or something.
Great symphony.
Nope. He's just bored
He's mad because his husband was doing it with another man.
Estoy usando el traductor de Google para escribir estos comentarios. Respeto todos los idiomas del mundo. Amo esta música. Amo a Bizet. Amo a Carmen Este es mi último comentario.
Jack Fastag "%
@@MrCharles2407 Por supuesto!!..estoy de acuerdo contigo!..abrazo...
I like this orchestra! Not sure where they are from?
Turkey.
Greetings from East Anglia in England
It's an University orchestra.
It's a Chinese orchestra from Beijing.
Chicken
오.. 좋은데..
anyone else here because of your assigned artist?
881😢😊
I feel Beethoven in that all notes are well organized in the third movement.
I agree with you
34:17 That person on the balcony waving his arms is very distracting
That's who was actually doing the conducting, you imbecile!
Un trésor caché...
enfin à l écoute.
I'm sorry, but I find this a tad flat-footed, especially the third movement. Where is the joy of the seventeen year old who wrote it? Fixable.
Propagandas...