Something I love is that Shan Yu said “the solider from the mountain” not something like you’re a women? Because the huns had female worriers fighting alongside the men so to him it wasn’t a shock to see a woman fighting
Well, even today, i have played video games with female gamers, some have beaten cause they were better at the game, but they seem to think its a humiliation to be beaten by a girl......what i said, silenced her and laughed at by other players in voice chat, i said 'are you implying that girls are worse than boys at video games?' and she said no, but then i said, 'then why would i be embarrassed to be beaten by a girl?' the others laughed and agreed and she just left.....it just shows, the most bigoted people are the ones that complain about bigotry so verbally loud.
@@lithari1480 look,it was said in Friends season 3 ep 9 all the way back in late 90s by Monica, we all grew up on it. Boys and men also keep using this phrase constantly to humiIiate each other. Boys tell other boys ha ha, you got beat up by a girl. Ted Mosby's son literally mocks his father for it in How I Met Your Mother, season 1. it's all around, in every real life group and every fictional TV show for decades. a "gamer girl" is clearly just repeating what her family,school and society is teaching her. she's using "you lost to a girl" as a phrase bcs she hears it everywhere she goes. Boys do it to. like all the time.
Women make better warriors anyway...they are generally more determined brutal and fearless...just look at girls in a street fight.they never bluff or back out
you wont see this comment but i have been just binge watching all your videos they are bringing me so much comfort right now, your commentary is amazing keep doing what you do love i hope everyday for you is the best!
I like your reaction good job. Your observations were on point, and compared to others, well, even though you probably don’t know much about Chinese history or culture, your comments were respectful and not frivolous, understanding that it is not your culture and only judge by non Chinese standards. Others seem to comment and thing ancient China should be like modern times culture. Thank you. FYI, the legend of Mulan is kinda legendary, there wasn’t a historical Mulan although there are a few Chinese woman who gained fame in war that most likely inspired the legend. Kinda like Robin Hood.
The fact that Mulan was told to go home but she refused, I think at that point it was more than trying to keep her family’s name respected, it was her trying to prove herself that she’s worth it
Exactly. She has always had that drive, to prove herself, but she signed up for the war so her father would be safe. But afterwards, she knew that it was much more. It was about proving herself and she knew she was the only thing that could save China from the Huns. Shang didn't heed her warning about Shan Yu. But she persisted because she knew her ability and she knew she could save the Emperor. She didn't need others to tell her she could do it. She just did it. And I think that's amazing.
the fact that the song "A girl worth fighting for" is played right before they see their first instance of the aftermath of war. and they see a burnt down village with a doll left behind and finally realize the girls they are really fighting for.
The singing voice of Mulan is Lea Salonga, a Disney legend from the Philippines, who also provided the singing voice for princess Jasmine! She’s the genius behind the song “A Whole New World” ❤️
Fact: the dog's name is Little Brother is a nod to the original legend. In ond of the versions Mulan did have a brother, but he was too young and could not join the army
Xiran Jay Zhao did a really good video examining the cultural and historical accuracy of both this version and the live action remake, and it's really interesting if you like learning that kind of thing
There are two theories I like about the great stone dragon not waking up. Either the great stone dragon was by her side all this time (the sword had the great stone dragon's face) or that Mulan herself was the great stone dragon and thus proved herself the strongest. Both are theories I love.
I like the theory of Mulan herself being the great dragon, since the sword is only _one_ dragon image that you see throughout her "transformation", specifically in a flash right before you see her face in the reflection of the blade. To me all of that points to the theory of it being her. 🙂
To answer your question of how old Mulan's father is: the historical Mulan's father was roughly 40 when she was born. That means he's pushing 60, which makes fighting in a war a death sentence. Sure, 60 isn't much by today's standards - people at the gym I work out at are older than that - but in that era? A disabled man in his 60's? He would have been killed. Mulan knows that, and that's why she decides she'll do this. And that's always been touching to me. My dad was older than hers when I was born, so I know a loving dad is a treasure and you have to value them while you have them - and I'd enlist for him if I had to, no question.
I love this movie so much! It's been one of my favorite movies since I was little. There are a couple historical inaccuracies though. One of the biggest being that the people we call the Huns in modern times never actually attacked China. The people that would have most likely attacked would have been the Mongolians or other Nomadic peoples who lived close to the Chinese borders. Another big inaccuracy is that Mulan was discovered early on and quit the army after that one war. In the original poem of Mulan she is in the army for over a decade and rose to the rank of general without ever being discovered.
I'm going to g make a guess based on your cadence, and the background: You're either a shrink or a early childhood educator. (And now to check if your channel info will support either of those.)
I had a real nice Sunday watching this! Favorite parts were probably the cheering along to Mulan climbing the pillar, you 100% knowing Cri-Kee was being a typewriter in that one scene, and your acknowledgement when the troops find that ravaged village in the pass that they're the *reserve troops* . Thanks for making my morning a little happier!
First time watching, and I loved your reaction! I'm so happy you were able to leave in snippets of the music without being demonetized (hopefully). This is probably my favorite Disney film, it's perfect bottom to top.
If nobody else has specifically said this, watch Mulan's "transformation" scene again and pay close attention to how many times you see dragon imagery throughout the sequence, particularly the flash of the dragon hilt on the sword just before you see Mulan's reflection in the blade. It all points to Mulan being the Great Stone Dragon herself, the protector of the Fa family. It's also why the stone dragon statue crumbled when Mushu went to wake it up - there was nothing TO wake up because the dragon was within Mulan.
One of my oldest friends of 30+ years who I've known since we were both six years old came out as trans in the last few years, and the song "Reflection" is apparently a pretty widely meaningful song for trans folks for obvious reasons. I had never made that connection before but now that it's been shown to me, I think it's beautiful. 💜
That’s really amazing reaction, As a Chinese girl, Mulan has been always our excellent example for us to protect our country, we are always taught to be a superwoman like Mulan.
I heard that at least some people from the Chinese audience were unhappy with the hair cutting scene, because, apparently, the soldiers used to keep their hair long, and cutting it was a sacrilege, not what in some Western places people tend to think: a new beginning, a new self. The producers did not take that VERY important fact into account. Disney makes movies of several different places and cultures on Earth, but always from a Western point of view, so is it really inclussive? By the way, I am sure that many people complained about the Live Action movie, that it didn't have some of the most epic moments of the 1998 movie, like the hair cutting scene, and many other complaints. The elimination of that scene for me is a point for the Live Action. Now, taking into account that for me Mulan also has a Western POV, let's move on to the next point. I noticed that, when Mulan dresses as a male soldier to save her father and China, the audience doesn't complain about it (as they shouldn't). But, when the boys dress as concubines to save China is usually taken as a joke by the audience. They all dress up as concubines safe Shang. I know he is general and that his face is very well known, but the the boys put some fancy dresses and make up on, and they change their voice, and it works. In my opinion, the producers didn't want to "put at risk" the "macho-man" figure of general Li Shang, who by the way, is the love interest of our protagonist. So, of course, she ends up with the "real man". So, does Mulan really change our perspective on gender roles? Don't get me wrong, I feel an emotional attachment to this movie. I certainly do NOT want to ruin this movie to anyone, but if what I say has some kind of truth to it, I think we should question to what extent is this and many other movies really inclussive and revolutionary.
Amazing reaction! If you loved this film, I think you would enjoy the live action version of it. There is a stage adaption for schools to perform, although I hope they will do a full musical adaptation for Broadway. 🎎👩🏻🐲🪭⚔️🎇🎆❤️💛
@@idk-ye7ur the only criticism I had for the LAR Mulan was that they should’ve incorporated some of the songs as background music and that the Phoenix should’ve been a dragon to subtly represent Mushu. However I understood the Phoenix representation with Mulan’s Journey.
“How many men do you think it takes to deliver a message?”
“One.”
Most cold blooded villain line in a Disney movie ever.
Maureen: ... and its going to be really sweet and some cute animals ...
10 year old me: "I don't get it?"
20 year old me: "... Oh, now I do 😶"
Something I love is that Shan Yu said “the solider from the mountain” not something like you’re a women? Because the huns had female worriers fighting alongside the men so to him it wasn’t a shock to see a woman fighting
Well, even today, i have played video games with female gamers, some have beaten cause they were better at the game, but they seem to think its a humiliation to be beaten by a girl......what i said, silenced her and laughed at by other players in voice chat, i said 'are you implying that girls are worse than boys at video games?' and she said no, but then i said, 'then why would i be embarrassed to be beaten by a girl?' the others laughed and agreed and she just left.....it just shows, the most bigoted people are the ones that complain about bigotry so verbally loud.
@@lithari1480 look,it was said in Friends season 3 ep 9 all the way back in late 90s by Monica, we all grew up on it. Boys and men
also keep using this phrase constantly to humiIiate each other. Boys tell other boys ha ha, you got beat up by a girl. Ted Mosby's son literally mocks his father
for it in How I Met Your Mother, season 1. it's all around, in every real life group and every fictional TV show for decades. a "gamer girl" is clearly just repeating what her family,school and society is teaching her. she's using "you lost to a girl" as a phrase bcs she
hears it everywhere she goes. Boys do it to. like all the time.
Women make better warriors anyway...they are generally more determined brutal and fearless...just look at girls in a street fight.they never bluff or back out
@@luutsii oh trust me I know about being a girl in a street fight 😂 girls will go literally feral
@@ajandrianjafymusic nature is good to us.we're lucky women are built different
you wont see this comment but i have been just binge watching all your videos they are bringing me so much comfort right now, your commentary is amazing keep doing what you do love i hope everyday for you is the best!
Mulan is my favorite disney princess! The fact that Shang gave her the heart eyes while she was ping is just 🤌🏻💋
bicon Shang
As a FRIEND not romantic
Mulan is not a princess or even royalty
I like your reaction good job. Your observations were on point, and compared to others, well, even though you probably don’t know much about Chinese history or culture, your comments were respectful and not frivolous, understanding that it is not your culture and only judge by non Chinese standards. Others seem to comment and thing ancient China should be like modern times culture. Thank you.
FYI, the legend of Mulan is kinda legendary, there wasn’t a historical Mulan although there are a few Chinese woman who gained fame in war that most likely inspired the legend. Kinda like Robin Hood.
There is a second movie for mulan that takes place after this one if you want to know more of the story
Mushu couldn't awake the great stone dragon at the beginning because he was already awoken in Mulan. She is the dragon that protects her family
Really? 😦
omg so exciteddd
I heard The little girl with doll was the Girl worth fighting for
Have you seen Gulliver's Travels from 1939? That is an animated musical film that came two years after Snow White.
No, I haven't heard of that version; wow, that was a long time ago! Thanks for the recommendation 😊
You should check out the sequel of mulan 2.
The fact that Mulan was told to go home but she refused, I think at that point it was more than trying to keep her family’s name respected, it was her trying to prove herself that she’s worth it
Exactly. She has always had that drive, to prove herself, but she signed up for the war so her father would be safe. But afterwards, she knew that it was much more. It was about proving herself and she knew she was the only thing that could save China from the Huns. Shang didn't heed her warning about Shan Yu. But she persisted because she knew her ability and she knew she could save the Emperor. She didn't need others to tell her she could do it. She just did it. And I think that's amazing.
the fact that the song "A girl worth fighting for" is played right before they see their first instance of the aftermath of war. and they see a burnt down village with a doll left behind and finally realize the girls they are really fighting for.
That sudden transition is also the moment the film ceased to be a musical. Girl Worth Fighting For is the last number in the whole movie.
The singing voice of Mulan is Lea Salonga, a Disney legend from the Philippines, who also provided the singing voice for princess Jasmine! She’s the genius behind the song “A Whole New World” ❤️
The singing was so beautiful. Thank you for telling me about Lea and thank you for watching with me! 🤗
yep. I love her! Any theatre nerd would know who she is.
Fact: the dog's name is Little Brother is a nod to the original legend. In ond of the versions Mulan did have a brother, but he was too young and could not join the army
"Don't fight dirty,"
You sounded like a fun auntie.
Lol I definitely had fun watching this movie! Thank you for watching!😊
Xiran Jay Zhao did a really good video examining the cultural and historical accuracy of both this version and the live action remake, and it's really interesting if you like learning that kind of thing
I love that after they find the girl to truly fight for (the child), there is no further singalong music and a tonal shift.
There are two theories I like about the great stone dragon not waking up.
Either the great stone dragon was by her side all this time (the sword had the great stone dragon's face) or that Mulan herself was the great stone dragon and thus proved herself the strongest. Both are theories I love.
I like the theory of Mulan herself being the great dragon, since the sword is only _one_ dragon image that you see throughout her "transformation", specifically in a flash right before you see her face in the reflection of the blade. To me all of that points to the theory of it being her. 🙂
your reactions are always fun to watch
To answer your question of how old Mulan's father is: the historical Mulan's father was roughly 40 when she was born. That means he's pushing 60, which makes fighting in a war a death sentence. Sure, 60 isn't much by today's standards - people at the gym I work out at are older than that - but in that era? A disabled man in his 60's? He would have been killed. Mulan knows that, and that's why she decides she'll do this. And that's always been touching to me. My dad was older than hers when I was born, so I know a loving dad is a treasure and you have to value them while you have them - and I'd enlist for him if I had to, no question.
One of my favorite Disney movies. Back when Disney took risk and were for both adults and kids.
I love this movie so much! It's been one of my favorite movies since I was little. There are a couple historical inaccuracies though. One of the biggest being that the people we call the Huns in modern times never actually attacked China. The people that would have most likely attacked would have been the Mongolians or other Nomadic peoples who lived close to the Chinese borders. Another big inaccuracy is that Mulan was discovered early on and quit the army after that one war. In the original poem of Mulan she is in the army for over a decade and rose to the rank of general without ever being discovered.
One of my favorite 2D Disney movies!
@Cio Lake Such an amazing movie! Love Maureen's reactions as always ❤️
Mulan is no joke my fave disney princess. None of the others come close
Eddie Murphy is so iconic, my favorite parts of the movie are his lines
"I'll Make a Man Out of You" is a favorite of mine. Sang by Donny Osmund! Mulan 2 is worth a watch at some point, IMO! :)
17:57 a girl worth fighting for
You know you’ve done something right when the Emperor himself gives you a “You bow to no one” scene.
I'm going to g make a guess based on your cadence, and the background: You're either a shrink or a early childhood educator. (And now to check if your channel info will support either of those.)
Neither! 😊
@@ScreenMaureen Thanks for the reply. I am surprised.
Really enjoyed this reaction and loved your commentary! Mulan is one of Disney’s best. ❤️
Glad you enjoyed it WanderingRoe! 🤗❤️
I had a real nice Sunday watching this! Favorite parts were probably the cheering along to Mulan climbing the pillar, you 100% knowing Cri-Kee was being a typewriter in that one scene, and your acknowledgement when the troops find that ravaged village in the pass that they're the *reserve troops* . Thanks for making my morning a little happier!
First time watching, and I loved your reaction! I'm so happy you were able to leave in snippets of the music without being demonetized (hopefully). This is probably my favorite Disney film, it's perfect bottom to top.
If nobody else has specifically said this, watch Mulan's "transformation" scene again and pay close attention to how many times you see dragon imagery throughout the sequence, particularly the flash of the dragon hilt on the sword just before you see Mulan's reflection in the blade. It all points to Mulan being the Great Stone Dragon herself, the protector of the Fa family. It's also why the stone dragon statue crumbled when Mushu went to wake it up - there was nothing TO wake up because the dragon was within Mulan.
One of my oldest friends of 30+ years who I've known since we were both six years old came out as trans in the last few years, and the song "Reflection" is apparently a pretty widely meaningful song for trans folks for obvious reasons. I had never made that connection before but now that it's been shown to me, I think it's beautiful. 💜
That’s really amazing reaction, As a Chinese girl, Mulan has been always our excellent example for us to protect our country, we are always taught to be a superwoman like Mulan.
Love your reaction!!!
Will you react to Snow White please?
Best Disney movie
id love to see you react to atlantis or treasure planet 💖
💜
:)
Mulan > Tarzan
Mulan 1998.
Not gonna lie, I thought she was the vegan teacher 😅
I heard that at least some people from the Chinese audience were unhappy with the hair cutting scene, because, apparently, the soldiers used to keep their hair long, and cutting it was a sacrilege, not what in some Western places people tend to think: a new beginning, a new self. The producers did not take that VERY important fact into account. Disney makes movies of several different places and cultures on Earth, but always from a Western point of view, so is it really inclussive? By the way, I am sure that many people complained about the Live Action movie, that it didn't have some of the most epic moments of the 1998 movie, like the hair cutting scene, and many other complaints. The elimination of that scene for me is a point for the Live Action.
Now, taking into account that for me Mulan also has a Western POV, let's move on to the next point. I noticed that, when Mulan dresses as a male soldier to save her father and China, the audience doesn't complain about it (as they shouldn't). But, when the boys dress as concubines to save China is usually taken as a joke by the audience. They all dress up as concubines safe Shang. I know he is general and that his face is very well known, but the the boys put some fancy dresses and make up on, and they change their voice, and it works. In my opinion, the producers didn't want to "put at risk" the "macho-man" figure of general Li Shang, who by the way, is the love interest of our protagonist. So, of course, she ends up with the "real man". So, does Mulan really change our perspective on gender roles?
Don't get me wrong, I feel an emotional attachment to this movie. I certainly do NOT want to ruin this movie to anyone, but if what I say has some kind of truth to it, I think we should question to what extent is this and many other movies really inclussive and revolutionary.
Amazing reaction! If you loved this film, I think you would enjoy the live action version of it. There is a stage adaption for schools to perform, although I hope they will do a full musical adaptation for Broadway.
🎎👩🏻🐲🪭⚔️🎇🎆❤️💛
That would be spectacular!
Isn't the live action worse in almost every aspect? At least in the writing it is, then i heard the chinese representation sucks too.
@@idk-ye7ur the only criticism I had for the LAR Mulan was that they should’ve incorporated some of the songs as background music and that the Phoenix should’ve been a dragon to subtly represent Mushu. However I understood the Phoenix representation with Mulan’s Journey.