'Modi govt is changing rural India, they are spending differently from MGNREGA era'
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 มี.ค. 2024
- There's a gradual change taking place in rural India and it's showing itself in eating habits, travel behaviour, and access to basic amenities. This change has insights for both the government and companies, Deputy Editor TCA Sharad Raghavan explains in #StandardDeviation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our TH-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
I recently bought an AC in my home in village through Flipkart which did not had electricity 10 years ago.
Great , which village and state please
My village got electricity, tap water, water for irrigation about 50 year ago.
LPG to water
Road to Airport
School to Hospital
Modi govt is not fair leaving no work for our youth leader RaGa to do when he will become PM in next 15 /20 years hopefully
No Democracy 😢
@@SPrabhakar this is not good for India. All your work mentioned will destroy India
😂😂
Nice one
What about that machine to covert potato to gold?
😂😂 lovely 🌹
Full vote for dictatorship
We'll vote for the dictator again and again till he retires and will continue to vote to whomever is identified by him forwarding his legacy
sums up accurately why every corner of the country currently is under modi wave....great insights and good reporting
Growth of two wheeler in last 2 year outpaced other vehicle, which is big benchmark of rural income growth
Heard of Nehruvian economists like rancham guha.. u sound like pappuvian economist😂
Explains the support this govt ia receiving in elections.
Never expected this from Print
Aaj print ko kya hogaya, modi ki tareef kaise kardi 😂
Paisa aaya hoga
@@highplatform1649 haa INDI alliance ka to account hi band kar diya😂
nda ne diya hoga@@Ayush_Vikram
They tried their level best to find fault from insignificant corners neglecting glaring achievements, now as they are losing subscribers and people watching, they are outwardly changi. Inside they are the same old anti Modi, anti BJP, anti Hindu and finally anti India...they are a part of the toolkit supported by Christian missionaries, jihadis...
@@highplatform1649syad Congress se paisa aana bnd ho gya ho😅
Such good data points and insights. We need more of such videos. Kudos to Sharad and the team !
This is really appreciable about The Print, they show both the sides as fairly as one can today.
Keep up the good work, folks !
Pleasant surprise from Print
Airport share of the bigger airports is falling... ppl in bigger cities are spending on better cars, and opting for travels by road, which is more economical for families with more than 4 ppl. Also since big city lives are busy, ppl see it a good way for family bonding. This also validates the road infrastructure that went through an overhaul and ppl of India are completely in awe of the countryside beauty.
Print is so reluctant to give credit to Modi govt, this is a rare admission
I think Print is the most neutral media currently available in the mainstream. If you look at Times Now, NDTV always praising Modi and if you look at Newslaudry, Quint always bashing Modi, undermine or hide India's GDP, hide Sandeshkhali, hide Peaceful's peaceful activities like UP double murder, Bengaluru Shopkeeper beating etc. But Print try to present both sides, but it is true that sometimes they invite some radical Andh Vidrodi also.
True 😂
The Print has always given credit where due. You people were busy watching that shit Republic TV.
@@rajx7120 you r a waitress worshipper
bhakts should watch only godi media like republic tv zee news and ramon magsaysay winner anchors like sudhir chaudhary , arnab goswami to jerk their modi daddy
Yes there is a marked change in the income levels of the rural folk.(its a crime to say rural poor in south India at least ). In My village today every household owns at least one two wheeler. Many own a car. The best part of the two wheeler revolution in villages is that they use it to improve their productivity in agriculture. The two wheeler enables them to reach the farm in lesser time than what they would spend on walking to work. They use the two wheeler to transport fertilizer, farm products to and fro from their farm and fields and market. 90% of them use tractors, farming equipment and back hoe loaders for agricultural purposes, reducing the dependence on farm animals. Every village in India has more than 1 JCB. Most of the villages have RO water facilities and the current trend is for families installing RO machine in their homes. 90 % of the homes are concrete buildings and other on the way to transition from thatched homes. 100 % homes own a TV set. more than 50% own refrigerator. They use the refrigerator two store milk and other farm produce. 80% of them send their children to convent schools in nearby towns. (A big failure on part of the government that it could not or does not want the transformation of education sector, which could have been the real game changer in the rural India. This can increase the farmers income 10times.). They use Autos to travel to work outside their village during their free time. The average consumption of Chicken and mutton in villages has gone up phenomenally , maybe what explains the drop in consumption of staples.
And you can see the real development of villages and the role education plays during festival times when the children come back to their native places without fails. The joy and pomp visible in their celebrations tell a lot about the rural change.
The last but not the least change in huge jump in the consumption of liquor in villages which quantifies the rise in their income levels.
Quite true. I see the similar improved villages aorund our township.
Surprised to have a good reporting from print, any how very fine change of rural india, full credit to our modi ji🙏
That is called death of democracy,power of godi media
How Modi govt. has helped people in start taking flights....absolutely crazy. Simply the youth in families of rich farmers want an urban lifestyle
Thank you Print for these facts presented.
We should be proud and thank government for uplifting the lowest strata of our society. 😊
print what has happened to u bro😂
Modi Govt should give us a tax cut after the election. It will kick off investment.
Andh Namazi and Khalistani farmers will shout more ferociously then.
PM's economic advisor had given a good explanation on this in an interview. Their main target now is to onboard more direct tax(Income tax payers)....and once they see this trend of new tax payer coming up at the pace they wanted then only income tax cuts can be announced slowly and gradually
can u plz forwardme the link ,where the economic advisor has said this@@Sourav_2k03
Yes. Petrol Tax cut can be done, by either reducing MSP expense, or by handing MSP to the states.
Then states with good common sense, would not do any MSP purchase, and instead allow money to stay with people, and allow market based supply-chain in agriculture to improve.
@@rajx7120 Petrol tax cut is a bad idea .. better to use it on non-renewals and EV's , lower GST on EVs
The iron rule #1 of economics still rules:
Government subsidies for consumers create shortages.
Government subsidies for producers create wasteful surpluses.
Push subsidies to inventors or unique deep tech startups@@SPrabhakar
Ha ye sach hai. Mere gaon me bhi aisa hai. Road, Railway aur electricity to bilkul renew ho gaya hai. Tap water to nahi manga phir bhi mila hai. Solar panel bhi. 😊
4:00 processed and packaged food is destroying humanity and most don't even realise it.
yeah, the west and japan + south korea has been ruined. We should learn from their mistakes
from the point of Economics, it is good. Processed and packaged foods can be bought if you have some extra money. It may be even Re. 1, but that Re. 1 is still circulated, not stagnant.
❤ that's a great development so succinctly compiled. But Sharad you must at times smile too 😊
Thanks to The Print and the presenter for bringing out this data
Good!! Great analysis! The 2nd and 3rd layer of Journos in The Print is solid and Shekhar Gupta Ji is building a great legacy!! Very happy to see this!
Praising and criticising both whenever required ...that's called unbiased journalism...
At last THE PRINT said truths about 49% of their content..
UDAN is modis magic ❤❤❤
Actually families like ours who earlier used to eat out are switching to traditional fire wood-earthenware slow cooked foods. If income levels of rural India increase, their expenses on essentials come, then it is a good sign. Eating packaged food, taking carbonated beverage and unwanted travel are not. They are health hazard and dent their packets.
The name "Standard deviation" clearly describes the content that can be expected from you. Your videos truly live up to the name!
Thank you for the video
Great positive story about rural India!
Good explanation
Hello, I met you on CTC, you were awesome bro, love n hugs. And "Standard Deviation" that is a dope name bro
Sir, can you please share link to the data so that I can do more research on the topic
Regards,
Researcher
Idea and plan of congress is simple...keep Indians poor..promise to give them 1000 rs a month and some food and congress will keep winning...abuse corporates in front of people but secretly make deals with them
its time people familiarise with what to trust, when to trust and whom to trust, why to trust, Trust, honesty and community living exists in rural india even today. Food and water security are two essentials which can stir up a revolution if mismanaged or misreported. It would be worthwhile for presenters to provide graphs or charts on a relative basis covering every ten years so that communities can understand where they are today. from 100 taps to 1000 taps does not mean much if the covered population expanded from 15000 to 20000 in the same period. producing content which makes sense easily is tough , expensive and time consuming but its worth it as it gives population a chance to focus on things that matter.
Excellent analysis
Bro is trying so hard to give credit where it's due😂
Most importantly we should accept that as we travel by road or rail anywhere in India the definitive demarcation between urban and rural communities is diminishing. The houses in rural areas are more or less similar to what you see in cities
As some wise person said Politicians campaign Elections with promises of freebees NOT on critical issues of Basic Quality Education, Basic Health Care, Law&order..
Indian people don't vote on critical issue sad fact
Rural consumption can be affected by logistics too since it is not economical to deliver FMCG goods at remote locations
Love it ❤❤❤
👏👏👏👏👌👌👌👌🌹🌹🌹🌹 lots to achieve
Consumption of greater quantities of packaged food and bottled beverages could be disastrous where healthcare infra is particularly poor. And rising footfall at smaller airports could simply be a result of absence of such airports up until now. Only the airlines can tell whether operations out of such airports are profitable. It's also a stretch to take rising footfall at such airports as an indicator of village folks growing a fondness of flying.
True but in non BJP states still open defecation is active and things are not developing
What a great episode backed with solid data. Would love if you guys continue mining more. As Shekhar says data never lies
Data never lies
Do you actually believe this
There should be better infrastructures,industries and better schools in rural areas aswell.
👌👌👌👌👌
If villagers are spending more on processed foods and dabas and restaurants, diseases like obesity and diabetes will automatically follow like it has done in urban India. The multi nationals that sell processed foods will benefit no doubt !
Your observation on pulses and food grain consumption should only be
Made with an analysis of nutrition. Also the e.
Xsample of rickety bicycle as two wheeler dropping does not take into account the huge increase in motorised 2 wheelers
Even if you impute the cost of free grain into consumption data, it doesn’t change the fact that people hadn’t had to spend that money leaving more on table non grain expenses. So % figure would get skewed even if there is no underlying change in expenditure pattern. Basic data analysis 101.
Food prices have not increase at all in the last 10 years. Less than 50%>
@@SPrabhakar😂😂😂
It has doubled at least.Remember eating thali in 2012 for 30 rupees in delhi.
@@RaviKiran-uq8np buying a thali is luxury item, it shouldn't even count. I'm talking about raw stuff people use to make thir own food.
And you can still get 50 ra thalis if you want.
@@SPrabhakar it's true, woman today can easily make 20k in any of the top 50-100 cities working as house help for less than 8 hours a day.
The truth is that people just don't want to work because of their ego. We all know that the demand for maid is so high any number of them can join and it will still be less than needed.
If you pause at 2:25 - the data for avg monthly expenditure has tripled from 11-12 to 22-23 (11 yrs). Comparing 04-05 to 2009-10 -it had roughly doubled in 5 years. Next, it had grown nearly 40-50% in 2 years to 2011-12 (so keeping pace). By that pace the expenditure should have gone 4 times in 11 years. So isn't it slowing down? Ofcourse for the first time the percentages of somethings will cross some made up point (like food dropping below 50%) but what kind of analysis is this? It is slowly supposed to come down anyway. You should discuss how fast is it falling.
abe tujhe pata nahi hai. Tu world ki fastest growing economy dekh. Major fastest growing economy nahi. Fir agar tu samjhdaar hoga, toh samjhega, ki base is important for calculation based on percentage.
Bro base is very important in perceiving actual growth, 2% of 100 is around 2/3 more than 5% of 25.
Yes you are right
But you should not forget that the increase in spending during 2007 to 2012 was due to high double digit inflation which touched almost 12 % in 2010,
Therefore the increase in spending during that period was unsustainable... And if you rationalise the inflation it would be very low
@@Sanatan_Rastra yes I agree, there is nominal growth and real growth which also includes the effects of inflation
@9:02 you mentioned Bengaluru which is truly a wrong picture. Every house has a water connection in BBMP limits enough for 2 families of 8 members in 1200 sq. feet plot or 4 families of 16 members in 2400 sq. feet space - ideal case, but due to Developers greed , a 2400 sq. feet plot now 16 houses 64 members at least 4 times more ( some even 108 members ). Hence they depend on borewell in addition to piped water. Borewell water can supplies 70% of Apartment needs with Piped water covering the rest . This is in a small Apartment case. In Large apartments with 700 households that are entirely dependent on Borewell water and very less piped water or no piped water and they depend on tankers as they collect Maintenance amount at 5 Rs - 8 Rs. per sq.ft area of apartment..So if rains fail this is bound to happen . In addition catchment areas and storage areas have now been concretized allowing no water seepage..It is not as if Jal Jeevan mission failed , it is just that Jal Jeevan could not meet the needs of greed... Please take this input ..No offense meant
Modi govt has done very good work in most of the sectors.However I feel they have to do much better work in health and education sector.Hope on Modi.3.0 they will concentrate much more on these sectors.
I feel much of the free rations (not as many are needy as being made out)are being encashed to spend on processed food and travel. It seems just as rations are distributed a trader follows to collect it with cash.
Probably listen to what he said Mr Consultant?
Hi Sharad, I am MBA finance and having 15 years exp in stock markets in Bangalore. Recently completed a course in data analytics. Interested in working with you for data analytics. Would like to here from you.
I live in semi urban india... We have got govt water taps more than a year back but don't know when will we get water😅... Hopefully other states are actually providing water on ground.
The biggest paradigm shift change is that women don’t want to cook. I am buying Zomato shares.
Yes continuous increasing toll gas price 1:18
Decrease in cereal consumption is good and an increase in processed food consumption is good? In which corrupt world?
He is talking about spending not the absolute Consumption.
@@AbhinavSingh-gn4se spending anything on processed food is not a positive sign. The trend will only increase
This explains POPULARITY of Modi. No wonder he'll win another 350+ mandate.
How are people able to afford all this without employment?
" A section of rural Indians"... How big is that section?
True bhaiya ...i have saw the darstic change in my village too , i have never thought of that people will spend on A/C over here ...but i have seen major infra devlopment and change in expenditure range
India needs to de-urbanize. Our approach to development shouldn't be urbanization. There's too many problems with current approach. Government should support work from home, make rural land more usable, focus on basic necessities (which includes internet and fast connectivity). India has a lot of land but ofcourse we can't afford to be densely populated, more and more Indians are living in shity conditions in mega cities because they have to work there. If we crack progress with de-urbanization we can become one of the most beautiful place on planet
Well said. Though it should not be done by following Gandhian Socialism.
@@puneetmishra4726 totally agree, Gandhian Socialism is incredible naive and short sighted
so much doubts inserted accepting official data ..theprint approach ?
Tribal communities in India have faced historical marginalization and lack of recognition. Factors include limited access to education, healthcare, and employment opportunities, leading to socio-economic disparities. Additionally, issues like displacement due to development projects and inadequate representation in decision-making processes contribute to their marginalized status.
600 Eklavya model residential schools have been opened by the Modi govt's tribal ministery, which will run like Navodaya Vidyalaya but for tribal students. And they have just recently appointed 10,000 people staff in these schools. Which were recruited via exams last year.
Something so magnificent is being done on the ground yet you refuse to see it. Blindness caused by Modi hatred.
@@SunilKumar-nf7ft
School manufacture andhbhakts?
@@mg.f.9023 I am getting same doubt after seeing you. You have also studied in school right?
he studied in madarasa@@saikumarmadadi7524
Tribal communities have not faced any historical marginalization as they have not been part of society because of their own volition.
Sir, does this mean we are now a developed country?
Electricity, tap water, happening 75 years after independence..🙏
I will suggest you to go to any village in eastern up or Bihar and see the consumptions by your own.
The mistake made by "Analysts living in cities" are almost always wrong.
Either you will see few data and paint some Rosy picture or some doomsday announcement. Neither will be correct.
Will give you one simple example -
If a family has 2 children then they are giving them Maggie, soup, momo, bread, etc.
This is not coming from some extra income or prosperity but from free grains savings, free money by state or central government,etc.
It is not an actual income and it is painting a false picture.
Also, people are consuming less Daal, meat or egg. If you check it properly,you will see that it is bcz if lack of money and it is causing malnutrition.
Maggie is cheap food to fullfill the belly.
Anyone sensing investment opportunity here . . . Micro finance concentrating only rural women? FMCG selling packed food to majorly to rural India? Anything else, please reply.
This video is just to give illusion of neutral journalist , all of the next videos will be pro Congress and anti modi. Don't be fool guys
Manrega should be redirected to clean villages
Its easy as hell
Jai ho Modiji
media hi to he kab badal jay pta nahi chalta
If print editors praises Modi govt. then oppositions are really really bad 😮
Suraj Pashchim se Uday hua tha aaj Pratkal main
Now pappu chamchas will say this journalist is a sanghi and andh bhakth..🤣🤣. The real andh bhakths are pappu andh chamchas..😂😂😂
and also they say it is godi media. But anyways shekhar gupta is a master boot licker and as* licker of pappu.
Good news 😁
Safety of Democracy is more important than development , afterten years there will bring development if Modi govt. or not credited does not go to Modi, the actual development will be measured from GDP, and GSDP our growth rate are going down and down
Not sure how eating processed food is a good news? While it may show increased income but it will lead to lower quality of health and may increase health expenditure
The report is about increased rural income not about health. pl understand.
what about INR devaluation? did you account for that in your data.. look at the inflation.. look at the drop in savings rate across all classes.. remove the atta daal 'freebi'/revari scheme and see how people sink
MANREGA is not gold standard. Why are you wasting your (and others') time
Humes party shud change their strategy now rural areas hv cars n bikes
They dnt wan subsidy now wan ferari or SUV😂
This is dangerous data. People are becoming lazy, moving away from healthy diet and chosing junk food.
Atleast the villagers were healthy and sturdy, now they're also succumbing to unhealthy lifestyle especially food.
Other things are desirable but food habits is concerning.
Modi giving every household free grain is considered adopted corruption buying vote or popularity.
Modi government should find solutions to upgrade the living standards income of rural by implementing modern agriculture and infrastructure to the villages as wise person say teach them to fish better them give them fish to eat
They will be forever being poor in rural areas without any modernize and infrastructure to connect city
don't make such videos of praising modi government. I am a liberal and i feel offended by such videos.
Sach kadwa hota hai
@@omvishwakarma9253sarcasm kar raha thaa wo 😂😂😂
Print has to give credit to Modi government, though reluctantly and after adding lots of ifs and buts..😂😂
How is eating junk food a welcome move?
Sure, be happy that even the healthcare sector will do well. Dude, I am really shocked that you’re happy that people are not eating at home and that condescending statement on the Roti. What’s wrong with people. What is healthier question, eating out and process food?
bik gaya hai print. Yeah sab Modi Shah ki saazish hai
😂
😂
Far out 😒 this guy reminds me of myself as a 12 year old how I had to read my English essays in front of my class. Good content, however please work on your oratory skills 🙏🏽
Since when is moving away from healthy home made dal roti chawal to proceesed junk food progress????😅
Progress is accounted for by increase in income and aviailability of options. Earlier even the option was not available.
Jai jai modi
Modi is a corrupt dictator, stop sucking his dick
Thanking our very great PM Modi ji soon there will be toilets outside city centers! jai Hind!!
then you don't have to sit on railway lines.@@user-pv2xy1og8h
Data Suspicious.
Your comment itself is suspicious. 😂
Thanking our very great PM Modi ji soon there will be toilets outside city centers! jai Hind!!
National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) report published end 2023.
The report showed that in 2022, India saw 11,290 suicides in the farming sector, a 3.75 per cent rise from the 10,881 suicides reported in 2021.
You do realise that our population also grew in the period!
@@MohitKumar-nc6kt
I Know Adani grew for sure😂
Amount received?
When your own media does not spew your narrative just say " amount received "or godi media😢😢 😂😂😂
When the truth is uncomfortable let's label it as "Godi Media". But meanwhile we remain chancha.
You are right the print is godi media
2 Rs
Poor print is coninuously trying to boost modi better ask subramania swami
These figures don't corroborate with sales figures of the auto & FMCG companies. Assembly lines of the cars in the small segment are drying up
But two wheeler sales are increasing. The discussion is more about people who can buy two wheelers not cars
Yes genius becuase a, overall car sales are increasinsg, b, small car options have become limited and most importantly small cars are now well in touching distance of entry level bigger cars - Compare prices of Alto K10 and Wagon R Base model - why will people choose smaller can when they get bigger car for same money minus a few features like stereo, steering mounted controls and cruise control.
😂😂😂😂 Clowns
The definition of rural is the reason why the government data is made to look so good. There is no credibility.
Yeh but different way creating religious disturbances and causing deaths of lower caste peoples😮