Inside the solution to India's waste problem | Brut Documentary
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 พ.ค. 2024
- Brut wanted to find a solution to the waste problem in Indian cities. But, when we went to the country's cleanest city, we came back with more questions than answers.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Brut India is the fastest-growing digital video publisher in the country. We're a young, independent platform producing compelling journalism in new formats.
You can also find us here:
Facebook: / brutindia
Instagram: / brut.india
Twitter: / brutindia
Snapchat: Brut India
Snapchat: Brut India Stories
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA W2D4 | Summer | โอกาสสุดท้าย ของสัปดาห์สอง](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/aswciGrYovo/mqdefault.jpg)
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA W2D3 | Summer | ไม่อยากเหนื่อยวันเสาร์ ก็ต้องจัดเต็ม](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CbsHmoJXjvE/mqdefault.jpg)
I am from Indore and i am surprised why other bigger cities are unable to achieve all this
i have seen the transformation from my own eyes and it has been super smooth
and here we are 6 times cleanest city in India
The mindset of people very much imp. as well as the management after that. Jb tk hum ghar aur bahaar ko ek jesa nhi samjhenge treat nhi krenge tb tk kooda bahaar hi dikhega. Log iss cheez pe to bhaut imphasize krte h ki ghar saaf rakho laxmi aayegi pr bahaar ka kya ussko bhul jaate h.
Serious answer:
1. Because India has systematically chosen student politics and representational politics(caste/religion/region) over mayoral politics. City politics becomes the place where you earn funds for the regional or national party's ambitions. So the person chosen by the parties isn't there to work. True for all parties including AAP.
2. The reason Indore is earning money is mostly through a fixed price biogas contract with the govt bus agency. Biogas is still a pollutant and many cities have opted for electric buses instead. Profits are not guaranteed.
3. Every city has its own unique economics. Thanks to the movie Nayak, most Indians think politics is all about socially conscious problem solving. It is more like a decision tree with several unintended consequences. Some other city may come up with a model where they incinerate all trash and sell the residues for recovery of heavy metals like the Japanese and Singaporeans do.
@@rutvikrs god damn it indian boy
@@rutvikrsI would not include AAP in this, they are doing massive amount of good work in cities currently.
@@TheUndertaker2408 I was with IAC in a significant consultant role and know people from inside the party. If you think AAP is any different in its functioning and outcomes than a regional party, then you have never been in one of their high level meetings.
1. No party can function purely on electoral bonds, volunteers and public donations, even the BJP. Canvassing costs a huge chunk. Social media, psephology and ad strategy to keep newspapers/tv channels in line are added costs. We are talking of a shortfall of 50-100 crs per Delhi election and 500-2000 crs per state election.
2. Any party that wants to be in the game for a long time creates, depending on the size of state/economy, two or ten individuals/families that control companies and a network of people. These loyalists are in charge of fake businesses that get the corrupt money to fund the election machine. Even if you raised 100% of the money clean with a billionaire, there is no way you can achieve network effect and reach the electorate. People don't change their mind after watching a news report or a YT video, they ask a person in their social network. If there is no person to interpret things for them, you will not gain momentum as a party.
3. AAP is also doing these things. They already have "one leader" akin to RaGa and Modi, a central command and are building out a network of supporters and income sources. This is convergent evolution in action.
Even world’s cleanest city , Copenhagen has a landfill site. Probably Indore didn’t want you to show even the smaller landfill site as part of the documentary as it takes away from the good work they are doing but probably it triggered the reporters ego and she just focused on that part as the theme of this documentary.
Journalism is for criticism. So that we can perfect it.
It's not an advertisement.
@@Dr.Kay_R, India has democracy,
India has free press, India is #Dirty
China was Dirty,
China has #None , China #is Clean.
If #criticism had bettered our lives, then India would have had highest GDP, HDI, education, etc etc 😂😂
In any country, 5% waste is not recyclable & not useful.
That will go to landfill in any case.
@@Dr.Kay_RLandfills in Copahagen and even Singapore are seen as essentials. But Landfills in Indore are seen as an issue. This is a clear case of biased journalism and not journalism for criticism
@@Edward4PlantagenetThat's the waste that should be given to process like pyrolysis and waste to energy plants. But these technologies will always have opposition.
I work at NEPRA, and I can vouch that we, along Indore municipal corporation are solving most of the problems. Not every system is perfect, the landfill here is the tiny fraction of the waste which is difficult to process. But the evident thing is that the city has been clean for 7 years because of 800 Metric Tons of waste being processed DAILY which directly translates to 3,00,000 MT of landfill saved every year.
I mean if every city followed Indore's model, Indian cities will becomes x10 cleaner! But, instead, these journalists try to find faults in it because it is run by the ruling government which is hard for them to digest.
People who litter should be a heavy fine and kept on record for a year. It should be taught in schools not to litter.
I think there is a whole subject called Moral Science taught in schools to educate not to litter. But that has failed to solve the problem. The solution has to come from homes and parents. We learn from our parents and that's how most of the society works.
Totally false they refuse to take my dog shit and other garden waste what we will do if goverment vehicle dont take waste
@@aleemahmed349 you have to start from a generation, thats where schools come into play..japanese children clean their own school...so it has to be practical..you take a bunch of children, give them gloves and clean a certain area .for eg school premises, or playground..thats how you make it a habit to clean your surroundings and not to litter.
@imran khan cover the dog shit with dry garden waste and it'll turn to manure in a few weeks. Use it for better growth of your garden. You'll save on fertilizers and pesticides over time.
@@FreeYourImagination
This not solution if they dont take my waste i will throw it on road because after paying money they are refusing to do their duty
We only think about our own personal hygiene, every household will dust and sweep their homes every single day without fail but will throw litter and garbage outside of their homes without a second thought and this is not just observed in people from low economic standing who don't receive proper education even high income individuals riding their Scorpio and fortuner will throw garbage on the streets. This is a symptom of a deeper issue in the Indian psyche, we think our own people are only our immediate family members and our home to just extend to the perimeter of our residence, what a narrow mind view of the citizens of a civilization which teaches vasudev kutumbakam. We ourselves don't value our nation and our patriotism only comes out on social media. Very shameful
You hit the nail on the head! The average Indian has no environmental sense. They need Public education.
I am living in Indore for last 6 months now. It's not magic or any secret, waste management strategies can workout with commitment. Indore Municipal Corporation and their ground team is absolutely amazing. And Every Indori respects them.
Brut has put click bait to increase views. Coming from other city to work and live here, i can say with absolute sureity that Moral of Indore will never go down. They will come 1st for 7th time...
You team should have visited Rajwada on Rang Panchami...you will understand what i am talking about...
Brut should start with cleaning themselves....
yes Brut team is trying to find negative aspects then they should come and see pune , how bad the waste management is
Nonsense comment without answering the question.
For all the people here, it was not some political party that has led the change, it was the work of qualified IAS officer (who has since been transferred to ujjain) and the hard work of many on ground workers that has made all the change.
Questioning is very easy; doing is altogther different game. Indore has brought behavioural changes in people regarding waste dumping. Indore has done wonderful in waste management. If you want raise question why don't you go and question big waste producing industries and cities like Delhi, banglore etc.
Indore is trying its level best to get to the targets, just because it does not want to bring the morale of the citizens down by getting the landfill (heavily reduced landfill, that is) pics out doesn't mean you can take the credit away by saying the 'corporation is hiding something' just to get views
What is wrong with this video, you can't find a single wrapper on the streets here in indore and instead of adopting this model throughout the country they are worrying about some minor faults. Living here is much better than in any so called metropolitan cities at least for your health and happiness.
What is wrong is your mentality? Journalism doesn't mean advertisement. This isn't a documentary. It's journalism.
JOURNALISM= TO FIND PROBLEMS IN EXISTING SYSTEM
I am very much impressed by the work of indore municipal authority and support of people, we're the mega cities struggles to achive this milestone, I think people of indore must be very proud of there city.... as the most cleanest city of india.. 👏👍
This is the problem with media houses like you, you just start questioning the positivity rather than spreading awareness and appreciating the efforts.
I am from Indore
City is growing too fast and population is increasing, in comparision to your surprise the land fill area has almost vanished. I put this as an achievement, may be they don't want to see even a slightest of dark patches but i am sure Indore Municipal Corporation is working day and night. We shall appreciate this government department working better than a private organisation.
1200 metric tonne waste is generated every day and they have to process it on same day
The reason i shifted to indore was not only for business expansion but for better lifestyle and environment. 6 months and no regrets. I love indore and now a proud indori.
Unnecessary negativity on the internet...
I'm from Indore, and I am proud of what the IMC, people and government has achieved. ❤
I don't know why are @brutindia Defaming Indore, Indore Nagar Nigam is doing an excellent job in their field. I live nearby Devguradiya in Indore and I don't see any misleading Facts in the process. Kindly encourage such cities in India to work Better Day by day instead of playing TRP Game. Thank You a proud INDORI .
Questioning is not synonymous with defaming. Read dictionary
if you dont question you wont improve, and i dont see any defaming, may be change your mindset
Ask yourself what the Indore Municipal Corporation is trying to hide, and why they felt the need to seize Brut’s camera and footage.
@@somnathdas4331 now it is. Glad that he didn't call them anti national
Exactly, achhe ko appreciate karne ke bajaye, tail end par agar residue bach gya hai waste management me, uoose jake khojna hai inhe. Arre learn from the good management first, and other cities, institutes should do the same.
Appreciate ur effort. But, Rather than being detective and sceptical about the municipality, I think we should focus on creating more awareness among schools, colleges, corporates, offices and eventually each house to come up with their own mini waste management models and restrain from using plastic n other non degradable things..
right? she was trying every possible way to give us a negative feeling of this place, taunting the official that "so i`m allowed to film positive side only"? like really? if this a thing to say to anyone?
@@crimsonmatterThanks for your valuable comment.. point noted
@@SBGabbarGamingthat's journalism. Journalism means to criticize the existing system. Not to advertise it.
In Indore you have heavy fines on littering. You have to visit to see the cleanliness.
The report should have ended at 6:10, the video beyond that was total waste of time for the officers and also the viewers.
sahi me,, pehle rules break karo phir pakde jao to blame the officials xD
Congrats Indore !! You are leading India ! May Allah bless you all!
Indore is one of the few cities in India that earns a profit from its waste management. This means that the Indore municipal corporation has converted one of the biggest expense center into a revenue center.
Instead of appreciating the waste management of this beautiful city, why @brut is making a report as if some malpractice is happening? The output of waste management of such a huge city cant be zero, just like that. If some residue is still there and they dont want to show that bad residue, why that is questionable for you? Celebrate what is good, why you want to dig deep in shit? And as the Collector said they are trying to reduce it from 4% to 0% in future dont you have faith on a govt officer? There is no need of unnecessary sting operation.
No critical thinking on your part. You want to see everything in either black or white.
What is stopping other cities from following Indore model?
Budget? Willingness? Politics? Lazyness? or something else?
Because India has systematically chosen student politics and representational politics(caste/religion/region) over mayoral politics. City politics becomes the place where you earn funds for the regional or national party's ambitions. So the person chosen by the parties isn't there to work. True for all parties including AAP.
On top it is willingness second it is budget. Indore gets comparatively increased funding for sustainability. All pilot projects for renewable come to Indore first.
Everything
Ego of ruling govt !!!
Brutindia never keeps his agenda aside😅
I personally found the part digging in the landfill a bit too long, also disrespectful if they already told no video is allowed why to still try with drone? Otherwise it's a great report! ALL governments should start fining people who litter with at least 500 INR... In Rishikesh, Uttarakhand the situation of massive tourism from Surrounding states highly increases the garbage problem. There is an illegal burning ground just next to our home which is unbearable... Hopefully other governments will follow Indore as an example and invest. But people need to also change their attitude! 🙏🏽🕉💐
Brut india❣️Thank you for creating this lovely vdo | So kind of you always, keep it up!
A Huge commendation for Indore, my question is "How do they manage the waste in the rest of Madhya Pradesh?"
This is seriously very sad reporting. No country in the world has such perfect system, and considering India overall we should worship this model. You over educated reporters are criticizing this and breaking the morale of hard working officers
Who told you that it is a 'perfect system'? There is obviously some imperfection in it which the officials were trying to hide.
If they want entire India to follow the 'Indore model', it should be open to scrutiny and testing. It may be some minor thing which may not be a big fault but if you try to hide it, it just looks extremely suspicious.
You seem to be from the category of people who prefer the aam & batua type of journalism which just involves kissing the authorities ass and taking everything they say on face value without using your brain for critical thinking.
Bro, that is understandable, no country can do perfection. But govt just can't lie about the facts. They can't hide information from the taxpayers. We are not in China. Plus reporter ka job hi h ye sab dikhane ka lmao.
See the problem is now a days people are forgetting the basic cause of journalism.. which is to ask questions and show the public the truth.. I understand that in the world of arnab goswami looking for facts has become a myth.. but if a government is not showing full truth to the public then it's a job and ethics of a journalist to dig deeper and find the turth.. a government morale shouldn't break because of criticism.. that's a ridiculous statement.. we are the ones paying taxes we have every right to criticize a government because they are providing a service to the public that's why they are getting paid..
Its the reporters job to seek out truth and clarity, and the municipality is trying to cover up any negative aspects about their waste management process. However i do agree that indore’s municipality is doing a phenomenal job (even if there is something shady going on) that is many times better than anything other indian states have achieved.
@@virenabrol every city have a landfill site, u want to see it? go to ur city landfill site and see, lol @ shady, there`s nothing shady, its just that they dnt want to show u any landfill, (even its at very small portion) , i`ve been to the garden and also planted treed by my own hand, its only one`s perspective if u want to see negative or positive.
we need this waste management in each city and village of India.
If you are so concerned please come to Kerala, Kochi and access yourself. You are just making some unclear observations, as that gentleman rightly said no system is fool proof , but Indore definitely stands out
Yeah Kerala is quite clean during my initial days of visiting Kochi and Thiruvananthpuram I realized that
@@masteroogway9281 don't know where you are from, might be Kerala is better than your place. But the waste management is pathetic
before reaching Kochin railway track you can see so many wastes
Anyone From Indore❤
Thank you 🕯️🍀
That's our Indore's Area 52 🤭😂
😂😂usko kuch masala nhi diye indore waale..
The best part was when you tried to break the rules. I just love it when journalists do it. Keep it up. Don't let the authority get satisfied by what they have done so far, keep pushing them harder. That's what according to me is true journalism.
Amazing work what Indore and MP has done in general. There cannot be perfection per se in such matters and a bit here and there is possible. Also they are doing their best whereas as the world has not even started moving towards better ways.
The reporter here surely in name of reporting everything is trying to downplay the efforts taken by citizen and the government in general. Its very difficult to get people on board plus bureaucrats and politician together on a single initiative. But in general one should not be surprised as such since Brut is backed by investors who are Pro Biden anyways (Media Mogul). So there is going to be bias depending who is ruling the state and center
What matters is the people, of people change then everything is possible, otherwise nothing.
From what i have seen through media, Indore is a model for all the cities in the country.
We need more documentaries covering the Same.
Love from Kerala ❤
I don't litter or don't put waste anywhere, also i pay my municipality every month for collecting waste. It triggers me everytime that it going to end up in landfill, such a shame
I saw the whole video. I really appreciate how Indore is handling its waste management system. Although I am curious why people are not allowed to go to the dump site. If anybody has any answers please let me know.
My assumption
1) there are scavengers including minors at dump sites. You don't wanna show kids scavenging garbage.
2)Already there's a big bad image of India vis-a-vis cleanliness and garbage. It's totally fine for corporations to keep the dirty areas from being filmed.
Wow
Indiana and clean in the same sentence
Every Indian village and city should follow Indore.
Although India is dirty not all regions becaise of people's bad habits....India has still the highest rates of recycling in the entire world....In western countreis they either export it or dump it in the ocean(deep sea water dumping), or huge landfills miles from the cities,which does jot even come in sight of people
Happiness equations, variables and ultimate decision: bang on
bhot masti chad rahi hain brut ko! tum log wohi log ho jo investigative journalism k naam par negativity phailate ho.
Sis can give juz say where these plant is situated and how to got the permission to visit
Its the reporters job to seek out truth and clarity, and the municipality is trying to cover up any negative aspects about their waste management process. However i do agree that indore’s municipality is doing a phenomenal job (even if there is something shady going on) that is many times better than anything other indian states have achieved.
Indore is inspiration flr all city in india if they follow means our govt should follow strictly
लोग तो चाँद मे भी दाग ढूंढ लेंगे। पहले केसा था और अब क्या है बदलाव कितना हुआ ये जरूरी है। सुधार लगातार चलने वाली प्रक्रिया है ।
I google searched and it shows new york and paris as cleanest cities in world, and there cities stinks, though there is no solid waste here and there. I don't know why Indore hasn't got cleanest city in world record.
every indori like me plz show attendance
You had clear instructions to not film then you cry when equipment is seized
Something is better than nothing....most cities in India are in worse conditions
The idea was good bit the reporter was definitely unprofessional.
why dont more city govt collaborate to do this with their own cities? it is not like indore is richer?
Because India has systematically chosen student politics and representational politics(caste/religion/region) over mayoral politics. City politics becomes the place where you earn funds for the regional or national party's ambitions. So the person chosen by the parties isn't there to work. True for all parties including AAP.
They are collaborating. Many cities and developing countries' representatives regularly visit the Indore city. Indore Municipal charge them on per person basis. It is also one of the revenue models of the city.
Please make a video on union carbide factory area...it's still spreading cancer ..and still not clean...#bhopal
The rest of the Indian state, cities, capitals, ward should learn from them
Proud Indori🤗
Look at the Background music 6.50 to 8.50 as if they have unleashed a criminal story. Making a controversy out of nothing . Environmentalist ne bhi beizatti kar di
Indore has accomplished a great city waste management model. Kudos to them. However, even some downsides or negatives should be investigated. Otherwise improvement stops sooner or later. If there is nothing to be ashamed of why stop journalists from filming? It would only create a doubt about something fishy going on, even if it's clearly not the case.
Way to go 👍
Some footage clip are from Gazipur dumping... Side Delhi
Any updates on WTE plants in Telangana?
Wonder why can't all cities, towns can't implement this same??
If mumbai could get a plant like this it would be so much better
Everything about the video: Positive
Reporter's mindset: Negative
Leave Indore. U deserve Delhi and Mumbai.
Two easy ways to Indore people made it the cleanest city:
1. People actually care and do their job
2. People don't forget the rule 1
Meanwhile Mumbai:
Zameen ka kachra maal , samandar me daal.
1% I'm a part of this issue and promise to segregate waste❤
You only have a question of sustainability. Indore has lead the way for all cities to show that they can clear a landfill and recycle all but 4% of the present garbage. Surely that should be a better thing to cover than the fact they didn't allow drone footage on the scientific landfill part. Maybe they are trying to improve that as well. In my opinion it's far better than seeing a waste mountain.
Guys! *Journalism is for criticism.* So that we can perfect our existing system.
*It's not an advertisement.* Change your mentality from godi media! Qnd this isn't a documentary, it's journalism!
Maybe Indoris should visit Chandigarh for once.
I have visited. Have you visited Indore ? The most sad part of Punjab ( except Chandigarh) to me was such a rich state, small state, big cars on roads, dance food language everything inspiring. But people lacking basic Ludhiana Jalandhar are just unbearable..so so dirty. The same people are in Chandigarh..those local markets in every sector you have the bins are filled with discarded stuff and dumped somewhere from where they are picked. There is no concept of big dust bins or dumps within city in Indore. It's picked right from the source and seggregated there and then only. Chandigarh is planned city so you find roads clean because pedestrian is not walking on road for cars and hence no litter. Challenge is when pedestrian cars and cows use the same road. That's what Indore has done. Changing the mindset of people living. I took a bus from Chandigarh bus stand to Dharmshala and beleive me cleanliness was not at all with standard of city like Chandigarh. I did not use the public toilet it was that bad. You can check for yourself if you ever come to Indore. You can point out veg Street food of Indore, poor railways, peculiar tone of speaking. Still manageable.But cleanliness..no bro..seen many cities. No people are so obsessed for that No 1 clean city tag.
I'm in indore❤
How to make a documentary about minor journalistic hurdle, while covering the superior waste management system of a city.
And end up doing the bad job at both of them.
Well if you are looking for such documentaries you have arrived at the right place.
Are aap log positives pe focus karo na yaar. Ab aapki CURIOSITY PIQUE ho gayi toh chota sa probable negative point ho sakta ho usko main point maanke baith jaate ho aur uspe video end kara hai.
Now the Nagar Nigam isn't bound to answer every single question of yours and when your camera was "FORCEFULLY SEIZED", AFTER you were warned that taking videos isn't allowed there, it was YOUR unintelligible decision to continue trying to get the drone footage. Then, when your camera was seized you say IT WAS FORCEFULLY SEIZED.
I do not understand why JOURNALISTS act like they've been dealt with unfairly or act like HUMARE SAATH AISA KAR DIYA. Shaanti pasand nahi hoti
Iske alawa poori report bohot badiya hai. You guys really should learn to balance the positive and the negatives better
Other cities wont be cleaner if people dont have that mindset. When I visited India, I was shocked how people just throw trash on the streets, while I would even hold my cigarette in my hand until I reach an ashtray of a café or a rubbish bin.
Great 😍😍😍.
Wet waste is cng, not clear on plastics, batteries n dry waste.
I have no idea segregating wet waste. What is it, wet paper in wet wet clothes in wet waste, the segregation time is confusing, better is organic and plastic
The thing is municiple is trying but some people want 100 % and they only see negatives.
This is not defaming any city. It is about telling the truth. And uncovering those issues which are not reported which we have to solve. It is good thing you are shedding light on these issues without anyone knowing how can we solve these issue. People who are saying BRUT is wrong or defaming Indore are same people who shove waste under the carpet and show relatives and world look how clean their house is. So to solve anything first you have to know what is wrong
India
vry usefull
atleast they are doing something great, media should support and and be critical at times, I'm staying in Kochi, and the fire at the dumpyard in bhramapuram was the worst any human being should be in, we couldn't breathe properly for a few days, and the Cochin corporation had paid 55crs to a company to manage the plant, and all they did was use petrol and a matchstick to clear the waste
They won't cover it cos Kerala is ruling by a communist government
Indore is way better in managing the waste then other cities. You should not act like detective here.
Journalism is for criticism. So that we can perfect it.
It's not an advertisement.
Why not Implemented all over India???? Under #Strict Clean India ACT
It's not a decision that can be taken at the central level
Sure indore's system may not be perfect but it's the best in India, rather than criticizing it so badly, you should atleast say good stuff also..
It’s a bjp state! 😂
Man I swear Indian left/liberal media would complain even if India surprisingly becomes as clean as Singapore one day
All new plastic products need to be made from 100% recycled materials.
No new single use plastic products should be made. Recycle everything.
Litter is disgusting. Everything need to be recycled.
Manufacturers need to use 100% recycled materials to make new products.
There needs to be a market for recycled materials so they can go back into production.
Quick question. Large rich cities have been unable to set up such programs because of cost. Who is funding this? Indore doesn't generate such tax income to fund such a program
❤❤
My ct🤩
Are you sad that you could not find any negatives? This is media and journalism(#shame)
Show the good things and let the rest of the Indian cities follow the Indore model first and then see how to correct the 5-10% problem with Indore model.
Indore is actually an example that most cities and towns are still lagging behind and should strive for a scientific waste disposal system. Have always trusted Brut, but this scepticism is Not done.
Brut is brute......
South Indians probably crying rn because it isn’t a city from Southern States.
I love it, keep crying like you always do 🗿
9:15 as mr biswas said there will always be minor holes even in the best practices ... seems like the reporter got bit to pissed off from denial to film in the area :) thats why she often tried to put indore in a bad light in this vid haha and im aware journalism is about poiniting out flaws...but this is not how you are supposed to do it
Praying for India 🙏🙏🙏
Prayer doesn't solve a problem. We went to Singapore to learn how they deal with waste
@@bahachoikr, only if more people could understand this.
I AM WASTE.