Luigi's Mansion 3 | Red Review
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ม.ค. 2020
- We finally got another Luigi's Mansion game, and this time without any handheld restrictions. But how is it compered to its predecessors?
Consider supporting me on Patreon
/ theredguy
Hey check out my twitter here
/ redredriguez
Send some love to the blue jerk who drew my character
dr--maniacus.deviantart.com/
Join my Discord server!
/ discord
#LuigisMansion #LuigisMansion3 #Luigi #LM3 #Nintendo #NintendoSwitch #Switch #DarkMoon #Gamecube #GCN #3DS #Review - เกม
Here's something you missed. King Boo doesn't trust Hellen. See how , after saving toad 3, he takes one of the paintings? (Peach's).
He know that Luigi will save Mario and he knows that Mario will run to her. There is some hidden lore in the game
When Mario was first rescued he was acting off, ignoring Luigis concerns and rushing a head of him.
I thought they were setting up a boss fight against King Boo possessing Mario to lure Luigi into an ambush. Wouldve been cool
Glad I'm not the only one that thought that. Mario was definitely acting... odd when you rescued him.
@@WaddleDee105 I guess Mario was desperate to save Peach that he had Luigi come with him (even if it’s a trap)
I thought the same thing.
That would be intresting....
Media: "TH-cam rewind was the most anticipated video all year"
Me:
I actually like Dark Moon the best, mostly for story reasons. Since the Mansion in 1 is cobbled together by the Boos as a trap and the hotel in 3 has been modified by the ghosts to also serve as a trap. The buildings in Dark Moon are actual places built and used by living people. People have lives and presumably died here. It is the only of the three where we explore places that are actually haunted instead of made by the ghosts. And they are all full of story told in little hints here and there, like the dollhouse in Haunted Towers or the crystals in Secret Mine. And King Boo has an actual active plan instead of just "revenge".
About the "randomly themed floors" most of them have an explanation.
The castle is probably referencing stuff like Medieval Times
The Garden area is like that because the ghost of the floor probably modified it.
The pirate floor is basically a pirate themed bar with an enormous pool
Disco fits quite a bit
The Movie Studio could be seen like a live movie theater?
The egypt floor is the only one that really doesn't fit as an attraction. But I think you should've out more attention in how the floors fit
The museum is just a cool place I guess
You should also consider how Hellen Gravely planned floor 5 to be the only floor accessible to Luigi and Co other than 1 and 2. That's why the rooms are "501,503" even tho there are no rooms in the lower floors.
And also consider that in cases like floor 7 the main ghosts probably modifed the floor
I really would've expected this game to have a Casino floor.
A luxury hotel without a casino? What is this tomfoolery?
I mean even Super Mario Sunshine's hotel had a casino and it's even haunted as well. They could've payed homage to that in this game.
@@ShyGuyXXL it would ve been nice but i'm fine without it
Deserves way more views for the amount of work put in.
Can we just notice the fact that Floor 11 has three triplet magicians who literally appear to be children? That would imply they met a horrible fate during a magic trick. That’s pretty dark.
Luigi's Mansion is no stranger to dead kids.
I think the music style of this game ,while having a bit of the music style of Dark Moon, also tries to be a bit similar to 1.
About the main theme not.being reused, there are actually many track who reuse the main theme.
They are just a lot more subtle.
Floor 15 is obvious
Floor 11 is a very clowny remix
Floor 14 is a very disco-y remix
Floor 13 is a bit of a remix
Many other tracks ,such as floor 2, have a similar structure but different melody.
Also there's one track with the same melody as a metroid track, so that's cool..?
Also, fun fact: the hotel shops theme seems to be a remix of "library piano" from Dark Moon.
E Gadd's lab theme is partially in 5/4 , a rare time signature
This game just does a better job at making remixes feel different , and doesn't reuse the theme as much
Constantly editing the message: some floors seem to have a "floor main theme" , such as floor 10, floor 6 and floor 4
Great news, as of 2022 this game has sold around 10 million units. So it's safe to say we won't have to wait another 6-12 years for a 4th game.
I am honored to have been silently mentioned a few times here! This is my favorite review of yours to date. Great pacing, excellent points, and nice editing. Well worth the wait, even.
Thanks again man! Probably wouldn't have even noticed Peach's weird neck if it wasn't for you, so thanks for that as well...
I dont mean to be so offtopic but does someone know of a method to get back into an instagram account?
I stupidly lost my login password. I would love any assistance you can offer me.
@Reese Immanuel Instablaster =)
Peach neck is the scariest thing ive seen in a long time 😭
Finally! My most anticipated video in a while
My fav Luigi's Mansion game.
I don't think they redecorated all of their rooms. I think that they cast some sort of illusion spell that eventually wore off.
No one is going to talk about how you can go to settings and edit the lighting.
Also Dark moon had a horror like soundtrack with the ambiance themes. Like the garage, Graveyard, The anti chamber etc. those ambiance themes sound something like a horror game. In my opinion as much as I love LM3 the sound track in the game is somewhat disappointing. It sounds Too goofy. I prefer the dark tunes LM2 had and the OG.
There were a fair amount of LM3 music that sound close to dark moon’s Dark like tunes like the music in the Unnatural History Museum it sounds so menacing.
But honestly each LM game is different
LM genre according to my friends.
LM1: Horror, Action, Comedy.
LM2: Action, Adventure, Thriller
LM3: Action, Comedy.
Luigi's mansion 3 would've been an amazing game for me, but my only singular issue was that I beat it in 3 hours. Spent 2 hours at the night that I got it, and 1 hour or so to beat it when I woke up. I feel like somehow dark moon, a handheld, was much longer, but thats probably because of some padding. It doesn't matter though, because gameplay is gameplay, story isn't what I always care about.
I agree. It’s also ridiculously easy, meaning I only died on the final boss.
Am I the only one that wished that Daisy should have come along with them instead of three generic Toads? Personally, I would have chosen: Mario, Peach, Daisy, Toad, and Yoshi. Or if they really needed three freaking Toads, why not use established ones such as Toad, Toadette, and Toadsworht? Whatever happened to Toadworth anyway? They just stopped using him.
Also Red Guy, after playing Scare-scraper a lot I just wanted to say you missed one other trap. Occasionally if you open closets 1/5 of them turn out to be a fake one that eats you. If you don't believe me try it yourself by opening every closet on a few floors and one way to avoid it is to use your plunger. The fake one drop pearls and real ones just open and don't get destroyed.
That actually did happen to me once and I was going to mention it in the video, but I couldn't find it in my footage. I got a bit impatient trying to find it so I gave up and cut that bit out since I only talked about it for a few seconds.
There is also a wardrobe trap in scarescraper. Rarely, you can get stuck in one
Awesome video I love your work, thanks for taking the time I was anticipating these🤩🤩
4:41. No no. Look at what Egadd says. He had a little help from someone to test the prototype Gooigi. 3ds Luigis Mansion is canon somehow.
I think the problem that holds this game back for me is just the overall lack of progression. Luigi is the exact same at the end of this game as when he started it and that kind of sinks the experience for me. I like how the original LM often let you explore more of the mansion than you could handle and you had to remember to come back as soon as you got an element medal or did something else, somewhere else. The mission structure is back from Dark Moon but just with a different veneer, floor are often like missions so it still feels like I am being railroaded as opposed to I'm solving this mansion. I wouldn't feel like this if the Hotel felt more connected than it is. In LM, you could be on the roof and have to go to floor 2, then down to the basement, then up to 3, then back to the roof but it flowed better. This game, nope. Other than going after Polterkitty, you never need to go back to a floor unless you are grinding gems which don't give you anything... Yippie!
I don't believe that this game was made for fans of the original. I think you nailed the points I've already made/tried to make. I didn't buy this game because I was afraid of being burned by it, so I borrowed it from a friend. As much polish the atmosphere has, I still far prefer the original. The game got stale really quick, I'm glad you spent so much time talking about combat since that's the main gripe I have with the game, every encounter devolves into just spamming the slam attack and winning. Most of the game just felt like padding/time-wasters. I hope that they return to the form of the original someday.
Well I think they may have looked at the first game a bit for some aspects like bringing back the portrait ghosts in spirit. But they obviously were more so making a follow up to Dark Moon. And yeah the combat was my favorite part of the original so I had to talk about it a lot here.
Game's not about combat as much as previous games. It's more about exploration. If you want an actual challenge, going.back to finished floor Is worth it
Great review man.
After upgrading, you get the ability to slam up to 7 times.
I actually just finished this game this week and I found myself feeling the same way. A good game that could've been so much more, but even me going into the game without comparing it to the original I was still pretty let down. My main issue with the game is that it started to feel...kind of aimless afterawhile. It was cool each floor being different and unique, but they felt so disconnected which I think a some story could've possibly helped feel that void. To me it started to feel aimless after the first cat mission. B2 was fine, but than suddenly we are in Egypt? Than after the magic floor we head back to b2 to get an upgrade, which probably I would've been fine with...if you used the upgrade more than one time in the main story. Not too long after we have another back tracking cat mission... (I was fine with the first time, but it didn't need to happen twice. Think there's other interesting ways they could've included the cat back like maybe let it be an asshole and trap Luigi somehow.) Anyways, afterwards we get the disco floor which i got pretty excited about only to be let down that it was just an average boss fight. The Hellen gravity floor was cool as well as the boss fight, but I thought the build up to King Boo as well as the fight was a disappointing. Felt like the finale could've used a bit more build up. I felt like the first half started great! The piano boss fight blew me out of the water and got me hyped for the rest of the game, but sadly that excited died down and turned into me just wanting to get the game over with. Anyways, sorry the long post. I definitely enjoyed the review!
You don't need to apologize for making a long post, the video is over an hour long lol. I love getting long comments like this.
I love this game almost as mush as the original, i know it's unpopular but i never really cared about the atmosphere in the first game
I've never played the original Luigi's Mansion. I played Dark Moon and 3, but I will say the original Luigi's Mansion looks like a better experience than Dark Moon and 3.
I think combat does not really get repetitive because there really isn't that much combat in this game, at least for its length
I wish Nintendo would have played around with the brief time travel gimmick resulting a younger version of E Gadd as a substitute for Gooigi without sacrificing the Goo team work puzzle solving aspect. It would have made things a bit more interesting . . .
Still a fun game nonetheless but still the first Luigi's mansion was my favorite. I hope one day they remake Luigi's Mansion for the Switch
Interesting idea, not sure how it could work but I wouldn't be opposed to a playable E Gadd.
This was a great review! I loved the original luigis mansion it was a great game not a perfect game i had my faults with it but it was overall a great game. Dark moon kinda turned in the opposite direction. Dark moon was not a bad game in my opinion but it could have been better. I didn’t like it because mostly of the mission structure. I did not mind it was on a 3Ds because i do play a bunch of other mario games on it such as paper mario. The combat was OK for dark moon not really much of a challenge only died once to the paranormal Chaos. I loved luigis mansion 3 but they could have done something better with some of the character though. plus i wanna why luigis carry’s a flashlight if theres no point. Bosses were really good, The game lacked a verity in them because 90% of the ghost encounters were Goobs. I wanted some more standard ghost like the original had. The king boo fight was not really good, No challenges. I actually only died once to the piano boss. Other than that i came close to dying a few other times but they just kept giving hearts. I felt that this game was better than dark moon in my opinion but it just was not good enough to beat the Original Luigis mansion in my opinion.
4:33 actually E gadd has a line where he says he got someone to help him test the prototype model of Googi. Which would be referring his past self meaning Googi is Canon to the first game
Yeah king boo really sucks in this game. I completely agree with everything you said about his character. I think that they should retire King boo as the main villain of the Luigi‘s mansion franchise. Him putting people in paintings is starting to get really old and he escaping his imprisonment literally every game is getting stale not to mention by 3 he has completely lost all of his menace and original personality but I do think he should be the main villain for one more game. There’s still so much we don’t know about king boo and I would really like for stuff to be answered in his last game where he’s the main villain. The biggest question being what is his history with the Mario brothers since he clearly knew them before the events of the first Luigis mansion game. I highly doubt they ever will replace king boo as the main villain of the franchise but I digress
I think it’s time for king boo to be retired as the main villain of the series. By 3 he’s lost all creepiness and Menes he originally had and him putting people into painting is getting really stale. Like it was cool the first time and it was fine in dark moon but now I’m starting to think that’s the only trick He has up his sleeve. Him also getting captured and then released in every game is also getting really stale. 3 had the perfect opportunity to introduce a new main villain with Helen gravely but not only did they barely do anything with her causing her to be nothing but missed potential, They also brought king boo back and barely do anything with him until the end of the game where he has is very easy and anti-climactic final boss fight. It’s the worst of both worlds. I think it’s time The series gets a new villain, but I highly doubt Nintendo will ever do that and they’re probably just gonna stick with king boo forever
Well To Be Honest King Boo Was The Villain For The Past Two Luigi’s Mansion Games So Would It Really Be Much Of A Surprise To See Him Be The Villain For The THIRD Time?
What happened to the tools laylee video?
All I'm curious about is to see what he thinks about the updates added since this review
The red guy You gave me a good idea. If I Was Doing Luigi's mansion 3 I would make it. So helen gravely Captures Mario and king boo.and bringing back the ghost from luigi Mansion one And dark rooms
I know that this is kinda insignificant but, it would have been a nice touch if Luigi's overalls were green with the blue shirt for this game as a classic little throwback to the O.G. Luigi
I beaten Luigi's Mansion 3 a few day ago and.......I did enjoy it, but theres something that feel off.
Like I think the graphics look incredible, the controls feel great, the story was interesting and I found a good number of bosses to be great.
Tho there are a few issues, I'm not a real fan of the Porterkitty segments, some levels (such as areas 11 and 12) were annoying and the final boss was a little bit hit-or-miss for me, also what you said at 9:01 to 9:17, I feel like that would have made the story more great.
Overall, I think Luigi's Mansion 3 is a great game and (while I never played it) a huge improvement over Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon, and while I think Luigi's Mansion is fine as a trilogy (seeing as I am a fan of films/games that are a Trilogy), I wouldn't mind if we got a Luigi's Mansion 4.
So good review The Red Guy.
Finally!
I mean actually Gooigi I am pretty sure is Canon to the first game because
E Gadd says he had to someone test the prototype and the someone was marked in green which is referencing the 3DS remake so I think it is Canon but it could just be an Easter egg for people who bought the Remake
I hated bosses in this game. Many of them were "try every item in your arsenal as luigi or Gooigi until something works". What made bosses good in the original game was that a lot of them either had dialogue, or they could comminicate via the gameboy horror, allowing the game to properly setup a puzzle for the player to solve.
Bosses in 3 are less like puzzles or characters and more like boss FIGHTS, which misses the original appeal entirely. The only really good one is the director, who is present throughout the entire floor he shows up in, has dialogue, and motivates the exploration through the movie set by "framing" the normal gameplay as luigi gathering action shots. This is 1000x better than the security guard, the pool guy, or the stupid fuckoff filler cat who only wastes the players time
I don't really like the slam. It feels to physical for, you know, ghosts.
I was a bit underwhelmed by the lack of upgrades. The game seemed to just go on and on. While it was polished and pretty it didn't really feel like I was progressing.
19:44 wait so are you telling me that this ghost is supposed to be red died and became a ghost?
Did no one mention on the dark moon video that Luigi's Mansion 1 had a jump button?
I believe it was the A/Mario button. It would allow you to hop over poison mushrooms the portrait ghosts spawned when you suctioned them long enough. Dark Moon did not add it to the game.
Are you sure? Never heard of this before.
@@tjlnintendo yep. While you were suctioning up ghosts you could jump.
@@fortello7219
I don’t think so. I think you are mis remembering. Can you give me evidence? I just booted up the game to try it. And I looked it up, no info.
Yeah I think you are misremembering my dude. Luigi most definitely cannot jump or use the A button while sucking up a ghost in Luigi’s Mansion 1.
Dark moon was the one that added the A button dodge feature.
22:29 You just played a remix of that track…
I think I have a similar opinion to you. It's kind of strange, really. We can say that 3 is good, but what's the point if it's not what we want? Well, I couldn't stand it, though, and I'm not sure why. Maybe the audio design is the issue. At least I can't recall there to be any atmosphere at all, making it more of a slog. And I think being rewarded with elevator buttons is a really stupid way of progressing the game. If the hotel had stairs all the way, the game would be over. Also, I think some of the puzzles are really awkward and I needed to look up a guide. Like destroying a laser cannon by jumping or something like that.
hello saw act man talk about u
I think the final boss is a really easy and really anti-climactic. I think dark moon and the first game had way better final bosses
Can't believe they reskinned my girl Melody Pianissima. Biggest sin this game has, tbh