Maybe not every single rooftop but every parking lot/garage, warehouse or factory with a large surface should absolutely do this! I so very wish I could park under solar panels here in Florida when I go to the store.
Singapore is the perfect place to develop urban farming and vertical farms imo, if they keep on improving the system, they can be a world leader in the industry.
meanwhile in singapore, they pump so much gas and fuel from Malaysia to power their crap. They may talk the talk, but they never walk the walk. Just show the world their fancy walking shoes is all they do.
@@MoonLiteNite no shit they're a tiny island. Want do you expect them to do. As a city their reliance on fossil fuels is small considering their situation. Primarily due to their car-free approach. As far as sustainability is concerned they are leaps and bounds ahead of most other cities.
A great model for the world not only for growing its own food but also cleaning up its waterways! Great going Singapore! A wonderful place to visit also.
@@TomorrowsBuild hey, now that i have your attention😁, please do a video on your B1M channel about the "Ellinikon" project in Athens. It's a development of a coastal old airport, in size three times of Monaco, which will among other things feature the biggest park in Europe and the biggest coastal park in the world. The whole project is worth 8 bn euros. I think it is well inside the spectrum of things your other channel shows.
Never disappoints? You are way out off your element DONNY! How about their discrimination against gay people, porn is highly illegal, its illegal to Walk around naked in your own house, some punishments are caning,hanging, and 3000 other weird shit. But yeah Singapore never disappoints 😂
Sometimes I wonder what the world would have looked like without innovations like this😊, my advice for everyone, both in the agricultural industry and elsewhere, is to evolve with the world in others so as not to to be left behind
Sorry for the inconvenience, I just had to add. Cryptocurrency is the future of money and a very good way to invest and make extra profit, I am grateful to Mr. Larry Kent Nick for introducing me and making me earn so much thanks to this new innovation
Sometimes life is very easy and simple, if you do something good for the general public, it will not go unnoticed, thank you Mr. Larry Kent Nick for making my life easier
I've watched a few videos about Singapore recently and I am very impressed by the resiliency and efforts of the country. It is truly inspiring. I wish them the best and I hope that the rest of the world, including countries with outdated philosophies, can embrace positive changes like Singapore is doing.
@@wunhonglee8952 it's a nice security that your country imports almost all of its food. Wait for the next big crisis to see how actually secure you are
@chrrrles using the large area of rooftops for urban farming is a very interesting idea. Makes no sense to have such a large area in our cities unused (of course instead of farm we can use the space for other things such as solae panels, but we have space for multiple uses).
@João Teixeira, green cities? yeah you got it all backwards... the fix is to not have cities, big villages only. cities ain't sustainable, if you haven't realized this by now, you is naive and should learn how food is made and served. me? oh I fixed my community before covid lockdowns, I'm running for mayor in a few years, I'm taking over so morons with ideas like yourself stop ruin my community. Boys and men who talks "green cities" is boys and men that will have their right to vote revoked. Blind naive kiddos talking above their understanding. You lucky you live where you do, here we wouldn't consider you a male.
@@tajfaa you don't get calls from parents saying "you saved my child's education". Improving the infrastructure is not a cult, that's political work and manual labor. When you confuse "a cult" with improving the infrastructure, you is lost.
When things were at their very worst: 2 Suns, Cross in the sky, 2 comets will collide = don`t be afraid - repent, accept Lord`s Hand of Mercy. Scientists will say it was a global illusion. Beaware - Jesus will never walk in flesh again. After WW3 - rise of the “ man of peace“ from the East = Antichrist - the most powerful, popular, charismatic and influential leader of all time. Many miracles will be attributed to him. He will imitate Jesus in every conceivable way. Don`t trust „pope“ Francis = the False Prophet - will seem to rise from the dead - will unite all Christian Churches and all Religions as one. One World Religion = the seat of the Antichrist. Benedict XVI is the last true pope - will be accused of a crime of which he is totally innocent. "Many events, including ecological upheavals, wars, the schism in My Church on Earth, the dictatorships in each of your nations - bound as one, at its very core - will all take place at the same time." 1 November 2012 The Book of Truth
@@gateauxq4604 aaaaa-lu-mi-nium, aluminium, alumin-jum-jum-jum-jum our chemistry teacher starts their song like this on a outside-walking-day in shool xDDD
I'm still waiting for the vertical farm concept I read about in Popular Science like 15 years ago. It was basically a high rise with a Whole Foods at the ground floor and with every conceivable farm type above it. Caged birds like chickens lived above running water and their feces dropped directly into the water to act as the fertilizer for the hydroponic greens as well as the primary food source for bottom feeding fish like tilapia.
We're all starting to move in that direction, to greater or lesser (mostly lesser) degrees. But certainly it 'is' in Singapore's best interests to start being more self-sufficient (and that goes for other high density population countries). Many people might dismiss this particular pandemic as being 'nothing much to worry about' - however, no one can deny that a far more deadly pandemic can spring up at anytime. The next Bubonic plague, a more virulent Bird Flu or Ebola. Anything can happen - because it's happened in the past. The last thing you want is to be living in a country when all others have closed their borders tight shut and won't even consider trading food over the border. It's under circumstances like that when countries are thinking - 'We might need this food for own own people if this disease is anything like as disruptive as the last one. So we'll keep all the food for ourselves.' Such a scenario can happen only too easily with the right disease on the rampage.
@@debbiehenri345 Self-sufficience is a stupid myth. No country can live in autarky and certainly not a country such as Singapore by growing some crops on their rooftops lol. Abundance doesn't come from the "natural resources" a country has but from their economic freedom and especially in the case of Singapore its free-trade policy. That's why Venezuela, with the most proven oil reserves in the world and with far more agricultural land than Singapore is poor and its inhabitants starve. While Singapore is wealthy and its citizens live in abundance despite not having farms, oil or else..
@@teslaasmr9375 i like how you conveniently leave out the fact that Venezuela is HEAVILY sanctioned by the u.s preventing them to trade openly hence the increase in poverty....
Cutting edge farming , I have visited Singapore regularly since 1980 and never ceases to amaze me with its very clever innovation technology.The future to farming🥦🥬🍉🍊
Same here, but I came first .... in 1980 as a young man and was astonished and fell in love at that time.... unfortunately I can't afford to live in Singapore, but managed to come near.....
@@SjaakSchulteis I ended up in Thailand and My Scottish Company Moved its Operations to Singapore So i Technically worked out of the Country But never took advantage of that Unfortunately
I have been to Singapore, and also I love Singapore. To my best understanding, there are about 60 offshore islands around the main island. I think “Sentosa” is the biggest out of these islands. I think these islands could be used in expanding their agro-based targets because technology is well developed in modern world, so I think some hi-tech methods could be used to connect some islands close-by and form a wider area for agriculture purposes.
In Sweden we have a much more intelligent (?) aproach. In the southern parts we have among the best soils for farming in Europe. It enables four harvests per year. So, we use giant bulldozers to remove the soil and build squarekilometer after squarekilometer of small houses in thousands. In a country where the environmental green party plays leading role. Simply impressive!!!
I think that was considered by the Singapore government but found unviable due to lack of space. So we had to try a different method. I believe the Singaporean approach is more similar to the Netherlands' approach (need to double check).
bruh... The only way you can ride the bulldozer in Singapore is if you're literally on the public road, or there's a construction of buildings hahaha same goal, different land space my dude. The only way SG expand is up now. Or be like Dubai and dump tons of of sand in the ocean. But theeeeenn again, SG dont have lots of sqft in owning the water. The only profitable, peaceful and most importantly sustainable farming for them is up not sideways. t
*I'm mainly interested in how people distribute their income, specifically how much goes to investing, saving, and consuming because I would be retiring or working fewer hours five years from now. I earn around 165,000 euros per year, but I have nothing to show for the moment.*
After reading your post, it is unclear whether you have a 401(k) plan. Considering your annual income of 165,000 EUR and your lack of financial progress, it is plausible that you should evaluate your monthly budget and pinpoint areas where you might be overspending. It would be prudent to seek financial guidance and cut down on monthly expenses. Any savings realized should be channeled towards wise investment opportunities.
@@tammystut Being self-employed, I finance my 401k businesses, and I remain open to generating income from various sources. Have you had any prior experience working with financial advisors? If yes, how was your experience? Is the experience as lucrative as advertised?
@@nickycolgantl9310 Certainly, JENNIFER D. ALAINE , a financial advisor, played a crucial role in easing my concerns regarding investing. With her guidance and subsequent investments, I was able to achieve a seven-figure milestone in less than three years.
I spent more than a decade on the practical end of the future farming space. It isn't viable, you just can't square the energy costs. Looks pretty, makes hipsters and architects feel good about themselves, costs a bomb and can't feed anyone. Thankful, actual farming is finally having a renaissance.
@@btaleonard02 what's worse is how much of the best land is turned into golf courses. People need to quit modernizing everything and realize that they are going to have to work with nature to survive. It's amazing how many people over develop areas and push out farms considering food is a literal requirement for life. If course, many idiots honestly believe food is manufactured at stores and there is no reason to kill an animal because you can go buy pre packaged meat at the store.
Thank you. I see all the hype around it but the only really use case I can see for it are areas where import costs are prohibitively expensive, i. E. on the moon, mars or a space station. The idea that a city state might be entirely isolated just doesn't make sense either. If a pandemic makes them shut their borders they will just have to open them because more would die from starvation that from the disease and if the country isn't able to break a full military blockade from all sides ot also won't be able to defend itself against an invasion.
If you have the roofplants covered pf plants,were you can put solar panels? Maybe on the windows of the skycrapers right,but looks like super innefficent and over complicated, this solution maybe is right for singapore who doesnt have farmland, but the most efficent way to grow food for me is the sun, why use a solar panel or fossil fuels (solar panel have the efficency of 40x100) so you need to cover a larger area for those to grow a plant, maybe im wrong. Super expensive food its not the way, maybe im wrong
What a great display of teamwork and innovation. Thank you. Been there and want to go again. If we all strived to provide a little of our needs we'd end up with excess.
@@jeems2066 I didn't comment on Singapore's dictatorship being good or bad, I was only saying to "Tarfa P. Kpamber" that what he writes in his comment would only work on a democracy. got it? :-)
Fully funded world class education grounded in core democratic values. Singapore has birthed a socioeconomic machine of creativity and ingenuity thanks to that no-debate investment. Singapore would ideally fall under a 'technocratic dictatorship'.
You might wanna to consider really hard if u wanna move to SG, cost of living is quite high. EG: an apartment in Mexico city cost about 3240000pesos, which is about 20000+SGD(do correct me if im wrong) A 3 Room flat with a 99year lease and value of the flat depreciates each year cost about 300000+SGD and btw unless you are buying a private property all purchasing of apartments(HDB) in SG goes by a ballot system. Even if you have the money doesnt mean u can geta chance to buy a flat
If every city could employee this technology we could reduce a lot of the supply chain's carbon footprint around the world. Plus everyone will be able to feed themselves.
Farmers would cry when they go bankrupt it cities grew their own food. That's why it hasn't happened yet, the economy in Canada couldn't handle a Change in the food guide for less dairy so they changed it back🤣
@Bapo Boy Not talking about the cities history or if there are raging parties and nightlife. I was talking about the initiative to grow food locally. But growing food to feed the people in your city is not boring.
Individuals could start this process for themselves on their balconies or even indoors. We grow herbs, greens, cabbage, and onions in containers, indoors and out.
I'd say Singapore is one of leading pioneers of modern Urban farming. Double thumbs up for them. I hope my country could have this kind of modern approach oh how they can build a more sustainable future.
You mean the indoor ones, with LED lights etc? No wonder, it's the same tech ;) It's a (slightly) messy thing (like all agriculture I guess), but the speed of growing is incredible. (I was in one of those test chambers a few times during a practica, had to clean and replant them.) I think the Arabs were the front runners of this, since they have water problems (and this saves a lot of water even though the plants basically swim) and not much usable land, but easy energy (solar)
@@steemlenn8797 In the late 1970s, the Dutch Agricultural University of Wageningen helped Saudi Arabia to cultivate potatoes in the desert. Now Saudi Arabia is the largest potato producer in the entire Middle East.
@@steemlenn8797 Did the farm make financial sense? I'm hating on the idea of vertical farming a lot because it's just seems so expensive. I get that the food might be a novelty ingredient that high end restaurants are willing to pay extra for or as a way to sustain a base on Mars, the Moon or in the arctic but when you can just use trucks, trains and ships to import food grown outside I just can't see how the economics of it would work out. After all the reason we don't grow more food isn't that we're running out of space to do so. It's that farmers in countries in the developing world simply don't have the capital for the machinery, fertilizer and herbicides/pesticides to get the same food output per area we see in richer countries yet. This goes completely against the hype so: Do I miss something? Are they so much more efficient that they can somehow replace regular farming after the massively higher costs for labor, land, water supplies, lights and all the energy use? Or did tech media create a hype around a use case the technology was never really meant for?
@@user-hv6wb5gk8p If it was financial sense is the wrong question for the place I was in, since it was a research facility. But the salads there growed at 3 times the speed than on fields. I actually did a small project (not water but earth based) with different settings (color) for the light, and there were cleary visible differences. (Also the smails clearly favored one of the 4 types of salad I was testing :D) Worldwide speaking indoor farming of salad was already cheaper in Saudi Arabia than importing it (because imports are expensive, not to mention that imports happen via air, so not exactly "green" green stuff) - mostly thanks to cheap electricity from solar power. I guess with better knowledge and tech at least some types of crops will be cheaper to produce this way in many parts of the world (especially from foreign climates). And here we are speaking about Saudi Arabia, they are not exactly lacking space. Singapore, Japan, where space costs more than only one arm and a leg the additional land might cost more than the tech.
Singaporean's have proved they can do anything required to not only survive, but to flourish. This is a fantastic idea, and I hope everyone comes together to make it a norm across SG society. There is always a way.
I went there for work as well though I only got to stay for a few months, but agree that it was incredible. It's hard explaining to family/friends just how amazing of a country it is, I feel like everyone should go at least once in their lifetime.
@@justinmorgan836 yes, lovely people, food and atmosphere. I even enjoy the Durian! I'll probably buy an apartment there and visit annually in the future. Hope to share a Singapore sling with you one day!
When I was growing up in Singapore we raised our own chicken, ducks, turkey, goats and even had a few cows for milk. Our little farmhouse was acquired by the govt and we had to move to a modern apartment building in 1984.
LIVING IN A CONCRETE JUNGLE, CAN ESCAPE FROM CONSTANT FLOODING. FREE FROM MOSQUITOES BREEDING AFTER E 🌧 ☔ ⛈ 🌧 ☔ SEASON, ALSO E SURROUNDING IS CLEANER ON E HIGHER FLOOR....
8:50 Steady, Freddie... Getting closer to "How it's Made" by the minute... 😉 Very cool concepts shown being used in the real world. Good stuff. I'd hate to have to depend on another country for 90% of my food...
That is low hanging fruit. What would make really good sense for scalability for an island nation like Singapore would be sea-steads. Fish farming, Sea greens, full water column. Makes perfect sense for the deep harbors around Singapore. Especially with the retired boats, scrap steel, and various other end-of-the-line logistics to be recycled. Moor a boat and use it as a sea steading platform. Allow for a transient sea community. Even if you're just growing chicken feed, clams, and oysters it makes good sense.
Another benefit that Singapore will soon find out is that the quality of their food in taste, nutrition and longevity will improve substantially. Consider that in addition to having a year-round growing season in SEA, they can stagger harvests with indoor farms to create a nearly constant supply of fresh food locally that does not have to wait a week on a refrigerated train/truck/ship to get to the market. Also, not only will they be reducing their carbon footprint by reducing their shipping burden, but they'll create the infrastructure for local agriculture. I won't even talk about the countless benefits of increasing the density of beneficial insects and expanding the colonization of beneficial gut flora through community agriculture...all I'll say is don't be surprised if you see instances of depression in Singapore (and any other city that uses this model) to plummet and their lifespans/overall health to increase.
Incorporating natural growth into developments encourages less wrapping waste if purchasing from food stores also naturally improve health with no additives. Brilliant! Not to mention it would help to reduce mental health increasing natural oxygen and clean air. I love your goals.
@tomorrow's build actually the map for farmland by landmass is wrong, the area that you highlighting as 1%. That island is actually a military training area, the farms are actually the top left of the country, the northwest of the country. and with local fish farms in the sea nearby around the island
Technically, the graph was just showing the 1% of our land is farmland, and not that Pulau Sudong is actually a farm. Although I feel that a map showing our farms would be better.
@@darylteo9983 Ah, so that map was meant to represent a 'measuring cup' getting filled up to 1%. Thank you for clarifying, I also interpreted it as a map of where the actual farmland is located.
Fascinating. This might finally be the place where the first farmscraper is built. The design is around for quite a while but nobody ever made a reality out of it.
I like this and have wanted to see it developed. So good for this guy... the only question I have is plants like to trap humidity and moisture, so how do you keep the cement and steel from breaking down, if all of these plants are bound closely to it? Just curious.
Imagine being this ignorant and claim Singapore has tremendous climate and fertile soil without knowing the scarcity of land and the weather actually are not suitable for most crops
I really do believe in growing at home. It's really great doing to hydroponically or aeroponically, and vertically if possible, which is what I've done before. It limits the need to fill up valuable residential space on buildings.
I love the compassion and respect that Singaporeans have for their city and always come together to create a better tomorrow. If this was the U.K. there wouldn’t be roof farms for food, they’d be roof weed farms.
Thats going to be a massive industry in the coming years! Imagine every city in the world is able to supply up to 30% of its own produce. Imagine the amount of land we will reclaim for livestock agriculture and green spaces!
I ripped out my lawn 3yrs ago and replaced it with an herb and vegetable garden. It's pretty cool to walk outside and grab some fresh herbs and vegetables for cooking. Not to mention with all the herbs, the amount of butterflies and birds I've seen that now frequent the yard. Also, I don't have to mow!
If i had a garden i would do the same.. more importent to mention.. you dont use immense amounts of fossil c02 producing energy to make your vegetables. The idea of hightech farming presented here forgets the elephant in the garden.. it is unbeleavable energy consuming.. and energy.. mostly comes and maybe will come for long time only from fossil ressources, producing c02 and getting more and more rare..
Govts should subsidize such innovative farming instead of expecting an already taxed consumer to pay higher prices. In time, as participation increases, prices will drop, and the subsidy can be withdrawn
As a farmer I was inspired by watching this video. I've now set a goal that each of my three daughters will have a unicorn in 3 years. Of course they're going to be carbon neutral unicorns.
Love your answer... the big Problem of hightech farming is the intense amount of energy that has to be spent to produce a tiny amount of equivalent food energy.. this in times of climate change and rising problems in getting enough fossil energy to run our modern world is just an illusion.
![[#2024MAMA] BIGBANG (빅뱅) - 뱅뱅뱅 (BANG BANG BANG) + FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EQsYfiPR9uM/mqdefault.jpg)
I'd like to see 100 % of rooftops to be either edible plants or solar panels!
Well, they got that one hotel whose rooftop is a swimming pool. Thus, 100% will be kinda hard to achieve.
Asé
I want it to be edible solar panels.
@@Wayclarke In a sense, salad is already an edible solar panel.
Maybe not every single rooftop but every parking lot/garage, warehouse or factory with a large surface should absolutely do this! I so very wish I could park under solar panels here in Florida when I go to the store.
Singapore is the perfect place to develop urban farming and vertical farms imo, if they keep on improving the system, they can be a world leader in the industry.
Always love Singapore’s proactive approach to everything🌹
Yes
Yeah it's cool asf!!!! Pretty sure the fact that the country is...small helps them to be proactive in order to exist 😅😅😅
yes
Lies again? World Hunger Work @ Home
got advanced thnology to treat water
Greener cities are the future! Singapore has proven that awesome designs and green energy can work together!
It needs to.
Humans are not built for living in giant concrete cities, we need the green otherwise we get miserable.
meanwhile in singapore, they pump so much gas and fuel from Malaysia to power their crap.
They may talk the talk, but they never walk the walk. Just show the world their fancy walking shoes is all they do.
@@MoonLiteNite no shit they're a tiny island. Want do you expect them to do. As a city their reliance on fossil fuels is small considering their situation. Primarily due to their car-free approach. As far as sustainability is concerned they are leaps and bounds ahead of most other cities.
STRICT PUNISHMENT WILL 😞 DETER PPL FROM VANDALISM. THEY HAVE TO LEARN TO DO WHATS ✅ ↔️ 👉 ➡️ N APPRECIATE E FARMERS N FOOD*****
SINGAPOREANS APPRECIATED WHAT E GOVT N E FARMERS ARE HELPING US IN MANY WAYS ❤ 😍 💖 ❣ 💕 💘
A great model for the world not only for growing its own food but also cleaning up its waterways! Great going Singapore! A wonderful place to visit also.
Just got to love the way Singapore always do things in such a creative way... #♡SG
Singapore, never disappoints, always leaves in awe.
Agreed!
@@TomorrowsBuild hey, now that i have your attention😁, please do a video on your B1M channel about the "Ellinikon" project in Athens. It's a development of a coastal old airport, in size three times of Monaco, which will among other things feature the biggest park in Europe and the biggest coastal park in the world. The whole project is worth 8 bn euros. I think it is well inside the spectrum of things your other channel shows.
You should travel more.
@@web2yt488 how is that relevant?
Never disappoints? You are way out off your element DONNY! How about their discrimination against gay people, porn is highly illegal, its illegal to Walk around naked in your own house, some punishments are caning,hanging, and 3000 other weird shit. But yeah Singapore never disappoints 😂
Sometimes I wonder what the world would have looked like without innovations like this😊, my advice for everyone, both in the agricultural industry and elsewhere, is to evolve with the world in others so as not to to be left behind
Sorry for the inconvenience, I just had to add. Cryptocurrency is the future of money and a very good way to invest and make extra profit, I am grateful to Mr. Larry Kent Nick for introducing me and making me earn so much thanks to this new innovation
I already like this guy, I would like to get involved please how can I contact him?
Surprisingly, contacting him is very easy, all you have to do is follow him on instagram
@ Larry Kent Nick Trading
Sometimes life is very easy and simple, if you do something good for the general public, it will not go unnoticed, thank you Mr. Larry Kent Nick for making my life easier
Wow. B1M's voice is such a pleasant surprise!
I was trying to figure it out. Thanks dude!
Its crazy just how uncanny his voice is that I never would even have thought that it was him lol
I've watched a few videos about Singapore recently and I am very impressed by the resiliency and efforts of the country. It is truly inspiring. I wish them the best and I hope that the rest of the world, including countries with outdated philosophies, can embrace positive changes like Singapore is doing.
Most other nations don't look at the world like Asians do. They think in generations, so their children's and grandchildren's future is secure.
And you'll get death sentence for having a bit of weed
@@tesha199 due to our country strict policy your child can anytime and anywhere 100% safe in Singapore.
@@wunhonglee8952 it's a nice security that your country imports almost all of its food. Wait for the next big crisis to see how actually secure you are
@@tesha199 this is what Mr Lee Kuan Yew have said for purchasing power, make sure our currency exchange is above all other Asian currencies.
We need to make our cities greener and this is a great way to do just that!
@chrrrles using the large area of rooftops for urban farming is a very interesting idea. Makes no sense to have such a large area in our cities unused (of course instead of farm we can use the space for other things such as solae panels, but we have space for multiple uses).
@@tajfaa then the mosquitoes will say hi every morning
@João Teixeira, green cities? yeah you got it all backwards... the fix is to not have cities, big villages only.
cities ain't sustainable, if you haven't realized this by now, you is naive and should learn how food is made and served.
me? oh I fixed my community before covid lockdowns, I'm running for mayor in a few years, I'm taking over so morons with ideas like yourself stop ruin my community.
Boys and men who talks "green cities" is boys and men that will have their right to vote revoked. Blind naive kiddos talking above their understanding. You lucky you live where you do, here we wouldn't consider you a male.
@@savagegtalks5912 good luck convincing people to join your cult lol
@@tajfaa you don't get calls from parents saying "you saved my child's education".
Improving the infrastructure is not a cult, that's political work and manual labor.
When you confuse "a cult" with improving the infrastructure, you is lost.
As always, Singapore is amazing. Urban gardening is relevant to every country as it forwards to advanced technology and buildings.
Urban greening, whether it for growing food or simply for wildlife should be a major priority for all cities.
This is a project that all Singaporean should give their 100% support! 👍
I hope many countries will replicate this kind of initiative. It will be a platform for us to utilize our lands well.
Almost unimaginable that this is a tomorrows build. And no yesterday's build.
We really need to start working on our future.
Many technologies have existed on paper or lab since decades.
However scaling is when it becomes a reality.
This has been going on for decades elsewhere, but just not _government mandated,_ which generally leads to problems.
It will not work. Singapore is to heavily populated.
And such farming is nothing than farming on a field
Only works on islands like Singapore
Not economical in countries with huge acreage of arable land
@@dv9239 Yes.
However land is getting scarce in many countries with growing population and industrialisation.
Singapore is one of my favourite places on earth.
Imagine walking down the street minding your own business and a zucchini falls on your head from a rooftop garden :')
😂😂😂
How do you know for sure its from a roof top garden? I Definitely not going to touch it!
Free zucchini
Funny idea, but not realistic. Zucchinismin particular,mic not harvested, dry out on the stalk, but don't fall off.
Just imagine the scenario with durians. That would hurt. A lot.
In a Country where land is scarce, credit have to given to their innovative thinking
5:44 thanks for the translation for us dense folk.
Eyyyyy at leat someone is self aware
When things were at their very worst:
2 Suns, Cross in the sky, 2 comets will collide = don`t be afraid - repent, accept Lord`s Hand of Mercy.
Scientists will say it was a global illusion.
Beaware - Jesus will never walk in flesh again.
After WW3 - rise of the “ man of peace“ from the East = Antichrist - the most powerful, popular, charismatic and influential leader of all time. Many miracles will be attributed to him. He will imitate Jesus in every conceivable way.
Don`t trust „pope“ Francis = the False Prophet
- will seem to rise from the dead
- will unite all Christian Churches and all Religions as one.
One World Religion = the seat of the Antichrist.
Benedict XVI is the last true pope - will be accused of a crime of which he is totally innocent.
"Many events, including ecological upheavals, wars, the schism in My Church on Earth, the dictatorships in each of your nations - bound as one, at its very core - will all take place at the same time."
1 November 2012
The Book of Truth
@@michagabo8819 that's cool, didn't ask, don't care
I don’t appreciate people messing with my food I like the way they grow in nature!!!!!!
I don't get your comment. Do you consider a rooftop garden or even an indoor one to be 'messing with your food'?
the location of Singapore is also highly strategic.
I love this comment. One day, I will visit Singapore!
@@HassanWorld It's amazing, you'll love it. Cleanest city of its size.
NFL, I've been there a few times. I absolutely love the country and would love to live there one day.
Singapore is also a great place to raise Crickets. They can be ground into flour to make high protein cricket bread and even delicious cricket pasta.
@@roberteischen4170 man maybe singapore sounds good and futuristic..but if u live here someday..i tell ya..its pretty boring country
Wow- this is an incredible plan. I hope it works for Singapore and more countries around the world!
Love to see this in more urban areas, which will be very beneficial to any community.
Y'all were really harvesting all the puns today.
Good idea Singapore, at least someone is using their brain, countries round the world should follow Singapore's example
Uh this is the tip of the iceberg...you don't know how much really goes into these builds. Some if not MOST of these builds aren't cost effective...
@@midnull6009 not cost effective for countries with a lot of land, but in singapore with limited land, this is definitely worth it
I’m from England, but lived in Singapore for 10 years. One thing I can vouch for, is the Singaporeans always use their brain when devising policy.
It wont help the world, we are not ment to stay on the earth for that long....
@Bapo Boy have you been to Singapore? Tell me how much you care about the above when you live here.
It’s funny that he cleared up his pronunciation of the word “ Basil” for Americans, when we pronounce so many other words he said different too.
Hahaha! Like what in particular?
@@TomorrowsBuild,
Haha! Like “renaissance”
Great videos by the way!
Timestamp
Aluminium
Y’all even spell it differently 😂
@@gateauxq4604 aaaaa-lu-mi-nium, aluminium, alumin-jum-jum-jum-jum
our chemistry teacher starts their song like this on a outside-walking-day in shool xDDD
Welcome, Singapore! I hope every country of this world follows you on this regard...It will really help in climate change.
Singapore where challenges takes you up instead of crippling you down ☝💯🌟👏🌈🌎
This is it!
There's nowhere that looks like Singapore; it's absolutely beautiful on a purely aesthetic level.
I'm still waiting for the vertical farm concept I read about in Popular Science like 15 years ago. It was basically a high rise with a Whole Foods at the ground floor and with every conceivable farm type above it. Caged birds like chickens lived above running water and their feces dropped directly into the water to act as the fertilizer for the hydroponic greens as well as the primary food source for bottom feeding fish like tilapia.
Lebanon and Iraq and Africa should follow this video
*I think Singapore is going to continue growing and improving, leaving the rest of the world in the ground.*
We're all starting to move in that direction, to greater or lesser (mostly lesser) degrees. But certainly it 'is' in Singapore's best interests to start being more self-sufficient (and that goes for other high density population countries).
Many people might dismiss this particular pandemic as being 'nothing much to worry about' - however, no one can deny that a far more deadly pandemic can spring up at anytime. The next Bubonic plague, a more virulent Bird Flu or Ebola. Anything can happen - because it's happened in the past.
The last thing you want is to be living in a country when all others have closed their borders tight shut and won't even consider trading food over the border.
It's under circumstances like that when countries are thinking - 'We might need this food for own own people if this disease is anything like as disruptive as the last one. So we'll keep all the food for ourselves.'
Such a scenario can happen only too easily with the right disease on the rampage.
@@debbiehenri345 Self-sufficience is a stupid myth. No country can live in autarky and certainly not a country such as Singapore by growing some crops on their rooftops lol. Abundance doesn't come from the "natural resources" a country has but from their economic freedom and especially in the case of Singapore its free-trade policy. That's why Venezuela, with the most proven oil reserves in the world and with far more agricultural land than Singapore is poor and its inhabitants starve. While Singapore is wealthy and its citizens live in abundance despite not having farms, oil or else..
@Swar Zhe who is the "we"?
@@teslaasmr9375 i like how you conveniently leave out the fact that Venezuela is HEAVILY sanctioned by the u.s preventing them to trade openly hence the increase in poverty....
All this kind of technology should be open and free for the humanity
Cutting edge farming , I have visited Singapore regularly since 1980 and never ceases to amaze me with its very clever innovation technology.The future to farming🥦🥬🍉🍊
I am excited for the future. This is next level.
Hello dear
“You will own nothing, and be happy”.
It is not exciting, buddy. It is scary - a sign of overpopulation.
Its safe to say, if these are the future of farming instead of agroforestry, we are fucked.
The next level would be using CRISPR technology to enhance vegetation. I cover Genomics in my channel if you're curious lol.
The greenery is incredible. Hope Singapore succeed in building the farms for food so they are have more food security and are more self sufficient.
Well done. Great Content as always!
Thank you so much!!
Great initiative in the right direction. Singapore always a step ahead. 👍
I Have Loved this Country and its People Since 1999 When i first Went there
Same here, but I came first .... in 1980 as a young man and was astonished and fell in love at that time.... unfortunately I can't afford to live in Singapore, but managed to come near.....
@@SjaakSchulteis I ended up in Thailand and My Scottish Company Moved its Operations to Singapore So i Technically worked out of the Country But never took advantage of that Unfortunately
I have been to Singapore, and also I love Singapore. To my best understanding, there are about 60 offshore islands around the main island. I think “Sentosa” is the biggest out of these islands. I think these islands could be used in expanding their agro-based targets because technology is well developed in modern world, so I think some hi-tech methods could be used to connect some islands close-by and form a wider area for agriculture purposes.
Sentosa is not that big in the first place. All the rest of the islands are small. Really small. ...
In Sweden we have a much more intelligent (?) aproach. In the southern parts we have among the best soils for farming in Europe. It enables four harvests per year. So, we use giant bulldozers to remove the soil and build squarekilometer after squarekilometer of small houses in thousands. In a country where the environmental green party plays leading role. Simply impressive!!!
The same in the productive farm areas in Norway as well.
Yes, but do you Scandinavians have a floating Apple store?
Tsk, I thought so.
I think that was considered by the Singapore government but found unviable due to lack of space. So we had to try a different method. I believe the Singaporean approach is more similar to the Netherlands' approach (need to double check).
bruh... The only way you can ride the bulldozer in Singapore is if you're literally on the public road, or there's a construction of buildings hahaha same goal, different land space my dude. The only way SG expand is up now. Or be like Dubai and dump tons of of sand in the ocean. But theeeeenn again, SG dont have lots of sqft in owning the water. The only profitable, peaceful and most importantly sustainable farming for them is up not sideways. t
@@beohel Dude he's being sarcastic.....
*I'm mainly interested in how people distribute their income, specifically how much goes to investing, saving, and consuming because I would be retiring or working fewer hours five years from now. I earn around 165,000 euros per year, but I have nothing to show for the moment.*
After reading your post, it is unclear whether you have a 401(k) plan. Considering your annual income of 165,000 EUR and your lack of financial progress, it is plausible that you should evaluate your monthly budget and pinpoint areas where you might be overspending. It would be prudent to seek financial guidance and cut down on monthly expenses. Any savings realized should be channeled towards wise investment opportunities.
@@tammystut Being self-employed, I finance my 401k businesses, and I remain open to generating income from various sources. Have you had any prior experience working with financial advisors? If yes, how was your experience? Is the experience as lucrative as advertised?
enormous wealth to come in the digital sector. people need to be informed!!!!
@@nickycolgantl9310 Certainly, JENNIFER D. ALAINE , a financial advisor, played a crucial role in easing my concerns regarding investing. With her guidance and subsequent investments, I was able to achieve a seven-figure milestone in less than three years.
HER information is available online for people who want to benefit from her services. Just search for her full name online and connect
Aaaa, My favourite country Singapore, clicked with lighting speed 😊🇸🇬
Haha, you're welcome! 😉
county
Nice video, thanks for sharing & Godspeed!
I spent more than a decade on the practical end of the future farming space. It isn't viable, you just can't square the energy costs. Looks pretty, makes hipsters and architects feel good about themselves, costs a bomb and can't feed anyone. Thankful, actual farming is finally having a renaissance.
I also wonder how much fertile farmland is now covered in the name of urban development.
@@btaleonard02 what's worse is how much of the best land is turned into golf courses. People need to quit modernizing everything and realize that they are going to have to work with nature to survive. It's amazing how many people over develop areas and push out farms considering food is a literal requirement for life. If course, many idiots honestly believe food is manufactured at stores and there is no reason to kill an animal because you can go buy pre packaged meat at the store.
Thank you. I see all the hype around it but the only really use case I can see for it are areas where import costs are prohibitively expensive, i. E. on the moon, mars or a space station. The idea that a city state might be entirely isolated just doesn't make sense either. If a pandemic makes them shut their borders they will just have to open them because more would die from starvation that from the disease and if the country isn't able to break a full military blockade from all sides ot also won't be able to defend itself against an invasion.
Stfu boomer
If you have the roofplants covered pf plants,were you can put solar panels? Maybe on the windows of the skycrapers right,but looks like super innefficent and over complicated, this solution maybe is right for singapore who doesnt have farmland, but the most efficent way to grow food for me is the sun, why use a solar panel or fossil fuels (solar panel have the efficency of 40x100) so you need to cover a larger area for those to grow a plant, maybe im wrong. Super expensive food its not the way, maybe im wrong
What a great display of teamwork and innovation. Thank you. Been there and want to go again. If we all strived to provide a little of our needs we'd end up with excess.
Singapore is so forward thinking they are gonna run the world while we all try to catch up
They will have to find a way to flatten China first. I would rather live in a world run by Singapore than China any day.
America be like "Dude"?
All hands must be on deck to revive agriculture globally. Nice presentation!
When you have people that are aware, and a government that pays attention, you get this.
you do know that Singapore is a dictatorship don't you?
@@vasopel Good “dictatorship” > Bad democracy. As long as the country is well run, people are treated fairly and are happy, I think all is good
@@jeems2066 I didn't comment on Singapore's dictatorship being good or bad, I was only saying to "Tarfa P. Kpamber" that what he writes in his comment would only work on a democracy. got it? :-)
@@vasopel nah, why can't a 'good dictator' pays attention to its aware citizen?
Fully funded world class education grounded in core democratic values. Singapore has birthed a socioeconomic machine of creativity and ingenuity thanks to that no-debate investment.
Singapore would ideally fall under a 'technocratic dictatorship'.
I’d love to live in Singapore, cheers from Mexico 🇲🇽
@Dignity Other countries should also have cities like Singapore
You might wanna to consider really hard if u wanna move to SG, cost of living is quite high.
EG: an apartment in Mexico city cost about 3240000pesos, which is about 20000+SGD(do correct me if im wrong)
A 3 Room flat with a 99year lease and value of the flat depreciates each year cost about 300000+SGD and btw unless you are buying a private property all purchasing of apartments(HDB) in SG goes by a ballot system. Even if you have the money doesnt mean u can geta chance to buy a flat
I'd love to live in Mexico. Let's trade places
If every city could employee this technology we could reduce a lot of the supply chain's carbon footprint around the world. Plus everyone will be able to feed themselves.
It would make a more green and sustainable way of living
Farmers would cry when they go bankrupt it cities grew their own food. That's why it hasn't happened yet, the economy in Canada couldn't handle a Change in the food guide for less dairy so they changed it back🤣
@Bapo Boy Not talking about the cities history or if there are raging parties and nightlife. I was talking about the initiative to grow food locally. But growing food to feed the people in your city is not boring.
Individuals could start this process for themselves on their balconies or even indoors. We grow herbs, greens, cabbage, and onions in containers, indoors and out.
Electricity isn't free and has a carbon footprint, sunlight for agriculture is better alternative.
I'd say Singapore is one of leading pioneers of modern Urban farming. Double thumbs up for them. I hope my country could have this kind of modern approach oh how they can build a more sustainable future.
Well done! Great content as always! Audio perfect!
Great Idea Singapore. Australia will talk about this for 100 years.
Reminds me a bit of the vertical farms of the Netherlands.
You mean the indoor ones, with LED lights etc?
No wonder, it's the same tech ;)
It's a (slightly) messy thing (like all agriculture I guess), but the speed of growing is incredible. (I was in one of those test chambers a few times during a practica, had to clean and replant them.)
I think the Arabs were the front runners of this, since they have water problems (and this saves a lot of water even though the plants basically swim) and not much usable land, but easy energy (solar)
Singapore imports alot of tech from Netherlands so i wouldn't be surprised if it's the same.
@@steemlenn8797 In the late 1970s, the Dutch Agricultural University of Wageningen helped Saudi Arabia to cultivate potatoes in the desert. Now Saudi Arabia is the largest potato producer in the entire Middle East.
@@steemlenn8797 Did the farm make financial sense? I'm hating on the idea of vertical farming a lot because it's just seems so expensive. I get that the food might be a novelty ingredient that high end restaurants are willing to pay extra for or as a way to sustain a base on Mars, the Moon or in the arctic but when you can just use trucks, trains and ships to import food grown outside I just can't see how the economics of it would work out.
After all the reason we don't grow more food isn't that we're running out of space to do so. It's that farmers in countries in the developing world simply don't have the capital for the machinery, fertilizer and herbicides/pesticides to get the same food output per area we see in richer countries yet.
This goes completely against the hype so: Do I miss something? Are they so much more efficient that they can somehow replace regular farming after the massively higher costs for labor, land, water supplies, lights and all the energy use? Or did tech media create a hype around a use case the technology was never really meant for?
@@user-hv6wb5gk8p If it was financial sense is the wrong question for the place I was in, since it was a research facility. But the salads there growed at 3 times the speed than on fields.
I actually did a small project (not water but earth based) with different settings (color) for the light, and there were cleary visible differences. (Also the smails clearly favored one of the 4 types of salad I was testing :D)
Worldwide speaking indoor farming of salad was already cheaper in Saudi Arabia than importing it (because imports are expensive, not to mention that imports happen via air, so not exactly "green" green stuff) - mostly thanks to cheap electricity from solar power. I guess with better knowledge and tech at least some types of crops will be cheaper to produce this way in many parts of the world (especially from foreign climates).
And here we are speaking about Saudi Arabia, they are not exactly lacking space. Singapore, Japan, where space costs more than only one arm and a leg the additional land might cost more than the tech.
One good way that makes a family fed by themselves.Really inspiring.
Love this. Well done Singapore, I am getting into gardening as well.
Singapore U will prosper BECAUSE U have patriotic leaders and people !
May God bless you as a nation. Keep up the good work.
I've been to Singapore. It was AMAZING! If anyone can build the farm of the future, you can bet your bottom dollar Singapore can.
Singapore is really ahead out of any countries in the world, amazing.
Singaporean's have proved they can do anything required to not only survive, but to flourish. This is a fantastic idea, and I hope everyone comes together to make it a norm across SG society. There is always a way.
Lived there for 4 years, best years of my life. Wish I could go back and work in IT again there someday.
I went there for work as well though I only got to stay for a few months, but agree that it was incredible. It's hard explaining to family/friends just how amazing of a country it is, I feel like everyone should go at least once in their lifetime.
@@justinmorgan836 yes, lovely people, food and atmosphere. I even enjoy the Durian! I'll probably buy an apartment there and visit annually in the future. Hope to share a Singapore sling with you one day!
When I was growing up in Singapore we raised our own chicken, ducks, turkey, goats and even had a few cows for milk. Our little farmhouse was acquired by the govt and we had to move to a modern apartment building in 1984.
And there is the problem. The government is now trying to correct a problem it created. DE-URBANIZE!
LIVING IN A CONCRETE JUNGLE, CAN ESCAPE FROM CONSTANT FLOODING. FREE FROM MOSQUITOES BREEDING AFTER E 🌧 ☔ ⛈ 🌧 ☔ SEASON, ALSO E SURROUNDING IS CLEANER ON E HIGHER FLOOR....
As a Malaysian, I hope Singapore urban farm to be successful. You can do it brother
It's incredible how from this beautifull planet we are making something like foreign planet human colonisation and rate it as success.
Every time I see some thing from Singapore the more impressed I get.
8:50 Steady, Freddie... Getting closer to "How it's Made" by the minute... 😉
Very cool concepts shown being used in the real world. Good stuff. I'd hate to have to depend on another country for 90% of my food...
A bit like being reliant on Russia for gas supplies?
This is what we should be doing all over the world growing growing fruits and vegetables everywhere everywhere helping each other
That is low hanging fruit.
What would make really good sense for scalability for an island nation like Singapore would be sea-steads. Fish farming, Sea greens, full water column. Makes perfect sense for the deep harbors around Singapore. Especially with the retired boats, scrap steel, and various other end-of-the-line logistics to be recycled. Moor a boat and use it as a sea steading platform. Allow for a transient sea community. Even if you're just growing chicken feed, clams, and oysters it makes good sense.
NYC needs this kind of planning. Good work. Hope it becomes part of city planning worldwide.
Another benefit that Singapore will soon find out is that the quality of their food in taste, nutrition and longevity will improve substantially. Consider that in addition to having a year-round growing season in SEA, they can stagger harvests with indoor farms to create a nearly constant supply of fresh food locally that does not have to wait a week on a refrigerated train/truck/ship to get to the market. Also, not only will they be reducing their carbon footprint by reducing their shipping burden, but they'll create the infrastructure for local agriculture.
I won't even talk about the countless benefits of increasing the density of beneficial insects and expanding the colonization of beneficial gut flora through community agriculture...all I'll say is don't be surprised if you see instances of depression in Singapore (and any other city that uses this model) to plummet and their lifespans/overall health to increase.
Incorporating natural growth into developments encourages less wrapping waste if purchasing from food stores also naturally improve health with no additives. Brilliant! Not to mention it would help to reduce mental health increasing natural oxygen and clean air. I love your goals.
@tomorrow's build actually the map for farmland by landmass is wrong, the area that you highlighting as 1%. That island is actually a military training area, the farms are actually the top left of the country, the northwest of the country. and with local fish farms in the sea nearby around the island
Technically, the graph was just showing the 1% of our land is farmland, and not that Pulau Sudong is actually a farm. Although I feel that a map showing our farms would be better.
@@darylteo9983 Ah, so that map was meant to represent a 'measuring cup' getting filled up to 1%. Thank you for clarifying, I also interpreted it as a map of where the actual farmland is located.
Idm turning tekong into a farm
@@lonestarr1490 Yeah I think most people would interpret it as that. But that's often how misinformation starts, by innocent misunderstanding.
This should be done in every city worldwide. It will help cool down the place and lessen the air pollution.
I really do love videos like this.
Fascinating. This might finally be the place where the first farmscraper is built. The design is around for quite a while but nobody ever made a reality out of it.
I like this and have wanted to see it developed. So good for this guy... the only question I have is plants like to trap humidity and moisture, so how do you keep the cement and steel from breaking down, if all of these plants are bound closely to it? Just curious.
Wow! Condos turn into veggie gardens and fishponds.
Singapore already has a tremendous climate and fertile soil for growing food.
Singapore has simply become very urbanised.
Imagine being this ignorant and claim Singapore has tremendous climate and fertile soil without knowing the scarcity of land and the weather actually are not suitable for most crops
Nice. Clearly they need to automate the process of sowing and repeating and not merely the feeding of these plants.
If only all cities were as progressive and the imaginative
yes more citys need caneing and the death penalty for drug use
I really do believe in growing at home. It's really great doing to hydroponically or aeroponically, and vertically if possible, which is what I've done before. It limits the need to fill up valuable residential space on buildings.
I love the compassion and respect that Singaporeans have for their city and always come together to create a better tomorrow.
If this was the U.K. there wouldn’t be roof farms for food, they’d be roof weed farms.
Thats going to be a massive industry in the coming years! Imagine every city in the world is able to supply up to 30% of its own produce. Imagine the amount of land we will reclaim for livestock agriculture and green spaces!
fusion would help make the lighting costs go down, unfortunately its 30 years away as usual
And as I heard the president of a superconducting wire company say at a Christmas party... "It was 20 years away 20 years ago, and it still is."
You can go vegan by today
Fascinating stuff. Singapore’s evolution over the past century is quite extraordinary.
No one:
US citizens: *bay-sil*
@A Z And you really think nobody can report you because you switched an 'e' for a 3?!
@A Z stop being childish. Youre being a shame for the Canada
I ripped out my lawn 3yrs ago and replaced it with an herb and vegetable garden. It's pretty cool to walk outside and grab some fresh herbs and vegetables for cooking. Not to mention with all the herbs, the amount of butterflies and birds I've seen that now frequent the yard. Also, I don't have to mow!
Way to go!
If i had a garden i would do the same.. more importent to mention.. you dont use immense amounts of fossil c02 producing energy to make your vegetables.
The idea of hightech farming presented here forgets the elephant in the garden.. it is unbeleavable energy consuming.. and energy.. mostly comes and maybe will come for long time only from fossil ressources, producing c02 and getting more and more rare..
Thank you PAP govt 🙏🙏
All of this is possible thanks to a very ambitious future thinking govt that is willing to punch above our weight
Singapore is so surreal! Visited a couple of years ago and it's like something from a sci-fi movie!
Love Singapore
I am greatly touched by the efforts!
Really interesting video, great stuff.
Freedom, initiative and entrepreneurship do work miracles
Another outstanding video 👏
Thank you so much! 🙌
Beautiful....
Govts should subsidize such innovative farming instead of expecting an already taxed consumer to pay higher prices. In time, as participation increases, prices will drop, and the subsidy can be withdrawn
Very impressive with your documentary. Singapore becomes a green city in the future.
As a farmer I was inspired by watching this video. I've now set a goal that each of my three daughters will have a unicorn in 3 years. Of course they're going to be carbon neutral unicorns.
I've got Narwhal horns and glue!
Love your answer... the big Problem of hightech farming is the intense amount of energy that has to be spent to produce a tiny amount of equivalent food energy..
this in times of climate change and rising problems in getting enough fossil energy to run our modern world is just an illusion.
@@Skenderbeuismyhero you can genetically engineer a unicorn from a horse and narwal cheeper than grow 30% of Singapore's calories in Singapore.
Probably in a shorter time frame too.
Voice of B1M❤❤❤watching from Bangkok ❤❤❤😊